SlideShare a Scribd company logo
TORTURE BAN VITAL FOR NATION'S SOUL
Cincinnati Post, The (OH) - December 7, 2006
Author: Kevin Eigelbach
Readability: 9-12 grade level (Lexile: 1140)
Every once in a while, I come across further evidence of how thoroughly Christian churches have failed the United States.
I found the latest example on the Web site of the National Religious Campaign Against Torture, www.nrcat.org.
More than 10,000 Americans have endorsed the Campaign's statement against torture. The site shows that American churches have
failed because 132 million Americans haven't signed on.
That's how many say they attend religious services at least once a week.
Why would a religious person favor torture? Fort Thomas resident Trasy Durso can't imagine.
"I don't believe in violence, torture is violence. It's pretty simple to me," she said. "Nobody wants to be tortured or violated physically."
Durso is one of at least 12 Northern Kentuckians who have electronically signed the anti-torture statement.
Another is Northern Kentucky University professor emeritus Jerry Richards, who said torture violates a key tenet of most religions -- do
unto others as you would have them do unto you.
And if we do it to others, others will do it unto us -- when they capture U.S. soldiers.
"We can't expect to engage in that behavior and have other nations respect our concern that it not happen to our own people," he said.
From a practical standpoint, torture doesn't elicit useful information anyway, he said. The victims simply say whatever they think their
tormentors want to hear, so that they will stop torturing them.
Images of Americans torturing prisoners, such as those seen at the Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq, hurt our standing internationally, said
signer Adalberto Pinelo, a political science professor at NKU.
We should unequivocally renounce torture, he said, but go further and ensure that our allies don't do it either.
"The idea that we capture people and ship them to countries where they can be tortured, I find that amazing and discouraging," he said.
The religious community hasn't spoken out about torture for several reasons, Richards said, including disbelief that Americans are doing it.
It has also failed to consider the long-term consequences of accepting torture -- what it does to the soul of America.
It reminds Richards of a quote from Gandhi about our atomic bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki in World War II.
Gandhi said we know what the bombing did to the conquered nation, but not what it would do to the soul of the conquerors
In October, President Bush signed into law the Military Commissions Act of 2006.
Dressed up as a ban on torture, it actually weakens safeguards against it. For example, U.S. law originally defined a war crime as a
violation of common Article 3 of the Geneva Conventions.
But the Act says only "grave" violations of Article 3 are war crimes, and gives the president the authority to decide what those are.
I like Article 3. It says you can't coerce prisoners to get information from them. If they refuse to answer questions, you can't do nasty
things to them. Plain and simple.
You god-fearing Christians might trust President Bush to interpret Article 3 correctly. But what about President Hillary?
The Campaign staff is hopeful that the new Congress will ban torture and poor treatment of detainees, said staff member the Rev.
Richard Killmer.
I hope so, too. OK, I'll say it: The soul of our nation is at stake.
Staff reporter Kevin Eigelbach writes on religion for The Post. Reach him at keigelbach@cincypost.com.
Edition: Cincinnati Section: Living Page number: D5 Record: 0612080202 Copyright: Copyright (c) 2006 The Cincinnati Post

More Related Content

What's hot

Contrived display at presidental debate
Contrived display at presidental debateContrived display at presidental debate
Contrived display at presidental debate
Christopher Cole
 
Violence ps paper
Violence ps paperViolence ps paper
Violence ps paperDarwil3
 
Contrived display at presidental debate
Contrived display at presidental debateContrived display at presidental debate
Contrived display at presidental debateChristopher Cole
 
Capital punishment power point
Capital punishment power pointCapital punishment power point
Capital punishment power point
cheeseheadboy
 
Capital punishment by DR FAIZ AHMAD
Capital punishment by DR FAIZ AHMADCapital punishment by DR FAIZ AHMAD
Capital punishment by DR FAIZ AHMAD
drfaiz2k6
 
The Pros and Cons of Capital Punishemt
The Pros and Cons of Capital PunishemtThe Pros and Cons of Capital Punishemt
The Pros and Cons of Capital Punishemtguest754ea4
 
MSNBC's Chris Matthews suggests Christians have no place in politics - Nation...
MSNBC's Chris Matthews suggests Christians have no place in politics - Nation...MSNBC's Chris Matthews suggests Christians have no place in politics - Nation...
MSNBC's Chris Matthews suggests Christians have no place in politics - Nation...
phobicmistake8593
 
Hillary blumenthal drumheller original documents hrc memo georgia-us_election...
Hillary blumenthal drumheller original documents hrc memo georgia-us_election...Hillary blumenthal drumheller original documents hrc memo georgia-us_election...
Hillary blumenthal drumheller original documents hrc memo georgia-us_election...AnonDownload
 
The Death Penalty
The Death Penalty The Death Penalty
The Death Penalty
William Kaplin
 
Musharraf
MusharrafMusharraf
Pro death penalty simran
Pro death penalty simranPro death penalty simran
Pro death penalty simranGP10
 
Capital punishment by Samax
Capital punishment by SamaxCapital punishment by Samax
Capital punishment by Samax
samaxsaini
 
The Kennedy Assassinations
The Kennedy AssassinationsThe Kennedy Assassinations
The Kennedy Assassinations
Al Walsh
 
TorontoStar
TorontoStarTorontoStar
TorontoStarJen W
 
US Chinese Naval Rivalry and Gwadar
US Chinese Naval Rivalry and GwadarUS Chinese Naval Rivalry and Gwadar
US Chinese Naval Rivalry and Gwadar
Agha A
 

What's hot (20)

Contrived display at presidental debate
Contrived display at presidental debateContrived display at presidental debate
Contrived display at presidental debate
 
Violence ps paper
Violence ps paperViolence ps paper
Violence ps paper
 
Contrived display at presidental debate
Contrived display at presidental debateContrived display at presidental debate
Contrived display at presidental debate
 
Capital punishment power point
Capital punishment power pointCapital punishment power point
Capital punishment power point
 
Capital punishment by DR FAIZ AHMAD
Capital punishment by DR FAIZ AHMADCapital punishment by DR FAIZ AHMAD
Capital punishment by DR FAIZ AHMAD
 
The Pros and Cons of Capital Punishemt
The Pros and Cons of Capital PunishemtThe Pros and Cons of Capital Punishemt
The Pros and Cons of Capital Punishemt
 
MSNBC's Chris Matthews suggests Christians have no place in politics - Nation...
MSNBC's Chris Matthews suggests Christians have no place in politics - Nation...MSNBC's Chris Matthews suggests Christians have no place in politics - Nation...
MSNBC's Chris Matthews suggests Christians have no place in politics - Nation...
 
Hillary blumenthal drumheller original documents hrc memo georgia-us_election...
Hillary blumenthal drumheller original documents hrc memo georgia-us_election...Hillary blumenthal drumheller original documents hrc memo georgia-us_election...
Hillary blumenthal drumheller original documents hrc memo georgia-us_election...
 
Syrian war news
Syrian war newsSyrian war news
Syrian war news
 
The Death Penalty
The Death Penalty The Death Penalty
The Death Penalty
 
Death penalty
Death penaltyDeath penalty
Death penalty
 
I DON'T CARE
I DON'T CAREI DON'T CARE
I DON'T CARE
 
51d309e73bf7d.pdf
51d309e73bf7d.pdf51d309e73bf7d.pdf
51d309e73bf7d.pdf
 
Musharraf
MusharrafMusharraf
Musharraf
 
Pro death penalty simran
Pro death penalty simranPro death penalty simran
Pro death penalty simran
 
Capital punishment by Samax
Capital punishment by SamaxCapital punishment by Samax
Capital punishment by Samax
 
The Kennedy Assassinations
The Kennedy AssassinationsThe Kennedy Assassinations
The Kennedy Assassinations
 
Facebook
FacebookFacebook
Facebook
 
TorontoStar
TorontoStarTorontoStar
TorontoStar
 
US Chinese Naval Rivalry and Gwadar
US Chinese Naval Rivalry and GwadarUS Chinese Naval Rivalry and Gwadar
US Chinese Naval Rivalry and Gwadar
 

Viewers also liked

General_application Jan2106
General_application Jan2106General_application Jan2106
General_application Jan2106Isaiah Chan
 
Profile
ProfileProfile
Profile
newlandza1
 
Pimpama recycled water plant (qld)
Pimpama recycled water plant (qld)Pimpama recycled water plant (qld)
Pimpama recycled water plant (qld)
Rick Nabett
 
Zonas 2do bimestre y notas 2do. b
Zonas 2do bimestre y notas 2do. bZonas 2do bimestre y notas 2do. b
Zonas 2do bimestre y notas 2do. b
Ave Maria Compu
 
Nestleì seeks to sweeten nesquik sales by cutting back on sugar wsj
Nestleì seeks to sweeten nesquik sales by cutting back on sugar   wsjNestleì seeks to sweeten nesquik sales by cutting back on sugar   wsj
Nestleì seeks to sweeten nesquik sales by cutting back on sugar wsj
New Food Innovation Ltd
 
Dementia and Palliative Care
Dementia and Palliative CareDementia and Palliative Care
Dementia and Palliative Care
Irish Hospice Foundation
 
Estereotipos
EstereotiposEstereotipos
Estereotipos
profesornfigueroa
 
Advance Care Planning & Advance Healthcare Directives with People with Dementia
Advance Care Planning & Advance Healthcare Directives with People with DementiaAdvance Care Planning & Advance Healthcare Directives with People with Dementia
Advance Care Planning & Advance Healthcare Directives with People with Dementia
Irish Hospice Foundation
 
Apresentação sobre o realismo nas artes
Apresentação sobre o realismo nas artesApresentação sobre o realismo nas artes
Apresentação sobre o realismo nas artes
Beatriz Andrade
 

Viewers also liked (11)

General_application Jan2106
General_application Jan2106General_application Jan2106
General_application Jan2106
 
Une historie de nöel
Une historie de nöelUne historie de nöel
Une historie de nöel
 
Profile
ProfileProfile
Profile
 
Pimpama recycled water plant (qld)
Pimpama recycled water plant (qld)Pimpama recycled water plant (qld)
Pimpama recycled water plant (qld)
 
Zonas 2do bimestre y notas 2do. b
Zonas 2do bimestre y notas 2do. bZonas 2do bimestre y notas 2do. b
Zonas 2do bimestre y notas 2do. b
 
Media Arts Portfolio
Media Arts PortfolioMedia Arts Portfolio
Media Arts Portfolio
 
Nestleì seeks to sweeten nesquik sales by cutting back on sugar wsj
Nestleì seeks to sweeten nesquik sales by cutting back on sugar   wsjNestleì seeks to sweeten nesquik sales by cutting back on sugar   wsj
Nestleì seeks to sweeten nesquik sales by cutting back on sugar wsj
 
Dementia and Palliative Care
Dementia and Palliative CareDementia and Palliative Care
Dementia and Palliative Care
 
Estereotipos
EstereotiposEstereotipos
Estereotipos
 
Advance Care Planning & Advance Healthcare Directives with People with Dementia
Advance Care Planning & Advance Healthcare Directives with People with DementiaAdvance Care Planning & Advance Healthcare Directives with People with Dementia
Advance Care Planning & Advance Healthcare Directives with People with Dementia
 
Apresentação sobre o realismo nas artes
Apresentação sobre o realismo nas artesApresentação sobre o realismo nas artes
Apresentação sobre o realismo nas artes
 

More from Kevin Eigelbach

Social Media Certificate Program
Social Media Certificate ProgramSocial Media Certificate Program
Social Media Certificate ProgramKevin Eigelbach
 
N-E murderer interview 2
N-E murderer interview 2N-E murderer interview 2
N-E murderer interview 2Kevin Eigelbach
 
N-E murderer interview 1
N-E murderer interview 1N-E murderer interview 1
N-E murderer interview 1Kevin Eigelbach
 
Business First - Liberty Mortgage
Business First - Liberty MortgageBusiness First - Liberty Mortgage
Business First - Liberty MortgageKevin Eigelbach
 

More from Kevin Eigelbach (9)

Social Media Certificate Program
Social Media Certificate ProgramSocial Media Certificate Program
Social Media Certificate Program
 
N-E murderer interview 2
N-E murderer interview 2N-E murderer interview 2
N-E murderer interview 2
 
N-E murderer interview 1
N-E murderer interview 1N-E murderer interview 1
N-E murderer interview 1
 
Jail abuse payoff
Jail abuse payoffJail abuse payoff
Jail abuse payoff
 
Kunkel column
Kunkel columnKunkel column
Kunkel column
 
Creationist column
Creationist columnCreationist column
Creationist column
 
Glen Cole story
Glen Cole storyGlen Cole story
Glen Cole story
 
Business First - Liberty Mortgage
Business First - Liberty MortgageBusiness First - Liberty Mortgage
Business First - Liberty Mortgage
 
Bingo series complete
Bingo series completeBingo series complete
Bingo series complete
 

torture column

  • 1. TORTURE BAN VITAL FOR NATION'S SOUL Cincinnati Post, The (OH) - December 7, 2006 Author: Kevin Eigelbach Readability: 9-12 grade level (Lexile: 1140) Every once in a while, I come across further evidence of how thoroughly Christian churches have failed the United States. I found the latest example on the Web site of the National Religious Campaign Against Torture, www.nrcat.org. More than 10,000 Americans have endorsed the Campaign's statement against torture. The site shows that American churches have failed because 132 million Americans haven't signed on. That's how many say they attend religious services at least once a week. Why would a religious person favor torture? Fort Thomas resident Trasy Durso can't imagine. "I don't believe in violence, torture is violence. It's pretty simple to me," she said. "Nobody wants to be tortured or violated physically." Durso is one of at least 12 Northern Kentuckians who have electronically signed the anti-torture statement. Another is Northern Kentucky University professor emeritus Jerry Richards, who said torture violates a key tenet of most religions -- do unto others as you would have them do unto you. And if we do it to others, others will do it unto us -- when they capture U.S. soldiers. "We can't expect to engage in that behavior and have other nations respect our concern that it not happen to our own people," he said. From a practical standpoint, torture doesn't elicit useful information anyway, he said. The victims simply say whatever they think their tormentors want to hear, so that they will stop torturing them. Images of Americans torturing prisoners, such as those seen at the Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq, hurt our standing internationally, said signer Adalberto Pinelo, a political science professor at NKU. We should unequivocally renounce torture, he said, but go further and ensure that our allies don't do it either. "The idea that we capture people and ship them to countries where they can be tortured, I find that amazing and discouraging," he said. The religious community hasn't spoken out about torture for several reasons, Richards said, including disbelief that Americans are doing it. It has also failed to consider the long-term consequences of accepting torture -- what it does to the soul of America. It reminds Richards of a quote from Gandhi about our atomic bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki in World War II. Gandhi said we know what the bombing did to the conquered nation, but not what it would do to the soul of the conquerors In October, President Bush signed into law the Military Commissions Act of 2006. Dressed up as a ban on torture, it actually weakens safeguards against it. For example, U.S. law originally defined a war crime as a violation of common Article 3 of the Geneva Conventions. But the Act says only "grave" violations of Article 3 are war crimes, and gives the president the authority to decide what those are. I like Article 3. It says you can't coerce prisoners to get information from them. If they refuse to answer questions, you can't do nasty things to them. Plain and simple. You god-fearing Christians might trust President Bush to interpret Article 3 correctly. But what about President Hillary? The Campaign staff is hopeful that the new Congress will ban torture and poor treatment of detainees, said staff member the Rev. Richard Killmer. I hope so, too. OK, I'll say it: The soul of our nation is at stake.
  • 2. Staff reporter Kevin Eigelbach writes on religion for The Post. Reach him at keigelbach@cincypost.com. Edition: Cincinnati Section: Living Page number: D5 Record: 0612080202 Copyright: Copyright (c) 2006 The Cincinnati Post