SlideShare a Scribd company logo
i
ii
i
Acknowledgement
Firstly, we wish to express our gratitude to the Yangon University of Economics
for giving us the opportunity to do and encouragement to conduct this paper.
Our special thanks go to Associate Professor Daw Yi Yi Khin, our program
coordinator, who showed keen interest in this paper, provided professional guidance,
motherly concern, critical comments and valuable advice.
We are thankful to our supervisor, Daw Pwint Phyu Aung (Assistant Lecturer,
Department of Applied Economics, Yangon University of Economics) for her kind
supervision, persistent supports, and encouragement throughout this research study. We
found her insightful criticisms useful and valuable in completing this study paper.
Above all, we wish to thanks our beloved family and our friends for their support
and encouragement.
Last, but not least, we would like to express our gratitude to all those who
contributed their time, efforts, and expertise directly or indirectly to bring the study to
final completion.
ii
Abstract
Since the new government took office in March 2011, Myanmar has embarked on
a process of extensive political and economic reform. In recent years, the international
community has witnessed many positive changes in Myanmar, including greater space for
civil society, an expansion in freedom of expression, and evident government concern
about environmental and local livelihood issues resulting from large‐scale development
projects. With new foreign investment laws and the lifting of economic sanctions by
Western countries, Myanmar is opening rapidly to the global market economy. With the
country’s plentiful resources and the input of foreign investment, Myanmar is ready to
pursue economic growth under the name of “development”.
The objective of the study is to examine the role of Foreign Direct Investment
(FDI) and the situation of FDI flows in Myanmar. The study was based on secondary data
source of Myanmar over the period of 2000 to 2014. To achieve a step change in FDI and
get closer to meeting the economy’s large need for investment, as well as to continue to
diversify the sectors to which FDI goes, Myanmar needs to prioritize two main areas:
developing a targeted FDI strategy led by a high-performing agency and improving
Myanmar’s business environment.
In order to provide more specific guidance to potential foreign investors, some
types of activities have been specified as open to foreign investment. A foreign investor
may apply for and obtain a permit under the Foreign Investment Law for an economic
activity not so specified, provided the foreign investor can explain how the activity would
be mutually beneficial to Myanmar and the foreign investor.
iii
CONTENTS
Acknowledgement i
Abstract ii
Contents iii
List of Tables iv
List of Figures iv
Chapter (I) Introduction 1
1.1 Rationale of the Study 1
1.2 Objective of the Study 2
1.3 Method of Study 3
1.4 Scope and Limitation of the Study 3
1.5 Organization of the Study 3
Chapter (II) Importance of Foreign Direct Investment in Developing Countries 4
2.1 Definitions of Foreign Direct Investment 4
2.2 The Role of FDI into Developing Countries 5
2.3 FDI flows and FDI stocks 5
2.4 The Effect of FDI in host countries and home countries 5
2.5 Benefits and Costs of FDI to Home and Host Countries 8
Chapter (III) Foreign Direct Investment in Myanmar 10
3.1 Background of FDI in Myanmar 10
3.2 Direction of FDI in Myanmar 10
3.3 FDI inflows into Myanmar 11
3.4 Countries investing the most in Myanmar 13
3.5 Natural Resources and FDI in Myanmar 19
Chapter (IV) Barriers and Opportunities in Myanmar 25
4.1 Barriers in Administration and Policies 25
4.2 Barriers in Information, Infrastructure and Institution 26
4.3 Human Resource Barriers 28
4.4 Investment Opportunities in Resource Sectors 29
4.5 Opportunities in Manufacturing 31
Chapter (V) Conclusion 33
5.1 Findings 33
5.2 Suggestions 35
References 36
iv
List of Tables
Tables Page
1. Foreign Direct Investment in Myanmar by Country (2000 - 2014) 14
2. Approved Amount of Foreign Direct Investment by Sector (2003 - 2014) 15
3. Foreign Direct Investment in Myanmar by year (2000 - 2014) 18
List of Figures
Figures Page
1. Figure 1 : The pattern of FDI inflows into Myanmar (2000-2014) 11
2. Figure 2 : Trend of FDI to Myanmar (2000-2012) 12
3. Figure 3: Top Ten Countries Investing In Myanmar (2000-2014) 16
4. Figure 4: Composition of Foreign Direct Investment 17
5. Figure 5: Natural resources and economic zones 24
- 1 -
Chapter (1)
Introduction
1.1. Rationale of the study
Foreign Direct Investment has emerged as one of the most important sources of
external resource inflows and an engine for economic development in developing
countries over the 1990s and has become a significant part of capital formation in the
countries concerned. Moreover positive externalities such as vertical linkage and
technology spillovers are believed to stimulate growth in the host countries. Many policy
makers in developing countries are setting policies that try to attract FDI in the hope of
bringing about economic growth by maximizing technology spillovers which could help
in the formation of human capital which in turn could significantly contribute to growth.
In the late 1998, Myanmar changed its economy from centrally planned economic
system to market-oriented one. After transforming into market-oriented economy,
Myanmar made many economic reforms and also accepted foreign direct investment into
the country. According to the World Bank data source in 2012, the inflow of foreign
direct investment into the country is $ 2.2 billion. As a developing country, Myanmar
needs more foreign direct investment in order to develop the country's economy. The
government has been undertaking many efforts to create favorable investment
environment, aiming at achieving more employment opportunities, developing human
resources, and facilitating the economic growth of the country.
The government of the Republic of the Union of Myanmar has conducted a series
of political and economic reforms since 2011. The companies which had hesitated to
invest in Myanmar such as from EU, the United States, Japan and ASEAN have now
started to seek a way to invest in the country especially in the areas with minimal risk.
Many companies, however, have not changed their "wait and see" attitude and they have
yet to decide about to make a significant investment in Myanmar. Nevertheless, the
Myanmar government is making necessary preparations for attracting more foreign direct
investment (FDI).
- 2 -
A new Foreign Investment Law was signed on November 2, 2012 to create a more
favorable climate for foreign investors. The new law stipulates that foreign investments
can take place as sole ownership (100% stake), or a joint venture with local citizens,
government, or organizations. According to the law, foreign firms are required to operate
through forming joint venture with local investors in certain sectors.
The Union of the Myanmar has already involved in ASEAN Economic
Community (AEC) which purpose is to lower import duties among ASEAN countries
gradually and targeted will be zero for most of their import duties. And the government
has also made significant efforts such as in promotion and expansion of exports, in
reducing tariffs and other restrictions on trade. Further, the government has focused on
improving physical infrastructures, flexible domestic markets, fostering transparency and
stability in rules related with FDI, equal treatment for foreign and local firms,
administrative procedures and regulatory transparency directly linked to the trading
process.
FDI is very important for Myanmar since it needs foreign capital to generate
employment for its citizens, acquire technology know-how and accumulate foreign
exchange to implement development projects. Given the continuous decline in Overseas
Development Assistance and bank borrowings from international financial agencies as a
result of the economic sanctions that followed the military coup in 1988, FDI continues to
be a significant source of external finance for ensuring development, fulfilling investment
and narrowing development gaps between and within states and regions. It also helps
ensure the sustainability of the recovery process and industrial development in Myanmar.
FDI brings along with it not only capital flows that would contribute to the balance of
payments but also a package of other economic benefit such as employment
opportunities, export market expansion, technology and entrepreneurial skill
enhancement.
1.2. Objective of the Study
The objective of the study is to examine the role of Foreign Direct Investment
(FDI) and the situation of FDI flows in Myanmar.
- 3 -
1.3. Method of Study
This study is made on simple descriptive method with available statistical data and
secondary data sources collection from various reliable data sources. The main sources of
data are Statistical Year Book, April 2015 (Central Statistical Organization) published by
Ministry of National Planning and Economic Development, the Government of the
Republic of the Union of Myanmar, and Directorate of Investment and Company
Administration(DICA). The major online resources included Data from World Bank and
Directorate-General for Trade, European Commission, and ADB reports.
1.4. Scope and Limitation of the Study
This study is focused on foreign direct investment inflows in Myanmar. The study
will present on economic environment of Myanmar with the emphasis on factors such as
macroeconomic environment, infrastructural development and human resource
development and FDI accommodating institutions. The study was based on secondary
data source of Myanmar over the period of 2000 to 2014.
1.5. Organization of the Study
This study is organized into five chapters. Chapter (1) is the introduction of the
study which includes rationale, objective and method of the study together with scope and
limitation of the study. Chapter (2) includes Importance of Foreign Direct Investment in
developing that organized by Definition of Foreign Direct Investment, The Role of FDI
into Developing Countries, FDI flows and FDI stocks, The Effect of FDI in host countries
and home countries and Benefits and Costs of FDI to Home and Host Countries. And
Foreign Direct Investment in Myanmar will be included in Chapter (3). In chapter (4),
Barriers and Opportunities in Myanmar will be involved. And the last chapter (5)
attempts on drawing a conclusion by pointing out the findings which need to be addressed
in order to promote the FDI in the country.
- 4 -
Chapter (II)
Importance of Foreign Direct Investment in Developing Countries
2.1 Definitions of Foreign Direct Investment
Foreign direct investment (FDI) plays an extraordinary and growing role in global
business. It can provide a firm with new markets and marketing channels, cheaper
production facilities, access to new technology, products, skills and financing. For a host
country or the foreign firm which receives the investment, it can provide a source of new
technologies, capital, processes, products, organizational technologies and management
skills, and as such can provide a strong impetus to economic development. Foreign direct
investment, in its classic definition, is defined as a company from one country making a
physical investment into building a factory in another country. The direct investment in
buildings, machinery and equipment is in contrast with making a portfolio investment,
which is considered an indirect investment. In recent years, given rapid growth and
change in global investment patterns, the definition has been broadened to include the
acquisition of a lasting management interest in a company or enterprise outside the
investing firm’s home country.
The international Monetary Fund (1997) defines FDI as "an investment that is
made to acquire a lasting interest in an enterprise operating in an economy other than that
of the investor, the investor's purpose being to have an effective voice in the management
of the enterprise."
According to UNCTAD definition, FDI is defined as an investment involving
management control of a resident entity in one economy by an enterprise resident in
another country.
Agiomirganakis et al. (2003) defined FDI as the flow of capital resulting from the
behavior of multinational companies. So, the factors which affect the MNC's behavior
will also affect the direction and magnitude of FDI.
- 5 -
2.2 The Role of FDI into Developing Countries
FDI is very important for the development of a country, especially, for developing
economics. The experience of newly industrialized countries (NICs) shows that FDI had
played an important role in their economic development. In the age of globalization with
cross-border flow of capital among nations, FDI becomes a key solution to reducing
development gaps among nations. The rapid growth of multinational corporations
(MNCs) has become the major driver for the process of FDI because they are looking
everywhere in the globe as investment center.
The government had identified a number of potential investment opportunities for
foreign investors and has also embarked on a privatization program. A foreign investor
(whether investing through a joint venture or a 100 percent owned entity) manufacturing
goods or providing services in Myanmar under the Foreign Investment Law will be
granted an exemption from income tax for three consecutive years, inclusive of the year
of commencement.
2.3 FDI flows and FDI stocks
Whenever we talk about the international movement of “capital”, there are two
types of capital movements: foreign direct investment (FDI) and foreign portfolio
investment (FPI). Foreign direct investment (FDI) refers to a movement of capital that
involves ownership and control for foreign ownership of production facilities took place
(i.e. long-term capital stock). Foreign portfolio investment (FPI) is financial capital
because it does not involve ownership or control but the flow (i.e. not the stock and it is
short–term financial flow).
2.4 The Effect of FDI in host countries and home countries
The effects of foreign direct investment (FDI) on the home countries (the source
of FDI) of Multinational Corporations (MNCs) have become well-known in the
international debate during the past decade. After the completion of the Uruguay round,
global liberalization of trade and investment and the regional integration processes in
Europe, the Americas, and the Asia-Pacific region are important reasons for this
resurgence of interest. Because of the Asian crisis in 1997-1999, a global boom in FDI
that was temporarily interrupted by a reduction in investment flows.
- 6 -
The annual number of cross-border investments in Europe exceeds 10,000, and
both China and the US attract thousands of FDI projects every year. Inflows to Russia
have accelerated after the collapse of the Soviet Union. In recent years, India has become
an important destination for FDI, and several other Asian countries record substantial
inflows. Both West Asian and African countries can be found among the economies with
the fastest increases in inward FDI (UNCTAD 2006).
In contrast, several developing countries such as Brazil, China, India, South
Africa, and Malaysia in which local companies have created sufficient intangible assets to
become multinational. However, developing countries have been focused on the effects of
inward FDI and thus there is little evidence on how they are affected by outward
investment. There are possible differences in the home country effects of FDI in
developed economies and in that of developing countries.
The inward FDI in hosting countries stimulate employment, and investment, and
economic growth. However, one view is that outward FDI have negative effects on home
country’s growth when applying the same logic to home countries implies that the
outward FDI would damage growth of home countries by taking away investment,
employment and output production. This is the general concern of the public in home
countries. Horizontal and vertical types of outward FDI could promote economic growth
of home countries. While horizontal FDI is market seeking and substitutes host country's’
employment and output for home country, vertical FDI is cost minimizing and
complement host country’s employment and output for home country.
The general characteristics of host countries are considered by investors deciding
whether to undertake a project in any country and important attention is being paid to
political variables in addition to traditional economic variables. The particular host
country economic determinants of FDI are (i) market-seeking FDI (i.e. firms are
attempting to locate facilities near large markets for their goods and services), (ii)
resource-seeking and asset seeking FDI (i.e. firms are in searching of particular resources
or particular human skills), and (iii) efficiency seeking FDI (i.e. firms can sell their
products worldwide and are in searching of the location where production costs are the
lowest). Beyond economic factors, foreign firms considering investment in any given
country will also be influenced by various policies and attitudes of the host country’s
government (i.e. political situation of the host country).
- 7 -
Within host countries, foreign- owned firms almost always pay higher wages than
domestically- owned firms. It is not always the case that they cause wages in locally-
owned firms to rise, but their presence does generally raise wage levels in host countries.
The impact of FDI in promoting the growth of host country exports and linkages to the
outside world is clearer (i.e. host country effects of inward FDI). The major role of FDI in
the transformation of host economies from being exporters of raw materials and foods to
being relatively exporters of high- tech manufactures. Much of the impact is from the
transfer of knowledge of world markets and of ways of fitting into worldwide production
networks, not visible in standard productivity measurements.
Multinational operations have led to a shift by parent firms in the United States
toward more capital- intensive and skill- intensive domestic production. However, that
type of reallocation does not appear to have taken place in Japan or Sweden. Foreign
firms generally have higher productivity than local firms, but the evidence for spillovers
to local firms' productivity is mixed. It seems to depend on host country policies and
environments and on the technological levels of industries and of host- country firms.
Much of the growth of presently developed countries came from increases in the
scale of production and in its capital intensity. The contribution of the foreign owned
firms is mainly of knowledge, particularly knowledge of demand in the world market, and
knowledge about how the host country can find a place in the worldwide allocation of
intermediate steps in the path of production that can be geographically separated. By the
development of new product (to the host country) inward direct investment is associated
with faster economic growth, although the extent of FDI inflows and national economic
growth do not produce strong and consistent relationships.
A clear mention can be made of the fact that there are impacts of FDI on the
sending or home country of the investment as well as on the receiving or host country.
The impact of FDI on home country (outward FDI) is more favorable than that of host
country (inward FDI) because FDI benefits the home country to a large extent albeit some
disadvantages. As shown in table, listed below are the impacts of foreign direct
investment (FDI) on home and host countries.
- 8 -
2.5 Benefits and Costs of FDI to Home and Host Countries
The benefits and costs of FDI to home and host countries are listed to understand
very easily by constructing the following table.
Table-1 Benefits and Costs of FDI to Home and Host Countries
Home Country Host Country
Benefits 1. Lower prices for consumer
2. Create demand for export
3. Cost Advantages
4. New Markets
5. Exposure to other countries
6. International Relations
7. Creates new employment
8. New technology
9. Increases income
1. Increase output
2. Increase wages
3. Increase employment
4. Increase exports
5. Increase Tax revenues
6. Realization of scale economies
7. Provision of technical & managerial
skills & of new technology
8. Weakening of power of domestic
monopoly
Costs 1. National sovereignty and
national defense
2. Affect employment
1. Adverse impact on the host country’s
commodity terms of trade
2. Decreased domestic saving
3. Decreased domestic investment
4. Instability in the balance of payments
& the exchange rate
5. Loss of control over domestic policy
6. Establishment of local monopoly
7. Inadequate attention to the
development of local education and
skills
8. National sovereignty and autonomy
Source: Ma Pwint Phyu Aung (2013), Ph.D Prelim (Ba-2), "Impact of FDI on Home and
Host Countries", Assignment, Meiktila University of Economics, Mandalay, Myanmar.
There may be more or less advantages and disadvantages in Foreign Direct
Investment to both home countries and host countries. The above table mentioned the
benefits and costs of Foreign Direct Investment for Home Countries and Host countries.
- 9 -
The benefits of home countries are lower prices for consumer, create demand for
export, cost advantages, new markets, exposure to other countries, international relations,
creates new employment, new technology, and increases income. The cost of these home
countries are national sovereignty and national defense and affect employment.
On the other hand, the benefits of host countries can be calculated that are
increase output, increase wages, increase employment, increase exports, increase tax
revenues, realization of scale economies, provision of technical & managerial skills & of
new technology, and weakening of power of domestic monopoly. The cost of the host
countries are adverse impact on the host country’s commodity terms of trade, decreased
domestic saving, decreased domestic investment, instability in the balance of payments &
the exchange rate, loss of control over domestic policy, establishment of local monopoly,
inadequate attention to the development of local education and skills, and national
sovereignty and autonomy.
- 10 -
Chapter (III)
Foreign Direct Investment in Myanmar
3.1 Background of FDI in Myanmar
Myanmar had been undertaking economic reforms since 1988. Since then, the
country has officially adopted market-oriented economy and welcomed FDI inflow.
Accordingly, a series of legislation conductive to market economy have been enacted and
some of the existing laws were amended to be compatible with the changing economic
environment.
Soon after the adoption of a market-oriented economy, Myanmar foreign
Investment Law was promulgated on 30 November 1988 and Myanmar Foreign
Investment Commission was formed on 7 December 1988. Myanmar fully recognizes the
advantages of FDI for its economic development. Consequently, the government has been
actively encouraging FDI in Myanmar. Its main foreign investment policy and objectives
are as follows.
a. Adoption of a market-oriented system for allocation of resources.
b. Encouragement of private investment and entrepreneurial activity. The basic
principles of Myanmar Foreign Investment Law are as follow.
 Exploitation of natural resources which require heavy investment
 Acquisition of high technology
 Developing production and services industries involving large capital
 Creating local employment opportunities,
 Developing of works which would save energy consumption and regional
investment.
3.2. Direction of FDI in Myanmar
Myanmar is a country rich in natural and human resources. It has vast cultivable
land, long coastlines, navigable river systems, abundant materials, gems, forests and a
literate population. These plus attractive incentives are expected to entice potential
foreign investors. Foreign investments from various counties have been coming into
- 11 -
Myanmar since 1989. The pattern of foreign direct investment inflows into Myanmar
from 2000-20141
is shown as follows. Data in all figures represent approval data by MIC.
Source: DICA
3.3. FDI inflows into Myanmar
The FDI inflows into Myanmar are heavily concentrated on natural resource based
and extractive industries such as power, oil and gas and mining sectors. From 1990 to
2005 total amount of FDI inflows into the country are concentrated in power sector
(81.59%). The inflows into other sectors are agriculture (0.27 %), manufacturing (1.96%)
and hotel and tourism (2.36%) which is relatively low because the country possesses
attractive features, in terms of resources may be constrained by variety of factors such as
sanctions imposed by US and EU, unfavorable exchange rates and foreign investment
laws (Myanmar Statistical Year Book, 2011).
Myanmar approved foreign investment totaling US $8.01 billion from 211
companies for the 2014-2015 fiscal year across 12 sectors, according to the Directorate of
Investment and Company Administration. Among the sectors attracting foreign direct
1
Myanamar Fiscal Year is from April to March.
-
2,000.00
4,000.00
6,000.00
8,000.00
10,000.00
12,000.00
14,000.00
16,000.00
18,000.00
20,000.00
22,000.00 2000-01
2001-02
2002-03
2003-04
2004-05
2005-06
2006-07
2007-08
2008-09
2009-10
2010-11
2011-12
2012-13
2013-14
2014-15
US$million
Year
Figure 1 : The pattern of FDI infolws into Myanmar (2000-2014)
US $ million
- 12 -
investment during the fiscal year ending 31 March, oil and gas sector topped the list at
$3.22 billion, followed by transport and communication with approved capital of $1.68
billion and manufacturing with $1.5 billion. The real estate sector attracted $0.78 billion
while $0.36 billion was approved for the hotel and tourism sector.
Figure 2: Trend of FDI to Myanmar
Source: Selected Monthly Economic Indicators, April 2012, DICA
Table shows that DICA’s data showed approved foreign direct investment nearly
doubled from $4.1billion in fiscal 2013-2014 to $8.01 billion in 2014-2015. Myanmar
expects to receive $6 billion in the current fiscal year.
From fiscal 1988-89 to 2014-2015, the approved amount of foreign investment in
Myanmar reached a total $54.23 billion, coming from 895 permitted companies from 38
countries.
US$ million
- 13 -
3.4. Countries investing the most in Myanmar
After changing the economy from a centrally-planned economy to a market-
oriented one, the government had made a series of liberalizing measures to promote and
raise the level of investment in almost every sector of the economy, an also encouraged
private sector to participate actively in foreign direct investment activities.
After foreign investment law was enacted, the government has attracted 18 foreign
enterprises with the amount of $ 449.487 million in 1989-1990, 22 foreign enterprises
with $ 280.573 million in 1990-1991, and 4 enterprises with $ 5.893 million in 1991-
1992. In brief, FDI inflows into the country gradually increased from 1989 to 1996. But
the amount of inflows decreased continuously from the year 1996-1997 because of Asian
Financial Crisis in that year. However, the amount increased again in 2004- 2005 and
2005-2006 because of huge investment in power sector by Thailand. In 2008-2009, total
investment increased to an amount of $ 984.446 million and rose sharply again in 2011
with the amount of $ 19997.968 million. All the investments during this period are mostly
from Asia, UK and Russia. The approved amount of FDI inflows are shown in the
following table.
- 14 -
Table (1): Foreign Direct Investment in Myanmar by Country (2000 - 2014)
(US$ million)
Sr.
No
Country
2000-
2001
2001-
2002
2002-
2003
2003-
2004
2004-
2005
2005-
2006
2006-
2007
2007-
2008
2008-
2009
2009-
2010
2010-
2011
2011-
2012
2012-
2013
2013-
2014
2014-
2015
Total
1 China 28.98 3.3 2.8 126.6 0.7 281.2 856 2.5 8269.2 4,345.73 231.77 56.92 516.90 14722.6
2 Thailand 25.75 22 29 6034.4 16.2 15 15.3 2146 1.30 489.07 165.68 8959.7
3 Singapore 36.915 6.1 81 38 39.2 226.2 418.23 2,340.12 4,297.19 7482.955
4 Hong Kong 13.229 1.5 12.9 3 6 5798.3 84.84 107.10 625.56 6652.429
5 Republic of Korea 47.222 5 0.3 34.9 37 12 -4 2676.4 25.27 37.94 81.21 299.59 3252.832
6 United Kingdom 30.612 1.5 27 273 799 99.83 232.70 156.86 850.76 2471.262
7 Malaysia 9.832 1.5 62.2 237.6 76.8 51.86 4.32 616.11 6.72 1066.942
8 Vietnam 20 18.15 329.39 142.00 175.40 684.94
9 India 47.5 137 73.00 11.50 26.04 208.89 503.93
10 The Netherland 10.30 302.40 312.7
11 Japan 4.7 2.7 1.4 3.8 -12 7.1 4.32 54.06 55.71 85.74 207.53
12 Canada 21.95 1.5 2.10 153.92 179.47
13 Russia 94 94
14 France -1.4 5.36 67.25 71.21
15 Liberia 64.60 64.6
16 Brunei 2 1.00 2.27 43.87 49.14
17 UAE 41 4.50 1.69 47.19
18 Luzibut 5.20 40.15 45.35
19 Mauritania 30.6 30.6
20 Switzerland 3.4 27.00 30.4
214.49 17.50 86.90 91.20 158.30 6,065.70 719.70 203.20 984.80 329.60 19,999.00 4,618.16 1,419.45 4,088.47 7,963.52 46,959.99
Source: Central Statistical Organization
- 15 -
Table (2): Approved Amount of Foreign Direct Investment (By Sector) (2000-2014)
(US$ million)
Sr.
No
Sector 2003-04 2004-05 2005-06 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 2012-13 2013-14 2014-15
1 Agriculture - 138.750 9.650 20.269 39.666
2 Livestock and Fisheries 2.600 12.000 5.600 96.016 26.861
3 Mining 1.450 6.000 0.700 5.000 855.996 2.500 1396.077 19.897 15.334 32.730 6.259
4 Manufacturing 2.820 3.520 18.720 - 0.232 33.230 66.321 32.254 400.716 1826.980 1502.013
5 Power 6030.000 281.222 8218.520 4343.978 364.201 46.511 40.110
6 Oil and Gas 54.300 142.550 34.975 438.480 170.000 114.000 278.600 10179.297 247.697 309.200 3220.306
7 Construction - - - - - - - - - - - -
8
Transport and
Communication
30.000 0.634 1190.232 1679.304
9 Hotel and Tourism 3.500 15.000 15.250 300.000 435.210 357.949
10 Real Estate 2.713 440.573 780.745
11 Industrial Estate - - - - - - - - - - - -
12 Other Services 14.766 18.534 357.320
Total 91.170 158.283 6,065.675 719.702 205.720 984.764 329.580 19,998.965 4,644.460 1,419.467 4,107.055 8,010.533
Source: Central Statistical Organization
- 16 -
According to the data from Central Statistical Organization, the most investing
countries in Myanmar are stated in about chart. The top investing country is the Republic
of China and the remaining countries are Thailand, Singapore, Hong Kong, Republic of
Korea, United Kingdom, Malaysia, Vietnam, India and The Netherland.
-
2,000.00
4,000.00
6,000.00
8,000.00
10,000.00
12,000.00
14,000.00
16,000.00US$Million
Country
Figure 3: Top Ten Countries Investing In Myanmar
(2000-2014)
US$ million
- 17 -
A various home countries had been investing in Myanmar in many different
sectors including oil and gas, power, manufacturing, transport and communication,
mining, hotel and tourism, real and industrial estate, agriculture and livestock and
fisheries. The above chart showed the comparison of Foreign Direct Investment by sector.
Agriculture, 0.47%
Livestock and
Fisheries, 0.32%
Mining,
5.32%
Manufacturing,
8.82%
Power, 43.88%
Oil and Gas,
34.49%
Transport and
Communication,
6.59%
Hotel and Tourism,
2.56%
Real Estate, 2.78%
Other Services,
0.89%
Figure 4: Composition of Foreign Direct Investment
- 18 -
Table (3): Foreign Direct Investment in Myanmar (2000-2014)
US$ million
Year No of Enterprises Approved Investment
2000-01 28 214.490
2001-02 7 17.500
2002-03 9 86.900
2003-04 8 91.200
2004-05 15 158.300
2005-06 5 6,065.700
2006-07 12 719.700
2007-08 7 203.200
2008-09 5 984.800
2009-10 7 329.600
2010-11 25 19,999.000
2011-12 13 4,618.160
2012-13 94 1,419.450
2013-14 122 4,088.470
2014-15 209 7,963.520
Total 566 46,959.990
Source: Central Statistical Organization
As of the 2014-2015 fiscal year that ended on 31 March 2015, 566 existing
foreign enterprises from over 33 countries had so far invested $46.95 billion in 11 sectors,
including oil and gas, power, manufacturing, transport and communication, mining, hotel
and tourism, real and industrial estate, agriculture and livestock and fisheries.
- 19 -
3.5. Natural Resources and FDI in Myanmar
Natural resources matter to Myanmar. Myanmar has a wide variety of natural
resources distributed across the country (see Figure 5). The recorded value of exports of
gas, oil, coal, jade, gems, metals, and wood made up about 70% of national exports, or
about 10% of GDP in 2012‒13, with natural gas exports alone of $US 3.6 billion. Natural
gas revenues ‘represent the largest source of foreign income for the government’, with a
peak of 6.5 % of GDP projected in 2014‒15.
Myanmar is estimated to rank 41st in the world for proven reserves of natural gas
and 78th for proven reserves of crude oil. An Asian Development Bank assessment of the
energy sector states: ‘a total of 104 blocks are demarcated onshore (53) and offshore (51)
for oil and gas exploration and development. Proven oil reserves total 160 million barrels.
Proven gas reserves total 20.11 trillion cubic feet with huge potential for discovery’.
Natural resource-related payments comprise both tax and non-tax revenue. The
exact share of Myanmar’s revenue deriving from natural resources is difficult to measure
because 1) tax revenue collected by the IRD includes taxes paid by companies in the
extractive sector and tax payments from state-owned enterprises (SOEs), as well as taxes
not related to natural resources; 2) state owned enterprise revenues from loss-making and
profit-making enterprises are now aggregated at the level of the supervising ministry,
making it hard to tell how much loss or how much profit each enterprise makes; 3)
payments, royalties and fees collected by Union line ministries and subnational entities
are not all uniformly recorded and made public (although some are available).
(a) Overview by sector
Oversight of natural resource extraction and natural resource revenue is split
between different ministries and levels of government, according to the type of resource,
and in some cases, the value of the resource. The following section will describe formal
responsibilities and procedures for handling revenue flow by sector.
- 20 -
(b) Mining
Mining sites are distributed throughout many states/regions in Myanmar. Though
large-scale sites such as the Letpadaung copper mine in Sagaing, Moegok gem mines in
Mandalay, and Hpakant jade mines in Kachin are well-known, smaller-scale mining is
widespread and has significant local environmental, social and economic impacts.
Estimates of informal extraction in the mining sector suggest informal extraction exceeds
formal channels, and that the value of the jade market, in particular, could be much larger
than reported figures.
The Ministry of Mines includes two departments: the Department of Mines and
the Department of Geological Survey and Mineral Exploration. The Department of Mines
oversees the mining enterprises and, in future, is also to handle environmental affairs for
the Ministry of Mines. The Department of Geological Survey and Mineral Exploration is
‘responsible for mapping, prospecting, and exploration of minerals, including coal’.
(c) Minerals
The mining of minerals including coal, p copper, lead, nickel, tin, antimony, iron,
and gold, is of great relevance to both Union and state and region governments, due to
both localized environmental and social impacts and potential rapid expansion of
investment in the sector. Under the 1994 Myanmar Mines Law, the Ministry of Mines
controls all permitting for mineral extraction in Myanmar. A draft amendment to the law
is now in the Union Parliament.
The current mining law divides mining operations into ‘large scale’ and ‘small
scale’ categories. Policymakers interviewed stated that the draft amended law will include
a category for ‘medium scale’ mining, transfer the control of permits for ‘small scale’ and
artisanal mining to state/region government control, and change the structure of contracts
to foster more private investment in the sector. At the time of this publication, the law had
not yet been released.
Large-scale mines are governed by a joint-venture or production-sharing contract
between the relevant Mining Enterprise and the private mining company. These contracts
vary case-by-case. According to the Asian Development Bank’s Energy Sector Initial
Assessment, for coal ‘the average PSC provides 30% of profits for the government and
70% for the private contractor’.
- 21 -
Small-scale mine companies apply to the Ministry of Mines for licenses and pay
fees up front. Before mining begins, the Ministry of Mines collects application fees and
land rental fees known as ‘dead rent’ according to the acreage of the mine site. Ministry
of Mines officials stated that all incoming taxes and fees are collected by the relevant
department and paid on an ongoing basis by the Ministry of Mines to the Ministry of
Finance account.
(d) Gems
Gems are regulated separately from other minerals by the 1995 Myanmar
Gemstone Law and are governed by the Myanmar Gems Enterprise (MGE) under the
Ministry of Mines. Amendments to the Gemstone Law are reportedly being drafted by the
Myanmar Gems Enterprise. In the Gemstone law, royalties are stipulated ‘based on the
value assessed by the valuing body’ at 20% in the case of ruby, sapphire, jade and
diamond, with 10% for other gemstones. The valuing body is set up by the Ministry of
Mines. According to the law, ‘If a company sells raw gemstone on its own in foreign
currency, after [the] 1st sale, 10% royalty [is due] on foreign currency actual sale value’.
All high-quality gems and all grades of jade are supposed to be sold at the
Myanmar Gems and Jade Emporium, held three times a year in the capital, Nay Pyi Taw,
since 2006. A 10% tax is due on sales at the Emporium and is collected by the Myanmar
Gems Enterprise.
(e) Oil and gas
Oil and gas revenues contribute to Myanmar’s budget through both direct and
indirect channels (tax and non-tax revenue), with gas being much more significant than
oil. In 2012‒13, natural gas exports to Thailand, ‘by far the largest single commodity
sold, totaled $US 3.5 billion or 30% of total exports’ from Myanmar.
All oil and gas companies are in partnership with the state-owned Myanmar Oil
and Gas Enterprise (MOGE) under the Ministry of Energy, the majority through
production-sharing contracts. There are three oil refineries in Myanmar, run by the
Myanmar Petrochemical Enterprise (MPE). Finance officials interviewed at MOGE stated
that there is variation by contract, but that MOGE has ‘15-20% participating interest
typically’. Under the model production-sharing contract for oil made public by MOGE,
the government receives from the contractor:
- 22 -
(f) Timber
Myanmar’s most valuable timber species is teak, though there are also other
valuable species of hardwood. A ban on the export of raw timber went into effect on 1
April 2014, with the stated goal of increasing value-added processes for wood products.
The state-owned Myanmar Timber Enterprise (MTE), under the Ministry of
Environmental Conservation and Forestry, has sole extraction rights for teak, though
private companies may run teak plantations. MTE officials interviewed said that the
enterprise is responsible for ‘timber harvesting, milling, and downstream processing and
marketing of forest products,’ and certification from MTE is required for the legal export
of timber. MTE itself has three departments: extraction, marketing, and export. MTE also
enters into joint ventures with companies for wood processing. The share of revenue
received from these processing businesses depends on the specific contract, which is
negotiated case-by-case.
(g) Hydropower
Hydropower generation supplies over 70% of Myanmar’s electric power, with a
total installed capacity of 46,101 megawatts. The hydropower potential of the country’s
rivers, which drain the four main basins of Ayeyarwady, Chindwin, Thanlwin, and
Sittaung, is estimated to be more than 100,000 megawatts (MW).
Responsibility for dam projects in Myanmar is divided among several ministries
and agencies, based on the size and purpose of the dam. According to a presentation from
the Ministry of Agriculture and Irrigation in 2011, ‘hydropower projects are under
implementation by the Department of Hydropower Implementation’ under the Ministry of
Electric Power and the Department of Irrigation, under the Ministry of Agriculture and
Irrigation.
The Ministry of Electric Power is now operating 20 hydropower plants in
Myanmar, while the Ministry of Agriculture and Irrigation constructs water reservoirs and
dams for irrigation purposes. The irrigation dams sometimes include small hydropower
units. The Ministry of Agriculture and Irrigation collects ‘irrigation tax from dams and
reservoirs’.
- 23 -
There is variation in contract types. Contracts include joint ventures with foreign
investors and policy documents discuss the potential development of new sites with a
build-operate-transfer model. It is not clear from this initial review how any revenue
from exported electricity from hydropower is or would be treated, and more research is
needed on the hydropower sector in Myanmar.
- 24 -
Figure 5: Natural resources and economic zones
Source: Myanmar Peace Monitor: ‘Economic and Political Stakes’ (September 2013).
- 25 -
Chapter (IV)
Barriers and Opportunities in Myanmar
Foreign Direct Investment plays a key role in the economic development of a
country. However, to attract FDI is not as easy and simple task. A number of barriers
hinder the inflow FDI into a particular developing country, especially for a Least
Development Country (LDC). These barriers lead to increased risks and costs of foreign
investors that can outweigh the location-specific advantages and resource endowments of
LDCs. This can impede FDI inflow into the country. Foreign investors want to get
superior returns from the investment to compensate greater risks. Political instability is
one of the most important barriers to FDI.
4.1 Barriers in Administration and Policies
(a) Administration Barriers
In some LDCs countries, the problem starts at the submission of investment
proposal stage. To get an approval to start a business or investment, the proposal has to
pass different stages of official producers and require documents and consensus from
various sectors. This problem is compounded by unclear and overlapping producers on
decision making by the authorities concerned. This procedure takes several weeks and
months. These barriers can dissuade foreign visitors from making favorable investment
decisions.
The persistence of administrative barriers together with absence of institutional
capacity in LDCs in situation where trivial procedures like moving a file one department
to another and from one table to next within the same department becomes major
obstacles to progress. Complex producers and lengthy work process without transparent
and standard rules create bribes and corruption at the operational level where official and
unofficial fees are paid to higher levels. Most government tries to solve these hurdles by
creating one stop approval shops but it leads to increase additional steps because there is
no clear delegation of authority on investment.
- 26 -
(b) Policies Barriers
Policy barriers are one of the causes to concern for foreign investors who want to
invest for long term plan in the particular country. Fiscal policy, monetary policy,
exchange rate policy and debt management policy are need into account to attract Foreign
Direct Investment. Foreign investors are interested in the stability of fiscal policies in the
host country, the level of tax revenue, the structure of tax and long term stability of tax
rate applicable to corporate income and capital gains, exercise tax and tax on import,
export, value-added and tax allowance and tax exemption for export income and the size
and sustainability of budget deficits since these may impact on future operation once
investment has started. Monetary policy is the central bank of the host country.
Foreign investors are also interested in the stability of domestics' interest rate, the
level of inflation, the credit policy and the extent of government domestic borrowing.
Foreign firms concerns about the trade policy of the host country. High barriers of import
both tariff and non-tariff may be one of the reasons for choosing FDI in this country. In
practice, they want to operate in liberalized trade regime with fewer restrictions on
producers of exporting and importing. However, foreign investors may want restricted
trade policy in the countries in which they are already operated to reduce the competition
of imported products from abroad. Therefore, MNCs stand on trade liberalization depends
on their position whether they are inside or outside of the country. The stability of
exchange rate and the permission to convert any time without restriction is also a major
concern for foreign investors.
4.2 Barriers in Information, Infrastructure and Institution
(a) Information Barriers
There is no doubt that any foreign investor wants to get enough, clear information
about the country that he is going to invest before making critical investment decisions.
They want to get detailed information about market size, growth rates and changing
consumer preferences and so on. But they are also important for resource seekers because
they want to access on information on size, quality and exploitability of resources that
they are interested in. The greater is access to information, the lesser are the risk to
investors.
- 27 -
Potential investors in manufacturing sectors want detailed information about the
supply and demand conditions, situation of local firms, law and regulation on labour,
export and import procedures and so on. In fact all potential investors in any sector and
with any motive require more or less information. Therefore, the lack of data and
unreliable data make them disappoint about the country to do business. From the point of
view of host countries, that attempt to attract FDI, this mean that just showing incentives
and changing policies is no guarantee to FDI. The role of investment promotion is to
attempt to reduce information asymmetries faced by potential foreign investors in their
investment decision process. Inadequate and unreliable statistics issued by the host
country increased complexity to foreign investors to understand the real situation in the
country. Issuing out of date data returns the same effect. Therefore, if a country can
overcome these information asymmetries, collecting and establishing necessary data
bases timely and effectively distribute them to foreign investors the chance to be chosen
for FDI will be greatly enhanced.
(b) Infrastructure Barriers
Poor infrastructure barriers also hinder to invest for investor in the developing
countries. In general, poor infrastructure can lead to increased costs and risks of doing
business in that country. It can increase the costs incurred by foreign investors because
they have to bear the cost of infrastructure development such as electricity, water supply
and communication facilities. It can increase the risk for foreign investors because they
face difficulties in acquiring inputs and distribution products through the market channels
in a timely manner. Difficulties in communication and transportation are also major
hurdles for smooth business operation.
The extent to which certain barriers poses obstacles to attracting FDI is more
severe in industries such as mining and manufacturing, given additional costs that foreign
investors must assume. These deficiencies of infrastructure may outweigh the benefits of
lower labor costs and abundant resources in LDCs. They can severely limit FDI inflows
from resource seekers. For potential investor in hotel and tourism, manufacturing sectors,
inadequate infrastructure may lead to increased costs for them. Unless these costs are
compensated by additional benefits, investors don't want to invest in a particular country.
However, these infrastructure weaknesses may create opportunities for some businesses
specializing in infrastructure services such as electricity and road construction.
- 28 -
(c) Institutional Barriers
Most developing, especially LDCs, are faced with constraints involving human,
social and institutional capital. In terms of human capital, they have higher proportion of
unskilled labor and shortage of qualified and experienced managers and technicians in
these countries. The availability of human capital is a major driver of FDI. A host country
that has larger supplies of higher level man power able to absorb new skills is likely to
attract more and better quality FDI than countries without such endowment. Therefore, a
country that wants to attract FDI must considerate the above factors.
4.3 Human Resource Barriers
Social capital represents the intangible assets that as a whole in all countries have.
It takes the form of various types of traditions and taboos, informal organizations, and
trust. Social capital comprises the invisible glue that binds societies and cultures together.
The dimensions of social capital that are particular concern to foreign investors are
constitutions and form of political organization, adherence to the rule-of-law, means of
dispute resolution whether formally or informally, crime rate and major crimes happened
in the country, level and pervasive of corruption, intrinsic ability to evolve by embracing
and adapting to technological and globally induced cultural change in a manner that is
positive and constructive. Foreign investors are most concerned about the efficiency of
public institutions and their impact on the quality and responsiveness of governance.
Generally speaking, these weaknesses, including administrative barriers are disincentives
to foreign investors. In term of human capital, they have higher proportion of unskilled
labor and shortage of qualified and experienced managers and technicians in country. The
availability of human capital is a major driver in FDI. A host country that has larger
supplies of higher-level man power able to absorb new skills is likely to attract more and
better quality FDI than countries without such endowment.
- 29 -
4.4 Investment Opportunities in Resource Sectors
(a) Agriculture
The agriculture sector contributed more than 50 percent of Myanmar GDP and
about 60 percent of the total employment in 2005. The country has significant land and
water resources, low cost labor, and eco-system varieties, and is strategically located
given in proximity to markets in East Asia, Middle East, Southeast Asia and South Asia,
which allow agro-industry to become a major foreign exchange earner for the country.
Myanmar possesses a large proportion of land area in the Southeast Asian region
and over 60 different varieties of crops such as rice, wheat, maize, beans and pulses, and
oilseeds, as well as industrial crops such as cottons, jute, rubber, sugar cane, palm and
tobacco can be cultivated. Its agriculture is almost in the hands of private farmers, and
cultivation is carried out on small farms even if land ownership right is still in the hands
of the state. Given the land availability in Myanmar and the dominance of the private
sector in Myanmar's agricultural sector, prospects are high for strategic business
cooperation with foreign investors who enjoy capital and technological advantages. The
growing demand for agricultural products from industrial developed countries like Japan
and the EU, as well as staple products for developing countries like India and Bangladesh
holds a great profit potential for those who want to invest in agriculture.
(b) Livestock and fisheries
Myanmar's livestock sector consists mainly of cattle, pigs, and poultry. They are
primarily bred in rural areas, though most of them are not for commercial consumption.
Currently, a small volume of animal products are exported even as Myanmar's central
plains are suitable for commercial breeding of hardy beef cattle. This means there is a
high potential for animal breeding in the country. Even though Myanmar does not have a
well-established livestock or diary sector, it can significantly increase it has diary
production, provided there is available foreign capital and technology, which may be
combined with Myanmar's land resources and favorable climate. The availability of
pasture lands show potential for future cattle ranching with meat production and
processing.
Myanmar possesses 1930 km-long costal line, which provides great opportunities
to trade in a wide variety of marine products for export. The western Rakhine coast is
renowned for its shellfish, while the southern islands are rich in various kinds of marine
- 30 -
including fresh and frozen fish, preserved fish and shellfish. Export volume can still be
vastly increased, given the growing demand for sea products from the world market.
Fresh fish and shell fish can be exported to Japan, Singapore, Malaysia, and China while
salted fish and preserved fish can be exported to India, Bangladesh and China.
(c) Wood-based industries
Myanmar has large forest areas from which large tons of timber and forest
products like bamboo and rattan can be extracted. Myanmar is well known for its teak
resources, and it furnishes approximately 90 percent of the world's commercial teak
supply. Its forests provide more than 8,500 different plant species, including 2,300 types
of trees and 850 types of orchid, and its covers more than half of the country. Instead of
exporting these forest products in their raw forms, processed and value-added products
should be developed with foreign technology and access to international market. In this
area, foreign investment can provide not only the needed capital but also the technology
and design that can improve the marketability of value-added wood products. Wood
products such as furniture enjoy a strong demand from every foreign market. Likewise,
wood-related products like plywood and veneer can be exported to China, India,
Malaysia, Singapore, Japan and some western countries.
(d) Mineral products
Myanmar had considerable mineral resources, most of which are still unexploited.
It shows another opportunity for foreign investor. Even though the state has the sole right
to develop and extract pearls, jade, precious stones and metals, the law allows the
provision of permits to the private sector and FDI if the pursuit of a project will meet the
state's requirements. Such mining activities are commonly carried out through joint
ventures, production sharing, or purchase contracts. Combined with foreign technology
and capital, there is a potential to increase some mineral products for export such as
silver, lead, tin, ores, coal and gemstones to Japan and other neighboring countries.
Myanmar is well known for its ruby and jade in the world market and it has
considerable indigenous supplies of gold, silver, pearl, and other precious stones and
metals. Again, this sector is reserved for the state but some types of FDI may be
considered for the interest of the state. Foreign investments can also be flowed in the form
of gem cutting, processing, and relevant export services. There are major world markets
for such products and they offer attractive opportunities for foreign investors. Regional
- 31 -
countries such as China, India, Indonesia, Malaysia, and Thailand have specific expertise
in mineral prospecting, extraction, and processing. Companies from Singapore and
Thailand are now doing feasible projects in Myanmar's tin industry. China also finds
opportunities in Myanmar's mineral extraction and processing sectors.
4.5 Opportunities in Manufacturing
This sector holds promise for growth, particularly, in the area of light industries.
These include textiles, foodstuffs, pharmaceuticals, ceramics, paper and chemical.
Currently over 60 percent of all manufacturing outputs in the country fallen under food
and beverage. With FDI and private sector involvement, the manufacturing sector is
expected to increase and diversify from basic domestic industries to more export-oriented
and dynamic ones.
(a) Garment industries
Given the much lower wage rates in Myanmar than Thailand, Malaysia and even
Cambodia and its abundant labor supply, the country has attracted foreign investors to
invest in this labor-intensive industry. Indeed, investment in the manufacturing sector
generates benefits to the country. With the agreement of the Ayeyawady-Chao Phraya-
Mekong Economic Cooperation Strategy (ACMECS), new industrial zones are being set
up for garment industries in Myawadi and Pa-an near Thailand's border, which can take
advantage of cheap labor. Since, Myanmar had relatively intelligent, hardworking, not to
mention cheap labor source, it has comparative advantage in relation to other countries in
the garment sector. The major bottleneck in this sector is delay in export and complex
import procedures, which affect the lead time for exporting garments and substantially
reduce the country's competitive edge. By removing unnecessary delays in this process,
the country's competitiveness in the garment industry will be greatly improved.
(b) Electronics and IT industries
Since Myanmar enjoys high literacy rate in the region and intelligent labor that
can absorb advanced technology, electronic and IT industries are promising sectors for
FDI inflow into Myanmar. If Myanmar could improve its infrastructure requirements,
these sectors are likely to be major recipients of FDI. Japan and Korea are interested to
invest these sectors, since Myanmar has a considerable large home-based market and can
serve as an export base to highly populated neighboring countries like China and India.
- 32 -
Myanmar has already put up an IT park in Yangon and constructed IT city between
Mandalay and Pyin Oo Lwin. Government, for its part, has been undertaking intensive
infrastructure development programs in this area since 2006. This shows an opportunity
for foreign investors that want to invest in Myanmar. The major setback in this sectors are
shortage of electricity and communication networks which, however, are expected to be
removed in the coming a few years, since government is intensely pursuing hydropower
projects to fulfill electricity requirements and launching extensive communication
networks in the country. Training programs to develop highly skilled technicians are also
extended to build competency in this area.
(c) Foodstuffs and pharmaceutical industries
Since Myanmar has a large agricultural sector, which provides various crops that
serve as inputs to foodstuffs industries. Moreover, over 60 percent of domestic private
small industries in Myanmar are already concentrated in foodstuff industry. This is a very
promising opportunity for foreign investors that want to invest in this sector for export,
since most of the domestic industries only focus on the local market. The pharmaceutical
industry is also another potential area to attract FDI, since the country is short supply for
pharmaceutical products from domestic state-owned factories. Developing business
linkages with local suppliers is an important requirement for investors who want to invest
into these sectors.
- 33 -
Chapter (V)
Conclusion
5.1 Findings
To achieve a step change in FDI and get closer to meeting the economy’s large
need for investment, as well as to continue to diversify the sectors to which FDI goes,
Myanmar needs to prioritize two main areas: developing a targeted FDI strategy led by a
high-performing agency and improving Myanmar’s business environment.
One of the major themes that came up repeatedly was concern about the business
environment in the country. In light of this, Myanmar needs to focus relentlessly on
improving the environment in which businesses can operate in the country. This will be
crucial to attracting larger volumes of FDI. Countries—or even individual cities—that
have been successful in attracting large volumes of FDI have made the creation of a
business friendly environment a priority. Their experience suggests four areas that
Myanmar would need to get right to help it attract FDI:
With the enactment of the 2012 Foreign Direct Investment Law, the reforms beign
conducted in political, economic and social spheres, and the appropriate strategy to
address issues discussed in this paper and the proper amendment of FIL in line with the
changing conditions as the country becomes more matured in attracting FDI, it can be
assumed that Myanmar could be on the right track, to be able to attract the kind and
amount of FDI, it really deserves.
Many investors and embassy trade representatives indicate that concerns about
whether the rule of law is fully established and embedded into the business environment
in Myanmar is a major source of uncertainty for prospective investors. Instilling
confidence in the sanctity of contracts and ensuring that arbitration is available in the
event of disagreements are both important considerations for investors contemplating
deals with local partners and the government.
The skilled labor usage problem could be alleviated by bringing up the capacity of
local workers by improving the education system. Then it will be cost effective for the
investors to use local skilled workers since the wage rate is comparatively low related to
their foreign counterparts, who would have the same skill levels. As for the problem
regarding MIC's discretionary power, if more comprehensive, predicable and transparent
- 34 -
rules and procedures regarding foreign investments could be crafted in the future, foreign
investors' concerns as regards the issue could be reduced significantly.
The environment of a country in the broadest sense - the quality of life - is often a
factor in whether companies decide whether to locate there. A country that offers social
benefits such as health care, public safety (low crime rates and an effective police force),
schools, and a rich cultural life may be more likely to attract businesses and talented
individuals. To sum up, Foreign Direct Investment in Myanmar is still pivotal to improve
its economic development. However, there are some challenges that need to fill the gap to
attract foreign investment such as effective performance agency and business
environment. Myanmar needs to be proactive in its efforts to attract FDI, given its
potential need for investment. Any effective FDI strategy needs to start with a clear
understanding of the country’s current competitive strengths and how they might evolve.
- 35 -
5.2 Suggestions
Myanmar needs to be proactive in its efforts to attract FDI, given its potential
need for investment. Any effective FDI strategy needs to start with a clear understanding
of the country’s current competitive strengths and how they might evolve. Myanmar’s
Directorate of Investment and Company Administration (DICA) serves as its investment
promotion agency, but that function is not yet fully developed. To play this role
successfully, DICA can look at the experience of its counterparts elsewhere. These
agencies tend to have four factors in common that drive success. First, they create a
culture that is customer-focused, responsive, and flexible, and are staffed with talented
people who are able to make the case for the investments and to connect effectively with
investors. Second, they have the powers to address the concerns of investors by being
firmly embedded in the center of government. Third, they leverage prominent private-
and public-sector representatives to champion the country’s offering to investors. Finally,
they build connections between foreign investors and local firms.
According to Data interpretation, the Foreign Direct Investment has significantly
increased in the fiscal year of 2010-2011 since the new government took office in March
2011. Myanmar is ready to pursue economic growth under the name of “development”.
Government should take place continuously implementation of foreign investment law
and act the law effectively in order to come more foreign direct investment to country for
national economic growth and development.
- 36 -
References
1. ADB (2012). "Myanmar in Transition: Opportunities and Challenges". August
2012.
2. Archibald, J. S. and others (2012). "Change and opportunity in Myanmar".
Economic Sanctions Alert, 9 April 2012. Hogan Lovells, Washington, D.C, New
York, London
3. ASEAN Secretariat, Statistics of Foreign Direct Investment in ASEAN, eighth
edition, 2006, page 30-40.
4. Central Statistical Organization (April 2015), "Selected Monthly Economic
Indicators", Ministry of National Planning and Economic Development, The
Government of The Republic of The Union of Myanmar.
5. "Foreign Investment Law Myanmar", The Foreign Investment Law the
Pyidaungsu Hluttaw Law No 21/2012, the 3rd
waning of Thadingyut, 1374 ME,
2nd
November, 2012.
6. IMF (2012). Myanmar 2011 Article IV Consultation, IMF Country Report No.
12/104. Washington, D.C.
7. Jared Bissinger (2012), "Foreign Direct Investment in Myanmar: A Resource
Boom but a Development Bust?", Contemporary Southeast Asia Vol. 34, No.1
(2012) pp.23-52
8. Khaing Sape Saw (Ms.) and Khin Maung Nyo (Mr.), March 15, 2014, "Promoting
Investment Climate: How to attract FDI?", ppt presentation, Joint by KGU-
MARCED, Kumamoto Gakuen University, JAPAN and Myanmar Research
Center for Economic Development, Myanmar Engineering Society (MES), Hlaing
Universities Campus.
9. Khin Cho Cho (August, 2007), "A Study on the Foreign Direct Investment and
Economic Development (case study: Myanmar)", (Unpublished Master Thesis),
Yangon Institute of Economics.
10. Khin Moe Myint (December 2012), "Foreign Direct Investment in Myanmar",
Master Thesis, Master of Development Studies Programme, Yangon Institute of
Economics.
11. "Myanmar: Opening Up To Its Trade And Foreign Direct Investment Potential ",
20 September 2012, revised 31 December 2012, Trade and Investment Division,
Staff Working Paper 01/12, United Nations Economics and Social Commission
for Asian and the Pacific (UN-ESCAP).
- 37 -
12. Myat Thida Aye, 2011, "Study on Foreign Direct Investment And Opportunities
in Myanmar", MPA Thesis, Master of Public Administration Programme, Yangon
Institute of Economics.
13. Myo Khaing Aung (December, 2013), "A Study on Economic Environment for
FDI in Myanmar", Master Thesis, Master of Public Administration Programme,
Yangon Institute of Economics.
14. Pwint Phyu Aung (2013), "Impact of FDI on Home and Host Countries",
Assignment, Ph.D Prelim (Ba-2), Meiktila University of Economics, Mandalay,
Myanmar.
15. Thandar Khine, 2008, "Foreign Direct Investment Relations between Myanmar
and ASEAN", IDE Discussion Paper No. 149, Institute of Developing Economics
(IDE), JETRO.
16. Thet Aung Lynn and Mari Oye, June 2014 "Natural Resources and Subnational
Governments in Myanmar", Subnational Governance in Myanmar Discussion
Paper Series, Discussion paper No.4, International Growth Centre, MDRI-CESD
and The Asia Foundation.
17. Thin Thin Kyi, Dr, (July 2015),"Foreign Direct Investment In Myanmar",
International Conference on Burma/Myanmar Studies, University Academic
Service Centre (UNISERV), Chiang Mai University, Thailand.
18. UNCTAD (1998) World Investment Report 1998 New York
19. Wah Wah Maung, 2002, "The Role of Foreign Direct Investment: Case Studies of
Myanmar and Vietnam", PhD Thesis, Jawaharlal Nehru University.
20. World Economic Forum (2012). Enabling Trade Index 2012. Geneva, New York
and Beijing.
21. Zaw Yadanar Hein (May, 2014), "Comparative Study of Foreign Direct
Investment in Myanmar and Vietnam", Master Thesis, Department of Economics,
Yangon Institute of Economics.
22. Banco de España and Maitena Duce (July 31, 2003), "Definitions of Foreign
Direct Investment (FDI): a methodological note", http://www.oecd.org/
23. "The effects on Myanmar's Foreign Investment Policies on FDI Inflow: An
Analysis of Panel Data across ASEAN Member Countries".
http://www.trincoll.edu/dept/econ
- 38 -

More Related Content

What's hot

Singapore economy
Singapore economySingapore economy
Singapore economy
Nana Topuria
 
Case study: FDI in Automobile Sector in India
Case study: FDI in Automobile Sector in IndiaCase study: FDI in Automobile Sector in India
Case study: FDI in Automobile Sector in India
Rahul S
 
Thailand Country Analysis
Thailand Country AnalysisThailand Country Analysis
Thailand Country Analysis
Abhiteja Pachipulusu
 
Thailand’s Economy
Thailand’s EconomyThailand’s Economy
Thailand’s Economy
marcpeter
 
Thailand Presentation
Thailand PresentationThailand Presentation
Thailand Presentation
Ellen Underwood
 
Thailand: Economic Setting
Thailand: Economic SettingThailand: Economic Setting
Thailand: Economic Setting
Jose Radin Garduque
 
Singapore politics and economics
Singapore politics and economicsSingapore politics and economics
Singapore politics and economics
Rajendra Ojha
 
Singapore's Economic Growth
Singapore's Economic GrowthSingapore's Economic Growth
Singapore's Economic Growth
Vikas Sharma
 
Singapore & malaysia economic analysis
Singapore & malaysia economic analysisSingapore & malaysia economic analysis
Singapore & malaysia economic analysis
krunal solanki
 
Business proposal for Construction industry of UAE
Business proposal for Construction industry of UAEBusiness proposal for Construction industry of UAE
Business proposal for Construction industry of UAE
KratiJain53
 
Malaysia macroeconomic view
Malaysia macroeconomic viewMalaysia macroeconomic view
Malaysia macroeconomic view
Dhiraj bonda
 
Understanding-Vietnam
Understanding-VietnamUnderstanding-Vietnam
Gbe group3
Gbe group3 Gbe group3
Gbe group3
VishalKhurana23
 
Pestel on Thailand
Pestel on Thailand Pestel on Thailand
Pestel on Thailand
Danish Shoukat
 
Session 2 archanun how aec promote intra_asean trade evidence from thailand
Session 2 archanun how aec promote intra_asean trade evidence from thailandSession 2 archanun how aec promote intra_asean trade evidence from thailand
Session 2 archanun how aec promote intra_asean trade evidence from thailand
ntuperc
 
KYAUK PHYU SPECIAL ECONOMIC ZONE DEVELOPMENT Road Show, Yangon, MYANMAR
KYAUK PHYU SPECIAL ECONOMIC ZONE DEVELOPMENT Road Show, Yangon, MYANMARKYAUK PHYU SPECIAL ECONOMIC ZONE DEVELOPMENT Road Show, Yangon, MYANMAR
KYAUK PHYU SPECIAL ECONOMIC ZONE DEVELOPMENT Road Show, Yangon, MYANMAR
MYO AUNG Myanmar
 
Remaking singapore
Remaking singaporeRemaking singapore
Remaking singapore
Mahammad Khadafi
 
The Impact of Trade and Debt on Nigeria Agribusiness Sector Output (1970-2010)
The Impact of Trade and Debt on Nigeria Agribusiness Sector Output (1970-2010)The Impact of Trade and Debt on Nigeria Agribusiness Sector Output (1970-2010)
The Impact of Trade and Debt on Nigeria Agribusiness Sector Output (1970-2010)
IOSR Journals
 
Vietnam analysis of the economic, commercial and social environment 2020
Vietnam analysis of the economic, commercial and social environment 2020Vietnam analysis of the economic, commercial and social environment 2020
Vietnam analysis of the economic, commercial and social environment 2020
Juan Inoriza
 
SRI LANKA 2020
SRI LANKA 2020SRI LANKA 2020
SRI LANKA 2020
Jazeem Abdul Hameed
 

What's hot (20)

Singapore economy
Singapore economySingapore economy
Singapore economy
 
Case study: FDI in Automobile Sector in India
Case study: FDI in Automobile Sector in IndiaCase study: FDI in Automobile Sector in India
Case study: FDI in Automobile Sector in India
 
Thailand Country Analysis
Thailand Country AnalysisThailand Country Analysis
Thailand Country Analysis
 
Thailand’s Economy
Thailand’s EconomyThailand’s Economy
Thailand’s Economy
 
Thailand Presentation
Thailand PresentationThailand Presentation
Thailand Presentation
 
Thailand: Economic Setting
Thailand: Economic SettingThailand: Economic Setting
Thailand: Economic Setting
 
Singapore politics and economics
Singapore politics and economicsSingapore politics and economics
Singapore politics and economics
 
Singapore's Economic Growth
Singapore's Economic GrowthSingapore's Economic Growth
Singapore's Economic Growth
 
Singapore & malaysia economic analysis
Singapore & malaysia economic analysisSingapore & malaysia economic analysis
Singapore & malaysia economic analysis
 
Business proposal for Construction industry of UAE
Business proposal for Construction industry of UAEBusiness proposal for Construction industry of UAE
Business proposal for Construction industry of UAE
 
Malaysia macroeconomic view
Malaysia macroeconomic viewMalaysia macroeconomic view
Malaysia macroeconomic view
 
Understanding-Vietnam
Understanding-VietnamUnderstanding-Vietnam
Understanding-Vietnam
 
Gbe group3
Gbe group3 Gbe group3
Gbe group3
 
Pestel on Thailand
Pestel on Thailand Pestel on Thailand
Pestel on Thailand
 
Session 2 archanun how aec promote intra_asean trade evidence from thailand
Session 2 archanun how aec promote intra_asean trade evidence from thailandSession 2 archanun how aec promote intra_asean trade evidence from thailand
Session 2 archanun how aec promote intra_asean trade evidence from thailand
 
KYAUK PHYU SPECIAL ECONOMIC ZONE DEVELOPMENT Road Show, Yangon, MYANMAR
KYAUK PHYU SPECIAL ECONOMIC ZONE DEVELOPMENT Road Show, Yangon, MYANMARKYAUK PHYU SPECIAL ECONOMIC ZONE DEVELOPMENT Road Show, Yangon, MYANMAR
KYAUK PHYU SPECIAL ECONOMIC ZONE DEVELOPMENT Road Show, Yangon, MYANMAR
 
Remaking singapore
Remaking singaporeRemaking singapore
Remaking singapore
 
The Impact of Trade and Debt on Nigeria Agribusiness Sector Output (1970-2010)
The Impact of Trade and Debt on Nigeria Agribusiness Sector Output (1970-2010)The Impact of Trade and Debt on Nigeria Agribusiness Sector Output (1970-2010)
The Impact of Trade and Debt on Nigeria Agribusiness Sector Output (1970-2010)
 
Vietnam analysis of the economic, commercial and social environment 2020
Vietnam analysis of the economic, commercial and social environment 2020Vietnam analysis of the economic, commercial and social environment 2020
Vietnam analysis of the economic, commercial and social environment 2020
 
SRI LANKA 2020
SRI LANKA 2020SRI LANKA 2020
SRI LANKA 2020
 

Viewers also liked

Foreign Direct Investment (FDI): Case Study on Myanmar
Foreign Direct Investment (FDI): Case Study on MyanmarForeign Direct Investment (FDI): Case Study on Myanmar
Foreign Direct Investment (FDI): Case Study on Myanmar
Khaing Sape Saw
 
Myanmar intro by frost Oct-12
Myanmar intro by frost Oct-12Myanmar intro by frost Oct-12
Myanmar intro by frost Oct-12
Peerasak C.
 
FDI , its advantages and disadvantages
FDI , its advantages and disadvantagesFDI , its advantages and disadvantages
FDI , its advantages and disadvantages
Rupal Tiwari
 
Strategic impact of inward Foreign Direct Investments on the labour markets o...
Strategic impact of inward Foreign Direct Investments on the labour markets o...Strategic impact of inward Foreign Direct Investments on the labour markets o...
Strategic impact of inward Foreign Direct Investments on the labour markets o...
Prof. Edwin Agwu Middlesex University Business School, Hendon Campus, London, UK
 
Innovation cluster
Innovation clusterInnovation cluster
Governing landscapes towards multifunctionality – Contradictions, Tensions & ...
Governing landscapes towards multifunctionality – Contradictions, Tensions & ...Governing landscapes towards multifunctionality – Contradictions, Tensions & ...
Governing landscapes towards multifunctionality – Contradictions, Tensions & ...
SIANI
 
Myanmar and the Policy Framework for Investment - Aung Naing Oo – Southeast A...
Myanmar and the Policy Framework for Investment - Aung Naing Oo – Southeast A...Myanmar and the Policy Framework for Investment - Aung Naing Oo – Southeast A...
Myanmar and the Policy Framework for Investment - Aung Naing Oo – Southeast A...
OECD Directorate for Financial and Enterprise Affairs
 
U shwe thein s1 land policy dialogue
U shwe thein s1 land policy dialogueU shwe thein s1 land policy dialogue
U shwe thein s1 land policy dialogue
mrlgregion
 
Land-use transitions and agroforestry in upland Myanmar
Land-use transitions and agroforestry in upland MyanmarLand-use transitions and agroforestry in upland Myanmar
Land-use transitions and agroforestry in upland Myanmar
SIANI
 
Agricultural trade, and economic growth in Myanmar (Comments)
Agricultural trade, and economic growth in Myanmar (Comments)Agricultural trade, and economic growth in Myanmar (Comments)
Agricultural trade, and economic growth in Myanmar (Comments)
International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI)
 
Determinants of foreign direct investment in malaysia
Determinants of foreign direct investment in malaysiaDeterminants of foreign direct investment in malaysia
Determinants of foreign direct investment in malaysia
Mohammad Hasan Tusher
 
Key findings - Stephen Thomsen - Launch of the OECD Investment Policy Review ...
Key findings - Stephen Thomsen - Launch of the OECD Investment Policy Review ...Key findings - Stephen Thomsen - Launch of the OECD Investment Policy Review ...
Key findings - Stephen Thomsen - Launch of the OECD Investment Policy Review ...
OECD Directorate for Financial and Enterprise Affairs
 
Myanmar - Significant Law and Regulation Relevant to the Offshore Oil and Gas...
Myanmar - Significant Law and Regulation Relevant to the Offshore Oil and Gas...Myanmar - Significant Law and Regulation Relevant to the Offshore Oil and Gas...
Myanmar - Significant Law and Regulation Relevant to the Offshore Oil and Gas...
Dr. Oliver Massmann
 
BC Model - An Analysis of the Financial Viability of Customer Service Provide...
BC Model - An Analysis of the Financial Viability of Customer Service Provide...BC Model - An Analysis of the Financial Viability of Customer Service Provide...
BC Model - An Analysis of the Financial Viability of Customer Service Provide...
Tanya Mendiratta
 
How Do Community Improvement Plans work for Agriculture - Haldimand County - ...
How Do Community Improvement Plans work for Agriculture - Haldimand County - ...How Do Community Improvement Plans work for Agriculture - Haldimand County - ...
How Do Community Improvement Plans work for Agriculture - Haldimand County - ...
Carolyn Puterbough
 
Library Resources for Stocks, Bonds, and Mutual Funds: Morningstar Research I...
Library Resources for Stocks, Bonds, and Mutual Funds: Morningstar Research I...Library Resources for Stocks, Bonds, and Mutual Funds: Morningstar Research I...
Library Resources for Stocks, Bonds, and Mutual Funds: Morningstar Research I...
barringtonarealibrary
 
Viability Not Liability
Viability Not LiabilityViability Not Liability
Viability Not Liability
walescva
 
Financial viability
Financial viabilityFinancial viability
Financial viability
Wisnu Dewobroto
 
New Media Wave
New Media WaveNew Media Wave
New Media Wave
Sivaraman Swaminathan
 
Cil birmingham presentation - 19 jan 2012 (2)
Cil   birmingham presentation - 19 jan 2012 (2)Cil   birmingham presentation - 19 jan 2012 (2)
Cil birmingham presentation - 19 jan 2012 (2)
Niicole93
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Foreign Direct Investment (FDI): Case Study on Myanmar
Foreign Direct Investment (FDI): Case Study on MyanmarForeign Direct Investment (FDI): Case Study on Myanmar
Foreign Direct Investment (FDI): Case Study on Myanmar
 
Myanmar intro by frost Oct-12
Myanmar intro by frost Oct-12Myanmar intro by frost Oct-12
Myanmar intro by frost Oct-12
 
FDI , its advantages and disadvantages
FDI , its advantages and disadvantagesFDI , its advantages and disadvantages
FDI , its advantages and disadvantages
 
Strategic impact of inward Foreign Direct Investments on the labour markets o...
Strategic impact of inward Foreign Direct Investments on the labour markets o...Strategic impact of inward Foreign Direct Investments on the labour markets o...
Strategic impact of inward Foreign Direct Investments on the labour markets o...
 
Innovation cluster
Innovation clusterInnovation cluster
Innovation cluster
 
Governing landscapes towards multifunctionality – Contradictions, Tensions & ...
Governing landscapes towards multifunctionality – Contradictions, Tensions & ...Governing landscapes towards multifunctionality – Contradictions, Tensions & ...
Governing landscapes towards multifunctionality – Contradictions, Tensions & ...
 
Myanmar and the Policy Framework for Investment - Aung Naing Oo – Southeast A...
Myanmar and the Policy Framework for Investment - Aung Naing Oo – Southeast A...Myanmar and the Policy Framework for Investment - Aung Naing Oo – Southeast A...
Myanmar and the Policy Framework for Investment - Aung Naing Oo – Southeast A...
 
U shwe thein s1 land policy dialogue
U shwe thein s1 land policy dialogueU shwe thein s1 land policy dialogue
U shwe thein s1 land policy dialogue
 
Land-use transitions and agroforestry in upland Myanmar
Land-use transitions and agroforestry in upland MyanmarLand-use transitions and agroforestry in upland Myanmar
Land-use transitions and agroforestry in upland Myanmar
 
Agricultural trade, and economic growth in Myanmar (Comments)
Agricultural trade, and economic growth in Myanmar (Comments)Agricultural trade, and economic growth in Myanmar (Comments)
Agricultural trade, and economic growth in Myanmar (Comments)
 
Determinants of foreign direct investment in malaysia
Determinants of foreign direct investment in malaysiaDeterminants of foreign direct investment in malaysia
Determinants of foreign direct investment in malaysia
 
Key findings - Stephen Thomsen - Launch of the OECD Investment Policy Review ...
Key findings - Stephen Thomsen - Launch of the OECD Investment Policy Review ...Key findings - Stephen Thomsen - Launch of the OECD Investment Policy Review ...
Key findings - Stephen Thomsen - Launch of the OECD Investment Policy Review ...
 
Myanmar - Significant Law and Regulation Relevant to the Offshore Oil and Gas...
Myanmar - Significant Law and Regulation Relevant to the Offshore Oil and Gas...Myanmar - Significant Law and Regulation Relevant to the Offshore Oil and Gas...
Myanmar - Significant Law and Regulation Relevant to the Offshore Oil and Gas...
 
BC Model - An Analysis of the Financial Viability of Customer Service Provide...
BC Model - An Analysis of the Financial Viability of Customer Service Provide...BC Model - An Analysis of the Financial Viability of Customer Service Provide...
BC Model - An Analysis of the Financial Viability of Customer Service Provide...
 
How Do Community Improvement Plans work for Agriculture - Haldimand County - ...
How Do Community Improvement Plans work for Agriculture - Haldimand County - ...How Do Community Improvement Plans work for Agriculture - Haldimand County - ...
How Do Community Improvement Plans work for Agriculture - Haldimand County - ...
 
Library Resources for Stocks, Bonds, and Mutual Funds: Morningstar Research I...
Library Resources for Stocks, Bonds, and Mutual Funds: Morningstar Research I...Library Resources for Stocks, Bonds, and Mutual Funds: Morningstar Research I...
Library Resources for Stocks, Bonds, and Mutual Funds: Morningstar Research I...
 
Viability Not Liability
Viability Not LiabilityViability Not Liability
Viability Not Liability
 
Financial viability
Financial viabilityFinancial viability
Financial viability
 
New Media Wave
New Media WaveNew Media Wave
New Media Wave
 
Cil birmingham presentation - 19 jan 2012 (2)
Cil   birmingham presentation - 19 jan 2012 (2)Cil   birmingham presentation - 19 jan 2012 (2)
Cil birmingham presentation - 19 jan 2012 (2)
 

Similar to The Role of Foreign Direct Investment in Myanmar by Naw Eh Khu Mue+Hnin Thuzar Nwe+Kyaw Thu Win+Mya Thandar+Myint Zu Thein

KLE4208
KLE4208 KLE4208
KLE4208
KLIBEL
 
Final 1
Final 1Final 1
Final 1
Rohit Rohit
 
Research on the problems and Countermeasures of China's Regional investment a...
Research on the problems and Countermeasures of China's Regional investment a...Research on the problems and Countermeasures of China's Regional investment a...
Research on the problems and Countermeasures of China's Regional investment a...
AM Publications,India
 
FDI and India
FDI and IndiaFDI and India
FDI and India
Dr.houkat1968
 
An Overview about Opportunities and challenges that a foreign investor faces ...
An Overview about Opportunities and challenges that a foreign investor faces ...An Overview about Opportunities and challenges that a foreign investor faces ...
An Overview about Opportunities and challenges that a foreign investor faces ...
SaifHasan48
 
Thailand Investment Review, September 2015
Thailand Investment Review, September 2015Thailand Investment Review, September 2015
Thailand Investment Review, September 2015
Thailand Board of Investment North America
 
Tax Incentives and Foreign Direct Investment in Nigeria
Tax Incentives and Foreign Direct Investment in NigeriaTax Incentives and Foreign Direct Investment in Nigeria
Tax Incentives and Foreign Direct Investment in Nigeria
iosrjce
 
A Study Of FDI In India
A Study Of FDI In IndiaA Study Of FDI In India
A Study Of FDI In India
Don Dooley
 
Fdi ppt (2)
Fdi ppt (2)Fdi ppt (2)
Fdi ppt (2)
Roni Bhowmik
 
Growth and Development of FDI on Indian Economy
Growth and Development of FDI on Indian EconomyGrowth and Development of FDI on Indian Economy
Growth and Development of FDI on Indian Economy
IJMER
 
CHINA IN MYANMAR(BURMA) FOR ARMS-LOGGING-DAM-COPPER-JADE etcs-PART ONE
CHINA IN MYANMAR(BURMA) FOR ARMS-LOGGING-DAM-COPPER-JADE etcs-PART ONECHINA IN MYANMAR(BURMA) FOR ARMS-LOGGING-DAM-COPPER-JADE etcs-PART ONE
CHINA IN MYANMAR(BURMA) FOR ARMS-LOGGING-DAM-COPPER-JADE etcs-PART ONE
MYO AUNG Myanmar
 
FDI in Bangladesh
FDI in BangladeshFDI in Bangladesh
FDI in Bangladesh
SaifHasan48
 
Investment policy reform in Myanmar, presentation by Aung Naing Oo, Director ...
Investment policy reform in Myanmar, presentation by Aung Naing Oo, Director ...Investment policy reform in Myanmar, presentation by Aung Naing Oo, Director ...
Investment policy reform in Myanmar, presentation by Aung Naing Oo, Director ...
Carly Avery
 
Investment policy reform in Myanmar
Investment policy reform in MyanmarInvestment policy reform in Myanmar
Investment policy reform in Myanmar
OECD Directorate for Financial and Enterprise Affairs
 
Market Level overview.docx
Market Level overview.docxMarket Level overview.docx
Market Level overview.docx
Bozidar Djurdjic
 
Impact of fdi banana republic or miracle growth
Impact of fdi banana republic or miracle growthImpact of fdi banana republic or miracle growth
Impact of fdi banana republic or miracle growth
IAEME Publication
 
A study of fdi in india
A study of fdi in indiaA study of fdi in india
A study of fdi in india
Alexander Decker
 
China investment attracting pattern and regional promotion planning report, 2...
China investment attracting pattern and regional promotion planning report, 2...China investment attracting pattern and regional promotion planning report, 2...
China investment attracting pattern and regional promotion planning report, 2...
Qianzhan Intelligence
 
Factors affecting fdi flow in ethiopia
Factors affecting fdi flow in ethiopiaFactors affecting fdi flow in ethiopia
Factors affecting fdi flow in ethiopia
Alexander Decker
 
An analytical study of fdi in india (2000 2015)
An analytical study of fdi in india (2000 2015)An analytical study of fdi in india (2000 2015)
An analytical study of fdi in india (2000 2015)
Abhishek vyas
 

Similar to The Role of Foreign Direct Investment in Myanmar by Naw Eh Khu Mue+Hnin Thuzar Nwe+Kyaw Thu Win+Mya Thandar+Myint Zu Thein (20)

KLE4208
KLE4208 KLE4208
KLE4208
 
Final 1
Final 1Final 1
Final 1
 
Research on the problems and Countermeasures of China's Regional investment a...
Research on the problems and Countermeasures of China's Regional investment a...Research on the problems and Countermeasures of China's Regional investment a...
Research on the problems and Countermeasures of China's Regional investment a...
 
FDI and India
FDI and IndiaFDI and India
FDI and India
 
An Overview about Opportunities and challenges that a foreign investor faces ...
An Overview about Opportunities and challenges that a foreign investor faces ...An Overview about Opportunities and challenges that a foreign investor faces ...
An Overview about Opportunities and challenges that a foreign investor faces ...
 
Thailand Investment Review, September 2015
Thailand Investment Review, September 2015Thailand Investment Review, September 2015
Thailand Investment Review, September 2015
 
Tax Incentives and Foreign Direct Investment in Nigeria
Tax Incentives and Foreign Direct Investment in NigeriaTax Incentives and Foreign Direct Investment in Nigeria
Tax Incentives and Foreign Direct Investment in Nigeria
 
A Study Of FDI In India
A Study Of FDI In IndiaA Study Of FDI In India
A Study Of FDI In India
 
Fdi ppt (2)
Fdi ppt (2)Fdi ppt (2)
Fdi ppt (2)
 
Growth and Development of FDI on Indian Economy
Growth and Development of FDI on Indian EconomyGrowth and Development of FDI on Indian Economy
Growth and Development of FDI on Indian Economy
 
CHINA IN MYANMAR(BURMA) FOR ARMS-LOGGING-DAM-COPPER-JADE etcs-PART ONE
CHINA IN MYANMAR(BURMA) FOR ARMS-LOGGING-DAM-COPPER-JADE etcs-PART ONECHINA IN MYANMAR(BURMA) FOR ARMS-LOGGING-DAM-COPPER-JADE etcs-PART ONE
CHINA IN MYANMAR(BURMA) FOR ARMS-LOGGING-DAM-COPPER-JADE etcs-PART ONE
 
FDI in Bangladesh
FDI in BangladeshFDI in Bangladesh
FDI in Bangladesh
 
Investment policy reform in Myanmar, presentation by Aung Naing Oo, Director ...
Investment policy reform in Myanmar, presentation by Aung Naing Oo, Director ...Investment policy reform in Myanmar, presentation by Aung Naing Oo, Director ...
Investment policy reform in Myanmar, presentation by Aung Naing Oo, Director ...
 
Investment policy reform in Myanmar
Investment policy reform in MyanmarInvestment policy reform in Myanmar
Investment policy reform in Myanmar
 
Market Level overview.docx
Market Level overview.docxMarket Level overview.docx
Market Level overview.docx
 
Impact of fdi banana republic or miracle growth
Impact of fdi banana republic or miracle growthImpact of fdi banana republic or miracle growth
Impact of fdi banana republic or miracle growth
 
A study of fdi in india
A study of fdi in indiaA study of fdi in india
A study of fdi in india
 
China investment attracting pattern and regional promotion planning report, 2...
China investment attracting pattern and regional promotion planning report, 2...China investment attracting pattern and regional promotion planning report, 2...
China investment attracting pattern and regional promotion planning report, 2...
 
Factors affecting fdi flow in ethiopia
Factors affecting fdi flow in ethiopiaFactors affecting fdi flow in ethiopia
Factors affecting fdi flow in ethiopia
 
An analytical study of fdi in india (2000 2015)
An analytical study of fdi in india (2000 2015)An analytical study of fdi in india (2000 2015)
An analytical study of fdi in india (2000 2015)
 

The Role of Foreign Direct Investment in Myanmar by Naw Eh Khu Mue+Hnin Thuzar Nwe+Kyaw Thu Win+Mya Thandar+Myint Zu Thein

  • 1. i
  • 2. ii
  • 3. i Acknowledgement Firstly, we wish to express our gratitude to the Yangon University of Economics for giving us the opportunity to do and encouragement to conduct this paper. Our special thanks go to Associate Professor Daw Yi Yi Khin, our program coordinator, who showed keen interest in this paper, provided professional guidance, motherly concern, critical comments and valuable advice. We are thankful to our supervisor, Daw Pwint Phyu Aung (Assistant Lecturer, Department of Applied Economics, Yangon University of Economics) for her kind supervision, persistent supports, and encouragement throughout this research study. We found her insightful criticisms useful and valuable in completing this study paper. Above all, we wish to thanks our beloved family and our friends for their support and encouragement. Last, but not least, we would like to express our gratitude to all those who contributed their time, efforts, and expertise directly or indirectly to bring the study to final completion.
  • 4. ii Abstract Since the new government took office in March 2011, Myanmar has embarked on a process of extensive political and economic reform. In recent years, the international community has witnessed many positive changes in Myanmar, including greater space for civil society, an expansion in freedom of expression, and evident government concern about environmental and local livelihood issues resulting from large‐scale development projects. With new foreign investment laws and the lifting of economic sanctions by Western countries, Myanmar is opening rapidly to the global market economy. With the country’s plentiful resources and the input of foreign investment, Myanmar is ready to pursue economic growth under the name of “development”. The objective of the study is to examine the role of Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) and the situation of FDI flows in Myanmar. The study was based on secondary data source of Myanmar over the period of 2000 to 2014. To achieve a step change in FDI and get closer to meeting the economy’s large need for investment, as well as to continue to diversify the sectors to which FDI goes, Myanmar needs to prioritize two main areas: developing a targeted FDI strategy led by a high-performing agency and improving Myanmar’s business environment. In order to provide more specific guidance to potential foreign investors, some types of activities have been specified as open to foreign investment. A foreign investor may apply for and obtain a permit under the Foreign Investment Law for an economic activity not so specified, provided the foreign investor can explain how the activity would be mutually beneficial to Myanmar and the foreign investor.
  • 5. iii CONTENTS Acknowledgement i Abstract ii Contents iii List of Tables iv List of Figures iv Chapter (I) Introduction 1 1.1 Rationale of the Study 1 1.2 Objective of the Study 2 1.3 Method of Study 3 1.4 Scope and Limitation of the Study 3 1.5 Organization of the Study 3 Chapter (II) Importance of Foreign Direct Investment in Developing Countries 4 2.1 Definitions of Foreign Direct Investment 4 2.2 The Role of FDI into Developing Countries 5 2.3 FDI flows and FDI stocks 5 2.4 The Effect of FDI in host countries and home countries 5 2.5 Benefits and Costs of FDI to Home and Host Countries 8 Chapter (III) Foreign Direct Investment in Myanmar 10 3.1 Background of FDI in Myanmar 10 3.2 Direction of FDI in Myanmar 10 3.3 FDI inflows into Myanmar 11 3.4 Countries investing the most in Myanmar 13 3.5 Natural Resources and FDI in Myanmar 19 Chapter (IV) Barriers and Opportunities in Myanmar 25 4.1 Barriers in Administration and Policies 25 4.2 Barriers in Information, Infrastructure and Institution 26 4.3 Human Resource Barriers 28 4.4 Investment Opportunities in Resource Sectors 29 4.5 Opportunities in Manufacturing 31 Chapter (V) Conclusion 33 5.1 Findings 33 5.2 Suggestions 35 References 36
  • 6. iv List of Tables Tables Page 1. Foreign Direct Investment in Myanmar by Country (2000 - 2014) 14 2. Approved Amount of Foreign Direct Investment by Sector (2003 - 2014) 15 3. Foreign Direct Investment in Myanmar by year (2000 - 2014) 18 List of Figures Figures Page 1. Figure 1 : The pattern of FDI inflows into Myanmar (2000-2014) 11 2. Figure 2 : Trend of FDI to Myanmar (2000-2012) 12 3. Figure 3: Top Ten Countries Investing In Myanmar (2000-2014) 16 4. Figure 4: Composition of Foreign Direct Investment 17 5. Figure 5: Natural resources and economic zones 24
  • 7. - 1 - Chapter (1) Introduction 1.1. Rationale of the study Foreign Direct Investment has emerged as one of the most important sources of external resource inflows and an engine for economic development in developing countries over the 1990s and has become a significant part of capital formation in the countries concerned. Moreover positive externalities such as vertical linkage and technology spillovers are believed to stimulate growth in the host countries. Many policy makers in developing countries are setting policies that try to attract FDI in the hope of bringing about economic growth by maximizing technology spillovers which could help in the formation of human capital which in turn could significantly contribute to growth. In the late 1998, Myanmar changed its economy from centrally planned economic system to market-oriented one. After transforming into market-oriented economy, Myanmar made many economic reforms and also accepted foreign direct investment into the country. According to the World Bank data source in 2012, the inflow of foreign direct investment into the country is $ 2.2 billion. As a developing country, Myanmar needs more foreign direct investment in order to develop the country's economy. The government has been undertaking many efforts to create favorable investment environment, aiming at achieving more employment opportunities, developing human resources, and facilitating the economic growth of the country. The government of the Republic of the Union of Myanmar has conducted a series of political and economic reforms since 2011. The companies which had hesitated to invest in Myanmar such as from EU, the United States, Japan and ASEAN have now started to seek a way to invest in the country especially in the areas with minimal risk. Many companies, however, have not changed their "wait and see" attitude and they have yet to decide about to make a significant investment in Myanmar. Nevertheless, the Myanmar government is making necessary preparations for attracting more foreign direct investment (FDI).
  • 8. - 2 - A new Foreign Investment Law was signed on November 2, 2012 to create a more favorable climate for foreign investors. The new law stipulates that foreign investments can take place as sole ownership (100% stake), or a joint venture with local citizens, government, or organizations. According to the law, foreign firms are required to operate through forming joint venture with local investors in certain sectors. The Union of the Myanmar has already involved in ASEAN Economic Community (AEC) which purpose is to lower import duties among ASEAN countries gradually and targeted will be zero for most of their import duties. And the government has also made significant efforts such as in promotion and expansion of exports, in reducing tariffs and other restrictions on trade. Further, the government has focused on improving physical infrastructures, flexible domestic markets, fostering transparency and stability in rules related with FDI, equal treatment for foreign and local firms, administrative procedures and regulatory transparency directly linked to the trading process. FDI is very important for Myanmar since it needs foreign capital to generate employment for its citizens, acquire technology know-how and accumulate foreign exchange to implement development projects. Given the continuous decline in Overseas Development Assistance and bank borrowings from international financial agencies as a result of the economic sanctions that followed the military coup in 1988, FDI continues to be a significant source of external finance for ensuring development, fulfilling investment and narrowing development gaps between and within states and regions. It also helps ensure the sustainability of the recovery process and industrial development in Myanmar. FDI brings along with it not only capital flows that would contribute to the balance of payments but also a package of other economic benefit such as employment opportunities, export market expansion, technology and entrepreneurial skill enhancement. 1.2. Objective of the Study The objective of the study is to examine the role of Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) and the situation of FDI flows in Myanmar.
  • 9. - 3 - 1.3. Method of Study This study is made on simple descriptive method with available statistical data and secondary data sources collection from various reliable data sources. The main sources of data are Statistical Year Book, April 2015 (Central Statistical Organization) published by Ministry of National Planning and Economic Development, the Government of the Republic of the Union of Myanmar, and Directorate of Investment and Company Administration(DICA). The major online resources included Data from World Bank and Directorate-General for Trade, European Commission, and ADB reports. 1.4. Scope and Limitation of the Study This study is focused on foreign direct investment inflows in Myanmar. The study will present on economic environment of Myanmar with the emphasis on factors such as macroeconomic environment, infrastructural development and human resource development and FDI accommodating institutions. The study was based on secondary data source of Myanmar over the period of 2000 to 2014. 1.5. Organization of the Study This study is organized into five chapters. Chapter (1) is the introduction of the study which includes rationale, objective and method of the study together with scope and limitation of the study. Chapter (2) includes Importance of Foreign Direct Investment in developing that organized by Definition of Foreign Direct Investment, The Role of FDI into Developing Countries, FDI flows and FDI stocks, The Effect of FDI in host countries and home countries and Benefits and Costs of FDI to Home and Host Countries. And Foreign Direct Investment in Myanmar will be included in Chapter (3). In chapter (4), Barriers and Opportunities in Myanmar will be involved. And the last chapter (5) attempts on drawing a conclusion by pointing out the findings which need to be addressed in order to promote the FDI in the country.
  • 10. - 4 - Chapter (II) Importance of Foreign Direct Investment in Developing Countries 2.1 Definitions of Foreign Direct Investment Foreign direct investment (FDI) plays an extraordinary and growing role in global business. It can provide a firm with new markets and marketing channels, cheaper production facilities, access to new technology, products, skills and financing. For a host country or the foreign firm which receives the investment, it can provide a source of new technologies, capital, processes, products, organizational technologies and management skills, and as such can provide a strong impetus to economic development. Foreign direct investment, in its classic definition, is defined as a company from one country making a physical investment into building a factory in another country. The direct investment in buildings, machinery and equipment is in contrast with making a portfolio investment, which is considered an indirect investment. In recent years, given rapid growth and change in global investment patterns, the definition has been broadened to include the acquisition of a lasting management interest in a company or enterprise outside the investing firm’s home country. The international Monetary Fund (1997) defines FDI as "an investment that is made to acquire a lasting interest in an enterprise operating in an economy other than that of the investor, the investor's purpose being to have an effective voice in the management of the enterprise." According to UNCTAD definition, FDI is defined as an investment involving management control of a resident entity in one economy by an enterprise resident in another country. Agiomirganakis et al. (2003) defined FDI as the flow of capital resulting from the behavior of multinational companies. So, the factors which affect the MNC's behavior will also affect the direction and magnitude of FDI.
  • 11. - 5 - 2.2 The Role of FDI into Developing Countries FDI is very important for the development of a country, especially, for developing economics. The experience of newly industrialized countries (NICs) shows that FDI had played an important role in their economic development. In the age of globalization with cross-border flow of capital among nations, FDI becomes a key solution to reducing development gaps among nations. The rapid growth of multinational corporations (MNCs) has become the major driver for the process of FDI because they are looking everywhere in the globe as investment center. The government had identified a number of potential investment opportunities for foreign investors and has also embarked on a privatization program. A foreign investor (whether investing through a joint venture or a 100 percent owned entity) manufacturing goods or providing services in Myanmar under the Foreign Investment Law will be granted an exemption from income tax for three consecutive years, inclusive of the year of commencement. 2.3 FDI flows and FDI stocks Whenever we talk about the international movement of “capital”, there are two types of capital movements: foreign direct investment (FDI) and foreign portfolio investment (FPI). Foreign direct investment (FDI) refers to a movement of capital that involves ownership and control for foreign ownership of production facilities took place (i.e. long-term capital stock). Foreign portfolio investment (FPI) is financial capital because it does not involve ownership or control but the flow (i.e. not the stock and it is short–term financial flow). 2.4 The Effect of FDI in host countries and home countries The effects of foreign direct investment (FDI) on the home countries (the source of FDI) of Multinational Corporations (MNCs) have become well-known in the international debate during the past decade. After the completion of the Uruguay round, global liberalization of trade and investment and the regional integration processes in Europe, the Americas, and the Asia-Pacific region are important reasons for this resurgence of interest. Because of the Asian crisis in 1997-1999, a global boom in FDI that was temporarily interrupted by a reduction in investment flows.
  • 12. - 6 - The annual number of cross-border investments in Europe exceeds 10,000, and both China and the US attract thousands of FDI projects every year. Inflows to Russia have accelerated after the collapse of the Soviet Union. In recent years, India has become an important destination for FDI, and several other Asian countries record substantial inflows. Both West Asian and African countries can be found among the economies with the fastest increases in inward FDI (UNCTAD 2006). In contrast, several developing countries such as Brazil, China, India, South Africa, and Malaysia in which local companies have created sufficient intangible assets to become multinational. However, developing countries have been focused on the effects of inward FDI and thus there is little evidence on how they are affected by outward investment. There are possible differences in the home country effects of FDI in developed economies and in that of developing countries. The inward FDI in hosting countries stimulate employment, and investment, and economic growth. However, one view is that outward FDI have negative effects on home country’s growth when applying the same logic to home countries implies that the outward FDI would damage growth of home countries by taking away investment, employment and output production. This is the general concern of the public in home countries. Horizontal and vertical types of outward FDI could promote economic growth of home countries. While horizontal FDI is market seeking and substitutes host country's’ employment and output for home country, vertical FDI is cost minimizing and complement host country’s employment and output for home country. The general characteristics of host countries are considered by investors deciding whether to undertake a project in any country and important attention is being paid to political variables in addition to traditional economic variables. The particular host country economic determinants of FDI are (i) market-seeking FDI (i.e. firms are attempting to locate facilities near large markets for their goods and services), (ii) resource-seeking and asset seeking FDI (i.e. firms are in searching of particular resources or particular human skills), and (iii) efficiency seeking FDI (i.e. firms can sell their products worldwide and are in searching of the location where production costs are the lowest). Beyond economic factors, foreign firms considering investment in any given country will also be influenced by various policies and attitudes of the host country’s government (i.e. political situation of the host country).
  • 13. - 7 - Within host countries, foreign- owned firms almost always pay higher wages than domestically- owned firms. It is not always the case that they cause wages in locally- owned firms to rise, but their presence does generally raise wage levels in host countries. The impact of FDI in promoting the growth of host country exports and linkages to the outside world is clearer (i.e. host country effects of inward FDI). The major role of FDI in the transformation of host economies from being exporters of raw materials and foods to being relatively exporters of high- tech manufactures. Much of the impact is from the transfer of knowledge of world markets and of ways of fitting into worldwide production networks, not visible in standard productivity measurements. Multinational operations have led to a shift by parent firms in the United States toward more capital- intensive and skill- intensive domestic production. However, that type of reallocation does not appear to have taken place in Japan or Sweden. Foreign firms generally have higher productivity than local firms, but the evidence for spillovers to local firms' productivity is mixed. It seems to depend on host country policies and environments and on the technological levels of industries and of host- country firms. Much of the growth of presently developed countries came from increases in the scale of production and in its capital intensity. The contribution of the foreign owned firms is mainly of knowledge, particularly knowledge of demand in the world market, and knowledge about how the host country can find a place in the worldwide allocation of intermediate steps in the path of production that can be geographically separated. By the development of new product (to the host country) inward direct investment is associated with faster economic growth, although the extent of FDI inflows and national economic growth do not produce strong and consistent relationships. A clear mention can be made of the fact that there are impacts of FDI on the sending or home country of the investment as well as on the receiving or host country. The impact of FDI on home country (outward FDI) is more favorable than that of host country (inward FDI) because FDI benefits the home country to a large extent albeit some disadvantages. As shown in table, listed below are the impacts of foreign direct investment (FDI) on home and host countries.
  • 14. - 8 - 2.5 Benefits and Costs of FDI to Home and Host Countries The benefits and costs of FDI to home and host countries are listed to understand very easily by constructing the following table. Table-1 Benefits and Costs of FDI to Home and Host Countries Home Country Host Country Benefits 1. Lower prices for consumer 2. Create demand for export 3. Cost Advantages 4. New Markets 5. Exposure to other countries 6. International Relations 7. Creates new employment 8. New technology 9. Increases income 1. Increase output 2. Increase wages 3. Increase employment 4. Increase exports 5. Increase Tax revenues 6. Realization of scale economies 7. Provision of technical & managerial skills & of new technology 8. Weakening of power of domestic monopoly Costs 1. National sovereignty and national defense 2. Affect employment 1. Adverse impact on the host country’s commodity terms of trade 2. Decreased domestic saving 3. Decreased domestic investment 4. Instability in the balance of payments & the exchange rate 5. Loss of control over domestic policy 6. Establishment of local monopoly 7. Inadequate attention to the development of local education and skills 8. National sovereignty and autonomy Source: Ma Pwint Phyu Aung (2013), Ph.D Prelim (Ba-2), "Impact of FDI on Home and Host Countries", Assignment, Meiktila University of Economics, Mandalay, Myanmar. There may be more or less advantages and disadvantages in Foreign Direct Investment to both home countries and host countries. The above table mentioned the benefits and costs of Foreign Direct Investment for Home Countries and Host countries.
  • 15. - 9 - The benefits of home countries are lower prices for consumer, create demand for export, cost advantages, new markets, exposure to other countries, international relations, creates new employment, new technology, and increases income. The cost of these home countries are national sovereignty and national defense and affect employment. On the other hand, the benefits of host countries can be calculated that are increase output, increase wages, increase employment, increase exports, increase tax revenues, realization of scale economies, provision of technical & managerial skills & of new technology, and weakening of power of domestic monopoly. The cost of the host countries are adverse impact on the host country’s commodity terms of trade, decreased domestic saving, decreased domestic investment, instability in the balance of payments & the exchange rate, loss of control over domestic policy, establishment of local monopoly, inadequate attention to the development of local education and skills, and national sovereignty and autonomy.
  • 16. - 10 - Chapter (III) Foreign Direct Investment in Myanmar 3.1 Background of FDI in Myanmar Myanmar had been undertaking economic reforms since 1988. Since then, the country has officially adopted market-oriented economy and welcomed FDI inflow. Accordingly, a series of legislation conductive to market economy have been enacted and some of the existing laws were amended to be compatible with the changing economic environment. Soon after the adoption of a market-oriented economy, Myanmar foreign Investment Law was promulgated on 30 November 1988 and Myanmar Foreign Investment Commission was formed on 7 December 1988. Myanmar fully recognizes the advantages of FDI for its economic development. Consequently, the government has been actively encouraging FDI in Myanmar. Its main foreign investment policy and objectives are as follows. a. Adoption of a market-oriented system for allocation of resources. b. Encouragement of private investment and entrepreneurial activity. The basic principles of Myanmar Foreign Investment Law are as follow.  Exploitation of natural resources which require heavy investment  Acquisition of high technology  Developing production and services industries involving large capital  Creating local employment opportunities,  Developing of works which would save energy consumption and regional investment. 3.2. Direction of FDI in Myanmar Myanmar is a country rich in natural and human resources. It has vast cultivable land, long coastlines, navigable river systems, abundant materials, gems, forests and a literate population. These plus attractive incentives are expected to entice potential foreign investors. Foreign investments from various counties have been coming into
  • 17. - 11 - Myanmar since 1989. The pattern of foreign direct investment inflows into Myanmar from 2000-20141 is shown as follows. Data in all figures represent approval data by MIC. Source: DICA 3.3. FDI inflows into Myanmar The FDI inflows into Myanmar are heavily concentrated on natural resource based and extractive industries such as power, oil and gas and mining sectors. From 1990 to 2005 total amount of FDI inflows into the country are concentrated in power sector (81.59%). The inflows into other sectors are agriculture (0.27 %), manufacturing (1.96%) and hotel and tourism (2.36%) which is relatively low because the country possesses attractive features, in terms of resources may be constrained by variety of factors such as sanctions imposed by US and EU, unfavorable exchange rates and foreign investment laws (Myanmar Statistical Year Book, 2011). Myanmar approved foreign investment totaling US $8.01 billion from 211 companies for the 2014-2015 fiscal year across 12 sectors, according to the Directorate of Investment and Company Administration. Among the sectors attracting foreign direct 1 Myanamar Fiscal Year is from April to March. - 2,000.00 4,000.00 6,000.00 8,000.00 10,000.00 12,000.00 14,000.00 16,000.00 18,000.00 20,000.00 22,000.00 2000-01 2001-02 2002-03 2003-04 2004-05 2005-06 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 2012-13 2013-14 2014-15 US$million Year Figure 1 : The pattern of FDI infolws into Myanmar (2000-2014) US $ million
  • 18. - 12 - investment during the fiscal year ending 31 March, oil and gas sector topped the list at $3.22 billion, followed by transport and communication with approved capital of $1.68 billion and manufacturing with $1.5 billion. The real estate sector attracted $0.78 billion while $0.36 billion was approved for the hotel and tourism sector. Figure 2: Trend of FDI to Myanmar Source: Selected Monthly Economic Indicators, April 2012, DICA Table shows that DICA’s data showed approved foreign direct investment nearly doubled from $4.1billion in fiscal 2013-2014 to $8.01 billion in 2014-2015. Myanmar expects to receive $6 billion in the current fiscal year. From fiscal 1988-89 to 2014-2015, the approved amount of foreign investment in Myanmar reached a total $54.23 billion, coming from 895 permitted companies from 38 countries. US$ million
  • 19. - 13 - 3.4. Countries investing the most in Myanmar After changing the economy from a centrally-planned economy to a market- oriented one, the government had made a series of liberalizing measures to promote and raise the level of investment in almost every sector of the economy, an also encouraged private sector to participate actively in foreign direct investment activities. After foreign investment law was enacted, the government has attracted 18 foreign enterprises with the amount of $ 449.487 million in 1989-1990, 22 foreign enterprises with $ 280.573 million in 1990-1991, and 4 enterprises with $ 5.893 million in 1991- 1992. In brief, FDI inflows into the country gradually increased from 1989 to 1996. But the amount of inflows decreased continuously from the year 1996-1997 because of Asian Financial Crisis in that year. However, the amount increased again in 2004- 2005 and 2005-2006 because of huge investment in power sector by Thailand. In 2008-2009, total investment increased to an amount of $ 984.446 million and rose sharply again in 2011 with the amount of $ 19997.968 million. All the investments during this period are mostly from Asia, UK and Russia. The approved amount of FDI inflows are shown in the following table.
  • 20. - 14 - Table (1): Foreign Direct Investment in Myanmar by Country (2000 - 2014) (US$ million) Sr. No Country 2000- 2001 2001- 2002 2002- 2003 2003- 2004 2004- 2005 2005- 2006 2006- 2007 2007- 2008 2008- 2009 2009- 2010 2010- 2011 2011- 2012 2012- 2013 2013- 2014 2014- 2015 Total 1 China 28.98 3.3 2.8 126.6 0.7 281.2 856 2.5 8269.2 4,345.73 231.77 56.92 516.90 14722.6 2 Thailand 25.75 22 29 6034.4 16.2 15 15.3 2146 1.30 489.07 165.68 8959.7 3 Singapore 36.915 6.1 81 38 39.2 226.2 418.23 2,340.12 4,297.19 7482.955 4 Hong Kong 13.229 1.5 12.9 3 6 5798.3 84.84 107.10 625.56 6652.429 5 Republic of Korea 47.222 5 0.3 34.9 37 12 -4 2676.4 25.27 37.94 81.21 299.59 3252.832 6 United Kingdom 30.612 1.5 27 273 799 99.83 232.70 156.86 850.76 2471.262 7 Malaysia 9.832 1.5 62.2 237.6 76.8 51.86 4.32 616.11 6.72 1066.942 8 Vietnam 20 18.15 329.39 142.00 175.40 684.94 9 India 47.5 137 73.00 11.50 26.04 208.89 503.93 10 The Netherland 10.30 302.40 312.7 11 Japan 4.7 2.7 1.4 3.8 -12 7.1 4.32 54.06 55.71 85.74 207.53 12 Canada 21.95 1.5 2.10 153.92 179.47 13 Russia 94 94 14 France -1.4 5.36 67.25 71.21 15 Liberia 64.60 64.6 16 Brunei 2 1.00 2.27 43.87 49.14 17 UAE 41 4.50 1.69 47.19 18 Luzibut 5.20 40.15 45.35 19 Mauritania 30.6 30.6 20 Switzerland 3.4 27.00 30.4 214.49 17.50 86.90 91.20 158.30 6,065.70 719.70 203.20 984.80 329.60 19,999.00 4,618.16 1,419.45 4,088.47 7,963.52 46,959.99 Source: Central Statistical Organization
  • 21. - 15 - Table (2): Approved Amount of Foreign Direct Investment (By Sector) (2000-2014) (US$ million) Sr. No Sector 2003-04 2004-05 2005-06 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 2012-13 2013-14 2014-15 1 Agriculture - 138.750 9.650 20.269 39.666 2 Livestock and Fisheries 2.600 12.000 5.600 96.016 26.861 3 Mining 1.450 6.000 0.700 5.000 855.996 2.500 1396.077 19.897 15.334 32.730 6.259 4 Manufacturing 2.820 3.520 18.720 - 0.232 33.230 66.321 32.254 400.716 1826.980 1502.013 5 Power 6030.000 281.222 8218.520 4343.978 364.201 46.511 40.110 6 Oil and Gas 54.300 142.550 34.975 438.480 170.000 114.000 278.600 10179.297 247.697 309.200 3220.306 7 Construction - - - - - - - - - - - - 8 Transport and Communication 30.000 0.634 1190.232 1679.304 9 Hotel and Tourism 3.500 15.000 15.250 300.000 435.210 357.949 10 Real Estate 2.713 440.573 780.745 11 Industrial Estate - - - - - - - - - - - - 12 Other Services 14.766 18.534 357.320 Total 91.170 158.283 6,065.675 719.702 205.720 984.764 329.580 19,998.965 4,644.460 1,419.467 4,107.055 8,010.533 Source: Central Statistical Organization
  • 22. - 16 - According to the data from Central Statistical Organization, the most investing countries in Myanmar are stated in about chart. The top investing country is the Republic of China and the remaining countries are Thailand, Singapore, Hong Kong, Republic of Korea, United Kingdom, Malaysia, Vietnam, India and The Netherland. - 2,000.00 4,000.00 6,000.00 8,000.00 10,000.00 12,000.00 14,000.00 16,000.00US$Million Country Figure 3: Top Ten Countries Investing In Myanmar (2000-2014) US$ million
  • 23. - 17 - A various home countries had been investing in Myanmar in many different sectors including oil and gas, power, manufacturing, transport and communication, mining, hotel and tourism, real and industrial estate, agriculture and livestock and fisheries. The above chart showed the comparison of Foreign Direct Investment by sector. Agriculture, 0.47% Livestock and Fisheries, 0.32% Mining, 5.32% Manufacturing, 8.82% Power, 43.88% Oil and Gas, 34.49% Transport and Communication, 6.59% Hotel and Tourism, 2.56% Real Estate, 2.78% Other Services, 0.89% Figure 4: Composition of Foreign Direct Investment
  • 24. - 18 - Table (3): Foreign Direct Investment in Myanmar (2000-2014) US$ million Year No of Enterprises Approved Investment 2000-01 28 214.490 2001-02 7 17.500 2002-03 9 86.900 2003-04 8 91.200 2004-05 15 158.300 2005-06 5 6,065.700 2006-07 12 719.700 2007-08 7 203.200 2008-09 5 984.800 2009-10 7 329.600 2010-11 25 19,999.000 2011-12 13 4,618.160 2012-13 94 1,419.450 2013-14 122 4,088.470 2014-15 209 7,963.520 Total 566 46,959.990 Source: Central Statistical Organization As of the 2014-2015 fiscal year that ended on 31 March 2015, 566 existing foreign enterprises from over 33 countries had so far invested $46.95 billion in 11 sectors, including oil and gas, power, manufacturing, transport and communication, mining, hotel and tourism, real and industrial estate, agriculture and livestock and fisheries.
  • 25. - 19 - 3.5. Natural Resources and FDI in Myanmar Natural resources matter to Myanmar. Myanmar has a wide variety of natural resources distributed across the country (see Figure 5). The recorded value of exports of gas, oil, coal, jade, gems, metals, and wood made up about 70% of national exports, or about 10% of GDP in 2012‒13, with natural gas exports alone of $US 3.6 billion. Natural gas revenues ‘represent the largest source of foreign income for the government’, with a peak of 6.5 % of GDP projected in 2014‒15. Myanmar is estimated to rank 41st in the world for proven reserves of natural gas and 78th for proven reserves of crude oil. An Asian Development Bank assessment of the energy sector states: ‘a total of 104 blocks are demarcated onshore (53) and offshore (51) for oil and gas exploration and development. Proven oil reserves total 160 million barrels. Proven gas reserves total 20.11 trillion cubic feet with huge potential for discovery’. Natural resource-related payments comprise both tax and non-tax revenue. The exact share of Myanmar’s revenue deriving from natural resources is difficult to measure because 1) tax revenue collected by the IRD includes taxes paid by companies in the extractive sector and tax payments from state-owned enterprises (SOEs), as well as taxes not related to natural resources; 2) state owned enterprise revenues from loss-making and profit-making enterprises are now aggregated at the level of the supervising ministry, making it hard to tell how much loss or how much profit each enterprise makes; 3) payments, royalties and fees collected by Union line ministries and subnational entities are not all uniformly recorded and made public (although some are available). (a) Overview by sector Oversight of natural resource extraction and natural resource revenue is split between different ministries and levels of government, according to the type of resource, and in some cases, the value of the resource. The following section will describe formal responsibilities and procedures for handling revenue flow by sector.
  • 26. - 20 - (b) Mining Mining sites are distributed throughout many states/regions in Myanmar. Though large-scale sites such as the Letpadaung copper mine in Sagaing, Moegok gem mines in Mandalay, and Hpakant jade mines in Kachin are well-known, smaller-scale mining is widespread and has significant local environmental, social and economic impacts. Estimates of informal extraction in the mining sector suggest informal extraction exceeds formal channels, and that the value of the jade market, in particular, could be much larger than reported figures. The Ministry of Mines includes two departments: the Department of Mines and the Department of Geological Survey and Mineral Exploration. The Department of Mines oversees the mining enterprises and, in future, is also to handle environmental affairs for the Ministry of Mines. The Department of Geological Survey and Mineral Exploration is ‘responsible for mapping, prospecting, and exploration of minerals, including coal’. (c) Minerals The mining of minerals including coal, p copper, lead, nickel, tin, antimony, iron, and gold, is of great relevance to both Union and state and region governments, due to both localized environmental and social impacts and potential rapid expansion of investment in the sector. Under the 1994 Myanmar Mines Law, the Ministry of Mines controls all permitting for mineral extraction in Myanmar. A draft amendment to the law is now in the Union Parliament. The current mining law divides mining operations into ‘large scale’ and ‘small scale’ categories. Policymakers interviewed stated that the draft amended law will include a category for ‘medium scale’ mining, transfer the control of permits for ‘small scale’ and artisanal mining to state/region government control, and change the structure of contracts to foster more private investment in the sector. At the time of this publication, the law had not yet been released. Large-scale mines are governed by a joint-venture or production-sharing contract between the relevant Mining Enterprise and the private mining company. These contracts vary case-by-case. According to the Asian Development Bank’s Energy Sector Initial Assessment, for coal ‘the average PSC provides 30% of profits for the government and 70% for the private contractor’.
  • 27. - 21 - Small-scale mine companies apply to the Ministry of Mines for licenses and pay fees up front. Before mining begins, the Ministry of Mines collects application fees and land rental fees known as ‘dead rent’ according to the acreage of the mine site. Ministry of Mines officials stated that all incoming taxes and fees are collected by the relevant department and paid on an ongoing basis by the Ministry of Mines to the Ministry of Finance account. (d) Gems Gems are regulated separately from other minerals by the 1995 Myanmar Gemstone Law and are governed by the Myanmar Gems Enterprise (MGE) under the Ministry of Mines. Amendments to the Gemstone Law are reportedly being drafted by the Myanmar Gems Enterprise. In the Gemstone law, royalties are stipulated ‘based on the value assessed by the valuing body’ at 20% in the case of ruby, sapphire, jade and diamond, with 10% for other gemstones. The valuing body is set up by the Ministry of Mines. According to the law, ‘If a company sells raw gemstone on its own in foreign currency, after [the] 1st sale, 10% royalty [is due] on foreign currency actual sale value’. All high-quality gems and all grades of jade are supposed to be sold at the Myanmar Gems and Jade Emporium, held three times a year in the capital, Nay Pyi Taw, since 2006. A 10% tax is due on sales at the Emporium and is collected by the Myanmar Gems Enterprise. (e) Oil and gas Oil and gas revenues contribute to Myanmar’s budget through both direct and indirect channels (tax and non-tax revenue), with gas being much more significant than oil. In 2012‒13, natural gas exports to Thailand, ‘by far the largest single commodity sold, totaled $US 3.5 billion or 30% of total exports’ from Myanmar. All oil and gas companies are in partnership with the state-owned Myanmar Oil and Gas Enterprise (MOGE) under the Ministry of Energy, the majority through production-sharing contracts. There are three oil refineries in Myanmar, run by the Myanmar Petrochemical Enterprise (MPE). Finance officials interviewed at MOGE stated that there is variation by contract, but that MOGE has ‘15-20% participating interest typically’. Under the model production-sharing contract for oil made public by MOGE, the government receives from the contractor:
  • 28. - 22 - (f) Timber Myanmar’s most valuable timber species is teak, though there are also other valuable species of hardwood. A ban on the export of raw timber went into effect on 1 April 2014, with the stated goal of increasing value-added processes for wood products. The state-owned Myanmar Timber Enterprise (MTE), under the Ministry of Environmental Conservation and Forestry, has sole extraction rights for teak, though private companies may run teak plantations. MTE officials interviewed said that the enterprise is responsible for ‘timber harvesting, milling, and downstream processing and marketing of forest products,’ and certification from MTE is required for the legal export of timber. MTE itself has three departments: extraction, marketing, and export. MTE also enters into joint ventures with companies for wood processing. The share of revenue received from these processing businesses depends on the specific contract, which is negotiated case-by-case. (g) Hydropower Hydropower generation supplies over 70% of Myanmar’s electric power, with a total installed capacity of 46,101 megawatts. The hydropower potential of the country’s rivers, which drain the four main basins of Ayeyarwady, Chindwin, Thanlwin, and Sittaung, is estimated to be more than 100,000 megawatts (MW). Responsibility for dam projects in Myanmar is divided among several ministries and agencies, based on the size and purpose of the dam. According to a presentation from the Ministry of Agriculture and Irrigation in 2011, ‘hydropower projects are under implementation by the Department of Hydropower Implementation’ under the Ministry of Electric Power and the Department of Irrigation, under the Ministry of Agriculture and Irrigation. The Ministry of Electric Power is now operating 20 hydropower plants in Myanmar, while the Ministry of Agriculture and Irrigation constructs water reservoirs and dams for irrigation purposes. The irrigation dams sometimes include small hydropower units. The Ministry of Agriculture and Irrigation collects ‘irrigation tax from dams and reservoirs’.
  • 29. - 23 - There is variation in contract types. Contracts include joint ventures with foreign investors and policy documents discuss the potential development of new sites with a build-operate-transfer model. It is not clear from this initial review how any revenue from exported electricity from hydropower is or would be treated, and more research is needed on the hydropower sector in Myanmar.
  • 30. - 24 - Figure 5: Natural resources and economic zones Source: Myanmar Peace Monitor: ‘Economic and Political Stakes’ (September 2013).
  • 31. - 25 - Chapter (IV) Barriers and Opportunities in Myanmar Foreign Direct Investment plays a key role in the economic development of a country. However, to attract FDI is not as easy and simple task. A number of barriers hinder the inflow FDI into a particular developing country, especially for a Least Development Country (LDC). These barriers lead to increased risks and costs of foreign investors that can outweigh the location-specific advantages and resource endowments of LDCs. This can impede FDI inflow into the country. Foreign investors want to get superior returns from the investment to compensate greater risks. Political instability is one of the most important barriers to FDI. 4.1 Barriers in Administration and Policies (a) Administration Barriers In some LDCs countries, the problem starts at the submission of investment proposal stage. To get an approval to start a business or investment, the proposal has to pass different stages of official producers and require documents and consensus from various sectors. This problem is compounded by unclear and overlapping producers on decision making by the authorities concerned. This procedure takes several weeks and months. These barriers can dissuade foreign visitors from making favorable investment decisions. The persistence of administrative barriers together with absence of institutional capacity in LDCs in situation where trivial procedures like moving a file one department to another and from one table to next within the same department becomes major obstacles to progress. Complex producers and lengthy work process without transparent and standard rules create bribes and corruption at the operational level where official and unofficial fees are paid to higher levels. Most government tries to solve these hurdles by creating one stop approval shops but it leads to increase additional steps because there is no clear delegation of authority on investment.
  • 32. - 26 - (b) Policies Barriers Policy barriers are one of the causes to concern for foreign investors who want to invest for long term plan in the particular country. Fiscal policy, monetary policy, exchange rate policy and debt management policy are need into account to attract Foreign Direct Investment. Foreign investors are interested in the stability of fiscal policies in the host country, the level of tax revenue, the structure of tax and long term stability of tax rate applicable to corporate income and capital gains, exercise tax and tax on import, export, value-added and tax allowance and tax exemption for export income and the size and sustainability of budget deficits since these may impact on future operation once investment has started. Monetary policy is the central bank of the host country. Foreign investors are also interested in the stability of domestics' interest rate, the level of inflation, the credit policy and the extent of government domestic borrowing. Foreign firms concerns about the trade policy of the host country. High barriers of import both tariff and non-tariff may be one of the reasons for choosing FDI in this country. In practice, they want to operate in liberalized trade regime with fewer restrictions on producers of exporting and importing. However, foreign investors may want restricted trade policy in the countries in which they are already operated to reduce the competition of imported products from abroad. Therefore, MNCs stand on trade liberalization depends on their position whether they are inside or outside of the country. The stability of exchange rate and the permission to convert any time without restriction is also a major concern for foreign investors. 4.2 Barriers in Information, Infrastructure and Institution (a) Information Barriers There is no doubt that any foreign investor wants to get enough, clear information about the country that he is going to invest before making critical investment decisions. They want to get detailed information about market size, growth rates and changing consumer preferences and so on. But they are also important for resource seekers because they want to access on information on size, quality and exploitability of resources that they are interested in. The greater is access to information, the lesser are the risk to investors.
  • 33. - 27 - Potential investors in manufacturing sectors want detailed information about the supply and demand conditions, situation of local firms, law and regulation on labour, export and import procedures and so on. In fact all potential investors in any sector and with any motive require more or less information. Therefore, the lack of data and unreliable data make them disappoint about the country to do business. From the point of view of host countries, that attempt to attract FDI, this mean that just showing incentives and changing policies is no guarantee to FDI. The role of investment promotion is to attempt to reduce information asymmetries faced by potential foreign investors in their investment decision process. Inadequate and unreliable statistics issued by the host country increased complexity to foreign investors to understand the real situation in the country. Issuing out of date data returns the same effect. Therefore, if a country can overcome these information asymmetries, collecting and establishing necessary data bases timely and effectively distribute them to foreign investors the chance to be chosen for FDI will be greatly enhanced. (b) Infrastructure Barriers Poor infrastructure barriers also hinder to invest for investor in the developing countries. In general, poor infrastructure can lead to increased costs and risks of doing business in that country. It can increase the costs incurred by foreign investors because they have to bear the cost of infrastructure development such as electricity, water supply and communication facilities. It can increase the risk for foreign investors because they face difficulties in acquiring inputs and distribution products through the market channels in a timely manner. Difficulties in communication and transportation are also major hurdles for smooth business operation. The extent to which certain barriers poses obstacles to attracting FDI is more severe in industries such as mining and manufacturing, given additional costs that foreign investors must assume. These deficiencies of infrastructure may outweigh the benefits of lower labor costs and abundant resources in LDCs. They can severely limit FDI inflows from resource seekers. For potential investor in hotel and tourism, manufacturing sectors, inadequate infrastructure may lead to increased costs for them. Unless these costs are compensated by additional benefits, investors don't want to invest in a particular country. However, these infrastructure weaknesses may create opportunities for some businesses specializing in infrastructure services such as electricity and road construction.
  • 34. - 28 - (c) Institutional Barriers Most developing, especially LDCs, are faced with constraints involving human, social and institutional capital. In terms of human capital, they have higher proportion of unskilled labor and shortage of qualified and experienced managers and technicians in these countries. The availability of human capital is a major driver of FDI. A host country that has larger supplies of higher level man power able to absorb new skills is likely to attract more and better quality FDI than countries without such endowment. Therefore, a country that wants to attract FDI must considerate the above factors. 4.3 Human Resource Barriers Social capital represents the intangible assets that as a whole in all countries have. It takes the form of various types of traditions and taboos, informal organizations, and trust. Social capital comprises the invisible glue that binds societies and cultures together. The dimensions of social capital that are particular concern to foreign investors are constitutions and form of political organization, adherence to the rule-of-law, means of dispute resolution whether formally or informally, crime rate and major crimes happened in the country, level and pervasive of corruption, intrinsic ability to evolve by embracing and adapting to technological and globally induced cultural change in a manner that is positive and constructive. Foreign investors are most concerned about the efficiency of public institutions and their impact on the quality and responsiveness of governance. Generally speaking, these weaknesses, including administrative barriers are disincentives to foreign investors. In term of human capital, they have higher proportion of unskilled labor and shortage of qualified and experienced managers and technicians in country. The availability of human capital is a major driver in FDI. A host country that has larger supplies of higher-level man power able to absorb new skills is likely to attract more and better quality FDI than countries without such endowment.
  • 35. - 29 - 4.4 Investment Opportunities in Resource Sectors (a) Agriculture The agriculture sector contributed more than 50 percent of Myanmar GDP and about 60 percent of the total employment in 2005. The country has significant land and water resources, low cost labor, and eco-system varieties, and is strategically located given in proximity to markets in East Asia, Middle East, Southeast Asia and South Asia, which allow agro-industry to become a major foreign exchange earner for the country. Myanmar possesses a large proportion of land area in the Southeast Asian region and over 60 different varieties of crops such as rice, wheat, maize, beans and pulses, and oilseeds, as well as industrial crops such as cottons, jute, rubber, sugar cane, palm and tobacco can be cultivated. Its agriculture is almost in the hands of private farmers, and cultivation is carried out on small farms even if land ownership right is still in the hands of the state. Given the land availability in Myanmar and the dominance of the private sector in Myanmar's agricultural sector, prospects are high for strategic business cooperation with foreign investors who enjoy capital and technological advantages. The growing demand for agricultural products from industrial developed countries like Japan and the EU, as well as staple products for developing countries like India and Bangladesh holds a great profit potential for those who want to invest in agriculture. (b) Livestock and fisheries Myanmar's livestock sector consists mainly of cattle, pigs, and poultry. They are primarily bred in rural areas, though most of them are not for commercial consumption. Currently, a small volume of animal products are exported even as Myanmar's central plains are suitable for commercial breeding of hardy beef cattle. This means there is a high potential for animal breeding in the country. Even though Myanmar does not have a well-established livestock or diary sector, it can significantly increase it has diary production, provided there is available foreign capital and technology, which may be combined with Myanmar's land resources and favorable climate. The availability of pasture lands show potential for future cattle ranching with meat production and processing. Myanmar possesses 1930 km-long costal line, which provides great opportunities to trade in a wide variety of marine products for export. The western Rakhine coast is renowned for its shellfish, while the southern islands are rich in various kinds of marine
  • 36. - 30 - including fresh and frozen fish, preserved fish and shellfish. Export volume can still be vastly increased, given the growing demand for sea products from the world market. Fresh fish and shell fish can be exported to Japan, Singapore, Malaysia, and China while salted fish and preserved fish can be exported to India, Bangladesh and China. (c) Wood-based industries Myanmar has large forest areas from which large tons of timber and forest products like bamboo and rattan can be extracted. Myanmar is well known for its teak resources, and it furnishes approximately 90 percent of the world's commercial teak supply. Its forests provide more than 8,500 different plant species, including 2,300 types of trees and 850 types of orchid, and its covers more than half of the country. Instead of exporting these forest products in their raw forms, processed and value-added products should be developed with foreign technology and access to international market. In this area, foreign investment can provide not only the needed capital but also the technology and design that can improve the marketability of value-added wood products. Wood products such as furniture enjoy a strong demand from every foreign market. Likewise, wood-related products like plywood and veneer can be exported to China, India, Malaysia, Singapore, Japan and some western countries. (d) Mineral products Myanmar had considerable mineral resources, most of which are still unexploited. It shows another opportunity for foreign investor. Even though the state has the sole right to develop and extract pearls, jade, precious stones and metals, the law allows the provision of permits to the private sector and FDI if the pursuit of a project will meet the state's requirements. Such mining activities are commonly carried out through joint ventures, production sharing, or purchase contracts. Combined with foreign technology and capital, there is a potential to increase some mineral products for export such as silver, lead, tin, ores, coal and gemstones to Japan and other neighboring countries. Myanmar is well known for its ruby and jade in the world market and it has considerable indigenous supplies of gold, silver, pearl, and other precious stones and metals. Again, this sector is reserved for the state but some types of FDI may be considered for the interest of the state. Foreign investments can also be flowed in the form of gem cutting, processing, and relevant export services. There are major world markets for such products and they offer attractive opportunities for foreign investors. Regional
  • 37. - 31 - countries such as China, India, Indonesia, Malaysia, and Thailand have specific expertise in mineral prospecting, extraction, and processing. Companies from Singapore and Thailand are now doing feasible projects in Myanmar's tin industry. China also finds opportunities in Myanmar's mineral extraction and processing sectors. 4.5 Opportunities in Manufacturing This sector holds promise for growth, particularly, in the area of light industries. These include textiles, foodstuffs, pharmaceuticals, ceramics, paper and chemical. Currently over 60 percent of all manufacturing outputs in the country fallen under food and beverage. With FDI and private sector involvement, the manufacturing sector is expected to increase and diversify from basic domestic industries to more export-oriented and dynamic ones. (a) Garment industries Given the much lower wage rates in Myanmar than Thailand, Malaysia and even Cambodia and its abundant labor supply, the country has attracted foreign investors to invest in this labor-intensive industry. Indeed, investment in the manufacturing sector generates benefits to the country. With the agreement of the Ayeyawady-Chao Phraya- Mekong Economic Cooperation Strategy (ACMECS), new industrial zones are being set up for garment industries in Myawadi and Pa-an near Thailand's border, which can take advantage of cheap labor. Since, Myanmar had relatively intelligent, hardworking, not to mention cheap labor source, it has comparative advantage in relation to other countries in the garment sector. The major bottleneck in this sector is delay in export and complex import procedures, which affect the lead time for exporting garments and substantially reduce the country's competitive edge. By removing unnecessary delays in this process, the country's competitiveness in the garment industry will be greatly improved. (b) Electronics and IT industries Since Myanmar enjoys high literacy rate in the region and intelligent labor that can absorb advanced technology, electronic and IT industries are promising sectors for FDI inflow into Myanmar. If Myanmar could improve its infrastructure requirements, these sectors are likely to be major recipients of FDI. Japan and Korea are interested to invest these sectors, since Myanmar has a considerable large home-based market and can serve as an export base to highly populated neighboring countries like China and India.
  • 38. - 32 - Myanmar has already put up an IT park in Yangon and constructed IT city between Mandalay and Pyin Oo Lwin. Government, for its part, has been undertaking intensive infrastructure development programs in this area since 2006. This shows an opportunity for foreign investors that want to invest in Myanmar. The major setback in this sectors are shortage of electricity and communication networks which, however, are expected to be removed in the coming a few years, since government is intensely pursuing hydropower projects to fulfill electricity requirements and launching extensive communication networks in the country. Training programs to develop highly skilled technicians are also extended to build competency in this area. (c) Foodstuffs and pharmaceutical industries Since Myanmar has a large agricultural sector, which provides various crops that serve as inputs to foodstuffs industries. Moreover, over 60 percent of domestic private small industries in Myanmar are already concentrated in foodstuff industry. This is a very promising opportunity for foreign investors that want to invest in this sector for export, since most of the domestic industries only focus on the local market. The pharmaceutical industry is also another potential area to attract FDI, since the country is short supply for pharmaceutical products from domestic state-owned factories. Developing business linkages with local suppliers is an important requirement for investors who want to invest into these sectors.
  • 39. - 33 - Chapter (V) Conclusion 5.1 Findings To achieve a step change in FDI and get closer to meeting the economy’s large need for investment, as well as to continue to diversify the sectors to which FDI goes, Myanmar needs to prioritize two main areas: developing a targeted FDI strategy led by a high-performing agency and improving Myanmar’s business environment. One of the major themes that came up repeatedly was concern about the business environment in the country. In light of this, Myanmar needs to focus relentlessly on improving the environment in which businesses can operate in the country. This will be crucial to attracting larger volumes of FDI. Countries—or even individual cities—that have been successful in attracting large volumes of FDI have made the creation of a business friendly environment a priority. Their experience suggests four areas that Myanmar would need to get right to help it attract FDI: With the enactment of the 2012 Foreign Direct Investment Law, the reforms beign conducted in political, economic and social spheres, and the appropriate strategy to address issues discussed in this paper and the proper amendment of FIL in line with the changing conditions as the country becomes more matured in attracting FDI, it can be assumed that Myanmar could be on the right track, to be able to attract the kind and amount of FDI, it really deserves. Many investors and embassy trade representatives indicate that concerns about whether the rule of law is fully established and embedded into the business environment in Myanmar is a major source of uncertainty for prospective investors. Instilling confidence in the sanctity of contracts and ensuring that arbitration is available in the event of disagreements are both important considerations for investors contemplating deals with local partners and the government. The skilled labor usage problem could be alleviated by bringing up the capacity of local workers by improving the education system. Then it will be cost effective for the investors to use local skilled workers since the wage rate is comparatively low related to their foreign counterparts, who would have the same skill levels. As for the problem regarding MIC's discretionary power, if more comprehensive, predicable and transparent
  • 40. - 34 - rules and procedures regarding foreign investments could be crafted in the future, foreign investors' concerns as regards the issue could be reduced significantly. The environment of a country in the broadest sense - the quality of life - is often a factor in whether companies decide whether to locate there. A country that offers social benefits such as health care, public safety (low crime rates and an effective police force), schools, and a rich cultural life may be more likely to attract businesses and talented individuals. To sum up, Foreign Direct Investment in Myanmar is still pivotal to improve its economic development. However, there are some challenges that need to fill the gap to attract foreign investment such as effective performance agency and business environment. Myanmar needs to be proactive in its efforts to attract FDI, given its potential need for investment. Any effective FDI strategy needs to start with a clear understanding of the country’s current competitive strengths and how they might evolve.
  • 41. - 35 - 5.2 Suggestions Myanmar needs to be proactive in its efforts to attract FDI, given its potential need for investment. Any effective FDI strategy needs to start with a clear understanding of the country’s current competitive strengths and how they might evolve. Myanmar’s Directorate of Investment and Company Administration (DICA) serves as its investment promotion agency, but that function is not yet fully developed. To play this role successfully, DICA can look at the experience of its counterparts elsewhere. These agencies tend to have four factors in common that drive success. First, they create a culture that is customer-focused, responsive, and flexible, and are staffed with talented people who are able to make the case for the investments and to connect effectively with investors. Second, they have the powers to address the concerns of investors by being firmly embedded in the center of government. Third, they leverage prominent private- and public-sector representatives to champion the country’s offering to investors. Finally, they build connections between foreign investors and local firms. According to Data interpretation, the Foreign Direct Investment has significantly increased in the fiscal year of 2010-2011 since the new government took office in March 2011. Myanmar is ready to pursue economic growth under the name of “development”. Government should take place continuously implementation of foreign investment law and act the law effectively in order to come more foreign direct investment to country for national economic growth and development.
  • 42. - 36 - References 1. ADB (2012). "Myanmar in Transition: Opportunities and Challenges". August 2012. 2. Archibald, J. S. and others (2012). "Change and opportunity in Myanmar". Economic Sanctions Alert, 9 April 2012. Hogan Lovells, Washington, D.C, New York, London 3. ASEAN Secretariat, Statistics of Foreign Direct Investment in ASEAN, eighth edition, 2006, page 30-40. 4. Central Statistical Organization (April 2015), "Selected Monthly Economic Indicators", Ministry of National Planning and Economic Development, The Government of The Republic of The Union of Myanmar. 5. "Foreign Investment Law Myanmar", The Foreign Investment Law the Pyidaungsu Hluttaw Law No 21/2012, the 3rd waning of Thadingyut, 1374 ME, 2nd November, 2012. 6. IMF (2012). Myanmar 2011 Article IV Consultation, IMF Country Report No. 12/104. Washington, D.C. 7. Jared Bissinger (2012), "Foreign Direct Investment in Myanmar: A Resource Boom but a Development Bust?", Contemporary Southeast Asia Vol. 34, No.1 (2012) pp.23-52 8. Khaing Sape Saw (Ms.) and Khin Maung Nyo (Mr.), March 15, 2014, "Promoting Investment Climate: How to attract FDI?", ppt presentation, Joint by KGU- MARCED, Kumamoto Gakuen University, JAPAN and Myanmar Research Center for Economic Development, Myanmar Engineering Society (MES), Hlaing Universities Campus. 9. Khin Cho Cho (August, 2007), "A Study on the Foreign Direct Investment and Economic Development (case study: Myanmar)", (Unpublished Master Thesis), Yangon Institute of Economics. 10. Khin Moe Myint (December 2012), "Foreign Direct Investment in Myanmar", Master Thesis, Master of Development Studies Programme, Yangon Institute of Economics. 11. "Myanmar: Opening Up To Its Trade And Foreign Direct Investment Potential ", 20 September 2012, revised 31 December 2012, Trade and Investment Division, Staff Working Paper 01/12, United Nations Economics and Social Commission for Asian and the Pacific (UN-ESCAP).
  • 43. - 37 - 12. Myat Thida Aye, 2011, "Study on Foreign Direct Investment And Opportunities in Myanmar", MPA Thesis, Master of Public Administration Programme, Yangon Institute of Economics. 13. Myo Khaing Aung (December, 2013), "A Study on Economic Environment for FDI in Myanmar", Master Thesis, Master of Public Administration Programme, Yangon Institute of Economics. 14. Pwint Phyu Aung (2013), "Impact of FDI on Home and Host Countries", Assignment, Ph.D Prelim (Ba-2), Meiktila University of Economics, Mandalay, Myanmar. 15. Thandar Khine, 2008, "Foreign Direct Investment Relations between Myanmar and ASEAN", IDE Discussion Paper No. 149, Institute of Developing Economics (IDE), JETRO. 16. Thet Aung Lynn and Mari Oye, June 2014 "Natural Resources and Subnational Governments in Myanmar", Subnational Governance in Myanmar Discussion Paper Series, Discussion paper No.4, International Growth Centre, MDRI-CESD and The Asia Foundation. 17. Thin Thin Kyi, Dr, (July 2015),"Foreign Direct Investment In Myanmar", International Conference on Burma/Myanmar Studies, University Academic Service Centre (UNISERV), Chiang Mai University, Thailand. 18. UNCTAD (1998) World Investment Report 1998 New York 19. Wah Wah Maung, 2002, "The Role of Foreign Direct Investment: Case Studies of Myanmar and Vietnam", PhD Thesis, Jawaharlal Nehru University. 20. World Economic Forum (2012). Enabling Trade Index 2012. Geneva, New York and Beijing. 21. Zaw Yadanar Hein (May, 2014), "Comparative Study of Foreign Direct Investment in Myanmar and Vietnam", Master Thesis, Department of Economics, Yangon Institute of Economics. 22. Banco de España and Maitena Duce (July 31, 2003), "Definitions of Foreign Direct Investment (FDI): a methodological note", http://www.oecd.org/ 23. "The effects on Myanmar's Foreign Investment Policies on FDI Inflow: An Analysis of Panel Data across ASEAN Member Countries". http://www.trincoll.edu/dept/econ