SlideShare a Scribd company logo
From last time: bureaucracy as the material consequence of our wants Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa
It is the “formative”  that makes the “normative” consequential Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa
A reminder of purpose ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa
The Hidden Life of Schools: Organizational Fact, Moral Value, and  Administrative Consequence Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8zVG8aBglVA http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XmJVTao4X-Y
Teaching and Schooling are  necessarily  moral enterprises ,[object Object],[object Object],Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa
Schooling as a moral claim ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa
Schooling as an Unavoidably Moral Act ,[object Object],Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa
But, “The best laid schemes o' mice an' men / Gang aft agley."  Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa Pressure on educators no excuse for cheating, Ontario Premier says  McGuinty reacts to reports that 10 public schools are under investigation for cheating and irregularities on standardized tests Karen Howlett  St. Thomas, Ont. — Globe and Mail Update Published on Tuesday, Sep. 21, 2010 3:43PM EDT Last updated on Tuesday, Sep. 21, 2010 6:19PM EDT
And so the moral life of schools remains an unresolved and volatile reality and a continuing concern for those who would administer. Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa
Understanding Canadian Schools  : (An Introduction to Educational Administration)  Administration as “Sense-Making” ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa
The Value of Questioning Assumptions ,[object Object],[object Object],Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa
Schooling: Power, Practices, and Structures ,[object Object],[object Object],Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa
And, of course... Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa Jenny Holzer Abuse of Power Comes as No Surprise , 1984
Understanding What Schools Are and Can Be ,[object Object],[object Object],Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa Koren,  New Yorker 22 March 1999
education  and  schooling  –  Two Very Different Words ,[object Object],[object Object],Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa
Learning Out of School ,[object Object],[object Object],Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa
Goals of Schooling ,[object Object],Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa -Benjamin Levin and Jon Young,  Understanding Canadian  Schools (Third Edition, 2002) , Reader p. 13
[object Object],Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa -Benjamin Levin and Jon Young,  Understanding Canadian Schools (Third Edition, 2002) , Reader p. 13 Rhethoric – vs. – Practice
Mark Holmes * : Six Functions of Canadian Schools ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa *M. Holmes (1986),  Curriculum Inquiry  15(1): 7-36
Mary Metz on the allocative purpose of schooling… ,[object Object],Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa
Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa “ Colleges would not have room for all, but would have little ground on which to accept some and reject others.  Employers looking for secretaries, retail salespersons, waiters, busdrivers, and factory workers would have jobs unfilled as every student considered such work beneath his or her accomplishment…”
[object Object],[object Object],Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],3 Questions to Consider Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa
Three Challenges to Those Who Would Administer ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa
Focault’s Epistemological Conundrum: A Challenge to Administrators ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa
Jean Anyon and School Difference: all schools are not equal ,[object Object],[object Object],Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa
Schools & the Reproduction of Inequity ,[object Object],[object Object],Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa
Lisa Delpit: Difference and Moral Action ,[object Object],[object Object],Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa
From “Racism without Racists: Institutional Racism in Urban Schools” ,[object Object],[object Object],Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa
Geoffrey Canada  The Harlem Children’s Zone Administration as Philosophy-in-Action ,[object Object],Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa
In Conclusion: Two Thoughts to Ponder one from Christopher Hodgkinson and one from  Willard Waller Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa
Christopher Hodgkinson ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa
[object Object],[object Object],Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa
Willard Waller ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa

More Related Content

What's hot

Moving beyond our vacuous education reform discussions
Moving beyond our vacuous education reform discussionsMoving beyond our vacuous education reform discussions
Moving beyond our vacuous education reform discussions
typicalruin872
 
2000 summer harney-dartmouth
2000 summer harney-dartmouth2000 summer harney-dartmouth
2000 summer harney-dartmouthJohn O. Harney
 
Agonquin College Keynote
Agonquin College KeynoteAgonquin College Keynote
Agonquin College Keynote
Terry Anderson
 
Tax exempt foundations_hearings-reece_committee-1953_4-1086pgs-part2-gov
Tax exempt foundations_hearings-reece_committee-1953_4-1086pgs-part2-govTax exempt foundations_hearings-reece_committee-1953_4-1086pgs-part2-gov
Tax exempt foundations_hearings-reece_committee-1953_4-1086pgs-part2-govRareBooksnRecords
 
Libr 559 M - Final Project - Cosco, Grace, McElroy
Libr 559 M - Final Project - Cosco, Grace, McElroyLibr 559 M - Final Project - Cosco, Grace, McElroy
Libr 559 M - Final Project - Cosco, Grace, McElroy
dgrace
 
Educational Resilience in the Digital University
Educational Resilience in the Digital UniversityEducational Resilience in the Digital University
Educational Resilience in the Digital University
Martin Oliver
 
Against Scaffolding: Radical Openness and Critical Digital Pedagogy
Against Scaffolding: Radical Openness and Critical Digital PedagogyAgainst Scaffolding: Radical Openness and Critical Digital Pedagogy
Against Scaffolding: Radical Openness and Critical Digital Pedagogy
Jesse Stommel
 
Lg15fall whaddaya knowb 27octf
Lg15fall whaddaya knowb 27octfLg15fall whaddaya knowb 27octf
Lg15fall whaddaya knowb 27octf
katherine watson
 
5 4-13 pcc commencement speech final
5 4-13 pcc commencement speech final5 4-13 pcc commencement speech final
5 4-13 pcc commencement speech finalAlanLadwig66
 
Vol 12 No 3 - July 2015
Vol 12 No 3 - July 2015Vol 12 No 3 - July 2015
Vol 12 No 3 - July 2015
ijlterorg
 
FuturEd Handout
FuturEd HandoutFuturEd Handout
FuturEd Handout
Chris Shade
 
Toward entrepreneurial universities for the 21st century - Stanford
Toward entrepreneurial universities for the 21st century - StanfordToward entrepreneurial universities for the 21st century - Stanford
Toward entrepreneurial universities for the 21st century - StanfordMarcos Eduardo Villa Corrales
 
The teaching profession at the cossroads
The teaching profession at the cossroadsThe teaching profession at the cossroads
The teaching profession at the cossroads
Universidad Complutense de Madrid
 

What's hot (14)

Moving beyond our vacuous education reform discussions
Moving beyond our vacuous education reform discussionsMoving beyond our vacuous education reform discussions
Moving beyond our vacuous education reform discussions
 
2000 summer harney-dartmouth
2000 summer harney-dartmouth2000 summer harney-dartmouth
2000 summer harney-dartmouth
 
Agonquin College Keynote
Agonquin College KeynoteAgonquin College Keynote
Agonquin College Keynote
 
mtbecklmuburcham
mtbecklmuburchammtbecklmuburcham
mtbecklmuburcham
 
Tax exempt foundations_hearings-reece_committee-1953_4-1086pgs-part2-gov
Tax exempt foundations_hearings-reece_committee-1953_4-1086pgs-part2-govTax exempt foundations_hearings-reece_committee-1953_4-1086pgs-part2-gov
Tax exempt foundations_hearings-reece_committee-1953_4-1086pgs-part2-gov
 
Libr 559 M - Final Project - Cosco, Grace, McElroy
Libr 559 M - Final Project - Cosco, Grace, McElroyLibr 559 M - Final Project - Cosco, Grace, McElroy
Libr 559 M - Final Project - Cosco, Grace, McElroy
 
Educational Resilience in the Digital University
Educational Resilience in the Digital UniversityEducational Resilience in the Digital University
Educational Resilience in the Digital University
 
Against Scaffolding: Radical Openness and Critical Digital Pedagogy
Against Scaffolding: Radical Openness and Critical Digital PedagogyAgainst Scaffolding: Radical Openness and Critical Digital Pedagogy
Against Scaffolding: Radical Openness and Critical Digital Pedagogy
 
Lg15fall whaddaya knowb 27octf
Lg15fall whaddaya knowb 27octfLg15fall whaddaya knowb 27octf
Lg15fall whaddaya knowb 27octf
 
5 4-13 pcc commencement speech final
5 4-13 pcc commencement speech final5 4-13 pcc commencement speech final
5 4-13 pcc commencement speech final
 
Vol 12 No 3 - July 2015
Vol 12 No 3 - July 2015Vol 12 No 3 - July 2015
Vol 12 No 3 - July 2015
 
FuturEd Handout
FuturEd HandoutFuturEd Handout
FuturEd Handout
 
Toward entrepreneurial universities for the 21st century - Stanford
Toward entrepreneurial universities for the 21st century - StanfordToward entrepreneurial universities for the 21st century - Stanford
Toward entrepreneurial universities for the 21st century - Stanford
 
The teaching profession at the cossroads
The teaching profession at the cossroadsThe teaching profession at the cossroads
The teaching profession at the cossroads
 

Viewers also liked

Ciao professore preview
Ciao professore previewCiao professore preview
Ciao professore previewbarlosky
 
Rorty and final vocabularies
Rorty and final vocabulariesRorty and final vocabularies
Rorty and final vocabulariesbarlosky
 
Koncertewangewangelizacyjny
KoncertewangewangelizacyjnyKoncertewangewangelizacyjny
Koncertewangewangelizacyjny
Bartosz Orliński
 
Task 11 group one - photo sharing
Task 11   group one - photo sharingTask 11   group one - photo sharing
Task 11 group one - photo sharingGROUP ONE
 
Paula case study
Paula case studyPaula case study
Paula case studybarlosky
 
Assignment 2 tough assignment
Assignment 2 tough assignmentAssignment 2 tough assignment
Assignment 2 tough assignmentbarlosky
 
Schools as moral organizations
Schools as moral organizationsSchools as moral organizations
Schools as moral organizationsbarlosky
 
天下雜誌日本館《青春的54個習慣》
天下雜誌日本館《青春的54個習慣》天下雜誌日本館《青春的54個習慣》
天下雜誌日本館《青春的54個習慣》eugenialin
 
UsabilityMatters! -VritiBhargava
UsabilityMatters! -VritiBhargavaUsabilityMatters! -VritiBhargava
UsabilityMatters! -VritiBhargava
Vriti Bhargava
 
Talk as the work
Talk as the workTalk as the work
Talk as the workbarlosky
 
Karl weick's loosely coupled systems
Karl weick's  loosely coupled systemsKarl weick's  loosely coupled systems
Karl weick's loosely coupled systemsbarlosky
 
Edu 6424 #7 richard rorty on
Edu 6424 #7 richard rorty onEdu 6424 #7 richard rorty on
Edu 6424 #7 richard rorty onbarlosky
 
Edu 5263 bureaucracy
Edu 5263 bureaucracyEdu 5263 bureaucracy
Edu 5263 bureaucracybarlosky
 
The problem with ethnocentrism
The problem with ethnocentrismThe problem with ethnocentrism
The problem with ethnocentrismbarlosky
 

Viewers also liked (18)

Ciao professore preview
Ciao professore previewCiao professore preview
Ciao professore preview
 
Planning
PlanningPlanning
Planning
 
Rorty and final vocabularies
Rorty and final vocabulariesRorty and final vocabularies
Rorty and final vocabularies
 
Koncertewangewangelizacyjny
KoncertewangewangelizacyjnyKoncertewangewangelizacyjny
Koncertewangewangelizacyjny
 
Task 11 group one - photo sharing
Task 11   group one - photo sharingTask 11   group one - photo sharing
Task 11 group one - photo sharing
 
Paula case study
Paula case studyPaula case study
Paula case study
 
PROMAINS
PROMAINSPROMAINS
PROMAINS
 
Assignment 2 tough assignment
Assignment 2 tough assignmentAssignment 2 tough assignment
Assignment 2 tough assignment
 
Schools as moral organizations
Schools as moral organizationsSchools as moral organizations
Schools as moral organizations
 
Australian Jobs
Australian JobsAustralian Jobs
Australian Jobs
 
天下雜誌日本館《青春的54個習慣》
天下雜誌日本館《青春的54個習慣》天下雜誌日本館《青春的54個習慣》
天下雜誌日本館《青春的54個習慣》
 
UsabilityMatters! -VritiBhargava
UsabilityMatters! -VritiBhargavaUsabilityMatters! -VritiBhargava
UsabilityMatters! -VritiBhargava
 
Talk as the work
Talk as the workTalk as the work
Talk as the work
 
Karl weick's loosely coupled systems
Karl weick's  loosely coupled systemsKarl weick's  loosely coupled systems
Karl weick's loosely coupled systems
 
Edu 6424 #7 richard rorty on
Edu 6424 #7 richard rorty onEdu 6424 #7 richard rorty on
Edu 6424 #7 richard rorty on
 
Edu 5263 bureaucracy
Edu 5263 bureaucracyEdu 5263 bureaucracy
Edu 5263 bureaucracy
 
The problem with ethnocentrism
The problem with ethnocentrismThe problem with ethnocentrism
The problem with ethnocentrism
 
5 S Work Place
5 S Work Place5 S Work Place
5 S Work Place
 

Similar to The hidden life of schools (young and levin)

Significant Differences
Significant DifferencesSignificant Differences
Brenda Leibowitz presentation at UNISA on higher education and social justice
Brenda Leibowitz presentation at UNISA on higher education and social justiceBrenda Leibowitz presentation at UNISA on higher education and social justice
Brenda Leibowitz presentation at UNISA on higher education and social justice
Brenda Leibowitz
 
Mini conference 2014 final
Mini conference 2014 finalMini conference 2014 final
Mini conference 2014 final
Brendan Larvor
 
Desperately Seeking Sociology
Desperately Seeking SociologyDesperately Seeking Sociology
Desperately Seeking Sociology
Tanya Williams
 
Allison & marielle group presentation learners and learning 2016
Allison & marielle   group presentation learners and learning 2016Allison & marielle   group presentation learners and learning 2016
Allison & marielle group presentation learners and learning 2016
sykeshea
 
Change for Motivation_Support for New Pedagogies of Teaching and Learning in ...
Change for Motivation_Support for New Pedagogies of Teaching and Learning in ...Change for Motivation_Support for New Pedagogies of Teaching and Learning in ...
Change for Motivation_Support for New Pedagogies of Teaching and Learning in ...Andrea Lagalisse
 
The powerofourvoicesbsla2010
The powerofourvoicesbsla2010The powerofourvoicesbsla2010
The powerofourvoicesbsla2010slakhansen
 
Vol 16 No 4 - April 2017
Vol 16 No 4 - April 2017Vol 16 No 4 - April 2017
Vol 16 No 4 - April 2017
ijlterorg
 
A portrait of the law school as realist kindergarten
A portrait of the law school as realist kindergartenA portrait of the law school as realist kindergarten
A portrait of the law school as realist kindergarten
York University - Osgoode Hall Law School
 
Issues in Urban Education
Issues in Urban EducationIssues in Urban Education
Issues in Urban EducationMarianne Jones
 
Teori sosiology1
Teori sosiology1Teori sosiology1
Teori sosiology1
HALIZAH RAMTHAN LIZA
 
The sociology of education
The sociology of educationThe sociology of education
The sociology of education
Hazel Joy Chong
 
What’S The Purpose Of Education
What’S The Purpose Of EducationWhat’S The Purpose Of Education
What’S The Purpose Of EducationRick McKinnon
 
Intelligence Brief - Interviews with Teachers
Intelligence Brief - Interviews with TeachersIntelligence Brief - Interviews with Teachers
Intelligence Brief - Interviews with Teachers
Christian Kolding
 
Hilsdon keynote ALDinHE 2018
Hilsdon keynote ALDinHE 2018Hilsdon keynote ALDinHE 2018
Hilsdon keynote ALDinHE 2018
jhilsdon
 
Advocacy Primer WCSLit
 Advocacy Primer WCSLit Advocacy Primer WCSLit
Advocacy Primer WCSLitSusan McBurney
 
69
6969
Building education through and for social justice: lessons from co-creating a...
Building education through and for social justice: lessons from co-creating a...Building education through and for social justice: lessons from co-creating a...
Building education through and for social justice: lessons from co-creating a...
decolonisingdmu
 
Issues in Urban Education 2
Issues in Urban Education 2Issues in Urban Education 2
Issues in Urban Education 2Marianne Jones
 

Similar to The hidden life of schools (young and levin) (20)

Significant Differences
Significant DifferencesSignificant Differences
Significant Differences
 
Brenda Leibowitz presentation at UNISA on higher education and social justice
Brenda Leibowitz presentation at UNISA on higher education and social justiceBrenda Leibowitz presentation at UNISA on higher education and social justice
Brenda Leibowitz presentation at UNISA on higher education and social justice
 
Mini conference 2014 final
Mini conference 2014 finalMini conference 2014 final
Mini conference 2014 final
 
Desperately Seeking Sociology
Desperately Seeking SociologyDesperately Seeking Sociology
Desperately Seeking Sociology
 
Allison & marielle group presentation learners and learning 2016
Allison & marielle   group presentation learners and learning 2016Allison & marielle   group presentation learners and learning 2016
Allison & marielle group presentation learners and learning 2016
 
Change for Motivation_Support for New Pedagogies of Teaching and Learning in ...
Change for Motivation_Support for New Pedagogies of Teaching and Learning in ...Change for Motivation_Support for New Pedagogies of Teaching and Learning in ...
Change for Motivation_Support for New Pedagogies of Teaching and Learning in ...
 
The powerofourvoicesbsla2010
The powerofourvoicesbsla2010The powerofourvoicesbsla2010
The powerofourvoicesbsla2010
 
Vol 16 No 4 - April 2017
Vol 16 No 4 - April 2017Vol 16 No 4 - April 2017
Vol 16 No 4 - April 2017
 
A portrait of the law school as realist kindergarten
A portrait of the law school as realist kindergartenA portrait of the law school as realist kindergarten
A portrait of the law school as realist kindergarten
 
Issues in Urban Education
Issues in Urban EducationIssues in Urban Education
Issues in Urban Education
 
Teori sosiology1
Teori sosiology1Teori sosiology1
Teori sosiology1
 
The sociology of education
The sociology of educationThe sociology of education
The sociology of education
 
What’S The Purpose Of Education
What’S The Purpose Of EducationWhat’S The Purpose Of Education
What’S The Purpose Of Education
 
**Advocacy Primer
**Advocacy Primer**Advocacy Primer
**Advocacy Primer
 
Intelligence Brief - Interviews with Teachers
Intelligence Brief - Interviews with TeachersIntelligence Brief - Interviews with Teachers
Intelligence Brief - Interviews with Teachers
 
Hilsdon keynote ALDinHE 2018
Hilsdon keynote ALDinHE 2018Hilsdon keynote ALDinHE 2018
Hilsdon keynote ALDinHE 2018
 
Advocacy Primer WCSLit
 Advocacy Primer WCSLit Advocacy Primer WCSLit
Advocacy Primer WCSLit
 
69
6969
69
 
Building education through and for social justice: lessons from co-creating a...
Building education through and for social justice: lessons from co-creating a...Building education through and for social justice: lessons from co-creating a...
Building education through and for social justice: lessons from co-creating a...
 
Issues in Urban Education 2
Issues in Urban Education 2Issues in Urban Education 2
Issues in Urban Education 2
 

The hidden life of schools (young and levin)

  • 1. From last time: bureaucracy as the material consequence of our wants Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa
  • 2. It is the “formative” that makes the “normative” consequential Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa
  • 3.
  • 4. The Hidden Life of Schools: Organizational Fact, Moral Value, and Administrative Consequence Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8zVG8aBglVA http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XmJVTao4X-Y
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8. But, “The best laid schemes o' mice an' men / Gang aft agley." Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa Pressure on educators no excuse for cheating, Ontario Premier says McGuinty reacts to reports that 10 public schools are under investigation for cheating and irregularities on standardized tests Karen Howlett St. Thomas, Ont. — Globe and Mail Update Published on Tuesday, Sep. 21, 2010 3:43PM EDT Last updated on Tuesday, Sep. 21, 2010 6:19PM EDT
  • 9. And so the moral life of schools remains an unresolved and volatile reality and a continuing concern for those who would administer. Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13. And, of course... Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa Jenny Holzer Abuse of Power Comes as No Surprise , 1984
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17.
  • 18.
  • 19.
  • 20.
  • 21. Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa “ Colleges would not have room for all, but would have little ground on which to accept some and reject others. Employers looking for secretaries, retail salespersons, waiters, busdrivers, and factory workers would have jobs unfilled as every student considered such work beneath his or her accomplishment…”
  • 22.
  • 23.
  • 24.
  • 25.
  • 26.
  • 27.
  • 28.
  • 29.
  • 30.
  • 31. In Conclusion: Two Thoughts to Ponder one from Christopher Hodgkinson and one from Willard Waller Prespared by Dr. Martin Barlosky, Faculty of Education, University of Ottawa
  • 32.
  • 33.
  • 34.