A CASE
TATA NANO
“An amazing invention that didn't turn out to be a innovation”
A BRIEF
HISTORY
Mission and Vision Statements
Inspiration and Vision
CHALLENGES FACED
OPPOSITION FROM FARMERS
▸ TATA group initiated the construction of the Singur plant on 21 January
2007.
▸ The project faced massive opposition from displaced farmers.
▸ The protests were supported by West Bengal’s opposition party.
▸ After an year and half of negotiations, TATA group finally announced on
3rd October 2008, that they were pulling out of Singur due to “political
unrest and agitation”.
▸ TATA said that the financial loss due to relocation ranges somewhere
between Rs. 400cr and Rs. 1,400cr.
CHALLENGES FACED
“CHEAP” TAG: ISSUES IN POSITIONING
▸ Instead on focussing on being good, TATA group marketed the car as
being the 'cheapest'.
▸ This may have worked in other countries but backfired massively in India
due to the intense perception of class position.
▸ It turned out that the lower class preferred to buy second hand higher-end
cars than to buy a Nano, which would mark them as poor.
▸ Due to the low price there were concerns that the cars would be of a
cheaper quality.
CHALLENGES FACED
QUALITY CONCERNS
▸ Due to the low price there were concerns that the cars would be of a
cheaper quality.
▸ There were several fire incidents related to Nano, though the company
denied that they were connected to car’s design or parts.
▸ In 2014, a Nano was crashed by ADAC in Germany. Despite Tata’s claim
that it was expecting 4 stars, Nano actually got zero stars for adult
protection and didn't even meet basic UN safety requirements.
CHALLENGES FACED
ISOLATION OF TARGET MARKET AND
OTHER ISSUES
▸Cars are sold through dealers, and Tata’s dealer network was almost
entirely urban, and they didn't have a way to reach out to small towns and
villages.
▸The target market knew how to buy a scooter but didn't know how to buy a
car.
▸Many people were simply intimidated to go to a car dealership.
▸Between 2003, when the development started and mid-2008 when the
production began the prices of raw materials went up by 13-23%.
Source: http://deniseleeyohn.com/bites/what-went-wrong-with-tata-motors-nano/
MARKETING RESPONSE
▸The TATA Nano had drawn over 2.03 lakh fully paid bookings
amounting to nearly Rs. 2,500cr.
▸Company officials say 70-80% of initial customers already had a car,
some even had two.
▸The target customers felt shy to walk into the showrooms.
▸The Maruti Alto sold 3.93 lakh units, while over 71,000 Nanos have
been sold since the latter was launched in July 2009.
▸The nano was to sell on ‘demand pull’, but now its plagued with poor
image and quality issues.
▸Dream of becoming number 1 entry -level hatchback shattered.
Source: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/12/10/business/global/10tata.html?_r=3&src=me&ref=business&amp
http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/news-by- industry/auto/automobiles/How-Tata- Nano-hit- a-
big-bump- in-India/articleshow/7032762.cms
Source:https://www.motorbeam.com/2015/10/cars/hatchback-car-sales-in-india-for-september-2015-maruti-dominates/
Source: http://www.business-standard.com/article/management/nano-sticks-to-the-slow-lane-116011300323_1.html
http://www.hindustantimes.com/autos/end-of-the-road-for-india-s-beloved-maruti-800-company-stops-production/story-2EwlOvTta125XZ1BhNBidK.html
www.newindianexpress.com
RECENT IMPROVEMENTS ON NANO
▸‘Place’: From grandiose showrooms to low key access points, distribution
was restructured, giving more access to the targeted customer segments.
▸‘Price’: Negotiations with NBFCs, public sector banks, local cooperative
banks were made to ensure attractive interest rates and financing options
for Nano customers.
▸‘Product’ : To enhance the safety features, a retro-fitting exercise was
undertaken, which included addition of fuse and non-inflammable cover to
all cars sold plus manufactured.
▸‘Promotion’: The initial setback caused due to cheap car image was
worked upon and car was rebranded as the most famous hatchback, fuel
efficient, good performance and pleasant interior.
Source - http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2010-12-03/news/27627574_1_nano-production-tata-nano-sanand
Since there were problems regarding the positioning of Nano, major changes
were undertaken in terms of the company to revive the product.
Changes explained based on the 4 P’s of marketing:
Tata nano 2

Tata nano 2

  • 1.
    A CASE TATA NANO “Anamazing invention that didn't turn out to be a innovation”
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5.
    CHALLENGES FACED OPPOSITION FROMFARMERS ▸ TATA group initiated the construction of the Singur plant on 21 January 2007. ▸ The project faced massive opposition from displaced farmers. ▸ The protests were supported by West Bengal’s opposition party. ▸ After an year and half of negotiations, TATA group finally announced on 3rd October 2008, that they were pulling out of Singur due to “political unrest and agitation”. ▸ TATA said that the financial loss due to relocation ranges somewhere between Rs. 400cr and Rs. 1,400cr.
  • 6.
    CHALLENGES FACED “CHEAP” TAG:ISSUES IN POSITIONING ▸ Instead on focussing on being good, TATA group marketed the car as being the 'cheapest'. ▸ This may have worked in other countries but backfired massively in India due to the intense perception of class position. ▸ It turned out that the lower class preferred to buy second hand higher-end cars than to buy a Nano, which would mark them as poor. ▸ Due to the low price there were concerns that the cars would be of a cheaper quality.
  • 7.
    CHALLENGES FACED QUALITY CONCERNS ▸Due to the low price there were concerns that the cars would be of a cheaper quality. ▸ There were several fire incidents related to Nano, though the company denied that they were connected to car’s design or parts. ▸ In 2014, a Nano was crashed by ADAC in Germany. Despite Tata’s claim that it was expecting 4 stars, Nano actually got zero stars for adult protection and didn't even meet basic UN safety requirements.
  • 8.
    CHALLENGES FACED ISOLATION OFTARGET MARKET AND OTHER ISSUES ▸Cars are sold through dealers, and Tata’s dealer network was almost entirely urban, and they didn't have a way to reach out to small towns and villages. ▸The target market knew how to buy a scooter but didn't know how to buy a car. ▸Many people were simply intimidated to go to a car dealership. ▸Between 2003, when the development started and mid-2008 when the production began the prices of raw materials went up by 13-23%. Source: http://deniseleeyohn.com/bites/what-went-wrong-with-tata-motors-nano/
  • 9.
    MARKETING RESPONSE ▸The TATANano had drawn over 2.03 lakh fully paid bookings amounting to nearly Rs. 2,500cr. ▸Company officials say 70-80% of initial customers already had a car, some even had two. ▸The target customers felt shy to walk into the showrooms. ▸The Maruti Alto sold 3.93 lakh units, while over 71,000 Nanos have been sold since the latter was launched in July 2009. ▸The nano was to sell on ‘demand pull’, but now its plagued with poor image and quality issues. ▸Dream of becoming number 1 entry -level hatchback shattered. Source: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/12/10/business/global/10tata.html?_r=3&src=me&ref=business&amp http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/news-by- industry/auto/automobiles/How-Tata- Nano-hit- a- big-bump- in-India/articleshow/7032762.cms
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
    RECENT IMPROVEMENTS ONNANO ▸‘Place’: From grandiose showrooms to low key access points, distribution was restructured, giving more access to the targeted customer segments. ▸‘Price’: Negotiations with NBFCs, public sector banks, local cooperative banks were made to ensure attractive interest rates and financing options for Nano customers. ▸‘Product’ : To enhance the safety features, a retro-fitting exercise was undertaken, which included addition of fuse and non-inflammable cover to all cars sold plus manufactured. ▸‘Promotion’: The initial setback caused due to cheap car image was worked upon and car was rebranded as the most famous hatchback, fuel efficient, good performance and pleasant interior. Source - http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2010-12-03/news/27627574_1_nano-production-tata-nano-sanand Since there were problems regarding the positioning of Nano, major changes were undertaken in terms of the company to revive the product. Changes explained based on the 4 P’s of marketing: