SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Paul Honke
Social Media and Anonymity
Analyzing Social Issues
12/7/15
It is safe to say that since the introduction of social networking, interaction and the ability
to stay connected with each other has reshaped the way we talk to people. Social media as well
as other social networking have allowed us to talk about anything to anyone. However, the form
of how you talk to people has sparked some controversy. For as many social media sites that
state your identity, there are as many that allow you to remain anonymous. It is through
anonymity that our behavior changes, sometimes for the good, mostly for the worse. Anonymity
through social media has allowed many people to bully and harass others with few repercussions.
This paper will note the positives and negatives of social media anonymity and point out why it
should be regulated on social media platforms.
Being anonymous in social networking and the web in general will change people’s
behaviors. Anonymity has been typically described as a state where others can’t identify you or
each other.1 A big advantage when using social media and other forms of online communication
is that you do not have to meet your friends face to face like in a phone conversation. Unlike a
phone conversation, social media can also take away the voice aspect. When nobody knows who
you are online, you can be anyone you wish.2 Much of this thinking revolves around the idea of
visual anonymity. Visual anonymity is when you are unidentifiable in appearance from other
members in social media or in a chat room.3 Due to the lack of face to face contact, certain social
cues are missed, potentially leading to different kinds of behavior.4 The presence of visual
anonymity is a crucial factor in how people’s behaviors change online. A big factor is that not
1 Kimberly Christopherson,“ThePositive andNegative Implications ofAnonymity in Internet Social Interactions: On the Internet, Nobody
Knows You’re a Dog,” Computers In Human Behavior 23(2007): 3040, accessedNov. 11, 2015,doi:10.1016/j.chb.2006.09.001.
2
Rebecca Chui, "A Multi-facetedApproachtoAnonymityOnline: ExaminingtheRelations betweenAnonymity andAntisocial
Behavior."Journal of Virtual Worlds Research 7 (2014): 3, accessed, Nov. 11, 2015,
https://journals.tdl.org/jvwr/index.php/jvwr/article/view/7073/6342
3
Ibid.
4
Ibid.
being visually identifiable on social media can lead to unruly behavior.5 Without anyone to
identify them or tell them otherwise, people can go on anonymous social media sites and say
anything they want. Usually, reactions to certain comments will lead to a higher level of
aggression, as it is a natural reaction toward certain social situations.6
Despite all the talk about how anonymity can change behaviors, there are plenty of
positives that come from being anonymous on social media or online. One of the biggest benefits
of anonymity is the ability to talk about difficult subjects.7 In a survey hosted by Ask.fm, 40
percent of teenagers use social networks and various forms of anonymity to talk about subjects
that they would not normally tell others.8 In fact, the same survey noted that teenagers in general
rarely have regrets about their postings.9 The fact that social media can be used to talk about
difficult subjects has been noted in many cases. An example of this can be from Whispers own
developer, Michael Heyword. He talks about a story where talking to a girl in a self-harm post
saved his life because of her advice.10 There are other ways that being anonymous can help
people online or on social media.
The aspect of privacy is a huge reason that many people advocate for being anonymous
in social media. According to Kimberly Christopherson, an current associate professor in
psychology at Morningside College, said in her essay, The Positive and Negative Implications of
5
Ibid.
6
Chui, "A Multi-facetedApproach, 4.
7
Kerry Flynn, “Teens EmbraceAnonymous Social Networks ToDiscuss AwkwardTopics, BuildConfidence: Study.” International Business
Times, Aug. 27, 2015, accessedNov.11,2015, http://www.ibtimes.com/teens-embrace-anonymous-social-networks-discuss-awkward-topics-
build-confidence-study-2070998.
8
Ibid.
9
Ibid.
10
P.H. “Anonymous Social Networking: Secrets andLies,” The Economist Blog, March 22, 14, AccessedNov.11,2015,
http://www.economist.com/blogs/schumpeter/2014/03/anonymous-social-networking.
Anonymity in Internet Social Interactions: On the Internet, Nobody Knows You’re a Dog,
“privacy refers to the ability to control the amount of contact one has with others.11” For many
people, privacy is an important aspect of their lives.12 Not everyone can be in constant
interaction with each other and everyone needs time to be alone. In terms of anonymity in social
media interactions, privacy can be related to three concepts; recovery, catharsis, and autonomy.13
Christopherson notes that recovery is the most important concept.14 Recovery is
described as the feeling of recuperation after contemplating about a situation and feeling reborn
afterwards.15 While recovery is important, catharsis is another important factor. Catharsis is
described as the uncontained release of personal thoughts to others.16 Through the use of
anonymity, people can go to online forums or anonymous social media to release pent up
feelings about a specific subject. With catharsis, the individual can find refuge in exploring their
feelings without being identified and with recovery, is able to relax and find a new lease on their
life.
The third concept related privacy on anonymous social media is autonomy. Autonomy is
described as the ability to try something different and new without fear of prejudice.17 Many
people have hobbies that they don’t want others to know. When a person’s interest becomes
public, it could run the risk of being deemed “embarrassing” and could be the source of ridicule
depending on the hobby. For many people, being anonymous on various social media outlets
11
Christopherson, “The Positive andNegative Implications ofAnonymity,” 3040.
12
Ibid.
13
Ibid., 3041.
14
Ibid., 3041.
15
Ibid., 3041.
16
Ibid., 3041.
17
Ibid., 3041.
helps them explore their own personal identity.18 In an interview, students in the ages of 13-19
mention that the internet and social media have allowed them to pick and choose to whom they
want to talk to as they become more expressive.19 Recently, many people use social media and
online communities to explore various issues based on their own sexuality.20
There is also the fact anonymity in various group projects may have beneficial results.
People who are identifiable can be the subject of stereotypes.21 Through anonymity in social
media and online communities, the issue of stereotype is taken away and people from all classes
can work on a playing field deemed equalization hypothesis.22 The idea that anonymity takes
away the individual in groups has often been challenged by the SIDE theory. SIDE theory
predicts that group interaction is based on level of salience in a group and the number of people
anonymous in social and online networks.23 Salience is when someone connects less to the group
than to themselves.24 If all members are identifiable save for one or two members who are
anonymous, then the ones in anonymity will hold more social identity to themselves and can
become unruly.25 In contrast, if all members are anonymous, and have a high level of salience
then the focus on the group takes prominence over individuals.26
18
Ibid., 3042.
19
Ibid., 3042.
20
Ibid., 3042.
21
Ibid., 3045.
22
Ibid., 3045-3046.
23
Ibid., 3048.
24
Ibid., 3048.
25
Ibid., 3048.
26
Ibid., 3048.
Despite all the benefits anonymity gives to someone on social media or other social
communities, there is no denying that anonymity can lead to many problems in bullying and anti-
social behavior. Despite the traditional form of bullying being more common, when a person
aggression against someone online increases the chances of his/her bullying another face to
face.27 Cyberbullying is a huge problem when it comes to anonymous social media.
Cyberbullying as explained by Fabio Sticca, a postdoctoral and Perren Sonja, a professor from
the University of Konstanz, in their article Is Cyberbullying Worse Than Traditional Bullying?
Examining the Differential Roles of Medium, Publiciy, and Anonymity for the Perceived Severity
of Bullying, is defined “as an aggressive behavior that is repeatedly and intentionally carried out
against a defenseless victim using electronic forms of contact.28” Many social network apps such
as Yik-Yak have had their share of cyberbullying stories. In one story, a teacher was conducting
a course on post-apocalyptic culture while the students spent their time on Yik-Yak talking about
her.29 When the teacher found out that they had been ridiculing her, she tried to file for
harassment.30 It is worth mention that not all cyberbullying is anonymous. Some digital formats
include the IP address or other personal information about the content provider.31 However, the
fact that someone is not truly anonymous does not matter to the cyberbully.32 Without someone’s
entire information revealed to the world alongside no face to face confrontation the bully feels as
27
ChristopherBarlett,“AnonymouslyHurtingOthers Online: TheEffect of Anonymity onCyberbullyingFrequency,” Psychologyof Popular
Media Culture 4 (2015): 71, accessedNov.11,2015, http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/a0034335.
28
Fabio Sticca, andSonja Perren, “Is CyberbullyingWorse ThanTraditional Bullying? Examiningthe Differential Roles of Medium, Publicity,
andAnonymity for the PerceivedSeverityof Bullying.”Journal of Youth& Adolescence 42(2013): 740, accessedNov.11,2015, doi:
10.1007/s10964-012-9867-3
29
Katherine Schulten,“Are Anonymous Social Media Networks Dangerous?,“ TheNew York Times Blog, March11, 2015, accessedNov. 11,
2015, http://learning.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/03/11/are-anonymous-social-media-networks-dangerous/?_r=0.
30
Ibid.
31
Barlett,“Anonymously HurtingOthers Online,”71.
32
Ibid.
though he/she is anonymous. This will make bullies act like they are unknown to the world and
continue to harass the victim.33 In a recent study, the largest amount of cyberbullying actually
comes from instant messaging.34
Due to the anonymous nature of certain social networks and online communities,
cyberbullying has numerous effects on its victims. One of these effects is depression.35
Depression from cyberbullying on social media has shown to have long lasting repercussions. If
the depression is severe enough, it can unfortunately lead to suicide.36 It’s good to point out that
social media sites that show your identify like Facebook has its own cyberbullying problems.
However, the difference between Facebook and anonymous social media is that the anonymous
one is harder to track and discover the culprit.37 Because sites such as Yik-Yak and Ask.fm allow
people to post derogatory statements without being asked who they are, the police have difficulty
finding the anonymous apps and users.38
Another huge problem with anonymous social media and cyberbullying is sexual
harassment. Objectifying women has been found in many forms of digital media such as video
games, movies, and TV shows.39 It has been shown in a study that the majority of defamatory
comments are aimed towards women who as a result, suffer a more sever levels of depression
33
Ibid.
34
Ibid.
35
Stephanie Pappas, “Cyberbullyingon Social Media LinkedtoTeenDepression,” Live Science June 22,2015, accessedonNov.26,2015,
http://www.livescience.com/51294-cyberbullying-social-media-teen-depression.html.
36
Ibid.
37
Paige Samson, “Anonymous social media apps encourages cyberbullying,” WSOCTV, June 6, 2014, accessedonNov. 26, 2015,
http://www.wsoctv.com/news/news/local/hidden-social-media-apps-encourage-cyber-bullying/ngF6y/.
38
Ibid.
39
Jesse Fox, et al. "PerpetuatingOnline Sexism Offline: Anonymity, Interactivity, andtheEffects of Sexist Hashtags on Social Media."
Computers in HumanBehavior 52(2015): 436,accessedon Nov. 11, 2015,doi:10.1016/j.chb.2015.06.024
and distress than their male counterparts.40 Sexist comments on social media and networks do
not have to be aimed directly at someone to be offensive. There is a concept called ambient
sexism, where the environment, being real or virtual, is filled with sexist comments and behavior
among both men and women.41 A good portion of this has to do with the “online disinhibition
effect,” which is the act of someone acting differently online than if the person interacted with
another face to face.42 While the SIDE theory does offer suggestions against the effect, certain
characteristics still apply such as invisibility, where the lack of face to face contact has the
illusion of being anonymous.43 In a study by Jesse Fox, an assistant professor and Carlos Cruz, a
student from the University of Ohio, and Ji Young Lee, a student from the University of
Pittsburg in their paper Perpetuating Online Sexism Offline: Anonymity, Interactivity, and the
Effects of Sexist Hashtags on Social Media, men and women participants were placed in visible
and anonymous groups and were asked to respond and interact with twitter posts with sexist
hashtags.44 Using online disinhibition as a framework, the researchers expected the men to react
to online material and show more sexist attitudes.45 The results showed the researchers to be very
accurate to their study. The results showed that the people including the men in the anonymous
group showed more sexist attitudes when interacting with them during the study.46 Perhaps the
most disturbing result that came from this was that the sexist attitudes had a tendency to carry
40
Ibid.
41
Ibid.
42
Fox, et al. "PerpetuatingOnline Sexism Offline,” 437.
43
Barlett,“Anonymously HurtingOthers Online,”71.
44
Fox, et al. "PerpetuatingOnline Sexism Offline,” 438.
45
Ibid.
46
Ibid., 440.
themselves over offline. After the test was completed, some participants were more sexist after
interacting with defamatory comments.47
As the problem with anonymity and cyberbullying grows, many social networks
responded in their own ways. As a Facebook user, the only way I know that people can be
anonymous are if they have a fake account. However that may be changing. A new Facebook
app, similar to Yik-Yak and Whisper has been designed to allow people to talk to each other
without using their real name.48 Unlike other anonymous social media apps, Facebook knows
what it is doing by implementing certain counter measures against offensive comments. Mark
Zuckerberg himself has noted that Facebook chatrooms will be monitored and that hate speeches
or other signs of cyberbullying will be removed.49 Facebook officials mention that anonymity is
a place where people can be free, but control is needed.50 This is in contrast to Yik-Yak, which is
still under threat from schools banning such anonymous apps due to the threat it gives to their
students.51
The war on anonymity is a controversial one. While I agree that anonymity has many
benefits, such as discussing subjects or exploring interests one normally would not do in public,
the negatives have ended up hurting many people and has given rise to more real world bullying
as well. Anonymity should be respected, but also be regulated. I for one think that sites such as
Whisper and Yik-Yak should follow Facebooks lead and monitor posts more securely.
47
Ibid.
48
Davey Alba “The Futureof Anonymityon theInternet Is Facebook Rooms,” Wired, Oct. 27, 14, accessedon Nov. 11, 2015,
http://www.wired.com/2014/10/facebook-rooms-future-anonymity-internet/.
49
Ibid.
50
Ibid.
51
“Yik Yak app: Whyschools are concerned.” CBC News, Jan. 21, 2014, accessed, Nov. 11, 2015, http://www.cbc.ca/news/technology/yik-yak-
app-why-schools-are-concerned-1.2920155.
Bibliography
Alba, Davey. “The Future of Anonymity on the Internet Is Facebook Rooms,” Wired, Oct. 27.
14. Accessed Nov. 11, 2015, http://www.wired.com/2014/10/facebook-rooms-future-
anonymity-internet/.
Barlett, Christopher P. “Anonymously Hurting Others Online: The Effect of Anonymity on
Cyberbullying Frequency,” Psychology of Popular Media Culture 4, no. 2 (2015): 70-79.
Accessed Nov. 11, 2015, http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/a0034335.
Christopherson, Kimberly M. “The Positive and Negative Implications of Anonymity in Internet
Social Interactions: On the Internet, Nobody Knows You’re a Dog,” Computers In
Human Behavior 23, no. 6 (2007): 3038-3056. Accessed Nov. 11, 2015,
doi:10.1016/j.chb.2006.09.001.
Chui, Rebecca. "A Multi-faceted Approach to Anonymity Online: Examining the Relations
between Anonymity and Antisocial Behavior." Journal of Virtual Worlds Research 7, no.
2 (2014): 1-13. Accessed Nov. 11, 2015, http://www.ibtimes.com/teens-embrace-
anonymous-social-networks-discuss-awkward-topics-build-confidence-study-2070998.
Flynn, Kerry. “Teens Embrace Anonymous Social Networks To Discuss Awkward Topics, Build
Confidence: Study.” International Business Times, Aug. 27, 2015. Accessed on Nov. 11,
15, http://www.ibtimes.com/teens-embrace-anonymous-social-networks-discuss-
awkward-topics-build-confidence-study-2070998.
Fox, Jesse, Cruz, Carlos, and Ji Young Lee. "Perpetuating Online Sexism Offline: Anonymity,
Interactivity, and the Effects of Sexist Hashtags on Social Media," Computers In Human
Behavior 52, no. (2015): 436-442. Accessed Nov. 11, 2015. doi:
10.1016/j.chb.2015.06.024.
Samson, Paige. “Anonymous social media apps encourages cyberbullying,” WSOCTV, June 6,
2014. Accessed on Nov. 26, 2015, http://www.wsoctv.com/news/news/local/hidden-
social-media-apps-encourage-cyber-bullying/ngF6y/.
Schulten, Katherine. “Are Anonymous Social Media Networks Dangerous?, “ The New York
Times (Blog), March 11, 2015. Accessed on Nov. 11, 2015,
http://learning.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/03/11/are-anonymous-social-media-networks-
dangerous/?_r=0.
Pappas, Stephanie. “Cyberbullying on Social Media Linked to Teen Depression,” Live Science,
June 22, 2015. Accessed on Nov. 26, 2015, http://www.livescience.com/51294-
cyberbullying-social-media-teen-depression.html.
P.H. “Anonymous Social Networking: Secrets and Lies,” The Economist (Blog), March 22, 14.
Accessed on Nov. 11, 2015,
http://www.economist.com/blogs/schumpeter/2014/03/anonymous-social-networking.
Sticca, Fabio, and Sonja Perren. “Is Cyberbullying Worse Than Traditional Bullying? Examining
the Differential Roles of Medium, Publiciy, and Anonymity for the Perceived Severity of
Bullying.” Journal of Youth & Adolescence 42 (2013): 739-750. Accessed Nov. 12, 2015,
doi: 10.1007/s10964-012-9867-3.
“Yik Yak app: Why schools are concerned.” CBC News, Jan. 21, 2014. Accessed on Nov. 11,
2015, http://www.cbc.ca/news/technology/yik-yak-app-why-schools-are-concerned-
1.2920155.

More Related Content

What's hot

Grant-Shackleford; Using Social Media For Sobriety Recovery... PP; APA Conven...
Grant-Shackleford; Using Social Media For Sobriety Recovery... PP; APA Conven...Grant-Shackleford; Using Social Media For Sobriety Recovery... PP; APA Conven...
Grant-Shackleford; Using Social Media For Sobriety Recovery... PP; APA Conven...Dr. Don Grant, CCDC, PhD
 
Empathy and social media
Empathy and social mediaEmpathy and social media
Empathy and social media
EstefanDinarte
 
Polarization on social media
Polarization on social mediaPolarization on social media
Polarization on social media
Kiran Garimella
 
So-Sial Networking
So-Sial NetworkingSo-Sial Networking
So-Sial NetworkingAlanGun Alan
 
Polarization on Social Media
Polarization on Social MediaPolarization on Social Media
Polarization on Social Media
Cecilie Larsen
 
Fys research paper
Fys research paperFys research paper
Fys research paper
Stephanie_Warlitner
 
Love (and Sex) in the Age of Social Media
Love (and Sex) in the Age of Social MediaLove (and Sex) in the Age of Social Media
Love (and Sex) in the Age of Social Media
Havas PR
 
Social Network Sites: An Overview
Social Network Sites: An OverviewSocial Network Sites: An Overview
Social Network Sites: An Overview
Jessica Vitak
 
FMCS3100 'Caught in a Digital Romance'
FMCS3100 'Caught in a Digital Romance'FMCS3100 'Caught in a Digital Romance'
FMCS3100 'Caught in a Digital Romance'
c3095561
 
Knowledge Tree
Knowledge TreeKnowledge Tree
Knowledge Treemarkleland
 
Social media paper fys 100
Social media paper fys 100Social media paper fys 100
Social media paper fys 100
justwatts3
 
Seminar 2 social networks
Seminar 2 social networksSeminar 2 social networks
Seminar 2 social networks
Bryan Hunt
 
HIV Prevention and Social Media
HIV Prevention and Social MediaHIV Prevention and Social Media
HIV Prevention and Social MediaNathan Brown
 
Social media? It’s serious! Understanding the dark side of social media
Social media? It’s serious! Understanding the dark side of social mediaSocial media? It’s serious! Understanding the dark side of social media
Social media? It’s serious! Understanding the dark side of social media
Ian McCarthy
 
Flipbook assignment (moodle)
Flipbook assignment (moodle)Flipbook assignment (moodle)
Flipbook assignment (moodle)Benia Nowak
 
Social media Group 1 Chapter 2
Social media Group 1  Chapter 2Social media Group 1  Chapter 2
Social media Group 1 Chapter 2
Julian Arias
 
Social Media The Good, The Bad and The Ugly
Social Media The Good, The Bad and The UglySocial Media The Good, The Bad and The Ugly
Social Media The Good, The Bad and The Ugly
Elizabeth Icsam
 
Dissertation (Final)
Dissertation (Final)Dissertation (Final)
Dissertation (Final)Natalie Tan
 
Social media, group 1 chapter 2
Social media, group 1  chapter 2Social media, group 1  chapter 2
Social media, group 1 chapter 2
hollajan
 

What's hot (20)

Grant-Shackleford; Using Social Media For Sobriety Recovery... PP; APA Conven...
Grant-Shackleford; Using Social Media For Sobriety Recovery... PP; APA Conven...Grant-Shackleford; Using Social Media For Sobriety Recovery... PP; APA Conven...
Grant-Shackleford; Using Social Media For Sobriety Recovery... PP; APA Conven...
 
Empathy and social media
Empathy and social mediaEmpathy and social media
Empathy and social media
 
Polarization on social media
Polarization on social mediaPolarization on social media
Polarization on social media
 
So-Sial Networking
So-Sial NetworkingSo-Sial Networking
So-Sial Networking
 
Polarization on Social Media
Polarization on Social MediaPolarization on Social Media
Polarization on Social Media
 
Fys research paper
Fys research paperFys research paper
Fys research paper
 
Love (and Sex) in the Age of Social Media
Love (and Sex) in the Age of Social MediaLove (and Sex) in the Age of Social Media
Love (and Sex) in the Age of Social Media
 
Tugasan 2
Tugasan 2Tugasan 2
Tugasan 2
 
Social Network Sites: An Overview
Social Network Sites: An OverviewSocial Network Sites: An Overview
Social Network Sites: An Overview
 
FMCS3100 'Caught in a Digital Romance'
FMCS3100 'Caught in a Digital Romance'FMCS3100 'Caught in a Digital Romance'
FMCS3100 'Caught in a Digital Romance'
 
Knowledge Tree
Knowledge TreeKnowledge Tree
Knowledge Tree
 
Social media paper fys 100
Social media paper fys 100Social media paper fys 100
Social media paper fys 100
 
Seminar 2 social networks
Seminar 2 social networksSeminar 2 social networks
Seminar 2 social networks
 
HIV Prevention and Social Media
HIV Prevention and Social MediaHIV Prevention and Social Media
HIV Prevention and Social Media
 
Social media? It’s serious! Understanding the dark side of social media
Social media? It’s serious! Understanding the dark side of social mediaSocial media? It’s serious! Understanding the dark side of social media
Social media? It’s serious! Understanding the dark side of social media
 
Flipbook assignment (moodle)
Flipbook assignment (moodle)Flipbook assignment (moodle)
Flipbook assignment (moodle)
 
Social media Group 1 Chapter 2
Social media Group 1  Chapter 2Social media Group 1  Chapter 2
Social media Group 1 Chapter 2
 
Social Media The Good, The Bad and The Ugly
Social Media The Good, The Bad and The UglySocial Media The Good, The Bad and The Ugly
Social Media The Good, The Bad and The Ugly
 
Dissertation (Final)
Dissertation (Final)Dissertation (Final)
Dissertation (Final)
 
Social media, group 1 chapter 2
Social media, group 1  chapter 2Social media, group 1  chapter 2
Social media, group 1 chapter 2
 

Viewers also liked

R. Orlando Duenas resume long 16
R. Orlando Duenas resume long 16R. Orlando Duenas resume long 16
R. Orlando Duenas resume long 16R. Orlando Duenas
 
Informe montenegro
Informe montenegroInforme montenegro
Informe montenegro
Andrés Rivera Montenegro
 
Cropscan group1
Cropscan group1Cropscan group1
Transcripcion Montenegro
Transcripcion MontenegroTranscripcion Montenegro
Transcripcion Montenegro
Andrés Rivera Montenegro
 
3 Companies One Global Solutions Presentation [Autosaved]
3 Companies One Global Solutions Presentation [Autosaved]3 Companies One Global Solutions Presentation [Autosaved]
3 Companies One Global Solutions Presentation [Autosaved]Colorado Clear
 
Autism Spectrum Disorders Research Paper
Autism Spectrum Disorders Research PaperAutism Spectrum Disorders Research Paper
Autism Spectrum Disorders Research PaperPaul Honke
 
Etnometodología
EtnometodologíaEtnometodología
Etnometodología
Andrés Rivera Montenegro
 
Merc av mod iv 2015
Merc av mod iv 2015Merc av mod iv 2015
Merc av mod iv 2015
aulaadmin
 
Islamismo danielamanrique
Islamismo danielamanriqueIslamismo danielamanrique
Islamismo danielamanrique
DManriqueM
 
Jacqueline wilson (trabajo alba)
Jacqueline wilson (trabajo alba)Jacqueline wilson (trabajo alba)
Jacqueline wilson (trabajo alba)
Alba3011
 
Maraton de lectura
Maraton de lecturaMaraton de lectura
Maraton de lectura
Projuano
 
Apa incentives
Apa incentivesApa incentives
Apa incentives
Ben Bipes
 
Boletín Informativo No. 20 (IMMEX)
Boletín Informativo No. 20 (IMMEX)Boletín Informativo No. 20 (IMMEX)
Boletín Informativo No. 20 (IMMEX)
Despacho Selecen
 
presentation_on_e-commerce _desktop
presentation_on_e-commerce _desktoppresentation_on_e-commerce _desktop
presentation_on_e-commerce _desktopMathura Balasundaram
 
Ionic project guide
Ionic project guideIonic project guide
Ionic project guide
Jong Woo Rhee
 
Lo scompenso cardiaco con funzione sistolica conservata 2012
Lo scompenso cardiaco con funzione sistolica conservata 2012Lo scompenso cardiaco con funzione sistolica conservata 2012
Lo scompenso cardiaco con funzione sistolica conservata 2012University of Messina (Italy)
 
Probability
ProbabilityProbability
Probability
Thongminhhon Nguyen
 
Biográfico Narrativo
Biográfico NarrativoBiográfico Narrativo
Biográfico Narrativo
Andrés Rivera Montenegro
 
La Hermenéutica
La HermenéuticaLa Hermenéutica
La Hermenéutica
Andrés Rivera Montenegro
 

Viewers also liked (20)

R. Orlando Duenas resume long 16
R. Orlando Duenas resume long 16R. Orlando Duenas resume long 16
R. Orlando Duenas resume long 16
 
Informe montenegro
Informe montenegroInforme montenegro
Informe montenegro
 
Cropscan group1
Cropscan group1Cropscan group1
Cropscan group1
 
Transcripcion Montenegro
Transcripcion MontenegroTranscripcion Montenegro
Transcripcion Montenegro
 
3 Companies One Global Solutions Presentation [Autosaved]
3 Companies One Global Solutions Presentation [Autosaved]3 Companies One Global Solutions Presentation [Autosaved]
3 Companies One Global Solutions Presentation [Autosaved]
 
Autism Spectrum Disorders Research Paper
Autism Spectrum Disorders Research PaperAutism Spectrum Disorders Research Paper
Autism Spectrum Disorders Research Paper
 
Etnometodología
EtnometodologíaEtnometodología
Etnometodología
 
Pdhpe
PdhpePdhpe
Pdhpe
 
Merc av mod iv 2015
Merc av mod iv 2015Merc av mod iv 2015
Merc av mod iv 2015
 
Islamismo danielamanrique
Islamismo danielamanriqueIslamismo danielamanrique
Islamismo danielamanrique
 
Jacqueline wilson (trabajo alba)
Jacqueline wilson (trabajo alba)Jacqueline wilson (trabajo alba)
Jacqueline wilson (trabajo alba)
 
Maraton de lectura
Maraton de lecturaMaraton de lectura
Maraton de lectura
 
Apa incentives
Apa incentivesApa incentives
Apa incentives
 
Boletín Informativo No. 20 (IMMEX)
Boletín Informativo No. 20 (IMMEX)Boletín Informativo No. 20 (IMMEX)
Boletín Informativo No. 20 (IMMEX)
 
presentation_on_e-commerce _desktop
presentation_on_e-commerce _desktoppresentation_on_e-commerce _desktop
presentation_on_e-commerce _desktop
 
Ionic project guide
Ionic project guideIonic project guide
Ionic project guide
 
Lo scompenso cardiaco con funzione sistolica conservata 2012
Lo scompenso cardiaco con funzione sistolica conservata 2012Lo scompenso cardiaco con funzione sistolica conservata 2012
Lo scompenso cardiaco con funzione sistolica conservata 2012
 
Probability
ProbabilityProbability
Probability
 
Biográfico Narrativo
Biográfico NarrativoBiográfico Narrativo
Biográfico Narrativo
 
La Hermenéutica
La HermenéuticaLa Hermenéutica
La Hermenéutica
 

Similar to Social Media and Anonymity

Social media
Social mediaSocial media
Social media
nickmartin2000
 
Running head Social Media5Social Media.docx
Running head Social Media5Social Media.docxRunning head Social Media5Social Media.docx
Running head Social Media5Social Media.docx
agnesdcarey33086
 
Pitfalls of Social MediaSome disadvantages of social network.docx
Pitfalls of Social MediaSome disadvantages of social network.docxPitfalls of Social MediaSome disadvantages of social network.docx
Pitfalls of Social MediaSome disadvantages of social network.docx
randymartin91030
 
Fys paper
Fys paperFys paper
Fys paper
hannahherbert
 
Effects of social media on society
Effects of social media on societyEffects of social media on society
Effects of social media on society
IshtiakH0ssain
 
Fys
FysFys
Doyle grimes debate paper
Doyle grimes debate paperDoyle grimes debate paper
Doyle grimes debate paper
DoyleGrimes6
 
Social Networking
Social NetworkingSocial Networking
Social Networking
guest1b0960
 
Understanding Users' Privacy Motivations and Behaviors in Online Spaces
Understanding Users' Privacy Motivations and Behaviors in Online SpacesUnderstanding Users' Privacy Motivations and Behaviors in Online Spaces
Understanding Users' Privacy Motivations and Behaviors in Online Spaces
Jessica Vitak
 
#PremDac16: Can you see me? with @drbexl
#PremDac16: Can you see me? with @drbexl#PremDac16: Can you see me? with @drbexl
#PremDac16: Can you see me? with @drbexl
Bex Lewis
 
How socialmediaishurtingsociety
How socialmediaishurtingsocietyHow socialmediaishurtingsociety
How socialmediaishurtingsociety
mcghee27
 
Privacy Matters
Privacy MattersPrivacy Matters
Privacy Matters
James Kane
 
Final project
Final projectFinal project
Final project
kimcard
 

Similar to Social Media and Anonymity (15)

Sm
SmSm
Sm
 
Sm
SmSm
Sm
 
Social media
Social mediaSocial media
Social media
 
Running head Social Media5Social Media.docx
Running head Social Media5Social Media.docxRunning head Social Media5Social Media.docx
Running head Social Media5Social Media.docx
 
Pitfalls of Social MediaSome disadvantages of social network.docx
Pitfalls of Social MediaSome disadvantages of social network.docxPitfalls of Social MediaSome disadvantages of social network.docx
Pitfalls of Social MediaSome disadvantages of social network.docx
 
Fys paper
Fys paperFys paper
Fys paper
 
Effects of social media on society
Effects of social media on societyEffects of social media on society
Effects of social media on society
 
Fys
FysFys
Fys
 
Doyle grimes debate paper
Doyle grimes debate paperDoyle grimes debate paper
Doyle grimes debate paper
 
Social Networking
Social NetworkingSocial Networking
Social Networking
 
Understanding Users' Privacy Motivations and Behaviors in Online Spaces
Understanding Users' Privacy Motivations and Behaviors in Online SpacesUnderstanding Users' Privacy Motivations and Behaviors in Online Spaces
Understanding Users' Privacy Motivations and Behaviors in Online Spaces
 
#PremDac16: Can you see me? with @drbexl
#PremDac16: Can you see me? with @drbexl#PremDac16: Can you see me? with @drbexl
#PremDac16: Can you see me? with @drbexl
 
How socialmediaishurtingsociety
How socialmediaishurtingsocietyHow socialmediaishurtingsociety
How socialmediaishurtingsociety
 
Privacy Matters
Privacy MattersPrivacy Matters
Privacy Matters
 
Final project
Final projectFinal project
Final project
 

Social Media and Anonymity

  • 1. Paul Honke Social Media and Anonymity Analyzing Social Issues 12/7/15
  • 2. It is safe to say that since the introduction of social networking, interaction and the ability to stay connected with each other has reshaped the way we talk to people. Social media as well as other social networking have allowed us to talk about anything to anyone. However, the form of how you talk to people has sparked some controversy. For as many social media sites that state your identity, there are as many that allow you to remain anonymous. It is through anonymity that our behavior changes, sometimes for the good, mostly for the worse. Anonymity through social media has allowed many people to bully and harass others with few repercussions. This paper will note the positives and negatives of social media anonymity and point out why it should be regulated on social media platforms. Being anonymous in social networking and the web in general will change people’s behaviors. Anonymity has been typically described as a state where others can’t identify you or each other.1 A big advantage when using social media and other forms of online communication is that you do not have to meet your friends face to face like in a phone conversation. Unlike a phone conversation, social media can also take away the voice aspect. When nobody knows who you are online, you can be anyone you wish.2 Much of this thinking revolves around the idea of visual anonymity. Visual anonymity is when you are unidentifiable in appearance from other members in social media or in a chat room.3 Due to the lack of face to face contact, certain social cues are missed, potentially leading to different kinds of behavior.4 The presence of visual anonymity is a crucial factor in how people’s behaviors change online. A big factor is that not 1 Kimberly Christopherson,“ThePositive andNegative Implications ofAnonymity in Internet Social Interactions: On the Internet, Nobody Knows You’re a Dog,” Computers In Human Behavior 23(2007): 3040, accessedNov. 11, 2015,doi:10.1016/j.chb.2006.09.001. 2 Rebecca Chui, "A Multi-facetedApproachtoAnonymityOnline: ExaminingtheRelations betweenAnonymity andAntisocial Behavior."Journal of Virtual Worlds Research 7 (2014): 3, accessed, Nov. 11, 2015, https://journals.tdl.org/jvwr/index.php/jvwr/article/view/7073/6342 3 Ibid. 4 Ibid.
  • 3. being visually identifiable on social media can lead to unruly behavior.5 Without anyone to identify them or tell them otherwise, people can go on anonymous social media sites and say anything they want. Usually, reactions to certain comments will lead to a higher level of aggression, as it is a natural reaction toward certain social situations.6 Despite all the talk about how anonymity can change behaviors, there are plenty of positives that come from being anonymous on social media or online. One of the biggest benefits of anonymity is the ability to talk about difficult subjects.7 In a survey hosted by Ask.fm, 40 percent of teenagers use social networks and various forms of anonymity to talk about subjects that they would not normally tell others.8 In fact, the same survey noted that teenagers in general rarely have regrets about their postings.9 The fact that social media can be used to talk about difficult subjects has been noted in many cases. An example of this can be from Whispers own developer, Michael Heyword. He talks about a story where talking to a girl in a self-harm post saved his life because of her advice.10 There are other ways that being anonymous can help people online or on social media. The aspect of privacy is a huge reason that many people advocate for being anonymous in social media. According to Kimberly Christopherson, an current associate professor in psychology at Morningside College, said in her essay, The Positive and Negative Implications of 5 Ibid. 6 Chui, "A Multi-facetedApproach, 4. 7 Kerry Flynn, “Teens EmbraceAnonymous Social Networks ToDiscuss AwkwardTopics, BuildConfidence: Study.” International Business Times, Aug. 27, 2015, accessedNov.11,2015, http://www.ibtimes.com/teens-embrace-anonymous-social-networks-discuss-awkward-topics- build-confidence-study-2070998. 8 Ibid. 9 Ibid. 10 P.H. “Anonymous Social Networking: Secrets andLies,” The Economist Blog, March 22, 14, AccessedNov.11,2015, http://www.economist.com/blogs/schumpeter/2014/03/anonymous-social-networking.
  • 4. Anonymity in Internet Social Interactions: On the Internet, Nobody Knows You’re a Dog, “privacy refers to the ability to control the amount of contact one has with others.11” For many people, privacy is an important aspect of their lives.12 Not everyone can be in constant interaction with each other and everyone needs time to be alone. In terms of anonymity in social media interactions, privacy can be related to three concepts; recovery, catharsis, and autonomy.13 Christopherson notes that recovery is the most important concept.14 Recovery is described as the feeling of recuperation after contemplating about a situation and feeling reborn afterwards.15 While recovery is important, catharsis is another important factor. Catharsis is described as the uncontained release of personal thoughts to others.16 Through the use of anonymity, people can go to online forums or anonymous social media to release pent up feelings about a specific subject. With catharsis, the individual can find refuge in exploring their feelings without being identified and with recovery, is able to relax and find a new lease on their life. The third concept related privacy on anonymous social media is autonomy. Autonomy is described as the ability to try something different and new without fear of prejudice.17 Many people have hobbies that they don’t want others to know. When a person’s interest becomes public, it could run the risk of being deemed “embarrassing” and could be the source of ridicule depending on the hobby. For many people, being anonymous on various social media outlets 11 Christopherson, “The Positive andNegative Implications ofAnonymity,” 3040. 12 Ibid. 13 Ibid., 3041. 14 Ibid., 3041. 15 Ibid., 3041. 16 Ibid., 3041. 17 Ibid., 3041.
  • 5. helps them explore their own personal identity.18 In an interview, students in the ages of 13-19 mention that the internet and social media have allowed them to pick and choose to whom they want to talk to as they become more expressive.19 Recently, many people use social media and online communities to explore various issues based on their own sexuality.20 There is also the fact anonymity in various group projects may have beneficial results. People who are identifiable can be the subject of stereotypes.21 Through anonymity in social media and online communities, the issue of stereotype is taken away and people from all classes can work on a playing field deemed equalization hypothesis.22 The idea that anonymity takes away the individual in groups has often been challenged by the SIDE theory. SIDE theory predicts that group interaction is based on level of salience in a group and the number of people anonymous in social and online networks.23 Salience is when someone connects less to the group than to themselves.24 If all members are identifiable save for one or two members who are anonymous, then the ones in anonymity will hold more social identity to themselves and can become unruly.25 In contrast, if all members are anonymous, and have a high level of salience then the focus on the group takes prominence over individuals.26 18 Ibid., 3042. 19 Ibid., 3042. 20 Ibid., 3042. 21 Ibid., 3045. 22 Ibid., 3045-3046. 23 Ibid., 3048. 24 Ibid., 3048. 25 Ibid., 3048. 26 Ibid., 3048.
  • 6. Despite all the benefits anonymity gives to someone on social media or other social communities, there is no denying that anonymity can lead to many problems in bullying and anti- social behavior. Despite the traditional form of bullying being more common, when a person aggression against someone online increases the chances of his/her bullying another face to face.27 Cyberbullying is a huge problem when it comes to anonymous social media. Cyberbullying as explained by Fabio Sticca, a postdoctoral and Perren Sonja, a professor from the University of Konstanz, in their article Is Cyberbullying Worse Than Traditional Bullying? Examining the Differential Roles of Medium, Publiciy, and Anonymity for the Perceived Severity of Bullying, is defined “as an aggressive behavior that is repeatedly and intentionally carried out against a defenseless victim using electronic forms of contact.28” Many social network apps such as Yik-Yak have had their share of cyberbullying stories. In one story, a teacher was conducting a course on post-apocalyptic culture while the students spent their time on Yik-Yak talking about her.29 When the teacher found out that they had been ridiculing her, she tried to file for harassment.30 It is worth mention that not all cyberbullying is anonymous. Some digital formats include the IP address or other personal information about the content provider.31 However, the fact that someone is not truly anonymous does not matter to the cyberbully.32 Without someone’s entire information revealed to the world alongside no face to face confrontation the bully feels as 27 ChristopherBarlett,“AnonymouslyHurtingOthers Online: TheEffect of Anonymity onCyberbullyingFrequency,” Psychologyof Popular Media Culture 4 (2015): 71, accessedNov.11,2015, http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/a0034335. 28 Fabio Sticca, andSonja Perren, “Is CyberbullyingWorse ThanTraditional Bullying? Examiningthe Differential Roles of Medium, Publicity, andAnonymity for the PerceivedSeverityof Bullying.”Journal of Youth& Adolescence 42(2013): 740, accessedNov.11,2015, doi: 10.1007/s10964-012-9867-3 29 Katherine Schulten,“Are Anonymous Social Media Networks Dangerous?,“ TheNew York Times Blog, March11, 2015, accessedNov. 11, 2015, http://learning.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/03/11/are-anonymous-social-media-networks-dangerous/?_r=0. 30 Ibid. 31 Barlett,“Anonymously HurtingOthers Online,”71. 32 Ibid.
  • 7. though he/she is anonymous. This will make bullies act like they are unknown to the world and continue to harass the victim.33 In a recent study, the largest amount of cyberbullying actually comes from instant messaging.34 Due to the anonymous nature of certain social networks and online communities, cyberbullying has numerous effects on its victims. One of these effects is depression.35 Depression from cyberbullying on social media has shown to have long lasting repercussions. If the depression is severe enough, it can unfortunately lead to suicide.36 It’s good to point out that social media sites that show your identify like Facebook has its own cyberbullying problems. However, the difference between Facebook and anonymous social media is that the anonymous one is harder to track and discover the culprit.37 Because sites such as Yik-Yak and Ask.fm allow people to post derogatory statements without being asked who they are, the police have difficulty finding the anonymous apps and users.38 Another huge problem with anonymous social media and cyberbullying is sexual harassment. Objectifying women has been found in many forms of digital media such as video games, movies, and TV shows.39 It has been shown in a study that the majority of defamatory comments are aimed towards women who as a result, suffer a more sever levels of depression 33 Ibid. 34 Ibid. 35 Stephanie Pappas, “Cyberbullyingon Social Media LinkedtoTeenDepression,” Live Science June 22,2015, accessedonNov.26,2015, http://www.livescience.com/51294-cyberbullying-social-media-teen-depression.html. 36 Ibid. 37 Paige Samson, “Anonymous social media apps encourages cyberbullying,” WSOCTV, June 6, 2014, accessedonNov. 26, 2015, http://www.wsoctv.com/news/news/local/hidden-social-media-apps-encourage-cyber-bullying/ngF6y/. 38 Ibid. 39 Jesse Fox, et al. "PerpetuatingOnline Sexism Offline: Anonymity, Interactivity, andtheEffects of Sexist Hashtags on Social Media." Computers in HumanBehavior 52(2015): 436,accessedon Nov. 11, 2015,doi:10.1016/j.chb.2015.06.024
  • 8. and distress than their male counterparts.40 Sexist comments on social media and networks do not have to be aimed directly at someone to be offensive. There is a concept called ambient sexism, where the environment, being real or virtual, is filled with sexist comments and behavior among both men and women.41 A good portion of this has to do with the “online disinhibition effect,” which is the act of someone acting differently online than if the person interacted with another face to face.42 While the SIDE theory does offer suggestions against the effect, certain characteristics still apply such as invisibility, where the lack of face to face contact has the illusion of being anonymous.43 In a study by Jesse Fox, an assistant professor and Carlos Cruz, a student from the University of Ohio, and Ji Young Lee, a student from the University of Pittsburg in their paper Perpetuating Online Sexism Offline: Anonymity, Interactivity, and the Effects of Sexist Hashtags on Social Media, men and women participants were placed in visible and anonymous groups and were asked to respond and interact with twitter posts with sexist hashtags.44 Using online disinhibition as a framework, the researchers expected the men to react to online material and show more sexist attitudes.45 The results showed the researchers to be very accurate to their study. The results showed that the people including the men in the anonymous group showed more sexist attitudes when interacting with them during the study.46 Perhaps the most disturbing result that came from this was that the sexist attitudes had a tendency to carry 40 Ibid. 41 Ibid. 42 Fox, et al. "PerpetuatingOnline Sexism Offline,” 437. 43 Barlett,“Anonymously HurtingOthers Online,”71. 44 Fox, et al. "PerpetuatingOnline Sexism Offline,” 438. 45 Ibid. 46 Ibid., 440.
  • 9. themselves over offline. After the test was completed, some participants were more sexist after interacting with defamatory comments.47 As the problem with anonymity and cyberbullying grows, many social networks responded in their own ways. As a Facebook user, the only way I know that people can be anonymous are if they have a fake account. However that may be changing. A new Facebook app, similar to Yik-Yak and Whisper has been designed to allow people to talk to each other without using their real name.48 Unlike other anonymous social media apps, Facebook knows what it is doing by implementing certain counter measures against offensive comments. Mark Zuckerberg himself has noted that Facebook chatrooms will be monitored and that hate speeches or other signs of cyberbullying will be removed.49 Facebook officials mention that anonymity is a place where people can be free, but control is needed.50 This is in contrast to Yik-Yak, which is still under threat from schools banning such anonymous apps due to the threat it gives to their students.51 The war on anonymity is a controversial one. While I agree that anonymity has many benefits, such as discussing subjects or exploring interests one normally would not do in public, the negatives have ended up hurting many people and has given rise to more real world bullying as well. Anonymity should be respected, but also be regulated. I for one think that sites such as Whisper and Yik-Yak should follow Facebooks lead and monitor posts more securely. 47 Ibid. 48 Davey Alba “The Futureof Anonymityon theInternet Is Facebook Rooms,” Wired, Oct. 27, 14, accessedon Nov. 11, 2015, http://www.wired.com/2014/10/facebook-rooms-future-anonymity-internet/. 49 Ibid. 50 Ibid. 51 “Yik Yak app: Whyschools are concerned.” CBC News, Jan. 21, 2014, accessed, Nov. 11, 2015, http://www.cbc.ca/news/technology/yik-yak- app-why-schools-are-concerned-1.2920155.
  • 10. Bibliography Alba, Davey. “The Future of Anonymity on the Internet Is Facebook Rooms,” Wired, Oct. 27. 14. Accessed Nov. 11, 2015, http://www.wired.com/2014/10/facebook-rooms-future- anonymity-internet/. Barlett, Christopher P. “Anonymously Hurting Others Online: The Effect of Anonymity on Cyberbullying Frequency,” Psychology of Popular Media Culture 4, no. 2 (2015): 70-79. Accessed Nov. 11, 2015, http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/a0034335. Christopherson, Kimberly M. “The Positive and Negative Implications of Anonymity in Internet Social Interactions: On the Internet, Nobody Knows You’re a Dog,” Computers In Human Behavior 23, no. 6 (2007): 3038-3056. Accessed Nov. 11, 2015, doi:10.1016/j.chb.2006.09.001. Chui, Rebecca. "A Multi-faceted Approach to Anonymity Online: Examining the Relations between Anonymity and Antisocial Behavior." Journal of Virtual Worlds Research 7, no. 2 (2014): 1-13. Accessed Nov. 11, 2015, http://www.ibtimes.com/teens-embrace- anonymous-social-networks-discuss-awkward-topics-build-confidence-study-2070998. Flynn, Kerry. “Teens Embrace Anonymous Social Networks To Discuss Awkward Topics, Build Confidence: Study.” International Business Times, Aug. 27, 2015. Accessed on Nov. 11, 15, http://www.ibtimes.com/teens-embrace-anonymous-social-networks-discuss- awkward-topics-build-confidence-study-2070998. Fox, Jesse, Cruz, Carlos, and Ji Young Lee. "Perpetuating Online Sexism Offline: Anonymity, Interactivity, and the Effects of Sexist Hashtags on Social Media," Computers In Human Behavior 52, no. (2015): 436-442. Accessed Nov. 11, 2015. doi: 10.1016/j.chb.2015.06.024. Samson, Paige. “Anonymous social media apps encourages cyberbullying,” WSOCTV, June 6, 2014. Accessed on Nov. 26, 2015, http://www.wsoctv.com/news/news/local/hidden- social-media-apps-encourage-cyber-bullying/ngF6y/. Schulten, Katherine. “Are Anonymous Social Media Networks Dangerous?, “ The New York Times (Blog), March 11, 2015. Accessed on Nov. 11, 2015, http://learning.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/03/11/are-anonymous-social-media-networks- dangerous/?_r=0.
  • 11. Pappas, Stephanie. “Cyberbullying on Social Media Linked to Teen Depression,” Live Science, June 22, 2015. Accessed on Nov. 26, 2015, http://www.livescience.com/51294- cyberbullying-social-media-teen-depression.html. P.H. “Anonymous Social Networking: Secrets and Lies,” The Economist (Blog), March 22, 14. Accessed on Nov. 11, 2015, http://www.economist.com/blogs/schumpeter/2014/03/anonymous-social-networking. Sticca, Fabio, and Sonja Perren. “Is Cyberbullying Worse Than Traditional Bullying? Examining the Differential Roles of Medium, Publiciy, and Anonymity for the Perceived Severity of Bullying.” Journal of Youth & Adolescence 42 (2013): 739-750. Accessed Nov. 12, 2015, doi: 10.1007/s10964-012-9867-3. “Yik Yak app: Why schools are concerned.” CBC News, Jan. 21, 2014. Accessed on Nov. 11, 2015, http://www.cbc.ca/news/technology/yik-yak-app-why-schools-are-concerned- 1.2920155.