NADS-2012-MKT-CORPORATE-EN-V1.5




                                 Convergence of Distributed
                               Simulation Architectures Using
                                            DDS
                                 OMG TECHNICAL MEETING SPECIAL EVENT
                                 Data Distribution Service Information Day
                                    March 20th 2013. Reston, Virginia




Jose-Maria Lopez-Rodriguez
VP Business Development NADS
SISO SAC board member
SISO LSA study group member
jmlopez@nads.es
Mar-2013
Evolution of the S&T industry
Our Vision: Future of M&S systems is on the network




                                                                                   Simulation in
                                                                                     the Cloud
                                                                                    (Simulation
                                                                                   as a Service)




Commercial in Confidence   © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012.
2                            Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
Concept of Distributed Simulation

   Simulations are interactive through current state-of-the-art communication systems

                                             Constructive




                            Live                                           Virtual

                                    Can be across the world
                                    or across the room!


                            Virtual                                         Live



                                              Constructive

       Simulation environments that are distributed across multiple computers, potentially
       at different locations
       O
       „ ften referred to as “federations”
 Commercial in Confidence   © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012.
 3                            Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
Distributed Simulations enable Joint Mission Training




CONSTRUCTIVE SIMULATION
BLUE FORCES
Injecting Blue Forces in the                                                           CONSTRUCTIVE SIMULATION
scenario                                                                               RED FORCES
                                                                                       Injecting Red Forces in the
                                                                                       scenario. Human behaviour
                                                                                       represented by agents & IA




                                   VIRTUAL SIMULATOR
                                   FORWARD AIR CONTROLLER
 VIRTUAL SIMULATOR                 Mission: Reconaissance & Designing Targets
 APACHE LONGBOW
 Mission: CAS                                                                          VIRTUAL SIMULATOR
                                                                                       A10 Thunderbolt
                                                                                       Mission: Observation & CAS
  Commercial in Confidence     © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012.
  4                              Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
Our Vision: Future of M&S systems is on the network




    But Reality is Complex:
    * Different Standards for interoperability
    * Too many COTS hard to interoperate between them
    * Different Data & Voice Communications
    * Legacy vs. COTS based Systems
    * Heterogeneus simulation ecosystems
    * Scaling-Up to Very Large Exercises



Commercial in Confidence   © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012.
5                            Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
Defense Administrations have invested a lot in
   simulation systems for weapon systems but:
   * Poor use of existing simulation assets
   * Distributed Mission Training is very difficult
   * Interoperability is very limited
   * Tied hands with HLA COTS vendors




Commercial in Confidence   © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012.
6                            Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
Because of this problems, SISO starts a new Study
Group : LSA, looking to solve many of this pains.




SISO LSA is looking to
customize DDS for the
simulation domain,
providing the foundation
for a Layered Simulation
Architecture
Commercial in Confidence   © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012.
7                            Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
Why use DDS in Simulation?

                                                                                Data
                                                                                                               Data
                                                                                Write
                                                                                                              Reader
 COMMUNICATION                                                                   r

                                                                                                                        Data
                                                                       Data
                                                                       Write                                           Reader
                                                                        r



     DDS is centered in controlling the                       Data
                                                                                TOPIC “A”
                                                                                                        TOPIC “D”

                                                              Write
     communication                                             r
                                                                                [DDS Global Data Space]
                                                                                                                         Data
                                                                                                                        Reader


     HLA tries to minimize the                                                              TOPIC “B”

     communication. It cannot control it                       Data
                                                                                    TOPIC “C”                           Data
                                                                                                                        Write
                                                               Write
                                                                                                                         r
                                                                r
     DIS trust the communication


                                                            SCALABILITY and FAULT TOLERANCE

                                                                      DDS has automatic discovery, is fully
                                                                      publish-subscriber, no single point of
                                                                      failure
                                                                      HLA is central server based: scalability
                                                                      and fault tolerance are difficult


 Commercial in Confidence   © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012.
 8                            Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
Why use DDS in Simulation?


  LESS-THAN-PERFECT COMMUNICATIONS

     DDS has been proved over small
     bandwidth (4800 bps in digital network
     radios)
     DDS can cope with heterogeneous
     networks


                                                                    REAL TIME SIMULATION

                                                                         Military platforms use DDS as
                                                                         the communication backbone
                                                                         Simulating with DDS can
                                                                         incorporate this data in real time



 Commercial in Confidence   © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012.
 9                            Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
CONVERGENCE OF DISTRIBUTED ARCHITECTURES WITH SISO LSA



                                                                HLA
                                                 DIS

                                                          TENA




                                                SISO LSA



 Commercial in Confidence   © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012.
 10                           Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
Simulation today: Use of different standards



                                                                            HLA and DIS cover more than the
                                 TENA                                        70% of the demand. Both are
                                               OO design                     standards embraced by IEEE and
                   Information management                                    SISO and known worldwide
         Ownership
          transfer                                                          These architectures have significant
                           Save & Restore
                                                                             overlap in capabilities and
            Initialize a         Pass interactions                           requirements
            federation
                                DIS
          QOS                                                      Support
         options      Multiple message types
                                                Resign            Unreliable
                           Synchronize                            Networks


         Event                                                    CTIA
        ordering
                                                     Persistent
                      HLA                            Database




  Commercial in Confidence        © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012.
  11                                Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
An assessment of HLA present capabilities




                                                                         Wire protocol does not exist
                                                                         The entire standard tries to limit
   A IEEE and NATO (Stanag 4603)                                         communication
    standards                                                                QoS are very limited.
   An accepted standard for                                             Lack of plug&play capacities.
    interoperating simulators                                               Performance is not enough for
   Has meta-data model (OMT)                                                massive data distribution across
   Define rules for interoperability                                        heterogeneous networks.
   Many COTS from different vendors                                         API is hard to use
      Services are part of HLA                                          No security standard
                                                                         Model is rigid




 Commercial in Confidence   © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012.
 12                           Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
When worlds collide




 Commercial in Confidence   © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012.
 13                           Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
LSA looks to improve ROI in the S&T industry


                                                               Many architectures
                                                               in use reduce
                                                               reusability,
                                                               interoperability and
                                                               composability

                     LSA tries to improve this three key
                                 parameters



  Commercial in Confidence   © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012.
  14                           Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
Concept #1: Interoperability




       Simulator A                                                                 Simulator B



Commercial in Confidence   © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012.
15                           Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
Concept #2: Reuse
                                                                                   same weapon model
                                                                                      runs in both
                                                                                       simulators




            Simulator A                                                Simulator B

Commercial in Confidence   © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012.
16                           Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
Concept #3: Composability



                                       Sim Assets


                                                                           Scenario built from
                                                                            simulation assets




Commercial in Confidence   © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012.
17                           Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
With LSA you could have Simulations as Services in the Cloud




                                                                                        Injecting
                                                                                        Simulation Entities
                                              L                                         in Real Time
                             ASSET #1         I                 Simulation
                                              B                   Asset
                                              R                   Server
                                              A
                                              R
                             ASSET #2         I
                                              E
                                              S



                             ASSET #3


                                                                                    LVC Simulation in progress
  Commercial in Confidence      © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012.
  18                              Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
LSA Use Case
SP Battle Lab Prototype (NOGESI)
Commercial in Confidence   © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012.
20                           Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
Try out LSA's flavors with
            Simware




Commercial in Confidence   © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012.
21                           Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
@NADS_news                              /NEXTELADS            jmlopezrodriguez   Nextel Aerospace




Please address any questions about this presentation to:




Commercial in Confidence   © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012.
22                           Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L.
Avenida de Manoteras, 18
28050 Madrid – Spain
+34 91 803 38 02
www.nads.es
www.simware.es



Follow us in:

     @NADS_news

      /NEXTELADS

     /jmlopezrodriguez

     /Nextel Aerospace

SISO LSA AND OMG DDS

  • 1.
    NADS-2012-MKT-CORPORATE-EN-V1.5 Convergence of Distributed Simulation Architectures Using DDS OMG TECHNICAL MEETING SPECIAL EVENT Data Distribution Service Information Day March 20th 2013. Reston, Virginia Jose-Maria Lopez-Rodriguez VP Business Development NADS SISO SAC board member SISO LSA study group member jmlopez@nads.es Mar-2013
  • 2.
    Evolution of theS&T industry Our Vision: Future of M&S systems is on the network Simulation in the Cloud (Simulation as a Service) Commercial in Confidence © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012. 2 Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
  • 3.
    Concept of DistributedSimulation Simulations are interactive through current state-of-the-art communication systems Constructive Live Virtual Can be across the world or across the room! Virtual Live Constructive Simulation environments that are distributed across multiple computers, potentially at different locations O „ ften referred to as “federations” Commercial in Confidence © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012. 3 Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
  • 4.
    Distributed Simulations enableJoint Mission Training CONSTRUCTIVE SIMULATION BLUE FORCES Injecting Blue Forces in the CONSTRUCTIVE SIMULATION scenario RED FORCES Injecting Red Forces in the scenario. Human behaviour represented by agents & IA VIRTUAL SIMULATOR FORWARD AIR CONTROLLER VIRTUAL SIMULATOR Mission: Reconaissance & Designing Targets APACHE LONGBOW Mission: CAS VIRTUAL SIMULATOR A10 Thunderbolt Mission: Observation & CAS Commercial in Confidence © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012. 4 Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
  • 5.
    Our Vision: Futureof M&S systems is on the network But Reality is Complex: * Different Standards for interoperability * Too many COTS hard to interoperate between them * Different Data & Voice Communications * Legacy vs. COTS based Systems * Heterogeneus simulation ecosystems * Scaling-Up to Very Large Exercises Commercial in Confidence © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012. 5 Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
  • 6.
    Defense Administrations haveinvested a lot in simulation systems for weapon systems but: * Poor use of existing simulation assets * Distributed Mission Training is very difficult * Interoperability is very limited * Tied hands with HLA COTS vendors Commercial in Confidence © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012. 6 Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
  • 7.
    Because of thisproblems, SISO starts a new Study Group : LSA, looking to solve many of this pains. SISO LSA is looking to customize DDS for the simulation domain, providing the foundation for a Layered Simulation Architecture Commercial in Confidence © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012. 7 Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
  • 8.
    Why use DDSin Simulation? Data Data Write Reader COMMUNICATION r Data Data Write Reader r DDS is centered in controlling the Data TOPIC “A” TOPIC “D” Write communication r [DDS Global Data Space] Data Reader HLA tries to minimize the TOPIC “B” communication. It cannot control it Data TOPIC “C” Data Write Write r r DIS trust the communication SCALABILITY and FAULT TOLERANCE DDS has automatic discovery, is fully publish-subscriber, no single point of failure HLA is central server based: scalability and fault tolerance are difficult Commercial in Confidence © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012. 8 Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
  • 9.
    Why use DDSin Simulation? LESS-THAN-PERFECT COMMUNICATIONS DDS has been proved over small bandwidth (4800 bps in digital network radios) DDS can cope with heterogeneous networks REAL TIME SIMULATION Military platforms use DDS as the communication backbone Simulating with DDS can incorporate this data in real time Commercial in Confidence © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012. 9 Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
  • 10.
    CONVERGENCE OF DISTRIBUTEDARCHITECTURES WITH SISO LSA HLA DIS TENA SISO LSA Commercial in Confidence © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012. 10 Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
  • 11.
    Simulation today: Useof different standards  HLA and DIS cover more than the TENA 70% of the demand. Both are OO design standards embraced by IEEE and Information management SISO and known worldwide Ownership transfer  These architectures have significant Save & Restore overlap in capabilities and Initialize a Pass interactions requirements federation DIS QOS Support options Multiple message types Resign Unreliable Synchronize Networks Event CTIA ordering Persistent HLA Database Commercial in Confidence © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012. 11 Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
  • 12.
    An assessment ofHLA present capabilities  Wire protocol does not exist  The entire standard tries to limit  A IEEE and NATO (Stanag 4603) communication standards  QoS are very limited.  An accepted standard for  Lack of plug&play capacities. interoperating simulators  Performance is not enough for  Has meta-data model (OMT) massive data distribution across  Define rules for interoperability heterogeneous networks.  Many COTS from different vendors  API is hard to use  Services are part of HLA  No security standard  Model is rigid Commercial in Confidence © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012. 12 Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
  • 13.
    When worlds collide Commercial in Confidence © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012. 13 Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
  • 14.
    LSA looks toimprove ROI in the S&T industry Many architectures in use reduce reusability, interoperability and composability LSA tries to improve this three key parameters Commercial in Confidence © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012. 14 Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
  • 15.
    Concept #1: Interoperability Simulator A Simulator B Commercial in Confidence © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012. 15 Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
  • 16.
    Concept #2: Reuse same weapon model runs in both simulators Simulator A Simulator B Commercial in Confidence © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012. 16 Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
  • 17.
    Concept #3: Composability Sim Assets Scenario built from simulation assets Commercial in Confidence © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012. 17 Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
  • 18.
    With LSA youcould have Simulations as Services in the Cloud Injecting Simulation Entities L in Real Time ASSET #1 I Simulation B Asset R Server A R ASSET #2 I E S ASSET #3 LVC Simulation in progress Commercial in Confidence © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012. 18 Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
  • 19.
    LSA Use Case SPBattle Lab Prototype (NOGESI)
  • 20.
    Commercial in Confidence © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012. 20 Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
  • 21.
    Try out LSA'sflavors with Simware Commercial in Confidence © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012. 21 Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
  • 22.
    @NADS_news /NEXTELADS jmlopezrodriguez Nextel Aerospace Please address any questions about this presentation to: Commercial in Confidence © NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE & SECURITY S.L., 2012. 22 Reservados todos los derechos / All Rights Reserved
  • 23.
    NEXTEL AEROSPACE DEFENCE& SECURITY S.L. Avenida de Manoteras, 18 28050 Madrid – Spain +34 91 803 38 02 www.nads.es www.simware.es Follow us in: @NADS_news /NEXTELADS /jmlopezrodriguez /Nextel Aerospace