1. Using ECOTECT for Exterior Qualitative
Solar Analysis
Direct Shading Analysis
Harvard Graduate School of Design
Diego Ibarra
Digital Workshops Series Spring 2010
2. Quick overview of ECOTECT
Examples of Quantitative Exterior Solar
Analysis
Examples of Qualitative Exterior Solar
Analyses
Direct Shading Method in ECOTECT
Demo: Step by Step tutorial
Diego Ibarra
AGENDA
3. “Autodesk ECOTECT Analysis 2010 is a …. building
design and environmental analysis tool that covers
…. full range of simulation and analysis functions …..
It ….allows designers to work easily in 3D and apply
all the tools necessary for an energy efficient and
sustainable future.” Autodesk website.
Author’s opinion: it is a very useful, mature and capable GUI
(probably the best out there today), however it should not be
used to perform quantitative analyses using its built-in engines
(thermal or daylight) (Ibarra and Reinhart 2009).
ECOTECT (Originally Square One Research
(Andrew Marsh), recently bought by Autodesk)
Diego Ibarra
4. You may download a FREE evaluation version of ECOTECT Analysis 2010
from the ‘autodesk’ website: http://students.autodesk.com/
SET - UP
Follow the instructions outlined bellow to set-up your computer. Make
sure to pay close attention to all the steps and execute them carefully.
Autodesk requires you to provide some general information about
yourself before you can download the evaluation version. Before the
actual download begins you will be prompted to save the file to disk.
The file you have downloaded is a zipped archive containing the
ECOTECT installation files. Save the zip file to a temporary folder on your
hard disk. Unzip it and double click on the file called ‘SETUP.EXE’. Follow
the on-screen instructions.
// ECOTECT //
Diego Ibarra
5. OVERVIEW
Simulation engines Graphical User Interface (GUI)
RADIANCE / DAYSIM /
EnergyPlus / others
ECOTECT’s
built-in engines ECOTECT
as a GUI
Diego Ibarra
6. version: 2/6/10
Simulation Engine vs. GUI
Most building energy simulation programs come with a graphical
user interface (GUI) as well as the actual simulation engine. The
former is used to prepare simulation input files for the latter and to
display simulation results once a simulation is complete.
The developers of simulation engines and GUIs often work for
different companies with the engine being developed at public
organizations (government lab & universities) whereas GUIs are
more often developed by commercial vendors. As a result there
can be several GUIs for the same simulation engine.
While the choice of GUI determines the ease of use if a simulation
program, it is ultimately the engine that determines how reliable
simulation results are. A great GUI with a weak engine cannot yield
reliable results!
OVERVIEW
Diego Ibarra
7. Quantitative Exterior Solar Analyses
Examples
Even when carrying out simple quantitative exterior
solar analysis you should be very careful and critic
about the results.
ECOTECT’s Irradiation distribution method has not
been validated (Comparison study in progress, Ibarra
and Reinhart 2010?). Following are a series of this
kind of analyses.
Diego Ibarra
12. Qualitative Exterior Solar Analyses
Overview
Exterior qualitative solar analyses use simple
geometric derived sun positions to directly trace solar
rays. They do not take into account solar radiation or
sky distribution methods.
Diego Ibarra
13. As in other building performance analyses we also have a GUI and a an
engine (code). However, in this case for simple qualitative shading studies
we only relay un simple geometric derivations (Within ECOTECT)
OVERVIEW
Simple engine (geometric
derivations using project
latitude)
Graphical User Interface
Built-in
Geometric Models
Diego Ibarra
39. Questions…
dibarra@gsd.harvard.edu
Digital Workshops Series Spring 2010
* Working document. Please visit the G(SD)2 website for future revisions.
Diego Ibarra, M.Arch, MDesS, LEED AP BD+C.
Doctoral Student, Sustainable Design, Harvard University.