SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Total Catechesis

 Who gets to choose?
How can war be justified?
Let Us Pray
O my God, teach my heart where and how to seek You,
where and how to find You.

You are my God and You are my all
and I have never seen You.

You have made me and remade me,
You have bestowed on me all the good things I possess,
Still I do not know You.

I have not yet done that for which I was made.
Teach me to seek You.
I cannot seek You unless You teach me
or find You unless You show Yourself to me.

Let me seek You in my desire,
let me desire You in my seeking.
Let me find You by loving You,
let me love You when I find You.

Amen
Tonight you will...


examine your beliefs about the death penalty and the reasons why you
hold your beliefs

understand what the Catholic Church teaches about the death penalty
and other life issues under the consistent ethic of life.

reexamine your own belief about life issues in light of what the Church
teaches and will choose your own action to promote life.
DEATH PENALTY - YES OR NO



A cult leader sends his followers to the home of a woman who is eight
months pregnant. He has ordered the cult members to kill her and
everyone else in the home, which they do. He shows no remorse, but
he did not actually commit the murders himself.
DEATH PENALTY - YES OR NO




 A man trains terrorists and sends them on suicide attacks that kill
thousands of innocent people in an “enemy” country.
DEATH PENALTY - YES OR NO



A thief is caught by police in the act of robbing a convenience store. The
thief grabs his gun and kills a female police officer, who is the mother of
two small children.
DEATH PENALTY - YES OR NO




A mentally challenged 18 year old kills a woman who caught him
robbing her home.
DEATH PENALTY - YES OR NO




A father kills a drug dealer who sold crack to his 13 year old son.
DEATH PENALTY - YES OR NO



A woman participates in a very vicious murder, committed with an ax,
but admits her crime and professes repentence, asking forgiveness of
God and the victim’s family.
DEATH PENALTY - YES OR NO




A pedofile kidnaps, rapes, and then murders a 10 year old girl.
DEATH PENALTY - YES OR NO




Two brothers, ages 12 and 14, beat their father to death with a baseball
bat. He had abused them physically and emotionally for many years.
Analyzing the “why”



THINK: Work independently on “Who Deserves the Death Penalty”

PAIR: Share the significant influences on your decisions

SHARE: Share some comments with the whole group
What do the man on death row and the newborn baby have in common?
What do an unborn baby and a terminally ill person have in common?
What do a person dying painfully and a Jew in Nazi Germany have in common?
What do a Jewish person in Nazi Germany and an innocent civilian who died from a bomb
                       dropped on her village have in common?
Write these down
               The Church’s postion



Every human life is sacred because we are all created in the image and
likeness of God. Because we are made in God’s image, we all have a
dignity and a worth that can never be taken away.
The Church’s postion




We are responsible for protecting the dignity of all, even people who
have killed someone else.
The Church’s postion



Executing someone for a crime is an extremem measure that should
happen only when absolutely necessary. Given today’s prison system,
such a situation is rare, if not nonexistant.
                John Paul II, The Gospel of Life
The Church’s postion


Being pro-life means defending the dignity of all human life from unborn
babies to people at the end of their life.

  Dignity is not based on what we deserve or don’t deserve.

  Based on one fact; all of us are created God’s image

  This position is called a “consistent ethic of life”
http://youtu.be/qguWRoYozLI
Write 2 or 3 sentences that tell something new you are thinking about
after hearing about the Church’s position on life issue.

  Which parts of the Church’s postion seem right to you?

  Are there any ideas in the Church’s position that you feel at odds
  with or don’t really understand?
Learning Objectives
                        Just War

You will come to appreciate God’s vision of peace and the very real
challenges involved in making that vision a reality in the world

You will be able to articulate the criteria used by the Church for judging
a war to be just

You will be equipped to apply the principles of a just war to current and
potential international conflict in the world.
Is the use of force justified?
 You are the democratically elected president of a small country in
the Middle East. Unlike many of its neighbors, your country has been
politically and economically stable for decades.Your economic
stability rests on tourism and rug weaving. Taken together, they
provide your people with a simple but adequate life. The quality of
your rugs is known and appreciated internationally. Now the country
immediately to the east is threatening your economic security. Its
weavers have copied your rug patterns and technology and are
turning out good-looking imitations at half the price.You know that
your political party will go under if the economy declines—and
everyone in the country will suffer. Moved by rug rage, you declare
war on your eastern enemy.
Is war justified?

 The border situation between your country and a neighboring country to the north
is a powder keg waiting to explode.Your country is rich in natural resources and
controls the flow of water between the two nations. The drought of the past few
years has left people in need on both sides of the border, but with fewer resources,
your southern neighbor is clearly in more trouble than your country. Smugglers and
illegal immigrants are destroying the fences along the border, evading the patrols, and
making the surrounding area a scary place to live. In retaliation you have sent patrols
across the border, trying to stem the illegal flow of immigrants into your country.
There have been deaths and tragedies on both sides. Both countries are hurting, and
neither is a clear winner in this conflict.You believe that things will only get worse in
the future, so you declare war.
Is war justified


You are the leader of your country’s armed forces.Your latest elected
president is incapable of making decisions and is ignorant of the severe
problems your country faces.You (and most military professionals)
think action needs to be taken immediately to halt the flurry of
terrorist attacks in your land. Fearing for your country’s survival, you
mobilize your forces and declare war on the terrorists.You will worry
about the consequences after you have beaten your enemy and
declared victory.
Is war justified?

Two of your neighbors to the west are at war. So far, you have stayed
neutral, but you are thinking of joining forces with one to conquer the
other.Your country’s population is expanding rapidly and will run out of
living space soon. War will give you the opportunity to annex part of
the loser’s land, giving future generations a bit of breathing space.
Without major loss of life or resources, you could end up the big
winner in this war and help bring the conflict to a speedy close.
Is war justified?


The neighboring country to your north is large and has been preparing
for war for several years.Your army is outnumbered five to one, but
your people are courageous and proud. When the war starts—and it is
certain to come soon—you will encourage them to fight with all their
strength rather than surrender to the forces sent their way. Being
attacked is reason enough to fight to the death.
Is war justified?

Your country has a long history of hatred with a neighboring country.
Tension and intolerance increase every day. When war starts again, you
know it will escalate quickly.Your country’s shaky infrastructure
(transportation and communication systems, health care and
educational institutions) will be set back many years, and the
environmental damage could take generations to repair. Damage to the
enemy country, however, will be even worse. War is never pretty. People
will suffer, but with your enemy soundly beaten, the violence should end
for good.
Is war justified?

When the tensions first flared, it looked like your country and the
country with which you are in conflict could talk together and work
out the problems. But now you know you cannot trust a thing they say.
The other countries in your region have offered to intervene, but you
figure that would just give your enemy time to strengthen defenses.You
see little chance of resolving the conflict peacefully, so you decide, as
the nation’s leader, to initiate war while you still have a chance of getting
the upper hand.
Points on Church teaching about war
We believe in a God of peace who reconciled the world through His
son Jesus Christ

We are called to live in peace, to prepare the world for God’s reign of
justice, love and peace.

Working for peace means defending human rights and promoting good
for all
  freeing people from poverty

  looking on all people as the members of one family

  working together to bring about justice and peace for all
Points on Church teaching about war

Conflict is inevitable in a sinful world. Church gives two ways to deal
with conflict

  Non-violence: dialogue, negotiations, peaceful protest, stikes, civil
  disobedience, civilian resistance

  Just War: strongly inclined against the use of force, certain
  conditions must be true
Just war
Just cause

Comparative Injustice

Legitimate Authority

Right Intention

Probablility of Success

Proportionality

Last Resort
Revisit scenarios
Regulating Force During Conflict



Noncombatant Immunity

Proportionality

Right Intention

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

E Tools in Catechesis
E Tools in CatechesisE Tools in Catechesis
E Tools in Catechesis
Caroline Cerveny
 
Curriculum Vitae
Curriculum VitaeCurriculum Vitae
Curriculum Vitae
Andrew McGovern
 
Total Catechesis Session 1
Total Catechesis Session 1Total Catechesis Session 1
Total Catechesis Session 1
bethschaper
 
Course 3, f eb. 2011
Course 3, f eb. 2011Course 3, f eb. 2011
Course 3, f eb. 2011
Andrea Slaven
 
Paradigm Shift in Scripture by Dr. Natividad Pagadut
Paradigm Shift in Scripture by Dr. Natividad PagadutParadigm Shift in Scripture by Dr. Natividad Pagadut
Paradigm Shift in Scripture by Dr. Natividad Pagadut
eccce821
 
Living The Sacraments Presentation
Living The Sacraments PresentationLiving The Sacraments Presentation
Living The Sacraments Presentation
Home
 

Viewers also liked (6)

E Tools in Catechesis
E Tools in CatechesisE Tools in Catechesis
E Tools in Catechesis
 
Curriculum Vitae
Curriculum VitaeCurriculum Vitae
Curriculum Vitae
 
Total Catechesis Session 1
Total Catechesis Session 1Total Catechesis Session 1
Total Catechesis Session 1
 
Course 3, f eb. 2011
Course 3, f eb. 2011Course 3, f eb. 2011
Course 3, f eb. 2011
 
Paradigm Shift in Scripture by Dr. Natividad Pagadut
Paradigm Shift in Scripture by Dr. Natividad PagadutParadigm Shift in Scripture by Dr. Natividad Pagadut
Paradigm Shift in Scripture by Dr. Natividad Pagadut
 
Living The Sacraments Presentation
Living The Sacraments PresentationLiving The Sacraments Presentation
Living The Sacraments Presentation
 

Similar to Session 2 september 30, 2012

Violence in the_media
Violence in the_mediaViolence in the_media
Violence in the_media
Makoi Majak
 
You Can Change Your World
You Can Change Your WorldYou Can Change Your World
You Can Change Your World
Peter Hammond
 
Peace Education in the Philippines
Peace Education in the  PhilippinesPeace Education in the  Philippines
Peace Education in the Philippines
Mary Jiemer Benolirao
 
Peace Education in the Philippines
Peace Education in the  PhilippinesPeace Education in the  Philippines
Peace Education in the Philippines
Mary Jiemer Benolirao
 
081019 Remember These Things
081019   Remember These Things081019   Remember These Things
081019 Remember These Things
Palm Desert Church of Christ
 
Balanced and biblical christian journalism
Balanced and biblical christian journalismBalanced and biblical christian journalism
Balanced and biblical christian journalism
Peter Hammond
 
Abortion Essay Against
Abortion Essay AgainstAbortion Essay Against
Abortion Essay Against
Lisa Windish
 
The Prophetic Voice - What Can the Bible Teach Us About Race Relations? (Final)
The Prophetic Voice - What Can the Bible Teach Us About Race Relations? (Final)The Prophetic Voice - What Can the Bible Teach Us About Race Relations? (Final)
The Prophetic Voice - What Can the Bible Teach Us About Race Relations? (Final)
Arthur Satterwhite
 
Christian Freedom Society
Christian Freedom SocietyChristian Freedom Society
Christian Freedom Society
William Turpin
 
A divine revelation of spiritual warfare Mary K Baxter
A divine revelation of spiritual warfare Mary K BaxterA divine revelation of spiritual warfare Mary K Baxter
A divine revelation of spiritual warfare Mary K Baxter
Katuri Susmitha
 
Develop your love for humanity and no wa1.docx
Develop your love for humanity and no wa1.docxDevelop your love for humanity and no wa1.docx
Develop your love for humanity and no wa1.docx
DEEPAK SHARMA SHARMA
 
The Art Of Spiritual Warfare by Dr. Stephen Phinney
The Art Of Spiritual Warfare by Dr. Stephen PhinneyThe Art Of Spiritual Warfare by Dr. Stephen Phinney
The Art Of Spiritual Warfare by Dr. Stephen Phinney
IOM AMERICA (Institute of Ministry)
 
Tips To Writing A College Admissions Essay Total
Tips To Writing A College Admissions Essay  TotalTips To Writing A College Admissions Essay  Total
Tips To Writing A College Admissions Essay Total
Carmen Martin
 
Terrorism and Nonviolence by Arun Gandhi
Terrorism and Nonviolence by Arun GandhiTerrorism and Nonviolence by Arun Gandhi
Terrorism and Nonviolence by Arun Gandhi
Gandhi Legacy Tour
 
Honor
HonorHonor
Train 2
Train 2Train 2
Train 2
hlilibrary
 
Persuasive Sample Essay
Persuasive Sample EssayPersuasive Sample Essay
Persuasive Sample Essay
Jennifer Moser
 
REL101(WI) World ReligionsReflection Paper #2The Problem of.docx
REL101(WI) World ReligionsReflection Paper #2The Problem of.docxREL101(WI) World ReligionsReflection Paper #2The Problem of.docx
REL101(WI) World ReligionsReflection Paper #2The Problem of.docx
carlt3
 
Hate Crime Essays.pdf
Hate Crime Essays.pdfHate Crime Essays.pdf
Hate Crime Essays.pdf
Vivian Lavender
 
Activated: Why suffering?
Activated: Why suffering?Activated: Why suffering?
Activated: Why suffering?
Spiritualibrary
 

Similar to Session 2 september 30, 2012 (20)

Violence in the_media
Violence in the_mediaViolence in the_media
Violence in the_media
 
You Can Change Your World
You Can Change Your WorldYou Can Change Your World
You Can Change Your World
 
Peace Education in the Philippines
Peace Education in the  PhilippinesPeace Education in the  Philippines
Peace Education in the Philippines
 
Peace Education in the Philippines
Peace Education in the  PhilippinesPeace Education in the  Philippines
Peace Education in the Philippines
 
081019 Remember These Things
081019   Remember These Things081019   Remember These Things
081019 Remember These Things
 
Balanced and biblical christian journalism
Balanced and biblical christian journalismBalanced and biblical christian journalism
Balanced and biblical christian journalism
 
Abortion Essay Against
Abortion Essay AgainstAbortion Essay Against
Abortion Essay Against
 
The Prophetic Voice - What Can the Bible Teach Us About Race Relations? (Final)
The Prophetic Voice - What Can the Bible Teach Us About Race Relations? (Final)The Prophetic Voice - What Can the Bible Teach Us About Race Relations? (Final)
The Prophetic Voice - What Can the Bible Teach Us About Race Relations? (Final)
 
Christian Freedom Society
Christian Freedom SocietyChristian Freedom Society
Christian Freedom Society
 
A divine revelation of spiritual warfare Mary K Baxter
A divine revelation of spiritual warfare Mary K BaxterA divine revelation of spiritual warfare Mary K Baxter
A divine revelation of spiritual warfare Mary K Baxter
 
Develop your love for humanity and no wa1.docx
Develop your love for humanity and no wa1.docxDevelop your love for humanity and no wa1.docx
Develop your love for humanity and no wa1.docx
 
The Art Of Spiritual Warfare by Dr. Stephen Phinney
The Art Of Spiritual Warfare by Dr. Stephen PhinneyThe Art Of Spiritual Warfare by Dr. Stephen Phinney
The Art Of Spiritual Warfare by Dr. Stephen Phinney
 
Tips To Writing A College Admissions Essay Total
Tips To Writing A College Admissions Essay  TotalTips To Writing A College Admissions Essay  Total
Tips To Writing A College Admissions Essay Total
 
Terrorism and Nonviolence by Arun Gandhi
Terrorism and Nonviolence by Arun GandhiTerrorism and Nonviolence by Arun Gandhi
Terrorism and Nonviolence by Arun Gandhi
 
Honor
HonorHonor
Honor
 
Train 2
Train 2Train 2
Train 2
 
Persuasive Sample Essay
Persuasive Sample EssayPersuasive Sample Essay
Persuasive Sample Essay
 
REL101(WI) World ReligionsReflection Paper #2The Problem of.docx
REL101(WI) World ReligionsReflection Paper #2The Problem of.docxREL101(WI) World ReligionsReflection Paper #2The Problem of.docx
REL101(WI) World ReligionsReflection Paper #2The Problem of.docx
 
Hate Crime Essays.pdf
Hate Crime Essays.pdfHate Crime Essays.pdf
Hate Crime Essays.pdf
 
Activated: Why suffering?
Activated: Why suffering?Activated: Why suffering?
Activated: Why suffering?
 

Session 2 september 30, 2012

  • 1. Total Catechesis Who gets to choose? How can war be justified?
  • 3. O my God, teach my heart where and how to seek You, where and how to find You. You are my God and You are my all and I have never seen You. You have made me and remade me, You have bestowed on me all the good things I possess, Still I do not know You. I have not yet done that for which I was made. Teach me to seek You. I cannot seek You unless You teach me or find You unless You show Yourself to me. Let me seek You in my desire, let me desire You in my seeking. Let me find You by loving You, let me love You when I find You. Amen
  • 4. Tonight you will... examine your beliefs about the death penalty and the reasons why you hold your beliefs understand what the Catholic Church teaches about the death penalty and other life issues under the consistent ethic of life. reexamine your own belief about life issues in light of what the Church teaches and will choose your own action to promote life.
  • 5. DEATH PENALTY - YES OR NO A cult leader sends his followers to the home of a woman who is eight months pregnant. He has ordered the cult members to kill her and everyone else in the home, which they do. He shows no remorse, but he did not actually commit the murders himself.
  • 6. DEATH PENALTY - YES OR NO A man trains terrorists and sends them on suicide attacks that kill thousands of innocent people in an “enemy” country.
  • 7. DEATH PENALTY - YES OR NO A thief is caught by police in the act of robbing a convenience store. The thief grabs his gun and kills a female police officer, who is the mother of two small children.
  • 8. DEATH PENALTY - YES OR NO A mentally challenged 18 year old kills a woman who caught him robbing her home.
  • 9. DEATH PENALTY - YES OR NO A father kills a drug dealer who sold crack to his 13 year old son.
  • 10. DEATH PENALTY - YES OR NO A woman participates in a very vicious murder, committed with an ax, but admits her crime and professes repentence, asking forgiveness of God and the victim’s family.
  • 11. DEATH PENALTY - YES OR NO A pedofile kidnaps, rapes, and then murders a 10 year old girl.
  • 12. DEATH PENALTY - YES OR NO Two brothers, ages 12 and 14, beat their father to death with a baseball bat. He had abused them physically and emotionally for many years.
  • 13. Analyzing the “why” THINK: Work independently on “Who Deserves the Death Penalty” PAIR: Share the significant influences on your decisions SHARE: Share some comments with the whole group
  • 14. What do the man on death row and the newborn baby have in common?
  • 15. What do an unborn baby and a terminally ill person have in common?
  • 16. What do a person dying painfully and a Jew in Nazi Germany have in common?
  • 17. What do a Jewish person in Nazi Germany and an innocent civilian who died from a bomb dropped on her village have in common?
  • 18. Write these down The Church’s postion Every human life is sacred because we are all created in the image and likeness of God. Because we are made in God’s image, we all have a dignity and a worth that can never be taken away.
  • 19. The Church’s postion We are responsible for protecting the dignity of all, even people who have killed someone else.
  • 20. The Church’s postion Executing someone for a crime is an extremem measure that should happen only when absolutely necessary. Given today’s prison system, such a situation is rare, if not nonexistant. John Paul II, The Gospel of Life
  • 21. The Church’s postion Being pro-life means defending the dignity of all human life from unborn babies to people at the end of their life. Dignity is not based on what we deserve or don’t deserve. Based on one fact; all of us are created God’s image This position is called a “consistent ethic of life”
  • 23. Write 2 or 3 sentences that tell something new you are thinking about after hearing about the Church’s position on life issue. Which parts of the Church’s postion seem right to you? Are there any ideas in the Church’s position that you feel at odds with or don’t really understand?
  • 24. Learning Objectives Just War You will come to appreciate God’s vision of peace and the very real challenges involved in making that vision a reality in the world You will be able to articulate the criteria used by the Church for judging a war to be just You will be equipped to apply the principles of a just war to current and potential international conflict in the world.
  • 25. Is the use of force justified? You are the democratically elected president of a small country in the Middle East. Unlike many of its neighbors, your country has been politically and economically stable for decades.Your economic stability rests on tourism and rug weaving. Taken together, they provide your people with a simple but adequate life. The quality of your rugs is known and appreciated internationally. Now the country immediately to the east is threatening your economic security. Its weavers have copied your rug patterns and technology and are turning out good-looking imitations at half the price.You know that your political party will go under if the economy declines—and everyone in the country will suffer. Moved by rug rage, you declare war on your eastern enemy.
  • 26. Is war justified? The border situation between your country and a neighboring country to the north is a powder keg waiting to explode.Your country is rich in natural resources and controls the flow of water between the two nations. The drought of the past few years has left people in need on both sides of the border, but with fewer resources, your southern neighbor is clearly in more trouble than your country. Smugglers and illegal immigrants are destroying the fences along the border, evading the patrols, and making the surrounding area a scary place to live. In retaliation you have sent patrols across the border, trying to stem the illegal flow of immigrants into your country. There have been deaths and tragedies on both sides. Both countries are hurting, and neither is a clear winner in this conflict.You believe that things will only get worse in the future, so you declare war.
  • 27. Is war justified You are the leader of your country’s armed forces.Your latest elected president is incapable of making decisions and is ignorant of the severe problems your country faces.You (and most military professionals) think action needs to be taken immediately to halt the flurry of terrorist attacks in your land. Fearing for your country’s survival, you mobilize your forces and declare war on the terrorists.You will worry about the consequences after you have beaten your enemy and declared victory.
  • 28. Is war justified? Two of your neighbors to the west are at war. So far, you have stayed neutral, but you are thinking of joining forces with one to conquer the other.Your country’s population is expanding rapidly and will run out of living space soon. War will give you the opportunity to annex part of the loser’s land, giving future generations a bit of breathing space. Without major loss of life or resources, you could end up the big winner in this war and help bring the conflict to a speedy close.
  • 29. Is war justified? The neighboring country to your north is large and has been preparing for war for several years.Your army is outnumbered five to one, but your people are courageous and proud. When the war starts—and it is certain to come soon—you will encourage them to fight with all their strength rather than surrender to the forces sent their way. Being attacked is reason enough to fight to the death.
  • 30. Is war justified? Your country has a long history of hatred with a neighboring country. Tension and intolerance increase every day. When war starts again, you know it will escalate quickly.Your country’s shaky infrastructure (transportation and communication systems, health care and educational institutions) will be set back many years, and the environmental damage could take generations to repair. Damage to the enemy country, however, will be even worse. War is never pretty. People will suffer, but with your enemy soundly beaten, the violence should end for good.
  • 31. Is war justified? When the tensions first flared, it looked like your country and the country with which you are in conflict could talk together and work out the problems. But now you know you cannot trust a thing they say. The other countries in your region have offered to intervene, but you figure that would just give your enemy time to strengthen defenses.You see little chance of resolving the conflict peacefully, so you decide, as the nation’s leader, to initiate war while you still have a chance of getting the upper hand.
  • 32. Points on Church teaching about war We believe in a God of peace who reconciled the world through His son Jesus Christ We are called to live in peace, to prepare the world for God’s reign of justice, love and peace. Working for peace means defending human rights and promoting good for all freeing people from poverty looking on all people as the members of one family working together to bring about justice and peace for all
  • 33. Points on Church teaching about war Conflict is inevitable in a sinful world. Church gives two ways to deal with conflict Non-violence: dialogue, negotiations, peaceful protest, stikes, civil disobedience, civilian resistance Just War: strongly inclined against the use of force, certain conditions must be true
  • 34. Just war Just cause Comparative Injustice Legitimate Authority Right Intention Probablility of Success Proportionality Last Resort
  • 36. Regulating Force During Conflict Noncombatant Immunity Proportionality Right Intention