Data Usage through Trust Platform and
Privacy by Design
Sampo Kellomäki (sampo@synergetics.be)

Privacy, Identity, and Security Seminar
20. September 2012, Almere


03 September 20, 2012
Privacy and Trust as Enablers of Data Use
• End users, patients, have to be considered as stake holders
• Their fears must be addressed for wider data use to be accepted
  - Privacy concerns (Dutch public has high awareness)
  - There can not be trustworthiness and privacy without security
• Proper job in addressing these in the end saves
  - No scandals to manage
  - No clean up costs from breaches
  - No backlash from half hearted approach
• More equitable society and empowerment of the citizen




           c 2012   Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design   2
Privacy, Trust, and Security: Generic Enablers
• Absolutely needed in health care
• Mostly needed in employability and many other areas
• If not needed, at least appreciated in consumer market as well
Ergo
• Common privacy, trust, and security architecture: TAS3
   - Slightly over engineered so it meets requirements of all areas
     –> No need for separate sector specific architectures
   - Share development cost and pool expertise
   - Allow different sectors eventually to link to a unified whole




           c 2012   Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design   3
3
TAS Is for Ecosystems




       c 2012   Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design   4
3
What TAS Is
• Horizontal solution
• Wire-interoperable Single Sign-On and Secure Web Services
• Mandatory authorization and base policies (to guarantee mini-
  mum level - you get to add your own on top of this)
• Mandatory, partially automated, audit to provide accountability
• Governance model, partner vetting, and connection of technol-
  ogy to contract and legal framework
and Is Not
• Your business application and business content stay the same
• Every sector (e.g. health care, employment) still needs to stan-
  dardize on the payload carried over TAS3



           c 2012   Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design   5
3
TAS : Research to Real Life
• European Commission FP7 Research Project 2008-2011: 10M euro
• Synergetics productized TAS3, enabling realistic trust networks
  - Production quality software
  - Resiliency and High Availability solutions
  - Scalability
  - Cloud proof
• Synergetics has legacy integration solution for TAS3
• Synergetics is expanding TAS3 beyond, towards new ecosystem
  needs - end2end Trust Assurance
• Develop Business Case why ecosystems should adopt TAS3




          c 2012   Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design   6
3
TAS Overview
• Privacy preserving
  - Pair-wise pseudonyms (avoid correlation)
  - Minimal disclosure (data pull model)
  - Technically feasible "right to be forgotten" (subscribe to delete)
• Secure Single Sign-On and Web Services
• Authorization framework
  - Organizational and framework policies
  - Personal sticky policies that go with the data
• Audit - ensure accountability
• User inclusion in authorization and audit
• Trustworthy: TAS3 lives up to the promise through technical and
  audit safeguards so you do not have to trust it blindly
  - Trust is good, control is better

           c 2012   Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design   7
c 2012   Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design   8
c 2012   Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design   9
c 2012   Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design   10
c 2012   Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design   11
Personal Data Store: Give Data Back to the User
• Build on TAS3 and take it to the next level
• New user centric paradigm for data use
• Data is kept in PDS under user control, not in silo systems
  - User gains more equitable position in ecosystem as she controls
    her data and is in position to release it under policies and for
    purposes she chooses
• Not just data but the added value services around it
  - Dataless service, running entirely off PDS becomes possible
  - All users of an ecosystem are potential customers without reg-
    istration
  - Gain business insight to population that can not be gleaned
    from traditional user database
• PDS is gaining momentum worldwide
  - TAS3 based PDS to become interoperable across Europe and US
           c 2012   Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design   12
c 2012   Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design   13
Network              "Who asks"   Persona                                               PDS v04 SK 20100909

Accessible              Filter    Selector
                                                            Metadata    Pointers        Actual data
Interfaces            (4pt PEP)    Filter
                                                                                      (original format)

   CRUD
   Interface                       ?


   RESTful                                          Data
   Interface
                                                    by me

   Trust
   Negotiat
   Audit Dri                                        Data
                                                    about
  Search
  and ISN
  Interface
                                                    me



                      Personal
Query and                              Personal
                      PDP
ISN Cache                              Consent,
                                       Policy and
                                       Obligation
                                       Store




            c 2012        Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design                  14
Appropriate for Healthcare
• Strong foundation
  - Everything encrypted approach
  - Authorization and audit trail
  - Privacy preservation
• Break-the-glass scenario (emergancy room) handled correctly
• Healthcare Ecosystem
  - Hospitals
  - Private clinics and Labs
  - Research insititutes and Universities
  - Pharmaceuticals
  - Insurance
• PDS hosts the Personal Health Records
• Analytics and data mining across anonymized populations com-
  bining data from the PDSes
          c 2012   Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design   15
Appropriate for Employability and Learning
• Strong foundation with pseudonymity
  - Avoid discrimination: choose candidate objectively
• Delegation handled correctly - Coaching
• Employability Ecosystem
  - Employers and HR
  - Educational institutes and life long learning
  - Matching and Evaluation services
  - Coaching
• PDS holds user’s ePortfolio (kind of electronic résumé)
  - PDS stays with the user from job-to-job
• Analytics and data mining across anonymized populations
  - Compare yourself to others
  - Matching of job offers to applicants
  - Skills capital at enterprise, regional, and national level
           c 2012   Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design   16
Appropriate for Many Other Sectors
• Horizontal solution
• Strong, standardized foundation is helpful in most places
• Many sectors in fact have natural ecosystems
   - An enterprise and its subcontractors form an ecosystem
     - Even the departments inside an enterprise are an ecosystem
     - Use same technology for intranet and extranet
   - Supply chain
   - Food traceability and security
• Privacy features designed to protect personal data can also pro-
  tect enterprise data
   - Share sensitive data without competitors getting insight to your
     business
• Ecosystems from different sectors will eventually touch each other
  and user can use all of them in a seamless way.
           c 2012   Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design   17
Appropriate Even For Personal Use
• You can use PDS for storing any data you choose, even data for
  sharing with family and friends
  - Data vault: confidence that the data is safe (not lost and with
    appropriate controls)
  - The access control mechanics that may be familiar from personal
    health record or ePortfolio will carry over: no need to learn sep-
    arate system
  - Much stronger privacy and security than Facebook
• Delegation and invitations facilitate sharing




           c 2012   Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design   18
Thank You!
Sampo Kellomäki (sampo@synergetics.be)
+351-918.731.007
skype chat: sampo.kellomaki




          c 2012   Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design   19

Sampo Kellomäki (Synergetics) @ PIDS seminar

  • 1.
    Data Usage throughTrust Platform and Privacy by Design Sampo Kellomäki (sampo@synergetics.be) Privacy, Identity, and Security Seminar 20. September 2012, Almere 03 September 20, 2012
  • 2.
    Privacy and Trustas Enablers of Data Use • End users, patients, have to be considered as stake holders • Their fears must be addressed for wider data use to be accepted - Privacy concerns (Dutch public has high awareness) - There can not be trustworthiness and privacy without security • Proper job in addressing these in the end saves - No scandals to manage - No clean up costs from breaches - No backlash from half hearted approach • More equitable society and empowerment of the citizen c 2012 Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design 2
  • 3.
    Privacy, Trust, andSecurity: Generic Enablers • Absolutely needed in health care • Mostly needed in employability and many other areas • If not needed, at least appreciated in consumer market as well Ergo • Common privacy, trust, and security architecture: TAS3 - Slightly over engineered so it meets requirements of all areas –> No need for separate sector specific architectures - Share development cost and pool expertise - Allow different sectors eventually to link to a unified whole c 2012 Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design 3
  • 4.
    3 TAS Is forEcosystems c 2012 Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design 4
  • 5.
    3 What TAS Is •Horizontal solution • Wire-interoperable Single Sign-On and Secure Web Services • Mandatory authorization and base policies (to guarantee mini- mum level - you get to add your own on top of this) • Mandatory, partially automated, audit to provide accountability • Governance model, partner vetting, and connection of technol- ogy to contract and legal framework and Is Not • Your business application and business content stay the same • Every sector (e.g. health care, employment) still needs to stan- dardize on the payload carried over TAS3 c 2012 Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design 5
  • 6.
    3 TAS : Researchto Real Life • European Commission FP7 Research Project 2008-2011: 10M euro • Synergetics productized TAS3, enabling realistic trust networks - Production quality software - Resiliency and High Availability solutions - Scalability - Cloud proof • Synergetics has legacy integration solution for TAS3 • Synergetics is expanding TAS3 beyond, towards new ecosystem needs - end2end Trust Assurance • Develop Business Case why ecosystems should adopt TAS3 c 2012 Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design 6
  • 7.
    3 TAS Overview • Privacypreserving - Pair-wise pseudonyms (avoid correlation) - Minimal disclosure (data pull model) - Technically feasible "right to be forgotten" (subscribe to delete) • Secure Single Sign-On and Web Services • Authorization framework - Organizational and framework policies - Personal sticky policies that go with the data • Audit - ensure accountability • User inclusion in authorization and audit • Trustworthy: TAS3 lives up to the promise through technical and audit safeguards so you do not have to trust it blindly - Trust is good, control is better c 2012 Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design 7
  • 8.
    c 2012 Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design 8
  • 9.
    c 2012 Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design 9
  • 10.
    c 2012 Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design 10
  • 11.
    c 2012 Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design 11
  • 12.
    Personal Data Store:Give Data Back to the User • Build on TAS3 and take it to the next level • New user centric paradigm for data use • Data is kept in PDS under user control, not in silo systems - User gains more equitable position in ecosystem as she controls her data and is in position to release it under policies and for purposes she chooses • Not just data but the added value services around it - Dataless service, running entirely off PDS becomes possible - All users of an ecosystem are potential customers without reg- istration - Gain business insight to population that can not be gleaned from traditional user database • PDS is gaining momentum worldwide - TAS3 based PDS to become interoperable across Europe and US c 2012 Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design 12
  • 13.
    c 2012 Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design 13
  • 14.
    Network "Who asks" Persona PDS v04 SK 20100909 Accessible Filter Selector Metadata Pointers Actual data Interfaces (4pt PEP) Filter (original format) CRUD Interface ? RESTful Data Interface by me Trust Negotiat Audit Dri Data about Search and ISN Interface me Personal Query and Personal PDP ISN Cache Consent, Policy and Obligation Store c 2012 Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design 14
  • 15.
    Appropriate for Healthcare •Strong foundation - Everything encrypted approach - Authorization and audit trail - Privacy preservation • Break-the-glass scenario (emergancy room) handled correctly • Healthcare Ecosystem - Hospitals - Private clinics and Labs - Research insititutes and Universities - Pharmaceuticals - Insurance • PDS hosts the Personal Health Records • Analytics and data mining across anonymized populations com- bining data from the PDSes c 2012 Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design 15
  • 16.
    Appropriate for Employabilityand Learning • Strong foundation with pseudonymity - Avoid discrimination: choose candidate objectively • Delegation handled correctly - Coaching • Employability Ecosystem - Employers and HR - Educational institutes and life long learning - Matching and Evaluation services - Coaching • PDS holds user’s ePortfolio (kind of electronic résumé) - PDS stays with the user from job-to-job • Analytics and data mining across anonymized populations - Compare yourself to others - Matching of job offers to applicants - Skills capital at enterprise, regional, and national level c 2012 Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design 16
  • 17.
    Appropriate for ManyOther Sectors • Horizontal solution • Strong, standardized foundation is helpful in most places • Many sectors in fact have natural ecosystems - An enterprise and its subcontractors form an ecosystem - Even the departments inside an enterprise are an ecosystem - Use same technology for intranet and extranet - Supply chain - Food traceability and security • Privacy features designed to protect personal data can also pro- tect enterprise data - Share sensitive data without competitors getting insight to your business • Ecosystems from different sectors will eventually touch each other and user can use all of them in a seamless way. c 2012 Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design 17
  • 18.
    Appropriate Even ForPersonal Use • You can use PDS for storing any data you choose, even data for sharing with family and friends - Data vault: confidence that the data is safe (not lost and with appropriate controls) - The access control mechanics that may be familiar from personal health record or ePortfolio will carry over: no need to learn sep- arate system - Much stronger privacy and security than Facebook • Delegation and invitations facilitate sharing c 2012 Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design 18
  • 19.
    Thank You! Sampo Kellomäki(sampo@synergetics.be) +351-918.731.007 skype chat: sampo.kellomaki c 2012 Sampo Kellomäki: Data Usage - Trust Platform and Privacy by Design 19