HIMSS ASIAPAC12 CONFERENCE
       17-19 SEPTEMBER 2012
    MARINA BAY SANDS, SINGAPORE
S&I-7
              SAIFUL HIDAYAT
                INDONESIA MOH EHR
                  OPPORTUNITIES
            CHALLENGES AND EXPERIENCES




9/25/2012      ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society   2
Agenda
•   Telkom Group Business Portfolio
•   Indonesia Healthcare Current Landscape & Implication
•   Telkom HIE-EHR Implementation and Plan
•   The challenges that must be addressed
•   Key lessons learnt




9/25/2012           ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society   3
TELKOM’s Highlight
Telkom is the largest telecommunication company and                                               TELKOM is listed at
network provider in Indonesia, majority owned by the                                      Indonesia Stock Exchange (IDX),
Government of Indonesia                                                                  New York Stock Exchange (NYSE),
(Total shares = 20,159,999,280, including 1 Dwiwarna share series A)                     London Stock Exchange (LSE) and
                                                                                            also Publicly Offering Without
                                                                                            Listing (POWL) at Tokyo Stock
 as of January 2nd , 2012
                                                                                                    Exchange (TSE)
                    Government
                                                            53.24%
                                              10,320,470,712 shares
                    Public
                                                            46.76%
                                               9,065,868,068 shares
                    Treasury Stock

                                                 773,659,960 shares

 Market cap USD 16.09 Billion or + 4.2% of total
 market cap. at IDX Indonesia

 9/25/2012                         ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society                          4
Telkom Business Portfolio - TIMES
                PERSONAL     CONSUMER/HOME                        SME                        LARGE ENTERPRISE
services




                                                  Wholesale

                                               International

Telecommunication                Information                                       Media & Edutainment
POTS                             Premise Integration Services                      Media
FWA                              VA, Managed App & Performance/ITO                 Online Business
Mobile / Cellular                E-Payment
International Services           ITeS (BPO, KPO, e-health)
Fixed Broadband

Network Services

Tower




 9/25/2012                 ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society                          5
Agenda
•   Telkom Group Business Portfolio
•   Indonesia Healthcare Current Landscape & Implication
•   Telkom HIE-EHR Implementation and Plan
•   The challenges that must be addressed
•   Key lessons learnt




9/25/2012          ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society   6
An Illustrative Healthcare Ecosystem
It is complex & often fragmented; eHealth provides benefits to all stakeholders in
        Indonesia through improved communication and information sharing
                                                                                                                                                          Diagnostic
                                                                                                                                                           Services
                                                                                                    Clinic/                      Hospitals                (Lab, Rad)
                                                                        GP                                                      (Inpatient,
                                                                                                   Specialist
                                                                                                                                Outpatient,
                                                                                                                                   ED)
                                                  Pharmacy          • Wide EMR penetration                           • CPOE and EMR
                        Employer                   Benefit          • Automated ref errals                           • Ref erral                             Pharmaceuticals
                                                  Managers          • Automated coding and                           • Remote health
                                                                      claim submission                                 monitoring
                                                                                                                     • Automated coding &
                                        Private                                             Health                     claims submission         CRO
                                       Insurers                                          Information
               • Members                                                                  Exchange
                 database
                 maintenance                                                                                                                                     Suppliers
                                          State Owned                                                                        Pharmacies
               • Automated
                 eligibility/ claims      Insurer (e.g.
                 processing                 ASKES)                               Patient/
               • Claims rating                                                  Consumers
               • Ef f ective case/                                                                                                       Mobile Clinic/
                 disease                                                                                                                  Home Care
                 management                           MOH
               • Medical records                                                          •   Portable PHR
                 storage                                                                  •   Personalized Portals
                                                                                                                                 Other
                                                                                          •   Patient Education
                                                                                                                              Healthcare
                                                                                          •   Remote health
Legend:                                     Regulatory                                        monitoring
                                                                                                                             (e.g. Dental)             Staking share in key
   : Private                                 Agencies                                                                                                  components of the
   : Public                                                                  Province/                                                                 eHealth ecosystem is
                                                                                                      Nursing Care
                           • Population health database                       District                                                                 important to ensure
   : Public & private      • Disease detection & analysis                     Health                                                                   growth & viability
                           • Pharmaceutical supply chain optimization         Offices

   9/25/2012                                           ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society                                                             7
eHealthcare Trend
                             Improving Stakeholders Interactions and Benefits




                                    Ensure Quality of MOH and Patient Safety
                                                      Care




Source : Deloitte Analysis
Indonesia eHealthcare Trend




Source: Telkom & SKT 2010
Indonesia Macroeconomic Outlook
                            Increase Healthcare Spend in Indonesia
 •   The Indonesian government is encouraging foreign investment in the provider sector to offset
     health care funding shortages
 •   Government is planning to increase health care spending from 2.8% to 5% of the gov. budget
 •   ASEAN Free Trade Area (AFTA).
 •   Analysis project 11 percent growth in personal disposable income through 2014 will drive
     higher individual health care spending in the country
                                                           Health Care Expenditure

                                        Indonesian GDP and health care expenditure(a)(b)
                                      (GDP, healthcare spending, USD, %, Indonesia, 2000 -
                                                             2015)
                                            1,400                                            1,297     3.0




                                                                                                              Portion of GDP (%)
                                            1,200                                                      2.5
                                  USD (B)




                                            1,000
                                                                                                       2.0
                                             800                                    707
                                                                                                       1.5
                                             600
                                                                                                       1.0
                                             400                       286
                                                           165                                         0.5
                                             200                                          36.3
                                                     3.3         8.0         19.8
                                               0                                                       0.0
                                                     2000        2005         2010          2015

Source: Deloitte Analysis                       Healthcare expenditure        Total GDP            % of GDP

 9/25/2012                        ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society                                      10
Indonesia Healthcare Outlook
                                             Demand Exceeds the Supply
        Demand                                                                  Supply
        • Factors such as improving macro economic                              • Limited players in the market that target the
          conditions, incl PPI                                                    affluent and middle-up segment
                                                                                • Currently, the ratio of hospital beds per
        • Compelling epidemiology, Indonesian life
                                                                                  100,000 population in Indonesia is 60 beds
          expectancy: 74 / 69 years (m/f) with CAGR              Unmet            per 100,000 population — eighth lowest in the
          of 0.5%; 70% chronic diseases are life style           Need             world
          related; 30-50% of everyone over 40 will
                                                                                • Shortage of healthcare professionals and
          have at least 1 chronic disease; represents
                                                                                  quality care facilities in Indonesia; Doctor to
          80% of health care cost
                                                                                  patient ratio 1:7700 vs.1:390 in USA vs.
                                                                                  1:1700 average in developing countries e.g.
                                                                                  India, Malaysia, etc.

       ‘Universal Coverage’ by 2014 will change dynamics
        With provision of insurance coverage for the
        general public under the ‘Universal Coverage’ 2014                              Public Care Providers
        Scheme, the population segment that currently
        does not have access to cardiac care or is not
        aware of the disease condition (lack of
        diagnosis), will flood public healthcare facilities

                                                                                                        Increased pressure on public
                       Medical Tourism                                                                  care facilities will further
                                                                                                        increase demand for private
                                                                                                        care
                                                              Indonesia’s demand for
                                                                   cardiac care
                                                                                             Post-2014
                                         Affluent to mid-up
                                              segment                                   150 million people added
                                                                                        to the patient pool
                                      Mid- to lower- strata
Source: Deloitte Analysis              of the population

 9/25/2012                               ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society                                   11
The EHR implementation
                               versus
              invest in core healthcare infrastructure
                  and provisioning to basic care




     Perhaps unique to Indonesia, the EHR implementation costs is
       anticipated to be significant public sector investment that
        competes with raising needs to invest in core healthcare
              infrastructure and provisioning to basic care
                 to more than 200 million Indonesians.

9/25/2012            ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society   12
Indonesia eHealth
Lanscape & Implication
• Partial used of eHealth Solutions:
     •       Silos Implementation
                                                                  2001 plus hospitals              46 private insurers
     •       Non Standard/ Multi Format Data:                          (DG BUK Sep 2012)                 (Bapepam)
               •   Lack of Interoperability
               •   Lack of data consolidation
     •       Lack of communication and data
             sharing
     •       Lack of public information access
• Government plan to have Universal                                 9,005 Puskesmas                21,852 pharmacies
  Health Coverage on Jan 2014                                          (Bankdata Pusdatin)                 (IAI)

     •       Law 24/ 2011 – Executing Agency of Social
             Security (BPJS)
     •       To provide basic healthcare for all
             Indonesian
 Integrated eHealth Shared Service
                                                                         115,155 eGPs              260 pharmaceutical
   Platform is a Must                                                                                   industries
 9/25/2012                           ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society                         13
Telkom Group eHealth Solution
                        Using Telkom’s HIE (Health Information Exchange)
       IT Security                            Internet &                                       TPA &               Personal
                                                                        GOV &
     Infrastructure                             Mobile                                         Private             Health
                                                                        Institutions
                                                                                               Insurance           Web Portal
Provider      Certificate       SEHR         Email &
Directory     Authority                      SMS
                                             Gateway



                      Universal
     PKI Server        Patient
                     Identifier


      Routing &
   Transformation
                       Telkom HIE (Health Information Exchange)                                                   Workflow Services
       Services                     (e-Health Hub)
                                                       Web Service Adapter
                                                                                                                Government
 Healthcare Providers                             Pharmacies             Suppliers             Finance          Insurance &
                                                                                                                SOE’s
Doctors /    Clinics & Laboratories    EMR
Specialist   Hospitals




                                                                                               HIMBARA Link &    ASGARA & 141 SOE’s
             Hisys e-Hospital                       Hisys e-                                   52 other Banks
                                                    Apotik
   TELKOM eHospital (HIS), eclinic, epuskesmas, eGP, eApotek , eSCM, eClaim
 9/25/2012                               ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society                            14
Agenda
•   Telkom Group Business Portfolio
•   Indonesia Healthcare Current Landscape & Implication
•   Telkom HIE-EHR Implementation and Plan
•   The challenges that must be addressed
•   Key lessons learnt




9/25/2012           ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society   15
HIE-EHR Implementation plan & Roadmap
VALUE-ADD                                   Illustrative Purposes
                                                                                                  mHealth
                                                            Enterprise-               Analytics
                                                               Driven

                                                                                              Health
                                                                                              Portal
                                                                     Tele-med   EHR
                                                            eOrder

                                                   eRefer


                                        eProcure

                              eClaims
                                               eRe-
                                              minder
                   eBilling
                                  ePro-                        Consumer-
                                  motion                         driven

                        eShop

 eGP     CIS/HIS

 ePhar
   m
                                                                                                            TIME

         Infrastructure                                Wide Scale                        Innovation
Agenda
•   Telkom Group Business Portfolio
•   Indonesia Healthcare Current Landscape & Implication
•   Telkom eHealth Initiatives and Activities with MOH
•   Telkom HIE-EHR Implementation and Plan
•   The challenges that must be addressed
•   Key lessons learnt




9/25/2012           ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society   17
The challenges
               that must be addressed




9/25/2012   ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society   18
Agenda
•   Telkom Group Business Portfolio
•   Indonesia Healthcare Current Landscape & Implication
•   Telkom eHealth Initiatives and Activities with MOH
•   Telkom HIE-EHR Implementation and Plan
•   The challenges that must be addressed
•   Key lessons learnt




9/25/2012           ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society   19
Key Success Factors
                                                                        Agreement from
                                      People                           Hospital Executive to
  Determine ownership,                                                    provide data
governance, and residency
  of data & information
                                                                                        Consensus on coding
                                                                                      Standard (ICD, SNOMED,
                                                                                         etc.) and Exnchange
                               Successful                                             Protocols (HL7, CDA, CCD,
            Informa
                                HIE-EHR                                Process                   etc.)
              tion
                             Implementation


                                                                        Right Adaptor for
                                                                          complex and
                                     Techno                           heterogenous apps. in
                                      logy                                the hospitals
9/25/2012               ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society                       20
Key Lesson Learnt
•   Self Sustainable systems  Right sustainable business models
•   Economically viable for Telkom and Government
•   Cost effective  We don’t have tons of cash to waste
•   Used proven technology
     R&D vs. time to market
     We don’t take unnecessary risk
     Proven Technology & Processes
     • Example: CCD works – used it, MIMS works – used it
• Involve doctors, pharmacies, health consultants in the team
                  Business Heavy VS Engineering Heavy

                     Its should be business case driven
9/25/2012              ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society   21
THANK YOU




9/25/2012   ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society   22

Saiful Hidayat : HIMSS ASPAC SI07_IndonesiaOpportunitiesChallengesAndExperiences

  • 1.
    HIMSS ASIAPAC12 CONFERENCE 17-19 SEPTEMBER 2012 MARINA BAY SANDS, SINGAPORE
  • 2.
    S&I-7 SAIFUL HIDAYAT INDONESIA MOH EHR OPPORTUNITIES CHALLENGES AND EXPERIENCES 9/25/2012 ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society 2
  • 3.
    Agenda • Telkom Group Business Portfolio • Indonesia Healthcare Current Landscape & Implication • Telkom HIE-EHR Implementation and Plan • The challenges that must be addressed • Key lessons learnt 9/25/2012 ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society 3
  • 4.
    TELKOM’s Highlight Telkom isthe largest telecommunication company and TELKOM is listed at network provider in Indonesia, majority owned by the Indonesia Stock Exchange (IDX), Government of Indonesia New York Stock Exchange (NYSE), (Total shares = 20,159,999,280, including 1 Dwiwarna share series A) London Stock Exchange (LSE) and also Publicly Offering Without Listing (POWL) at Tokyo Stock as of January 2nd , 2012 Exchange (TSE) Government 53.24% 10,320,470,712 shares Public 46.76% 9,065,868,068 shares Treasury Stock 773,659,960 shares Market cap USD 16.09 Billion or + 4.2% of total market cap. at IDX Indonesia 9/25/2012 ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society 4
  • 5.
    Telkom Business Portfolio- TIMES PERSONAL CONSUMER/HOME SME LARGE ENTERPRISE services Wholesale International Telecommunication Information Media & Edutainment POTS Premise Integration Services Media FWA VA, Managed App & Performance/ITO Online Business Mobile / Cellular E-Payment International Services ITeS (BPO, KPO, e-health) Fixed Broadband Network Services Tower 9/25/2012 ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society 5
  • 6.
    Agenda • Telkom Group Business Portfolio • Indonesia Healthcare Current Landscape & Implication • Telkom HIE-EHR Implementation and Plan • The challenges that must be addressed • Key lessons learnt 9/25/2012 ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society 6
  • 7.
    An Illustrative HealthcareEcosystem It is complex & often fragmented; eHealth provides benefits to all stakeholders in Indonesia through improved communication and information sharing Diagnostic Services Clinic/ Hospitals (Lab, Rad) GP (Inpatient, Specialist Outpatient, ED) Pharmacy • Wide EMR penetration • CPOE and EMR Employer Benefit • Automated ref errals • Ref erral Pharmaceuticals Managers • Automated coding and • Remote health claim submission monitoring • Automated coding & Private Health claims submission CRO Insurers Information • Members Exchange database maintenance Suppliers State Owned Pharmacies • Automated eligibility/ claims Insurer (e.g. processing ASKES) Patient/ • Claims rating Consumers • Ef f ective case/ Mobile Clinic/ disease Home Care management MOH • Medical records • Portable PHR storage • Personalized Portals Other • Patient Education Healthcare • Remote health Legend: Regulatory monitoring (e.g. Dental) Staking share in key : Private Agencies components of the : Public Province/ eHealth ecosystem is Nursing Care • Population health database District important to ensure : Public & private • Disease detection & analysis Health growth & viability • Pharmaceutical supply chain optimization Offices 9/25/2012 ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society 7
  • 8.
    eHealthcare Trend Improving Stakeholders Interactions and Benefits Ensure Quality of MOH and Patient Safety Care Source : Deloitte Analysis
  • 9.
  • 10.
    Indonesia Macroeconomic Outlook Increase Healthcare Spend in Indonesia • The Indonesian government is encouraging foreign investment in the provider sector to offset health care funding shortages • Government is planning to increase health care spending from 2.8% to 5% of the gov. budget • ASEAN Free Trade Area (AFTA). • Analysis project 11 percent growth in personal disposable income through 2014 will drive higher individual health care spending in the country Health Care Expenditure Indonesian GDP and health care expenditure(a)(b) (GDP, healthcare spending, USD, %, Indonesia, 2000 - 2015) 1,400 1,297 3.0 Portion of GDP (%) 1,200 2.5 USD (B) 1,000 2.0 800 707 1.5 600 1.0 400 286 165 0.5 200 36.3 3.3 8.0 19.8 0 0.0 2000 2005 2010 2015 Source: Deloitte Analysis Healthcare expenditure Total GDP % of GDP 9/25/2012 ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society 10
  • 11.
    Indonesia Healthcare Outlook Demand Exceeds the Supply Demand Supply • Factors such as improving macro economic • Limited players in the market that target the conditions, incl PPI affluent and middle-up segment • Currently, the ratio of hospital beds per • Compelling epidemiology, Indonesian life 100,000 population in Indonesia is 60 beds expectancy: 74 / 69 years (m/f) with CAGR Unmet per 100,000 population — eighth lowest in the of 0.5%; 70% chronic diseases are life style Need world related; 30-50% of everyone over 40 will • Shortage of healthcare professionals and have at least 1 chronic disease; represents quality care facilities in Indonesia; Doctor to 80% of health care cost patient ratio 1:7700 vs.1:390 in USA vs. 1:1700 average in developing countries e.g. India, Malaysia, etc. ‘Universal Coverage’ by 2014 will change dynamics With provision of insurance coverage for the general public under the ‘Universal Coverage’ 2014 Public Care Providers Scheme, the population segment that currently does not have access to cardiac care or is not aware of the disease condition (lack of diagnosis), will flood public healthcare facilities Increased pressure on public Medical Tourism care facilities will further increase demand for private care Indonesia’s demand for cardiac care Post-2014 Affluent to mid-up segment 150 million people added to the patient pool Mid- to lower- strata Source: Deloitte Analysis of the population 9/25/2012 ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society 11
  • 12.
    The EHR implementation versus invest in core healthcare infrastructure and provisioning to basic care Perhaps unique to Indonesia, the EHR implementation costs is anticipated to be significant public sector investment that competes with raising needs to invest in core healthcare infrastructure and provisioning to basic care to more than 200 million Indonesians. 9/25/2012 ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society 12
  • 13.
    Indonesia eHealth Lanscape &Implication • Partial used of eHealth Solutions: • Silos Implementation 2001 plus hospitals 46 private insurers • Non Standard/ Multi Format Data: (DG BUK Sep 2012) (Bapepam) • Lack of Interoperability • Lack of data consolidation • Lack of communication and data sharing • Lack of public information access • Government plan to have Universal 9,005 Puskesmas 21,852 pharmacies Health Coverage on Jan 2014 (Bankdata Pusdatin) (IAI) • Law 24/ 2011 – Executing Agency of Social Security (BPJS) • To provide basic healthcare for all Indonesian  Integrated eHealth Shared Service 115,155 eGPs 260 pharmaceutical Platform is a Must industries 9/25/2012 ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society 13
  • 14.
    Telkom Group eHealthSolution Using Telkom’s HIE (Health Information Exchange) IT Security Internet & TPA & Personal GOV & Infrastructure Mobile Private Health Institutions Insurance Web Portal Provider Certificate SEHR Email & Directory Authority SMS Gateway Universal PKI Server Patient Identifier Routing & Transformation Telkom HIE (Health Information Exchange) Workflow Services Services (e-Health Hub) Web Service Adapter Government Healthcare Providers Pharmacies Suppliers Finance Insurance & SOE’s Doctors / Clinics & Laboratories EMR Specialist Hospitals HIMBARA Link & ASGARA & 141 SOE’s Hisys e-Hospital Hisys e- 52 other Banks Apotik TELKOM eHospital (HIS), eclinic, epuskesmas, eGP, eApotek , eSCM, eClaim 9/25/2012 ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society 14
  • 15.
    Agenda • Telkom Group Business Portfolio • Indonesia Healthcare Current Landscape & Implication • Telkom HIE-EHR Implementation and Plan • The challenges that must be addressed • Key lessons learnt 9/25/2012 ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society 15
  • 16.
    HIE-EHR Implementation plan& Roadmap VALUE-ADD Illustrative Purposes mHealth Enterprise- Analytics Driven Health Portal Tele-med EHR eOrder eRefer eProcure eClaims eRe- minder eBilling ePro- Consumer- motion driven eShop eGP CIS/HIS ePhar m TIME Infrastructure Wide Scale Innovation
  • 17.
    Agenda • Telkom Group Business Portfolio • Indonesia Healthcare Current Landscape & Implication • Telkom eHealth Initiatives and Activities with MOH • Telkom HIE-EHR Implementation and Plan • The challenges that must be addressed • Key lessons learnt 9/25/2012 ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society 17
  • 18.
    The challenges that must be addressed 9/25/2012 ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society 18
  • 19.
    Agenda • Telkom Group Business Portfolio • Indonesia Healthcare Current Landscape & Implication • Telkom eHealth Initiatives and Activities with MOH • Telkom HIE-EHR Implementation and Plan • The challenges that must be addressed • Key lessons learnt 9/25/2012 ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society 19
  • 20.
    Key Success Factors Agreement from People Hospital Executive to Determine ownership, provide data governance, and residency of data & information Consensus on coding Standard (ICD, SNOMED, etc.) and Exnchange Successful Protocols (HL7, CDA, CCD, Informa HIE-EHR Process etc.) tion Implementation Right Adaptor for complex and Techno heterogenous apps. in logy the hospitals 9/25/2012 ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society 20
  • 21.
    Key Lesson Learnt • Self Sustainable systems  Right sustainable business models • Economically viable for Telkom and Government • Cost effective  We don’t have tons of cash to waste • Used proven technology  R&D vs. time to market  We don’t take unnecessary risk  Proven Technology & Processes • Example: CCD works – used it, MIMS works – used it • Involve doctors, pharmacies, health consultants in the team Business Heavy VS Engineering Heavy Its should be business case driven 9/25/2012 ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society 21
  • 22.
    THANK YOU 9/25/2012 ©2012 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society 22