The petitioner rebuts arguments made by respondents in the PCO Judges case. First, the oath taken by Chief Justice Abdul Hameed Dogar and other judges under PCO 1 of 2007 after the Supreme Court's 2007 decision was invalid. Second, General Musharraf's actions in dismissing the 2007 judicial order and imposing emergency violated the constitution. Third, there were no vacancies when non-de jure Chief Justice Dogar made appointments, as the de jure judges were still holding office. The petitioner also argues the Tikka Iqbal case does not justify increasing judicial positions. Chief Justice Dogar's decision in that case disregarded the original petition and Musharraf's actions were self-serving, not