By
Dr. Swatantra Kumar
Professor
Shri SiddhiVinayaka Institute of Management
 Developed to Developing world
Developed
World
Developing
World
 Developing to Developed world
Developed
World
Developing
World
 Population
 85% of the people (5.8 billion)
live in poor countries
 Total GDP
 In total GDP China is No. 2;
India – No. 4
 Total GDP of poor countries is
roughly $35Trillion (half of
World GDP)
 Projected GDP Growth rates
 China and India (Double as compared to Rich
countries)
 GDP per capita
 US – 6th; China – 94; India - 128
 Point is simple
 In rich countries there are few people who each
spend a lot
 In Developing world there are a lot of people who
each spend a little.
Either way, total spending is vast
 One person with 10 Dollars
 10 persons with 1 Dollar each
It requires innovation
Reverse innovation
 The performance gap
 50% solution at 15% price (StrippingVs. radical
innovation)
 The infrastructure gap
 Opportunity not a constraint (GE Healthcare)
 The sustainability gap
 China air pollution (500 on scale of 1-500) –
Electric Car (BYD)
 The regulatory gap
 High regulationVs. low regulation (Under
regulation at times provides opportunities to
experiment)
 The preferences gap
 Different worlds different preferences (CornVs
Lentils based products – PepsiCo)
Innovators win, exporters loose
Marginalized
market today
Mainstream
market tomorrow
Level one thinking:
poor countries are
irrelevant
Level two thinking:
just sit tight
Level three thinking:
customization is
sufficient
Level four: winning
requires innovation
Level five: the stakes
are global not local
 M&M founded in 1945 as a steelmaker,
entered agriculture market in around 1965
(partnered with international harvester).
 1994 – Mahindra entered US market
 Affordable, fuel efficient tractors
 In US Deere & Co. was the dominant player.
 MUSA avoided competing with Deere. Started
selling the product to hobby farmers,
landscapers, and building contractors
 Machine was reliable, sturdy and priced to sell,
with few modifications such as supersized seats
and larger break pedals.
 It build close relationships with small dealerships,
particularly family-run operations.
 Run on JIT basis. Offering to deliver a tractor within 24-
48 hours.
 Also facilitated financing, made close relationship with
customers (10-15% buyers got calls from its president)
 MUSA sales growth averaged 40% per year, from 1999
to 2006
 Deere got baffled by this and started short term
cash incentives to lure the buyers.
 Mahindra fired back with an ad featuring the
headline “Deere John, I have found someone
new”
 Contrary to that Deere has largely been a failure
in Indian market.
 Consequently M&M became the number-one
tractor maker worldwide, as measured by units
sold.
 Open heart surgery for just $2,000
 US price - $ 20,000
 Despite the ultra-low price, NH hospital’s new
profit margins are slightly higher than USA
 Quality: its mortality rates within 30 days of
bypass surgery is 1.4% as compared to US
average of 1.9%
 The real magic lies in process innovation
 Standardization, specialization of labour,
economies of scale, and assembly line
production (just Like Henry Ford)
 Extensive resource utilization
– expensive equipments are
used five times more as
compared to USA.
 Specialization of doctors in
specific type of surgery.
 Surgeons perform two to
three times more procedures.
 This accelerates learning,
improves skills, and increases
quality.
 Now they are building a large 2000 bed
hospital in the Cayman islands (close to USA)
– an hour’s flight from Miami
 Reverse Innovation
Reverse innovation – what, how & where
Reverse innovation – what, how & where

Reverse innovation – what, how & where

  • 1.
    By Dr. Swatantra Kumar Professor ShriSiddhiVinayaka Institute of Management
  • 2.
     Developed toDeveloping world Developed World Developing World
  • 3.
     Developing toDeveloped world Developed World Developing World
  • 4.
     Population  85%of the people (5.8 billion) live in poor countries  Total GDP  In total GDP China is No. 2; India – No. 4  Total GDP of poor countries is roughly $35Trillion (half of World GDP)
  • 5.
     Projected GDPGrowth rates  China and India (Double as compared to Rich countries)  GDP per capita  US – 6th; China – 94; India - 128  Point is simple  In rich countries there are few people who each spend a lot  In Developing world there are a lot of people who each spend a little. Either way, total spending is vast
  • 6.
     One personwith 10 Dollars  10 persons with 1 Dollar each It requires innovation Reverse innovation
  • 7.
     The performancegap  50% solution at 15% price (StrippingVs. radical innovation)  The infrastructure gap  Opportunity not a constraint (GE Healthcare)  The sustainability gap  China air pollution (500 on scale of 1-500) – Electric Car (BYD)
  • 8.
     The regulatorygap  High regulationVs. low regulation (Under regulation at times provides opportunities to experiment)  The preferences gap  Different worlds different preferences (CornVs Lentils based products – PepsiCo) Innovators win, exporters loose
  • 9.
  • 10.
    Level one thinking: poorcountries are irrelevant Level two thinking: just sit tight Level three thinking: customization is sufficient Level four: winning requires innovation Level five: the stakes are global not local
  • 11.
     M&M foundedin 1945 as a steelmaker, entered agriculture market in around 1965 (partnered with international harvester).  1994 – Mahindra entered US market  Affordable, fuel efficient tractors  In US Deere & Co. was the dominant player.  MUSA avoided competing with Deere. Started selling the product to hobby farmers, landscapers, and building contractors  Machine was reliable, sturdy and priced to sell, with few modifications such as supersized seats and larger break pedals.
  • 12.
     It buildclose relationships with small dealerships, particularly family-run operations.  Run on JIT basis. Offering to deliver a tractor within 24- 48 hours.  Also facilitated financing, made close relationship with customers (10-15% buyers got calls from its president)  MUSA sales growth averaged 40% per year, from 1999 to 2006
  • 13.
     Deere gotbaffled by this and started short term cash incentives to lure the buyers.  Mahindra fired back with an ad featuring the headline “Deere John, I have found someone new”  Contrary to that Deere has largely been a failure in Indian market.  Consequently M&M became the number-one tractor maker worldwide, as measured by units sold.
  • 15.
     Open heartsurgery for just $2,000  US price - $ 20,000  Despite the ultra-low price, NH hospital’s new profit margins are slightly higher than USA  Quality: its mortality rates within 30 days of bypass surgery is 1.4% as compared to US average of 1.9%  The real magic lies in process innovation  Standardization, specialization of labour, economies of scale, and assembly line production (just Like Henry Ford)
  • 16.
     Extensive resourceutilization – expensive equipments are used five times more as compared to USA.  Specialization of doctors in specific type of surgery.  Surgeons perform two to three times more procedures.  This accelerates learning, improves skills, and increases quality.
  • 17.
     Now theyare building a large 2000 bed hospital in the Cayman islands (close to USA) – an hour’s flight from Miami  Reverse Innovation