Retail Food Group (RFG) operates food franchises and company-owned stores in Australia, New Zealand, and Asia. While macroeconomic factors present challenges, RFG has maintained profitability through market share gains using strategic acquisitions and initiatives. Financially, RFG has enjoyed growth since acquiring Esquire Coffee in 2011. However, two major restructuring projects in 2014 may impact results that year. The report recommends holding the stock until the success of these projects is clear.
RFG is a food retailer headquartered in Gold Coast, QLD that operates franchises across Australia and internationally. It has pursued aggressive growth through acquisitions, most recently acquiring Hudson Pacific, which will provide inventory supply to franchises and create a vertical supply chain. The report forecasts RFG's revenue to increase 50% due to Hudson, though increased operating costs are expected to offset profit growth in the near term. The share price is recommended to be a hold.
From the Desk of the CEO.
The heat is on. While many of us have been vacationing in cooler climes, the Sensex has kept itself rather busy, gaining another 4% during the month of May. The upmove has come largely on the back of better-than-expected corporate results and expectations of a good monsoon. Markets are also taking cognisance of various indicators like improved auto sales, higher steel and cement offtake, public infrastructure spending, etc. which are positive signs of an imminent economic recovery.
Crude prices have silently crept up and are currently hovering at the $50 level, almost double from the January lows. So despite the adverse implications of higher crude prices on the Indian economy, there seems to be some positive correlation between crude prices and the equity markets. Though this pattern may not have always played out in the last few decades, the first few months of 2016 certainly seem to indicate so. The main reason for this is the significantly high weightage that the Energy sector has in indices the world over. When oil plummeted to sub-$30 levels, it seriously impacted the profitability of some of the world’s biggest corporations, not only causing their stock prices to fall sharply, but also impacting the broader markets in general. It also indicated a global recessionary trend, thus affecting investor sentiment and causing them to become nervous and risk-averse. The bounce back in crude has brought the price to a level that makes it profitable for companies to drill, creating a sense of well-being for both, the Energy sector as well as the countries whose economies are dependent solely on oil. Where crude prices go from here remains to be seen.
After several quarters of benign inflation, the WPI rose to 0.34% while retail inflation soared to 5.39% in April 2016. This, coupled with higher oil prices would make it difficult for Governor Rajan to announce a rate cut at the next RBI policy meeting on 7th June. Across the globe however, Janet Yellen’s comments on improving economic data in the US has the markets believing that a rate hike by the US Federal Reserve is a high possibility during its next meeting in mid-June. The outcome of Britain’s referendum on Brexit is also an event that we will be closely watching.
With markets factoring in all the good news for now, conventional logic says that short term investors need to be cautious. But when the stock market catches momentum, all negative predictions may be proven wrong.
There are of course, many more bulls than bears when it comes to a 1 year plus view. Long term investors may continue their investments and look to buy into any dips.
Wish all of you a happy monsoon season.
The document provides an overview of domestic and global economic news from May 16-20, 2016. Some key points:
- India's wholesale price index turned positive after 17 months, suggesting rising pricing power and potential inflation pressures.
- Crude oil and natural gas production in India fell in April compared to the previous year.
- The US dollar strengthened against the yen and euro zone business growth was stable but below recent highs.
- China will further reform business registration procedures to reduce costs and support economic restructuring.
- Most Indian indices declined over the week, with Sensex falling 1.37%, while crude oil prices rose slightly and the rupee depreciated against the US dollar.
- The Indian markets rose over the past week to 6-month highs as the Nifty crossed 8000 levels, driven by encouraging corporate results and expectations of a better monsoon.
- Upcoming events like the RBI policy meeting and UK referendum on EU membership could impact markets and currencies globally.
- Domestically, India aims for 7.6% GDP growth in FY17 while remaining a top steel importer globally.
Special report 10 apr 2019 epic researchEpic Research
- Wall Street stocks fell as trade tensions rose between the US and Europe. Asian stocks also declined on lowered global growth outlook from IMF.
- Oil prices rose towards 5-month highs supported by OPEC supply cuts and US sanctions on other producers.
- The report provides stock market commentary and analysis, commodity prices and recommendations, and the day's most active options.
- Yields on bonds have remained at historically low levels for decades, exposing markets to volatility and posing problems for pension funds that rely on stable returns from bonds.
- Pension funds facing low yields may need to increase contributions from workers and governments or invest in riskier assets like equities to meet liabilities. This could have social ramifications.
- Similarly, low yields make it difficult for insurance companies to meet liabilities through low-risk investments, potentially leading to higher premiums.
This document provides an overview and outlook across various sectors in the Indian economy and globally. It begins with a note from the CEO discussing current economic conditions and opportunities from innovation and disruption. Several sections then analyze domestic and global equity markets, debt markets, key economic indicators, and provide outlooks for various sectors in India and globally. The document aims to inform investors on current economic and market conditions.
RFG is a food retailer headquartered in Gold Coast, QLD that operates franchises across Australia and internationally. It has pursued aggressive growth through acquisitions, most recently acquiring Hudson Pacific, which will provide inventory supply to franchises and create a vertical supply chain. The report forecasts RFG's revenue to increase 50% due to Hudson, though increased operating costs are expected to offset profit growth in the near term. The share price is recommended to be a hold.
From the Desk of the CEO.
The heat is on. While many of us have been vacationing in cooler climes, the Sensex has kept itself rather busy, gaining another 4% during the month of May. The upmove has come largely on the back of better-than-expected corporate results and expectations of a good monsoon. Markets are also taking cognisance of various indicators like improved auto sales, higher steel and cement offtake, public infrastructure spending, etc. which are positive signs of an imminent economic recovery.
Crude prices have silently crept up and are currently hovering at the $50 level, almost double from the January lows. So despite the adverse implications of higher crude prices on the Indian economy, there seems to be some positive correlation between crude prices and the equity markets. Though this pattern may not have always played out in the last few decades, the first few months of 2016 certainly seem to indicate so. The main reason for this is the significantly high weightage that the Energy sector has in indices the world over. When oil plummeted to sub-$30 levels, it seriously impacted the profitability of some of the world’s biggest corporations, not only causing their stock prices to fall sharply, but also impacting the broader markets in general. It also indicated a global recessionary trend, thus affecting investor sentiment and causing them to become nervous and risk-averse. The bounce back in crude has brought the price to a level that makes it profitable for companies to drill, creating a sense of well-being for both, the Energy sector as well as the countries whose economies are dependent solely on oil. Where crude prices go from here remains to be seen.
After several quarters of benign inflation, the WPI rose to 0.34% while retail inflation soared to 5.39% in April 2016. This, coupled with higher oil prices would make it difficult for Governor Rajan to announce a rate cut at the next RBI policy meeting on 7th June. Across the globe however, Janet Yellen’s comments on improving economic data in the US has the markets believing that a rate hike by the US Federal Reserve is a high possibility during its next meeting in mid-June. The outcome of Britain’s referendum on Brexit is also an event that we will be closely watching.
With markets factoring in all the good news for now, conventional logic says that short term investors need to be cautious. But when the stock market catches momentum, all negative predictions may be proven wrong.
There are of course, many more bulls than bears when it comes to a 1 year plus view. Long term investors may continue their investments and look to buy into any dips.
Wish all of you a happy monsoon season.
The document provides an overview of domestic and global economic news from May 16-20, 2016. Some key points:
- India's wholesale price index turned positive after 17 months, suggesting rising pricing power and potential inflation pressures.
- Crude oil and natural gas production in India fell in April compared to the previous year.
- The US dollar strengthened against the yen and euro zone business growth was stable but below recent highs.
- China will further reform business registration procedures to reduce costs and support economic restructuring.
- Most Indian indices declined over the week, with Sensex falling 1.37%, while crude oil prices rose slightly and the rupee depreciated against the US dollar.
- The Indian markets rose over the past week to 6-month highs as the Nifty crossed 8000 levels, driven by encouraging corporate results and expectations of a better monsoon.
- Upcoming events like the RBI policy meeting and UK referendum on EU membership could impact markets and currencies globally.
- Domestically, India aims for 7.6% GDP growth in FY17 while remaining a top steel importer globally.
Special report 10 apr 2019 epic researchEpic Research
- Wall Street stocks fell as trade tensions rose between the US and Europe. Asian stocks also declined on lowered global growth outlook from IMF.
- Oil prices rose towards 5-month highs supported by OPEC supply cuts and US sanctions on other producers.
- The report provides stock market commentary and analysis, commodity prices and recommendations, and the day's most active options.
- Yields on bonds have remained at historically low levels for decades, exposing markets to volatility and posing problems for pension funds that rely on stable returns from bonds.
- Pension funds facing low yields may need to increase contributions from workers and governments or invest in riskier assets like equities to meet liabilities. This could have social ramifications.
- Similarly, low yields make it difficult for insurance companies to meet liabilities through low-risk investments, potentially leading to higher premiums.
This document provides an overview and outlook across various sectors in the Indian economy and globally. It begins with a note from the CEO discussing current economic conditions and opportunities from innovation and disruption. Several sections then analyze domestic and global equity markets, debt markets, key economic indicators, and provide outlooks for various sectors in India and globally. The document aims to inform investors on current economic and market conditions.
Introduction of GST in the Rajya Sabha has significance because it could have been passed in the Lok Sabha also. However, Rajya Sabha is where the government does not have majority and since it’s a constitutional amendment that requires two thirds majority, convincing all the parties is a key milestone and to that extent, introduction and subsequent passage of the bill in the Rajya Sabha will be important.
•Earnings Data for 8 core industries including mining, infrastructure and electricity was received which indicated a growth by 5.2% which augers well. However, one needs to see if this is a onetime occurrence or will it continue. Also, since rainfall was moderate, by the end of July, rural consumption is expected to be strong. To that extent, GDP is likely to grow anywhere between 7.5-8% this year. The government’s earlier projections in the budget carry an upward bias.
Dear Investors,
The month of July has seen the heavens literally open their doors and shower their blessings on us. After a late start in June, the monsoon picked up
smartly and the country as a whole received abundant rainfall, bringing cheer to one and all and definitely a sense of relief. The same good cheer
seems to have percolated to the global equity markets as well. Having brushed off the Brexit issue, markets have continued their upward move
relentlessly through the month of July. The US benchmark index, the S&P 500 hit a new lifetime high earlier in the month on the back of good jobs
data and an optimistic view of growth in the US economy. Not wanting to be left out in any way, the Nifty set a new 52-week high and the Sensex
scaled 28,000.
The quarterly results have been a mixed bag so far. While there have been more hits than misses, the IT sector as a whole and some pharma
companies have been the major pockets of underperformance. Most of the private sector retail banks and NBFCs have shown a stellar performance,
while growth in public sector banks was stagnant due to liquidity and NPA issues. In the consumer space, lower costs have added to the profits of
several companies, but revenue growth and volume growth were disappointing. There is hope that these will see a significant pick up in the second
half of the financial year once the benefits of the 7th Pay Commission and a good monsoon kick in.
The markets have been struggling to cross the 8000 level on the Nifty lately. If we consider the previous quarter
individually, the markets have given stellar returns. Most of the indices have given double digit returns, mid cap
index has given around 14% returns. We can observe that the market has given absolute returns in the previous
quarter but is finding it difficult to shape up the further movement.
• Going forward, the market will focus on the upcoming news flows. The non corporate macro data still remains
mixed. The CPI numbers have been reported at 5.4%, higher than expectations, but broadly it remains in the
RBIs comfort zone of 5 - 5.5%. The WPI was reported in the positive territory after 17 Months at 0.7%. The bigger
worry currently is the possible delay in monsoons according to a statement by the IMD. If the delay is only by a
week, there is not much a need for worry for the kharif season. If the monsoon is delayed further, that would
impact the inflation further upwards. This in turn would delay the rate cut expected in the next bi monthly policy
meet.
- The equity markets have seen mixed results so far this quarter, with earnings growth improving after 7 quarters of declines but global economic data showing weakness.
- Steel consumption in India fell to its lowest level since 2015, while the government has taken steps to boost job creation and economic growth such as corporate tax cuts.
- Economic data in Europe, the UK, and China continued to disappoint with declines in growth, exports, and imports, while US job growth slowed in April.
The document provides an overview and outlook on domestic and global financial markets. It discusses the CEO's positive outlook on the Indian equity market rally and fiscal reforms. On the domestic front, it summarizes inflation trends, industrial growth, bond yields, and provides recommendations on debt strategies. Globally, it reviews equity market performance and updates on major economies. The overall document aims to advise investors by analyzing economic and market conditions.
The document provides an overview of global market performance and commodity prices. It discusses declines in the Dow and gains in the S&P 500 and Nasdaq on Monday. Asian shares were subdued on Tuesday as investors braced for key events. Oil prices reached their highest since November due to concerns over Libyan exports. The document also provides stock recommendations and analysis of commodity prices and world food prices.
The document provides a weekly summary of global and domestic economic news and market performance for the week of April 25-29, 2016. Key points include:
- Indian equity markets were mixed as key sectors like automobiles and banks showed selective gains, while the overall markets exhibited signs of exhaustion after strong gains.
- Global markets remained stable as the US Fed did not change interest rates and the Bank of Japan maintained monetary stimulus.
- Domestic manufacturing activity declined to a 4-month low, putting pressure on the RBI to keep rates low. Eurozone factory output grew weakly.
- Chinese economic growth slowed slightly in April as manufacturing expansion was lower than expected, raising doubts about sustained recovery.
Global bond yields are at historical lows which mean global bond prices have rallied across developed markets while S&P 500 is close to its historical high. This by itself is a dichotomy as bond prices and equity prices are not expected to rally together at the same point. Either of the two has to be true.
•Bond prices and yields are inversely related therefore, bond prices rally when yields and interest rates are expected to be low. Interest rates are expected to be low because growth prospects are low. This would entail the central banks to cut rates and because the demand for credits will be low due to the low growth prospects, the yields are expected to be low which explains the rally in bond prices. Considering this, the rally in the equity markets is not possible as there is no expectation for growth. This is the dichotomy that the global world is at particularly in the developed markets. In the light of the current scenario, either of the two has to give in i.e. either bond prices correct leading to normalcy in yields or equity markets give in.
This document provides a weekly summary of economic, market, and other news from August 16-19, 2016. Some key points:
- India's CPI inflation rose above 6% in July, exceeding the central bank's tolerance limit and raising expectations of further rate hikes.
- Global government bond yields increased modestly, with the US 10-year yield rising to 1.6%, while oil prices fell on doubts that upcoming producer talks would reduce oversupply.
- Domestically, strong monsoon rains are expected to boost agricultural growth and the overall economy. Internationally, China's exports declined in 2016 and are projected to fall further due to economic pressures.
The document provides a research report from Krause Fund recommending Alcoa Inc. (NYSE: AA) as a strong buy. It summarizes Alcoa's business operations, current stock performance, financial ratios, and provides an analysis of key economic indicators and how they may impact Alcoa's future performance. The analysts initiate coverage with a buy rating and $18-20 price target due to Alcoa's shift toward more profitable downstream products, potential for market share gains, and expectations that recent restructuring efforts will allow it to execute on goals leading to long term share gains.
The document provides an overview and outlook across various asset classes and sectors in India and globally. Some key points:
- Domestic equity markets have seen modest gains of around 8.5% year-to-date despite recent volatility due to political tensions. Bond yields have fallen in India on expectations of further rate cuts.
- Global central banks like the Fed and ECB appear less accommodative but the US economy remains resilient. Growth has slowed in Japan and parts of Europe.
- Automobiles, banks, FMCG and infrastructure sectors are expected to perform well in India, while cement may see a recovery. Select domestic sectors and stocks still appear attractive relative to other emerging markets.
- The document provides an economic and market summary for the week of November 14-18, 2016. It discusses developments in global markets, the Indian economy and stock market, and provides commentary on sectors and asset classes.
- Key points include the expectation of US Federal rate hikes in December, the impact of India's demonetization on various industries, and an outlook that Indian stock markets will see further declines in the short-term but provide buying opportunities. Debt markets are also seen as favorable due to expected interest rate cuts.
This document provides a weekly summary of global and domestic economic news and market performance for the week of August 8-12, 2016. Some key points:
- India's wholesale and consumer price inflation increased in July driven by higher food prices. Industrial production growth slowed in the Eurozone and China.
- US retail sales were flat in July and the budget deficit declined, while China's economic growth slowed with the weakest investment growth in over 15 years.
- The Indian stock market ended the week slightly lower, with the Sensex falling 0.11%. Most sectoral indices also declined over the week except for banking. Commodity prices were mixed with gold falling slightly while crude oil rose.
The document summarizes recent news and developments in global markets and the Indian economy from October 31 - November 4, 2016. It discusses the impact of the FBI announcement regarding Hillary Clinton's emails on US and global markets. It also covers the upcoming US presidential election and its potential effects. Domestically, it discusses recent inflation data, bank earnings, and the progress of GST implementation in India. Globally, it mentions recent economic data and central bank decisions in the US, UK, Eurozone, and China.
This document provides an overview and outlook across various sectors in India and globally. It discusses domestic and global economic factors, equity and debt market performance, sector-specific views, and other relevant topics. Key points include a positive outlook for domestic consumption sectors due to the festive season, signs of recovery in the Indian manufacturing sector, and expectations that global central banks will continue accommodative monetary policies.
- Last week, global equity markets declined sharply due to one bad trading day that rattled investors who had become complacent about continuously rising prices. However, market corrections of 6-8% are normal and investors should focus on investing in good quality stocks during declines rather than withdrawing.
- Concerns remain about instability in Europe's banking system, uncertainty around US interest rates after the election, and potential for Chinese currency devaluation. Wholesale inflation slowed in India while the government may increase public spending to spur growth.
- Key stock indices declined over the past week with the Sensex falling 1.46% while most sectors also ended lower with metals and power dropping the most.
The document provides an economic and market summary for the week of July 18-22, 2016. Key points include:
- Momentum stocks should be exited and defensive investments pursued as markets may be volatile.
- The IMF lowered India's GDP growth forecast to 7.4% for the current fiscal year.
- Greece relaxed some capital controls as bailout reforms progress and banking confidence returns.
- Central banks will remain cautious on policy moves pending clarity on Brexit's economic impacts.
- Core inflation in India declined to 4.5% in June from 4.7% previously, which may support a 25 basis point rate cut by the RBI in August. Industrial growth also turned positive in April after contracting previously.
- Financial results from companies so far have been better than expected, though IT sector disappointed due to Brexit. Global markets are focused on upcoming earnings season in India.
- The Bank of England is expected to cut rates to a record low of 0.25% to cushion the UK economy from Brexit shock. China's land and wage growth slowed in the first half of 2016 due to overcapacity issues.
The document provides an equity market and economic overview for the week of April 18-22, 2016. Some key points:
- Q4 company results were broadly in line with expectations, and results this season may be similar or slightly higher.
- Banks that received regulatory relief from the RBI on recognizing bad assets saw sharp rallies, but their fundamentals have not changed. Investors should not buy into these banks based on the RBI's leeway.
- Globally, disappointing results from Microsoft and tepid growth from Google do not bode well for markets and may lead to selling pressure. The current market can be viewed as a "buy on decline" scenario.
This document provides a case study on Jollibee Foods Corporation and their consideration of expanding internationally to Papua New Guinea, Hong Kong, and California. It summarizes Jollibee's history and growth in the Philippines since 1975. It also outlines some of the key human resources, operating, financial, and marketing issues Jollibee has faced in previous international expansions. These include strained relationships between domestic and international operations, cultural differences hampering decisions, and management issues at locations like Hong Kong. The document analyzes the fast food industry and Jollibee's position to help inform their choice of international strategy and location.
Introduction of GST in the Rajya Sabha has significance because it could have been passed in the Lok Sabha also. However, Rajya Sabha is where the government does not have majority and since it’s a constitutional amendment that requires two thirds majority, convincing all the parties is a key milestone and to that extent, introduction and subsequent passage of the bill in the Rajya Sabha will be important.
•Earnings Data for 8 core industries including mining, infrastructure and electricity was received which indicated a growth by 5.2% which augers well. However, one needs to see if this is a onetime occurrence or will it continue. Also, since rainfall was moderate, by the end of July, rural consumption is expected to be strong. To that extent, GDP is likely to grow anywhere between 7.5-8% this year. The government’s earlier projections in the budget carry an upward bias.
Dear Investors,
The month of July has seen the heavens literally open their doors and shower their blessings on us. After a late start in June, the monsoon picked up
smartly and the country as a whole received abundant rainfall, bringing cheer to one and all and definitely a sense of relief. The same good cheer
seems to have percolated to the global equity markets as well. Having brushed off the Brexit issue, markets have continued their upward move
relentlessly through the month of July. The US benchmark index, the S&P 500 hit a new lifetime high earlier in the month on the back of good jobs
data and an optimistic view of growth in the US economy. Not wanting to be left out in any way, the Nifty set a new 52-week high and the Sensex
scaled 28,000.
The quarterly results have been a mixed bag so far. While there have been more hits than misses, the IT sector as a whole and some pharma
companies have been the major pockets of underperformance. Most of the private sector retail banks and NBFCs have shown a stellar performance,
while growth in public sector banks was stagnant due to liquidity and NPA issues. In the consumer space, lower costs have added to the profits of
several companies, but revenue growth and volume growth were disappointing. There is hope that these will see a significant pick up in the second
half of the financial year once the benefits of the 7th Pay Commission and a good monsoon kick in.
The markets have been struggling to cross the 8000 level on the Nifty lately. If we consider the previous quarter
individually, the markets have given stellar returns. Most of the indices have given double digit returns, mid cap
index has given around 14% returns. We can observe that the market has given absolute returns in the previous
quarter but is finding it difficult to shape up the further movement.
• Going forward, the market will focus on the upcoming news flows. The non corporate macro data still remains
mixed. The CPI numbers have been reported at 5.4%, higher than expectations, but broadly it remains in the
RBIs comfort zone of 5 - 5.5%. The WPI was reported in the positive territory after 17 Months at 0.7%. The bigger
worry currently is the possible delay in monsoons according to a statement by the IMD. If the delay is only by a
week, there is not much a need for worry for the kharif season. If the monsoon is delayed further, that would
impact the inflation further upwards. This in turn would delay the rate cut expected in the next bi monthly policy
meet.
- The equity markets have seen mixed results so far this quarter, with earnings growth improving after 7 quarters of declines but global economic data showing weakness.
- Steel consumption in India fell to its lowest level since 2015, while the government has taken steps to boost job creation and economic growth such as corporate tax cuts.
- Economic data in Europe, the UK, and China continued to disappoint with declines in growth, exports, and imports, while US job growth slowed in April.
The document provides an overview and outlook on domestic and global financial markets. It discusses the CEO's positive outlook on the Indian equity market rally and fiscal reforms. On the domestic front, it summarizes inflation trends, industrial growth, bond yields, and provides recommendations on debt strategies. Globally, it reviews equity market performance and updates on major economies. The overall document aims to advise investors by analyzing economic and market conditions.
The document provides an overview of global market performance and commodity prices. It discusses declines in the Dow and gains in the S&P 500 and Nasdaq on Monday. Asian shares were subdued on Tuesday as investors braced for key events. Oil prices reached their highest since November due to concerns over Libyan exports. The document also provides stock recommendations and analysis of commodity prices and world food prices.
The document provides a weekly summary of global and domestic economic news and market performance for the week of April 25-29, 2016. Key points include:
- Indian equity markets were mixed as key sectors like automobiles and banks showed selective gains, while the overall markets exhibited signs of exhaustion after strong gains.
- Global markets remained stable as the US Fed did not change interest rates and the Bank of Japan maintained monetary stimulus.
- Domestic manufacturing activity declined to a 4-month low, putting pressure on the RBI to keep rates low. Eurozone factory output grew weakly.
- Chinese economic growth slowed slightly in April as manufacturing expansion was lower than expected, raising doubts about sustained recovery.
Global bond yields are at historical lows which mean global bond prices have rallied across developed markets while S&P 500 is close to its historical high. This by itself is a dichotomy as bond prices and equity prices are not expected to rally together at the same point. Either of the two has to be true.
•Bond prices and yields are inversely related therefore, bond prices rally when yields and interest rates are expected to be low. Interest rates are expected to be low because growth prospects are low. This would entail the central banks to cut rates and because the demand for credits will be low due to the low growth prospects, the yields are expected to be low which explains the rally in bond prices. Considering this, the rally in the equity markets is not possible as there is no expectation for growth. This is the dichotomy that the global world is at particularly in the developed markets. In the light of the current scenario, either of the two has to give in i.e. either bond prices correct leading to normalcy in yields or equity markets give in.
This document provides a weekly summary of economic, market, and other news from August 16-19, 2016. Some key points:
- India's CPI inflation rose above 6% in July, exceeding the central bank's tolerance limit and raising expectations of further rate hikes.
- Global government bond yields increased modestly, with the US 10-year yield rising to 1.6%, while oil prices fell on doubts that upcoming producer talks would reduce oversupply.
- Domestically, strong monsoon rains are expected to boost agricultural growth and the overall economy. Internationally, China's exports declined in 2016 and are projected to fall further due to economic pressures.
The document provides a research report from Krause Fund recommending Alcoa Inc. (NYSE: AA) as a strong buy. It summarizes Alcoa's business operations, current stock performance, financial ratios, and provides an analysis of key economic indicators and how they may impact Alcoa's future performance. The analysts initiate coverage with a buy rating and $18-20 price target due to Alcoa's shift toward more profitable downstream products, potential for market share gains, and expectations that recent restructuring efforts will allow it to execute on goals leading to long term share gains.
The document provides an overview and outlook across various asset classes and sectors in India and globally. Some key points:
- Domestic equity markets have seen modest gains of around 8.5% year-to-date despite recent volatility due to political tensions. Bond yields have fallen in India on expectations of further rate cuts.
- Global central banks like the Fed and ECB appear less accommodative but the US economy remains resilient. Growth has slowed in Japan and parts of Europe.
- Automobiles, banks, FMCG and infrastructure sectors are expected to perform well in India, while cement may see a recovery. Select domestic sectors and stocks still appear attractive relative to other emerging markets.
- The document provides an economic and market summary for the week of November 14-18, 2016. It discusses developments in global markets, the Indian economy and stock market, and provides commentary on sectors and asset classes.
- Key points include the expectation of US Federal rate hikes in December, the impact of India's demonetization on various industries, and an outlook that Indian stock markets will see further declines in the short-term but provide buying opportunities. Debt markets are also seen as favorable due to expected interest rate cuts.
This document provides a weekly summary of global and domestic economic news and market performance for the week of August 8-12, 2016. Some key points:
- India's wholesale and consumer price inflation increased in July driven by higher food prices. Industrial production growth slowed in the Eurozone and China.
- US retail sales were flat in July and the budget deficit declined, while China's economic growth slowed with the weakest investment growth in over 15 years.
- The Indian stock market ended the week slightly lower, with the Sensex falling 0.11%. Most sectoral indices also declined over the week except for banking. Commodity prices were mixed with gold falling slightly while crude oil rose.
The document summarizes recent news and developments in global markets and the Indian economy from October 31 - November 4, 2016. It discusses the impact of the FBI announcement regarding Hillary Clinton's emails on US and global markets. It also covers the upcoming US presidential election and its potential effects. Domestically, it discusses recent inflation data, bank earnings, and the progress of GST implementation in India. Globally, it mentions recent economic data and central bank decisions in the US, UK, Eurozone, and China.
This document provides an overview and outlook across various sectors in India and globally. It discusses domestic and global economic factors, equity and debt market performance, sector-specific views, and other relevant topics. Key points include a positive outlook for domestic consumption sectors due to the festive season, signs of recovery in the Indian manufacturing sector, and expectations that global central banks will continue accommodative monetary policies.
- Last week, global equity markets declined sharply due to one bad trading day that rattled investors who had become complacent about continuously rising prices. However, market corrections of 6-8% are normal and investors should focus on investing in good quality stocks during declines rather than withdrawing.
- Concerns remain about instability in Europe's banking system, uncertainty around US interest rates after the election, and potential for Chinese currency devaluation. Wholesale inflation slowed in India while the government may increase public spending to spur growth.
- Key stock indices declined over the past week with the Sensex falling 1.46% while most sectors also ended lower with metals and power dropping the most.
The document provides an economic and market summary for the week of July 18-22, 2016. Key points include:
- Momentum stocks should be exited and defensive investments pursued as markets may be volatile.
- The IMF lowered India's GDP growth forecast to 7.4% for the current fiscal year.
- Greece relaxed some capital controls as bailout reforms progress and banking confidence returns.
- Central banks will remain cautious on policy moves pending clarity on Brexit's economic impacts.
- Core inflation in India declined to 4.5% in June from 4.7% previously, which may support a 25 basis point rate cut by the RBI in August. Industrial growth also turned positive in April after contracting previously.
- Financial results from companies so far have been better than expected, though IT sector disappointed due to Brexit. Global markets are focused on upcoming earnings season in India.
- The Bank of England is expected to cut rates to a record low of 0.25% to cushion the UK economy from Brexit shock. China's land and wage growth slowed in the first half of 2016 due to overcapacity issues.
The document provides an equity market and economic overview for the week of April 18-22, 2016. Some key points:
- Q4 company results were broadly in line with expectations, and results this season may be similar or slightly higher.
- Banks that received regulatory relief from the RBI on recognizing bad assets saw sharp rallies, but their fundamentals have not changed. Investors should not buy into these banks based on the RBI's leeway.
- Globally, disappointing results from Microsoft and tepid growth from Google do not bode well for markets and may lead to selling pressure. The current market can be viewed as a "buy on decline" scenario.
This document provides a case study on Jollibee Foods Corporation and their consideration of expanding internationally to Papua New Guinea, Hong Kong, and California. It summarizes Jollibee's history and growth in the Philippines since 1975. It also outlines some of the key human resources, operating, financial, and marketing issues Jollibee has faced in previous international expansions. These include strained relationships between domestic and international operations, cultural differences hampering decisions, and management issues at locations like Hong Kong. The document analyzes the fast food industry and Jollibee's position to help inform their choice of international strategy and location.
Retail, cannibalism and harmony: self destroying retail concept.Darius Radkevicius
This document discusses customer complaints about large retail stores and proposes an "organic store" concept that focuses on harmoniously meeting customer and employee needs. It advocates designing stores based on organic architecture principles that consider human-space relationships and functionality over marketing manipulation. An organic store would structure space and equipment around real life processes and movement patterns. Integrating IT with an organic backbone could improve space utilization, work efficiency, reduce excess/losses, and increase customer loyalty by at least 35%, creating a more profitable store that customers enjoy visiting.
How and Why a Global Brand Starbucks failed in AustraliaViren Baid
As a part of our Research Project - II at the S P Jain School of Global Management, Sydney we conducted a research on how one of the biggest brands of the world Starbucks failed to local competition in Australia
This document provides a SWOT analysis of the retail industry in India. It identifies several strengths, including a large purchasing power from the emerging middle class, favorable population demographics, and low retail penetration compared to other countries. Weaknesses include political and regulatory uncertainty, poor infrastructure, and low conversion rates. Opportunities exist in developing digital strategies, rural retailing, and taking a customer-centric approach. Threats include the availability and cost of real estate, high employee attrition rates, and an underdeveloped shopping culture.
DiBella Coffee vs Starbucks - Consumer behavior, segmentation, positioning an...MarcusHEikeland
This document provides an analysis comparing Di Bella Coffee and Starbucks. It includes sections on consumer behavior, market segmentation, positioning, and recommendations. Di Bella focuses on specialty coffee and the customer experience while Starbucks has expanded globally but diluted their brand. The document recommends Di Bella expand domestically and internationally to establish market leadership while continuing to innovate and build their brand.
The document outlines a marketing plan for Dream Bakers, a café and bakery located in Mardan, Pakistan. It will offer a variety of coffee, cakes, pastries and other products at competitive prices. The plan details the target market, strategies, financial projections, and controls to achieve the mission of offering high quality bakery products and becoming a leading reputable bakery in the area. It analyzes competitors, trends, and provides breakdowns of expenses, cash flows, and the breakeven point. The marketing team will implement strategies around pricing, promotion, and product/service quality to attract customers and achieve financial objectives.
Pall Corporation manufactures filtration, separation, and purification systems and consumables. It has two business segments: Life Sciences serving biopharma, food & beverage, and medical; and Industrial serving process technologies, aerospace, and microelectronics. Pall experienced 1% sales growth in 2013 due to biopharma growth offsetting weak industrials. The analyst recommends Pall as a hold due to its market leadership in filtration but expensive valuation of 30x earnings.
Global economies are witnessing two-speed recovery with the US economy showing firm signs of recovery, while growth in Euro Area still languishing in sub-optimal territory. Among the Asian economies, growth in Japan and China too continues to remain tepid. We discuss this in detail in the section on Global Trends in this month’s issue of Economy Matters. In the section on Domestic Trends, we analyze that the economic condition in the present scenario is in greater disarray than it was during the breakout of the global financial crisis of 2008-09, when both government as well as the RBI were quick to respond to the challenges and brought the economy back to recovery path within no time. In Corporate Performance, we examine the sectoral performance in the last fiscal in order to find the sectors which were badly hit in the wake of the current bout of economic crisis. The Sectoral spotlight for this issue is on Agriculture, a traditionally important sector of the Indian economy because of its enormous contribution in being the provider of basic source of livelihood to the most of the population in India. However in the recent past various challenges such as low agricultural yield, declining share of public investment, and lack of technological advancements have plagued the sector. We discuss the sector’s challenges and suggest measures to bolster its output. In the Special Article, we discuss India's deteriorating external position in the last few years, manifesting itself in a steady deterioration in the current account which slipped from a surplus at the start of the last decade to a huge deficit of 4.8 per cent in 2012-13. Bulk of the deterioration in current account is attributable to the sharp rise in merchandise trade deficit over the last decade. Ultimately, for India to contain its current account deficit at a more sustainable level of 2.0-2.5 per cent of GDP, it is essential that we ensure competitiveness of our goods and services, so that our imports are contained and exports boosted.
JPM Prime Brokerage Global Hedge Fund Trends November 2013Brian Shapiro
Hedge funds posted broad gains in October and year-to-date, led by equity long/short and event-driven strategies. Leverage declined slightly while short positions increased 2%. Most regions saw increased equity prices and tightening credit spreads. Earnings exceeded estimates but revenue growth was flat, raising uncertainty around sustained earnings growth. Global earnings forecasts continue to decline.
This document provides a summary of the Indian FMCG sector. It discusses key economic factors like GDP growth, inflation, and foreign direct investment that impact the FMCG industry. It then analyzes the industry through a SWOT analysis, PEST analysis, and five forces model. It outlines the major categories and products in the FMCG sector. It also examines the growth prospects and opportunities in the industry, as well as the roles and recent scenarios. Finally, it provides an analysis of major FMCG companies in India like HUL, Dabur, P&G, and Colgate Palmolive.
This document provides an industry analysis report on the fast moving consumer goods (FMCG) sector in India. It begins with an executive summary describing the FMCG industry and some key companies operating in India. It then covers analyses of the Indian economy including GDP growth rates, inflation, risks, and foreign direct investment trends relevant to the FMCG sector. The document conducts industry analyses including a SWOT analysis, PEST analysis, and Five Forces model of the Indian FMCG industry. It also describes the major categories and products within the FMCG sector, growth prospects, market opportunities, and the roles and future of the industry. Finally, it provides overviews of several leading FMCG companies in India.
Susquehanna Bancshares provides an investor presentation for the 3rd quarter of 2013. The presentation includes forward-looking statements and cautions investors that actual results may differ due to risks and uncertainties. It provides an overview of Susquehanna, including its market presence, financial information, and strategies to drive organic loan growth, defend its net interest margin, grow fee revenue, maintain efficiency, and accelerate capital generation and returns. Highlights from the 2nd quarter of 2013 include steady loan growth, continued focus on core deposit growth, strong profitability, and solid credit quality.
Investment BAFI 1042 Kevin Dorr 3195598 GOODMAN .docxmariuse18nolet
Investment BAFI 1042
Kevin Dorr 3195598
GOODMAN FIELDER LIMITED (GFF)
COMPANY VALUATION REPORT
1
GOODMAN FIELDER
LIMITED
COMPANY VALUATION REPORT
Scope
• The report looks at all publicly available data about the company via
the annual reports and publications
• An analyses of the company’s weakness and strength has been
conducted with detailed look at the fundamentals impacting the company
• The report outlines the ratios in relation to probability, return on
equity, using several modelling techniques
• There are charts and information used form the cash flow statement,
balance sheet and historical data sourced from the ASX
• The analysis of the company is compared to its competitors, industry,
sector and market it operates in.
• The report looks at stock price movement and all assumptions are
made available and are explained.
• Expert opinion and copyrighted material is used in the report and has
been appropriately
referenced.
REPORT
OUTLINE
This report attempt to
provide an analytical
evaluation of
Goodman fielder,
every attempt has
been made to make all
data accessible and
complete. This report
contains financial data,
historical analysis,
forecasts and
estimates based on
best available and
most up to date
information. The aim is
for the reader to be
able to make an
informed decision
about the fair value of
GFF stock and
compare it to GFF
peers in the industry. It
should give reader the
ability to form an
opinion on Goodman
fielder as an
investment based on
financial information
analytics.
2
Executive summary
Goodman fielder is one of the largest producers of food in Australia and it supplies product in many categories,
however it is first or second in every food category it participates in. It owns brands such as such as Nature's
Fresh, Helga's, Praise, Wonder White, Quality Bakers, White Wings, and Meadow Lea with offerings in consumer
brands such as Fresh milk, Meadow White Wings cake mixes, Praise salad dressings, and Leaning Tower frozen
pizza (Yahoo Finance 2012). It reaches over 30000 outlets in and around Australia. There are several major
shareholders of the company such as J. P. Morgan Nominees Australia Limited which owns 19%, HSBC Custody
Nominees (Australia) Limited that owns 17% and National Nominees Limited the owners of 22% of the
company(ASX 2012.)
On 19 August 2011 Goodman Fielder announced a net loss of $166.7 million for the year ended 30 June 2011,
this was attributable to a non-cash impairment charge of $300 million. Revenues from ordinary activities were
$2.56 billion, which is down 3.9% from the year before The New CEO of Goodman Fielder Limited Chris Delaney
is going to implement a strategic review which is focused on improving the performance of the company. There
are significant opportunities to increase efficiency, improve supply chain structure and inno.
This document analyzes the financial performance of the sugar industry in India from 2013-2014. It examines various financial ratios to understand the industry's liquidity, leverage, turnover, and profitability. The current ratio and quick ratio indicate the industry had adequate current assets to cover short-term debts. The debt-equity ratio shows low leverage. Interest coverage ratios demonstrate the industry's ability to pay financial obligations. Inventory and asset turnover ratios measure efficient use of assets. Gross profit ratios fluctuated significantly year-to-year due to the seasonal nature of sugar production. Overall, the analysis uses financial ratios to provide insight into the sugar industry's viability and profitability in India.
- Global equity markets declined due to concerns over the tapering of US quantitative easing and rising US bond yields. The MSCI AC World Index fell 1.43% on losses in Japan and emerging markets.
- In Asia, Japanese markets saw sharp falls while Chinese and Philippine economic data was relatively strong. The Bank of Thailand cut interest rates. In Europe, unemployment rose in southern countries while data in Switzerland, Sweden and the UK was ahead of expectations.
- US housing and consumer confidence data was positive but equity markets fell for the second week. In Latin America, central banks in Canada and Colombia left rates unchanged while Brazil raised rates and had weak GDP growth.
The report contains the following four chapters:
Chapter 1: Global Pharmaceutical Market
Chapter 2: Solutions to Challenges
Chapter 3: Global Players
Chapter 4: Overview of Industry Trends
You may follow my blog: biostrategyanalytics.wordpress.com for further posts related to financial and strategic issues in the Pharmaceutical / Biotechnology sector.
For any questions or recommendations do not hesitate to contact me.
- Global equity markets declined last week due to concerns over slowing global growth and tightening global liquidity. The World Bank lowered its global growth forecast for 2013.
- In Asia, Japanese markets fell on a stronger yen despite positive economic data. Chinese industrial production growth slowed slightly. Central banks in Indonesia, Korea, and Philippines kept rates unchanged.
- European markets pared losses but concerns over liquidity remained. UK and Eurozone industrial production rose. Turkey's economy expanded strongly. MSCI upgraded UAE and Qatar to emerging markets.
- US markets declined as retail sales rose but consumer sentiment fell. Brazil saw sharp declines and abolished an IOF tax to stabilize its currency. Several large M&A deals were
- The Greenlight Capital funds returned 4.3% in Q3 2013, bringing the YTD return to 11.8%
- The document discusses the Federal Reserve's quantitative easing programs and questions whether they have meaningfully helped economic growth or created systemic risks
- During the quarter, the fund's long positions like Apple and Vodafone outperformed while its short positions like Chipotle struggled despite underperforming fundamentals
JPM prime brokerage global hedge fund trends august 2013Brian Shapiro
After gains in most markets in July, hedge funds posted aggregate returns of +1.36% for the month. Equity long/short and event driven strategies performed best, while global macro strategies declined slightly. Gross leverage across all prime brokerage accounts increased from 1.81 to 1.84 as some managers added short exposures despite rising markets. Leverage was above average for some equity-biased strategies but below average for others like multi-strategy funds.
Deloitte Report "Global Powers of Retail 2013"Oliver Grave
This document provides an economic outlook for global retailers in 2013. It discusses the challenges facing Western Europe due to the ongoing sovereign debt crisis and recession in many countries. It notes that a failure to further integrate the Eurozone economically and politically could lead to more sovereign defaults and a deeper recession. The document also summarizes the economic situation and outlook in China and the United States. For China, it describes the government's stimulus efforts to counter slowing growth and discusses longer-term challenges. For the US, it expects the economy to avoid falling off the "fiscal cliff" and to see modestly faster growth in 2013, supported by an improving housing market and consumer spending.
JPM Prime Brokerage 2014 Institutional Investor Sentiments ReportBrian Shapiro
The document summarizes the key findings of J.P. Morgan's 2014 Investor Sentiments Report, which surveyed nearly 300 institutional investors about their hedge fund investment activity and outlook. Some of the main points include:
- Event driven and long/short equity strategies were most popular in 2013, while macro and managed futures strategies saw redemptions.
- Pension funds represented the fastest growing group of hedge fund investors, increasing allocations the most of any sector.
- Most investors plan to maintain or increase hedge fund investments in 2014 and are more open to investing in new hedge fund launches and longer-lockup "hybrid" funds.
Global equities saw strong gains until mid-February but then saw broad selling across assets as bond yields rose sharply. Global growth outlook remains positive at 5-6% for 2021. In India, earnings continued to beat estimates led by materials and energy, while bond yields rose. Mid and small caps outperformed large caps in February. The RBI kept rates unchanged and reiterated an accommodative stance.
The document summarizes the performance of ASEAN consumer stocks in 2Q15 and provides an outlook. Key points:
- 2Q15 earnings disappointed with 41% of stocks reporting results below expectations, similar to 1Q15. Disappointments were due to slower growth, currency impacts, and margin contraction.
- The author's 2015 aggregate growth forecast was lowered to 6% from 12% previously due to lowered GDP forecasts and subdued management outlooks following lackluster earnings.
- The author has adopted a less cautious stance than previous months as expectations have moderated, but does not expect a significant earnings pickup in 3Q15 as consumer sentiment remains subdued.
The document provides an overview of the chemical industry and the Indian chemical industry. It discusses the following key points:
1. The chemical industry globally is a $3 trillion industry that produces precursors and intermediates for most other industries. The industry is expected to grow at 8% annually. Asia is the fastest growing region.
2. The Indian chemical industry earned $155-160 billion in 2013 and is expected to grow 11-12% in the next 2-3 years. Key segments like specialty chemicals will see considerable growth.
3. A PEST analysis is provided to understand the macroenvironmental factors impacting the chemical industry in areas like politics, economics, society and technology.
This document provides an overview and analysis of mergers and acquisitions activity in the global consumer goods sector in 2012. It highlights several key trends driving M&A, including the rising importance of emerging markets, particularly in Asia; the adoption of multi-channel retail strategies incorporating online sales; and ongoing consolidation in high-growth luxury and premium brands. The report also examines deal activity and opportunities in various consumer sub-sectors and geographic regions, including the growing baby diapers market in Brazil.
Similar to Retail Food Group - Analysis Report - Group 5 (20)
1. 1Group 5 Assignment
1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
This report provides a detailed insight into the evaluation of Retail Food
Group (RFG) based on the macroeconomic factors, food retailing
industry and its financial health.
The findings have shown that the company has been able to maintain a
constant profit margin despite a poor indicator of macroeconomic
factors due to the fragile recovery in the Europe and the current
shutdown of the US government. Furthermore, regardless of the
saturation of the domestic food retailing sector in Australia, RFG
succeeded in capturing more market shares by its strategies from its
bargaining power to its strong client base. Recently, the acquisitions of
Crust Gourmet Pizza Bar and The Coffee Guy Group have demonstrated
the group’s aggressive approach to become one of the key players in
the food and restaurant market.
The group has enjoyed good financial health since 2011 after strategic
acquisition of Esquire Coffee. In addition, the debt fell from 40 percent
to 30 percent approximately indicating a growth in confidence of
shareholders after the successful acquisition.
FY2013 profit is expected to be in line with recent trend of growth,
while FY2014 is forecasted to be subdued as compared to market and
recent trend. It is the transition year with two major projects including
Project Evo and Project QSR400, aiming to restructure business model
and increase market share of pizza chain.
In summary, several benefits of potential investments mentioned
notwithstanding, it is highly recommended that the stock should be on
hold due to the significant reliance on the success of two major
projects in FY2014 with the target price at $4.38
RETAIL FOOD GROUP LTD
-VALUATION REPORT-
AFIN838 – BUSINESS VALUATION - GROUP ASSIGNMENT
24 September 2013
Retail Food Group Ltd ASX:RFG
OVERPRICED - HOLD
Price Target: 4.38
Downsize Potential: (1.6%)
Price Performance (AUD) at 23-Sep-2013
Current share price $4.45
52-week high price $4.87
52-week low price $2.83
Shares outstanding 130,3m
Market Capitalisation $579.8m
Total debt (+) $99.9m
Preference Share (+) $0
Cash & cash equivalents (-) $13.2m
Short term investment (-) $0
Enterprise Value $666.5m
Market Beta 0.83
Source: Yahoo Finance, 1H2013 Company Reports,
Damodaran Data (2013)
Trading Multiples at 23-Sep-2013
EV/EBITDA 13.6x
P/E 20.2x
Profitability CY2012
ROA (%) 8.1%
ROE (%) 12.2%
Source: Company Reports
ANALYSTS:
- HUU QUANG NGUYEN – ID: 42272130
- TRAN NHAT HUY NGUYEN – ID: 43117953
- HUONG GIANG NGUYEN – ID: 43175252
- DO DAT DONG – ID: 43111270
- TRI TAM CAO – ID: 42055253
Source: Yahoo Finance
2. 2Group 5 Assignment
Table of Contents
1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY....................................................................................................... 1
2. ECONOMIC ANALYSIS ........................................................................................................ 3
2.1 Global Economy..................................................................................................................... 3
2.2 Gross Domestic Product........................................................................................................ 3
2.3 Inflation and interest rate ..................................................................................................... 3
3. INDUSTRY ANALYSIS.......................................................................................................... 4
3.1 Porter’s five forces analysis................................................................................................... 4
3.2 Sensitivity to business cycle analysis..................................................................................... 6
4. BUSINESS ANALYSIS........................................................................................................... 6
4.1 Company Profile.................................................................................................................... 6
4.2 Company Strategy................................................................................................................. 8
4.3 SWOT Analysis....................................................................................................................... 9
4.4. Sustainability ...................................................................................................................... 11
5. FINANCIAL STATEMENT ANALYSIS.................................................................................... 11
5.1 Historical revenue and profit .............................................................................................. 11
5.2 Profitability.......................................................................................................................... 12
5.3 Liquidity and solvency......................................................................................................... 12
5.4 Investment management.................................................................................................... 13
5.5 Sustainable growth rate...................................................................................................... 14
5.6 Investment – related ratios................................................................................................. 14
6. VALUATION ..................................................................................................................... 15
6.1 Valuation Methodology ...................................................................................................... 15
6.2 Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC)......................................................................... 16
6.3 Valuation ............................................................................................................................. 18
6.4 Recommendation................................................................................................................ 23
7. REFERENCE LIST.................................................................................................................23
8. APPENDIX…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….….25
3. 3Group 5 Assignment
2. ECONOMIC ANALYSIS
2.1 Global Economy
The world’s economy has witnessed a slow growth
driven to a great extent by the Global Financial Crisis
(GFC) in 2007.
Firstly, the Euro economy was evidenced to improve,
albeit slowly, in this June. Nonetheless, the euro area is
expected to grow at below 1 per cent until the end of
next year. Correspondingly, despite a decline of
unemployment rate of 7.4 per cent last month, the US
economy is struggling with its slumping nominal GDP
of 1.4 per cent at semi-annualised rate. Nonetheless,
the shutdown of the US government has recently had
negatively profound impacts on the overall recovery
of this advanced economy.
Furthermore, China’s growth appears to be stable at 7
per cent. In addition, the Fed’s likelihood to taper its
bond-buying programme might wreak havoc both on
emerging market economies such as India or
Indonesia which might lead to another Asian Financial
Crisis.
2.2 Gross Domestic Product
The Australian GDP has slowed down to 2.5 per cent
and is expected to have further decrease of 25 basis
points at the end of this year. A major factor
contributing to a slumping GDP is because the mining
sector has reached its peak in June 2013. The market
capitalisation has declined 31 per cent approximately
from $75.3 billion in June 2011 to $51.8 billion in June
2013. Also, costs including impairment charges have
risen dramatically to $1 billion resulting a net profit of
$1.6 billion compared to $2.8 in 2011. Thus, mining
sector appears to be less attractive to international
investors, which in turn leads to a decrease of foreign
inflow causing the Aussie dollar to lose its strong
position.
2.3 Inflation and interest rate
The recent outlook on employment rate and wages
growth tends to push down the inflation. Nonetheless,
the depreciation in the exchange rate is likely to have
4. 4Group 5 Assignment
an upward pressure on the inflation. These two effects are expected to offset one another.
Therefore, the inflation at the end of this year is forecast to remain moderate. Also, the
introduction of carbon tax last year will also have a direct impact on the inflation.
3. INDUSTRY ANALYSIS
This section focuses on the analysis of the industry in which Retail Food Group is
operating (food retailing industry). This includes two sub analyses which are “Five Forces”
analysis and sensitivity to business cycle analysis. Result of these analyses will be the
foundation for the assessment of profit potential of RFG.
3.1 Porter’s five forces analysis
a. Rivalry among existing competitors: high
The sluggish growth rate of the industry: The fact that food and drink industry has reached
the saturation stage along with less private consumption slows down the growth rate of this
industry. According to a research conducted by Business Monitor International (2013),
private consumption in Australia is expected to decrease from 3% in 2012 to only 1.2% in
2013 which would leave the estimated food and drink sales stagnant in medium term. In
such subdued industry, competition will be intense when the existing players struggle
fiercely to take share from others.
Concentration is low. Patisserie, pizza bar and coffee house chains are three main sectors in
which RFG’s brands are operating. Among three, patisserie with the presence of large
number of shops from unbranded to branded names in Australia’s market is viewed as the
most intense segment. Meanwhile although the market is more concentrated, the
competition in two other segments is also likely aggressive with the presence of globally
known brands such as Gloria’s Jeans or Starbuck (for coffee house chains) and Pizza Hut,
Hugos Bar Pizza (for pizza bar).
Degree of differentiation is low to medium. This is because most of products in food and
drink category generally are viewed as highly substitutable products. Despite the fact that
5. 5Group 5 Assignment
pizza bars and coffee shops always struggle to make themselves differentiated from other
players, basically customers are found easily change their choice of food and drink to other
shops. Costa Coffee, which is main competitor of Starbuck, can be considered as an
example. By acquiring Coffee Nation which is an operator of more than 1000 self-service
coffee machines, the firm differentiated itself based on speed so that consumers can quickly
grab a cup of coffee (Josh 2011). However, this differentiated feature is hard to be viewed
as a long-term competitive feature so that the firm may rely on for maintaining their sales.
b. Threat of new entrants: medium to high
First move advantage is insignificant. Although the presence of widely-known brands
makes it difficult for new comers to grab the share right at the initial penetration, it’s also
challenging for existing players to set up certain standards for their products or services due
to the characteristic of low differentiation of the products in this industry.
Legal barrier is inconsiderable. All businesses wish to operate in this industry must comply
fully and strictly with all standards and regulations concerning food hygiene. It is, however,
not a challenging barrier for proper and genuine businesses.
Capital requirements are medium. In this industry, largest portion in capital expenditure is
for location and construction. A good location in shopping centre or high street along with
impressive shop’s decoration will be attributable substantially to initial investment.
Relationship between customers and business is high. Brand name is one of the most
considerable barriers for new entrants. John Henshall and Greg Smith (2009) in their
research about “Creating brand value in food industry” stated that if consumers change
their choice of food, such change due to taste which is a “habit and is determined by
culture” accounts for a very small proportion and “brand value which is created through
marketing activities will play a role in encouraging customers switching from one food
category to another”.
c. Threat of substitute : high
Switching cost is low. It’s due to low level of differentiation of the products.
Relative price / performance of substitute products are low. It is noted that food and drink
are classified into category that satisfies human’s basic needs and wants, such as need for
energy, health and satisfaction (taste) (John, Greg 2009). There are, therefore substitute
products which are cheaper but still satisfy these basic needs.
d. Bargaining power of buyers: medium to high
Price sensitivity is medium to high. Due to the fact that food and drink are product
categories satisfying human’s basic needs as well as the availability of a wide variety of
substitutes, buyers are viewed as highly price sensitive ones. However, it’s true that pizza
and coffee are seen as up-market products in food and drink category and therefore, its
price sensitivity level is quite lower than other ordinary substitutes.
6. 6Group 5 Assignment
Bargaining position is strong. It’s clear that in food industry in general, buyers are in strong
bargaining position thanks to large number of consumers and wide variety of substitutes.
e. Bargaining power of suppliers: low to medium
Concentration is low. According to the statistics released by Department of Industry,
Innovation Science, Research and Tertiary Education (2012), food beverage and tobacco is
the largest subsector contributing to the value of the manufacturing sector. This fact
indicates that behind this industry is a wide network of suppliers which could be grocery
stores, butchers, constructors, transporters, machinery suppliers.
Differentiation is low to medium. In order to create differentiation, coffee house chains or
pizza markers may require differentiated ingredients from their suppliers. However, such
differentiation is insignificant due to not too high level of differentiation for the outputs.
To sum up, on the basis of five forces analysis competition in food and drink industry in medium
term is expected to be fierce. Moreover, the character of an industry with highly substitutable
products and also already reaching saturation stage will make the competition become
tougher. Hence, in medium term, profitability for players in this industry is expected to be
lower. Also, the tendency of cutting down private consumption due to recent difficult
economic condition drives the businesses to other competitive moves other than prices to
maintain their market share in the next few years.
3.2 Sensitivity to business cycle analysis
Fundamentally, food retailing is classified as defensive industry thereby sales is less sensitive to
business cycle. However, it is noted that main market segment that RFG is heading is the
segment of highly differentiated products at which customers are willing to pay premium to
enjoy such differentiation. In addition, the substitution of the products in the industry is
considerably high so that customers are beneficial with wide variety of choice at wide range of
prices. This also means that when financial condition of the customers varies, it is likelihood
that they vary their choice from RFG’s products to others in lower-price segments. Hence, it is
foregone conclusion that in such highly defensive industry, RFG tends to be more vulnerable to
business cycle than other peers.
4. BUSINESS ANALYSIS
4.1 Company Profile
4.1.1 Business description
Retail Food Group operates as a franchisor for most of its food brands and also manages its
own outlets. In addition, the firm supplies roasted-coffee and bakery products to both
franchisees and company-owned restaurants.
7. 7Group 5 Assignment
Locations of Stores
Australia
New Zealand
Other
The Group main operations are in Australia
and New Zealand. In addition, they also
expand their presence to China, Papua New
Guinea, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, Indonesia
and Singapore.
a/ Franchising
There are 8 brands comprised 5 franchise
systems under Retail Food’s management,
which open 1,391 outlets in total. Revenue is
generated from royalties based on
franchisees’ turnover and license fees.
Donut King: Donut King provides catering services of yeast and cake donuts, breakfast,
ice-cream, coffee and healthy beverages. The majority of 351 Donut King Restaurants
are located in Australia; additionally, there are 14 stores open in New Zealand, Papua
New Guinea, China and Saudi Arabia.
Michel’s Patisserie: Michel’s offers premium-quality coffee and cakes tailored to
customer order. There are 325 stores, with 322 outlets located in Australia.
Brumby’s Bakery: Brumby’s customers are served additive-free breads and pie freshly
made in-store. 295 out of 310 total stores are located in Australia, and 14 outlets in New
Zealand.
Coffee Maximisation Unit: The franchise arm of this division consists of bb’s café, The
Coffee Guy and Esquires Coffee House. Both bb’s café and Esquires aim at providing a
relaxing atmosphere for customers to enjoy high-quality coffee and complement food
and beverages at reasonable price. There are 97 stores in total, 60 of which are located
in New Zealand and the rest are in Australia. The Coffee Guy is a special business
specialises in low-cost coffee served from drive-thru, self-supporting capsule and kiosk.
All 56 outlets of The Coffee Guy operate in New Zealand.
QSR Division: This division consists of Crust Gourmet and Pizza Capers. Both brands
place the emphasis on high-quality pizza and flexible buying options for customers.
Most of the 128 Crust restaurants and 123 Pizza Capers outlets are in Australia.
b/ Wholesaling & Retailing:
Retail Food wholesales roasted coffee to its franchisees and managed stores. The retail division
comprises voluntary and involuntary managed outlets. Involuntary managed restaurants will be
transferred to franchisees when they sign up.
8. 8Group 5 Assignment
4.1.2 Key Executives
Retail Food business is executed by a strong management team with proven experience in
managing franchise systems.
Name Position Qualifications
Tony Alford Chief Executive Officer CPA, ICA
Andre Nell Chief Operating Officer ICA
Peter McGettigan Chief Financial Officer ICA
Mark Connors Chief Legal Officer QLS, CSA
Gary Alford Director of Franchise
Tracey Caterall Director – Marketing & Innovation Mbus
Julie Bromley Director – Human Resources BCom
4.2 Company Strategy
4.2.1 Competitive strategy
RFG’s competitive advantage lies in the excellent quality of its products, which was prepared by
well-trained chefs, bakers and baristas. Furthermore, due to the nature of franchise business, it
is also possible for the Company to exploit economies of scale. Marketing, promotion, product
research and IT activities can be conducted at corporate level and not necessarily increase with
number of stores. As premium quality effectively shields RFG from price competition, relatively
stable level of operating expenses allows the Group to gain higher operating margin than its
peers.
4.2.2 Business strategy
The Group is proceeding to divest non-core business by the transition of wholesale bakery
supply to Michel’s Patisserie franchisees to traditional royalty-based system. While this reduced
significant amount of revenue generated from wholesale (over $20 million per annum),
operating costs declined at higher rate and led to higher NPAT margin.
There is also a strong emphasis on coffee brands image, through the acquisition of The Coffee
Guy in late 2012, the expansion of coffee roasting facility and the new partnership with Channel
7’s breakfast show Sunrise to be the onset café from February 2013. RFG also focuses on its
gourmet pizza business segment, which has become market leader in the sub-sector following
the acquisition of Crust Gourmet Pizza in October 2012. Moreover, RFG planned to shift focus
from low margin brand Donut King to higher margin products like pizza and coffee. They also
grouped similar brands into consolidated units as Coffee Maximisation Unit and Quick Services
Restaurants (QSR) Unit for optimal management strategy, avoiding cannibalism and efficient
resources allocation.
Specifically for the QSR Unit, Retail Food Group is executing a plan to open 400 outlets by 2015.
The number of stores belong to this unit will reach 340 in 2014, of which 100 locations are
under consideration. Approximately $18 million of investment is reserved for this project to
9. 9Group 5 Assignment
spend on 4 main initiatives: reduction in initial franchisee fee for easier franchise
establishments, incentives for multi-site owners, initial investment in new outlets and potential
acquisitions.
As for the coffee unit, there has been a substantial expansion of capacity. RFG bought a new
coffee roasting facility in Yalata and expects to finish the fit-out by mid-2014.
In addition, the Group explicitly expressed intention to acquire further brands to expand the
franchise system. They have initiated talks about takeover of other brands, though none
reaches conclusions at the moment.
Across all retail outlet and corporate level, there is an adoption of digital marketing strategy by
providing in-house operated ecommerce channel, social media integration, online ordering and
customer-facing technology.
Lastly, the launch of Project Evo indicates an attempt to revolutionize brands images through
new products introduction, store reorganization and modernization. Each brand has its own
project team to develop and execute innovative concepts, and initial rollouts of the plan have
proven to be successful and attracted customer’s interest.
4.3 SWOT Analysis
4.3.1 Strengths
Due to the focus on franchise system, RFG has low capital investment and enjoy over 60% of
total revenue from royalties and license fee. The minimal fixed costs allow better operating
leverage and reduce impact on the Group’s earnings when customer’s demand is low.
RFG has also registered the intellectual property ownership of all of its retail brands, which
offer protection against competition from imposters, better customer’s recognition and
periodic license renewal payments from franchisees.
Furthermore, effective and regular market research keeps the Group’s brands up to date with
customer’s preferences. This is reflected in continual innovation initiatives conducted at RFG’s
outlets in terms of menu alteration, store designs and value-added services. Besides, the
company has also tapped into the growing trend of digital marketing to increase brand
awareness and consumer engagement. If those plans are executed efficiently, RFG’s brands will
be associated with exceptional products and services and enjoy higher customer retention rate.
Last but not least, RFG is in a relatively good financial position. With abundant cash reserves
and conservative gearing ratio of approximately 27.4%, the Company has the necessary
capacity to acquire profitable brands and expand its franchise network.
10. 10Group 5 Assignment
4.3.2 Weaknesses
The first shortcoming about RFG business is the relatively low popularity of most of its brands.
Compared to regular brands such as Domino Pizza, Pizza Hut or Starbucks, there is a clear
dominance in brand awareness of those competitors over RFG’s brands. This indicates
insufficient marketing initiatives and promotion activities in RFG’s part. While Project Evo is a
proof of the Group’s attempt to solve the brand recognition problem, further review and
improvement plans should be considered to maintain the project impact over the long term.
Additionally, the delegation of Michel’s Patisserie supply chain to external providers poses the
risk of inconsistent quality and reliability of delivery. The closure of one major bakery supplier
in Queensland in 2012 left the Group with disrupted operations and a significant administration
cost of $2.4 million to support Michel’s outlets in the region. The issue raises a need for
thorough screening of potential suppliers prior to commitment to avoid similar business
disruption.
4.3.3 Opportunities
Firstly, the recovery of global economy has appeared to have good impacts on the companies.
The Australian dollar has declined dramatically. The margin for exporting coffee is projected to
be higher at the end of December 2013. Also, foreign exchange gain might also be witnessed.
Secondly, the social media crisis of Domino’s Pizza back in 2009 is a good case study for RFG.
This costly mistake could bring about a collapse of a big brand due to public severe crisis.
However, a quick and well-handled response from the CEO helped Domino’s Pizza to maintain
its business despite damaged reputation. In essence, wholesale coffee roasting is a fast growing
business in Australia. The executives have reached the decision to increase its coffee roasting
and sales to third parties to exploit this opportunity.
4.3.4 Threats
Mobile commerce is implemented by major players within the sector. For example, Pizza Hut
has successfully approached more clients by using these applications due to its convenience in
ordering food online using customers’ smart phones; the group may lose its market share
significantly if not join these advanced selling tools.
More importantly, the coffee beverage franchise industry continues to be dominated by key
players such as Gloria Jeans and Starbucks. To compete with these big brands, the group needs
to improve on its coffee brand image.
Lastly, decrease in government spending in the near future by politicians in the future might
slow down the demand of consumers. Hence, consumers would reduce on the amount of
money spent eating outside. A substantial decline might thereby be witnessed.
11. 11Group 5 Assignment
4.4. Sustainability
RFG is in relatively high growth stage. Although the company leverage ratio of 38.11% is close
to industry average (Damodaran data), which is an indication for maturity, they are aggressively
involved in business expansion with the acquisition of a coffee roasting facility in Yalata
recently. The CEO also expressed the intention for further brands acquisition in his
announcement in 2013. Furthermore, RFG’s average return on capital of 10.25% is still higher
than its WACC estimate of around 7%, though the rate of return is approaching the cost of
return.
In comparison with other sectors, the restaurant and food wholesale sectors have long cycle
life, where changes in technology are less rapid and less important. Moreover, the Group’s
competitive advantages in product differentiation and economies of scale from its broad
network of franchisees help deter copy-cats. RFG is also sensitive to market trend,
demonstrated by the shift of focus from the low-margin Donut King brand to higher margin
brands in its pizza and coffee units, and the adoption of digital marketing and introduction of
high technology to brand outlets. These factors position Retail Food Group as a strong player in
the market with promising prospects.
Nevertheless, the company is facing with fierce competition and lackluster economic
conditions. It is undeniable that RFG is still a follower to market leaders like Domino’s Pizza and
Starbucks. The overlap of their customers would limit RFG’s ability to control price in respond
to change in customer demand. In addition, a subdued-growth economy would most likely
depress demand for restaurant services. As a higher-end player in this sector, the Group’s
performance could be negatively affected in the near term.
5. FINANCIAL STATEMENT ANALYSIS
5.1 Historical revenue and
profit
RFG Revenue has reached a peak
of nearly $150m in 2009; and total
revenue of RFG experienced a
sustained decline in the next 3
years. However, revenue from
rendering of services mainly from
franchising operations moves on
total contradicting path, and keeps
going up from $46m in 2008 to
around $85m during this period.
As a result, proportion of rendering revenue out of total revenue becomes increasingly larger
which was more than 50% in 2011 and ends the year 2013 at nearly 70%. These remarkable
0
50,000
100,000
150,000
200,000
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
Historical revenue and profit
Operating revenue Rendering service revenue
NPAT EBIT
12. 12Group 5 Assignment
increases of rendering revenue were mostly attributable to sustained franchising operations of
RFG during this period namely the acquisition of Brumby’s Bakeries Holding and of Michel’s
Patisseries in 2007, the acquisition of further Brumby’s master franchise territories and Esquire
Coffee Houses franchise system in 2010.
Regarding net profit, it is noted that despite significant decline of total revenue during the
period, net profit after tax (NPAT) has been on upward trend, rising by more than 60% between
2008 and 2013. Such opposite movements could be explained by the fact that franchising
operations enabled RFG to cut off substantial operating costs which in turn, boost the profit
regardless of the reduction in revenue. In fact, operating costs were dropping by nearly 20%
during these 5 years.
5.2 Profitability
The evaluation of firm’s profitability is based on five financial ratios including Profit Margin
(PM), Asset Turnover (AO), Return on Assets (ROA) and Return on Equity (ROE)
Considering weighted average cost of capital of firm (7.94%) as the appropriate benchmark for
evaluating firm’s return on asset (ROA), it is noted that firm’s ROA during the last 5 years
performed well which consistently outperformed this benchmark.
In term of return on equity (ROE), it is driven by 3 factors including profit margin (PM), asset
turnover (AO) and adjusted leverage (which is the ratio of total asset to shareholders’ equity).
According to the chart, among these 3 factors, adjusted leverage and AO are the main engines
for the reduction of ROE. The modest increase in PM was not enough to offset the plunge in
both leverage and AO which eventually resulted in a remarkable decrease in ROE from 19% in
2008 to only 12% in 2010. If using firm’s cost of equity as benchmark for ROE, firm’s ROE during
the last 5 years performed better than its benchmark of 8.94% (firm’s cost of equity).
5.3 Liquidity and solvency
- Current liabilities and short-term liquidity
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
Profitability
Profit margin (PM)
Asset turnover (AO)
Return on equity (ROE)
Return on asset (ROA)
13. 13Group 5 Assignment
Based on current ratio and quick ratio of RFG in the last 5 years, firm’s short-term liquidity has
been at appropriate level and increasingly improved. Both ratios were much higher than 1,
which indicates that its current assets were able to cover its current liabilities. Even if the
liquidation of its inventories would have become more difficult, other current assets mainly
cash are still sufficient to cover liabilities, that are reflected by the high quick and cash ratio.
The exception in 2010 at which all liquidity ratios showed that RFG’s liquidity was significantly
low was attributable to heavy short-term borrowings in this year. Such external funds were
used to finance acquisitions that RFG had in this year. Media release by RFG showed that only
the acquisition of Esquire Coffee House in 2010 costs RFG $9m.
- Debt and long-term solvency
Gradual decreasing of debt to total capital ratio has indicated the confidence in future growth
of shareholders for lower gearing strategy. An exceptional rise in 2010 would be due to heavy
borrowing to finance their acquisitions in the year. In addition, the company’s interest coverage
ratio tends to increase recently which demonstrates lower default risk.
5.4 Investment management
- Working capital management
For the last 5 years, the firm has experienced erosion in its working capital management, as can
be seen from a remarkable decrease in operating working capital turnover (from the peak of
0.00
0.50
1.00
1.50
2.00
2.50
3.00
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
Liquidity
Current ratio Quick ratio Cash ratio
0.00
2.00
4.00
6.00
8.00
0%
20%
40%
60%
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
Solvency
Debt to total capital ratio Interest coverage ratio
14. 14Group 5 Assignment
$179.69m in 2010 to only $20.47m in 2013). This erosion is mainly caused by less effective
inventories management, reflected by a reduction in inventory turnover. Despite the gradual
movement of RFG from its own operations to franchising model since 2008, its inventories have
been increasing constantly overtime due to direct supply of coffee and bakery products to its
franchisors. The downturn in working capital management seems to be exacerbated recently by
bad performance in account receivables management, which can be seen by a remarkable
increase in day receivables (from 35 days in 2011 to 54 days in 2013), meaning that its credit
policy could be problematic when it takes more time for firm to be paid by its debtors.
- Long-term assets management
The firm has not utilized efficiently its assets which could be considered as low net long-term
asset turnover. However, such low ratio is mainly due to substantial increase in its long-term
assets which in turn promise a more sales growth in long run. It is also noted that majority of
RFG’s long-term asset is intangible asset which accounts for more than 90%. Its intangible
assets consist of goodwill, intellectual property rights, and most importantly, franchise network.
Such high portion of intangible assets in total long-term assets is reasonable since the strategic
plan of RFG is moving from own operations to franchising operations which in turn makes the
value of franchise network increasingly larger.
5.5 Sustainable growth rate
The sustainable growth rate which reflects the growth rate of firm while keeping its
profitability and financial policies unchanged is driven by 2 forces including return on equity
(ROE) and payout policy. Based on analysed result, firm’s growth rate decreases more
substantially from 14.5% in 2008 to only 4.1% in 2013. Such remarkable plummet is attributable
to the drop in its ROE and substantial rise in its dividend payout overtime.
5.6 Investment – related ratios
0.00
2.00
4.00
6.00
8.00
10.00
12.00
14.00
16.00
18.00
20.00
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 CY2012
Trading Multiples
P/E
P/B
15. 15Group 5 Assignment
Both price-to-earnings ratio (PE) and price-to-book ratio (PB) are progressively higher. High PE
ratio reflects the expectation of the investors for higher future earnings growth for the whole
industry. Compared with other rivals in the industry, current PE ratio of RFG corresponds to the
average of the whole industry but less impressive than that of Domino’s Pizza Enterprise (which
is currently around 22%).
In consistency with PE ratio, PB ratio is on upward trend. The fluctuation degree of PB ratio ,
which is slightly higher than 1, keeps PB at healthy level. However, such healthy PB ratio along
with high ROE unfortunately could not hint any primary signal for the value of stock. Therefore,
more technical analysis should be done to provide more appropriate assessment for the value
of stock.
6. VALUATION
6.1 Valuation Methodology
The intrinsic value of the company is calculated based on Discounted Free Cash Flow
(DCF) method. Regardless of unavailability of annual report for fiscal year 2013 (FY2013), most
of statutory accounts can be estimated with reference to recent company announcements and
half year data. As the result, FY2013 is used as the base year for forecasting. The equity value is
the result of present value of projected free cash flow to firm (FCFF) deducted by book value of
debt in FY2013. FCFF is projected based on two stage approaches with relatively high growth
rate & margin for the period of FY2013-FY2017 and stable period after that.
In high growth phase, DCF model developed for Retail Food Group analyses three
scenarios with different growth rates and profit margins.
Scenario 1: Base Case as per strategic plan & average rate – Regardless of strong
growth in FY2013, the growth rate of wholesales business is expected to be at circa 7%
after significant restructure in 2014. Franchising business is forecasted to maintain
average growth rate of past recent 3 years. Gross margin and EBITDA margin also
remain around the average trend of 38% and 36% respectively.
Scenario 2: Moderate Growth – Growth rate of wholesales and franchising are declining
gradually at 1% and 2% respectively. This scenario indicates the situation in which Retail
Food Group is unable to realize the impact of business restructure and generate enough
sales to maintain the current growth.
Scenario 3: Margin Pressure – Gross Profit margin is expected to decrease to 35% by
higher cost of sales in wholesales activity, while EBTDA margin also decreases by 15%
below the threshold rate due to higher operational costs.
High Growth Phase
FY2013 - FY2017
Stable Growth
Phase
FY2018 - ∞
16. 16Group 5 Assignment
The table below demonstrates the assumptions of growth rate, margin for three
different scenarios.
6.2 Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC)
6.2.1 Capital Structure
According to Annual Report 2012, the target gearing ratio of the company is between
40%-60% as the proportion of net debt to equity. The company’s target gearing ratio was
derived based on book value and with net debt after deduction of cash and cash equivalent.
This benchmark gearing ratio is hence adjusted consistently to our capital structure model with
market value and no cash deduction. The long-term capital structure of RFG was calculated
based on the average of market value of debt to equity ratio for the period of FY2008-CY2012
and after removal of out of benchmark range figures. As the result, the company’s long-term
D/E ratio is estimated at 0.38.
6.2.2 Effective Tax Rate
Effective tax rate was derived from normal marginal tax rate of 30% and with
adjustment from dividend franking credit. Due to fluctuation of effective tax rate each year and
unchanged marginal tax rate, the long term effective tax rate is forecasted to be 12.77%,
computed from average of three most recent years’ rates.
6.2.3 Cost of Equity
The required rate of return of RFG stock is calculated based on Capital Asset Pricing
Model (CAPM). The market portfolio is assumed to be ASX200, since the stock is primarily listed
Assumptions Scenario FY2013 FY2014 FY2015 FY2016 FY2017
Revenue Growth - Goods
Normal Condition 1 22% 5% 7% 7% 7%
Growth Pressure 2 22% 4% 6% 5% 4%
Margin Pressure 3 22% 5% 7% 7% 7%
Revenue Growth - Franchise
Normal Condition 1 21% 12% 15% 13% 13%
Growth Pressure 2 21% 10% 13% 11% 9%
Margin Pressure 3 21% 12% 15% 13% 13%
Gross Margins
Normal Condition 1 38% 38% 38% 38% 38%
Growth Pressure 2 38% 38% 38% 38% 38%
Margin Pressure 3 38% 35% 35% 35% 35%
EBITDA Margins
Normal Condition 1 36% 26% 36% 36% 36%
Growth Pressure 2 36% 26% 36% 36% 36%
Margin Pressure 3 36% 22% 31% 31% 31%
17. 17Group 5 Assignment
and traded on ASX200. In pursuit of long term forecasting cost of equity, yield of 10 year
Australian Government Bonds are referenced as risk free rate. Based on the intensive research
of Michael S. Blake, John Fallon, and Ana Zolotic (2012), published by Queensland Competition
Authority, market risk premium, incorporated in CAPM model, is 6%. Beta of RFG was derived
and evaluated with respect to two approaches including ordinary least square regression and
industry beta.
Based on ordinary regression method from 3 year weekly discrete returns between RFG
and ASX200 (9th
Aug 2010 – 5th
Aug 2013), Beta is obtained from slope of regression line at
0.549. However, this beta is weakly supported by low R Square (0.08), hence industry beta was
used instead. According to Damodaran (2013) on Australia, New Zealand, and Canada market,
beta of restaurant industry, which RFG is operating, is 0.62. Since the main contribution of
Australia in those markets and similarity of these markets, it was decided to utilize this industry
beta of 0.62 to calculate the levered beta of RFG, which results in 0.83 for RFG Beta.
Levered Beta Cost of Equity
Industry Beta 0.62 Risk Free Rate 3.97%
D/E 0.38 Market Risk Premium 6%
Effective Tax Rate 12.77%
Cost of Equity 8.94%
RFG Beta 0.83
6.2.4 Cost of Debt
Since the company’s debt is solely funded by bank loans, cost of debt equals to average
loan rates, which is 6.1% as stated in annual report 2012. It is assumed to be stable in the
future.
6.2.5 WACC Calculation
WACC is the weighted average of after tax cost of debt and cost of equity. With circa 28% debt
proportion of total capital, cost of equity of 8.94%, and effective tax rate of 12.77%, WACC of the
company is therefore 7.94%. This WACC can be assumed to be the cost of capital for RFG in long term.
OLS BETA = 0.5049
-20.00%
-15.00%
-10.00%
-5.00%
0.00%
5.00%
10.00%
15.00%
-10.00% -5.00% 0.00% 5.00% 10.00%
RETAIL FOOD GROUP (RFG)
18. 18Group 5 Assignment
D/V Ratio 27.59%
E/V Ratio 72.41%
Cost of Debt 6.10%
Tax Adjusted Cost of Debt 5.32%
Cost of Equity 8.94%
Beta 0.83
Risk Free Rate 3.97%
Market Risk Premium 6.00%
Effective Tax Rate 12.77%
WACC 7.94%
6.3 VALUATION
6.3.1 Cash Flow Drivers
Revenue:
Revenue of RFG is contributed from wholesales and franchise activities. Therefore, it is
more reasonable to allocate different growth rate for these two types of revenue. In recent
years, revenue growth rate from wholesale and retail of RFG was nearly 15%. From 2011 to
2012, this rate was around 35%, therefore, it is anticipated that in 2013, turnover from
wholesale and retail of this company would increase around 22%. This high growth rate could
be the result of solid growth in coffee, which account for more than half of revenue from
wholesale and retail. In following years, company cannot maintain the high growth rate in this
section in normal condition. Therefore, this rate is expected to be 5% in 2014, which is precisely
the same with plan of company, then, remain stable with 7% from 2015 to 2017. The reason for
this rate is coffee market would be profitable in next following years and third-party wholesale
of coffee account for big amount in total wholesale revenue. Moreover, second coffee roasting
facility could increase roasting capacity and diversify risk away from the first coffee roaster in
Granville
-
10,000
20,000
30,000
40,000
50,000
60,000
70,000
FY2013 F FY2014 F FY2015 F FY2016 F FY2017 F
Revenue From Wholesale/Retail
Revenue From Wholesale/Retail
0
50,000
100,000
150,000
200,000
FY2013 F FY2014 F FY2015 F FY2016 F FY2017 F
Revenue from Rendering of Service
Revenue from Rendering of Service
19. 19Group 5 Assignment
In addition, company has changed their policy in recent years and focused more on
franchising activity. In particular, proportion of revenue from franchise went up YOY and
accounted for around 64% total revenue. In 2013, company acquired Coffee Guy, a famous
mobile coffee chain in New Zealand. Regardless of subdued performance in Michel’s Patisserie
and other bakery brands, Donut King remains to be the rising star. Hence, growth of franchise
revenue in this year is forecasted to be around 22%. The company is currently promoting
franchisees to convert formats to Project Evo. The incentives include suspension of initial
franchise or other fee, traditional funding repayable with interest, traditional funding with
reduced payment obligation subject to performance benchmark and increase franchise service
fees over the life of the franchise grant periods. Therefore, growth rate of franchise revenue in
2014 would be lower than long term trend. However, with prospect of healthy growth in pizza
sector, RFG revenue is expected to grow at 15% in 2015, and 13% in 2016-2017.
EBITDA:
EBITDA margin for RFG was around 36% for the past 5years, and it would stay relatively
constant in the future. Exceptionally, in FY2014, as a result of project Evo campaign, operating
costs are forecasted to increase significantly and drive EBIDA margin to circa 25% for that year.
Property, Plant, & Equipment:
Capital Expenditure (CAPEX):
The company has injected c$11.1m of CAPEX in FY2013 for restructuring the business,
purchasing three properties in Queensland, and acquisition of Crust Gourmet pizza in Australia
and the Coffee Guy in New Zealand. For the period of FY2014-2015, Retail Food Group plans to
accelerate the growth of pizza division by $18m investment for project QSR400. This
investment will focus on four core objectives including:
- Incentivized initial franchisee fee arrangements,
- Stimulation of multi-site owner initiatives,
- Initial investments in both self-owned and franchising outlets, and
- Any possible acquisitions.
The larger proportion of investment will incur in FY2015, and most of the core objectives of
investment are for capital expenditure. Hence the company is expected to invest circa $4m in
FY2014, and $9m in FY2015.
Depreciation: Depreciation increases substantially in FY2013 and is expected to
further rise due to significant injection of capital expenditure. In accordance to strait line
method of expensing capital structure, the company’s depreciation account will have a gradual
increase after FY2015.
Intangible Assets: as the result of successful acquisitions of two new entities, intangible
assets increase approximately $48m during FY2013. Main contributions of intangible accounts
are from purchased goodwill, indefinite franchise networks and intellectual property rights.
20. 20Group 5 Assignment
With positive future outlook, these cash generating units can be expected to continue growing
in the future. As the result, no amortization cost should be provided in the near future.
Intangible Assets are expected to rise significantly during high growth phase due project EVO of
expanding franchising network.
Financial Income can be forecasted to grow at the multiples of average financial income
to total revenue for the past five years at 0.24%, while interest rate is assumed to stay constant
at 6.1% to project for financial expense.
Working Capital: proportion of working capital to revenue was implemented to project
the necessary working capital for required growth of revenue, while trade payable was
calculated based on proportion to cost of sales.
Leverage: Retail Food Group’s capital structure is assumed to be constant for the next 5
year projection at circa 45% debt to equity. The figure is based on threshold range announced
in fiscal year 2012 with given range of net debt to equity in between 40-60%. The company is
expected to fund more heavily from shareholders in the long term prospect.
Other Financial Assets – Vendor Finance & marketing funds: Vendor finance represents
funding provided to franchisees for the purpose of acquiring a franchised outlet, while loans to
national marketing funds represent short term funding provided to marketing funds associated
with Group’s six franchise systems. Due to this nature of franchising activity, vendor finance &
marking fund loan are projected on the average of recent proportion of vendor finance to
franchising revenue.
6.3.2 Forecasted Free Cash Flow in High Growth Phase
$'000 FY2013 F FY2014 F FY2015 F FY2016 F FY2017 F
Profit After Tax 32,016 24,182 39,857 43,770 47,052
Non Cash/Operating Expenses 6,897 7,658 8,418 9,418 9,937
Change In Working Capital (760) 677 (1,317) (878) (348)
Cash Flow from Operating Activities 38,153 32,517 46,958 52,310 56,641
Change in Vendor Finance & Investments (7,044) 4,027 (2,333) (2,391) 265
Change in PP&E (11,500) (4,051) (9,078) (760) (797)
Change in intangible asset (48,932) 0 (15,615) (14,972) (15,779)
Change in Financial Derivatives 2,789 (512) (215) 102 745
Cash Flow from Investing Activities (64,687) (537) (27,241) (18,021) (15,566)
Free Cash Flow To Firm (26,535) 31,981 19,717 34,290 41,075
21. 21Group 5 Assignment
Retail Food Group has the substantial negative free cash flow in FY2013 due to business
acquisitions in first half of the year, and purchase of three properties in Queensland as
indicated in CAPEX part. There would be a large negative cash outflow in FY2015 as the result of
project EVO and potential acquisitions. Dramatic business restructuring in franchising and
coffee wholesale can be expected to provide steady growth for profit in this period.
6.3.3 Terminal Value
Terminal Growth Rate of the company is the product of average growth rate of
international peers in the restaurant sector and food wholesale/retail sector, internal stable
growth rate model, and company’s long-term expectation of 2.25%. To obtain relevant growth
rate, international peer data in the restaurant sector includes firms in mature stage such as
McDonald, Wendy, Brinker International, and Jack In The Box. Since a significant proportion of
Retail Food Group’s revenue is generated from roasted coffee wholesaling, average growth rate
for Food retail/wholesale companies is also considered. In addition, the stable growth rate,
calculated from return of capital and reinvestment rate in FY2017, was also added to the
basket.
The terminal value of the company was calculated based on Gordon Growth model with
inputs from FCFF in FY2017, stable growth rate of 2.27%, and WACC of 7.94%.
6.3.4 Target Share Price
Enterprise value of the company is the present value of all free cash flow for high
growth period and terminal value. After subtracting net value of debt, implied share price in
each scenario was achieved via dividing this balance with total outstanding shares of Retail
Food Group. Scenario 1 is likely to occur at 60%, while the rest is equally shared among scenario
2 & 3. The table below shows forecasted share price in each scenario and the target share price
after accounting for weighted average from all scenarios.
Scenario 1 Scenario 2 Scenario 3
Probability 60% 20% 20%
Enterprise Value ($'000) 697,890 639,468 581,253
Net Debt Value ($'000) 92,006 92,006 92,006
Implied Equity Value ($'000) 585,797 529,724 473,232
22. 22Group 5 Assignment
6.3.5 Sensitivity Analysis
Perpetuity growth
With current perpetuity growth rate of 2.43%, the company share price falls within 5% area
lower than market price. In case of more optimistic economic condition, the share price is
expected to increase significantly to $6.25 as correspondence to 4% long term growth rate. In
other hand, in case of economic downturn, long term growth rate would be lower than current
economic growth rate at around 1.5-2% and indicates a sell signal to the market.
Perpetuity
growth
1.50% 2.00% 2.43% 2.50% 3.00% 3.50% 4.00%
Share price 3.69 4.03 4.38 4.43 4.92 5.51 6.25
Risk free rate
In 2013, the government has reduced the cash rate to push household and business
consumption after slow-down of economy especially from mining sector. Hence, it affected on
yield of Australian 10 year bond, which is the benchmark as risk free rate for computation of
required rate of return. However, changes in cash rate and risk free rate would occur when the
economy activity change in the future, and would affect our target share price.
Risk free rate 2% 2.50% 3% 3.50% 3.97% 4.50% 5%
WACC 6.52% 6.88% 7.24% 7.64% 7.94% 8.33% 8.69%
Share price 6.31 5.70 5.19 4.74 4.38 4.02 3.72
Probability of scenarios
Currently, probability of scenario 1 is projected with highest likelihood of occurrence; however
it may depart from original value in accordance to success of project EVO in 2014-2015, and
overall condition of food & beverage industry.
Probability of Base Case 45% 50% 55% 60% 65% 70% 75%
Share price 4.31 4.34 4.36 4.38 4.4 4.43 4.45
4.65
4.20
3.75
4.38
0.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00
Scenario 1
Scenario 2
Scenario 3
Target Share Price
RFG Share Price
23. 23Group 5 Assignment
6.4 Recommendation
Retail Food Group is currently operating in challenging market condition with overall
slowdown of Australia economy, competitive food & beverage market. However, the company
has implemented several business model restructure with higher focus on franchising activities
and brand awareness since 2012. There would be more significant developing projects in
coming FY2014-FY2015. Some of positive effects after these business restructure have incurred
during the year 2013, and Australia economy is expected to recover after recent slowdown by
easing monetary policy. However, the RFG share is evaluated to be overheated in the market by
optimistic forecast, we expect moderate growth for the company in near future. According to
our valuation model, we strongly recommend a hold for Retail Food Group in current situation
with price range between $3.75 and $4.65 and target at $.438. The stock’s target intrinsic value
is dramatically subject to the success of Project Evo & QSR400 in FY2014-2015.
7. REFERENCE LIST
Aussie Mine, 2013, Pricewaterhouse Coopers Australia, viewed 18 Sep 2013
<http://www.pwc.com.au/industry/energy-utilities-mining/publications/aussie-mine.htm>
Business Monitor International 2013, ‘Australia Food & Drink report Q3 2013’.
Damodaran, A. 2006, Damodaran on Valuation, 2nd
ed, John Wiley & Sons, New Jersey.
Department of Industry, Innovation Science, Research and Tertiary Education 2012, ‘Key fact:
Australian food product manufacturing’, viewed 14 August 2013,
<http://www.innovation.gov.au/industry/FoodProcessingIndustry/Pages/Library%20Card/Austr
alianFoodProcessingIndustryDataCard.aspx>
Four Seasons the Fed Should Start Tapering in September, 2013, Wall Street Journal, viewed 18
Sep 2013,< http://blogs.wsj.com/moneybeat/2013/08/27/four-reasons-the-fed-should-start-
tapering-in-september/>
International Monetary Fund, 2013, World Economic Outlook Update, viewed 18 Sep 2013,
<http://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/weo/2013/update/02/>
John, H, Gleg, S. 2009, ‘Creating brand value in the food industry’, Deloitte, viewed 14 August
2013,<http://www.deloitte.com/assets/DcomUnitedKingdom/Local%20Assets/Documents/Ser
vices/Tax/Tax%20redrawn/UK_Tax_TaxRedrawn_Creatingbrandvalueinthefoodindustry.pdf>