The document discusses various tools for detecting code smells and refactoring opportunities in Java codebases: 1. JDeodorant detects code smells like God Classes and Feature Envy and suggests refactorings. It analyzed a 120k LOC codebase in 11 minutes. 2. JMove identifies Feature Envy smells and proposes moving methods to better classes. It provided 13 suggestions for a codebase in 45 minutes. 3. JSpIRIT identifies 10 code smells and found 1349 in a codebase in 1 minute. Clicking a smell brings you to the problematic code. 4. Stench Blossom identifies smells as you code to avoid stopping work. It indicates smells without suggestions

1. Refactor to the Limit!

2. 1
1 Your Code Stinks!
2 JDeodorant
3 JMove
4 JSpIRIT
5 Stench Blossom
6 TopicViewer
7 iPlasma
8 The Plan
9 If I Had Time
10 Wrapup
Agenda

3. 2
Your Code Stinks!
The following are from Object Oriented Metrics in Practice, Lanza & Marinescu (2004)
God Class – Performs too much work on its own and centralizes the intelligence of a system. Reduces
reusability, understandability, and maintainability of a class or subsystem.
Feature Envy – Method that is more interested in the data of other classes than its own class. The
method may be misplaced and should be moved to another class.
Data Class – “Dumb” data holders without complex functionality but other classes strongly rely on them.
Brain Method – Centralizes the functionality of a class, and is often hard to maintain and understand.
Is long, has excessive branching, deep nesting, and uses many local and instance variables.
Brain Class – Similar to God Classes in that they are large and complex, but do not abusively access the
data of “satellite” classes or are more cohesive. They have at least one Brain Method.
Intensive Coupling – A single client method is strongly coupled with only a few provider classes.
Dispersed Coupling – A single method is excessively tied to many other operations dispersed among
many classes.
Shotgun Surgery – A single method has many methods in other classes depending on it.
Refused Parent Bequest – Child class does not specialize its parent class
Tradition Breaker – Child class does not enhance / specialize the functionality of the parent class
Disharmonies We’ll be Talking About Today

4. 3
Your Code Stinks!
How the Disharmonies are Related
From Object Oriented Metrics in Practice, Lanza & Marinescu (2004)

5. 4
Your Code Stinks!
God Classes
• 5 – 7 times more change prone
• 4 – 19 times more bug prone
Dispersed Coupling
• Points to defect and maintenance prone classes
From the Technical Debt webinar at
https://fc-d.umd.edu/sites/default/files/Publications/ReportsAndPresentations/TD_webinar_11_11_10.pdf
The Worst Offenders

6. 5
1 Your Code Stinks!
2 JDeodorant
3 JMove
4 JSpIRIT
5 Stench Blossom
6 TopicViewer
7 iPlasma
8 The Plan
9 If I Had Time
10 Wrapup

7. 6
JDeodorant
Detects several code smells and provides actionable suggestions to remedy them:
• God Class
• Long Method
• Type Checking
• Feature Envy
• Duplicated Code (not discussed here)
Project site: http://users.encs.concordia.ca/~nikolaos/jdeodorant/
Written by a team of professors and PhD students
About JDeodorant

8. 7
JDeodorant
1) Install from the update site http://users.encs.concordia.ca/~nikolaos/update/
2) Open the desired smell detection strategy from the Bad Smells menu
How to Use JDeodorant

9. 8
JDeodorant
3) Select the project you would like scanned from the Package Explorer
4) Click on the i button in the opened smell view to start the scan
How to use JDeodorant

10. 9
JDeodorant
Identifies God classes and proposes class extraction refactorings
Took 11 minutes (w/3GB RAM) to analyze JHotDraw 7.6 (120K LOC) and produced 115 suggestions
God Class

11. 10
JDeodorant
Iidentifies Feature Envy smells and suggests Move Method refactorings
Took about 5 min (w/3GB RAM) to run against JHotDraw 7.6
Feature Envy

12. 11
JDeodorant
A long method may not be entirely cohesive and it may be possible to extract one or more blocks of logic
into a separate method, making the method easier to understand and maintain.
Took 1 hour and 40 minutes to analyze JHotDraw 7.6 (w/3GB RAM) and didn’t find any instances of this
smell. May run faster with more memory.
Long Method
Picture from JDeodorant Site

13. 12
JDeodorant
The Type Checking scan identifies where polymorphism or the strategy pattern should be used
Took less than 10 seconds to analyze JHotDraw 7.6 and did not find any instances of this smell.
Type Checking
Picture from JDeodorant Site

14. 13
JDeodorant
Pros
Open Sourced under the Eclipse Public License at https://github.com/tsantalis/JDeodorant
Works in the most recent release of Eclipse
Provides UML visualizations
At version 5.0 and is mature and full-featured
Successfully works in most recent release of Eclipse (Mars R.2)
Once project is parsed for a smell, incremental scans can quickly be re-run against individual packages or
classes
Cons
Can’t run in the background
Some detections can take a long time for medium and large projects
Pros and Cons

15. 14
1 Your Code Stinks!
2 JDeodorant
3 JMove
4 JSpIRIT
5 Stench Blossom
6 TopicViewer
7 iPlasma
8 The Plan
9 If I Had Time
10 Wrapup

16. 15
JMove
• JMove identfies Feature Envy smells and suggests Move Method refactorings
• If the method is could be moved to multiple classes, a recommendation is made to move it to the class
where it will be the most similar to the other methods in that class
• Project page: http://aserg.labsoft.dcc.ufmg.br/jmove/ (links to paper and plugin)
• Took 45 minutes against JHotDraw 7.6 w/3GB RAM and provided 13 suggestions
• Checks if a method has more similarities to the methods in another class than its current class. It
takes dependencies of the following types between the current class and possible target classes into
account:
• Method Calls
• Field accesses
• Object Instantiations
• Local Declarations
• Return Types
• Exceptions
• Annotations
About JMove

17. 16
JMove
1) Download from http://aserg.labsoft.dcc.ufmg.br/jmove/ and unzip in your Eclipse installation root
directory.
2) Start Eclipse and select Bad Smells -> JMove or Refactorings -> JMove from the menu.
3) Select the project you’d like scanned from the Package Explorer.
4) Click on the i button in the JMove view to start the scan
How to use JMove

18. 17
JMove
Jmove in Action

19. 18
JMove
Pros
• Tool authors found that JMove‘s precision and recall were 60% and 81%, compared to 26% and 54%
for JDeodorant. Authors found it produced fewer recommendations, but they were better.
• Open sourced under the MIT license at https://github.com/vitormsales/JMove
• Easy to install and use
Cons
• Required to scan an entire Eclipse project – no incremental re-scans
• Can’t be run in the background
• Has been at Beta 0.1 for 3 years
• Not under active development
• Stops working mid-analysis in the Eclipse Mars.2 (4.5.2) but works in Mars (4.5.0)
Pros and Cons

20. 19
1 Your Code Stinks!
2 JDeodorant
3 JMove
4 JSpIRIT
5 Stench Blossom
6 TopicViewer
7 iPlasma
8 The Plan
9 If I Had Time
10 Wrapup

21. 20
JSpIRIT
Identifies 10 of the 11 code disharmonies presented in Lanza & Merinescu’s “Object Oriented Metrics in
Practice” The Significant Duplication disharmony was not included
Found 1349 disharmonies in JHotDraw 7.6 in 1 minute (with 2 GB RAM)
Identified disharmonies can be clicked on to show where the disharmony is located in the codebase
About JSpIRIT

22. 21
JSpIRIT
1) Download the non-agglomeration version from the JSpIRIT page at
https://sites.google.com/site/santiagoavidal/projects/jspirit
2) Copy it to the dropins directory of your Eclipse installation and start Eclipse
3) Select the project you’d like to analyze, right click it, and select JSpIRIT -> Find Code Smells
How to use JSpIRIT

23. 22
JSpIRIT
How to use JSpIRIT
The JSpIRIT View will pop up once the analysis is complete
Clicking on the item in the view will bring you to the afflicted class or method

24. 23
JSpIRIT
Pros
Works with most recent release of Eclipse (Mars.2 / 4.5.2)
Ranks which design flaws are the worst
Clicking on the design flaw brings you to the element in the code
Ranking is configurable
Free as in beer
Cons
Must be run on entire project. No incremental analysis is possible
Does not propose fixes or specifics about the problem
Eclipse not responsive during analysis
Agglomeration view produces errors in the Agglomeration version
Not open source
Pros and Cons

25. 24
JSpIRIT
Similar to JSpIRIT in its goal of detecting same disharmonies
Available from
https://sewiki.iai.uni-bonn.de/research/cultivate/tutorial_exploring_smells_and_metrics
Unfortunately it is a bit difficult to set up and use
Similar Tool: Cultivate

26. 25
1 Your Code Stinks!
2 JDeodorant
3 JMove
4 JSpIRIT
5 Stench Blossom
6 TopicViewer
7 iPlasma
8 The Plan
9 If I Had Time
10 Wrapup

27. 26
Stench Blossom
Identifies code smells as you develop and makes you aware of them without getting in your way.
Detects 10 code smells and indicates their severity:
• Data Clumps
• Feature Envy
• Message Chain
• Switch Statement
• Typecast
• InstanceOf
• Long Method
• Large Class
• Primitive Obsession
• Magic Number
• (Long) Comments
• Duplicated Code
About Stench Blossom

28. 27
Stench Blossom
Install the Stench Blossom Eclipse plugin from
https://github.com/CaptainEmerson/refactoring-
tools/raw/master/installables/update_sites/stench_blossom
Enable the Stench Blossom Smell Indicator in the Eclipse Toolbar
Installing Stench Blossom

29. 28
Stench Blossom
Less obvious smells -> orange and above the horizontal line
Obvious smells -> blue and below the horizontal line
Horizontal (thin) line appears if the cursor is not in the editor
Each smell has a specific wedge
Worse the smell, the larger the radius
Understanding the Ambient View

30. 29
Stench Blossom
Hovering your mouse over a wedge shows which smell it is indicating
Clicking on the tooltip will enable the Exploration View
Using the Active View

31. 30
Stench Blossom
Using the Explanation View
References to methods and variables of external classes are highlighted
Suggestions not provided on purpose to allow developer to come up with the best solution
Explanation views can be pinned / prevented from scrolling by clicking on the staple icon

32. 31
Stench Blossom
Code elements are boxed in the editor when hovered in the Explanation view
Using the Exploration View

33. 32
Stench Blossom
Pros
Identifies smells as you work, avoiding the need to stop working and wait for analysis to complete
Does not slow the IDE down
Open Sourced at https://github.com/DeveloperLiberationFront/refactoring-tools
Documented in https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/5705/85ed977bf37b586d6a01e2845a388afb1a26.pdf
All features work in Eclipse Mars R.2
Cons
Not sure if it works with Java 8 features since it was last updated over 2 years ago
Pros and Cons

34. 33
1 Your Code Stinks!
2 JDeodorant
3 JMove
4 JSpIRIT
5 Stench Blossom
6 TopicViewer
7 iPlasma
8 The Plan
9 If I Had Time
10 Wrapup

35. 34
TopicViewer
Analyzes words used in source files. Can optionally include Javadoc and comments in vocabulary
extraction.
Produces a colorful map with recommendations of classes that belong together.
Project site at https://code.google.com/archive/p/topic-viewer/
I’ve exported the code from Google Code to https://github.com/jimbethancourt/topic-viewer and recently
improved semantic clustering performance by more than 2X (2:10 mins -> 43sec onJHotDraw) for
version under source control.
Downloadable from https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/67114006/TopicViewer.rar (from Google Code
project site)
Vocabulary Extraction (1st step) took about 30 seconds for JHotDraw 7.6 (using defaults)
Semantic Clustering (2nd step) took less than 1 minute and 30 seconds for downloaded version
About TopicViewer

36. 35
TopicViewer
Our Goal: A Distribution Map

37. 36
TopicViewer
1) Download Topic Viewer from https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/67114006/TopicViewer.rar
and unzip
2) Double-click the TopicViewer.jar and TopicViewer starts. To use more memory than the default
heap size of your JVM, you will need to launch it from the command line or a batch file.
Installing TopicViewer

38. 37
TopicViewer
Activities -> Configure Workspace
Step 1: Configure Workspace

39. 38
TopicViewer
Select a workspace directory where the project files for a single codebase analysis will live
Click Open Workspace
You should get the message “Workspace has just been configured” once complete
Step 2: Select a Workspace

40. 39
TopicViewer
Step 3: Extract the Project Vocabulary

41. 40
TopicViewer
Click the Select button (on the top right) and select desired root directory of your codebase. Be
careful you don’t include test directories if you don’t want them included in the analysis.
Set desired analysis options and click the Start button.
Step 4: Run Semantic Analysis of Codebase

42. 41
TopicViewer
Click on Activities -> Semantic Clustering
Specify parameters (I take the defaults)
Click Select on the Top right, select workspace/lsi/src-root-directory-name.matrix, and click Open
Click Start on the bottom left
Step 5: Run Semantic Clustering

43. 42
TopicViewer
Select Activities -> View Results -> Distribution Map
Click Select in the top left and select workspace/correlation/src-root-directory-name.matrix
Classes that may belong together in the same package have the same color / number
Step 6: Open Distribution Map

44. 43
TopicViewer
Pros
Produces insightful and helpful suggestions
Simple
Cons
No guided workflow
App not responsive during analysis
Progress bar doesn’t update until it’s complete
Medium and large codebases require more memory and time.
Attempts implement concurrency and streams have failed miserably.
Notes
Downloaded version run faster for large codebases since it uses Sparse matrices in some spots and
needs less memory.
May be worth backing out the Parallel Colt migration and re-applying code changes made in the
HierarchicalClustering class (mostly fixing equals / not equals checks)
Pros and Cons

45. 44
1 Your Code Stinks!
2 JDeodorant
3 JMove
4 JSpIRIT
5 Stench Blossom
6 TopicViewer
7 iPlasma
8 The Plan
9 If I Had Time
10 Wrapup

46. 45
iPlasma
Tool for performing quality analysis of object-oriented software systems
Development led by the authors of the book Object Oriented Metrics in Practice
Project page: http://loose.upt.ro/reengineering/research/iplasma
Download from http://loose.upt.ro/iplasma/iplasma.zip
Once unzipped, run unzip_DiriPlasma6toolsiPlasmainsider.bat to launch iPlasma
About iPlasma

47. 46
iPlasma
Click Load -> Java Sources
Using iPlasma

48. 47
iPlasma
Enter the path of the root directory of the codebase you want to analyze in the Source path textbox.
You can also navigate to it and select it by clicking on the “…” button
The Cache file name textbox can be left blank
Click OK and the model will load. JHotDraw 7.6 loaded in just over a minute (1:04)
Using iPlasma

49. 48
iPlasma
Once codebase is loaded, you’re presented with an Overview Pyramid.
Quick explanation available at https://sewiki.iai.uni-
bonn.de/research/cultivate/tutorial_exploring_smells_and_metrics#overview_pyramid
Using iPlasma

50. 49
iPlasma
Click on the directory you’re interested in learning more about and the Group menu option will
activate:
Using iPlasma

51. 50
iPlasma
The Group menu allows you to select a group of metrics (most but not all work).
iPlasma’s Group Menu

52. 51
iPlasma
Options in the Group and Property menus change depending on what element is clicked in the
navigation tree tree in the top left.
Group menu options show new children in the navigation tree
Property menu options show new sortable columns
The Group and Property Menus Change

53. 52
iPlasma
Clicking a class will show details about the class, the disharmonies the class is suffering from,
and recommendations of improvements that could be made to it.
Click a Class to Learn More About It

54. 53
iPlasma
Click on an item under Root and then select an option from the Filter menu to filter in (show) only
classes with that property
Filter Menu

55. 54
iPlasma
Pros
Parses source quickly
Open sourced at https://sourceforge.net/p/iplasma-horia/code/HEAD/tree/ (no license specified)
Finds a number of issues in codebase that are not found by other tools
Cons
Older – Parser may not support Java 8 code
Somewhat clunky and not the most intuitive tool to use
Not all features are fully implemented (though most appear to be)
Pros and Cons

56. 55
1 Your Code Stinks!
2 JDeodorant
3 JMove
4 JSpIRIT
5 Stench Blossom
6 TopicViewer
7 iPlasma
8 The Plan
9 If I Had Time
10 Wrapup

57. 56
The Plan
On an day-to-day basis
• Refactor as you develop – there’s no better time than the present
• Focus on delivering business value for your effort and minimize business disruption
• Don’t refactor all problems.
Only stop work and refactor
• Code that changes frequently
• See Ranking Refactoring Suggestions based on Historical Volatility
http://users.encs.concordia.ca/~nikolaos/publications/CSMR_2011.pdf
or the presentation at
http://www.slideshare.net/tsantalis/ranking-refactoring-suggestions-based-on-historical-volatility
• Code that is bug prone
• It will likely have bugs in the future if not refactored
Coordinate move method & move class refactorings with your team to avoid surprises since these
refactorings may impact a significant number of classes.
What / When Should I Refactor?

58. 57
1 Your Code Stinks!
2 JDeodorant
3 JMove
4 JSpIRIT
5 Stench Blossom
6 TopicViewer
7 iPlasma
8 The Plan
9 If I Had Time
10 Wrapup

59. 58
If I Had Time
Another tool for identifying Extract Method opportunities, but it doesn’t work
Authors indicated recall and precision was significantly higher than JDeodorant
Project page: http://aserg.labsoft.dcc.ufmg.br/jextract/ (with downloadable source)
Paper: http://homepages.dcc.ufmg.br/~mtov/pub/2014_cbsoft_jextract.pdf
Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6htJOzXwRNA
JExtract

60. 59
If I Had Time
Analyzes source code commit history and identifies co-change clusters. Idea is that code that
changes together belongs together.
Project site: http://aserg.labsoft.dcc.ufmg.br/modularitycheck/
Source code: https://github.com/aserg-ufmg/ModularityCheck
ModularityCheck

61. 60
If I Had Time
Eclipse plugin that makes software remodularization / class move suggestions:
https://www.sg.ethz.ch/media/publication_files/2014_Modularity_1.pdf
https://sourceforge.net/projects/somomoto/ (plugin doesn’t work in present state) GPL 3 license
From the paper above:
SOMOMOTO
Test case: the remodularization of JGRAPHX (a JAVA
graphical library). The JAVA classes are depicted as circles,
while their color reflects the corresponding package
membership (same color, same package). (a) original. (b)
after remodularization by SOMOMOTO.

62. 61
If I Had Time
Dr. Jehad Delal’s publication Identifying Refactoring Opportunities in Object-Oriented Code: A
Systematic Literature Review
(http://www.isc.ku.edu.kw/drjehad/identifying%20refactoring%20opprtunities%20IST.pdf) lists a
number of papers that discuss refactoring opportunity discovery tools.
Investigate all Papers on Tools

63. 62
1 Your Code Stinks!
2 JDeodorant
3 JMove
4 JSpIRIT
5 Stench Blossom
6 TopicViewer
7 iPlasma
8 The Plan
9 If I Had Time
10 Wrapup

64. 63
Wrapup
Not all tools will detect that the same piece of code needs to be refactored
Not every instance of every detected smell may be a valid one
Be careful that move method & move class refactorings do not introduce cyclic dependencies
There is no substitute for YOU and your experience
Most of these tools will likely move you away from package-by-layer and towards package-by-
feature (which is usually a good thing!)
Keep in Mind

65. 64
Wrapup
JDeodorant: http://users.encs.concordia.ca/~nikolaos/jdeodorant/
Jmove : http://aserg.labsoft.dcc.ufmg.br/software/
JSpIRIT: https://sites.google.com/site/santiagoavidal/projects/jspirit
Stench Blossom: https://github.com/CaptainEmerson/refactoring-
tools/raw/master/installables/update_sites/stench_blossom
TopicViewer: https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/67114006/TopicViewer.rar
My TopicViewer repo: https://github.com/jimbethancourt/topic-viewer
iPlasma: http://loose.upt.ro/iplasma/iplasma.zip
http://www.oreilly.com/programming/free/files/software-architecture-patterns.pdf
Take a Picture of THIS Page

66. Thank You!