REAL ESTATE FRAUDStanislaus County District AttorneyW.R. McKenzie, Deputy District AttorneyGlenn Gulley, Criminal InvestigatorMark Smith, Criminal Investigator
A LITTLE ABOUT US:June 2005…SB 537 passed  (Govt. Code 27388)$3.00 every Recorded Real Estate Document to go to Trust Fund for FraudStanislaus County began January 2006Full Time DDATwo Criminal Investigators
What do we Do:Focus on investigation and prosecution of Real Estate FraudEmphasis on Crimes that impact Vulnerable Victims:Elderly, Disabled, Unsophisticated, Foreclosure victimsEducational programs in the CommunityTo help reduce the number of victims
More Specifically,What do we Do:Investigate Frauds and ForgeriesForeclosure FraudTitle FraudFiling False Financial Statements in relation to Mortgage FraudEmbezzlement & Misappropriation of FundsConstruction Fraud
What is fraud?Theft…Stealing someone’s money or propertyFalse pretenses…criminal lies and  induces someone to part with their money or property
Who are Perpetrators?IndividualsNotariesLendersBrokers/AgentsConstruction ContractorsFamily
Common crimes:Forged Title TransfersForeclosure FraudEmbezzlementsMortgage FraudPredatory LendingRental Schemes/Rent SkimmingReal Estate Investment SchemesIdentity Theft
Forged Documents/Fraudulent Conveyances:Steal the Equity in the HomeLoan taken on Property or sell PropertyVictim/Homeowner has no knowledgeAchieved by forged Grant Deed and Recording Title Transfer Sometimes Accomplished through forged Power of AttorneyResult:  Conversion of Victim’s property to cash
What kind of fraud do we see in your industry?
Foreclosure Fraud:Desperate Homeowner in ForeclosureMay offer to take title to cure defaultMay offer to rent back houseOften tells homeowner saving their creditSteals Equity…Sells House…Evicts VictimOften Foreclosure sale will give distressed homeowner the equity after debt is paid!!
EQUITY SKIMMINGStraw Buyer UsedForged or False Loan Documents submitted to the LenderFalse Credit ReportsStraw Buyer Quit Claims to InvestorInvestor Fails to make Mortgage PaymentsRents Property Until Foreclosure
Mortgage Elimination Scams:Dorian GroupSeminars all over the countryOver-inflated appraisalsMultiple Loans on property w/Gift-back programsLender never sees last minute addendumsMillions of dollars on a single piece of property
Predatory Lending:Loans with Exorbitant Fees and PointsNever explained to VictimElderly and Disabled are targeted by unscrupulous LendersVictim is unable to make monthly payments and Lender makes the loan anyway
Reverse Mortgages:Targets ElderlySB 1609/Civil Code 1923.2Prohibits lender from Requiring Victim to Purchase or offer an Annuity to the victimRequires Lender to refer borrower to counseling… 5 approved by HUDBorrower must have a certificate of completion of counseling services before completion of loan
How does this crisis affect us? Hundreds of  Subprime lenders have gone out of business.Billions of dollars were lost in city taxes from foreclosed/abandoned propertiesConfidence in the American Marketplace is at an all time lowConfidence in the government and the industry is at an all time low.
What is happening now?
Buy and BailBorrower purchases a new home and then allows their previously owner-occupied home to go into foreclosure.Borrower tells new lender that they intend to sell or rent out the old house.  Old home upside down
Inflated rental income
No intent to sell or rent but states otherwise to new lender
Falsified rental agreements
Other false statements regarding the old homeShort Sale FraudProperty appraised below FMV.  Sold to “new purchaser” who then re-sells it for FMV
Pockets the money or
Resells to original owner for far less than they originally owed.
Both the current and new lender are victims in this crime.Equity StrippingForeclosure specialist assists homeownerHomeowner told to make payments to rescuerDeed transfer may be hidden in the paperworkRescuer pockets the money
Fraud Enforcement and Recovery Act (FERA)May 20, 2009Expands federal jurisdictionFederally related mortgage loanSecured by residential propertyOccupied by 1 to 4 familiesProceeds used to pay of an existing loan secured by propertyAnd whichInvolves FDIC or HUD or Fannie, Ginnie etc…Or creditor invests more than $1m per year in residential
18 U.S.C. 1014Whoever knowingly makes any false statement or report, or willfully overvalues any land, property or security for the purpose of influencing in any way any business or person that makes federally related mortgage loan.Statute of Limitation is 10 years.Maximum punishment $1m fine and 30 years
Signed by Governor in 2009
SB 36Requires a license endorsement for real estate brokers who solicit or negotiate mortgagesBusiness and Professions Code §10166Fines, License consequences
SB 94Loan Modification NO ADVANCE FEES … PERIODMisdemeanor $10,000 or $50,000 fine.  Also Requires translation
SB 237Appraisal ChangesB&P 11302Creates registration program for appraisal management companiesRequires licensing and background for all
SB 239Real Estate Fraud PC 532f – FelonyLies or omits on a mortgage applicationAllows the above lie to take placeReceives ANY compensation knowing either of the aboveRecords any documents knowing any of the above
AB 260Predatory Lending Civil Code 4995Defines “higher priced mortgage loan”Limits prepayment penalties to 2% 1st year 1% second yearProhibits negative amortizationLimits total amount of compensationRequires a Fiduciary duty on part of brokerRestricts “steering”$10,000 fine plus loss of license
AB 329Reverse Mortgage Civil Code section 1932.2Seller cannot be associated with other financial or insurance entitiesNo referals to other productsGive list of at least 10 HUD approved counsellorsMust give Checklist of questions for counsellorLoan Cannot be approved until signed checklist returned to lender
AB 957Seller CANNOT require a specific escrow agent or title insurance3 times total costCivil Code Section 1103.20
AB 1160Mortgages must now include a summary of terms in whatever language is used to negotiate itPrior to execution and no less than 3 days after release of applicationSpanish, Chinese, Tagalog, Vietnamese or Korean.$10,000 fine.
Other CrimesFiling False Statements (PC 115.5)Forgery (PC 470)Obtaining $ or Property by False Pretenses (PC 532)False Financial Statements Credit/Loan Applications (PC 532a)Unlawful Notarial Acts  (GC 8227.2)Elder Financial Abuse (PC 368)
REAL ESTATE AGENTS Business & Professions 10176Applies to AgentsCovers Misrepresentations & False Loan DocumentsCan subject you to investigation by the DRE;  which may then be referred to us.
REPORTING A CRIME:Immigration status of the victim is not relevantContracts for the sale of real property should be in your first languageDon’t be embarrassed to report the crimeFraudsters prey on people who will trust them…Don’t trust them!!!!!
HOW ARE YOU A PERPETRATOR…?“BY AIDING & ABETTING…”
PRINCIPALSDIRECTLY & ACTIVELY COMMIT THE ACT CONSTITUTING THE CRIME; (E.G. “THE FORGER”)AIDERS/ABETTERSEQUALLY GUILTY
AIDERS & ABETTERSA Person Person aids and abets when:(1)  with knowledge of the unlawful purpose of the perpetrator and; (2)  with the intent or purpose of committing/encouraging or facilitating the commission of a crime(3)  by act or advice aids, promotes, encourages, or instigates the commission of a crime  You know a statement is false and submit the loan anyway…
WHAT ABOUT DUTY OF CONFIDENTIALITY…?Government Code Section 7470 provides in relevant part:“This section shall not preclude a financial institution , in its discretion from initiating contact with, and disclosing customer financial records to, appropriate state agencies concerning suspect violations of any law…”
Red Flags in Real Estate Transactions:Power of Attorney used without ExplanationNo property inspection Seller procures AppraiserRequest to Avoid EscrowRequest to Avoid Title InsuranceCash Payments made outside Escrow
More Red Flags…Disparity in Document DatesRecent LiensPost Office Box Listed for Borrower or EmployerSudden Changes to EscrowEscrow Instructions  & Addendums not sent to Lender
WHAT CAN YOU DO…?Pay attention to the Red FlagsIf you see a Red Flag ask questionsConduct a limited inquiry and /or investigationContact you attorney ask for adviceIf it doesn’t sound right it probably isn’tIf you suspect FRAUD...Call our office!
WHAT TO REMEMBER?DISCLOSURE!DISCLOSURE!DISCLOSURE!

Re Professionals 2009

  • 3.
    REAL ESTATE FRAUDStanislausCounty District AttorneyW.R. McKenzie, Deputy District AttorneyGlenn Gulley, Criminal InvestigatorMark Smith, Criminal Investigator
  • 4.
    A LITTLE ABOUTUS:June 2005…SB 537 passed (Govt. Code 27388)$3.00 every Recorded Real Estate Document to go to Trust Fund for FraudStanislaus County began January 2006Full Time DDATwo Criminal Investigators
  • 5.
    What do weDo:Focus on investigation and prosecution of Real Estate FraudEmphasis on Crimes that impact Vulnerable Victims:Elderly, Disabled, Unsophisticated, Foreclosure victimsEducational programs in the CommunityTo help reduce the number of victims
  • 6.
    More Specifically,What dowe Do:Investigate Frauds and ForgeriesForeclosure FraudTitle FraudFiling False Financial Statements in relation to Mortgage FraudEmbezzlement & Misappropriation of FundsConstruction Fraud
  • 7.
    What is fraud?Theft…Stealingsomeone’s money or propertyFalse pretenses…criminal lies and induces someone to part with their money or property
  • 8.
  • 9.
    Common crimes:Forged TitleTransfersForeclosure FraudEmbezzlementsMortgage FraudPredatory LendingRental Schemes/Rent SkimmingReal Estate Investment SchemesIdentity Theft
  • 10.
    Forged Documents/Fraudulent Conveyances:Stealthe Equity in the HomeLoan taken on Property or sell PropertyVictim/Homeowner has no knowledgeAchieved by forged Grant Deed and Recording Title Transfer Sometimes Accomplished through forged Power of AttorneyResult: Conversion of Victim’s property to cash
  • 11.
    What kind offraud do we see in your industry?
  • 12.
    Foreclosure Fraud:Desperate Homeownerin ForeclosureMay offer to take title to cure defaultMay offer to rent back houseOften tells homeowner saving their creditSteals Equity…Sells House…Evicts VictimOften Foreclosure sale will give distressed homeowner the equity after debt is paid!!
  • 13.
    EQUITY SKIMMINGStraw BuyerUsedForged or False Loan Documents submitted to the LenderFalse Credit ReportsStraw Buyer Quit Claims to InvestorInvestor Fails to make Mortgage PaymentsRents Property Until Foreclosure
  • 14.
    Mortgage Elimination Scams:DorianGroupSeminars all over the countryOver-inflated appraisalsMultiple Loans on property w/Gift-back programsLender never sees last minute addendumsMillions of dollars on a single piece of property
  • 15.
    Predatory Lending:Loans withExorbitant Fees and PointsNever explained to VictimElderly and Disabled are targeted by unscrupulous LendersVictim is unable to make monthly payments and Lender makes the loan anyway
  • 16.
    Reverse Mortgages:Targets ElderlySB1609/Civil Code 1923.2Prohibits lender from Requiring Victim to Purchase or offer an Annuity to the victimRequires Lender to refer borrower to counseling… 5 approved by HUDBorrower must have a certificate of completion of counseling services before completion of loan
  • 17.
    How does thiscrisis affect us? Hundreds of Subprime lenders have gone out of business.Billions of dollars were lost in city taxes from foreclosed/abandoned propertiesConfidence in the American Marketplace is at an all time lowConfidence in the government and the industry is at an all time low.
  • 18.
  • 19.
    Buy and BailBorrowerpurchases a new home and then allows their previously owner-occupied home to go into foreclosure.Borrower tells new lender that they intend to sell or rent out the old house. Old home upside down
  • 20.
  • 21.
    No intent tosell or rent but states otherwise to new lender
  • 22.
  • 23.
    Other false statementsregarding the old homeShort Sale FraudProperty appraised below FMV. Sold to “new purchaser” who then re-sells it for FMV
  • 24.
  • 25.
    Resells to originalowner for far less than they originally owed.
  • 26.
    Both the currentand new lender are victims in this crime.Equity StrippingForeclosure specialist assists homeownerHomeowner told to make payments to rescuerDeed transfer may be hidden in the paperworkRescuer pockets the money
  • 27.
    Fraud Enforcement andRecovery Act (FERA)May 20, 2009Expands federal jurisdictionFederally related mortgage loanSecured by residential propertyOccupied by 1 to 4 familiesProceeds used to pay of an existing loan secured by propertyAnd whichInvolves FDIC or HUD or Fannie, Ginnie etc…Or creditor invests more than $1m per year in residential
  • 28.
    18 U.S.C. 1014Whoeverknowingly makes any false statement or report, or willfully overvalues any land, property or security for the purpose of influencing in any way any business or person that makes federally related mortgage loan.Statute of Limitation is 10 years.Maximum punishment $1m fine and 30 years
  • 29.
  • 30.
    SB 36Requires alicense endorsement for real estate brokers who solicit or negotiate mortgagesBusiness and Professions Code §10166Fines, License consequences
  • 31.
    SB 94Loan ModificationNO ADVANCE FEES … PERIODMisdemeanor $10,000 or $50,000 fine. Also Requires translation
  • 32.
    SB 237Appraisal ChangesB&P11302Creates registration program for appraisal management companiesRequires licensing and background for all
  • 33.
    SB 239Real EstateFraud PC 532f – FelonyLies or omits on a mortgage applicationAllows the above lie to take placeReceives ANY compensation knowing either of the aboveRecords any documents knowing any of the above
  • 34.
    AB 260Predatory LendingCivil Code 4995Defines “higher priced mortgage loan”Limits prepayment penalties to 2% 1st year 1% second yearProhibits negative amortizationLimits total amount of compensationRequires a Fiduciary duty on part of brokerRestricts “steering”$10,000 fine plus loss of license
  • 35.
    AB 329Reverse MortgageCivil Code section 1932.2Seller cannot be associated with other financial or insurance entitiesNo referals to other productsGive list of at least 10 HUD approved counsellorsMust give Checklist of questions for counsellorLoan Cannot be approved until signed checklist returned to lender
  • 36.
    AB 957Seller CANNOTrequire a specific escrow agent or title insurance3 times total costCivil Code Section 1103.20
  • 37.
    AB 1160Mortgages mustnow include a summary of terms in whatever language is used to negotiate itPrior to execution and no less than 3 days after release of applicationSpanish, Chinese, Tagalog, Vietnamese or Korean.$10,000 fine.
  • 38.
    Other CrimesFiling FalseStatements (PC 115.5)Forgery (PC 470)Obtaining $ or Property by False Pretenses (PC 532)False Financial Statements Credit/Loan Applications (PC 532a)Unlawful Notarial Acts (GC 8227.2)Elder Financial Abuse (PC 368)
  • 39.
    REAL ESTATE AGENTSBusiness & Professions 10176Applies to AgentsCovers Misrepresentations & False Loan DocumentsCan subject you to investigation by the DRE; which may then be referred to us.
  • 40.
    REPORTING A CRIME:Immigrationstatus of the victim is not relevantContracts for the sale of real property should be in your first languageDon’t be embarrassed to report the crimeFraudsters prey on people who will trust them…Don’t trust them!!!!!
  • 41.
    HOW ARE YOUA PERPETRATOR…?“BY AIDING & ABETTING…”
  • 42.
    PRINCIPALSDIRECTLY & ACTIVELYCOMMIT THE ACT CONSTITUTING THE CRIME; (E.G. “THE FORGER”)AIDERS/ABETTERSEQUALLY GUILTY
  • 43.
    AIDERS & ABETTERSAPerson Person aids and abets when:(1) with knowledge of the unlawful purpose of the perpetrator and; (2) with the intent or purpose of committing/encouraging or facilitating the commission of a crime(3) by act or advice aids, promotes, encourages, or instigates the commission of a crime You know a statement is false and submit the loan anyway…
  • 44.
    WHAT ABOUT DUTYOF CONFIDENTIALITY…?Government Code Section 7470 provides in relevant part:“This section shall not preclude a financial institution , in its discretion from initiating contact with, and disclosing customer financial records to, appropriate state agencies concerning suspect violations of any law…”
  • 45.
    Red Flags inReal Estate Transactions:Power of Attorney used without ExplanationNo property inspection Seller procures AppraiserRequest to Avoid EscrowRequest to Avoid Title InsuranceCash Payments made outside Escrow
  • 46.
    More Red Flags…Disparityin Document DatesRecent LiensPost Office Box Listed for Borrower or EmployerSudden Changes to EscrowEscrow Instructions & Addendums not sent to Lender
  • 47.
    WHAT CAN YOUDO…?Pay attention to the Red FlagsIf you see a Red Flag ask questionsConduct a limited inquiry and /or investigationContact you attorney ask for adviceIf it doesn’t sound right it probably isn’tIf you suspect FRAUD...Call our office!
  • 48.
  • 49.
    OFFICE OF THEDISTRICT ATTORNEY(209) 525-5550
  • 51.
    10 tips forAvoiding Fraud:What are you signing…Get an attorneyCheck References of Industry ProfessionalsBeware of Promises of Outrageous Profits Always conduct business in Office or BankBeware of Telephone solicitations Check Comparable sales in areaCheck Documents carefully…Avoid pressure to sign
  • 52.
    10 Tips toAvoid Fraud (cont.)Review History of propertyMake sure you understand the terms of your mortgage then check against actual documentsBeware of Alleged Business people who are “Mobile”…Never sign Blank DocumentsIf it sounds to good to be true…. IT IS!!!!!