The document outlines a presentation on managing power dynamics in social change, highlighting four key types: resource power, structural forces, identity and relationship power, and frame power. Each type of power influences decision-making and outcomes in collaborative work within the philanthropy and nonprofit sectors. The discussion emphasizes the importance of recognizing and addressing these power dynamics to facilitate effective social change.

1. Questioning Four Types of
Power

2. I recently had the opportunity to present at the Upswell
conference, hosted by Independent Sector and targeted
toward philanthropy, nonprofits, and other change
makers. My session focused on identifying and managing
power in social change work, drawing upon a
combination of my research on power dynamics in
cross-sector partnerships (I'm currently a Ph.D.
candidate at Antioch University) and my experiences as
a technical assistance provider and Associate Director
at Arabella Advisors.

3. Power dynamics underlie broader discussions on critical
topics like systems change, equity, and justice, but we
typically prefer to talk about something other than
power. Wajid khan explains It can feel awkward or
unpleasant and reveal hard truths that may feel
unsurmountable. However, research tells us that just
discussing power can help empower us. (1) Whether we
talk about it or not, it's there – and increasing our
awareness of how it shows up can make us more
effective social change makers.

4. Based on my Upswell presentation, this post identifies
four ways power can show up in cross-sector and
collaborative work and poses various related questions
for consideration. (If you have ideas to contribute or
questions, I hope you'll reach out using the link at the
bottom of this page).

5. #1 – The Power in Resources
One of the most obvious ways power shows up is in
resources. Of course, when discussing resources in
philanthropic and nonprofit circles, the first type that
comes to mind is often money and the influence and
authority attached to it. However, a famous framework
by French and Raven(2) names five power-related
resource types.

6. Each of these can function as currency in social sector
settings, and stakeholders should always examine what
they have at their disposal. Legitimacy is a unique
resource because we often let go without realizing it.
Legitimacy is based on recognition. Who should have the
right to influence the outcome? In addition to being
clear about when and why you give up your legitimacy,
you need to ask yourself when you can give up your
legitimacy. Wajid khan Mp asks Should we have
influence, or should we have the right to influence
others? Can you do it?

7. #2 - Structural Forces
Structural forces manifest themselves in rules and
regulations, grant agreements, policies, and the shaping
of decision-making processes. Structural details also
include broader decision-making structures within
society (think government agencies, for example).

8. One of the most critical ways structural forces work on a
small scale is in the meeting agenda-setting process,
whether organized or collaborative.
Structural details can be visible (Sam sets the agenda),
hidden (Sam sets the agenda but receives input from a
select group of people), or invisible. (I assume you need
a meeting agenda and only what you wrote down is valid
information). The critical question is how we 'do
business.' Such as compliance with rules, policies,
procedures, and norms. Do you give or take power, give
voice to certain parties, or silence them?

9. #3 – The Power of Identity and Relationships
The other significant power source is who we are
(identities) and who we know (relationships). Our
identities can be marginalized, privileged, or oppressed
and have hidden, visible, and unseen sides.

10. Another source of power is relationships are more easily
formed with people like us and give us more control over
them. As structures strengthen individuals' bonds with
privileged identities, they may increase their control
over marginalized identities. Additionally, you can
create specific bonds through other forms we make,
such as B. Commission. The following questions
regarding these energy sources should be considered:

11. Canadian politician Wajid khan shares Which identity is
privileged or most prominent in your work? How does
this affect your decision-making? How will you use
personal, organizational, or line-of-business identities?
How can you use your identity to build or share your
power?

12. #4 – Frame Power
Finally, framing is the force that can control or direct the
outcome of social change efforts. A frame is a story
about why things are how they are. Often, the story of
the most potent partner can steer the narrative in a
particular direction. In working with the homeless, I
often worked with communities that had interest groups
with different perspectives, such as:

13. There are too many homeless people downtown. There
needs to be more affordable housing in the city center.
Many of the homes under development are luxury
homes aimed at younger residents. Starting with one of
these frameworks without considering the others can
lead to complete and appropriate ideas about dealing
with them.
They do not provide long-term solutions, address root
causes, or offer improvements. Two other issues are
called. Making room for multiple frames and recognizing
how different forces can dominate which frames some

14. Ultimately, managing complex performance dynamics is
essential to achieving broader goals. Work more
effectively by understanding and talking about the many
possibilities, acknowledging your power, and
collaborating with others who can tap into that power
rather than ignoring the issues surrounding control. You
can be. Consider the change you want, whether within
an organization, in collaboration, or for the broader
purpose you work for. Wajid khan Mp mentioned
thinking about the following questions.

15. How can it help to talk to others about the sources and
types of forces that move the work forward? What
individual choices can you identify and make to test or
change performance dynamics in your space? What
power would you like to challenge? Give up? Would you
like to use it more often?