2. ResponsibleReturn.com
Consulting & Software as a Service business focusing on bringing social
good out of its silos [in the nonprofit & academic spaces] and fully
integrating systems-oriented principles into business strategy.
Twitter: @responsibleROI
Facebook: /responsiblereturn
5. Like Happiness...
The economics of happiness has spawned a
variety of global interpretations:
● Social Progress Index
● Happiness Index (S. Korea)
● Better Life Index (OECD)
● Multidimensional Poverty Index (Oxford, UK)
● Gross Domestic Happiness (France)
● Green & Happiness Index (Thailand)
● Human Development Index (UNDP)
● Satisfaction w Life Index (IDB)
6. Diverse Examples of Happiness Economics
‘Happiest’ countries:
Wealthy, developed
Scandinavian Countries
● subsidized higher education
● subsidized healthcare
● extensive public transportation
● bike-friendly urban infrastructure
● declared Lutheran, practicing
atheists
Pioneer of ‘happiness’
metric: Impoverished,
Agricultural Bhutan
● lack of access to primary
education
● extreme poverty
● chronic unemployment
● rooted in Buddhist philosophy
7. Origin & History
● Originally addressed in part by ‘Welfare
Economics’ & Behavioral economics (Daniel
Kahneman)
● 1972, first mention of ‘Happiness’ -- King of
Bhutan debuted ‘Gross National Happiness’
8. For today, consider….
● Ultimately, the ‘happiness’ is a misnomer - and is insufficient to
articulate the true gap in our 21st century economy
● The name inspires questions and controversy, which distract from
the true issue:
o Is an economic system really responsible for the individual
happiness of citizens?
o Is it possible to understand happiness on a ‘cultural curve’ (ie
variety of cultural norms which dictate a society’s
perspectives)?
o Is something so complex & subjective possible outside of an
authoritarian/homogenous culture (ie like Bhutan & Denmark)?
9. Focusing on shared underlying principles...
● non-financial indicators of wellbeing
● intangible elements of social inequality
● placing cost on the general decline of
environment/eco. diversity
● quality of life factors (ie health, community,
etc.)
10. Focus: Adding Economic Value
While progress towards a more robust understanding of human
progress is good, it does not fully capture the problem.
● GDP is an insufficient indicator of progress in the 21st
century, negating the true impact of transactions on
future generations + the rest of the world
● However, you may change an economic structure as
much as you want, but without addressing those
affecting different parts of society- change won’t happen
o Example: simply saying that a place lacks ecological diversity still doesn’t get at the heart
of WHY it doesn’t, who is responsible & how you can repair it
11. Example: Real Cost of a Burger
Does a McDonald’s burger really “cost”
society $1?
Considering the eventual healthcare costs (due to lack of nutrition), the subsidization of
beef production, the environmental damage of runoff from most factory meat farms, and
more…..
it’s estimated the true cost of a burger
is roughly $30
12. The Illusion of Price
“It’s the deep, ever-mounting, unpaid debt of
harm that business as usual owes people,
communities, society, the natural world, and
future generations.” (Umair Haque)
13. Opportunity: Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR)
● This is how organizations are held
accountable for the impact they cause in
society
● Trend of CSR has grown with the evolution of
happiness/welfare economics
● Demand for CSR has increased through
customer requests & global government
reporting requirements
14. Problem: Corporates Missing the Mark
● Lack of regulation in CSR leads to false
reports
● Unsubstantiated claims of value creation
● Manipulated data
● Perception of responsibility in limited terms
(ie a “green” company which treats their employees terribly)
15. Responsible Return
● Consulting for businesses that aim to create
authentic value for society (ie be socially
responsible)
● Creating a software product that maps
corporate impact
● Seeking support for the launch of a sister
nonprofit to hold corporates accountable in
this unregulated space
17. ResponsibleReturn.com
Consulting & Software as a Service business focusing on bringing social
good out of its silos [in the nonprofit & academic spaces] and fully
integrating systems-oriented principles into business strategy.
Twitter: @responsibleROI
Facebook: /responsiblereturn
18. Resources
● Short Guide to ‘Gross National Happiness’ (GNH)
● Centre for Bhutan Studies & GNH Research
● Buddhist Origin of Bhutan’s GNH
● Nestle in Exacerbates California Drought
● Cultural Bias in Copenhagen, DK
● New Capitalism: Umair Haque
Editor's Notes
-Many different shades/perspectives on this topic
-Jillian’s been posting some stuff about Denmark & Scandinavia on H&S fb…. along with Gross National Happiness in Bhutan
-& Technically: Econ of Happiness in Bhutan is not the same as Econ of Happiness in Scandinavia
*Let’s get some understanding of the perspective of the audience*
*shout out some words + concepts that you associate with happiness & we’ll take a vote
-contentment
-safety
-friends & family
-prosperity
*now, which ones would attribute to an economic system?
-Many different shades/perspectives on this topic
-Jillian’s been posting some stuff about Denmark & Scandinavia on H&S fb…. along with Gross National Happiness in Bhutan
-& Technically: Econ of Happiness in Bhutan is not the same as Econ of Happiness in Scandinavia
*Let’s get some understanding of the perspective of the audience*
*shout out some words + concepts that you associate with happiness & we’ll take a vote
-contentment
-safety
-friends & family
-prosperity
*now, which ones would attribute to an economic system?
-let’s expand on these differences:
-1972, Bhutan introduced GNH to country
-Bhutan: goal is to have electricity to 100% of rural population by 2020
(https://www.devex.com/news/happy-but-poor-measuring-development-in-bhutan-82420 )
-Scandinavian countries scored high because they said they had a high level of security, sense of satisfaction with their lives
(http://www.theguardian.com/news/2013/nov/20/mental-health-antidepressants-global-trends )
-These research institutions pioneer studies regarding: the relationship between money & contentment, contentment & security, and ____
-1972 was the first mention of ‘Happiness’ --King of Bhutan debuted ‘Gross National Happiness’
-but ultimately, the ‘happiness’ is a misnomer - and is insufficient to articulate the true gap in our 21st century economy
-the name inspires questions and controversy, which distract from the true issue:
*is an economic system really responsible for the individual happiness of citizens?
*is it possible to understand happiness on a cultural curve? (ie Scandinavian culture of verbalized contentment, but all countries have some of the highest #of prescribed antidepressants)
*Is something so complex possible outside of an authoritarian/homogenous culture (ie like Bhutan & Denmark)?
Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD)
Inter-American Development Bank (IDB)
-the bigger picture is ultimately to focus on greater non-financial indicators in determining social progress & success:
*health
*ecological diversity
1. Psychological Wellbeing
2. Standard of Living
3. Good Governance
4.Health
5.Education
6.Community Vitality
7.Cultural Diversity and Resilience
8. Time Use
9. Ecological Diversity and Resilience
-what I want to discuss today: what I believe is the true underlying gap in our economy
-while progress towards a more robust understanding of human progress is good, it does not fully capture the problem
-you can change an economic structure as much as you want, but without addressing those affecting different parts of society- change won’t happen
-Example: simply saying that a place lacks ecological diversity still doesn’t get at the heart of WHY it doesn’t, and who is responsible & able to repair it
-this is a greater shift of how impact get measured in society & putting a true price on the ‘transactions’ that occur
true cost of a burger is estimated at $30:-healthcare (ie no nutrition)
-production mystery meat/beef
-subsidized beef production
“the [current outdated capitalism’s] cornerstones undercount costs (ignoring damage) and overcount benefits (overstate how products make people better off).”
(11, Manifesto)
-this is the place where players are actually beginning to be held accountable to the impact they cause in society
-trend has grown with econ of happiness/welfare econ
-Europe require large/public companies to report on some CSR elements
-India requires large/public companies to report
-Becoming strategic in US
-local govts requiring LEED buildings
-
-fully integrate socially-responsible thinking into their business strategy
-we will not stand for continued false claims of social responsibility - which ruin it for authentic businesses