Program ’11: The best fungicide program
for YOUR putting greens


Lane Tredway
Associate Professor and Extension Specialist
Department of Plant Pathology
North Carolina State University
Heat imposed severe stress on creeping bentgrass
greens in 2010.

                               30
                                        departure from normal HIGH temperature
                                        departure from normal LOW temperature
                             22.5
 Departure from Normal (F)




                               15

                              7.5

                                0

                              -7.5

                              -15

                             -22.5
                                  May        June         July       August      Sept   Oct
The diagnostic
lab saw some bacteria
    in our samples.
Which bacteria
did they see? Is it a
     pathogen?
                            The diagnostic
                        lab saw some bacteria
                            in our samples.
Which bacteria
                    did they see? Is it a
                         pathogen?
                                                The diagnostic
                                            lab saw some bacteria
      They didn’t say, but                      in our samples.
clearly we have a huge bacteria
         problem here.
Acidovorax sp.
Xanthomonas translucens

No suspected pathogens
Identifying the Acidovorax species associated with
creeping bentgrass putting greens.
Bacteria Research Plans for 2011

  • closing in on an identification for the Acidovorax
    species associated with creeping bentgrasss

  • inoculations of field plots with Acidovorax and
    Xanthomonas isolates to determine their
    pathogenicity

  • evaluation of antibiotics and other compounds
    as possible control practices
The problems in 2010 actually started in May.

                              7
Cumulative Rainfall (in.)




                            5.25




                             3.5




                            1.75




                              0
                                   Jan   Feb   Mar   Apr   May   Jun   Jul   Aug   Sept   Oct   Nov
Pythium root rot
Many fungicide programs are weak against Pythium.

   May 13      Headway (1.5 fl oz)

   May 27      Concert (4.5 fl oz)

   June 10     Renown (4.5 fl oz)

   June 24     Daconil + Fore (3.2 + 4 oz)

   July 8      Medallion + Concert + Signature (0.25 + 4.5 + 4)

   July 22     Renown + Fore (4.5 + 4 oz)

   August 5    Medallion + Concert + Signature (0.25 + 4.5 + 4)

   August 20   Daconil + Fore (3.2 + 4 oz)
Pythium root rot is driven by soil moisture.
Program 13 offers no Pythium root rot protection.

          May 22      Tartan (2 fl oz)

          June 5      Insignia (0.9 oz)

          June 19     Spectro (5.76 oz)

          July 3      Signature + Daconil (4 + 3.2 oz)

          July 17     Insignia (0.9 oz)

          July 31     Signature + Daconil (4 + 3.2 oz)

          August 14   26GT (4 fl oz)

          August 28   Tartan (2 fl oz)
“It can’t be a disease because I’m on Program 13!”
“I sprayed Eagle because I’m on Program X and
it was on the schedule.”
Spray programs are not uncommon in agriculture.




flickr:TaminaMiller
Every golf course is different.

Climate, microclimate,
expectations, and
management styles vary.
Art and Science
Where’s the art in this?
Let’s put the art back in
disease control!
Program ’11
  How to develop and implement a fungicide program.
Program ’11
  How to develop and implement a fungicide program.

  1. develop list of diseases based on location, cultivar, soil
     type, and history
Program ’11
  How to develop and implement a fungicide program.

  1. develop list of diseases based on location, cultivar, soil
     type, and history
  2. use historical weather data to determine when each
     disease is ‘normally’ active
Program ’11
  How to develop and implement a fungicide program.

  1. develop list of diseases based on location, cultivar, soil
     type, and history
  2. use historical weather data to determine when each
     disease is ‘normally’ active
  3. select product(s) that will control the disease(s) that are
     expected to be active each week
Program ’11
  How to develop and implement a fungicide program.

  1. develop list of diseases based on location, cultivar, soil
     type, and history
  2. use historical weather data to determine when each
     disease is ‘normally’ active
  3. select product(s) that will control the disease(s) that are
     expected to be active each week
  4. select rates, intervals, and application method
Program ’11
  How to develop and implement a fungicide program.

  1. develop list of diseases based on location, cultivar, soil
     type, and history
  2. use historical weather data to determine when each
     disease is ‘normally’ active
  3. select product(s) that will control the disease(s) that are
     expected to be active each week
  4. select rates, intervals, and application method
  5. adjust as needed based on actual weather conditions
1. What diseases do you need to control?
• ‘A-1’ creeping bentgrass
• established in 2005
• USGA construction
                                                                dollar spot




                                            Pythium root rot



                      algae



                                                               brown patch


   fairy ring


                              Pythium root dysfunction
2. What conditions favor these diseases?
Pythium root dysfunction - average daily soil temperatures
between 50ºF and 70ºF

fairy ring - average daily soil temperatures between 55ºF and
65ºF

dollar spot - low temperatures above 50ºF

algae - high temperatures above 80ºF

brown patch - low temperatures above 60ºF

Pythium root rot - wet soils
3. Determine when disease activity is expected.
3. Determine when disease activity is expected.
Too
    many
  fungicides
to choose from!
                  flickr:kanickmoses
4. Resources for fungicide selection.

• product labels

• Pest Control for Professional Turf Managers

• turf disease profiles (turfpathology.org)

• disease management utility (turfpathology.org)

• Chemical Control of Turfgrass Diseases

  (Vincelli)
4. Resources for fungicide selection.

• product labels

• Pest Control for Professional Turf Managers

• turf disease profiles (turfpathology.org)

• disease management utility (turfpathology.org)

• Chemical Control of Turfgrass Diseases

  (Vincelli)
4. Resources for fungicide selection.

• product labels

• Pest Control for Professional Turf Managers

• turf disease profiles (turfpathology.org)

• disease management utility (turfpathology.org)

• Chemical Control of Turfgrass Diseases

  (Vincelli)
Disease Management Utility




                             turffiles.ncsu.edu/diseasemgmt
Disease Management Utility on TurfFiles




                                  turffiles.ncsu.edu/diseasemgmt
PRD

fairy ring

dollar spot

algae

brown patch

PRR
PRD

fairy ring

dollar spot

algae

brown patch

PRR
PRD           Segway
fairy ring

dollar spot

algae

brown patch

PRR
PRD           Segway
fairy ring

dollar spot

algae

brown patch

PRR           Segway
PRD           Segway
fairy ring             Bayleton
dollar spot

algae

brown patch

PRR           Segway
PRD           Segway         Honor
fairy ring             Bayleton
dollar spot

algae

brown patch

PRR           Segway
PRD           Segway         Honor
fairy ring             Bayleton
dollar spot                  Honor
algae

brown patch

PRR           Segway
PRD           Segway         Honor
fairy ring             Bayleton      Torque
dollar spot                  Honor
algae

brown patch

PRR           Segway
PRD           Segway         Honor
fairy ring             Bayleton      Torque
dollar spot                  Honor   Torque
algae

brown patch

PRR           Segway
PRD           Segway         Honor            Signature + Banol
fairy ring             Bayleton      Torque
dollar spot                  Honor   Torque
algae

brown patch

PRR           Segway
PRD           Segway         Honor            Signature + Banol
fairy ring             Bayleton      Torque
dollar spot                  Honor   Torque
algae

brown patch

PRR           Segway                          Signature + Banol
PRD           Segway         Honor            Signature + Banol
fairy ring             Bayleton      Torque
dollar spot                  Honor   Torque                 26GT
algae

brown patch

PRR           Segway                          Signature + Banol
PRD           Segway         Honor            Signature + Banol
fairy ring             Bayleton      Torque
dollar spot                  Honor   Torque                 26GT
algae

brown patch                                                26GT
PRR           Segway                          Signature + Banol
PRD           Segway         Honor            Signature + Banol
fairy ring             Bayleton      Torque
dollar spot                  Honor   Torque                 26GT
algae                                                       Daconil Ult
brown patch                                                26GT
PRR           Segway                          Signature + Banol
PRD           Segway         Honor            Signature + Banol
fairy ring             Bayleton      Torque
dollar spot                  Honor   Torque                 26GT          Disarm C
algae                                                       Daconil Ult
brown patch                                                26GT
PRR           Segway                          Signature + Banol
PRD           Segway         Honor            Signature + Banol
fairy ring             Bayleton      Torque
dollar spot                  Honor   Torque                 26GT          Disarm C
algae                                                       Daconil Ult   Disarm C
brown patch                                                26GT
PRR           Segway                          Signature + Banol
PRD           Segway         Honor            Signature + Banol
fairy ring             Bayleton      Torque
dollar spot                  Honor   Torque                 26GT          Disarm C
algae                                                       Daconil Ult   Disarm C
brown patch                                                26GT           Disarm C
PRR           Segway                          Signature + Banol
PRD           Segway         Honor            Signature + Banol
fairy ring             Bayleton      Torque
dollar spot                  Honor   Torque                 26GT          Disarm C   Honor
algae                                                       Daconil Ult   Disarm C
brown patch                                                26GT           Disarm C
PRR           Segway                          Signature + Banol
PRD           Segway         Honor            Signature + Banol
fairy ring             Bayleton      Torque
dollar spot                  Honor   Torque                 26GT          Disarm C   Honor
algae                                                       Daconil Ult   Disarm C   Fore
brown patch                                                26GT           Disarm C
PRR           Segway                          Signature + Banol
PRD           Segway         Honor            Signature + Banol
fairy ring             Bayleton      Torque
dollar spot                  Honor   Torque                 26GT          Disarm C   Honor
algae                                                       Daconil Ult   Disarm C   Fore
brown patch                                                26GT           Disarm C   Honor
PRR           Segway                          Signature + Banol
PRD           Segway         Honor            Signature + Banol
fairy ring             Bayleton      Torque
dollar spot                  Honor   Torque                 26GT          Disarm C   Honor
algae                                                       Daconil Ult   Disarm C   Fore
brown patch                                                26GT           Disarm C   Honor
PRR           Segway                          Signature + Banol    Terrazole
PRD           Segway         Honor            Signature + Banol
fairy ring             Bayleton      Torque
dollar spot                  Honor   Torque                 26GT          Disarm C   Honor
algae                                                       Daconil Ult   Disarm C   Fore
brown patch                                                26GT           Disarm C   Honor
PRR           Segway                          Signature + Banol    Terrazole    Subdue
PRD           Segway                Honor              Signature + Banol
fairy ring                Bayleton            Torque
dollar spot                         Honor     Torque                 26GT                  Disarm C            Honor
algae                                                                Daconil Ult           Disarm C            Fore
brown patch                                                         26GT                   Disarm C            Honor
PRR           Segway                                   Signature + Banol         Terrazole           Subdue




              Segway      Bayleton Honor      Torque   Signature     26GT        Terrazole Disarm C Subdue Honor

              0.9 fl oz   1 fl oz   1.1 oz    0.6 fl oz 4 oz         4 fl oz     4 fl oz   5 fl oz   1 fl oz   1.1 fl oz

              water-in    water-in water-in   water-in foliar        foliar      water-in foliar     water-in foliar

                                                       Banol         Daconil Ult                               Fore

                                                       2 fl oz       3.2 fl oz                                 6 oz

                                                       foliar        foliar                                    foliar
Program Infinity (March - June)

       Date                    Product(s)
     March 13              Segway (0.9 fl oz)
       April 3              Bayleton (1 fl oz)
      April 10              Honor (1.1 fl oz)
       May 1                Torque (0.6 fl oz)
       May 8           Signature + Banol (4 +2 oz)
      May 22           Daconil + 26GT (6 + 4 oz)
      May 29                Terrazole (4 oz)
      June 5                Disarm C (5 fl oz)
      June 12            Subdue Maxx (1 fl oz)
      June 19          Fore + Honor (6 + 1.1 oz)
Comparing ways to develop and implement
fungicide programs

       1. Program 13 (Clemson)

       2. BASF Program

       3. Bayer Program

       4. Syngenta Program

       5. Program Infinity

       6. Program ’11 - treatments adjusted as
          needed based on weather conditions
Program ’11: How to follow along...
Program ’11: How to follow along...

              turfpathology.org
Program ’11: How to follow along...

              turfpathology.org


              facebook.com/turfpathology
Program ’11: How to follow along...

              turfpathology.org


              facebook.com/turfpathology


              twitter.com/ncturfpathology
Program ’11: How to follow along...

              turfpathology.org


              facebook.com/turfpathology


              twitter.com/ncturfpathology


              feeds.feedburner.com/turfpathology
Support nematode
research at Clemson and
       NC State!




                          http://sharonapbio-taxonomy.wikispaces.com
Recovery from aerification is driven by fertility.

Program '11: The Best Fungicide Program for YOUR Putting Greens

  • 1.
    Program ’11: Thebest fungicide program for YOUR putting greens Lane Tredway Associate Professor and Extension Specialist Department of Plant Pathology North Carolina State University
  • 2.
    Heat imposed severestress on creeping bentgrass greens in 2010. 30 departure from normal HIGH temperature departure from normal LOW temperature 22.5 Departure from Normal (F) 15 7.5 0 -7.5 -15 -22.5 May June July August Sept Oct
  • 5.
    The diagnostic lab sawsome bacteria in our samples.
  • 6.
    Which bacteria did theysee? Is it a pathogen? The diagnostic lab saw some bacteria in our samples.
  • 7.
    Which bacteria did they see? Is it a pathogen? The diagnostic lab saw some bacteria They didn’t say, but in our samples. clearly we have a huge bacteria problem here.
  • 8.
  • 9.
    Identifying the Acidovoraxspecies associated with creeping bentgrass putting greens.
  • 10.
    Bacteria Research Plansfor 2011 • closing in on an identification for the Acidovorax species associated with creeping bentgrasss • inoculations of field plots with Acidovorax and Xanthomonas isolates to determine their pathogenicity • evaluation of antibiotics and other compounds as possible control practices
  • 11.
    The problems in2010 actually started in May. 7 Cumulative Rainfall (in.) 5.25 3.5 1.75 0 Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sept Oct Nov
  • 12.
  • 13.
    Many fungicide programsare weak against Pythium. May 13 Headway (1.5 fl oz) May 27 Concert (4.5 fl oz) June 10 Renown (4.5 fl oz) June 24 Daconil + Fore (3.2 + 4 oz) July 8 Medallion + Concert + Signature (0.25 + 4.5 + 4) July 22 Renown + Fore (4.5 + 4 oz) August 5 Medallion + Concert + Signature (0.25 + 4.5 + 4) August 20 Daconil + Fore (3.2 + 4 oz)
  • 14.
    Pythium root rotis driven by soil moisture.
  • 15.
    Program 13 offersno Pythium root rot protection. May 22 Tartan (2 fl oz) June 5 Insignia (0.9 oz) June 19 Spectro (5.76 oz) July 3 Signature + Daconil (4 + 3.2 oz) July 17 Insignia (0.9 oz) July 31 Signature + Daconil (4 + 3.2 oz) August 14 26GT (4 fl oz) August 28 Tartan (2 fl oz)
  • 16.
    “It can’t bea disease because I’m on Program 13!”
  • 17.
    “I sprayed Eaglebecause I’m on Program X and it was on the schedule.”
  • 18.
    Spray programs arenot uncommon in agriculture. flickr:TaminaMiller
  • 19.
    Every golf courseis different. Climate, microclimate, expectations, and management styles vary.
  • 20.
  • 22.
  • 23.
    Let’s put theart back in disease control!
  • 25.
    Program ’11 How to develop and implement a fungicide program.
  • 26.
    Program ’11 How to develop and implement a fungicide program. 1. develop list of diseases based on location, cultivar, soil type, and history
  • 27.
    Program ’11 How to develop and implement a fungicide program. 1. develop list of diseases based on location, cultivar, soil type, and history 2. use historical weather data to determine when each disease is ‘normally’ active
  • 28.
    Program ’11 How to develop and implement a fungicide program. 1. develop list of diseases based on location, cultivar, soil type, and history 2. use historical weather data to determine when each disease is ‘normally’ active 3. select product(s) that will control the disease(s) that are expected to be active each week
  • 29.
    Program ’11 How to develop and implement a fungicide program. 1. develop list of diseases based on location, cultivar, soil type, and history 2. use historical weather data to determine when each disease is ‘normally’ active 3. select product(s) that will control the disease(s) that are expected to be active each week 4. select rates, intervals, and application method
  • 30.
    Program ’11 How to develop and implement a fungicide program. 1. develop list of diseases based on location, cultivar, soil type, and history 2. use historical weather data to determine when each disease is ‘normally’ active 3. select product(s) that will control the disease(s) that are expected to be active each week 4. select rates, intervals, and application method 5. adjust as needed based on actual weather conditions
  • 32.
    1. What diseasesdo you need to control? • ‘A-1’ creeping bentgrass • established in 2005 • USGA construction dollar spot Pythium root rot algae brown patch fairy ring Pythium root dysfunction
  • 33.
    2. What conditionsfavor these diseases? Pythium root dysfunction - average daily soil temperatures between 50ºF and 70ºF fairy ring - average daily soil temperatures between 55ºF and 65ºF dollar spot - low temperatures above 50ºF algae - high temperatures above 80ºF brown patch - low temperatures above 60ºF Pythium root rot - wet soils
  • 35.
    3. Determine whendisease activity is expected.
  • 36.
    3. Determine whendisease activity is expected.
  • 37.
    Too many fungicides to choose from! flickr:kanickmoses
  • 38.
    4. Resources forfungicide selection. • product labels • Pest Control for Professional Turf Managers • turf disease profiles (turfpathology.org) • disease management utility (turfpathology.org) • Chemical Control of Turfgrass Diseases (Vincelli)
  • 39.
    4. Resources forfungicide selection. • product labels • Pest Control for Professional Turf Managers • turf disease profiles (turfpathology.org) • disease management utility (turfpathology.org) • Chemical Control of Turfgrass Diseases (Vincelli)
  • 40.
    4. Resources forfungicide selection. • product labels • Pest Control for Professional Turf Managers • turf disease profiles (turfpathology.org) • disease management utility (turfpathology.org) • Chemical Control of Turfgrass Diseases (Vincelli)
  • 41.
    Disease Management Utility turffiles.ncsu.edu/diseasemgmt
  • 42.
    Disease Management Utilityon TurfFiles turffiles.ncsu.edu/diseasemgmt
  • 43.
  • 44.
  • 45.
    PRD Segway fairy ring dollar spot algae brown patch PRR
  • 46.
    PRD Segway fairy ring dollar spot algae brown patch PRR Segway
  • 47.
    PRD Segway fairy ring Bayleton dollar spot algae brown patch PRR Segway
  • 48.
    PRD Segway Honor fairy ring Bayleton dollar spot algae brown patch PRR Segway
  • 49.
    PRD Segway Honor fairy ring Bayleton dollar spot Honor algae brown patch PRR Segway
  • 50.
    PRD Segway Honor fairy ring Bayleton Torque dollar spot Honor algae brown patch PRR Segway
  • 51.
    PRD Segway Honor fairy ring Bayleton Torque dollar spot Honor Torque algae brown patch PRR Segway
  • 52.
    PRD Segway Honor Signature + Banol fairy ring Bayleton Torque dollar spot Honor Torque algae brown patch PRR Segway
  • 53.
    PRD Segway Honor Signature + Banol fairy ring Bayleton Torque dollar spot Honor Torque algae brown patch PRR Segway Signature + Banol
  • 54.
    PRD Segway Honor Signature + Banol fairy ring Bayleton Torque dollar spot Honor Torque 26GT algae brown patch PRR Segway Signature + Banol
  • 55.
    PRD Segway Honor Signature + Banol fairy ring Bayleton Torque dollar spot Honor Torque 26GT algae brown patch 26GT PRR Segway Signature + Banol
  • 56.
    PRD Segway Honor Signature + Banol fairy ring Bayleton Torque dollar spot Honor Torque 26GT algae Daconil Ult brown patch 26GT PRR Segway Signature + Banol
  • 57.
    PRD Segway Honor Signature + Banol fairy ring Bayleton Torque dollar spot Honor Torque 26GT Disarm C algae Daconil Ult brown patch 26GT PRR Segway Signature + Banol
  • 58.
    PRD Segway Honor Signature + Banol fairy ring Bayleton Torque dollar spot Honor Torque 26GT Disarm C algae Daconil Ult Disarm C brown patch 26GT PRR Segway Signature + Banol
  • 59.
    PRD Segway Honor Signature + Banol fairy ring Bayleton Torque dollar spot Honor Torque 26GT Disarm C algae Daconil Ult Disarm C brown patch 26GT Disarm C PRR Segway Signature + Banol
  • 60.
    PRD Segway Honor Signature + Banol fairy ring Bayleton Torque dollar spot Honor Torque 26GT Disarm C Honor algae Daconil Ult Disarm C brown patch 26GT Disarm C PRR Segway Signature + Banol
  • 61.
    PRD Segway Honor Signature + Banol fairy ring Bayleton Torque dollar spot Honor Torque 26GT Disarm C Honor algae Daconil Ult Disarm C Fore brown patch 26GT Disarm C PRR Segway Signature + Banol
  • 62.
    PRD Segway Honor Signature + Banol fairy ring Bayleton Torque dollar spot Honor Torque 26GT Disarm C Honor algae Daconil Ult Disarm C Fore brown patch 26GT Disarm C Honor PRR Segway Signature + Banol
  • 63.
    PRD Segway Honor Signature + Banol fairy ring Bayleton Torque dollar spot Honor Torque 26GT Disarm C Honor algae Daconil Ult Disarm C Fore brown patch 26GT Disarm C Honor PRR Segway Signature + Banol Terrazole
  • 64.
    PRD Segway Honor Signature + Banol fairy ring Bayleton Torque dollar spot Honor Torque 26GT Disarm C Honor algae Daconil Ult Disarm C Fore brown patch 26GT Disarm C Honor PRR Segway Signature + Banol Terrazole Subdue
  • 65.
    PRD Segway Honor Signature + Banol fairy ring Bayleton Torque dollar spot Honor Torque 26GT Disarm C Honor algae Daconil Ult Disarm C Fore brown patch 26GT Disarm C Honor PRR Segway Signature + Banol Terrazole Subdue Segway Bayleton Honor Torque Signature 26GT Terrazole Disarm C Subdue Honor 0.9 fl oz 1 fl oz 1.1 oz 0.6 fl oz 4 oz 4 fl oz 4 fl oz 5 fl oz 1 fl oz 1.1 fl oz water-in water-in water-in water-in foliar foliar water-in foliar water-in foliar Banol Daconil Ult Fore 2 fl oz 3.2 fl oz 6 oz foliar foliar foliar
  • 66.
    Program Infinity (March- June) Date Product(s) March 13 Segway (0.9 fl oz) April 3 Bayleton (1 fl oz) April 10 Honor (1.1 fl oz) May 1 Torque (0.6 fl oz) May 8 Signature + Banol (4 +2 oz) May 22 Daconil + 26GT (6 + 4 oz) May 29 Terrazole (4 oz) June 5 Disarm C (5 fl oz) June 12 Subdue Maxx (1 fl oz) June 19 Fore + Honor (6 + 1.1 oz)
  • 67.
    Comparing ways todevelop and implement fungicide programs 1. Program 13 (Clemson) 2. BASF Program 3. Bayer Program 4. Syngenta Program 5. Program Infinity 6. Program ’11 - treatments adjusted as needed based on weather conditions
  • 72.
    Program ’11: Howto follow along...
  • 73.
    Program ’11: Howto follow along... turfpathology.org
  • 74.
    Program ’11: Howto follow along... turfpathology.org facebook.com/turfpathology
  • 75.
    Program ’11: Howto follow along... turfpathology.org facebook.com/turfpathology twitter.com/ncturfpathology
  • 76.
    Program ’11: Howto follow along... turfpathology.org facebook.com/turfpathology twitter.com/ncturfpathology feeds.feedburner.com/turfpathology
  • 79.
    Support nematode research atClemson and NC State! http://sharonapbio-taxonomy.wikispaces.com
  • 80.
    Recovery from aerificationis driven by fertility.