AMIR BARYLKO
            ADVANCED
         DESIGN PATTERNS



Amir Barylko               Advanced Design Patterns
WHO AM I?

  • Software     quality expert

  • Architect

  • Developer

  • Mentor

  • Great      cook

  • The    one who’s entertaining you for the next hour!
Amir Barylko                                          Advanced Design Patterns
RESOURCES

  • Email: amir@barylko.com

  • Twitter: @abarylko

  • Blog: http://www.orthocoders.com

  • Materials: http://www.orthocoders.com/presentations




Amir Barylko                                      Advanced Design Patterns
PATTERNS
                    What are they?
                What are anti-patterns?
               Which patterns do you use?




Amir Barylko                                Advanced Design Patterns
WHAT ARE PATTERNS?

  •Software         design Recipe
  •or     Solution
  •Should         be reusable
  •Should         be general
  •No          particular language
Amir Barylko                         Advanced Design Patterns
ANTI-PATTERNS
  •   More patterns != better design

  •   No cookie cutter

  •   Anti Patterns : Patterns to identify failure

      •   God Classes

      •   High Coupling

      •   Breaking SOLID principles....

      •   (name some)
Amir Barylko                                         Advanced Design Patterns
WHICH PATTERNS
                   DO YOU USE?
  • Fill   here with your patterns:




Amir Barylko                          Advanced Design Patterns
ADVANCED PATTERNS
                     Let’s vote!




Amir Barylko                       Advanced Design Patterns
SOME PATTERNS...

  • Chain      of resp. 18   • Event   Sourcing     • Null   Object
                              22
  • Proxy      1                                    • Factory    4
                             • List
  • ActiveRecord        12    Comprehension         • Strategy   11
                              1
  • Repository      5                               • DTO    4
                             • Object    Mother10
  • Event Aggregator                                • Page   Object 16
    26                       • Visitor   8

Amir Barylko                                             Advanced Design Patterns
CHAIN OF RESPONSIBILITY

  • More   than one object may handle a request, and the handler
    isn't known a priori.

  • The    handler should be ascertained automatically.

  • You want to issue request to one of several objects without
    specifying The receiver explicitly.

  • The set of objects that can handle a request should be
    specified dynamically

Amir Barylko                                          Advanced Design Patterns
Amir Barylko   Advanced Design Patterns
SnapToX



                  Next
                         SnapToY



                                   SnapToPrevious
                            Next




Amir Barylko                             Advanced Design Patterns
Amir Barylko   Advanced Design Patterns
PROXY

  • Avoid       creating the object until needed

  • Provides      a placeholder for additional functionality

  • Very       useful for mocking

  • Many       implementations exist (IoC, Dynamic proxies, etc)




Amir Barylko                                               Advanced Design Patterns
GOF




Amir Barylko         Advanced Design Patterns
PROXY SEQUENCE




Amir Barylko                Advanced Design Patterns
ACTIVERECORD

  • Isa Domain Model where classes match very closely the
    database structure

  • Each table is mapped to class with methods for finding,
    update, delete, etc.

  • Each       attribute is mapped to a column

  • Associations      are deduced from the classes


Amir Barylko                                         Advanced Design Patterns
create_table   "movies", :force => true do |t|
    t.string     "title"
    t.string     "description"
    t.datetime   "created_at"
    t.datetime   "updated_at"
  end

  create_table   "reviews", :force => true do |t|
    t.string     "name"
    t.integer    "stars"
    t.text       "comment"
    t.integer    "movie_id"
    t.datetime   "created_at"
    t.datetime   "updated_at"
  end

   class Movie < ActiveRecord::Base
     validates_presence_of :title, :description
     has_many :reviews
   end
   class Review < ActiveRecord::Base
     belongs_to :movie
   end


Amir Barylko                                        Advanced Design Patterns
movie = Movie.new

   movie.all # all records

   # filter by title
   movie.where(title: 'Spaceballs')

   # finds by attribute
   movie.find_by_title('Blazing Saddles')

   # order, skip some and limit the result
   movie.order('title DESC').skip(2).limit(5)

   # associations CRUD
   movie.reviews.create(name: 'Jay Sherman',
                   stars: 1,
                   comment: 'It stinks!')


Amir Barylko                                Advanced Design Patterns
REPOSITORY

  • Mediator        between domain and storage

  • Acts       like a collection of items

  • Supports        queries

  • Abstraction       of the storage




Amir Barylko                                     Advanced Design Patterns
Amir Barylko   Advanced Design Patterns
http://martinfowler.com/eaaCatalog/repository.html
Amir Barylko                                     Advanced Design Patterns
ANTIPATTERN
         CHEAPER BY THE DOZEN




Amir Barylko             Advanced Design Patterns
WHAT TO DO?

  • Use    a criteria or better a queryable result (LINQ)

  • Use    a factory to return repositories

  • Use    a UnitOfWork with a factory




Amir Barylko                                        Advanced Design Patterns
EVENT AGGREGATOR
  • Manage      events using a subscribe / publish mechanism

  • Isolates   subscribers from publishers

  • Decouple      events from actual models

  • Events     can be distributed

  • Centralize    event registration logic

  • No    need to track multiple objects


Amir Barylko                                           Advanced Design Patterns
Channel events
  from multiple
  objects into a
  single object to
  s i m p l i f y
  registration for
  clients



Amir Barylko         Advanced Design Patterns
MT COMMONS




Amir Barylko                Advanced Design Patterns
COUPLED




Amir Barylko             Advanced Design Patterns
DECOUPLED




Amir Barylko               Advanced Design Patterns
EVENT SOURCING

  • Register     all changes in the application using events

  • Event      should be persisted

  • Complete       Rebuild

  • Temporal      Query

  • Event      Replay


Amir Barylko                                              Advanced Design Patterns
http://martinfowler.com/eaaDev/EventSourcing.html
Amir Barylko                                    Advanced Design Patterns
Amir Barylko   Advanced Design Patterns
LIST COMPREHENSION

  • Syntax      Construct in languages

  • Describe      properties for the list (sequence)

  • Filter

  • Mapping

  • Same       idea for Set or Dictionary comprehension


Amir Barylko                                              Advanced Design Patterns
LANGUAGE COMPARISON
  • Scala
   for (x <- Stream.from(0); if x*x > 3) yield 2*x

  • LINQ
   var range = Enumerable.Range(0..20);
   from num in range where num * num > 3 select num * 2;

  • Clojure
   (take 20 (for [x (iterate inc 0) :when (> (* x x) 3)] (* 2 x)))


  • Ruby
   (1..20).select { |x| x * x > 3 }.map { |x| x * 2 }


Amir Barylko                                          Advanced Design Patterns
OBJECT MOTHER / BUILDER

  • Creates     an object for testing (or other) purposes

  • Assumes      defaults

  • Easy   to configure

  • Fluent     interface

  • Usually    has methods to to easily manipulate the domain


Amir Barylko                                            Advanced Design Patterns
public class When_adding_a_an_invalid_extra_frame
   {
       [Test]
       public void Should_throw_an_exception()
       {
           // arrange
           10.Times(() => this.GameBuilder.AddFrame(5, 4));

               var game = this.GameBuilder.Build();

               // act & assert
               new Action(() => game.Roll(8)).Should().Throw();
         }
   }




               http://orthocoders.com/2011/09/05/the-bowling-game-kata-first-attempt/


Amir Barylko                                                                Advanced Design Patterns
Amir Barylko   Advanced Design Patterns
VISITOR

  • Ability    to traverse (visit) a object structure

  • Different     visitors may produce different results

  • Avoid      littering the classes with particular operations




Amir Barylko                                               Advanced Design Patterns
LINQ EXPRESSION TREE




Amir Barylko                    Advanced Design Patterns
EXPRESSION VISITOR




Amir Barylko                   Advanced Design Patterns
AND EXPR EVALUATION




Amir Barylko               Advanced Design Patterns
NULL OBJECT

  • Represent “null” with      an actual instance

  • Provides      default functionality

  • Clear      semantics of “null” for that domain




Amir Barylko                                         Advanced Design Patterns
class animal {
    public:
       virtual void make_sound() = 0;
    };

    class dog : public animal {
       void make_sound() { cout << "woof!" << endl; }
    };

    class null_animal : public animal {
       void make_sound() { }
    };




           http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Null_Object_pattern


Amir Barylko                                      Advanced Design Patterns
FACTORY

  • Creates      instances by request

  • More       flexible than Singleton

  • Can    be configured to create different families of objects

  • IoC    containers are closely related

  • Can    be implemented dynamic based on interfaces

  • Can    be used also to release “resource” when not needed
Amir Barylko                                           Advanced Design Patterns
interface GUIFactory {
       public Button createButton();
   }

   class WinFactory implements GUIFactory {
       public Button createButton() {
           return new WinButton();
       }
   }
   class OSXFactory implements GUIFactory {
       public Button createButton() {
           return new OSXButton();
       }
   }

   interface Button {
       public void paint();
   }
      http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abstract_factory_pattern

Amir Barylko                                    Advanced Design Patterns
STRATEGY

  • Abstracts   the algorithm to solve a particular problem

  • Can    be configured dynamically

  • Are    interchangeable




Amir Barylko                                          Advanced Design Patterns
http://orthocoders.com/2010/04/
Amir Barylko                                     Advanced Design Patterns
DATA TRANSFER OBJECT

  • Simplifies   information transfer across services

  • Can    be optimized

  • Easy   to understand




Amir Barylko                                           Advanced Design Patterns
http://martinfowler.com/eaaCatalog/dataTransferObject.html

Amir Barylko                                 Advanced Design Patterns
PAGE OBJECT

  • Abstract      web pages functionality to be used usually in testing

  • Each       page can be reused

  • Changes       in the page impact only the implementation, not the
    clients




Amir Barylko                                              Advanced Design Patterns
class ProjectListPage
       include PageObject

         def navigate
           visit('/projects')
           self
         end

         def edit(project)
           row = find(:xpath, "//td[.='#{project.name}']")
           row.parent.click_link('Edit')
           ProjectEditPage.new
         end

         def projects
           all(:css, "#projects tr")......
         end
   end



Amir Barylko                                     Advanced Design Patterns
When /^I go to the projects page$/ do
       project_list_page.navigate
     end

     When /^I activate the project$/ do
       project_list_page.
         navigate.
         edit(current_project).
         activate.
         save
     end




Amir Barylko                          Advanced Design Patterns
QUESTIONS?




Amir Barylko                Advanced Design Patterns
RESOURCES

  • Email: amir@barylko.com, @abarylko

  • Slides: http://www.orthocoders.com/presentations

  • Patterns: Each   pattern example has a link




Amir Barylko                                      Advanced Design Patterns
RESOURCES II




Amir Barylko                  Advanced Design Patterns
RESOURCES III




Amir Barylko                   Advanced Design Patterns
QUALITY SOFTWARE
                    TRAINING
  • Topics: Kanban,    BDD & TDD.

  • When: May       4, 10-11 & 16-17

  • More       info: http://www.maventhought.com

  • Goal: Learn  techniques, methodologies and tools to improve
    the quality in your job.



Amir Barylko                                       Advanced Design Patterns

PRDCW-advanced-design-patterns

  • 1.
    AMIR BARYLKO ADVANCED DESIGN PATTERNS Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 2.
    WHO AM I? • Software quality expert • Architect • Developer • Mentor • Great cook • The one who’s entertaining you for the next hour! Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 3.
    RESOURCES •Email: amir@barylko.com • Twitter: @abarylko • Blog: http://www.orthocoders.com • Materials: http://www.orthocoders.com/presentations Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 4.
    PATTERNS What are they? What are anti-patterns? Which patterns do you use? Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 5.
    WHAT ARE PATTERNS? •Software design Recipe •or Solution •Should be reusable •Should be general •No particular language Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 6.
    ANTI-PATTERNS • More patterns != better design • No cookie cutter • Anti Patterns : Patterns to identify failure • God Classes • High Coupling • Breaking SOLID principles.... • (name some) Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 7.
    WHICH PATTERNS DO YOU USE? • Fill here with your patterns: Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 8.
    ADVANCED PATTERNS Let’s vote! Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 9.
    SOME PATTERNS... • Chain of resp. 18 • Event Sourcing • Null Object 22 • Proxy 1 • Factory 4 • List • ActiveRecord 12 Comprehension • Strategy 11 1 • Repository 5 • DTO 4 • Object Mother10 • Event Aggregator • Page Object 16 26 • Visitor 8 Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 10.
    CHAIN OF RESPONSIBILITY • More than one object may handle a request, and the handler isn't known a priori. • The handler should be ascertained automatically. • You want to issue request to one of several objects without specifying The receiver explicitly. • The set of objects that can handle a request should be specified dynamically Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 11.
    Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 12.
    SnapToX Next SnapToY SnapToPrevious Next Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 13.
    Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 14.
    PROXY •Avoid creating the object until needed • Provides a placeholder for additional functionality • Very useful for mocking • Many implementations exist (IoC, Dynamic proxies, etc) Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 15.
    GOF Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 16.
    PROXY SEQUENCE Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 17.
    ACTIVERECORD •Isa Domain Model where classes match very closely the database structure • Each table is mapped to class with methods for finding, update, delete, etc. • Each attribute is mapped to a column • Associations are deduced from the classes Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 18.
    create_table "movies", :force => true do |t| t.string "title" t.string "description" t.datetime "created_at" t.datetime "updated_at" end create_table "reviews", :force => true do |t| t.string "name" t.integer "stars" t.text "comment" t.integer "movie_id" t.datetime "created_at" t.datetime "updated_at" end class Movie < ActiveRecord::Base validates_presence_of :title, :description has_many :reviews end class Review < ActiveRecord::Base belongs_to :movie end Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 19.
    movie = Movie.new movie.all # all records # filter by title movie.where(title: 'Spaceballs') # finds by attribute movie.find_by_title('Blazing Saddles') # order, skip some and limit the result movie.order('title DESC').skip(2).limit(5) # associations CRUD movie.reviews.create(name: 'Jay Sherman', stars: 1, comment: 'It stinks!') Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 20.
    REPOSITORY •Mediator between domain and storage • Acts like a collection of items • Supports queries • Abstraction of the storage Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 21.
    Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 22.
  • 23.
    ANTIPATTERN CHEAPER BY THE DOZEN Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 24.
    WHAT TO DO? • Use a criteria or better a queryable result (LINQ) • Use a factory to return repositories • Use a UnitOfWork with a factory Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 25.
    EVENT AGGREGATOR • Manage events using a subscribe / publish mechanism • Isolates subscribers from publishers • Decouple events from actual models • Events can be distributed • Centralize event registration logic • No need to track multiple objects Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 26.
    Channel events from multiple objects into a single object to s i m p l i f y registration for clients Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 27.
    MT COMMONS Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 28.
    COUPLED Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 29.
    DECOUPLED Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 30.
    EVENT SOURCING • Register all changes in the application using events • Event should be persisted • Complete Rebuild • Temporal Query • Event Replay Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 31.
  • 32.
    Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 33.
    LIST COMPREHENSION • Syntax Construct in languages • Describe properties for the list (sequence) • Filter • Mapping • Same idea for Set or Dictionary comprehension Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 34.
    LANGUAGE COMPARISON • Scala for (x <- Stream.from(0); if x*x > 3) yield 2*x • LINQ var range = Enumerable.Range(0..20); from num in range where num * num > 3 select num * 2; • Clojure (take 20 (for [x (iterate inc 0) :when (> (* x x) 3)] (* 2 x))) • Ruby (1..20).select { |x| x * x > 3 }.map { |x| x * 2 } Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 35.
    OBJECT MOTHER /BUILDER • Creates an object for testing (or other) purposes • Assumes defaults • Easy to configure • Fluent interface • Usually has methods to to easily manipulate the domain Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 36.
    public class When_adding_a_an_invalid_extra_frame { [Test] public void Should_throw_an_exception() { // arrange 10.Times(() => this.GameBuilder.AddFrame(5, 4)); var game = this.GameBuilder.Build(); // act & assert new Action(() => game.Roll(8)).Should().Throw(); } } http://orthocoders.com/2011/09/05/the-bowling-game-kata-first-attempt/ Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 37.
    Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 38.
    VISITOR •Ability to traverse (visit) a object structure • Different visitors may produce different results • Avoid littering the classes with particular operations Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 39.
    LINQ EXPRESSION TREE AmirBarylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 40.
    EXPRESSION VISITOR Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 41.
    AND EXPR EVALUATION AmirBarylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 42.
    NULL OBJECT • Represent “null” with an actual instance • Provides default functionality • Clear semantics of “null” for that domain Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 43.
    class animal { public: virtual void make_sound() = 0; }; class dog : public animal { void make_sound() { cout << "woof!" << endl; } }; class null_animal : public animal { void make_sound() { } }; http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Null_Object_pattern Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 44.
    FACTORY •Creates instances by request • More flexible than Singleton • Can be configured to create different families of objects • IoC containers are closely related • Can be implemented dynamic based on interfaces • Can be used also to release “resource” when not needed Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 45.
    interface GUIFactory { public Button createButton(); } class WinFactory implements GUIFactory { public Button createButton() { return new WinButton(); } } class OSXFactory implements GUIFactory { public Button createButton() { return new OSXButton(); } } interface Button { public void paint(); } http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abstract_factory_pattern Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 46.
    STRATEGY •Abstracts the algorithm to solve a particular problem • Can be configured dynamically • Are interchangeable Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 47.
  • 48.
    DATA TRANSFER OBJECT • Simplifies information transfer across services • Can be optimized • Easy to understand Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 49.
  • 50.
    PAGE OBJECT • Abstract web pages functionality to be used usually in testing • Each page can be reused • Changes in the page impact only the implementation, not the clients Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 51.
    class ProjectListPage include PageObject def navigate visit('/projects') self end def edit(project) row = find(:xpath, "//td[.='#{project.name}']") row.parent.click_link('Edit') ProjectEditPage.new end def projects all(:css, "#projects tr")...... end end Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 52.
    When /^I goto the projects page$/ do project_list_page.navigate end When /^I activate the project$/ do project_list_page. navigate. edit(current_project). activate. save end Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 53.
    QUESTIONS? Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 54.
    RESOURCES •Email: amir@barylko.com, @abarylko • Slides: http://www.orthocoders.com/presentations • Patterns: Each pattern example has a link Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 55.
    RESOURCES II Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 56.
    RESOURCES III Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns
  • 57.
    QUALITY SOFTWARE TRAINING • Topics: Kanban, BDD & TDD. • When: May 4, 10-11 & 16-17 • More info: http://www.maventhought.com • Goal: Learn techniques, methodologies and tools to improve the quality in your job. Amir Barylko Advanced Design Patterns