SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 6
Download to read offline
GENERAL ARTICLES
CURRENT SCIENCE, VOL. 86, NO. 9, 10 MAY 20041210
Plant breeding: A component of public
health strategy
B. K. Misra, Rajiv K. Sharma* and S. Nagarajan
Micronutrient malnutrition leading to hidden hunger is seriously damaging the health of billions of
people world over. Micronutrient malnutrition (e.g., Fe, Zn and vitamin A deficiencies) now afflicts
over 40% of the world’s population. Food fortification that involves adding of micronutrients to the
food has played an important role in tackling the malnutrition problem to a great extent. Biofortifi-
cation, on the other hand, improves the genetic potential of the crop plants to produce micronutri-
ent-rich grains and thus offers self-sustaining solution.
Micronutrient malnutrition: the ‘hidden hunger’
Billions of people in developing countries suffer from a
sinister form of hunger called micronutrient malnutrition.
Micronutrients are trace chemical compounds (such as
vitamins) and trace elements required in small amounts
for health and well-being. Most poor people in develop-
ing nations rely primarily on staple food crops, food sour-
ces notoriously poor in bio-available micronutrients. Often
referred to as ‘hidden hunger,’ micronutrient malnutrition
is seriously damaging the cognitive development of chil-
dren, lowering disease resistance and vital growth in chil-
dren and reducing the likelihood that mothers survive
childbirth. Iron deficiency, is the most widespread nutri-
tional disorder in the world and India is no exception
(Table 1). More than 2 billion people globally are iron defi-
cient, and the problem is severe enough to cause anaemia
in 1.2 billion people. This condition impairs immunity,
making humans susceptible to infection and increases the
risk of complications during childbirth. It also adversely
affects intellectual development and reduces the mental
and physical capacity of populations. From birth to adult-
hood, iron deficiency is estimated to affect more than
three billion people – well over two out of every three
persons in developing countries1
. It is interesting to note
that better-nourished, healthier people have higher incomes
and contribute more to national income growth2
. A more
direct route to better nutrition could bring considerable
economic benefits.
Vitamin A deficiency is a leading contributor to child
mortality in developing countries. This key nutrient is cru-
cial for the effective functioning of the immune system.
Though on the decline, vitamin A deficiency still affects
the ability of 250 million children to fight-off deadly dis-
eases that kill millions of children every year in develop-
ing countries. It is also the single most important cause of
blindness among children. Micronutrient malnutrition (e.g.
Fe, Zn and vitamin A deficiencies) now afflicts over 40%
of the world’s population and is increasing, especially in
many developing nations. According to a World Bank esti-
mate3
, at the current level of malnutrition existing in South
Asia, 5% of the gross national product is lost each year
due to deficiencies in the intake of just three nutrients, viz.
iron, vitamin A and iodine. For each 50 million in popu-
lation, this translates into an economic loss of US $ 1 bil-
lion per year, a whopping over US $20 billion for India.
Agriculture is partly responsible for the current malnu-
trition. Green Revolution cropping systems may have
inadvertently contributed to the growth in micronutrient
deficiencies in resource-poor populations. It has never
made nutrient output an explicit goal of its production
systems. Many agricultural policies have inadvertently
fostered a decline in nutrition and diet diversity for the
poor. Additionally, the nutrition and health communities
have never considered using agriculture as a primary tool
in their programmes directed at alleviating poor nutrition
and ill health, globally. A new paradigm for agriculture
and nutrition is now needed. We must explore ways that
agriculture can contribute to finding sustainable solutions
to food system failures through holistic food-based system
approaches, thereby closely linking agricultural produc-
tion to improving human health, livelihood and well-being.
Such action will rouse support for agricultural research
worldwide because it addresses consumer issues as well
as agricultural production issues and is, therefore, politi-
cally supportable.
The authors are in the Division of Genetics, Indian Agricultural Research
Institute, New Delhi 110 012, India.
*For correspondence (e-mail: rajivksharma@rediffmail.com)
Table 1. Prevalence of nutritional
anaemia in India
Age group Per cent affected
Infants 65
Children (1–6 years) 60
Adolescent girls 88
Pregnant women 85
GENERAL ARTICLES
CURRENT SCIENCE, VOL. 86, NO. 9, 10 MAY 2004 1211
The Indian scenario
Wheat and rice contribute around 75% of the total grain
production in India. Innumerable products are made with
these grains, but their consumption pattern is varied. While
85% of the total wheat production is consumed in the
form of chapatti in northern, central, western and parts of
eastern India, rice is consumed in a big way in southern
and eastern parts of the country. A substantial decrease in
the availability of legumes over three decades, from an
average of 64.4 g during the pre-Green Revolution de-
cade to about 33.6 g per capita per day during 1996 to
2002 (Table 2) in the country, has been largely respon-
sible for protein malnutrition. Women in general and
child-bearing women in particular, and the weanling chil-
dren are the worst sufferers of the nutrient, protein and
vitamin A deficiencies (Table 3). Additionally, it has been
estimated that globally, about 28% children are under-
nourished (Table 4).
Approaches to handle malnutrition
Supplementation and fortification – partial solutions
to hidden hunger in developing countries
Food fortification is likely to have played an important
role in the current nutritional health and well-being of
populations in industrialized countries. Starting in the
early part of the 20th century, fortification was used to
target specific health conditions: goitre with iodized salt;
rickets with vitamin D-fortified milk; beriberi, pellagra
and anaemia with B-vitamins and Fe-enriched cereals;
more recently, in USA, risk of pregnancy affected by
neural-tube defects with folic acid-fortified cereals. A rela-
tive lack of appropriate centrally-processed food vehi-
cles, less-developed commercial markets and relatively
low consumer awareness and demand, mean that it has
taken about another 50 years for fortification to be seen
as a viable option for the less-developed countries4
.
Traditional strategies for preventing micronutrient defi-
ciencies in developing countries have focused on health-
education programmes, long-term vitamin supplementa-
tion, and the fortification of important foods. Tireless
efforts by the international public health community have
made great strides in combating micronutrient malnutri-
tion. Salt iodization, for example, has substantially redu-
ced the negative health impacts of iodine deficiency.
Iron, zinc and vitamin A deficiency, however, still plague
the developing world, even as public and private nutrition
campaigns work ceaselessly to fortify foods, supplement
diets and educate mothers about the importance of diver-
sified diets. Existing programmes have not been able to
reach all the people who need them at affordable cost.
Although often successful in the industrialized world,
these approaches tend to be costly and unsustainable in
developing countries.
Global efforts
The Micronutrient Initiative (MI) is a non-profit organi-
zation specializing in addressing micronutrient malnu-
trition. MI is governed by an international Board of
Directors. MI supports and promotes food fortification
and supplementation programmes in Asia, Africa and
Latin America, and provides technical and operational
support in those countries where micronutrient malnutri-
tion is most prevalent. MI carries out its work in partner-
ship with other international agencies, governments and
the industry. MI is based in Ottawa, Canada and main-
tains regional offices in New Delhi, India and Johannes-
burg, South Africa.
This project aims to virtually eliminate iodine and vita-
min A deficiencies and to reduce iron deficiency in women
in four countries in South Asia (Bangladesh, India, Nepal
and Pakistan). South Asia was chosen for special focus
because of the magnitude of the problem in the region
and the perceived political commitment to micronutrient
programming. The project aims to help governments plan
and implement national micronutrient programmes using
Table 2. Per capita daily avail-
ability of pulses (in grams)
in the country11
Period Availability
1956–65 64.4
1966–75 46.3
1976–85 41.1
1986–95 38.7
1996–2002 33.7
Table 3. Extent and consequences of micronutrient malnutrition
Deficiency
Prevalence in
developing countries Groups most affected Consequences
Iron 3.5 billion people All, but especially women
and children
Reduced cognitive ability; childbirth complications;
lowered physical capacity
Vitamin A 250 million children Children Increased child mortality; blindness
Zinc May be as widespread as
iron deficiency
Women and children Poor child growth and health; pregnancy and child-
birth complications; lower birth weight
GENERAL ARTICLES
CURRENT SCIENCE, VOL. 86, NO. 9, 10 MAY 20041212
an integrated combination of supplementation, food forti-
fication and dietary approaches. The role of MI in this
programme is to act as a facilitator and catalyst, provide
technical input and encourage donor support. MI works
closely with government ministries, UNICEF, World Bank
and other agencies. Strategies for each country are tailo-
red to national needs, taking into account political, deve-
lopmental and operational potential in addition to available
data on micronutrient malnutrition in each country. MI’s
South Asia Regional Office opened in 1997, to address
the needs of the large proportion of the regional popula-
tion suffering from micronutrient deficiencies. The first
Director was appointed in 1997, and national programme
officers for Bangladesh, India and Nepal joined in 1998.
In 1999–2000, activity revolved around ongoing country
programmes in Bangladesh, India, and Nepal, and during
the last few months, foundational work is being carried
out in Pakistan that may lead to a programme in the com-
ing year. Programmes focus on micronutrient needs iden-
tified in each country’s national plan of action on nutrition,
with particular emphasis on population groups most-at-
risk of micronutrient malnutrition: young children, adole-
scent girls and pregnant/lactating women. In South Asia,
with the exception of feasibility assessments conducted
by international consultants, MI works through local govern-
mental, NGO and international donor partners to imple-
ment its activities.
Indian efforts
In recent years, there has been tremendous emphasis at
the national level to reduce malnutrition through fortifi-
cation. Whole meal wheat flour that is used to make cha-
patti is being fortified with iron; salt is fortified with
iodine and made available to the consumers. Such prod-
ucts are available in the markets of metros and cities, and
hardly reach the rural folk who really need such fortified
products. There are several reasons responsible for wide-
spread anaemia among women from rural settings. Che-
mical fortification and supplementation, which are the
traditional ways of balancing the diet, largely failed to
nail the problem of malnutrition. Another important issue
responsible for malnutrition among Indians is that around
27% of the population, which is below the poverty line,
hardly manages to get two meals a day.
The MI’s Indian programme is housed within IDRC’s
regional office, using its infrastructure to create individual
research and intervention projects that address micronu-
trient needs. MI-India mainly focuses on the directions
set out in its strategic plan for food fortification and sup-
plementation at the national level and the control of mi-
cronutrient deficiencies, with specific emphasis on IDA,
VAD, and IDDs, through integrated health and nutrition
programmes at the state level. Research into the fortifica-
tion of foods like wheat flour, oil, sugar and salt was
taken up in partnership with national research institutions
like the Central Food Technological Research Institute,
the National Institute of Nutrition, the Vasantdada Sugar
Institute and others. At the state level, an integrated pro-
gramme was developed in West Bengal and Gujarat by
establishing state-level task force committees and advi-
sory committees, and with the assistance of consultants
focusing on fortification, supplementation, dietary diver-
sification and public-health measures (provision of water
and sanitation facilities and de-worming). Although the
scope of work is wide, fortification and supplementation
are the main focus areas.
Biofortification: the lasting self-sustaining
solution
Commercial fortification of foods is easier to practice and
is a more common intervention to tackle malnutrition. The
required micronutrients are added to the food item mid-
way between the farm and the consumer. Imagine, if it
were possible to tailor plants which by themselves would
do this act of fortification. This indeed is possible and is
known as the process of biofortification. Whether achi-
eved through the conventional method of breeding or
through biotechnological approaches, this unquestionably
is a better option for containing the menace of malnutri-
tion; however, this has its own limitations. Biofortifica-
tion uses agriculture as an instrument for improving human
health and nutrition, as well as for increasing agricultural
productivity. The breeding efforts focus on improving the
micronutrient content of the staple foods people already
eat, providing a relatively inexpensive, sustainable means
of delivering micronutrients to the poor. This reduces the
number of more severely malnourished people who will
still require treatment by complementary, but more costly,
conventional methods. The biofortification approach pro-
vides a truly feasible means of reaching malnourished
populations in relatively remote rural areas and deliver-
ing naturally fortified foods to people with limited access
to supplements or to commercially marketed fortified
foods. Thus, the breeding strategy will complement other
successful ongoing interventions to reduce micronutrient
malnutrition.
Once in place, the biofortified crop system is self-sus-
tainable. A one-time investment in breeding research will
yield nutritionally improved varieties that will continue
to be grown and consumed year after year, even if gov-
ernment attention and international funding for micronu-
Table 4. Per cent prevalence of under-
nutrition in children less than 5 years
Region % Prevalence
World 28
South Asia 49
Developing countries 29
India 42
Source: Ref. 12.
GENERAL ARTICLES
CURRENT SCIENCE, VOL. 86, NO. 9, 10 MAY 2004 1213
trient issues fade. It is this multiplier aspect of plant breed-
ing across time and distance that makes it cost-effective.
Mineral-packed seeds sell themselves to farmers because,
as recent research has shown, these trace minerals are
important to plant nutrition as well. Healthy plants use
inputs such as water, fertilizer and soil trace minerals
more efficiently, so that the new seeds can be expected to
be environmentally beneficial as well5
. Benefits for agri-
cultural productivity and the environment are comple-
mentary aspects of breeding for trace mineral density,
which further enhances the cost-effectiveness and sus-
tainability of biofortification. These desirable agronomic
traits will also contribute to local food security and grea-
ter adoption of biofortified crop varieties by poor farmers
interested in increasing their income.
Cereal grains such as wheat, maize and rice furnish the
energy that people need to survive. Cereal grains are not
good sources of micronutrients, but, at least in wheat,
there is good reason to believe that levels of iron and zinc
can be increased through plant breeding. If micronutri-
ent-rich wheat were widely available in developing coun-
tries, the malnourished poor who eat wheat everyday,
would automatically receive iron and zinc without having
to take supplements or purchase more expensive foods.
Can wheat pack more nutritional power?
Wheat is the world’s most important food crop and any
improvement in its genetic potential to pack more
nutritive value will have far-reaching results. The nutri-
tional value of some wheat products is given in Table 5.
More specifically, the micronutrients range in wheat and
other related species is presented in Table 6. There is an
urgent need to improve the level of bioavailable Fe (iron)
in plant foods. Modern molecular techniques now make it
possible to genetically modify plants in ways that can result
in more accumulation of Fe in edible plant organs. Signi-
ficantly, increasing the total amount of Fe in edible por-
tions of food crops will not be enough to satisfy human
Fe requirements for several reasons. First, plant foods
can contain substances that interfere with the absorption
or utilization of Fe by humans (e.g. certain tannins, cer-
tain fibres and phytic acid). Second, greatly increasing Fe
levels in plant tissues could result in decreased crop yields,
consequences which would not be acceptable to farmers.
Anti-nutrients in food crops can be significantly lowered
via genetic manipulation. However, many of these sub-
stances play important metabolic roles in plant growth
and development and in plant resistance to environmental
stress. Further, they provide important health benefits
(e.g. as anticarcinogens and lowering the risk of heart
disease). Reducing their levels could be detrimental to
both plant and human health. Increasing substances that
enhance Fe bioavailability is another possibility. Pro-
moter substances can counteract the negative effects of
‘antinutrients’ on Fe bioavailability. Promoters should be
identified and significantly increased in important staple
food crops. Doing so would lower the prevalence of iron
deficiency in the world.
To raise the micronutrient content in wheat grain, re-
searchers first need to explore whether some wheats, or
wild species related to wheat, have higher levels of iron
and zinc than others. Preliminary studies conducted at
CIMMYT-Mexico, CIMMYT-Turkey, and the University
of Adelaide, Australia have suggested that this variability
Table 5. Nutritional value of wheat products13
Amount of nutrient (g)/100 g*
Nutrient
Whole grain
wheat
Whole wheat
bread White bread
Whole wheat
pasta (boiled) Wheatgerm
Energy 340 246 267 124 360
Protein 10.69 9.7 8.2 5.33 23.15
Fat 1.99 4.2 3.6 0.54 9.72
Carbohydrate 75.36 46.1 49.5 26.54 51.8
Fibre 12.7 6.9 2.3 4.5 13.2
Water 10.42 37.7 36.7 67.15 11.12
*All nutrients in grams, except energy which is in kcal.
Table 6. Range of micronutrients available in wheat and related species
Range of micronutrients (µg/g DW)
Crop Fe Zn Mn Cu
Bread wheat 17.6 to 42.3 7.1 to 60.6 12.0 to 46.8 0.16 to 8.3
Durum wheat 22.3 to 34.1 11.7 to 60.4 15.3 to 33.2 0.92 to 4.67
Triticale 61 to 67 8.3 to 62.4 13.5 to 34 2.4 to 6.1
Rye 41 to 47 23 to 32.3 24.6 to 44.6 2.9 to 4.6
GENERAL ARTICLES
CURRENT SCIENCE, VOL. 86, NO. 9, 10 MAY 20041214
in micronutrient levels does exist, especially in wild rela-
tives and wheat landraces. Since only 1% of the materials
available at CIMMYT has been tested, much more vari-
ability is likely to be found. Our own experimentations
have revealed existence of utilizable variability (Table 5)
for these micronutrients in the wheat germplasm avail-
able with the breeding group.
Another positive finding is that increased micronutri-
ent content in wheat is not linked to lower wheat yields.
There is a good possibility of breeding wheat varieties that
will produce high quantities of micronutrient-rich grain.
Breeders also need to consider that there may be suffi-
cient micronutrients in the grain, but they may be present
in forms that are not available to human beings. Ivan Ortiz-
Monasterio, CIMMYT wheat agronomist, points out that
micronutrients must be available not only in plants but in
soils. ‘Soils often contain high amounts of minerals, but
they aren’t available to crop plants,’ he says. ‘If plants
can’t take iron and zinc from the soil, the grain they pro-
duce won’t have enough of these nutrients either.’ Breed-
ers will have to improve the efficiency with which wheat
extracts these nutrients from the soil, and just as impor-
tantly, the efficiency with which it stores them in the grain.
If researchers develop wheat varieties that deliver more
minerals in their grain, agricultural productivity will im-
prove, because plants, like people, need micronutrients.
Seed with high concentrations of micronutrients produces
more viable and vigorous seedlings. Wheat varieties that
are better at taking minerals from the soil have better dis-
ease resistance, nutrition and yields, particularly in mine-
ral-deficient soils in arid regions.
Plant breeding as a public health strategy
Maarten van Ginkel and Richard Trethówan, CIMMYT
bread-wheat breeders, have raised some important points
related to breeding wheat with higher levels of micronu-
trients. ‘Farmers growing the micronutrient-rich wheats
will get higher yields and use fewer chemicals to control
diseases,’ points out van Ginkel. Adds Trethowan, ‘Once
the genes that increase grain micronutrient content are in-
corporated into all our wheats, the costs of continuing to
breed these wheats will be no different than the costs of
breeding “normal” wheats.’ Because wheat is the most
widely consumed crop in the world, the impact on nutri-
tion could be extensive. In the long run, a breeding pro-
gramme may cost less and reach more people than most
nutrition programmes (another reason why plant breeding
could be a sound public health strategy).
Exploring possibilities to establish fortified
crops
Before one undertakes a programme for the development
of a transgenic, preference of the consumers needs to be
considered. As is understandable, golden rice6
fulfils many
of the requirements that will help in containing malnutri-
tion but for the yellow colour, and throughout the world
yellow rice hardly finds a place on the dining table. More
often, consumers prefer white products (e.g. milled rice,
wheat flour, maize, etc.). Improving the β-carotene level
in durum wheat would have been an easily acceptable
preposition from the consumer point of view, since yellow
or orange pasta products would have easy acceptance.
There may be several such examples, which might fit in
this framework. The scientist who is the main architect
would himself have to take the initiative to popularize his
product. This, however, goes against the temperament of
the scientist, but it is imperative to work in this direction.
The concerned scientist should involve scientists from
different disciplines like biochemistry, nutrition, plant
pathology, agronomy and extension services, and a scien-
tist to evaluate the end-product potentialities of his bio-
fortified product. The group of scientists will generate
data on the product from different perspectives, which in
turn will help convince the needy policy-makers. Major
nutrition education programmes would have to be under-
taken to convince consumers to switch over to these col-
oured varieties. However, if these programmes are suc-
cessful, then the yellow-orange colour will work as a
marker for the more nutritious varieties compared to the
less nutritious ones and a disadvantage might have been
turned into an advantage7
. Biofortification through con-
ventional breeding is a time-consuming process and has
so far proved to be of little or no significance when it
comes to enhancing nutrients like iron in wheat, which
remains linked to phytate and is not freely available to
the body unless the genes for phytase are incorporated.
This is an issue that has not been studied in detail and
needs attention. To handle the peculiar situation where the
biofortified foods are struggling to serve their purpose, it
would be appropriate to work out some other option which
would be practical and would receive wider acceptability.
Conclusion and economics involved
Wide diversity exists for the micronutrients in wheat and
related species (Table 6). Conventional breeding methodo-
logy assisted by molecular markers tools can effectively
be employed to develop wheat genotypes containing sig-
nificantly higher amounts of critical micronutrients. Pre-
sence of phytate is said to be responsible for obstructing
the bioavailability of Zn and Fe. Information is inade-
quate to demonstrate the difference in the availability of
these nutrients when it comes to comparing high nutrient
varieties with those carrying low amount of nutrients.
Efforts made to transfer phytate genes from microbes have
not been successful because of the thermosensitive nature of
the enzyme. Development of GM crops is a feasible option
to augment various crops with the required micronutri-
ents. Several transgenics covering various crops are avail-
GENERAL ARTICLES
CURRENT SCIENCE, VOL. 86, NO. 9, 10 MAY 2004 1215
able today. Golden rice is a well-known example in which
genes for lysine, iron, zinc and β-carotene have been suc-
cessfully incorporated. An indica strain enriched with β-
carotene and zinc is also now available8
. Such trans-
genics are becoming increasingly popular and currently
occupy over 40 million hectares globally9
. It is important
to note that most of the transgenics have been developed
in the West and the US, where the problem of malnutri-
tion is not a major one. Certainly, the beneficiaries of these
GM crops would be the developing and underdeveloped
nations. The irony of the problem is that most developed
nations are not ready to bring GM crops under cultiva-
tion, obviously because they are not sure of their possible
undesirable effects. The situation is not at all different in
developing countries. Now, the question is whether we con-
tinue to develop the transgenics in various crops or we
concomitantly work for their logical acceptance as well,
without which many of these transgenics may not see light
of the day.
Although benefits from supplementation and fortific-
tion programmes are immediate and carry high benefit-
to-cost ratio, benefits disappear fast if investments are not
sustained to meet increasing level of investments year after
year. If investments are sustained, benefits disappear fast.
Some rough calculations may be made for these interven-
tions. The cost of micronutrients and vitamin pills is not
high, say Rs 50 per person per year. If one out of every
ten persons were to receive supplementation, the whole
exercise would require over Rs 500 crores per year on
a regular basis for sustained benefits. Plant breeding on
the other hand, would require one-time investment of only
a few crores to develop micronutrient-rich wheat varieties
which would be self-multiplying and self-sustaining.
Although plant-breeding research has a longer gestation
period before it makes an appreciable impact, an invest-
ment of a few crores in two crops, rice and wheat, can take
care of malnutrition on a long-term basis in a self-sus-
tainable manner. Once introduced into the working germ-
plasm, these traits will remain in all future cultivars and
insulate the population at large against malnutrition.
1. Anon, Fourth Report on the World Nutrition Situation, United
Nations, Geneva, Switzerland, 2000.
2. Haddad, L. and Alderman, H., Malnutrition: Income growth or nu-
trition programs. In IFPRI 1999–2000, Annual Report, IFPRI, 2000.
3. Anon, Development in practice series. World Bank, Washington,
DC, 1994.
4. Darnton, H. I. and Nalubola, R., Proc. Nutr. Soc., 2002, 61, 231–
241.
5. Graham, R., Welch, R. and Bouis, H., Adv. Agron., 2001, 70, 77–
142.
6. Ye, X., Al-Babili, S., Kloti, A., Zhang, J., Lucca, P., Beyer, P. and
Potrykus, I., Science, 2000, 287, 303–305.
7. Hagenimana, V. and Low, J., Food Nutr. Bull., 2000, 21, 414–418.
8. Krishnan, S., Datta, K., Baisakh, N., Vasconcelos, M. and Datta,
S. K., Curr. Sci., 2003, 84, 1232–1234.
9. Kim, J. K. and Krishnan, H. B. J. Crop Prod., 2002, 5, 93–130.
10. Kapoor et al., Indian J. Paediatr., 2002, 69, 607.
11. Anon, Agricultural Statistics at a Glance, Agricultural Statistics
Division, Directorate of Economics and Statistics, Department
of Agriculture and Cooperation, Ministry of Agriculture, Govt. of
India, 2003, pp. 139–140.
12. UNICEF, The state of world’s children 2001.
13. US Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service, 1999,
USDA Nutrient Database for Standard Reference, Release 13.
Nutrient Data Laboratory Home Page, www.nal.usda.gov/fnic/
foodcomp
14. Bouis, H., Enrichment of food staples through plant breeding: A
new strategy for fighting malnutrition. Nutrition, 2000, 16, 701–704.
Received 27 October 2003; accepted 20 March 2004

More Related Content

What's hot

Poverty and food insecurity
Poverty and food insecurityPoverty and food insecurity
Poverty and food insecurityclaireatukunda
 
Food Insecurity and Government Intervention for Sustainable Food Access in Od...
Food Insecurity and Government Intervention for Sustainable Food Access in Od...Food Insecurity and Government Intervention for Sustainable Food Access in Od...
Food Insecurity and Government Intervention for Sustainable Food Access in Od...IJLT EMAS
 
Paper Presented-Soya Fortified Yorghurt
Paper Presented-Soya Fortified YorghurtPaper Presented-Soya Fortified Yorghurt
Paper Presented-Soya Fortified YorghurtPrapti Patel
 
Food security in world 2050
Food security in world 2050Food security in world 2050
Food security in world 2050Pramod Anand
 
Global Food Policy A Primer
Global Food Policy A PrimerGlobal Food Policy A Primer
Global Food Policy A Primerijtsrd
 
An Alternative Strategy of Social Entrepreneurship Initiative for Food Securi...
An Alternative Strategy of Social Entrepreneurship Initiative for Food Securi...An Alternative Strategy of Social Entrepreneurship Initiative for Food Securi...
An Alternative Strategy of Social Entrepreneurship Initiative for Food Securi...Business, Management and Economics Research
 
Regina Moench-Pfanner - Diets in Transition: Urbanization & Processed Food at...
Regina Moench-Pfanner - Diets in Transition: Urbanization & Processed Food at...Regina Moench-Pfanner - Diets in Transition: Urbanization & Processed Food at...
Regina Moench-Pfanner - Diets in Transition: Urbanization & Processed Food at...HKUST IEMS
 
Zero hunger
Zero hungerZero hunger
Zero hungerJebaKani
 
Food security and economic development
Food security and economic developmentFood security and economic development
Food security and economic developmentSM Lalon
 
Feeding America and the Hunger Crisis
Feeding America and the Hunger CrisisFeeding America and the Hunger Crisis
Feeding America and the Hunger CrisisKeith Mirchandani
 
Somalia flour lab nick
Somalia flour lab nickSomalia flour lab nick
Somalia flour lab nickcwaage
 

What's hot (18)

Zero Hunger Challenge Discussion January 2014
Zero Hunger Challenge Discussion January 2014Zero Hunger Challenge Discussion January 2014
Zero Hunger Challenge Discussion January 2014
 
4. World Hunger
4. World Hunger4. World Hunger
4. World Hunger
 
Poverty and food insecurity
Poverty and food insecurityPoverty and food insecurity
Poverty and food insecurity
 
food
foodfood
food
 
Food Insecurity and Government Intervention for Sustainable Food Access in Od...
Food Insecurity and Government Intervention for Sustainable Food Access in Od...Food Insecurity and Government Intervention for Sustainable Food Access in Od...
Food Insecurity and Government Intervention for Sustainable Food Access in Od...
 
Paper Presented-Soya Fortified Yorghurt
Paper Presented-Soya Fortified YorghurtPaper Presented-Soya Fortified Yorghurt
Paper Presented-Soya Fortified Yorghurt
 
Food security in world 2050
Food security in world 2050Food security in world 2050
Food security in world 2050
 
Global Food Policy A Primer
Global Food Policy A PrimerGlobal Food Policy A Primer
Global Food Policy A Primer
 
An Alternative Strategy of Social Entrepreneurship Initiative for Food Securi...
An Alternative Strategy of Social Entrepreneurship Initiative for Food Securi...An Alternative Strategy of Social Entrepreneurship Initiative for Food Securi...
An Alternative Strategy of Social Entrepreneurship Initiative for Food Securi...
 
Wheat Flour Fortification
Wheat Flour FortificationWheat Flour Fortification
Wheat Flour Fortification
 
Biofortificación en alimentos
Biofortificación en alimentosBiofortificación en alimentos
Biofortificación en alimentos
 
Regina Moench-Pfanner - Diets in Transition: Urbanization & Processed Food at...
Regina Moench-Pfanner - Diets in Transition: Urbanization & Processed Food at...Regina Moench-Pfanner - Diets in Transition: Urbanization & Processed Food at...
Regina Moench-Pfanner - Diets in Transition: Urbanization & Processed Food at...
 
Zero hunger
Zero hungerZero hunger
Zero hunger
 
Food security and economic development
Food security and economic developmentFood security and economic development
Food security and economic development
 
Tackling Hunger in India
Tackling Hunger in India Tackling Hunger in India
Tackling Hunger in India
 
National nutritional week
National nutritional weekNational nutritional week
National nutritional week
 
Feeding America and the Hunger Crisis
Feeding America and the Hunger CrisisFeeding America and the Hunger Crisis
Feeding America and the Hunger Crisis
 
Somalia flour lab nick
Somalia flour lab nickSomalia flour lab nick
Somalia flour lab nick
 

Similar to Plant Breeding as a component of public health strategy

Micronutrient final with_cover
Micronutrient final with_coverMicronutrient final with_cover
Micronutrient final with_coverUtpal Ganguly
 
national nutritional programme
national nutritional programmenational nutritional programme
national nutritional programmePreetam Manoli
 
Transgenic Crops for Biofortification.pdf
Transgenic Crops for Biofortification.pdfTransgenic Crops for Biofortification.pdf
Transgenic Crops for Biofortification.pdfIqbalHussain913371
 
Afghanistan nutrition based policy
Afghanistan nutrition based policyAfghanistan nutrition based policy
Afghanistan nutrition based policyabdulsatar190
 
Adding Fruit in our Diet: The Only Solution to Hidden Hunger
Adding Fruit in our Diet: The Only Solution to Hidden HungerAdding Fruit in our Diet: The Only Solution to Hidden Hunger
Adding Fruit in our Diet: The Only Solution to Hidden HungerReetika Sharma
 
Hidden hunger-subgroupD8.pptx
Hidden hunger-subgroupD8.pptxHidden hunger-subgroupD8.pptx
Hidden hunger-subgroupD8.pptxSaiVenkat156159
 
Micronutrient Malnutrition (Hidden Hunger)
Micronutrient Malnutrition (Hidden Hunger)Micronutrient Malnutrition (Hidden Hunger)
Micronutrient Malnutrition (Hidden Hunger)Mohammad Hasan Chowdhury
 
Ldr 625 m7 red team clc assignment final
Ldr 625 m7 red team clc assignment finalLdr 625 m7 red team clc assignment final
Ldr 625 m7 red team clc assignment finalDeliciouscrisp
 
LDR 625 M7 RED TEAM CLC Assignment with Notes
LDR 625 M7 RED TEAM CLC Assignment with NotesLDR 625 M7 RED TEAM CLC Assignment with Notes
LDR 625 M7 RED TEAM CLC Assignment with NotesDeliciouscrisp
 
Large Scale Food Fortification
Large Scale Food Fortification Large Scale Food Fortification
Large Scale Food Fortification Francois Stepman
 

Similar to Plant Breeding as a component of public health strategy (20)

Micronutrient final with_cover
Micronutrient final with_coverMicronutrient final with_cover
Micronutrient final with_cover
 
national nutritional programme
national nutritional programmenational nutritional programme
national nutritional programme
 
Transgenic Crops for Biofortification.pdf
Transgenic Crops for Biofortification.pdfTransgenic Crops for Biofortification.pdf
Transgenic Crops for Biofortification.pdf
 
Nutrition security
Nutrition securityNutrition security
Nutrition security
 
Afghanistan nutrition based policy
Afghanistan nutrition based policyAfghanistan nutrition based policy
Afghanistan nutrition based policy
 
Food for thought: Eating better
Food for thought: Eating betterFood for thought: Eating better
Food for thought: Eating better
 
Malnutrition
MalnutritionMalnutrition
Malnutrition
 
Adding Fruit in our Diet: The Only Solution to Hidden Hunger
Adding Fruit in our Diet: The Only Solution to Hidden HungerAdding Fruit in our Diet: The Only Solution to Hidden Hunger
Adding Fruit in our Diet: The Only Solution to Hidden Hunger
 
Hidden hunger-subgroupD8.pptx
Hidden hunger-subgroupD8.pptxHidden hunger-subgroupD8.pptx
Hidden hunger-subgroupD8.pptx
 
The changing challenges of hidden hunger: Micronutrients within the nutrition...
The changing challenges of hidden hunger: Micronutrients within the nutrition...The changing challenges of hidden hunger: Micronutrients within the nutrition...
The changing challenges of hidden hunger: Micronutrients within the nutrition...
 
NITAROOKIES
NITAROOKIESNITAROOKIES
NITAROOKIES
 
Essay On Malnutrition
Essay On MalnutritionEssay On Malnutrition
Essay On Malnutrition
 
Micronutrient Malnutrition (Hidden Hunger)
Micronutrient Malnutrition (Hidden Hunger)Micronutrient Malnutrition (Hidden Hunger)
Micronutrient Malnutrition (Hidden Hunger)
 
AlphaWarriors
AlphaWarriorsAlphaWarriors
AlphaWarriors
 
Ldr 625 m7 red team clc assignment final
Ldr 625 m7 red team clc assignment finalLdr 625 m7 red team clc assignment final
Ldr 625 m7 red team clc assignment final
 
LDR 625 M7 RED TEAM CLC Assignment with Notes
LDR 625 M7 RED TEAM CLC Assignment with NotesLDR 625 M7 RED TEAM CLC Assignment with Notes
LDR 625 M7 RED TEAM CLC Assignment with Notes
 
The Role of Food Gardens in Addressing Malnutrition in Children
The Role of Food Gardens in Addressing Malnutrition in ChildrenThe Role of Food Gardens in Addressing Malnutrition in Children
The Role of Food Gardens in Addressing Malnutrition in Children
 
TheChangers
TheChangersTheChangers
TheChangers
 
Malnutrition
MalnutritionMalnutrition
Malnutrition
 
Large Scale Food Fortification
Large Scale Food Fortification Large Scale Food Fortification
Large Scale Food Fortification
 

Plant Breeding as a component of public health strategy

  • 1. GENERAL ARTICLES CURRENT SCIENCE, VOL. 86, NO. 9, 10 MAY 20041210 Plant breeding: A component of public health strategy B. K. Misra, Rajiv K. Sharma* and S. Nagarajan Micronutrient malnutrition leading to hidden hunger is seriously damaging the health of billions of people world over. Micronutrient malnutrition (e.g., Fe, Zn and vitamin A deficiencies) now afflicts over 40% of the world’s population. Food fortification that involves adding of micronutrients to the food has played an important role in tackling the malnutrition problem to a great extent. Biofortifi- cation, on the other hand, improves the genetic potential of the crop plants to produce micronutri- ent-rich grains and thus offers self-sustaining solution. Micronutrient malnutrition: the ‘hidden hunger’ Billions of people in developing countries suffer from a sinister form of hunger called micronutrient malnutrition. Micronutrients are trace chemical compounds (such as vitamins) and trace elements required in small amounts for health and well-being. Most poor people in develop- ing nations rely primarily on staple food crops, food sour- ces notoriously poor in bio-available micronutrients. Often referred to as ‘hidden hunger,’ micronutrient malnutrition is seriously damaging the cognitive development of chil- dren, lowering disease resistance and vital growth in chil- dren and reducing the likelihood that mothers survive childbirth. Iron deficiency, is the most widespread nutri- tional disorder in the world and India is no exception (Table 1). More than 2 billion people globally are iron defi- cient, and the problem is severe enough to cause anaemia in 1.2 billion people. This condition impairs immunity, making humans susceptible to infection and increases the risk of complications during childbirth. It also adversely affects intellectual development and reduces the mental and physical capacity of populations. From birth to adult- hood, iron deficiency is estimated to affect more than three billion people – well over two out of every three persons in developing countries1 . It is interesting to note that better-nourished, healthier people have higher incomes and contribute more to national income growth2 . A more direct route to better nutrition could bring considerable economic benefits. Vitamin A deficiency is a leading contributor to child mortality in developing countries. This key nutrient is cru- cial for the effective functioning of the immune system. Though on the decline, vitamin A deficiency still affects the ability of 250 million children to fight-off deadly dis- eases that kill millions of children every year in develop- ing countries. It is also the single most important cause of blindness among children. Micronutrient malnutrition (e.g. Fe, Zn and vitamin A deficiencies) now afflicts over 40% of the world’s population and is increasing, especially in many developing nations. According to a World Bank esti- mate3 , at the current level of malnutrition existing in South Asia, 5% of the gross national product is lost each year due to deficiencies in the intake of just three nutrients, viz. iron, vitamin A and iodine. For each 50 million in popu- lation, this translates into an economic loss of US $ 1 bil- lion per year, a whopping over US $20 billion for India. Agriculture is partly responsible for the current malnu- trition. Green Revolution cropping systems may have inadvertently contributed to the growth in micronutrient deficiencies in resource-poor populations. It has never made nutrient output an explicit goal of its production systems. Many agricultural policies have inadvertently fostered a decline in nutrition and diet diversity for the poor. Additionally, the nutrition and health communities have never considered using agriculture as a primary tool in their programmes directed at alleviating poor nutrition and ill health, globally. A new paradigm for agriculture and nutrition is now needed. We must explore ways that agriculture can contribute to finding sustainable solutions to food system failures through holistic food-based system approaches, thereby closely linking agricultural produc- tion to improving human health, livelihood and well-being. Such action will rouse support for agricultural research worldwide because it addresses consumer issues as well as agricultural production issues and is, therefore, politi- cally supportable. The authors are in the Division of Genetics, Indian Agricultural Research Institute, New Delhi 110 012, India. *For correspondence (e-mail: rajivksharma@rediffmail.com) Table 1. Prevalence of nutritional anaemia in India Age group Per cent affected Infants 65 Children (1–6 years) 60 Adolescent girls 88 Pregnant women 85
  • 2. GENERAL ARTICLES CURRENT SCIENCE, VOL. 86, NO. 9, 10 MAY 2004 1211 The Indian scenario Wheat and rice contribute around 75% of the total grain production in India. Innumerable products are made with these grains, but their consumption pattern is varied. While 85% of the total wheat production is consumed in the form of chapatti in northern, central, western and parts of eastern India, rice is consumed in a big way in southern and eastern parts of the country. A substantial decrease in the availability of legumes over three decades, from an average of 64.4 g during the pre-Green Revolution de- cade to about 33.6 g per capita per day during 1996 to 2002 (Table 2) in the country, has been largely respon- sible for protein malnutrition. Women in general and child-bearing women in particular, and the weanling chil- dren are the worst sufferers of the nutrient, protein and vitamin A deficiencies (Table 3). Additionally, it has been estimated that globally, about 28% children are under- nourished (Table 4). Approaches to handle malnutrition Supplementation and fortification – partial solutions to hidden hunger in developing countries Food fortification is likely to have played an important role in the current nutritional health and well-being of populations in industrialized countries. Starting in the early part of the 20th century, fortification was used to target specific health conditions: goitre with iodized salt; rickets with vitamin D-fortified milk; beriberi, pellagra and anaemia with B-vitamins and Fe-enriched cereals; more recently, in USA, risk of pregnancy affected by neural-tube defects with folic acid-fortified cereals. A rela- tive lack of appropriate centrally-processed food vehi- cles, less-developed commercial markets and relatively low consumer awareness and demand, mean that it has taken about another 50 years for fortification to be seen as a viable option for the less-developed countries4 . Traditional strategies for preventing micronutrient defi- ciencies in developing countries have focused on health- education programmes, long-term vitamin supplementa- tion, and the fortification of important foods. Tireless efforts by the international public health community have made great strides in combating micronutrient malnutri- tion. Salt iodization, for example, has substantially redu- ced the negative health impacts of iodine deficiency. Iron, zinc and vitamin A deficiency, however, still plague the developing world, even as public and private nutrition campaigns work ceaselessly to fortify foods, supplement diets and educate mothers about the importance of diver- sified diets. Existing programmes have not been able to reach all the people who need them at affordable cost. Although often successful in the industrialized world, these approaches tend to be costly and unsustainable in developing countries. Global efforts The Micronutrient Initiative (MI) is a non-profit organi- zation specializing in addressing micronutrient malnu- trition. MI is governed by an international Board of Directors. MI supports and promotes food fortification and supplementation programmes in Asia, Africa and Latin America, and provides technical and operational support in those countries where micronutrient malnutri- tion is most prevalent. MI carries out its work in partner- ship with other international agencies, governments and the industry. MI is based in Ottawa, Canada and main- tains regional offices in New Delhi, India and Johannes- burg, South Africa. This project aims to virtually eliminate iodine and vita- min A deficiencies and to reduce iron deficiency in women in four countries in South Asia (Bangladesh, India, Nepal and Pakistan). South Asia was chosen for special focus because of the magnitude of the problem in the region and the perceived political commitment to micronutrient programming. The project aims to help governments plan and implement national micronutrient programmes using Table 2. Per capita daily avail- ability of pulses (in grams) in the country11 Period Availability 1956–65 64.4 1966–75 46.3 1976–85 41.1 1986–95 38.7 1996–2002 33.7 Table 3. Extent and consequences of micronutrient malnutrition Deficiency Prevalence in developing countries Groups most affected Consequences Iron 3.5 billion people All, but especially women and children Reduced cognitive ability; childbirth complications; lowered physical capacity Vitamin A 250 million children Children Increased child mortality; blindness Zinc May be as widespread as iron deficiency Women and children Poor child growth and health; pregnancy and child- birth complications; lower birth weight
  • 3. GENERAL ARTICLES CURRENT SCIENCE, VOL. 86, NO. 9, 10 MAY 20041212 an integrated combination of supplementation, food forti- fication and dietary approaches. The role of MI in this programme is to act as a facilitator and catalyst, provide technical input and encourage donor support. MI works closely with government ministries, UNICEF, World Bank and other agencies. Strategies for each country are tailo- red to national needs, taking into account political, deve- lopmental and operational potential in addition to available data on micronutrient malnutrition in each country. MI’s South Asia Regional Office opened in 1997, to address the needs of the large proportion of the regional popula- tion suffering from micronutrient deficiencies. The first Director was appointed in 1997, and national programme officers for Bangladesh, India and Nepal joined in 1998. In 1999–2000, activity revolved around ongoing country programmes in Bangladesh, India, and Nepal, and during the last few months, foundational work is being carried out in Pakistan that may lead to a programme in the com- ing year. Programmes focus on micronutrient needs iden- tified in each country’s national plan of action on nutrition, with particular emphasis on population groups most-at- risk of micronutrient malnutrition: young children, adole- scent girls and pregnant/lactating women. In South Asia, with the exception of feasibility assessments conducted by international consultants, MI works through local govern- mental, NGO and international donor partners to imple- ment its activities. Indian efforts In recent years, there has been tremendous emphasis at the national level to reduce malnutrition through fortifi- cation. Whole meal wheat flour that is used to make cha- patti is being fortified with iron; salt is fortified with iodine and made available to the consumers. Such prod- ucts are available in the markets of metros and cities, and hardly reach the rural folk who really need such fortified products. There are several reasons responsible for wide- spread anaemia among women from rural settings. Che- mical fortification and supplementation, which are the traditional ways of balancing the diet, largely failed to nail the problem of malnutrition. Another important issue responsible for malnutrition among Indians is that around 27% of the population, which is below the poverty line, hardly manages to get two meals a day. The MI’s Indian programme is housed within IDRC’s regional office, using its infrastructure to create individual research and intervention projects that address micronu- trient needs. MI-India mainly focuses on the directions set out in its strategic plan for food fortification and sup- plementation at the national level and the control of mi- cronutrient deficiencies, with specific emphasis on IDA, VAD, and IDDs, through integrated health and nutrition programmes at the state level. Research into the fortifica- tion of foods like wheat flour, oil, sugar and salt was taken up in partnership with national research institutions like the Central Food Technological Research Institute, the National Institute of Nutrition, the Vasantdada Sugar Institute and others. At the state level, an integrated pro- gramme was developed in West Bengal and Gujarat by establishing state-level task force committees and advi- sory committees, and with the assistance of consultants focusing on fortification, supplementation, dietary diver- sification and public-health measures (provision of water and sanitation facilities and de-worming). Although the scope of work is wide, fortification and supplementation are the main focus areas. Biofortification: the lasting self-sustaining solution Commercial fortification of foods is easier to practice and is a more common intervention to tackle malnutrition. The required micronutrients are added to the food item mid- way between the farm and the consumer. Imagine, if it were possible to tailor plants which by themselves would do this act of fortification. This indeed is possible and is known as the process of biofortification. Whether achi- eved through the conventional method of breeding or through biotechnological approaches, this unquestionably is a better option for containing the menace of malnutri- tion; however, this has its own limitations. Biofortifica- tion uses agriculture as an instrument for improving human health and nutrition, as well as for increasing agricultural productivity. The breeding efforts focus on improving the micronutrient content of the staple foods people already eat, providing a relatively inexpensive, sustainable means of delivering micronutrients to the poor. This reduces the number of more severely malnourished people who will still require treatment by complementary, but more costly, conventional methods. The biofortification approach pro- vides a truly feasible means of reaching malnourished populations in relatively remote rural areas and deliver- ing naturally fortified foods to people with limited access to supplements or to commercially marketed fortified foods. Thus, the breeding strategy will complement other successful ongoing interventions to reduce micronutrient malnutrition. Once in place, the biofortified crop system is self-sus- tainable. A one-time investment in breeding research will yield nutritionally improved varieties that will continue to be grown and consumed year after year, even if gov- ernment attention and international funding for micronu- Table 4. Per cent prevalence of under- nutrition in children less than 5 years Region % Prevalence World 28 South Asia 49 Developing countries 29 India 42 Source: Ref. 12.
  • 4. GENERAL ARTICLES CURRENT SCIENCE, VOL. 86, NO. 9, 10 MAY 2004 1213 trient issues fade. It is this multiplier aspect of plant breed- ing across time and distance that makes it cost-effective. Mineral-packed seeds sell themselves to farmers because, as recent research has shown, these trace minerals are important to plant nutrition as well. Healthy plants use inputs such as water, fertilizer and soil trace minerals more efficiently, so that the new seeds can be expected to be environmentally beneficial as well5 . Benefits for agri- cultural productivity and the environment are comple- mentary aspects of breeding for trace mineral density, which further enhances the cost-effectiveness and sus- tainability of biofortification. These desirable agronomic traits will also contribute to local food security and grea- ter adoption of biofortified crop varieties by poor farmers interested in increasing their income. Cereal grains such as wheat, maize and rice furnish the energy that people need to survive. Cereal grains are not good sources of micronutrients, but, at least in wheat, there is good reason to believe that levels of iron and zinc can be increased through plant breeding. If micronutri- ent-rich wheat were widely available in developing coun- tries, the malnourished poor who eat wheat everyday, would automatically receive iron and zinc without having to take supplements or purchase more expensive foods. Can wheat pack more nutritional power? Wheat is the world’s most important food crop and any improvement in its genetic potential to pack more nutritive value will have far-reaching results. The nutri- tional value of some wheat products is given in Table 5. More specifically, the micronutrients range in wheat and other related species is presented in Table 6. There is an urgent need to improve the level of bioavailable Fe (iron) in plant foods. Modern molecular techniques now make it possible to genetically modify plants in ways that can result in more accumulation of Fe in edible plant organs. Signi- ficantly, increasing the total amount of Fe in edible por- tions of food crops will not be enough to satisfy human Fe requirements for several reasons. First, plant foods can contain substances that interfere with the absorption or utilization of Fe by humans (e.g. certain tannins, cer- tain fibres and phytic acid). Second, greatly increasing Fe levels in plant tissues could result in decreased crop yields, consequences which would not be acceptable to farmers. Anti-nutrients in food crops can be significantly lowered via genetic manipulation. However, many of these sub- stances play important metabolic roles in plant growth and development and in plant resistance to environmental stress. Further, they provide important health benefits (e.g. as anticarcinogens and lowering the risk of heart disease). Reducing their levels could be detrimental to both plant and human health. Increasing substances that enhance Fe bioavailability is another possibility. Pro- moter substances can counteract the negative effects of ‘antinutrients’ on Fe bioavailability. Promoters should be identified and significantly increased in important staple food crops. Doing so would lower the prevalence of iron deficiency in the world. To raise the micronutrient content in wheat grain, re- searchers first need to explore whether some wheats, or wild species related to wheat, have higher levels of iron and zinc than others. Preliminary studies conducted at CIMMYT-Mexico, CIMMYT-Turkey, and the University of Adelaide, Australia have suggested that this variability Table 5. Nutritional value of wheat products13 Amount of nutrient (g)/100 g* Nutrient Whole grain wheat Whole wheat bread White bread Whole wheat pasta (boiled) Wheatgerm Energy 340 246 267 124 360 Protein 10.69 9.7 8.2 5.33 23.15 Fat 1.99 4.2 3.6 0.54 9.72 Carbohydrate 75.36 46.1 49.5 26.54 51.8 Fibre 12.7 6.9 2.3 4.5 13.2 Water 10.42 37.7 36.7 67.15 11.12 *All nutrients in grams, except energy which is in kcal. Table 6. Range of micronutrients available in wheat and related species Range of micronutrients (µg/g DW) Crop Fe Zn Mn Cu Bread wheat 17.6 to 42.3 7.1 to 60.6 12.0 to 46.8 0.16 to 8.3 Durum wheat 22.3 to 34.1 11.7 to 60.4 15.3 to 33.2 0.92 to 4.67 Triticale 61 to 67 8.3 to 62.4 13.5 to 34 2.4 to 6.1 Rye 41 to 47 23 to 32.3 24.6 to 44.6 2.9 to 4.6
  • 5. GENERAL ARTICLES CURRENT SCIENCE, VOL. 86, NO. 9, 10 MAY 20041214 in micronutrient levels does exist, especially in wild rela- tives and wheat landraces. Since only 1% of the materials available at CIMMYT has been tested, much more vari- ability is likely to be found. Our own experimentations have revealed existence of utilizable variability (Table 5) for these micronutrients in the wheat germplasm avail- able with the breeding group. Another positive finding is that increased micronutri- ent content in wheat is not linked to lower wheat yields. There is a good possibility of breeding wheat varieties that will produce high quantities of micronutrient-rich grain. Breeders also need to consider that there may be suffi- cient micronutrients in the grain, but they may be present in forms that are not available to human beings. Ivan Ortiz- Monasterio, CIMMYT wheat agronomist, points out that micronutrients must be available not only in plants but in soils. ‘Soils often contain high amounts of minerals, but they aren’t available to crop plants,’ he says. ‘If plants can’t take iron and zinc from the soil, the grain they pro- duce won’t have enough of these nutrients either.’ Breed- ers will have to improve the efficiency with which wheat extracts these nutrients from the soil, and just as impor- tantly, the efficiency with which it stores them in the grain. If researchers develop wheat varieties that deliver more minerals in their grain, agricultural productivity will im- prove, because plants, like people, need micronutrients. Seed with high concentrations of micronutrients produces more viable and vigorous seedlings. Wheat varieties that are better at taking minerals from the soil have better dis- ease resistance, nutrition and yields, particularly in mine- ral-deficient soils in arid regions. Plant breeding as a public health strategy Maarten van Ginkel and Richard Trethówan, CIMMYT bread-wheat breeders, have raised some important points related to breeding wheat with higher levels of micronu- trients. ‘Farmers growing the micronutrient-rich wheats will get higher yields and use fewer chemicals to control diseases,’ points out van Ginkel. Adds Trethowan, ‘Once the genes that increase grain micronutrient content are in- corporated into all our wheats, the costs of continuing to breed these wheats will be no different than the costs of breeding “normal” wheats.’ Because wheat is the most widely consumed crop in the world, the impact on nutri- tion could be extensive. In the long run, a breeding pro- gramme may cost less and reach more people than most nutrition programmes (another reason why plant breeding could be a sound public health strategy). Exploring possibilities to establish fortified crops Before one undertakes a programme for the development of a transgenic, preference of the consumers needs to be considered. As is understandable, golden rice6 fulfils many of the requirements that will help in containing malnutri- tion but for the yellow colour, and throughout the world yellow rice hardly finds a place on the dining table. More often, consumers prefer white products (e.g. milled rice, wheat flour, maize, etc.). Improving the β-carotene level in durum wheat would have been an easily acceptable preposition from the consumer point of view, since yellow or orange pasta products would have easy acceptance. There may be several such examples, which might fit in this framework. The scientist who is the main architect would himself have to take the initiative to popularize his product. This, however, goes against the temperament of the scientist, but it is imperative to work in this direction. The concerned scientist should involve scientists from different disciplines like biochemistry, nutrition, plant pathology, agronomy and extension services, and a scien- tist to evaluate the end-product potentialities of his bio- fortified product. The group of scientists will generate data on the product from different perspectives, which in turn will help convince the needy policy-makers. Major nutrition education programmes would have to be under- taken to convince consumers to switch over to these col- oured varieties. However, if these programmes are suc- cessful, then the yellow-orange colour will work as a marker for the more nutritious varieties compared to the less nutritious ones and a disadvantage might have been turned into an advantage7 . Biofortification through con- ventional breeding is a time-consuming process and has so far proved to be of little or no significance when it comes to enhancing nutrients like iron in wheat, which remains linked to phytate and is not freely available to the body unless the genes for phytase are incorporated. This is an issue that has not been studied in detail and needs attention. To handle the peculiar situation where the biofortified foods are struggling to serve their purpose, it would be appropriate to work out some other option which would be practical and would receive wider acceptability. Conclusion and economics involved Wide diversity exists for the micronutrients in wheat and related species (Table 6). Conventional breeding methodo- logy assisted by molecular markers tools can effectively be employed to develop wheat genotypes containing sig- nificantly higher amounts of critical micronutrients. Pre- sence of phytate is said to be responsible for obstructing the bioavailability of Zn and Fe. Information is inade- quate to demonstrate the difference in the availability of these nutrients when it comes to comparing high nutrient varieties with those carrying low amount of nutrients. Efforts made to transfer phytate genes from microbes have not been successful because of the thermosensitive nature of the enzyme. Development of GM crops is a feasible option to augment various crops with the required micronutri- ents. Several transgenics covering various crops are avail-
  • 6. GENERAL ARTICLES CURRENT SCIENCE, VOL. 86, NO. 9, 10 MAY 2004 1215 able today. Golden rice is a well-known example in which genes for lysine, iron, zinc and β-carotene have been suc- cessfully incorporated. An indica strain enriched with β- carotene and zinc is also now available8 . Such trans- genics are becoming increasingly popular and currently occupy over 40 million hectares globally9 . It is important to note that most of the transgenics have been developed in the West and the US, where the problem of malnutri- tion is not a major one. Certainly, the beneficiaries of these GM crops would be the developing and underdeveloped nations. The irony of the problem is that most developed nations are not ready to bring GM crops under cultiva- tion, obviously because they are not sure of their possible undesirable effects. The situation is not at all different in developing countries. Now, the question is whether we con- tinue to develop the transgenics in various crops or we concomitantly work for their logical acceptance as well, without which many of these transgenics may not see light of the day. Although benefits from supplementation and fortific- tion programmes are immediate and carry high benefit- to-cost ratio, benefits disappear fast if investments are not sustained to meet increasing level of investments year after year. If investments are sustained, benefits disappear fast. Some rough calculations may be made for these interven- tions. The cost of micronutrients and vitamin pills is not high, say Rs 50 per person per year. If one out of every ten persons were to receive supplementation, the whole exercise would require over Rs 500 crores per year on a regular basis for sustained benefits. Plant breeding on the other hand, would require one-time investment of only a few crores to develop micronutrient-rich wheat varieties which would be self-multiplying and self-sustaining. Although plant-breeding research has a longer gestation period before it makes an appreciable impact, an invest- ment of a few crores in two crops, rice and wheat, can take care of malnutrition on a long-term basis in a self-sus- tainable manner. Once introduced into the working germ- plasm, these traits will remain in all future cultivars and insulate the population at large against malnutrition. 1. Anon, Fourth Report on the World Nutrition Situation, United Nations, Geneva, Switzerland, 2000. 2. Haddad, L. and Alderman, H., Malnutrition: Income growth or nu- trition programs. In IFPRI 1999–2000, Annual Report, IFPRI, 2000. 3. Anon, Development in practice series. World Bank, Washington, DC, 1994. 4. Darnton, H. I. and Nalubola, R., Proc. Nutr. Soc., 2002, 61, 231– 241. 5. Graham, R., Welch, R. and Bouis, H., Adv. Agron., 2001, 70, 77– 142. 6. Ye, X., Al-Babili, S., Kloti, A., Zhang, J., Lucca, P., Beyer, P. and Potrykus, I., Science, 2000, 287, 303–305. 7. Hagenimana, V. and Low, J., Food Nutr. Bull., 2000, 21, 414–418. 8. Krishnan, S., Datta, K., Baisakh, N., Vasconcelos, M. and Datta, S. K., Curr. Sci., 2003, 84, 1232–1234. 9. Kim, J. K. and Krishnan, H. B. J. Crop Prod., 2002, 5, 93–130. 10. Kapoor et al., Indian J. Paediatr., 2002, 69, 607. 11. Anon, Agricultural Statistics at a Glance, Agricultural Statistics Division, Directorate of Economics and Statistics, Department of Agriculture and Cooperation, Ministry of Agriculture, Govt. of India, 2003, pp. 139–140. 12. UNICEF, The state of world’s children 2001. 13. US Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service, 1999, USDA Nutrient Database for Standard Reference, Release 13. Nutrient Data Laboratory Home Page, www.nal.usda.gov/fnic/ foodcomp 14. Bouis, H., Enrichment of food staples through plant breeding: A new strategy for fighting malnutrition. Nutrition, 2000, 16, 701–704. Received 27 October 2003; accepted 20 March 2004