Luke notices the girl he likes, Olivia, acting in a school play. After she leaves, a magic lamp prop drops and Luke wishes he wasn't a loser when rubbing it. A genie appears and offers to help Luke get Olivia's attention. The genie gives Luke a makeover and he spends time with Olivia, but realizes he has developed feelings for the genie instead. When Luke goes to confront Olivia, she insults his interests. Luke then wishes for the genie to no longer be bound to the lamp so they can be together.