The DIR Model
  Outcome Studies
     Summary
200 Cases of Children
• All children were seen for consultation or
  treatment by Dr. Greenspan over an 8
  year period.
• All children were evaluated on the autism
  spectrum by 2 or 3 other evaluation teams
• All children were treated in accordance
  with the comprehensive DIR Model
  described in the book Engaging Autism
Developmental Patterns
                                                                    Presenting Patterns
                                                              •     5% - no affective engagement
                                                              •     31% - only intermittent engagement
• Engagement                                                  •     40% - intermittent engagement and some
                                                                    reciprocity
                                                              •     24% - intermittent engagement and
                                                                    reciprocity and islands
                                                              •     of symbolic capacity
                                                              •     100% - lacking long chains of reciprocal
                                                                    interactions
• Auditory Processing Problems                                    • 100%

• Motor Planning Dysfunction                                      • 100%


• Reactivity to Sensation                                     • 39% - Underreactive
                                                              • 19% - Hyperreactive
                                                              • 36% - Mixed
•    *Journal of Developmental and Learning Disorders, 1997
DIR–Floortime Intervention
           Outcomes
                         All Degrees of Implementation of
                             Recommended Program
                             N=200
• Good to Outstanding    58%
• Medium                 25%
• Ongoing Difficulties   17%
Looking more closely at 20 children in the
                  good to
        outstanding outcome group
• In 1997 Greenspan & Wieder used the Functional
  Emotional Assessment Scale (FEAS. Greenspan,
  DeGangi, & Wieder, 2001),
   – a reliable and validated instrument which measures
     emotional, social, and intellectual functioning
• Compared these 20 children to an age and
  socioeconomic status-matched group of peers with no
  history of developmental challenges, as well as a group
  of children with ASD who had continuing challenges.
• They found there were no differences between the
  DIR/Floortime intervention group and the “typical” peer
  comparison group in terms of emotional, social, and
  intellectual functioning, but significant differences with
  the group that had continuing difficulties.
• They also assessed the group of twenty with the
  Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scale,( Sparrow, Balla, &
FEAS Outcomes
                           N Mean FEAS Range

• DIR/Floortime            3    74.8   70-76
  Intervention Group
• Normal Comparison        5    74.9   65-76
  Group
• Continuing Significant
                           12   23.7   <20-40
  Difficulties
Vineland Outcomes
   Sample of Children with Good to Outstanding
                    Outcomes
                      N=15

• Higher than age
  levels in                 • 93%
  communication
• Higher than age           • 87%
  levels in socialization
• Higher than age           • 53%
  levels in daily living
  skills
Recommended Books
Engaging Autism: Using the Floortime Approach to Help Children Relate,
Communicate, and Think, by Stanley I. Greenspan, M.D. & Serena Wieder,
Ph.D., 2006. Perseus Books, 800-242-7737.
The Child With Special Needs. by Stanley I. Greenspan, M.D. & Serena
Wieder, Ph.D., 1997. Perseus Books, 800-242-7737.
The Challenging Child. by Stanley I. Greenspan, M.D., 1995. Perseus Books.
The First Idea: How Symbols, Language and Intelligence Evolved from Our
Primate Ancestors to Modern Humans. By Stanley I. Greenspan, M.D. and
Stuart Shanker, Phil.D. 2004. Perseus Books, 800-242-7737.
Floor Time Techniques and the DIR Model for Children and Families with
Special Needs: Training Videotape Series. with Stanley I. Greenspan, M.D.
and Serena Wieder, Ph.D., 2001, a series of 13 videotapes available from ICDL,
301-656-2667.
Reaserch Support for a Comprehensive Developmental Approach to Autistic
Spectrum Disorders and Other Developmental and Learning Disorders: The
Developmental, Individual Difference, Relationship-Based Model. Stanley I.
Greenspan MD. Can be found at http://www.icdl.com - (301-656-2667)
                                                                                 8

Outcome study

  • 1.
    The DIR Model Outcome Studies Summary
  • 2.
    200 Cases ofChildren • All children were seen for consultation or treatment by Dr. Greenspan over an 8 year period. • All children were evaluated on the autism spectrum by 2 or 3 other evaluation teams • All children were treated in accordance with the comprehensive DIR Model described in the book Engaging Autism
  • 3.
    Developmental Patterns Presenting Patterns • 5% - no affective engagement • 31% - only intermittent engagement • Engagement • 40% - intermittent engagement and some reciprocity • 24% - intermittent engagement and reciprocity and islands • of symbolic capacity • 100% - lacking long chains of reciprocal interactions • Auditory Processing Problems • 100% • Motor Planning Dysfunction • 100% • Reactivity to Sensation • 39% - Underreactive • 19% - Hyperreactive • 36% - Mixed • *Journal of Developmental and Learning Disorders, 1997
  • 4.
    DIR–Floortime Intervention Outcomes All Degrees of Implementation of Recommended Program N=200 • Good to Outstanding 58% • Medium 25% • Ongoing Difficulties 17%
  • 5.
    Looking more closelyat 20 children in the good to outstanding outcome group • In 1997 Greenspan & Wieder used the Functional Emotional Assessment Scale (FEAS. Greenspan, DeGangi, & Wieder, 2001), – a reliable and validated instrument which measures emotional, social, and intellectual functioning • Compared these 20 children to an age and socioeconomic status-matched group of peers with no history of developmental challenges, as well as a group of children with ASD who had continuing challenges. • They found there were no differences between the DIR/Floortime intervention group and the “typical” peer comparison group in terms of emotional, social, and intellectual functioning, but significant differences with the group that had continuing difficulties. • They also assessed the group of twenty with the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scale,( Sparrow, Balla, &
  • 6.
    FEAS Outcomes N Mean FEAS Range • DIR/Floortime 3 74.8 70-76 Intervention Group • Normal Comparison 5 74.9 65-76 Group • Continuing Significant 12 23.7 <20-40 Difficulties
  • 7.
    Vineland Outcomes Sample of Children with Good to Outstanding Outcomes N=15 • Higher than age levels in • 93% communication • Higher than age • 87% levels in socialization • Higher than age • 53% levels in daily living skills
  • 8.
    Recommended Books Engaging Autism:Using the Floortime Approach to Help Children Relate, Communicate, and Think, by Stanley I. Greenspan, M.D. & Serena Wieder, Ph.D., 2006. Perseus Books, 800-242-7737. The Child With Special Needs. by Stanley I. Greenspan, M.D. & Serena Wieder, Ph.D., 1997. Perseus Books, 800-242-7737. The Challenging Child. by Stanley I. Greenspan, M.D., 1995. Perseus Books. The First Idea: How Symbols, Language and Intelligence Evolved from Our Primate Ancestors to Modern Humans. By Stanley I. Greenspan, M.D. and Stuart Shanker, Phil.D. 2004. Perseus Books, 800-242-7737. Floor Time Techniques and the DIR Model for Children and Families with Special Needs: Training Videotape Series. with Stanley I. Greenspan, M.D. and Serena Wieder, Ph.D., 2001, a series of 13 videotapes available from ICDL, 301-656-2667. Reaserch Support for a Comprehensive Developmental Approach to Autistic Spectrum Disorders and Other Developmental and Learning Disorders: The Developmental, Individual Difference, Relationship-Based Model. Stanley I. Greenspan MD. Can be found at http://www.icdl.com - (301-656-2667) 8