SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 11
 
 
Low NOx Burners (LNB) and  Separated  Overfire  Air (SOFA)
Old Dirty Plants (uncontrolled) Cleaner Retrofitted Plants New Power Plants Emissions Age of Plant
2008 NOx Rates With NGS LNB Performance Rank Plant State NOx (lb/MMBtu) Rank Plant State NOx (lb/MMBtu) 1 Riverside MN 0.99 1 Riverside MN 0.99 2 Bay Front WI 0.94 2 Bay Front WI 0.94 3 Lakeside IL 0.91 3 Lakeside IL 0.91 4 Sheldon NE 0.90 4 Sheldon NE 0.90 5 Chamois MO 0.87 5 Chamois MO 0.87 6 Niles OH 0.83 6 Niles OH 0.83 7 Coyote ND 0.77 7 Coyote ND 0.77 8 Alma WI 0.76 8 Alma WI 0.76 9 Streeter IA 0.74 9 Streeter IA 0.74 10 Dubuque IA 0.73 10 Dubuque IA 0.73 ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... 156 Navajo AZ 0.35 ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... 321 Navajo AZ 0.20
EPA Health Standard  In 2010 – EPA introduced a new short term, hourly NO2 standard of 100 ppb  (3 year average of 98% percentile). In 2010 - Page measured 28 ppb in regard to the new hourly standard
EPA Air Quality Index, adjusted by the American Lung Association Page - 2.6 ug/m3 annual average  24 hour PM 2.5 Concentration Air Quality Index 0.0 ug/m 3  to  15.4 ug/m 3 Good (Green) 15.4 ug/m 3   to  35.0 ug/m 3 Moderate (Yellow) 35.1 ug/m 3   to  65.4 ug/m 3 Unhealthy for Sensitive Groups (Orange) 65.5 ug/m 3   to  150.4 ug/m 3 Unhealthy (Red) 150.5 ug/m 3   to  250.4 ug/m 3 Very Unhealthy (Purple) Greater than or equal to 250.5 ug/m 3 Hazardous (Maroon)
 
 
Fourth Highest Daily Maximum 8-Hour Average Ozone Concentrations (ppb)in various National Parks for 2006–2008
 

More Related Content

Similar to NGS Emissions and Air Quality Compliance

Zell, Chris, Geosyntec Consultants, What's in the Smelter? Metals Criteria in...
Zell, Chris, Geosyntec Consultants, What's in the Smelter? Metals Criteria in...Zell, Chris, Geosyntec Consultants, What's in the Smelter? Metals Criteria in...
Zell, Chris, Geosyntec Consultants, What's in the Smelter? Metals Criteria in...Kevin Perry
 
The Right View on Environmental & Energy Policy
The Right View on Environmental & Energy PolicyThe Right View on Environmental & Energy Policy
The Right View on Environmental & Energy PolicyLeo Dombrowski
 
Thesis_11 11 2016
Thesis_11 11 2016Thesis_11 11 2016
Thesis_11 11 2016panukikale
 
Impact on Air Quality and Climate Change: Where the Dairy Industry Stands- Fr...
Impact on Air Quality and Climate Change: Where the Dairy Industry Stands- Fr...Impact on Air Quality and Climate Change: Where the Dairy Industry Stands- Fr...
Impact on Air Quality and Climate Change: Where the Dairy Industry Stands- Fr...DAIReXNET
 
Libby Dayton - What The Revised P Index Will Look Like
Libby Dayton - What The Revised P Index Will Look LikeLibby Dayton - What The Revised P Index Will Look Like
Libby Dayton - What The Revised P Index Will Look LikeJohn Blue
 
Chapter-16 Environmental Issues Biology NEET
Chapter-16 Environmental Issues Biology NEETChapter-16 Environmental Issues Biology NEET
Chapter-16 Environmental Issues Biology NEETNirav Soni
 
Conserving Energy Apes Project
Conserving Energy Apes ProjectConserving Energy Apes Project
Conserving Energy Apes ProjectJonathon Armaly
 
Tom Newmark - Field Trials in Costa Rica
Tom Newmark - Field Trials in Costa Rica Tom Newmark - Field Trials in Costa Rica
Tom Newmark - Field Trials in Costa Rica bio4climate
 
Tom Newmark - Field Trials in Costa Rica
Tom Newmark - Field Trials in Costa RicaTom Newmark - Field Trials in Costa Rica
Tom Newmark - Field Trials in Costa Ricagabriellebastien
 
Thomas Uva, "Upper Narragansett Bay Water Quality Sins of the Past, Present...
Thomas Uva, "Upper Narragansett Bay Water Quality  Sins of the Past, Present...Thomas Uva, "Upper Narragansett Bay Water Quality  Sins of the Past, Present...
Thomas Uva, "Upper Narragansett Bay Water Quality Sins of the Past, Present...riseagrant
 
Air Quality and Tree Programs
Air Quality and Tree ProgramsAir Quality and Tree Programs
Air Quality and Tree ProgramsCalifornia ReLeaf
 
Peter Grace On Rangelands and Calculators
Peter Grace On Rangelands and CalculatorsPeter Grace On Rangelands and Calculators
Peter Grace On Rangelands and CalculatorsCarbon Coalition
 

Similar to NGS Emissions and Air Quality Compliance (20)

Nitrogen Transformations in Aquaponic Systems
Nitrogen Transformations in Aquaponic SystemsNitrogen Transformations in Aquaponic Systems
Nitrogen Transformations in Aquaponic Systems
 
CLRA MSSS 2015 Walker Winnipeg
CLRA MSSS 2015 Walker WinnipegCLRA MSSS 2015 Walker Winnipeg
CLRA MSSS 2015 Walker Winnipeg
 
Zell, Chris, Geosyntec Consultants, What's in the Smelter? Metals Criteria in...
Zell, Chris, Geosyntec Consultants, What's in the Smelter? Metals Criteria in...Zell, Chris, Geosyntec Consultants, What's in the Smelter? Metals Criteria in...
Zell, Chris, Geosyntec Consultants, What's in the Smelter? Metals Criteria in...
 
The Right View on Environmental & Energy Policy
The Right View on Environmental & Energy PolicyThe Right View on Environmental & Energy Policy
The Right View on Environmental & Energy Policy
 
Thesis_11 11 2016
Thesis_11 11 2016Thesis_11 11 2016
Thesis_11 11 2016
 
Impact on Air Quality and Climate Change: Where the Dairy Industry Stands- Fr...
Impact on Air Quality and Climate Change: Where the Dairy Industry Stands- Fr...Impact on Air Quality and Climate Change: Where the Dairy Industry Stands- Fr...
Impact on Air Quality and Climate Change: Where the Dairy Industry Stands- Fr...
 
US Six Cities and Relevance for Clean Air Policy in Ireland
US Six Cities and Relevance for Clean Air Policy in IrelandUS Six Cities and Relevance for Clean Air Policy in Ireland
US Six Cities and Relevance for Clean Air Policy in Ireland
 
Soil conservation and greenhouse gas emissions - sean
Soil conservation and greenhouse gas emissions - sean Soil conservation and greenhouse gas emissions - sean
Soil conservation and greenhouse gas emissions - sean
 
Libby Dayton - What The Revised P Index Will Look Like
Libby Dayton - What The Revised P Index Will Look LikeLibby Dayton - What The Revised P Index Will Look Like
Libby Dayton - What The Revised P Index Will Look Like
 
Chapter-16 Environmental Issues Biology NEET
Chapter-16 Environmental Issues Biology NEETChapter-16 Environmental Issues Biology NEET
Chapter-16 Environmental Issues Biology NEET
 
ETHEROWS.DOC
ETHEROWS.DOCETHEROWS.DOC
ETHEROWS.DOC
 
Conserving Energy Apes Project
Conserving Energy Apes ProjectConserving Energy Apes Project
Conserving Energy Apes Project
 
chun2009.pdf
chun2009.pdfchun2009.pdf
chun2009.pdf
 
Woodchip bioreactors hoover & soupir
Woodchip bioreactors   hoover & soupirWoodchip bioreactors   hoover & soupir
Woodchip bioreactors hoover & soupir
 
Tom Newmark - Field Trials in Costa Rica
Tom Newmark - Field Trials in Costa Rica Tom Newmark - Field Trials in Costa Rica
Tom Newmark - Field Trials in Costa Rica
 
Tom Newmark - Field Trials in Costa Rica
Tom Newmark - Field Trials in Costa RicaTom Newmark - Field Trials in Costa Rica
Tom Newmark - Field Trials in Costa Rica
 
Alex Hobbs Biomass
Alex Hobbs   BiomassAlex Hobbs   Biomass
Alex Hobbs Biomass
 
Thomas Uva, "Upper Narragansett Bay Water Quality Sins of the Past, Present...
Thomas Uva, "Upper Narragansett Bay Water Quality  Sins of the Past, Present...Thomas Uva, "Upper Narragansett Bay Water Quality  Sins of the Past, Present...
Thomas Uva, "Upper Narragansett Bay Water Quality Sins of the Past, Present...
 
Air Quality and Tree Programs
Air Quality and Tree ProgramsAir Quality and Tree Programs
Air Quality and Tree Programs
 
Peter Grace On Rangelands and Calculators
Peter Grace On Rangelands and CalculatorsPeter Grace On Rangelands and Calculators
Peter Grace On Rangelands and Calculators
 

More from en3pro

Forgotten People and NGS: Securing Environmental and Climate Justice
Forgotten People and NGS: Securing Environmental and Climate JusticeForgotten People and NGS: Securing Environmental and Climate Justice
Forgotten People and NGS: Securing Environmental and Climate Justiceen3pro
 
John Coggins/SRP - Coal-fired Plants and Renewables
John Coggins/SRP - Coal-fired Plants and RenewablesJohn Coggins/SRP - Coal-fired Plants and Renewables
John Coggins/SRP - Coal-fired Plants and Renewablesen3pro
 
Peabody - Arizona Operations
Peabody - Arizona OperationsPeabody - Arizona Operations
Peabody - Arizona Operationsen3pro
 
DOI - Framework for a Solution
DOI - Framework for a SolutionDOI - Framework for a Solution
DOI - Framework for a Solutionen3pro
 
NGS Owners Initial Proposal Timeline Discussion
NGS Owners Initial Proposal Timeline DiscussionNGS Owners Initial Proposal Timeline Discussion
NGS Owners Initial Proposal Timeline Discussionen3pro
 
Grand Canyon Trust - Opportunity for Transition
Grand Canyon Trust - Opportunity for TransitionGrand Canyon Trust - Opportunity for Transition
Grand Canyon Trust - Opportunity for Transitionen3pro
 
Forgotten People and NGS - Securing Economic & Climate Justice
Forgotten People and NGS - Securing Economic & Climate JusticeForgotten People and NGS - Securing Economic & Climate Justice
Forgotten People and NGS - Securing Economic & Climate Justiceen3pro
 
NGS Owners Initial Proposal 1 21-2011
NGS Owners Initial Proposal 1 21-2011NGS Owners Initial Proposal 1 21-2011
NGS Owners Initial Proposal 1 21-2011en3pro
 
Gila River Indian Community and NGS Impacts
Gila River Indian Community and NGS ImpactsGila River Indian Community and NGS Impacts
Gila River Indian Community and NGS Impactsen3pro
 
Navajo Nation EPA - Comments to ANPRM for BART FIP for FCPP and NGS
Navajo Nation EPA - Comments to ANPRM for BART FIP for FCPP and NGSNavajo Nation EPA - Comments to ANPRM for BART FIP for FCPP and NGS
Navajo Nation EPA - Comments to ANPRM for BART FIP for FCPP and NGSen3pro
 
Arizona Coal: Economic Development for the Hopi Tribe
Arizona Coal: Economic Development for the Hopi TribeArizona Coal: Economic Development for the Hopi Tribe
Arizona Coal: Economic Development for the Hopi Tribeen3pro
 
USEPA 2011-01-07 presentation
USEPA 2011-01-07 presentationUSEPA 2011-01-07 presentation
USEPA 2011-01-07 presentationen3pro
 
Black Mesa Water Coalition - Green Economy
Black Mesa Water Coalition - Green EconomyBlack Mesa Water Coalition - Green Economy
Black Mesa Water Coalition - Green Economyen3pro
 
CAP and the Navajo Generating Station
CAP and the Navajo Generating StationCAP and the Navajo Generating Station
CAP and the Navajo Generating Stationen3pro
 
Air Pollution over Navajo and Hopi Lands - Beth Holland
Air Pollution over Navajo and Hopi Lands - Beth HollandAir Pollution over Navajo and Hopi Lands - Beth Holland
Air Pollution over Navajo and Hopi Lands - Beth Hollanden3pro
 

More from en3pro (15)

Forgotten People and NGS: Securing Environmental and Climate Justice
Forgotten People and NGS: Securing Environmental and Climate JusticeForgotten People and NGS: Securing Environmental and Climate Justice
Forgotten People and NGS: Securing Environmental and Climate Justice
 
John Coggins/SRP - Coal-fired Plants and Renewables
John Coggins/SRP - Coal-fired Plants and RenewablesJohn Coggins/SRP - Coal-fired Plants and Renewables
John Coggins/SRP - Coal-fired Plants and Renewables
 
Peabody - Arizona Operations
Peabody - Arizona OperationsPeabody - Arizona Operations
Peabody - Arizona Operations
 
DOI - Framework for a Solution
DOI - Framework for a SolutionDOI - Framework for a Solution
DOI - Framework for a Solution
 
NGS Owners Initial Proposal Timeline Discussion
NGS Owners Initial Proposal Timeline DiscussionNGS Owners Initial Proposal Timeline Discussion
NGS Owners Initial Proposal Timeline Discussion
 
Grand Canyon Trust - Opportunity for Transition
Grand Canyon Trust - Opportunity for TransitionGrand Canyon Trust - Opportunity for Transition
Grand Canyon Trust - Opportunity for Transition
 
Forgotten People and NGS - Securing Economic & Climate Justice
Forgotten People and NGS - Securing Economic & Climate JusticeForgotten People and NGS - Securing Economic & Climate Justice
Forgotten People and NGS - Securing Economic & Climate Justice
 
NGS Owners Initial Proposal 1 21-2011
NGS Owners Initial Proposal 1 21-2011NGS Owners Initial Proposal 1 21-2011
NGS Owners Initial Proposal 1 21-2011
 
Gila River Indian Community and NGS Impacts
Gila River Indian Community and NGS ImpactsGila River Indian Community and NGS Impacts
Gila River Indian Community and NGS Impacts
 
Navajo Nation EPA - Comments to ANPRM for BART FIP for FCPP and NGS
Navajo Nation EPA - Comments to ANPRM for BART FIP for FCPP and NGSNavajo Nation EPA - Comments to ANPRM for BART FIP for FCPP and NGS
Navajo Nation EPA - Comments to ANPRM for BART FIP for FCPP and NGS
 
Arizona Coal: Economic Development for the Hopi Tribe
Arizona Coal: Economic Development for the Hopi TribeArizona Coal: Economic Development for the Hopi Tribe
Arizona Coal: Economic Development for the Hopi Tribe
 
USEPA 2011-01-07 presentation
USEPA 2011-01-07 presentationUSEPA 2011-01-07 presentation
USEPA 2011-01-07 presentation
 
Black Mesa Water Coalition - Green Economy
Black Mesa Water Coalition - Green EconomyBlack Mesa Water Coalition - Green Economy
Black Mesa Water Coalition - Green Economy
 
CAP and the Navajo Generating Station
CAP and the Navajo Generating StationCAP and the Navajo Generating Station
CAP and the Navajo Generating Station
 
Air Pollution over Navajo and Hopi Lands - Beth Holland
Air Pollution over Navajo and Hopi Lands - Beth HollandAir Pollution over Navajo and Hopi Lands - Beth Holland
Air Pollution over Navajo and Hopi Lands - Beth Holland
 

NGS Emissions and Air Quality Compliance

  • 1.  
  • 2.  
  • 3. Low NOx Burners (LNB) and Separated Overfire Air (SOFA)
  • 4. Old Dirty Plants (uncontrolled) Cleaner Retrofitted Plants New Power Plants Emissions Age of Plant
  • 5. 2008 NOx Rates With NGS LNB Performance Rank Plant State NOx (lb/MMBtu) Rank Plant State NOx (lb/MMBtu) 1 Riverside MN 0.99 1 Riverside MN 0.99 2 Bay Front WI 0.94 2 Bay Front WI 0.94 3 Lakeside IL 0.91 3 Lakeside IL 0.91 4 Sheldon NE 0.90 4 Sheldon NE 0.90 5 Chamois MO 0.87 5 Chamois MO 0.87 6 Niles OH 0.83 6 Niles OH 0.83 7 Coyote ND 0.77 7 Coyote ND 0.77 8 Alma WI 0.76 8 Alma WI 0.76 9 Streeter IA 0.74 9 Streeter IA 0.74 10 Dubuque IA 0.73 10 Dubuque IA 0.73 ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... 156 Navajo AZ 0.35 ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... 321 Navajo AZ 0.20
  • 6. EPA Health Standard In 2010 – EPA introduced a new short term, hourly NO2 standard of 100 ppb (3 year average of 98% percentile). In 2010 - Page measured 28 ppb in regard to the new hourly standard
  • 7. EPA Air Quality Index, adjusted by the American Lung Association Page - 2.6 ug/m3 annual average 24 hour PM 2.5 Concentration Air Quality Index 0.0 ug/m 3 to 15.4 ug/m 3 Good (Green) 15.4 ug/m 3 to 35.0 ug/m 3 Moderate (Yellow) 35.1 ug/m 3 to 65.4 ug/m 3 Unhealthy for Sensitive Groups (Orange) 65.5 ug/m 3 to 150.4 ug/m 3 Unhealthy (Red) 150.5 ug/m 3 to 250.4 ug/m 3 Very Unhealthy (Purple) Greater than or equal to 250.5 ug/m 3 Hazardous (Maroon)
  • 8.  
  • 9.  
  • 10. Fourth Highest Daily Maximum 8-Hour Average Ozone Concentrations (ppb)in various National Parks for 2006–2008
  • 11.  

Editor's Notes

  1. On September 21, 2006, the EPA announced a revised 24-hour National Ambient Air Quality standard for PM2.5, changing the standard to 35 μg/m3 from 65 μg/m3. As of December 2009, the EPA had not yet announced changes to the Air Quality Index based on the new standard. The Lung Association adjusted the level of the category “Unhealthy for Sensitive Groups” to include the new standard, making that category range from 35.1 μg/m3 to 65.4 μg/m3.