SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Networks and judicial review Dr. Mariolina Eliantonio, LL.M. Maastricht University
Outline Introduction to networks Effectivejudicialprotection in the EU Identifying the gaps in judicialprotection Case specificdecisions Acts of general nature
1.1 Modelsofadministration ,[object Object]
E.g. Commission – competition law from 1960 until reform of 2003
Decentralised: application and enforcement of EU law by national administrative authorities
E.g. national regulatory authorities whichadministerEU telecommunication legislation
Agencies: actions of Member States are overlooked and subject to some control at the EU level
Networks between national authorities and the EU,[object Object]
1.3 Networks: legal nature The networks do not possess legal personality or autonomous powers They are an institutional infrastructure through which national authorities interact with each other and the Commission on matters directed at the successful exercise of their regulatory mandate
1.4 Networkdecisions: types Case specific: network may be consulted by national authorities in the course of decision-making proceedings Consultation on draft decisions of national authorities Facilitation of information exchange General: network adopts soft law policy instruments which are a guidance for national authorities Identification of best practices and performance indicators Position of the network members on how to best apply EU provisions Advice to Commission
1.5 Network decisions: consequences Decisions are in the realm of soft law ,[object Object]
Theydon’t have to beconsideredbycourts
Anywaytheytend to befollowedbycourts
lack of necessary expertise
respect for document agreeduponbyCommission and all nationalauthorities of the MS,[object Object]
3.1 Identifying the gaps in judicialprotection: case specificdecisionsa. case allocation Facilitatedby the network Exchanges and consultations on transfer are mattersbetween public enforcers Firms and complainants are informedthat a transfer takesplacebutthey don’t know the reasonswhichunderlie the determination Finaldetermination in the proceedingsissubjecttojudicialreview BUT itwillbe hard (ifnotimpossible) for the applicantto prove that the transfer wasunlawful
3.1 Identifyingthe gaps in judicialprotection: case specificdecisionsa. case allocation Solution network itselfmakesbindingact on transfer so decisionisreviewable Which court wouldthenhavejurisdiction?  Fearthat the mechanismwould stop working Harmonisationofproceduralenvironment so thatfirmswon’t have a reasontocomplainover transfer Itisfeasible? Legalbasis Itdesirable? Hugecosts and coherenceof the system
3.1 Identifyingthe gaps in judicialprotection: case specificdecisionsb. exchangeof information Happens within the network Exchange itself is considered an internal network matter: no decision is adopted and firms are not informed of the exchange Possible that transferee uses info they could either not have collected themselves or for whose collection the national procedural law would provide for more stringent requirements
3.1 Identifyingthe gaps in judicialprotection: case specificdecisionsb. exchangeof information Solution Act of transfer becomes a reviewable act Which court wouldthenhavejurisdiction?  Fear of underminining the effectiveness of the mechanism Review of the info collected on the basis of the transferee law Fear of underminining the effectiveness of the mechanism Harmonisation of rules on information Itisfeasible? Legalbasis Itdesirable? Differences are minimal, hugecosts and coherenceproblem

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Abstract of mit open course ware new textiles
Abstract of mit open course ware new textilesAbstract of mit open course ware new textiles
Abstract of mit open course ware new textiles
Marc Tena Gil
 
Manual administrativo conquistadores 2014 pdf
Manual administrativo conquistadores 2014   pdfManual administrativo conquistadores 2014   pdf
Manual administrativo conquistadores 2014 pdfPerú
 
Fintech for students
Fintech for studentsFintech for students
Fintech for students
Ferdinand Kjærulff
 
Pendidikan Kewarganegaraan - Wawasan Nusantara (Wilayah Perbatasan Indonesia)
Pendidikan Kewarganegaraan - Wawasan Nusantara (Wilayah Perbatasan Indonesia)Pendidikan Kewarganegaraan - Wawasan Nusantara (Wilayah Perbatasan Indonesia)
Pendidikan Kewarganegaraan - Wawasan Nusantara (Wilayah Perbatasan Indonesia)McNakagawa Apin
 
Perfecting The Supermarket Food Demo
Perfecting The Supermarket Food DemoPerfecting The Supermarket Food Demo
Perfecting The Supermarket Food Demo
Barbara Ruhs, MS, RD, LDN
 
Founders for Forum - Rising Star - CodersTrust pitch
Founders for Forum - Rising Star - CodersTrust pitchFounders for Forum - Rising Star - CodersTrust pitch
Founders for Forum - Rising Star - CodersTrust pitchFerdinand Kjærulff
 
Ain't Nobody Got Time For That!: Media Services Inservice Presentation
Ain't Nobody Got Time For That!: Media Services Inservice PresentationAin't Nobody Got Time For That!: Media Services Inservice Presentation
Ain't Nobody Got Time For That!: Media Services Inservice Presentationlewisandclarkcc
 
Fantasy and science fiction
Fantasy and science fictionFantasy and science fiction
Fantasy and science fiction
Melanie Swanson
 

Viewers also liked (12)

Abstract of mit open course ware new textiles
Abstract of mit open course ware new textilesAbstract of mit open course ware new textiles
Abstract of mit open course ware new textiles
 
Manual administrativo conquistadores 2014 pdf
Manual administrativo conquistadores 2014   pdfManual administrativo conquistadores 2014   pdf
Manual administrativo conquistadores 2014 pdf
 
Fintech for students
Fintech for studentsFintech for students
Fintech for students
 
Asam basa
Asam   basaAsam   basa
Asam basa
 
Pendidikan Kewarganegaraan - Wawasan Nusantara (Wilayah Perbatasan Indonesia)
Pendidikan Kewarganegaraan - Wawasan Nusantara (Wilayah Perbatasan Indonesia)Pendidikan Kewarganegaraan - Wawasan Nusantara (Wilayah Perbatasan Indonesia)
Pendidikan Kewarganegaraan - Wawasan Nusantara (Wilayah Perbatasan Indonesia)
 
Perfecting The Supermarket Food Demo
Perfecting The Supermarket Food DemoPerfecting The Supermarket Food Demo
Perfecting The Supermarket Food Demo
 
Zotero manual
Zotero manualZotero manual
Zotero manual
 
Brown act
Brown actBrown act
Brown act
 
Founders for Forum - Rising Star - CodersTrust pitch
Founders for Forum - Rising Star - CodersTrust pitchFounders for Forum - Rising Star - CodersTrust pitch
Founders for Forum - Rising Star - CodersTrust pitch
 
Virtuel køreskoleundervisning
Virtuel køreskoleundervisningVirtuel køreskoleundervisning
Virtuel køreskoleundervisning
 
Ain't Nobody Got Time For That!: Media Services Inservice Presentation
Ain't Nobody Got Time For That!: Media Services Inservice PresentationAin't Nobody Got Time For That!: Media Services Inservice Presentation
Ain't Nobody Got Time For That!: Media Services Inservice Presentation
 
Fantasy and science fiction
Fantasy and science fictionFantasy and science fiction
Fantasy and science fiction
 

Similar to Networks and judicial review

Environmental Protection Through E-Regulation: Critical and Empirical Perspec...
Environmental Protection Through E-Regulation: Critical and Empirical Perspec...Environmental Protection Through E-Regulation: Critical and Empirical Perspec...
Environmental Protection Through E-Regulation: Critical and Empirical Perspec...
Rónán Kennedy
 
20131009 aon security breach legislation
20131009 aon security breach legislation20131009 aon security breach legislation
20131009 aon security breach legislationJos Dumortier
 
Data Retention in the EU
Data Retention in the EUData Retention in the EU
Data Retention in the EUblogzilla
 
Regulatory Structure In Convergence
Regulatory Structure In ConvergenceRegulatory Structure In Convergence
Regulatory Structure In Convergence
Jorge Bossio
 
Proposal for a Regulation establishing the interoperability of EU informatio...
 Proposal for a Regulation establishing the interoperability of EU informatio... Proposal for a Regulation establishing the interoperability of EU informatio...
Proposal for a Regulation establishing the interoperability of EU informatio...
Thierry Debels
 
S. dudzik, enforceability of regulatory decisions
S. dudzik, enforceability of regulatory decisionsS. dudzik, enforceability of regulatory decisions
S. dudzik, enforceability of regulatory decisionsMichal
 
Access to competition file as a precondition of access to justice
Access to competition file as a precondition of access to justiceAccess to competition file as a precondition of access to justice
Access to competition file as a precondition of access to justice
Emanuela Matei
 
eIDAS Regulation (Reg. No. 910/2014)
eIDAS Regulation (Reg. No. 910/2014) eIDAS Regulation (Reg. No. 910/2014)
eIDAS Regulation (Reg. No. 910/2014)
Cosetta Masi
 
Synchronous Interconnection of Ukrainian and Moldovan Power Systems to ENTSO-...
Synchronous Interconnection of Ukrainian and Moldovan Power Systems to ENTSO-...Synchronous Interconnection of Ukrainian and Moldovan Power Systems to ENTSO-...
Synchronous Interconnection of Ukrainian and Moldovan Power Systems to ENTSO-...Stanislav Masevych
 
(DAMPS 2013) E-services via the Internet and compliance with the law. File 20...
(DAMPS 2013) E-services via the Internet and compliance with the law. File 20...(DAMPS 2013) E-services via the Internet and compliance with the law. File 20...
(DAMPS 2013) E-services via the Internet and compliance with the law. File 20...
Vytautas Čyras
 
Jurisdictional Issues In Internet Disputes
Jurisdictional Issues  In Internet DisputesJurisdictional Issues  In Internet Disputes
Jurisdictional Issues In Internet Disputes
Talwant Singh
 
Lex Cyber Law-Silvana Dode Mobility 2023.pptx
Lex Cyber Law-Silvana Dode Mobility 2023.pptxLex Cyber Law-Silvana Dode Mobility 2023.pptx
Lex Cyber Law-Silvana Dode Mobility 2023.pptx
ChristinaFortunova
 
Electronic Surveillance Of Communications 100225
Electronic Surveillance Of Communications 100225Electronic Surveillance Of Communications 100225
Electronic Surveillance Of Communications 100225
Klamberg
 
Electronic Surveillance of Communications 100225
Electronic Surveillance of Communications 100225Electronic Surveillance of Communications 100225
Electronic Surveillance of Communications 100225
Klamberg
 
SCL Annual Conference 2019: Regulating social media platforms for interoperab...
SCL Annual Conference 2019: Regulating social media platforms for interoperab...SCL Annual Conference 2019: Regulating social media platforms for interoperab...
SCL Annual Conference 2019: Regulating social media platforms for interoperab...
Chris Marsden
 
Table-ronde : Big data, partage des données et communs à l'échelle régionale ...
Table-ronde : Big data, partage des données et communs à l'échelle régionale ...Table-ronde : Big data, partage des données et communs à l'échelle régionale ...
Table-ronde : Big data, partage des données et communs à l'échelle régionale ...
Fund for Democratic Culture
 
Agenda, SIGMA Public procurement review bodies conference, Ohrid 9 June 2016
Agenda, SIGMA Public procurement review bodies conference, Ohrid 9 June 2016Agenda, SIGMA Public procurement review bodies conference, Ohrid 9 June 2016
Agenda, SIGMA Public procurement review bodies conference, Ohrid 9 June 2016
Support for Improvement in Governance and Management SIGMA
 
COMPUTER LAW, INVESTIGATION AND ETHICS DOMAIN
COMPUTER LAW, INVESTIGATION AND ETHICS DOMAINCOMPUTER LAW, INVESTIGATION AND ETHICS DOMAIN
COMPUTER LAW, INVESTIGATION AND ETHICS DOMAIN
amiable_indian
 

Similar to Networks and judicial review (20)

Environmental Protection Through E-Regulation: Critical and Empirical Perspec...
Environmental Protection Through E-Regulation: Critical and Empirical Perspec...Environmental Protection Through E-Regulation: Critical and Empirical Perspec...
Environmental Protection Through E-Regulation: Critical and Empirical Perspec...
 
20131009 aon security breach legislation
20131009 aon security breach legislation20131009 aon security breach legislation
20131009 aon security breach legislation
 
Data Retention in the EU
Data Retention in the EUData Retention in the EU
Data Retention in the EU
 
Regulatory Structure In Convergence
Regulatory Structure In ConvergenceRegulatory Structure In Convergence
Regulatory Structure In Convergence
 
Proposal for a Regulation establishing the interoperability of EU informatio...
 Proposal for a Regulation establishing the interoperability of EU informatio... Proposal for a Regulation establishing the interoperability of EU informatio...
Proposal for a Regulation establishing the interoperability of EU informatio...
 
S. dudzik, enforceability of regulatory decisions
S. dudzik, enforceability of regulatory decisionsS. dudzik, enforceability of regulatory decisions
S. dudzik, enforceability of regulatory decisions
 
Access to competition file as a precondition of access to justice
Access to competition file as a precondition of access to justiceAccess to competition file as a precondition of access to justice
Access to competition file as a precondition of access to justice
 
eIDAS Regulation (Reg. No. 910/2014)
eIDAS Regulation (Reg. No. 910/2014) eIDAS Regulation (Reg. No. 910/2014)
eIDAS Regulation (Reg. No. 910/2014)
 
Synchronous Interconnection of Ukrainian and Moldovan Power Systems to ENTSO-...
Synchronous Interconnection of Ukrainian and Moldovan Power Systems to ENTSO-...Synchronous Interconnection of Ukrainian and Moldovan Power Systems to ENTSO-...
Synchronous Interconnection of Ukrainian and Moldovan Power Systems to ENTSO-...
 
(DAMPS 2013) E-services via the Internet and compliance with the law. File 20...
(DAMPS 2013) E-services via the Internet and compliance with the law. File 20...(DAMPS 2013) E-services via the Internet and compliance with the law. File 20...
(DAMPS 2013) E-services via the Internet and compliance with the law. File 20...
 
Jurisdictional Issues In Internet Disputes
Jurisdictional Issues  In Internet DisputesJurisdictional Issues  In Internet Disputes
Jurisdictional Issues In Internet Disputes
 
Lex Cyber Law-Silvana Dode Mobility 2023.pptx
Lex Cyber Law-Silvana Dode Mobility 2023.pptxLex Cyber Law-Silvana Dode Mobility 2023.pptx
Lex Cyber Law-Silvana Dode Mobility 2023.pptx
 
I walden
I waldenI walden
I walden
 
Electronic Surveillance Of Communications 100225
Electronic Surveillance Of Communications 100225Electronic Surveillance Of Communications 100225
Electronic Surveillance Of Communications 100225
 
Electronic Surveillance of Communications 100225
Electronic Surveillance of Communications 100225Electronic Surveillance of Communications 100225
Electronic Surveillance of Communications 100225
 
SCL Annual Conference 2019: Regulating social media platforms for interoperab...
SCL Annual Conference 2019: Regulating social media platforms for interoperab...SCL Annual Conference 2019: Regulating social media platforms for interoperab...
SCL Annual Conference 2019: Regulating social media platforms for interoperab...
 
Table-ronde : Big data, partage des données et communs à l'échelle régionale ...
Table-ronde : Big data, partage des données et communs à l'échelle régionale ...Table-ronde : Big data, partage des données et communs à l'échelle régionale ...
Table-ronde : Big data, partage des données et communs à l'échelle régionale ...
 
Agenda, SIGMA Public procurement review bodies conference, Ohrid 9 June 2016
Agenda, SIGMA Public procurement review bodies conference, Ohrid 9 June 2016Agenda, SIGMA Public procurement review bodies conference, Ohrid 9 June 2016
Agenda, SIGMA Public procurement review bodies conference, Ohrid 9 June 2016
 
Sigismondi caso italia
Sigismondi caso italiaSigismondi caso italia
Sigismondi caso italia
 
COMPUTER LAW, INVESTIGATION AND ETHICS DOMAIN
COMPUTER LAW, INVESTIGATION AND ETHICS DOMAINCOMPUTER LAW, INVESTIGATION AND ETHICS DOMAIN
COMPUTER LAW, INVESTIGATION AND ETHICS DOMAIN
 

Recently uploaded

Supporting (UKRI) OA monographs at Salford.pptx
Supporting (UKRI) OA monographs at Salford.pptxSupporting (UKRI) OA monographs at Salford.pptx
Supporting (UKRI) OA monographs at Salford.pptx
Jisc
 
Thesis Statement for students diagnonsed withADHD.ppt
Thesis Statement for students diagnonsed withADHD.pptThesis Statement for students diagnonsed withADHD.ppt
Thesis Statement for students diagnonsed withADHD.ppt
EverAndrsGuerraGuerr
 
How to Break the cycle of negative Thoughts
How to Break the cycle of negative ThoughtsHow to Break the cycle of negative Thoughts
How to Break the cycle of negative Thoughts
Col Mukteshwar Prasad
 
Chapter 3 - Islamic Banking Products and Services.pptx
Chapter 3 - Islamic Banking Products and Services.pptxChapter 3 - Islamic Banking Products and Services.pptx
Chapter 3 - Islamic Banking Products and Services.pptx
Mohd Adib Abd Muin, Senior Lecturer at Universiti Utara Malaysia
 
Polish students' mobility in the Czech Republic
Polish students' mobility in the Czech RepublicPolish students' mobility in the Czech Republic
Polish students' mobility in the Czech Republic
Anna Sz.
 
Basic phrases for greeting and assisting costumers
Basic phrases for greeting and assisting costumersBasic phrases for greeting and assisting costumers
Basic phrases for greeting and assisting costumers
PedroFerreira53928
 
special B.ed 2nd year old paper_20240531.pdf
special B.ed 2nd year old paper_20240531.pdfspecial B.ed 2nd year old paper_20240531.pdf
special B.ed 2nd year old paper_20240531.pdf
Special education needs
 
Digital Tools and AI for Teaching Learning and Research
Digital Tools and AI for Teaching Learning and ResearchDigital Tools and AI for Teaching Learning and Research
Digital Tools and AI for Teaching Learning and Research
Vikramjit Singh
 
Additional Benefits for Employee Website.pdf
Additional Benefits for Employee Website.pdfAdditional Benefits for Employee Website.pdf
Additional Benefits for Employee Website.pdf
joachimlavalley1
 
Palestine last event orientationfvgnh .pptx
Palestine last event orientationfvgnh .pptxPalestine last event orientationfvgnh .pptx
Palestine last event orientationfvgnh .pptx
RaedMohamed3
 
The approach at University of Liverpool.pptx
The approach at University of Liverpool.pptxThe approach at University of Liverpool.pptx
The approach at University of Liverpool.pptx
Jisc
 
1.4 modern child centered education - mahatma gandhi-2.pptx
1.4 modern child centered education - mahatma gandhi-2.pptx1.4 modern child centered education - mahatma gandhi-2.pptx
1.4 modern child centered education - mahatma gandhi-2.pptx
JosvitaDsouza2
 
Template Jadual Bertugas Kelas (Boleh Edit)
Template Jadual Bertugas Kelas (Boleh Edit)Template Jadual Bertugas Kelas (Boleh Edit)
Template Jadual Bertugas Kelas (Boleh Edit)
rosedainty
 
Operation Blue Star - Saka Neela Tara
Operation Blue Star   -  Saka Neela TaraOperation Blue Star   -  Saka Neela Tara
Operation Blue Star - Saka Neela Tara
Balvir Singh
 
Home assignment II on Spectroscopy 2024 Answers.pdf
Home assignment II on Spectroscopy 2024 Answers.pdfHome assignment II on Spectroscopy 2024 Answers.pdf
Home assignment II on Spectroscopy 2024 Answers.pdf
Tamralipta Mahavidyalaya
 
Mule 4.6 & Java 17 Upgrade | MuleSoft Mysore Meetup #46
Mule 4.6 & Java 17 Upgrade | MuleSoft Mysore Meetup #46Mule 4.6 & Java 17 Upgrade | MuleSoft Mysore Meetup #46
Mule 4.6 & Java 17 Upgrade | MuleSoft Mysore Meetup #46
MysoreMuleSoftMeetup
 
CLASS 11 CBSE B.St Project AIDS TO TRADE - INSURANCE
CLASS 11 CBSE B.St Project AIDS TO TRADE - INSURANCECLASS 11 CBSE B.St Project AIDS TO TRADE - INSURANCE
CLASS 11 CBSE B.St Project AIDS TO TRADE - INSURANCE
BhavyaRajput3
 
Introduction to Quality Improvement Essentials
Introduction to Quality Improvement EssentialsIntroduction to Quality Improvement Essentials
Introduction to Quality Improvement Essentials
Excellence Foundation for South Sudan
 
Phrasal Verbs.XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
Phrasal Verbs.XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXPhrasal Verbs.XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
Phrasal Verbs.XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
MIRIAMSALINAS13
 
GIÁO ÁN DẠY THÊM (KẾ HOẠCH BÀI BUỔI 2) - TIẾNG ANH 8 GLOBAL SUCCESS (2 CỘT) N...
GIÁO ÁN DẠY THÊM (KẾ HOẠCH BÀI BUỔI 2) - TIẾNG ANH 8 GLOBAL SUCCESS (2 CỘT) N...GIÁO ÁN DẠY THÊM (KẾ HOẠCH BÀI BUỔI 2) - TIẾNG ANH 8 GLOBAL SUCCESS (2 CỘT) N...
GIÁO ÁN DẠY THÊM (KẾ HOẠCH BÀI BUỔI 2) - TIẾNG ANH 8 GLOBAL SUCCESS (2 CỘT) N...
Nguyen Thanh Tu Collection
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Supporting (UKRI) OA monographs at Salford.pptx
Supporting (UKRI) OA monographs at Salford.pptxSupporting (UKRI) OA monographs at Salford.pptx
Supporting (UKRI) OA monographs at Salford.pptx
 
Thesis Statement for students diagnonsed withADHD.ppt
Thesis Statement for students diagnonsed withADHD.pptThesis Statement for students diagnonsed withADHD.ppt
Thesis Statement for students diagnonsed withADHD.ppt
 
How to Break the cycle of negative Thoughts
How to Break the cycle of negative ThoughtsHow to Break the cycle of negative Thoughts
How to Break the cycle of negative Thoughts
 
Chapter 3 - Islamic Banking Products and Services.pptx
Chapter 3 - Islamic Banking Products and Services.pptxChapter 3 - Islamic Banking Products and Services.pptx
Chapter 3 - Islamic Banking Products and Services.pptx
 
Polish students' mobility in the Czech Republic
Polish students' mobility in the Czech RepublicPolish students' mobility in the Czech Republic
Polish students' mobility in the Czech Republic
 
Basic phrases for greeting and assisting costumers
Basic phrases for greeting and assisting costumersBasic phrases for greeting and assisting costumers
Basic phrases for greeting and assisting costumers
 
special B.ed 2nd year old paper_20240531.pdf
special B.ed 2nd year old paper_20240531.pdfspecial B.ed 2nd year old paper_20240531.pdf
special B.ed 2nd year old paper_20240531.pdf
 
Digital Tools and AI for Teaching Learning and Research
Digital Tools and AI for Teaching Learning and ResearchDigital Tools and AI for Teaching Learning and Research
Digital Tools and AI for Teaching Learning and Research
 
Additional Benefits for Employee Website.pdf
Additional Benefits for Employee Website.pdfAdditional Benefits for Employee Website.pdf
Additional Benefits for Employee Website.pdf
 
Palestine last event orientationfvgnh .pptx
Palestine last event orientationfvgnh .pptxPalestine last event orientationfvgnh .pptx
Palestine last event orientationfvgnh .pptx
 
The approach at University of Liverpool.pptx
The approach at University of Liverpool.pptxThe approach at University of Liverpool.pptx
The approach at University of Liverpool.pptx
 
1.4 modern child centered education - mahatma gandhi-2.pptx
1.4 modern child centered education - mahatma gandhi-2.pptx1.4 modern child centered education - mahatma gandhi-2.pptx
1.4 modern child centered education - mahatma gandhi-2.pptx
 
Template Jadual Bertugas Kelas (Boleh Edit)
Template Jadual Bertugas Kelas (Boleh Edit)Template Jadual Bertugas Kelas (Boleh Edit)
Template Jadual Bertugas Kelas (Boleh Edit)
 
Operation Blue Star - Saka Neela Tara
Operation Blue Star   -  Saka Neela TaraOperation Blue Star   -  Saka Neela Tara
Operation Blue Star - Saka Neela Tara
 
Home assignment II on Spectroscopy 2024 Answers.pdf
Home assignment II on Spectroscopy 2024 Answers.pdfHome assignment II on Spectroscopy 2024 Answers.pdf
Home assignment II on Spectroscopy 2024 Answers.pdf
 
Mule 4.6 & Java 17 Upgrade | MuleSoft Mysore Meetup #46
Mule 4.6 & Java 17 Upgrade | MuleSoft Mysore Meetup #46Mule 4.6 & Java 17 Upgrade | MuleSoft Mysore Meetup #46
Mule 4.6 & Java 17 Upgrade | MuleSoft Mysore Meetup #46
 
CLASS 11 CBSE B.St Project AIDS TO TRADE - INSURANCE
CLASS 11 CBSE B.St Project AIDS TO TRADE - INSURANCECLASS 11 CBSE B.St Project AIDS TO TRADE - INSURANCE
CLASS 11 CBSE B.St Project AIDS TO TRADE - INSURANCE
 
Introduction to Quality Improvement Essentials
Introduction to Quality Improvement EssentialsIntroduction to Quality Improvement Essentials
Introduction to Quality Improvement Essentials
 
Phrasal Verbs.XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
Phrasal Verbs.XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXPhrasal Verbs.XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
Phrasal Verbs.XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
 
GIÁO ÁN DẠY THÊM (KẾ HOẠCH BÀI BUỔI 2) - TIẾNG ANH 8 GLOBAL SUCCESS (2 CỘT) N...
GIÁO ÁN DẠY THÊM (KẾ HOẠCH BÀI BUỔI 2) - TIẾNG ANH 8 GLOBAL SUCCESS (2 CỘT) N...GIÁO ÁN DẠY THÊM (KẾ HOẠCH BÀI BUỔI 2) - TIẾNG ANH 8 GLOBAL SUCCESS (2 CỘT) N...
GIÁO ÁN DẠY THÊM (KẾ HOẠCH BÀI BUỔI 2) - TIẾNG ANH 8 GLOBAL SUCCESS (2 CỘT) N...
 

Networks and judicial review

  • 1. Networks and judicial review Dr. Mariolina Eliantonio, LL.M. Maastricht University
  • 2. Outline Introduction to networks Effectivejudicialprotection in the EU Identifying the gaps in judicialprotection Case specificdecisions Acts of general nature
  • 3.
  • 4. E.g. Commission – competition law from 1960 until reform of 2003
  • 5. Decentralised: application and enforcement of EU law by national administrative authorities
  • 6. E.g. national regulatory authorities whichadministerEU telecommunication legislation
  • 7. Agencies: actions of Member States are overlooked and subject to some control at the EU level
  • 8.
  • 9. 1.3 Networks: legal nature The networks do not possess legal personality or autonomous powers They are an institutional infrastructure through which national authorities interact with each other and the Commission on matters directed at the successful exercise of their regulatory mandate
  • 10. 1.4 Networkdecisions: types Case specific: network may be consulted by national authorities in the course of decision-making proceedings Consultation on draft decisions of national authorities Facilitation of information exchange General: network adopts soft law policy instruments which are a guidance for national authorities Identification of best practices and performance indicators Position of the network members on how to best apply EU provisions Advice to Commission
  • 11.
  • 12. Theydon’t have to beconsideredbycourts
  • 14. lack of necessary expertise
  • 15.
  • 16. 3.1 Identifying the gaps in judicialprotection: case specificdecisionsa. case allocation Facilitatedby the network Exchanges and consultations on transfer are mattersbetween public enforcers Firms and complainants are informedthat a transfer takesplacebutthey don’t know the reasonswhichunderlie the determination Finaldetermination in the proceedingsissubjecttojudicialreview BUT itwillbe hard (ifnotimpossible) for the applicantto prove that the transfer wasunlawful
  • 17. 3.1 Identifyingthe gaps in judicialprotection: case specificdecisionsa. case allocation Solution network itselfmakesbindingact on transfer so decisionisreviewable Which court wouldthenhavejurisdiction? Fearthat the mechanismwould stop working Harmonisationofproceduralenvironment so thatfirmswon’t have a reasontocomplainover transfer Itisfeasible? Legalbasis Itdesirable? Hugecosts and coherenceof the system
  • 18. 3.1 Identifyingthe gaps in judicialprotection: case specificdecisionsb. exchangeof information Happens within the network Exchange itself is considered an internal network matter: no decision is adopted and firms are not informed of the exchange Possible that transferee uses info they could either not have collected themselves or for whose collection the national procedural law would provide for more stringent requirements
  • 19. 3.1 Identifyingthe gaps in judicialprotection: case specificdecisionsb. exchangeof information Solution Act of transfer becomes a reviewable act Which court wouldthenhavejurisdiction? Fear of underminining the effectiveness of the mechanism Review of the info collected on the basis of the transferee law Fear of underminining the effectiveness of the mechanism Harmonisation of rules on information Itisfeasible? Legalbasis Itdesirable? Differences are minimal, hugecosts and coherenceproblem
  • 20. 3.1 Identifyingthe gaps in judicialprotection: case specificdecisions Conclusion do we need to fill these gaps? Network based governance was created to solve the problems created by the decentralised enforcement  providing an administrative infrastructure Its success as an administration model is based on the flexibility of the model If more judicial review is introduced, network members may become cautious in the use of the mechanisms
  • 21. 3.1 Identifyingthe gaps in judicialprotection: case specificdecisions Conclusion (II) Network decisions themselves should not be challengeable… … but then advantages of harmonisation become clear Neutralises incentives to litigation Avoids unequal treatment
  • 22. 3.2 Identifying the gaps in judicialprotection: actsofgeneral nature Aimed at influencing individual decisions of the national authorities Formally: soft law, no binding value However: documents generally followed by national authorities Risk: firms are constrained by these documents while they may embody a wrong or inefficient outcome Should these documents be made reviewable? Need to make them hard law to be reviewable (at this stage no court – national or EU – would rule on their legality because they don’t produce binding effects)
  • 23. 3.2 Identifyingthe gaps in judicialprotection: actsofgeneral nature Networks have to acquire legal personality and issue binding rules Advantages Incentive to keep high quality of the network documents Increase accountability and thus legitimacy of decisions Disadvantages Meroni complied with? Consensus on content harder to achieve National authorities more cautious on adopting decisions if they know they are binding More litigation and discouraging effect to produce more decisions in the future Courts will review decisions so less incentives to be innovative
  • 24. 3.2 Identifyingthe gaps in judicialprotection: actsofgeneral nature Problem of competent court National courts? Lack of expertise Different outcomes and risk of non uniform application CFI? Enough expertise Uniform solution for EU Problem with standing Individual concern: act of general nature Direct concern: there is act at national level + discretion of national authorities Change introduced by Lisbon doesn’t bring changes (direct concern still needs to be proven) Appellate body of the network itself Enough expertise Uniform solution Problem with independence?
  • 25. 3.2 Identifyingthe gaps in judicialprotection: actsofgeneral nature Even if access… intensity of review? Probably reticence Expertise of networks Conclusion Justiciability of network decisions problematic Solution through more ex ante participation? At the moment no right to be heard What if someone not consulted? No enforcement  rules governing participatory process are not binding Should they be? Too much procedure and slowness of system? System then no longer efficient?
  • 26. Thank you for your attention! Every remark, question, comment or suggestion is welcome atm.eliantonio@maastrichtuniversity.nl