Janice Neitzel
    Principal & Founder
Sustainable Solutions Group

  www.SustSolutions.com
Responsible Sourcing
► Demand for healthy, higher welfare food is greater
  than is supply and companies need a plan.
► Consumers and NGOs are demanding transparency
  in sourcing.
► Companies are seeking guidance to:

   1. Gain Competitive Advantage

   2. Have Parity with Competitors

   3. Avoid being an NGO target
Services

  Animal Welfare                         NGO Relationship
   Advisement                              Management




                         Responsible
                      Sourcing Roadmap




   Responsible                            CSR Messaging
Leadership Training
Guiding Responsible Sourcing
► We specialize in Animal Welfare Advisement.

► Through NGO Relationship Management we guide you
  avoid being an NGO target.

► We provide custom Responsible Leadership Training.

► We create CSR Messaging consistent with your brand.

► We guide your Responsible Sourcing Roadmap for
  healthy, higher welfare meat, dairy, & eggs.
Responsible Sourcing Roadmap




         Copyright Sustainable Solutions Group 2012
Team
   Janice Neitzel, MBA, Principal & Founder
   Guides top food industry decision-makers to plan and implement
   responsible sourcing improvements and CSR messaging.

   Dr. Temple Grandin, Advisor
   World-renowned expert on animal behavior and Professor of Animal Science at
   Colorado State University. 2010 Time Magazine’s 100 most influential people.

   Alma Triplett, Principal
   26 years experience at a $24B restaurant company managing global
   multi-cultural organizational change.

   Carter McRee, MBA, Principal
   With a PhD in Biomedical Sciences, uses a scientific approach to guide
   clients to source from healthier food production systems.

   Debbie Zapatka, Director of Graphic Design
   25 years graphic design for CVS/Caremark, SkyMall, PetSmart, Intel,
   Leo Burnett,, Ogilvy, and more.
Testimonials
 Harris Teeter, Brad Graham,                   Sonic Corp., Nancy Robertson,
 GVP Purchasing                                SVP, Franchise HR Development
 “Janice is a true professional! She has
 provided timely detailed direction and is a   “Your working with us has been so thought-
 results driven expert that consistently       provoking and helpful. Your help in
 delivers a high level of detailed knowledge   facilitating discussion on these (animal
 on tough industry issues. “                   welfare ) issues at Sonic has been huge.”




 Unilever, Kevin Wyderka,
                                               Ruby Tuesday, Rick Johnson,
 Systems Director
                                               SVP Purchasing
 “Janice demonstrates creativity and
                                               “It has been a privilege to work with you.
 balances reality. She has excellent
                                               We admire your dedication to the welfare
 facilitation skills to manage groups
                                               of animals.”
 effectively and bring them to
 consensus.”
Demand for Grass-fed / Organic
                                            2012 Hartman Group Report 1
                                            Cites grass-fed meat, cage-free eggs, and
                                            heirloom marbled pork as growing US trends.



                                            2011 AMI/FMI Joint Study 2
                                            Shows US consumer demand driving increased
                                            sales of organic and all-natural meat and poultry
                                            citing:
                                                 44%  better health
                                                 37%  better animal treatment
                                                 33%  better nutrition, taste & freshness

1   Source: http://www.foodnavigator-usa.com/On-your-radar/Sodium-reduction/Butter-portion-
    control-tart-cherries-and-stevia.-Welcome-to-2012
2   Source: http://www.progressivegrocer.com/inprint/article/id2274/ground-rules/
Demand to Ensure High Welfare
     2010 Consumers Perception of Food Production 1
     70% of US respondents want to know how producers are
     ensuring farmed animal care


                                                        2010 Context Marketing Study 2
                                                        70% of US consumers are willing to
                                                        pay more for “ethical” foods and
                                                        91% include animal welfare




1   Source: http://www.foodsystemsinsider.com/Consumer-perceptions-of-food-production/
    2010-05-06/Article_FSI.aspx?oid=1067779&fid=MAY_2010_1ST_FRIDAY
2   Source: http://contextmarketing.com/sources/feb28-2010/ethicalfoodreport.pdf
Consumers Want Welfare Labels
                                                   2011 Kansas University Study 1
                                                   Consumers will pay up to 20% more for
                                                   meat / eggs with a mandatory welfare label
                                                      consumers don't like gestation crates
                                                       or hen battery cages.


   2010 Australia 2
   After mandatory egg labeling of caged or un-caged
       cage free eggs sales increased 90%
       caged eggs sales fell 50%




Source: http://www.agmanager.info/livestock/marketing/AnimalWelfare/AW-
Labeling_FactSheet_07-19-11.pdf
Source: http://www.abc.net.au/news/2011-01-03/labelling-sees-free-range-egg-sales-soar/1892582
State Regulations Forthcoming
            Gestation Crate Bans
            California, Florida, Arizona,
            Maine, Oregon, Colorado,
            Michigan, Ohio



            Battery Cage Bans
            California, Michigan
2011 US Farmers & Ranchers
  Alliance Study
  ► Americans describe modern farming as
             mass production,
             subsidies,
             chemicals,
             factory farming,
             and animal cruelty
  ► 92% of US hens in battery cages
  ► 70% of US sows in gestation crates
Source:http://www.feedstuffsfoodlink.com/ME2/dirmod.asp?sid=&nm=&type=news&mod=
News&mid=9A02E3B96F2A415ABC72CB5F516B4C10&tier=3&nid=175440CE19204715
9190C24583EED5B7
US Consumers Support UEP
  Enriched Cage Bill
                                         ► 2012 Bantam Group Survey:
                                           Respondents support the bill
                                           4-to-1

                                         ► Transitions egg production
                                           from the barren “battery cages”
                                           to “enriched cages.”

                                         ► “Enriched cages” provide
                                           perches, nest boxes and
                                           scratch pads.
Image Source: http://kunc.org/post/ex-foes-stage-coop-detat-egg-laying-chickens

Source: http://www.meatingplace.com/MembersOnly/webNews/details.aspx?item=30291
Producers Need Support
for Transitions
                 ► Conversion Strategy
                 ► Change Management
                 ► Timeline Management
                 ► Financing

► Project Management of Entire Transition
Investor Sentiment
                                              2011 Motley Fool’s “Seeking
                                              More Humane Profits”
                                              “In their search for truly ethical
                                              companies, socially
                                              responsible investors highly
                                              rank businesses that work to
                                              eradicate cruelty from their
                                              operations.”



Source: http://www.fool.com/investing/general/2011/02/08/seeking-more-humane-profits.aspx
US Animal Welfare Market Leaders
       ► 2010 Stock up 157%
           “Food with Integrity”


       ► 2010 Stock up 72%
           Global Animal Partnership
            5-step Program
Sample Companies Sourcing
Higher Welfare Foods
McDonald’s and Compass Group
Requiring US Crate-Free
“McDonald’s believes gestation
stalls are not a sustainable
production system for the future.
There are alternatives that we
think are better for the welfare of
sows”
                          "Encouraged by Bon
                          Appetit's efforts, we are
                          proud to be the first large
                          foodservice company to
                          make this commitment.”
Commitments to 100% Cage-Free

                      Costco,
                      Trader
                      Joe’s, and
                      Walmart,
Subway plans to
                      have
switch 100 % of
                      committed
its eggs to cage-
                      all private
free and has
                      label eggs
already done so
                      to be
in the UK.
                      cage-free
Sara Lee & Kraft Sourcing
Cage-Free
             “Sara Lee has joined the
             national movement away from
             using eggs from caged hens…
             [and] has committed to
             purchase more than one million
             cage-free eggs per year.”

             “We recognize that animal
             welfare is an issue that
             resonates with customers, and
             we’re taking this step to address
             their concerns.”
Burger King Driving Change
“Our corporate conscience
drives our commitment to
animal welfare. For almost a
decade, we have used our
purchasing power to
encourage positive steps in
… the production of cage
free animal products.”
Increased Supply Needed due to
Consumer Demand and Transparency
      Level 4
                           Level 3
      Leaders
                      Planning even with
   Comprehensive
                        supply lacking
     Approach




      Level 1              Level 2
  Business as Usual   Taking Some Steps

Neitzel

  • 1.
    Janice Neitzel Principal & Founder Sustainable Solutions Group www.SustSolutions.com
  • 2.
    Responsible Sourcing ► Demandfor healthy, higher welfare food is greater than is supply and companies need a plan. ► Consumers and NGOs are demanding transparency in sourcing. ► Companies are seeking guidance to: 1. Gain Competitive Advantage 2. Have Parity with Competitors 3. Avoid being an NGO target
  • 3.
    Services AnimalWelfare NGO Relationship Advisement Management Responsible Sourcing Roadmap Responsible CSR Messaging Leadership Training
  • 4.
    Guiding Responsible Sourcing ►We specialize in Animal Welfare Advisement. ► Through NGO Relationship Management we guide you avoid being an NGO target. ► We provide custom Responsible Leadership Training. ► We create CSR Messaging consistent with your brand. ► We guide your Responsible Sourcing Roadmap for healthy, higher welfare meat, dairy, & eggs.
  • 5.
    Responsible Sourcing Roadmap Copyright Sustainable Solutions Group 2012
  • 6.
    Team Janice Neitzel, MBA, Principal & Founder Guides top food industry decision-makers to plan and implement responsible sourcing improvements and CSR messaging. Dr. Temple Grandin, Advisor World-renowned expert on animal behavior and Professor of Animal Science at Colorado State University. 2010 Time Magazine’s 100 most influential people. Alma Triplett, Principal 26 years experience at a $24B restaurant company managing global multi-cultural organizational change. Carter McRee, MBA, Principal With a PhD in Biomedical Sciences, uses a scientific approach to guide clients to source from healthier food production systems. Debbie Zapatka, Director of Graphic Design 25 years graphic design for CVS/Caremark, SkyMall, PetSmart, Intel, Leo Burnett,, Ogilvy, and more.
  • 7.
    Testimonials Harris Teeter,Brad Graham, Sonic Corp., Nancy Robertson, GVP Purchasing SVP, Franchise HR Development “Janice is a true professional! She has provided timely detailed direction and is a “Your working with us has been so thought- results driven expert that consistently provoking and helpful. Your help in delivers a high level of detailed knowledge facilitating discussion on these (animal on tough industry issues. “ welfare ) issues at Sonic has been huge.” Unilever, Kevin Wyderka, Ruby Tuesday, Rick Johnson, Systems Director SVP Purchasing “Janice demonstrates creativity and “It has been a privilege to work with you. balances reality. She has excellent We admire your dedication to the welfare facilitation skills to manage groups of animals.” effectively and bring them to consensus.”
  • 8.
    Demand for Grass-fed/ Organic 2012 Hartman Group Report 1 Cites grass-fed meat, cage-free eggs, and heirloom marbled pork as growing US trends. 2011 AMI/FMI Joint Study 2 Shows US consumer demand driving increased sales of organic and all-natural meat and poultry citing: 44%  better health 37%  better animal treatment 33%  better nutrition, taste & freshness 1 Source: http://www.foodnavigator-usa.com/On-your-radar/Sodium-reduction/Butter-portion- control-tart-cherries-and-stevia.-Welcome-to-2012 2 Source: http://www.progressivegrocer.com/inprint/article/id2274/ground-rules/
  • 9.
    Demand to EnsureHigh Welfare 2010 Consumers Perception of Food Production 1 70% of US respondents want to know how producers are ensuring farmed animal care 2010 Context Marketing Study 2 70% of US consumers are willing to pay more for “ethical” foods and 91% include animal welfare 1 Source: http://www.foodsystemsinsider.com/Consumer-perceptions-of-food-production/ 2010-05-06/Article_FSI.aspx?oid=1067779&fid=MAY_2010_1ST_FRIDAY 2 Source: http://contextmarketing.com/sources/feb28-2010/ethicalfoodreport.pdf
  • 10.
    Consumers Want WelfareLabels 2011 Kansas University Study 1 Consumers will pay up to 20% more for meat / eggs with a mandatory welfare label consumers don't like gestation crates  or hen battery cages. 2010 Australia 2 After mandatory egg labeling of caged or un-caged cage free eggs sales increased 90% caged eggs sales fell 50% Source: http://www.agmanager.info/livestock/marketing/AnimalWelfare/AW- Labeling_FactSheet_07-19-11.pdf Source: http://www.abc.net.au/news/2011-01-03/labelling-sees-free-range-egg-sales-soar/1892582
  • 11.
    State Regulations Forthcoming Gestation Crate Bans California, Florida, Arizona, Maine, Oregon, Colorado, Michigan, Ohio Battery Cage Bans California, Michigan
  • 12.
    2011 US Farmers& Ranchers Alliance Study ► Americans describe modern farming as  mass production,  subsidies,  chemicals,  factory farming,  and animal cruelty ► 92% of US hens in battery cages ► 70% of US sows in gestation crates Source:http://www.feedstuffsfoodlink.com/ME2/dirmod.asp?sid=&nm=&type=news&mod= News&mid=9A02E3B96F2A415ABC72CB5F516B4C10&tier=3&nid=175440CE19204715 9190C24583EED5B7
  • 13.
    US Consumers SupportUEP Enriched Cage Bill ► 2012 Bantam Group Survey: Respondents support the bill 4-to-1 ► Transitions egg production from the barren “battery cages” to “enriched cages.” ► “Enriched cages” provide perches, nest boxes and scratch pads. Image Source: http://kunc.org/post/ex-foes-stage-coop-detat-egg-laying-chickens Source: http://www.meatingplace.com/MembersOnly/webNews/details.aspx?item=30291
  • 14.
    Producers Need Support forTransitions ► Conversion Strategy ► Change Management ► Timeline Management ► Financing ► Project Management of Entire Transition
  • 15.
    Investor Sentiment 2011 Motley Fool’s “Seeking More Humane Profits” “In their search for truly ethical companies, socially responsible investors highly rank businesses that work to eradicate cruelty from their operations.” Source: http://www.fool.com/investing/general/2011/02/08/seeking-more-humane-profits.aspx
  • 16.
    US Animal WelfareMarket Leaders ► 2010 Stock up 157%  “Food with Integrity” ► 2010 Stock up 72%  Global Animal Partnership 5-step Program
  • 17.
  • 18.
    McDonald’s and CompassGroup Requiring US Crate-Free “McDonald’s believes gestation stalls are not a sustainable production system for the future. There are alternatives that we think are better for the welfare of sows” "Encouraged by Bon Appetit's efforts, we are proud to be the first large foodservice company to make this commitment.”
  • 19.
    Commitments to 100%Cage-Free Costco, Trader Joe’s, and Walmart, Subway plans to have switch 100 % of committed its eggs to cage- all private free and has label eggs already done so to be in the UK. cage-free
  • 20.
    Sara Lee &Kraft Sourcing Cage-Free “Sara Lee has joined the national movement away from using eggs from caged hens… [and] has committed to purchase more than one million cage-free eggs per year.” “We recognize that animal welfare is an issue that resonates with customers, and we’re taking this step to address their concerns.”
  • 21.
    Burger King DrivingChange “Our corporate conscience drives our commitment to animal welfare. For almost a decade, we have used our purchasing power to encourage positive steps in … the production of cage free animal products.”
  • 22.
    Increased Supply Neededdue to Consumer Demand and Transparency Level 4 Level 3 Leaders Planning even with Comprehensive supply lacking Approach Level 1 Level 2 Business as Usual Taking Some Steps