Mr. Friend is a
crime analyst
with the Santa
Cruz, California,
Police
Department.
Predictive Policing: Using Technology to Reduce Crime
By Zach Friend, M.P.P.
4/9/2013
Nationwide law enforcement agencies face the problem
of doing more with less. Departments slash budgets
and implement furloughs, while management struggles
to meet the public safety needs of the community. The
Santa Cruz, California, Police Department handles the
same issues with increasing property crimes and
service calls and diminishing staff. Unable to hire more
officers, the department searched for a nontraditional
solution.
In late 2010 researchers published a paper that the
department believed might hold the answer. They
proposed that it was possible to predict certain crimes,
much like scientists forecast earthquake aftershocks.
An “aftercrime” often follows an initial crime. The time and location of previous criminal activity helps to
determine future offenses. These researchers developed an algorithm (mathematical procedure) that
calculates future crime locations.1
Equalizing Resources
The Santa Cruz Police Department has 94 sworn officers and serves a population of 60,000. A
university, amusement park, and beach push the seasonal population to 150,000. Department personnel
contacted a Santa Clara University professor to apply the algorithm, hoping that leveraging technology
would improve their efforts. The police chief indicated that the department could not hire more officers.
He felt that the program could allocate dwindling resources more efficiently.
Santa Cruz police envisioned deploying officers by shift to the most targeted locations in the city. The
predictive policing model helped to alert officers to targeted locations in real time, a significant
improvement over traditional tactics.
Making it Work
The algorithm is a culmination of anthropological and criminological behavior research. It uses complex
mathematics to estimate crime and predict future hot spots. Researchers based these studies on
In Depth
Featured Articles
- IAFIS Identifies Suspect from 1978 Murder Case
- Predictive Policing: Using Technology to Reduce
Crime
- Legal Digest Part 1 - Part 2
Search Warrant Execution: When Does Detention Rise to
Custody?
- Perspective
Public Safety Consolidation: Does it Make Sense?
- Leadership Spotlight
Leadership Lessons from Home
Archive
- Web and Print
Departments
- Bulletin Notes - Bulletin Honors
- ViCAP Alerts - Unusual Weapons
- Bulletin Reports
Topics in the News
See previous LEB content on:
- Hostage Situations - Crisis Management
- School Violence - Psychopathy
About LEB
- History - Author Guidelines (pdf)
- Editorial Staff - Editorial Release Form (pdf)
Patch Call
Known locally as the
“Gateway to the Summit,”
which references the city’s
proximity to the Bechtel Family
National Scout Reserve. More
The patch of the Miamisburg,
Ohio, Police Department
prominently displays the city
seal surroun.
Student #1 I have chosen to write about the history of data anal.docxjohniemcm5zt
Student #1
I have chosen to write about the history of data analysis for the Los Angeles Police Department. While I currently reside in Colorado Springs, Colorado and work as a deputy sheriff in Denver, Colorado I grew up in the greater Los Angeles area and I know that they should have a large amount of data to draw from.
Currently the Los Angeles Police Department uses COMPSTAT to compile their data. They have a unit, known as the COMPSTAT unit, whose sole job is to compile crime statistics and analyze the data (Los Angeles Police Department, 2016) COMPSTAT is short for computer statistics. COMPSTAT was developed by Police Commissioner William Bratton in 1994 for use by the New York Police Department. According to the University of Maryland by the year 2000 over a third of police agencies with over 100 officers were utilizing some sort of COMPSTAT like program (University of Maryland, 2015). In 2002 William Bratton became the Chief of Police for the Los Angeles Police Department and brought with him the concept of COMPSTAT. During the first six years of his tenure Los Angeles saw a steady decrease in the cities crime rates thanks largely in part to COMPSTAT policing.
Mean, mode and median play a large part in analyzing criminal data. The mean is the average number. An example of this for crime data analysis would be in neighborhood C there was 14 robberies committed on Monday between 1 and 3 AM, 17 robberies on Tuesday at the same time period and 9 on Wednesday during the same time period. The mean would be 13.3 robberies per night for those 3 nights. Knowing this is high for the city the data could be used to justify extra police presence in Neighborhood C. An example of the mode would be if in the same neighborhood in the same week there were 17 robberies on both Friday and Saturday, 12 on Thursday and 11 on Sunday. The mode would be 17 and it would also be a reason to add extra police presence in the neighborhood until a significant decrease was seen in the amount of robberies taking place. Finally we come to the median. This is simply line the numbers up for the week and take the number that falls in the middle. In the case of the robberies occurring in neighborhood C the number would be 14. All of this data can be combined to show watch commanders and captain’s areas where they should be focusing their officer’s time. If there is a neighborhood that has seen only one or two robberies during the week, it is definitely not in as much need of a heavy police presence as Neighborhood C is.
Student #2
Beginning in the mid-1990’s, police in New York began to run statistical analysis of the city’s crime reports, arrests and other police activity known as COMPSTAT. Law enforcement agencies since this analysis began, has implemented their own data-driven approaches to tracking and adapting to crime trends. The LAPD is both heavily armed and thoroughly computerized. The Real-Time Analysis and Critical Response Division is its central processor..
As per studies conducted by the University of California, it is observed that crime in any area follows the same pattern as that of earthquake aftershocks. It is difficult to predict an earthquake, but once it happens the aftershocks following it are quite predictable. Same is true for the crimes happening in a geographical area.
Student #1 I have chosen to write about the history of data anal.docxjohniemcm5zt
Student #1
I have chosen to write about the history of data analysis for the Los Angeles Police Department. While I currently reside in Colorado Springs, Colorado and work as a deputy sheriff in Denver, Colorado I grew up in the greater Los Angeles area and I know that they should have a large amount of data to draw from.
Currently the Los Angeles Police Department uses COMPSTAT to compile their data. They have a unit, known as the COMPSTAT unit, whose sole job is to compile crime statistics and analyze the data (Los Angeles Police Department, 2016) COMPSTAT is short for computer statistics. COMPSTAT was developed by Police Commissioner William Bratton in 1994 for use by the New York Police Department. According to the University of Maryland by the year 2000 over a third of police agencies with over 100 officers were utilizing some sort of COMPSTAT like program (University of Maryland, 2015). In 2002 William Bratton became the Chief of Police for the Los Angeles Police Department and brought with him the concept of COMPSTAT. During the first six years of his tenure Los Angeles saw a steady decrease in the cities crime rates thanks largely in part to COMPSTAT policing.
Mean, mode and median play a large part in analyzing criminal data. The mean is the average number. An example of this for crime data analysis would be in neighborhood C there was 14 robberies committed on Monday between 1 and 3 AM, 17 robberies on Tuesday at the same time period and 9 on Wednesday during the same time period. The mean would be 13.3 robberies per night for those 3 nights. Knowing this is high for the city the data could be used to justify extra police presence in Neighborhood C. An example of the mode would be if in the same neighborhood in the same week there were 17 robberies on both Friday and Saturday, 12 on Thursday and 11 on Sunday. The mode would be 17 and it would also be a reason to add extra police presence in the neighborhood until a significant decrease was seen in the amount of robberies taking place. Finally we come to the median. This is simply line the numbers up for the week and take the number that falls in the middle. In the case of the robberies occurring in neighborhood C the number would be 14. All of this data can be combined to show watch commanders and captain’s areas where they should be focusing their officer’s time. If there is a neighborhood that has seen only one or two robberies during the week, it is definitely not in as much need of a heavy police presence as Neighborhood C is.
Student #2
Beginning in the mid-1990’s, police in New York began to run statistical analysis of the city’s crime reports, arrests and other police activity known as COMPSTAT. Law enforcement agencies since this analysis began, has implemented their own data-driven approaches to tracking and adapting to crime trends. The LAPD is both heavily armed and thoroughly computerized. The Real-Time Analysis and Critical Response Division is its central processor..
As per studies conducted by the University of California, it is observed that crime in any area follows the same pattern as that of earthquake aftershocks. It is difficult to predict an earthquake, but once it happens the aftershocks following it are quite predictable. Same is true for the crimes happening in a geographical area.
This paper focuses on finding spatial and temporal criminal hotspots. It analyses two different real-world crimes datasets for Denver, CO and Los Angeles, CA and provides a comparison between the two datasets through a statistical analysis supported by several graphs. Then, it clarifies how we conducted Apriori algorithm to produce interesting frequent patterns for criminal hotspots. In addition, the paper shows how we used Decision Tree classifier and Naïve Bayesian classifier in order to predict potential crime types. To further analyse crimes’ datasets, the paper introduces an analysis study by combining our findings of Denver crimes’ dataset with its demographics information in order to capture the factors that might affect the safety of neighborhoods. The results of this solution could be used to raise people’s awareness regarding the dangerous locations and to help agencies to predict future crimes in a specific location within
a particular time.
An unsupervised learning
k-means clustering technique is used to identify and focus
on a set of crimes (prostitution, narcotics, burglary, battery
and interference with a public officer) recorded in the city
of Chicago. The crime data is supplemented with orthogonal
temperature and unemployment data. ANOVA and Kruskal-
Wallis statistical tests assess the temporal significance in
crimes clusters. The findings indicate various crime hot spots
which are temporal and location specific, and therefore may
act as input to the scheduling and allocation of policing resources.
Advanced Search February 2015Back to Archives B.docxdaniahendric
Advanced Search
February 2015
Back to Archives | Back to September 2010 Contents
Proactive Patrolling through the Use of Patrol Scripts
By David A. Rivero, Chief of Police, University of Miami Police Department, Coral Gables, Florida; and John P.
Pepper, Crime Prevention and Emergency Management Coordinator, University of Miami Police Department,
Coral Gables, Florida
Click to view the digital edition.
atrol has been, is, and will continue to be the backbone of college and local policing. Response to
emergency and nonemergency calls to patrol officers for service is a primary component of policing or,
more specifically, reactive policing. Most law enforcement commanders would say they try to eliminate the need
for their patrol officers to be reactive through the institution of various proactive patrol initiatives. It’s a valid
concept in theory and in proven practice: prevent the crimes before they happen so reactive, after-the-fact
response becomes unnecessary. The result is fewer persons victimized, less financial and personal loss, less
overall crime, and more police recognition and appreciation. Everyone wins.
Though many college and local law enforcement agencies are often busy with reactive call response, most
agencies would cite that, at any given time, there is at least one officer available and not assigned to any call.
The question then becomes how to best utilize these limited available patrol resources to proactively prevent
future reactive responses.
Random patrol has long been an accepted allocation of these available patrol resources. The University of
Miami in Coral Gables, Florida, sought a better and more effective methodology for preventing crime that is
focused and targeted at the times and locations where crimes are likely to occur.
Crime is often cited as unpredictable. To some extent, it is, but to some extent, it is not. It is basically impossible
to know exactly when and where a specific crime is going to occur without good intelligence. It is, however,
possible to identify general locations and corresponding times when crimes may be more likely to occur. Some
law enforcement agencies have recognized this through crime analysis and crime mapping techniques. At
certain times, in certain areas, and under certain conditions, crime will occur at an above-average rate; often,
such situational convergences are referred to as “hot spots.” Some agencies use this information to direct
available patrol resources to hot spots during the times of high crime incidence. Specific planned events also
recognized the need for additional attention from current patrolling officers, as more people means more
potential for crimes. Often, crime analysis data and event scheduling data lead to the issuance of general be-on-
the-lookout (BOLO) notices and watch orders for regular on-duty officers. These are effective guidance tools. At
the University of Miami, it was decided to institutionalize daily guidance to the officers thro ...
PredPol: How Predictive Policing WorksPredPol, Inc
PredPol’s cloud-based predictive policing software enables law enforcement agencies to better prevent crime in their communities by generating predictions on the places and times that future crimes are most likely to occur.
PredPol’s technology has been helping law enforcement agencies to dramatically reduce crime in jurisdictions of all types and sizes, across the U.S. and overseas. Over the past year, Atlanta and Los Angeles have reduced specific crimes in targeted areas at rates ranging from nearly 20% to over 40%. Smaller jurisdictions, such as Norcross, Georgia, have seen nearly a 30% reduction in burglaries and robberies; in Alhambra, California, car burglaries have dropped 20% since the software technology was deployed.
Using advanced mathematics and computer learning, PredPol’s algorithms predict many types of crime, including property crimes, drug incidents, gang activity, and gun violence as well as traffic accidents.
Only three pieces of data are used to make predictions – type of crime, place of crime, and time of crime. No personal data is utilized in making these predictions.
Crime analysts and command staff using PredPol are 100% more effective than they are with traditional hotspot mapping at predicting where and when crimes are likely to occur. That means police have twice as many opportunities to deter and reduce crime.
Biased-Based Policing Reports Are Failing
the Police and the Community
Why Agencies Need to Stop Using Census Data
Richard R. Johnson, Ph.D.
September, 2016
Recent public opinion surveys have revealed that the vast majority of Americans believe that use
of racial profiling by the police is widespread.1 This is deeply disturbing for two reasons. First, it
is disturbing because it undermines police legitimacy among the vast majority of our citize ns.
Second, it is disturbing because the vast majority of law enforcement officers I have known do not
engage in bias-based policing. While racial profiling likely occurs among a small number of
individual officers acting outside the bounds of their oath to uphold the Constitution, it is unlike ly
that racial profiling is systemic to law enforcement in the United States.
This begs the question, then, why do so many people perceive that racial profiling is widespread?
We could blame individual members of the news media that seek to raise their ratings by stoking
the flames of controversy, or certain protest organizations that seek to capitalize on distrust of the
police. To be sure, these sources have contributed to the problem. Another factor that has also
contributed to the problem, however, is the fundamentally flawed information that many
law enforcement agencies have given the public through their biased-based policing data that
was gathered and reported incorrectly.
Many law enforcement agencies gather data on the race and gender of the individuals their officers
stop, search, and arrest. They report these data to the public in a biased-based policing report.
Agencies produce these reports for a variety of reasons, such as statutory requirements, as part of
their compliance with CALEA Standard 1.2.9.d, or simply out of a sincere desire to embrace
transparency. While most law enforcement agencies, and individual officers, claim they do not
racially profile, the vast majority of these reports show members of minority groups, especially
African-American men, are disproportionately stopped, searched, and arrested. Why? One factor
at work is the use of incorrect research methodologies and measures that are biased (often
unintentionally) against officers from the start. One of the most damaging of these incorrect
methodologies is the use of U.S. Census data as a benchmark comparison.
http://dolanconsultinggroup.com/
http://dolanconsultinggroup.com/instructor/richard-r-johnson-phd/
http://dolanconsultinggroup.com/
Benchmarks
In order for any racial profiling data collection activity to be meaningful, the racial composition of
police stops, searches, and arrests need to be compared to something. A benchmark is generally
defined as a point of reference from which measurements may be made; something that serves as
a standard by which others may be measured or judged; or a standardized problem or test that
serves as a basis for evaluat ...
Running head: CRIME ANALYSIS 1
CRIME ANALYSIS TECHNOLOGY 2
Crime analysis is a function that usually involves the systemic analysis in identifying as well as analyzing the crime patterns and trends. Crime analysis is very important for law enforcement agencies as it helps law enforcers effectively deploy the available resources in a better and effective manner, which enables them to identify and apprehend suspects. Crime analysis is also very significant when it comes to arriving at solutions devised to come up with the right solution to solve the current crime problem and issues as well as coming up with the right prevention strategies. Since the year 2014, crime rates in the USA have increased steadily as per a study done by USAFacts, which is a non-partisan initiative (Osborne & Wernicke, 2013). With this increase in crime rates, which has majorly resulted in massive growth in technology, it is essential to come up with better means and ways of dealing with the increased crime rates. With the current advancement in technology, better law enforcement tools developed, which has enabled better crime deterrence in better and efficient ways. All this has been facilitated by the efforts of crime analysts who have come up with better tools and thus enabling the law enforcers to better deal with the crimes (Osborne & Wernicke, 2013). In this paper, I will consider the application of crime analysis technology and techniques in fighting crimes. Application of crime analysis technology and techniques used to make crime analysis more accurate and efficient.
Currently, the two technological tools that are used in predictive policing software have enabled security agencies to effectively use predictive policing ("Crime Analysis: Fighting Crime with Data," 2017). Application of this software has enabled better crime prevention as with data obtained in the previous crimes have been used to predict possible future severe crimes in a specific area.
Through the adoption and use of crime analysis, law enforcement agencies have been able to fight against crimes as when compared with the past effectively. The use of crime analysis comes at the right time, where there has been an increase in crime rates in the current digital error. In a survey done by Wynyard group in 2015, the study revealed that for every 10 law enforcement officials 9 of them believe that the use of current technology in crime analysis has had positive effects in helping the agencies in solving crimes as they can identify essential links and trends in crimes ("Crime Analysis: Fighting Crime with Data," 2017). In the same way, other sectors have benefited from data analysis with spreadsheets, databases, and mapping, law enforcers have been able to use data analysis to come up with a better decision. Crime analysis ha ...
Running head: CRIME ANALYSIS 1
CRIME ANALYSIS TECHNOLOGY 2
Crime analysis is a function that usually involves the systemic analysis in identifying as well as analyzing the crime patterns and trends. Crime analysis is very important for law enforcement agencies as it helps law enforcers effectively deploy the available resources in a better and effective manner, which enables them to identify and apprehend suspects. Crime analysis is also very significant when it comes to arriving at solutions devised to come up with the right solution to solve the current crime problem and issues as well as coming up with the right prevention strategies. Since the year 2014, crime rates in the USA have increased steadily as per a study done by USAFacts, which is a non-partisan initiative (Osborne & Wernicke, 2013). With this increase in crime rates, which has majorly resulted in massive growth in technology, it is essential to come up with better means and ways of dealing with the increased crime rates. With the current advancement in technology, better law enforcement tools developed, which has enabled better crime deterrence in better and efficient ways. All this has been facilitated by the efforts of crime analysts who have come up with better tools and thus enabling the law enforcers to better deal with the crimes (Osborne & Wernicke, 2013). In this paper, I will consider the application of crime analysis technology and techniques in fighting crimes. Application of crime analysis technology and techniques used to make crime analysis more accurate and efficient.
Currently, the two technological tools that are used in predictive policing software have enabled security agencies to effectively use predictive policing ("Crime Analysis: Fighting Crime with Data," 2017). Application of this software has enabled better crime prevention as with data obtained in the previous crimes have been used to predict possible future severe crimes in a specific area.
Through the adoption and use of crime analysis, law enforcement agencies have been able to fight against crimes as when compared with the past effectively. The use of crime analysis comes at the right time, where there has been an increase in crime rates in the current digital error. In a survey done by Wynyard group in 2015, the study revealed that for every 10 law enforcement officials 9 of them believe that the use of current technology in crime analysis has had positive effects in helping the agencies in solving crimes as they can identify essential links and trends in crimes ("Crime Analysis: Fighting Crime with Data," 2017). In the same way, other sectors have benefited from data analysis with spreadsheets, databases, and mapping, law enforcers have been able to use data analysis to come up with a better decision. Crime analysis ha.
Mr. Bush, a 45-year-old middle school teacher arrives at the emergen.docxaudeleypearl
Mr. Bush, a 45-year-old middle school teacher arrives at the emergency department by EMS ground transport after he experienced severe mid-sternal chest pain at work. On arrival to the ED:
a. What priority interventions would you initiate?
b. What information would you require to definitively determine what was causing Mr. Bush’s chest pain?
.
Movie Project Presentation Movie TroyInclude Architecture i.docxaudeleypearl
Movie Project Presentation: Movie: Troy
Include: Architecture in the movie. Historical research to figure out if the movie did a good job of representing the art historical past of not. Anything in the movie that are related to art or art history. And provide its outline and bibliography (any website source is acceptable as well)
.
More Related Content
Similar to Mr. Friend is acrime analystwith the SantaCruz, Califo.docx
This paper focuses on finding spatial and temporal criminal hotspots. It analyses two different real-world crimes datasets for Denver, CO and Los Angeles, CA and provides a comparison between the two datasets through a statistical analysis supported by several graphs. Then, it clarifies how we conducted Apriori algorithm to produce interesting frequent patterns for criminal hotspots. In addition, the paper shows how we used Decision Tree classifier and Naïve Bayesian classifier in order to predict potential crime types. To further analyse crimes’ datasets, the paper introduces an analysis study by combining our findings of Denver crimes’ dataset with its demographics information in order to capture the factors that might affect the safety of neighborhoods. The results of this solution could be used to raise people’s awareness regarding the dangerous locations and to help agencies to predict future crimes in a specific location within
a particular time.
An unsupervised learning
k-means clustering technique is used to identify and focus
on a set of crimes (prostitution, narcotics, burglary, battery
and interference with a public officer) recorded in the city
of Chicago. The crime data is supplemented with orthogonal
temperature and unemployment data. ANOVA and Kruskal-
Wallis statistical tests assess the temporal significance in
crimes clusters. The findings indicate various crime hot spots
which are temporal and location specific, and therefore may
act as input to the scheduling and allocation of policing resources.
Advanced Search February 2015Back to Archives B.docxdaniahendric
Advanced Search
February 2015
Back to Archives | Back to September 2010 Contents
Proactive Patrolling through the Use of Patrol Scripts
By David A. Rivero, Chief of Police, University of Miami Police Department, Coral Gables, Florida; and John P.
Pepper, Crime Prevention and Emergency Management Coordinator, University of Miami Police Department,
Coral Gables, Florida
Click to view the digital edition.
atrol has been, is, and will continue to be the backbone of college and local policing. Response to
emergency and nonemergency calls to patrol officers for service is a primary component of policing or,
more specifically, reactive policing. Most law enforcement commanders would say they try to eliminate the need
for their patrol officers to be reactive through the institution of various proactive patrol initiatives. It’s a valid
concept in theory and in proven practice: prevent the crimes before they happen so reactive, after-the-fact
response becomes unnecessary. The result is fewer persons victimized, less financial and personal loss, less
overall crime, and more police recognition and appreciation. Everyone wins.
Though many college and local law enforcement agencies are often busy with reactive call response, most
agencies would cite that, at any given time, there is at least one officer available and not assigned to any call.
The question then becomes how to best utilize these limited available patrol resources to proactively prevent
future reactive responses.
Random patrol has long been an accepted allocation of these available patrol resources. The University of
Miami in Coral Gables, Florida, sought a better and more effective methodology for preventing crime that is
focused and targeted at the times and locations where crimes are likely to occur.
Crime is often cited as unpredictable. To some extent, it is, but to some extent, it is not. It is basically impossible
to know exactly when and where a specific crime is going to occur without good intelligence. It is, however,
possible to identify general locations and corresponding times when crimes may be more likely to occur. Some
law enforcement agencies have recognized this through crime analysis and crime mapping techniques. At
certain times, in certain areas, and under certain conditions, crime will occur at an above-average rate; often,
such situational convergences are referred to as “hot spots.” Some agencies use this information to direct
available patrol resources to hot spots during the times of high crime incidence. Specific planned events also
recognized the need for additional attention from current patrolling officers, as more people means more
potential for crimes. Often, crime analysis data and event scheduling data lead to the issuance of general be-on-
the-lookout (BOLO) notices and watch orders for regular on-duty officers. These are effective guidance tools. At
the University of Miami, it was decided to institutionalize daily guidance to the officers thro ...
PredPol: How Predictive Policing WorksPredPol, Inc
PredPol’s cloud-based predictive policing software enables law enforcement agencies to better prevent crime in their communities by generating predictions on the places and times that future crimes are most likely to occur.
PredPol’s technology has been helping law enforcement agencies to dramatically reduce crime in jurisdictions of all types and sizes, across the U.S. and overseas. Over the past year, Atlanta and Los Angeles have reduced specific crimes in targeted areas at rates ranging from nearly 20% to over 40%. Smaller jurisdictions, such as Norcross, Georgia, have seen nearly a 30% reduction in burglaries and robberies; in Alhambra, California, car burglaries have dropped 20% since the software technology was deployed.
Using advanced mathematics and computer learning, PredPol’s algorithms predict many types of crime, including property crimes, drug incidents, gang activity, and gun violence as well as traffic accidents.
Only three pieces of data are used to make predictions – type of crime, place of crime, and time of crime. No personal data is utilized in making these predictions.
Crime analysts and command staff using PredPol are 100% more effective than they are with traditional hotspot mapping at predicting where and when crimes are likely to occur. That means police have twice as many opportunities to deter and reduce crime.
Biased-Based Policing Reports Are Failing
the Police and the Community
Why Agencies Need to Stop Using Census Data
Richard R. Johnson, Ph.D.
September, 2016
Recent public opinion surveys have revealed that the vast majority of Americans believe that use
of racial profiling by the police is widespread.1 This is deeply disturbing for two reasons. First, it
is disturbing because it undermines police legitimacy among the vast majority of our citize ns.
Second, it is disturbing because the vast majority of law enforcement officers I have known do not
engage in bias-based policing. While racial profiling likely occurs among a small number of
individual officers acting outside the bounds of their oath to uphold the Constitution, it is unlike ly
that racial profiling is systemic to law enforcement in the United States.
This begs the question, then, why do so many people perceive that racial profiling is widespread?
We could blame individual members of the news media that seek to raise their ratings by stoking
the flames of controversy, or certain protest organizations that seek to capitalize on distrust of the
police. To be sure, these sources have contributed to the problem. Another factor that has also
contributed to the problem, however, is the fundamentally flawed information that many
law enforcement agencies have given the public through their biased-based policing data that
was gathered and reported incorrectly.
Many law enforcement agencies gather data on the race and gender of the individuals their officers
stop, search, and arrest. They report these data to the public in a biased-based policing report.
Agencies produce these reports for a variety of reasons, such as statutory requirements, as part of
their compliance with CALEA Standard 1.2.9.d, or simply out of a sincere desire to embrace
transparency. While most law enforcement agencies, and individual officers, claim they do not
racially profile, the vast majority of these reports show members of minority groups, especially
African-American men, are disproportionately stopped, searched, and arrested. Why? One factor
at work is the use of incorrect research methodologies and measures that are biased (often
unintentionally) against officers from the start. One of the most damaging of these incorrect
methodologies is the use of U.S. Census data as a benchmark comparison.
http://dolanconsultinggroup.com/
http://dolanconsultinggroup.com/instructor/richard-r-johnson-phd/
http://dolanconsultinggroup.com/
Benchmarks
In order for any racial profiling data collection activity to be meaningful, the racial composition of
police stops, searches, and arrests need to be compared to something. A benchmark is generally
defined as a point of reference from which measurements may be made; something that serves as
a standard by which others may be measured or judged; or a standardized problem or test that
serves as a basis for evaluat ...
Running head: CRIME ANALYSIS 1
CRIME ANALYSIS TECHNOLOGY 2
Crime analysis is a function that usually involves the systemic analysis in identifying as well as analyzing the crime patterns and trends. Crime analysis is very important for law enforcement agencies as it helps law enforcers effectively deploy the available resources in a better and effective manner, which enables them to identify and apprehend suspects. Crime analysis is also very significant when it comes to arriving at solutions devised to come up with the right solution to solve the current crime problem and issues as well as coming up with the right prevention strategies. Since the year 2014, crime rates in the USA have increased steadily as per a study done by USAFacts, which is a non-partisan initiative (Osborne & Wernicke, 2013). With this increase in crime rates, which has majorly resulted in massive growth in technology, it is essential to come up with better means and ways of dealing with the increased crime rates. With the current advancement in technology, better law enforcement tools developed, which has enabled better crime deterrence in better and efficient ways. All this has been facilitated by the efforts of crime analysts who have come up with better tools and thus enabling the law enforcers to better deal with the crimes (Osborne & Wernicke, 2013). In this paper, I will consider the application of crime analysis technology and techniques in fighting crimes. Application of crime analysis technology and techniques used to make crime analysis more accurate and efficient.
Currently, the two technological tools that are used in predictive policing software have enabled security agencies to effectively use predictive policing ("Crime Analysis: Fighting Crime with Data," 2017). Application of this software has enabled better crime prevention as with data obtained in the previous crimes have been used to predict possible future severe crimes in a specific area.
Through the adoption and use of crime analysis, law enforcement agencies have been able to fight against crimes as when compared with the past effectively. The use of crime analysis comes at the right time, where there has been an increase in crime rates in the current digital error. In a survey done by Wynyard group in 2015, the study revealed that for every 10 law enforcement officials 9 of them believe that the use of current technology in crime analysis has had positive effects in helping the agencies in solving crimes as they can identify essential links and trends in crimes ("Crime Analysis: Fighting Crime with Data," 2017). In the same way, other sectors have benefited from data analysis with spreadsheets, databases, and mapping, law enforcers have been able to use data analysis to come up with a better decision. Crime analysis ha ...
Running head: CRIME ANALYSIS 1
CRIME ANALYSIS TECHNOLOGY 2
Crime analysis is a function that usually involves the systemic analysis in identifying as well as analyzing the crime patterns and trends. Crime analysis is very important for law enforcement agencies as it helps law enforcers effectively deploy the available resources in a better and effective manner, which enables them to identify and apprehend suspects. Crime analysis is also very significant when it comes to arriving at solutions devised to come up with the right solution to solve the current crime problem and issues as well as coming up with the right prevention strategies. Since the year 2014, crime rates in the USA have increased steadily as per a study done by USAFacts, which is a non-partisan initiative (Osborne & Wernicke, 2013). With this increase in crime rates, which has majorly resulted in massive growth in technology, it is essential to come up with better means and ways of dealing with the increased crime rates. With the current advancement in technology, better law enforcement tools developed, which has enabled better crime deterrence in better and efficient ways. All this has been facilitated by the efforts of crime analysts who have come up with better tools and thus enabling the law enforcers to better deal with the crimes (Osborne & Wernicke, 2013). In this paper, I will consider the application of crime analysis technology and techniques in fighting crimes. Application of crime analysis technology and techniques used to make crime analysis more accurate and efficient.
Currently, the two technological tools that are used in predictive policing software have enabled security agencies to effectively use predictive policing ("Crime Analysis: Fighting Crime with Data," 2017). Application of this software has enabled better crime prevention as with data obtained in the previous crimes have been used to predict possible future severe crimes in a specific area.
Through the adoption and use of crime analysis, law enforcement agencies have been able to fight against crimes as when compared with the past effectively. The use of crime analysis comes at the right time, where there has been an increase in crime rates in the current digital error. In a survey done by Wynyard group in 2015, the study revealed that for every 10 law enforcement officials 9 of them believe that the use of current technology in crime analysis has had positive effects in helping the agencies in solving crimes as they can identify essential links and trends in crimes ("Crime Analysis: Fighting Crime with Data," 2017). In the same way, other sectors have benefited from data analysis with spreadsheets, databases, and mapping, law enforcers have been able to use data analysis to come up with a better decision. Crime analysis ha.
Similar to Mr. Friend is acrime analystwith the SantaCruz, Califo.docx (20)
Mr. Bush, a 45-year-old middle school teacher arrives at the emergen.docxaudeleypearl
Mr. Bush, a 45-year-old middle school teacher arrives at the emergency department by EMS ground transport after he experienced severe mid-sternal chest pain at work. On arrival to the ED:
a. What priority interventions would you initiate?
b. What information would you require to definitively determine what was causing Mr. Bush’s chest pain?
.
Movie Project Presentation Movie TroyInclude Architecture i.docxaudeleypearl
Movie Project Presentation: Movie: Troy
Include: Architecture in the movie. Historical research to figure out if the movie did a good job of representing the art historical past of not. Anything in the movie that are related to art or art history. And provide its outline and bibliography (any website source is acceptable as well)
.
Motivation and Retention Discuss the specific strategies you pl.docxaudeleypearl
Motivation and Retention
Discuss the specific strategies you plan to use to motivate individuals from your priority
population to participate in your program and continue working on their behavior change.
You can refer to information you obtained from the Potential Participant Interviews. You
also can search the literature for strategies that have been successfully used in similar
situations; be sure to cite references in APA format.
.
Mother of the Year In recognition of superlative paren.docxaudeleypearl
Mother of the Year
In recognition of superlative parenting
Elizabeth Nino
is awarded
2012 Mother of the Year
May 9, 2012
MOM
Smash That Like Button: Facebook’s Chris Cox Is Messing with One of the Most Valuable Features on the Internet
Inside Facebook’s Decision to Blow Up the Like Button
The most drastic change to Facebook in years was born a year ago during an off-site at the Four Seasons Silicon Valley, a 10-minute drive from headquarters. Chris Cox, the social network’s chief product officer, led the discussion, asking each of the six executives around the conference room to list the top three projects they were most eager to tackle in 2015. When it was Cox’s turn, he dropped a bomb: They needed to do something about the “like” button.
The like button is the engine of Facebook and its most recognized symbol. A giant version of it adorns the entrance to the company’s campus in Menlo Park, Calif. Facebook’s 1.6 billion users click on it more than 6 billion times a day—more frequently than people conduct searches on Google—which affects billions of advertising dollars each quarter. Brands, publishers, and individuals constantly, and strategically, share the things they think will get the most likes. It’s the driver of social activity. A married couple posts perfectly posed selfies, proving they’re in love; a news organization offers up what’s fun and entertaining, hoping the likes will spread its content. All those likes tell Facebook what’s popular and should be shown most often on the News Feed. But the button is also a blunt, clumsy tool. Someone announces her divorce on the site, and friends grit their teeth and “like” it. There’s a devastating earthquake in Nepal, and invariably a few overeager clickers give it the ol’ thumbs-up.
Changing the button is like Coca-Cola messing with its secret recipe. Cox had tried to battle the like button a few times before, but no idea was good enough to qualify for public testing. “This was a feature that was right in the heart of the way you use Facebook, so it needed to be executed really well in order to not detract and clutter up the experience,” he says. “All of the other attempts had failed.” The obvious alternative, a “dislike” button, had been rejected on the grounds that it would sow too much negativity.
Cox told the Four Seasons gathering that the time was finally right for a change, now that Facebook had successfully transitioned a majority of its business to smartphones. His top deputy, Adam Mosseri, took a deep breath. “Yes, I’m with you,” he said solemnly.
Later that week, Cox brought up the project with his boss and longtime friend. Mark Zuckerberg’s response showed just how much leeway Cox has to take risks with Facebook’s most important service. “He said something like, ‘Yes, do it.’ He was fully supportive,” Cox says. “Good luck,” he remembers Zuckerberg telling him. “That’s a hard one.”
The solution would eventually be named Reactions. It will arrive .
Mrs. G, a 55 year old Hispanic female, presents to the office for he.docxaudeleypearl
Mrs. G, a 55 year old Hispanic female, presents to the office for her annual exam. She reports that lately she has been very fatigued and just does not seem to have any energy. This has been occurring for 3 months. She is also gaining weight since menopause last year. She joined a gym and forces herself to go twice a week, where she walks on the treadmill at least 30 minutes but she has not lost any weight, in fact she has gained 3 pounds. She doesn’t understand what she is doing wrong. She states that exercise seems to make her even more hungry and thirsty, which is not helping her weight loss. She wants get a complete physical and to discuss why she is so tired and get some weight loss advice. She also states she thinks her bladder has fallen because she has to go to the bathroom more often, recently she is waking up twice a night to urinate and seems to be urinating more frequently during the day. This has been occurring for about 3 months too. This is irritating to her, but she is able to fall immediately back to sleep.
Current medications:
Tylenol 500 mg 2 tabs daily for knee pain. Daily multivitamin
PMH:
Has left knee arthritis. Had chick pox and mumps as a child. Vaccinations up to
date.
GYN hx:
G2 P1. 1 SAB, 1 living child, full term, wt 9lbs 2 oz. LMP 15months ago. No history of abnormal Pap smear.
FH:
parents alive, well, child alive, well. No siblings. Mother has HTN and father has high cholesterol.
SH:
works from home part time as a planning coordinator. Married. No tobacco history, 1-2 glasses wine on weekends. No illicit drug use
Allergies
: NKDA, allergic to cats and pollen. No latex allergy
Vital signs
: BP 129/80; pulse 76, regular; respiration 16, regular
Height 5’2.5”, weight 185 pounds
General:
obese female in no acute distress. Alert, oriented and cooperative.
Skin
: warm dry and intact. No lesions noted
HEENT:
head normocephalic. Hair thick and distribution throughout scalp. Eyes without exudate, sclera white. Wears contacts. Tympanic membranes gray and intact with light reflex noted. Pinna and tragus nontender. Nares patent without exudate. Oropharynx moist without erythema. Teeth in good repair, no cavities noted. Neck supple. Anterior cervical lymph nontender to palpation. No lymphadenopathy. Thyroid midline, small and firm without palpable masses.
CV
: S1 and S2 RRR without murmurs or rubs
Lungs
: Clear to auscultation bilaterally, respirations unlabored.
Abdomen
- soft, round, nontender with positive bowel sounds present; no organomegaly; no abdominal bruits. No CVAT.
Labwork:
CBC
:
WBC 6,000/mm3 Hgb 12.5 gm/dl Hct 41% RBC 4.6 million MCV 88 fl MCHC
34 g/dl RDW 13.8%
UA:
pH 5, SpGr 1.013, Leukocyte esterase negative, nitrites negative, 1+ glucose; small protein; negative for ketones
CMP:
Sodium 139
Potassium 4.3
Chloride 100
CO2 29
Glucose 95
BUN 12
Creatinine 0.7
GFR est non-AA 92 mL/min/1.73 GFR est AA 101 mL/min/1.73 Calcium 9.5
Total protein 7.6 Bilirubin, total 0.6 Alkaline.
Mr. Rivera is a 72-year-old patient with end stage COPD who is in th.docxaudeleypearl
Mr. Rivera is a 72-year-old patient with end stage COPD who is in the care of Hospice. He has a history of smoking, hypertension, obesity, and type 2 Diabetes. He is on Oxygen 2L per nasal cannula around the clock. His wife and 2 adult children help with his care. Develop a concept map for Mr. Rivera. Consider the patients Ethnic background (he and his family are from Mexico) and family dynamics. Please use the
concept map
form provided.
.
Mr. B, a 40-year-old avid long-distance runner previously in goo.docxaudeleypearl
Mr. B, a 40-year-old avid long-distance runner previously in good health, presented to his primary provider for a yearly physical examination, during which a suspicious-looking mole was noticed on the back of his left arm, just proximal to the elbow. He reported that he has had that mole for several years, but thinks that it may have gotten larger over the past two years. Mr. B reported that he has noticed itchiness in the area of this mole over the past few weeks. He had multiple other moles on his back, arms, and legs, none of which looked suspicious. Upon further questioning, Mr. B reported that his aunt died in her late forties of skin cancer, but he knew no other details about her illness. The patient is a computer programmer who spends most of the work week indoors. On weekends, however, he typically goes for a 5-mile run and spends much of his afternoons gardening. He has a light complexion, blonde hair, and reports that he sunburns easily but uses protective sunscreen only sporadically.
Physical exam revealed: Head, neck, thorax, and abdominal exams were normal, with the exception of a hard, enlarged, non-tender mass felt in the left axillary region. In addition, a 1.6 x 2.8 cm mole was noted on the dorsal upper left arm. The lesion had an appearance suggestive of a melanoma. It was surgically excised with 3 mm margins using a local anesthetic and sent to the pathology laboratory for histologic analysis. The biopsy came back Stage II melanoma.
1. How is Stage II melanoma treated and according to the research how effective is this treatment?
250 words.
.
Moving members of the organization through the change process ca.docxaudeleypearl
Moving members of the organization through the change process can be quite difficult. As leaders take on this challenge of shifting practice from the current state to the future, they face the obstacles of confidence and competence experienced by staff. Change leaders understand the importance of recognizing their moral purpose and helping others to do the same. Effective leaders foster moral purpose by building relationships, considering other’s perspectives, demonstrating respect, connecting others, and examining progress (Fullan & Quinn, 2016). For this Discussion, you will clarify your own moral perspective and how it will impact the elements of focusing direction.
To prepare:
· Review the Adams and Miskell article. Reflect on the measures taken in building capacity throughout the organization.
· Review Fullan and Quinn’s elements of Focusing Direction in Chapter 2. Reflect on aspects needed to build capacity as a leader.
· Analyze the two case examples used to illustrate focused direction in Chapter 2.
· Clarify your own moral purpose, combining your personal values, persistence, emotional intelligence, and resilience.
A brief summary clarifying your own moral imperative.
· Using the guiding questions in Chapter 2 on page 19, explain your moral imperative and how you can use your strengths to foster moral imperative in others.
· Based on Fullan’s information on change leadership, in which areas do you feel you have strong leadership skills? Which areas do you feel you need to continue to develop?
Learning Resources
Required Readings
Fullan, M., & Quinn, J. (2016).
Coherence: The right drivers in action for schools, districts, and systems
. Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin.
Chapter 2, “Focusing Direction” (pp. 17–46)
Florian, L. (Ed.). (2014).
The SAGE handbook of special education
(2nd ed.). London, England: Sage Publications Ltd.
Chapter 23, “Researching Inclusive Classroom Practices: The Framework for Participation” (389–404)
Chapter 31, “Assessment for Learning and the Journey Towards Inclusion” (pp. 523–536)
Adams, C.M., & Miskell, R.C. (2016). Teacher trust in district administration: A promising line of inquiry. Journal of Leadership for Effective and Equitable Organizations, 1-32. DOI: 10.1177/0013161X1665220
Choi, J. H., Meisenheimer, J. M., McCart, A. B., & Sailor, W. (2016). Improving learning for all students through equity-based inclusive reform practices effectiveness of a fully integrated school-wide model on student reading and math achievement. Remedial and Special Education, doi:10.1177/0741932516644054
Sailor, W. S., & McCart, A. B. (2014). Stars in alignment. Research and Practice for Persons with Severe Disabilities, 39(1), 55-64. doi: 10.1177/1540796914534622
Required Media
Grand City Community
Laureate Education (Producer) (2016c).
Tracking data
[Video file]. Baltimore, MD: Author.
Go to the Grand City Community and click into
Grand City School District Administration Offices
. Revie.
Mr. E is a pleasant, 70-year-old, black, maleSource Self, rel.docxaudeleypearl
Mr. E is a pleasant, 70-year-old, black, male
Source: Self, reliable source
Subjective:
Chief complaint:
“I urinate frequently.”
HPI:
Patient states that he has had an increase in urination for the past several years, which seems to be worsening over the past year. He estimates that he urinates clear/light yellow urine approximately every 1.5-2 hours while awake and is up 2-4 times at night to urinate. He states some urgency and hesitancy with urination and feeling of incomplete voiding. He denies any pain or blood. Denies any head trauma. Denies any increase in thirst or hunger. He denies any unintentional weight loss.
Allergies
: NKA
Current Mediations
:
Multivitamin, daily
Aspirin, 81 mg, daily
Olmesartan, 20 mg daily
Atorvastatin, 10 mg daily
Diphenhydramine, 50 mg, at night
Pertinent History:
Hypertension, hyperlipidemia, insomnia
Health Maintenance. Immunizations:
Immunizations up to date
Family History:
No cancer, cardiac, pulmonary or autoimmune disease in immediate family members
Social History:
Patient lives alone. He drinks one cup of caffeinated coffee each morning at the local diner. He denies any nicotine, alcohol or drug use.
ROS:
Incorporated into HPI
Objective:
VS
– BP: 118/68, HR: 86, RR: 16, Temp 97.6, oxygenation 100%, weight: 195 lbs, height: 70 inches.
Mr. E is alert, awake, oriented x 3. Patient is clean and dressed appropriate for age.
Cardiac: No cardiomegaly or thrills; regular rate and rhythm, no murmur or gallop
Respiratory: Clear to auscultation
Abdomen: Bowel sounds positive. Soft, nontender, nondistended, no hepatomegaly
Neuro: CN 2-12 intact
Renal/prostate: Prostate enlarged, non-tender. No asymmetry or nodules palpated
Labs:
Test Name
Result
Units
Reference Range
Color
Yellow
Yellow
Clarity
Clear
Clear
Bilirubin
Negative
Negative
Specific Gravity
1.011
1.003-1.030
Blood
Negative
Negative
pH
7.5
4.5-8.0
Nitrite
Negative
Negative
Leukocyte esterase
Negative
Negative
Glucose
Negative
mg/dL
Negative
Ketones
Negative
mg/dL
Negative
Protein
Negative
mg/dL
Negative
WBC
Negative
/hpf
Negative
RBC
Negative
/hpf
Negative
Lab
Pt’s Result
Range
Units
Sodium
137
136-145
mmol/L
Potassium
4.7
3.5-5.1
mmol/L
Chloride
102
98-107
mmol/L
CO2
30
21-32
mmol/L
Glucose
92
70-99
mg/dL
BUN
7
6-25
mg/dL
Creat
1.6
.8-1.3
mg/dL
GFR
50
>60
Calcium
9.6
8.2-10.2
mg/dL
Total Protein
8.0
6.4-8.2
g/dL
Albumin
4.5
3.2-4.7
g/dL
Bilirubin
1.1
<1.1
mg/dL
Alkaline Phosphatase
94
26-137
U/L
AST
25
0-37
U/L
ALT
55
15-65
U/L
Pt’s results
Normal Range
Units
WBC
9.9
3.4 - 10.8
x10E3/uL
RBC
4.0
3.77 - 5.28
x10E6/uL
Hemoglobin
11.5
11.1 - 15.9
g/dL
H.
Motor Milestones occur in a predictable developmental progression in.docxaudeleypearl
Motor Milestones occur in a predictable developmental progression in young children. They begin with reflexive movements that develop into voluntary movement patterns. For the motor milestone of independent walking, there are many precursor reflexes that must first integrate and beginning movement patterns that must be learned. Explain the motor progression of walking in a child, starting with the integration of primitive reflexes to the basic motor skills needed for a child to walk independently. Discuss at which time frame each milestone occurs from birth to walking (12-18 months of age). What are some reasons why a child could be delayed in walking? At what age is a child considered delayed in walking and in need of intervention? What interventions are available to children who are having difficulty walking? Please be sure to use APA citations for all sources used to formulate your answers.
.
Most women experience their closest friendships with those of th.docxaudeleypearl
Most women experience their closest friendships with those of the same sex. Men have suffered more of a stigma in terms of sharing deep bonds with other men. Open affection and connection is not actively encouraged among men. Recent changes in society might impact this, especially with the advent of the meterosexual male. “The meterosexual male is less interested in blood lines, traditions, family, class, gender, than in choosing who they want to be and who they want to be with” (Vernon, 2010, p. 204).
In this week’s reading material, the following philosophers discuss their views on this topic: Simone de Beauvoir, Thomas Aquinas, MacIntyre, Friedman, Hunt, and Foucault. Make sure to incorporate their views as you answer each discussion question. Think about how their views may be similar or different from your own. In at least 250 words total, please answer each of the following, drawing upon your reading materials and your personal insight:
To what extent do you think women still have a better opportunity to forge deeper friendships than men? What needs to change to level the friendship playing field for men, if anything?
How is the role of the meterosexual man helping to forge a new pathway for male friendships?
.
Most patients with mental health disorders are not aggressive. Howev.docxaudeleypearl
Most patients with mental health disorders are not aggressive. However, it is important for nurses to be able to know the signs and symptoms associated with the five phases of aggression, and to appropriately apply nursing interventions to assist in treating aggressive patients. Please read the case study below and answer the four questions related to it.
Aggression Case Study
Christopher, who is 14 years of age, was recently admitted to the hospital for schizophrenia. He has a history of aggressive behavior and states that the devil is telling him to kill all adults because they want to hurt him. Christopher has a history of recidivism and noncompliance with his medications. One day on the unit, the nurse observes Christopher displaying hypervigilant behaviors, pacing back and forth down the hallway, and speaking to himself under his breath. As the nurse runs over to Christopher to talk, he sees that his bedroom door is open and runs into his room and shuts the door. The nurse responds by attempting to open the door, but Christopher keeps pulling the door shut and tells the nurse that if the nurse comes in the room he will choke the nurse. The nurse responds by calling other staff to assist with the situation.
1. What phase of the aggression cycle is Christopher in at the beginning of this scenario? What phase is he in at the end the scenario? (State the evidence that supports your answers).
2. What interventions could have been implemented to prevent Christopher from escalating at the beginning of the scenario?
3. What interventions should the nurse take to deescalate the situation when Christopher is refusing to open his door?
4. If a restrictive intervention (restraint/seclusion) is used, what are some important steps for the nurse to remember?
SCHOLAR NURSING ARTICLE>>>APA FORMAT>>>
.
Most of our class readings and discussions to date have dealt wi.docxaudeleypearl
Most of our class readings and discussions to date have dealt with the issue of ethics and ethical behavior. Various philosophers have made contributions to jurisprudence including how to apply ethical principles (codes of conduct?) to ethical dilemma.
Your task is to watch the Netflix documentary ‘The Social Dilemma.’ If you cannot currently access Netflix it offers a free trial opportunity, which you can cancel after viewing the documentary. Should this not be an option for whatever reason, then please email me and we will create an alternative ethics question.
DUE DATE: Tuesday, Sept. 29, 2020 by noon
SEND YOUR NO MORE THAN 5 PAGE DOUBLE SPACED RESPONSE TO MY EMAIL ADDRESS. LATE PAPERS SUBJECT TO DOWNGRADING
As critics have written, the documentary showcases ways our minds are twisted and twirled by social media companies like Facebook, Twitter, and Google through their platforms and search engines, and the why of what they are doing, and what must be done to stop it.
After watching the movie, respond to the following questions in the order given. Use full sentences and paragraphs, and start off each section by stating the question you are answering. Be succinct.
What are the critical ethical issues identified?
What concerns are raised over the polarization of society and promulgation of fake news?
What is the “attention-extraction model” of software design and why worry?
What is “surveillance capitalism?”
Do you agree that social media warps your perceptions of reality?
Who has the power and control over these social media platforms – software designers, artificial intelligence (Ai), CEOs of media platforms, users, government?
Are social media platforms capable of self-regulation to address the political and ethical issues raised or not? If not, then should government regulate?
What other actions can be taken to address the basic concern of living in a world “…where no one believes what’s true.”
.
Most people agree we live in stressful times. Does stress and re.docxaudeleypearl
Most people agree we live in stressful times. Does stress and reactions to stress contribute to illness? Explain why or why not. Support your opinions with information from the text.
Make sure to reference and cite your textbook as well as any other source you may use to support your answers to the question. Your initial post must include appropriate APA references at the end.
.
Most of the ethical prescriptions of normative moral philosophy .docxaudeleypearl
Most of the ethical prescriptions of normative moral philosophy tend to fall into one of the following three categories: deontology, consequentialism, and virtue ethics. These categories in turn put an emphasis on different normative standards for judging what constitutes right and wrong actions.
Moral psychologists and behavioral economists such as Jonathan Haidt and Dan Ariely take a different approach: focusing not on some normative ethical framework for moral judgment, but rather on the psychological foundations of moral intuition and on the limitations that our human frailty places on real-world honesty, decency, and ethical commitments.
In this context, write a short essay (minimum 400 words) on what you see as the most important differences between the traditional normative philosophical approaches and the more recent empirical approach of moral psychology when it comes to ethics. As part of your answer also make sure that you discuss the implications of these differences.
Deadline reminder:
this assignment is
due on June 14th
. Any assignments submitted after that date will lose 5 points (i.e., 20% of the maximum score of 25 points) for each day that they are submitted late. Accordingly, after June 14th, any submissions would be worth zero points and at that time the assignment inbox will close.
.
Most healthcare organizations in the country are implementing qualit.docxaudeleypearl
Most healthcare organizations in the country are implementing quality improvement programs to save lives, enhance customer satisfaction, and reduce the cost of healthcare services. Limited human and material resources often undermine such efforts. Zenith Hospital in a rural community has 200 beds. Postsurgical patients tend to contract infections at the surgical site, requiring extended hospitalization. Mr. Jones—75 years old—was admitted to Zenith Hospital for inguinal hernia repairs. He was also hypertensive, with a compromised immune system. Two days after surgery, he acquired an infection at the surgical site, with elevated temperature, and then he developed septicemia. His condition worsened, and he was moved to isolation in the intensive care unit (ICU). A day after transfer to the ICU, he went into ventricular arrhythmia and was placed on a respirator and cardiac monitoring machine. Intravenous fluids, antibiotics, and antipyretics could not bring the fever down, and blood analysis continued to deteriorate.
The hospital infection control unit got involved. The team confirmed that postsurgical infections were on the increase, but the hospital was unable to identify the sources of infection. The surgery unit and surgical team held meetings to understand possible sources of infection. The team leader had earlier reported to management that they needed to hire more surgical nurses, arguing that nurses in the unit were overworked, had to go on leave, and often worked long hours without break.
Mr. Jones’ family members were angry and wanted to know the source of his infection, why he was on the respirator in isolation, and why his temperature was not coming down. Unfortunately, his condition continued to deteriorate. His daughter invited the family’s legal representative to find out what was happening to her father and to commence legal proceedings.
Then, the healthcare manager received information that two other patients were showing signs of postsurgical infection. The healthcare manager and care providers acknowledged the serious quality issues at Zenith Hospital, particularly in the surgical unit. The healthcare manager wrote to the Chairman of the Hospital Board, seeking approval to implement a quality improvement program. The Board held an emergency meeting and approved the manager’s request. The healthcare manager has invited you to support the organization in this process.
Please address the following questions in your response:
What are successful approaches for gaining a shared understanding of the problem?
How can effective communication be implemented?
What is a qualitative approach that helps in identifying the quality problem?
What tools can provide insight into understanding the problem?
In quality improvement, what does appreciative inquiry help do?
What is a benefit of testing solutions before implementation?
What is a challenge that is inherent in the application of the plan, do, study, act (PDSA) method?
What .
More work is necessary on how to efficiently model uncertainty in ML.docxaudeleypearl
More work is necessary on how to efficiently model uncertainty in ML and NLP, as well as how to represent uncertainty resulting from big data analytics.
Pages - 4
Excluding the required cover page and reference page.
APA format 7 with an introduction, a body content, and a conclusion.
No Plagiarism
.
Mortgage-Backed Securities and the Financial CrisisKelly Finn.docxaudeleypearl
Mortgage-Backed Securities and the Financial Crisis
Kelly Finn
FNCE 4302
Mortgage-Backed Securities (MBS) are “pass-through” bundles of housing debt sold as investment vehicles
A mortgage-backed security, MBS, is a type of asset-backed security that pays investors regular payments, similar to a bond. It gets the title as a “pass-through” because the security involves several entities in the origination and securitization process (where the asset is identified, and where it is used as a base to create a new investment instrument people can profit off of).
Key Players involved in the MBS Process
[Mortgage] Lenders: banks who sell mortgages to GSE’s
GSE: Government Sponsored Entities created by the US Government to make owning property more accessible to Americans
1938: Fannie Mae (FNMA): Federal National Mortgage Assoc.
1970: Freddie Mac (FHLMC): Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corp.
Increase mortgage borrowing
Introduce competitor to Fannie Mae
1970: Ginnie Mae (GNMA): Government National Mortgage Assoc.
US Government: Treasury: implicit commitment of providing support in case of trouble
The several entities involved in the process make MBS a “pass-through”. Here we have 3 main entities that we’ll call “Key Players” for the purpose of this presentation which aims to provide you with a basic and simple explanation of MBS and their role in the financial crisis.
GSE’s created by the US Government in 1938
Part of FDR’s New Plan during Great Depression
Purpose: make owning property more accessible to more Americans
GSE (ex. Fannie Mae) buys mortgages (debt) from banks, & then pools mortgages into little bundles investors can buy (securitization)
Bank’s mortgage is exchanged with GSE’s cash
Created liquid secondary market for mortgages
Result:
1) Bank has more cash to lend out to people
2) Now all who want to a house (expensive) can get the money needed to buy one!
Where MBS came from & when
Yay for combatting homelessness and increasing quality of life for the common American!
Thanks Uncle Sam!
MBS have been around for a long time. Officially in the US, they have their origins in government. During the Great Depression in the 1930s, President Franklin Delano Roosevelt signed into creation Fannie Mae that was brought about to help ease American citizen’s difficulty in becoming homeowners. The sole purpose of a GSE thus was to not make profit, but to promote citizen welfare in regards to housing. Seeing that it was created by regulatory government powers, it earned the title of Government Sponsored Entity, which we will abbreviate as GSE. 2 other GSE’s in housing were created in later decades like Freddie Mae, to further stimulate the mortgage market alongside Fannie, and Ginnie which did a similar thing but only for certain groups of people (Veterans, etc) and to a much smaller scale.
How MBS works: Kelly is a homeowner looking to borrow a lot of money
*The Lender, who issued Kelly the mor.
Moral Development Lawrence Kohlberg developed six stages to mora.docxaudeleypearl
Moral Development:
Lawrence Kohlberg developed six stages to moral behavior in children and adults. Punishment and obedience orientation, interpersonal concordance, law and order orientation, social contract orientation, and universal ethics orientation. All or even just one of these stages will make a good topic for your research paper or you could just do the research paper on Kohlberg.
.
Module OverviewLiberal and Market Models of Higher Education .docxaudeleypearl
Module Overview:
Liberal and Market Models of Higher Education Policy
Module Five focuses on two states, California and Minnesota, as the complexities of higher education policy are examined and the variety of political, social, economic, and environmental factors contributing to the ways in which policies are developed are discussed. These policies, in turn, deeply impact the higher education systems within both states, with a particularly strong influence on funding models for colleges and universities.
Higher Education Policy in California
The California Master Plan for Higher Education guided the development of three campus systems in California: the University of California (UC), California State University (CSU), and California Community Colleges systems (St. John, Daun-Barnett, & Moronski-Chapman, 2013). Nearly four out of five college students in California attend one of the three public education systems and three out of every four bachelor degrees awarded annually are from either the UC or CSU systems (Johnson, 2014). Yet, the state is facing somewhat of an education crisis and Johnson projects a shortfall of one million college graduates by 2025.
In recent years, the historic California model has broken down as the systems have been negatively impacted by the state’s fiscal woes. While colleges and universities have responded to funding cuts by reducing expenses, including cutting administrative costs and hiring more non-tenure track faculty, declines in state support have forced the UC system to increase tuition fees by 50% in three years while CSU fees have increase by 47% in the same period (Johnson, Cook, Murphy, and Weston, 2014). Students are increasingly becoming indebted in order to accomplish their educational goals in California; the average loan amounts among students have risen 36% between 2005 and 2010 (a figure adjusted for inflation) (Johnson, 2014). Hoping to save expenses, many students begin their college educations at California community colleges, which have become so overcrowded that in 2012, 137,000 students could not enroll into at least one class that they needed and community colleges resorted to “rationing” courses (Dellner, 2012). This evidence suggests new changes are needed in the California state system to support students at all levels of enrollment.
In part, California’s steady decreases in higher education funding are a consequence of a need to fund other state services; for example, Johnson (2012) notes that from 2002 to 2012, state expenditures for higher education fell by close to 10% whereas expenditures for corrections and rehabilitation increased by 26%. Historical trends suggest that the state’s priorities began shifting from higher education toward corrections since the 1970s, even though the majority of Californians (68%) opposed spending cuts in higher education to reduce state budget deficits and 62% supported spending cuts in corrections to balance state budgets (Baldassare, Bonner, Pet.
We all have good and bad thoughts from time to time and situation to situation. We are bombarded daily with spiraling thoughts(both negative and positive) creating all-consuming feel , making us difficult to manage with associated suffering. Good thoughts are like our Mob Signal (Positive thought) amidst noise(negative thought) in the atmosphere. Negative thoughts like noise outweigh positive thoughts. These thoughts often create unwanted confusion, trouble, stress and frustration in our mind as well as chaos in our physical world. Negative thoughts are also known as “distorted thinking”.
Ethnobotany and Ethnopharmacology:
Ethnobotany in herbal drug evaluation,
Impact of Ethnobotany in traditional medicine,
New development in herbals,
Bio-prospecting tools for drug discovery,
Role of Ethnopharmacology in drug evaluation,
Reverse Pharmacology.
Palestine last event orientationfvgnh .pptxRaedMohamed3
An EFL lesson about the current events in Palestine. It is intended to be for intermediate students who wish to increase their listening skills through a short lesson in power point.
Students, digital devices and success - Andreas Schleicher - 27 May 2024..pptxEduSkills OECD
Andreas Schleicher presents at the OECD webinar ‘Digital devices in schools: detrimental distraction or secret to success?’ on 27 May 2024. The presentation was based on findings from PISA 2022 results and the webinar helped launch the PISA in Focus ‘Managing screen time: How to protect and equip students against distraction’ https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/education/managing-screen-time_7c225af4-en and the OECD Education Policy Perspective ‘Students, digital devices and success’ can be found here - https://oe.cd/il/5yV
Instructions for Submissions thorugh G- Classroom.pptxJheel Barad
This presentation provides a briefing on how to upload submissions and documents in Google Classroom. It was prepared as part of an orientation for new Sainik School in-service teacher trainees. As a training officer, my goal is to ensure that you are comfortable and proficient with this essential tool for managing assignments and fostering student engagement.
The Art Pastor's Guide to Sabbath | Steve ThomasonSteve Thomason
What is the purpose of the Sabbath Law in the Torah. It is interesting to compare how the context of the law shifts from Exodus to Deuteronomy. Who gets to rest, and why?
Unit 8 - Information and Communication Technology (Paper I).pdfThiyagu K
This slides describes the basic concepts of ICT, basics of Email, Emerging Technology and Digital Initiatives in Education. This presentations aligns with the UGC Paper I syllabus.
Read| The latest issue of The Challenger is here! We are thrilled to announce that our school paper has qualified for the NATIONAL SCHOOLS PRESS CONFERENCE (NSPC) 2024. Thank you for your unwavering support and trust. Dive into the stories that made us stand out!
Model Attribute Check Company Auto PropertyCeline George
In Odoo, the multi-company feature allows you to manage multiple companies within a single Odoo database instance. Each company can have its own configurations while still sharing common resources such as products, customers, and suppliers.
Synthetic Fiber Construction in lab .pptxPavel ( NSTU)
Synthetic fiber production is a fascinating and complex field that blends chemistry, engineering, and environmental science. By understanding these aspects, students can gain a comprehensive view of synthetic fiber production, its impact on society and the environment, and the potential for future innovations. Synthetic fibers play a crucial role in modern society, impacting various aspects of daily life, industry, and the environment. ynthetic fibers are integral to modern life, offering a range of benefits from cost-effectiveness and versatility to innovative applications and performance characteristics. While they pose environmental challenges, ongoing research and development aim to create more sustainable and eco-friendly alternatives. Understanding the importance of synthetic fibers helps in appreciating their role in the economy, industry, and daily life, while also emphasizing the need for sustainable practices and innovation.
Chapter 3 - Islamic Banking Products and Services.pptx
Mr. Friend is acrime analystwith the SantaCruz, Califo.docx
1. Mr. Friend is a
crime analyst
with the Santa
Cruz, California,
Police
Department.
Predictive Policing: Using Technology to Reduce Crime
By Zach Friend, M.P.P.
4/9/2013
Nationwide law enforcement agencies face the problem
of doing more with less. Departments slash budgets
and implement furloughs, while management struggles
to meet the public safety needs of the community. The
Santa Cruz, California, Police Department handles the
same issues with increasing property crimes and
service calls and diminishing staff. Unable to hire more
officers, the department searched for a nontraditional
solution.
In late 2010 researchers published a paper that the
department believed might hold the answer. They
proposed that it was possible to predict certain crimes,
much like scientists forecast earthquake aftershocks.
An “aftercrime” often follows an initial crime. The time and
location of previous criminal activity helps to
determine future offenses. These researchers developed an
2. algorithm (mathematical procedure) that
calculates future crime locations.1
Equalizing Resources
The Santa Cruz Police Department has 94 sworn officers and
serves a population of 60,000. A
university, amusement park, and beach push the seasonal
population to 150,000. Department personnel
contacted a Santa Clara University professor to apply the
algorithm, hoping that leveraging technology
would improve their efforts. The police chief indicated that the
department could not hire more officers.
He felt that the program could allocate dwindling resources
more efficiently.
Santa Cruz police envisioned deploying officers by shift to the
most targeted locations in the city. The
predictive policing model helped to alert officers to targeted
locations in real time, a significant
improvement over traditional tactics.
Making it Work
The algorithm is a culmination of anthropological and
criminological behavior research. It uses complex
mathematics to estimate crime and predict future hot spots.
Researchers based these studies on
In Depth
Featured Articles
- IAFIS Identifies Suspect from 1978 Murder Case
3. - Predictive Policing: Using Technology to Reduce
Crime
- Legal Digest Part 1 - Part 2
Search Warrant Execution: When Does Detention Rise to
Custody?
- Perspective
Public Safety Consolidation: Does it Make Sense?
- Leadership Spotlight
Leadership Lessons from Home
Archive
- Web and Print
Departments
- Bulletin Notes - Bulletin Honors
- ViCAP Alerts - Unusual Weapons
- Bulletin Reports
Topics in the News
See previous LEB content on:
- Hostage Situations - Crisis Management
4. - School Violence - Psychopathy
About LEB
- History - Author Guidelines (pdf)
- Editorial Staff - Editorial Release Form (pdf)
Patch Call
Known locally as the
“Gateway to the Summit,”
which references the city’s
proximity to the Bechtel Family
National Scout Reserve. More
The patch of the Miamisburg,
Ohio, Police Department
prominently displays the city
seal surrounded by an outline
of the state. More
LEB Updates
Subscribe to receive monthly updates listing articles featured on
this website. Details
Home • Stats & Services • Reports and Publications • LEB •
2013 • April • Predictive Policing: Using Technology to Reduce
Crime
FBI — Predictive Policing: Using Technology to Reduce Crime
http://www.fbi.gov/stats-services/publications/law-enforcement-
bulletin/...
1 of 4 6/3/2013 3:38 PM
5. information that officers inherently know. For example, when
people are victims, the chance that they or
their neighbors will be victimized again increases. Offenders
criminalize familiar areas. There are
detectable patterns associated with the times and locations of
their crimes.
Using an earthquake aftershock algorithm, the system employs
verified crime data to predict future
offenses in 500-square-foot locations. The program uses
historical information combined with current
data to determine patterns. The system needs between 1,200 and
2,000 data points, including
burglaries, batteries, assaults, or other crimes, for the most
accuracy. Santa Cruz, averaging between
400 and 600 burglaries per year, used 5 years of data.
Throughout the experiment the Santa Cruz Police Department
focused on burglaries— vehicular,
residential, and commercial—and motor vehicle thefts.2 The
system works on gang violence, batteries,
aggravated assaults, drug crimes, and bike thefts. It functions
on all property crimes and violent crimes
that have enough data points and are not crimes of passion, such
as domestic violence. Homicides
generally do not provide enough data points to produce accurate
predictions.
Using the Data
To add an extra layer of security, employees transfer the data on
designated crime types from the
6. records management system (RMS) to the secure Web-based
system. The algorithm requires the date,
time, type, and location of a crime. This is public data, which
adds another level of security in case
someone intercepts the information. No one submits, collects, or
uses personal data. The system
processes the information through the algorithm and combines it
with historical crime data to make
predictions.
Staff members log in, just like they do on an e-mail account,
and the system generates hot spot maps.
For Santa Cruz police, there are 15 hot spot maps per shift.
Distributed through roll calls, these maps
indicate 500-square-foot locations. Officers pass through these
areas when they are not obligated to
address other calls. No one dispatches or requires them to patrol
the sites; they do it as part of their
routine extra checks. Some agencies using the program
designate predictive policing units to run patrols,
while others use unmarked cars to traverse hotspots.
The Santa Cruz Police Department decided not to mandate the
patrols. Personnel thought it would
eliminate the feeling of an administrative directive and
empower officers to be as proactive as their call
levels allowed. When police enter and clear the hot spot
locations, they notify dispatch with a designated
clearing code. This enables dispatch personnel to collect data on
the frequency of the officers’ presence
in the hot spots.
FBI — Predictive Policing: Using Technology to Reduce Crime
http://www.fbi.gov/stats-services/publications/law-enforcement-
bulletin/...
7. 2 of 4 6/3/2013 3:38 PM
Evaluating the Process
During the first 6 months of the program, the department made
over 2 dozen arrests within the hot spot
locations. However, the true measure of the program’s success
is not apprehensions, but the reduction
of crime. Santa Cruz police officers indicated an initial 11
percent reduction in burglaries and a 4 percent
decrease in motor vehicle thefts. As time progresses, the
reductions increase. Over a 6-month period,
burglaries declined 19 percent.
The system requires 6 months of data to assess whether the
method actually is reducing the crime rate.
Because the Santa Cruz police did not introduce any additional
variables—no additional officers were
hired, shift lengths continued, patrol structure remained the
same—the department attributed the crime
reduction to the model.
The Los Angeles Police Department (LAPD) tested the method
under a controlled experiment. The
project scientifically proved the model’s effectiveness. The city
has a larger population and more
complex patrol needs than Santa Cruz. Researchers established
the experiment in the Foothill Division
with a population of 300,000 people. They compared the
predictive policing system with LAPD’s best
practices.
Similar to the Santa Cruz test, the department distributed maps
8. to officers at the beginning of roll call. On
some days analysts produced the maps using traditional LAPD
hot spot methods. On other days, they
used the algorithm. No one told the officers where the maps
came from. Graphically they looked the
same.
The algorithm provided twice the accuracy that LAPD’s current
practices produced. While property crime
was up .4 percent throughout Los Angeles, Foothill’s declined
by 12 percent. Foothill benefitted from the
largest crime reduction of any division during the experiment.
People found it hard to understand that an algorithm performed
similar to a crime analyst. Eventually,
even the most skeptical individuals realized that the method
worked. The LAPD expanded the program
to other divisions serving a total population of over 1.5 million
people. Each one that implemented the
predictive policing software achieved crime reduction. The
department recognized that the predictive
policing system is a large improvement over previously used
approaches. When looking at a map from 1
week, the assumption is that the next week will be the same.
The computer eliminates the bias that
people have.
Gaining Support
As with any new program, questions and concerns arise. People
resist change. The Santa Cruz Police
Department worked with officers to develop maps and solicit
feedback before implementation of the
program. The department emphasized that the program does not
replace officer intuition but
9. supplements it.
The Santa Cruz Police Department found that veteran officers
usually identify 8 or 9 of the 15 hot spot
locations. Newer officers discover 1 or 2 of the areas. This
validates skilled police officers’ intuition,
provides additional targeted locations, and imparts tactical
information for new officers. The maps
reinforce existing knowledge and inform about targeting
locations. They standardize information across
shifts and experience levels.
The algorithm combines historic and daily crime information,
produces real-time predictions of areas to
patrol, and normalizes information among shifts. It eliminates
the concern about adequate information
sharing. Officers obtaining the daily hot spot maps receive any
information they missed due to vacation,
illness, or regular days off.
The program shares information graphically. It does not replace
the value of senior officers teaching
younger ones or the need for roll calls to discuss crime trends.
It cannot replace police officers’
knowledge and skills and does not remove the officer from the
equation. It puts law enforcement in the
right time and place to prevent crime.
Conclusion
FBI — Predictive Policing: Using Technology to Reduce Crime
http://www.fbi.gov/stats-services/publications/law-enforcement-
bulletin/...
3 of 4 6/3/2013 3:38 PM
10. Accessibility | eRulemaking | Freedom of Information Act |
Legal Notices | Legal Policies and Disclaimers | Links | Privacy
Policy | USA.gov | White House
FBI.gov is an official site of the U.S. government, U.S.
Department of Justice
Close
Additional departments in the states of California, Washington,
South Carolina, Arizona, Tennessee, and
Illinois have implemented the program. In November 2011 Time
Magazine named predictive policing one
of 50 best inventions for 2011.3 The Santa Cruz police chief
acknowledged the recognition, but said the
accolades are less important than the crime reduction.
According to the chief, “Innovation is the key to
modern policing, and we’re proud to be leveraging technology
in a way that keeps our community
safer.”4
Endnotes
1 Dr. George Mohler, Santa Clara University, California, and
Dr. P. Jeffrey Brantingham, University of
California at Los Angeles, California, developed the algorithm
(mathematical model) for predictive
policing.
2 George Mohler, P. Jeffrey Brantingham, and Zach Friend
conducted the research in Santa Cruz,
California.
11. 3 Lev Grossman, Cleo Brock-Abraham, Nick Carbone, Eric
Dodds, Jeffrey Kluger, Alice Park, Nate
Rawlings, Claire Suddath, Feifei Sun, Mark Thompson, Bryan
Walsh, and Kayla Webley, “The 50 Best
Inventions of 2011,” Time Magazine, November 28, 2011.
www.time.com/time/magazine/article
/0,9171,2099708-13,00.html (accessed September 27, 2012).
4 Santa Cruz Police Chief Kevin Vogel.
FBI — Predictive Policing: Using Technology to Reduce Crime
http://www.fbi.gov/stats-services/publications/law-enforcement-
bulletin/...
4 of 4 6/3/2013 3:38 PM
Copyright of FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin is the property of
Superintendent of Documents
and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or
posted to a listserv without
the copyright holder's express written permission. However,
users may print, download, or
email articles for individual use.
Science and Justice 54 (2014) 494–501
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Science and Justice
14. closure of
some of the more established traditional laboratories. A
discipline
should be (re-)built around the study of the ‘trace’, the remnant
of a
unique criminal activity that occurred in the past. The
information it
conveys is not only restricted to serve the Court process but
should
also support the study of many types of crime activities,
following a
variety of objectives [35,36,52,53].
This paper aims at structuring this debate by stating twelve
inter-
connected propositions, at different levels of generality, to be
tested
by research. They should be considered as a preliminary
construct
open to evolution.
cole des Sciences Criminelles,
Elsevier Ireland Ltd. All rights reserv
1.1. Is this expansion necessary?
Proposition 1. Expanding R&D in forensic science beyond its
delineation
in the report is a necessity for providing a discipline with a
sufficient ambi-
tion to justify its existence, ensure its own coherency and
favour its sustain-
able development.
The need to consider the contribution of forensic science
beyond the
laboratory is already occasionally postulated by scholars [30],
15. but the
scientific literature on this issue remains rare [52]. There are
many pos-
sibilities to specify territories to be explored [37]. They have
overlapping
shapes. We propose one possible configuration that helps to
pinpoint
risks and opportunities for forensic science to engage in these
areas.
1.2. What should this expansion cover?
The most evident step for such an expansion consists of
adopting a
global view that goes from the crime scene to the presentation
of evi-
dence in Court. In this context, the traditional laboratory is
situated as
one possible structure responsible for performing specialised
operations.
Proposition 2. Research in forensic science covers the study of
its contri-
bution along the whole chain of the justice process, from the
crime scene,
to the presentation of forensic information in Court.
This elementary expansion for forensic science is not a given.
There
are many inhibitors that dissuade researchers to embark on such
a ven-
ture. Some commentators even deny, or strictly limit, an
expanded role
for forensic science along this chain:
ed.
16. http://crossmark.crossref.org/dialog/?doi=10.1016/j.scijus.2014.
05.001&domain=pdf
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.scijus.2014.05.001
mailto:[email protected]
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.scijus.2014.05.001
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/journal/13550306
495O. Ribaux, B. Talbot Wright / Science and Justice 54 (2014)
494–501
‘Expanding the forensic scientists’ domain to the ‘activity
level’
destroys the line between their expertise in their specific
forensic
discipline and a more general (and dangerous) claim to general
investigative expertise ([46: 70]).
This confined view is mainly justified by the need to keep
scientific
independence, mitigating contextual bias and avoiding
encroachment
upon each other competencies.
Such statements are particularly stimulating for research. They
immediately lead to directly address the question of the
application of
forensic science. Would it truly deserve existence, by merely
bringing
small/simple pieces of evidence before the justice system
(source level
involvement only)? And in doing so endangering the fairness of
the
judicial process at such an increased cost?
The extremity of this confinement should be more carefully
studied,
17. because it is not immediately apparent when adjoined with
Polanyi's
statement:
‘Even the most strictly mechanized procedure leaves something
to
personal skill in the exercise of which an individual bias may
enter’
([41]: 19).
And combined with Rosenthal affirmation:
‘It costs something to reduce errors, and it costs more and more
to
get rid of each error as there are fewer of them left’ [49].
Reconstructing specific events that occurred in the past is
subject to
many forms of uncertainty. Whatever the level of sophistication
of pro-
cedures and models for making decisions, forensic failures will
continue
to occur unavoidably. Each high profile case will invariably put
a little
more pressure on the system with the effect of progressively
confining
scientific laboratories in the landscape of the justice system.
This reduction in the scope of laboratories may open space for
more
fragile information and biased forms of reasoning to prosper in
crime
investigation. This could not be more evident than in the
collection of
human information (interview) that is guided by forensic
results, in
18. the complete absence of forensic advice.
An alternative response to the collapse of some independent
labora-
tories is to rebuild forensic capacity within police
organisations. It may
be another natural evolution of systems searching to fill gaps
created.
Is this movement already a reality? Research could empirically
test
this hypothesis.
The reality of this confinement is often tempered by the
employ-
ment of a case manager in the laboratory. This still understudied
func-
tion focuses on mitigating risks of biases produced by observer
effects.
It proceeds by separating the management of the case from the
evalua-
tion of observations, and by filtering contextual information
about the
case through sequential unmasking procedures [56]. However,
this
defensive function provides little indication on how forensic
science
and crime investigation should logically be articulated to favour
the
resolution of investigative problems. This needs to be studied
also.
Whatever the viewpoint, forensic science cannot operate in
isola-
tion. Indeed, lack of research dedicated to expressing this
articulation al-
lows space for pervasive misunderstandings and tensions
19. between
organisations and individuals to prosper. It is also true that no
guarantee
can be made for forensic case data to be safely and
transparently
exploited to its full potential in the variety of processes it
serves.
The study of the whole chain brings into focus two of its
important
components: (a) the contribution of forensic science to crime
investiga-
tion and (b) crime scene investigation itself.
1.2.1. Studying how forensic science may integrate with crime
investigation
The proposition to adopt a global view that starts at the scene
and
ends in Court forces the study of different forms of articulation
of foren-
sic science within crime investigation, and their respective
conse-
quences on the whole process.
This is an area of many controversies. They occur in a judicial
context
that is itself poorly formalised [25], and which is the target of
many crit-
icisms. In particular, in his 1984 seminal paper, Egger [14]
pinpointed
the incapacity of police systems to connect dots, leading to
disastrous
failures in serial murder investigations. He denounced the
fragmenta-
tion of crime investigation as it causes linkage blindness.
20. This is where the fragmentation of forensic science, confined in
spe-
cialities and silos, certainly does not address these systemic
weaknesses
coined by Egger. Research may examine how the fluidity of the
treat-
ment of scientific information is inhibited by traditional
organisational
settings of forensic laboratories. Thus, the following statement
chal-
lenges the usual pathway designed for forensic science.
Proposition 3. Crime investigation is holistic, and forensic
science is a
significant contributor to it.
In shaping police organisations during the last decade, the focus
has
been on how crime analysts, investigators, forensic scientists
and other
contributors differ through their speciality, while they actually
partici-
pate collectively to the same process of crime investigation.
Digital
traces have added new dimensions to the picture. They are used
almost
systematically and are central to most of today's investigations.
A prom-
ising avenue for research would be to consider what the actors
(i.e. the
various contributors to the investigations bringing their own
knowl-
edge and expertise) share, and what kind of collaboration must
be
stimulated to favour and regulate problem solving. Indeed, the
term
21. investigation contains at its root vestige, which means in French
the
remnant of an activity, the mark, the ‘trace’ [10]; exactly what
forensic
science studies according to Margot [36]. Adopting this view
allows
the definition of stable concepts and frameworks.
A research programme could thus examine, as its object, a
system
composed of different kinds of investigators (e.g. police
investigator,
forensic investigator, criminal intelligence analysts) trying to
solve
problems through a collective approach, by bringing their
specific
knowledge and skills in treating specific types of information.
A lot of
empirical studies could be launched around this system, its
functioning,
its adaptation to the investigation of specific cases, its
transparency and
its effectiveness.
This kind of research will inevitably address the question of
organising
forensic science with respect to the fragmentation of the
investigative
process. Various forms of bias and their consequences have
been inten-
sively discussed in forensic literature. This catalysed the debate
of
marginalising the forensic scientist from the investigation.
However, the
consequences of this fragmentation and de-contextualisation
have been
22. far less considered. This opens an important consideration that
is directly
related with a more holistic view of the investigation.
Proposition 4. The fragmentation of processes in systems and
the distanc-
ing of scientists from other figures of the investigation might
contribute to a
variety of failures, not addressed by laboratory quality
management. Thus,
contextualisation and de-contextualisation must be studied in
mirror,
depending on needs and expectations of the criminal justice
process.
There are already many documented illustrations where such
fail-
ures have occurred. One significant example is the Byford's
report on
the Yorkshire Ripper inquiry in 1981 [6]. So called ‘Byford
scientists’
have since the mid 90s deployed good practices in the role of
forensic
investigators, contributing concretely to the resolution of many
serious
crimes [1,57].
It is their responsibility to generate a productive collaboration
with
the other ‘actors’ (i.e. a contributing figure), of the
investigation. Similar
models have since been developed in many laboratories. These
scien-
tists have a global view on forensic case data available in the
context
of a case. They provide advice on how to treat it by defining
23. sequences
of operations, as well as evaluating and integrating results with
other
parts of the investigation. Priorities are defined for optimising
informa-
tion gained and, at the same time, avoiding costly and
superfluous
496 O. Ribaux, B. Talbot Wright / Science and Justice 54
(2014) 494–501
operations. However, the nature of the contribution of this
generalist,
even if it is well admitted in the field, is very rarely debated in
the scien-
tific literature [1,54,55]. Consequently, the realisation of this
task
remains largely tacit and therefore needs to be formalised in
order to
ensure transparency (see proposition five). We experience this
same
modelling gap at the scene.
1.2.2. Studying forensic science at the crime scene
Empirical research has detected many unexplained discrepancies
when measuring performance at the crime scene. They have
been recur-
rently made evident not only across jurisdictions and
operational units,
but also when making comparisons within the same units [2].
Such
results are compounded by the disparity of views about the
character
of crime scene examination as shown by a survey conducted in
Scotland
24. [33]. As it turns out, a significant number of respondents,
among them
forensic scientists from the laboratory and crime scene
examiners
themselves, still consider it as substantially ‘mechanical’ (can
be carried
out by applying a set of predefined learned procedures that
allow little
space for inductive thinking).
Such unexplained disparities should raise many more questions
for
research. Standard operating procedures for crime scene
examination
and lab-on-a-chip technologies are on the way to
implementation be-
fore intensive research is performed to understand the
underlying
logic of the treatment. We risk putting the cart before the horse.
A set of studies should deserve more attention in this context.
For
instance, Kelty and Julian [24] have identified seven qualities
that char-
acterise high performance crime scene examiners selected by
peers:
knowledge, life experience, professionalism, approach to life,
cognitive
abilities, communication and stress management. These
dimensions
overlap with the recurrent themes identified in the literature
reviewed
by Ludwig and Fraser [32] on what factors seem to influence
forensic
science effectiveness (and weaknesses) in dealing with high
volume
25. crime.
The results are signs that crime scene examination is not
mechanical
in character. It rather belongs to an imaginative type of activity.
They
encourage associations of ideas, favour the use of a solid
scientific back-
ground to regulate reasoning, and allow the deployment of
abilities
Fig. 1. The reconstruction process. A criminal activity perturbs
the physical environment (a)
developed (d). The consequences are eventually tested, refuted,
discriminated and evaluated t
to intensively communicate and exchange information. Such
signs indi-
cate the types of frameworks to be elaborated or how to recruit
people.
But research must go far further in deciphering the underlying
logic
operating at the scene and in crime investigation.
1.2.3. The study of an investigative and crime scene logic
Let us use a very simplified model in order to sketch the
modelling
challenge (Fig. 1).
Forensic science deals with activities that are unique, and that
gener-
ate material (or digital) exchanges, according to Locard's
principle. After
a certain time (Δt), crime scene investigators attend the scene
and
collect specimens.
Crime reconstruction consists of developing hypotheses about
26. the
activity, objects and individuals. A series of cycles aim at
discriminating
and refuting hypotheses, as well as develop new hypotheses.
Beliefs
change as a function of newly available information.
The active development of hypotheses about what occurred in
the
specific situation is at the core of the process. Crime scene
investigators
intensively apply this ‘abductive’ logic at the scene [11]. At the
other
extremity of the judicial process, the Court, the expert evaluates
infor-
mation from the perspective of the remaining hypotheses of the
defence
and of the prosecutor. At this stage, a more deductive style of
reasoning
takes place for the forensic scientist, in a stabilised cycle
(probabilities of
observations knowing the proposition of the prosecutor, and
respec-
tively of the defence).
There is still much to be understood beyond this very simplified
model. Taking part in the expression of an investigative logic is
suggested as a priority for forensic science.
Proposition 5. Research in forensic science needs an
epistemological
component for elaborating upon the foundations of an
investigative logic
exploiting information conveyed by traces (forensic case data).
This very limited overview shows that the quality of crime
27. scene ex-
amination and forensic investigation is mainly determined by
the ability
to draw relevant hypotheses from observations in the specific
circum-
stances of the case, and to regulate their management.
Moreover, the
potential contribution of forensic science in crime investigation
is of a
. Relevant specimen is recognised, collected and measured (b).
Alternative hypothesis is
hrough experiments.
497O. Ribaux, B. Talbot Wright / Science and Justice 54 (2014)
494–501
broad variety, when viewed with such a clinical perspective
[58]. It is
felt to be significant, but this is still not demonstrated by
research.
An epistemological exploration can lead for instance to suggest
links
between works such as Peirce semiotic [13], the evidential
paradigm of
the historian Carlo Ginzburg [16], the method of historical
science that
searches for explanations to past singular events on the basis of
current-
ly observable marks [7,8], the scientific investigation of crime
defined
by Kind [25], the use of probabilities in the investigation
suggested by
Jackson et al. [22], and case-based reasoning when successful
solutions
28. to previous problems are used to deal with a new similar
situation [26].
Probably many other approaches can be integrated where traces
are
recognised as signs providing information on what occurred in
the past.
1.3. Questioning the effectiveness of forensic science
This background causes other concerns about how to
appropriately
integrate innovative and flourishing technologies. The
laboratory-
centric view of forensic science causes deviation from this
fundamental
question. It focuses mainly on technologies rather than on the
value of
information conveyed by forensic case data. Peter Deforest
wrote in
1999:
‘Has the field advanced?’ On the face of it there would seem to
be no
question that the field of criminalistics has advanced. But has
it?
While we have forged ahead technologically, in my view we
have
backslid with respect to our core activity — that of applying
science
and scientific reasoning to criminal and civil investigations
([12:
197]).
Technologies are aimed at supporting the resolution of
problems.
But the specific problem under scrutiny, as well as the global
29. impact
of forensic science on solving and reducing crime often remains
relegat-
ed behind the prescriptive application of procedures and
technologies.
The rapid evolution of technologies may provide an explanation
of
this deviation. DNA came about 80 years after the
implementation of
fingerprints. But the quantity of electronic data has since
exploded, at
a time scale that is equivalent to about half a professional
career. ‘Big
data’ has become an effective issue in less than one generation
of
students [51]. Efforts to assimilate these changes are
tremendous. The
Policing debate
Fig. 2. Order of magnitude of the DNA evi
market is stimulated to push new technologies at a rate that
exceeds
our own ability to integrate them. Lab-on-a-chip and big data
technolo-
gies are at the door, but the current paradigm provides no
solution for
avoiding a further destabilisation of the discipline. A solid
vision elabo-
rated through a strong focus on fundamental research has
become
indispensable in our rapidly evolving system.
Another exciting avenue for research exists here.
Proposition 6. Refocusing forensic science on problem solving
30. will
provide a more central position to the discipline in crime
investigation, as
well as greater stability and sustainability.
By focusing on means rather than ends and distancing from
other
actors, current forensic systems forget to consider their global
effective-
ness in policing [53]. Indeed, when it is measured, an
embarrassing
evidence funnel is made visible, i.e. there is a huge gap between
what
is collected at the scene and what is effectively used at the end
of the
judicial process. This gap is made always more explicit through
the so
called end-to-end studies on the use of DNA profiles (Fig. 2).
They show that the chance for a trace, generated by the activity
of
the offender, to be eventually presented at Court, remains very
low,
no matter how extensively technology is deployed.
Information is lost at various decision points throughout the
case
handling process. Registering the case and attending the scene,
process-
ing the crime scene and choosing if a specimen must be sent to
the lab-
oratory are examples of choices to be made. Many factors
influence the
extraction of the profile, the comparison of the profile with the
content
of databases, the interpretation of matches, the integration of
31. results
into the investigation, the use of this evidence in reporting, and
eventu-
ally the use of the piece of evidence at Court. Regardless, when
seen as a
whole, the process provides a questioning picture for the
effectiveness
of forensic science.
Such evaluations however are unfair. These indicators do not
grasp
the broad variety of useful information brought to the
investigation by
forensic science. The UK Parliamentary Select Committee
‘Forensic
Science on Trial’ acknowledged this in 2005:
‘The main contribution that forensic science makes to the
criminal
justice system is the generation of intelligence to assist
investiga-
tions’ ([20]: 8).
Justice / Forensic debate
dence funnel for high volume crime.
image of Fig.�2
498 O. Ribaux, B. Talbot Wright / Science and Justice 54
(2014) 494–501
There are unfortunately still very few empirical bases to ground
this
assertion.
Beyond investigation, forensic science is understood according
32. to
the lines debated in the scientific literature. Development
centres on
serving the Court process, yet it is evaluated on how it supports
crime
control or crime reduction strategies in policing (see Fig. 2).
There is a
tension here that needs urgently to be made visible by research,
because
this misunderstanding may have dramatic consequences in
deciding
the future of forensic science [2,5,48,57].
1.4. Forensic science in policing
There is again a lack of models and almost no scientific debate
to
express the potential of forensic science in policing.
Proposition 7. Forensic science can and should contribute to,
and actively
engage in policing.
Going into policing is another controversial possible expansion
for
forensic science. As Inman and Rudin state, forensic science is
required
to strictly stay focussed on the court's need:
‘The scientific analysis is only performed at the behest of
someone
seeking to introduce the evidence into a court of law’ ([21:15]).
In this context, can forensic science enter into the policing
debate,
which is a discipline that has acquired some autonomy from the
justice
system?
33. This is also a delicate question, but let's have a quick and
simplified
look at a contemporary policing debate in order to better
identify risks
and opportunities. It may actually be that the broad use of
separate fo-
rensic identification techniques in a court-oriented strategy is
already
contributing to overwhelm actors of the system. The order of
magnitude
of the number of matches obtained through biometric systems
has
changed. Estimations already indicate that the treatment of all
the
matches obtained at a national and international level through
auto-
matic data exchanges becomes intractable. At the same time, the
real
effect of this traditional intensive case-by-case identification
method
is controversial in terms of crime reduction [44].
But what are the alternatives? Mostly they focus much more on
the
study of repetitive crimes. They started to emerge in the 1970s
along
many different lines. Goldstein has initiated one of the most
important
streams [17]. He defined ‘problem oriented policing’ (POP),
which
aims at providing a proactive component to the organisation.
The pro-
cess concentrates efforts on Scanning repetitive and persistent
criminal
or security problems encountered by the police in their daily
34. operations
(S). Their Analysis (A) encourages then inferring the causes of
the prob-
lem identified. Elaboration of possible Responses for mitigating
the
problem, choosing and implementing what is expected to be the
more
efficient solutions are the next steps of the approach (R). The
systematic
Assessment and adaptation of the chosen dispositive finalises
the pro-
cess (A). The focus is on mitigating the problem by preferring
preven-
tive approaches, not necessarily by arresting or identifying
individuals.
This method has become very popular in policing and known
under
the acronym SARA.
Does forensic science really have something to do with problem
ori-
ented policing? There are actually many examples of such
implications.
One such experience in Boston is particularly interesting and
was the
object of scientific papers written by Braga [3,4], a
distinguished special-
ist in problem oriented policing. It was eventually recognised
that the
systematic comparisons of bullets collected at crime scenes
‘helped
guide violence prevention efforts by establishing patterns in
particular
areas and among specific individuals’. Of importance is to
notice that
this programme was not led by the police, but by other
35. institutions
that had to deal with the problem. Policing does not mean that
the
police are the only actors, or even that they must lead such
projects or
to what degree they participate in the application of the method.
What is common in these modern strategies, beyond problem
solv-
ing policing, is the focus on repetitive crimes under all their
forms. Even
if different streams in policing exist, they tend to be regrouped
under
the umbrella of ‘intelligence-led policing’.
This opens the door to potential fears prompted by the
misinterpre-
tation of the term ‘intelligence’. Thus, has forensic science to
compro-
mise with intelligence by developing a forensic intelligence
branch?
Maybe the term itself ‘forensic intelligence’ which is
occasionally
regarded an oxymoron, is not an appropriate one. The term
seeks only
to express that forensic case data has the potential to contribute
in a
structured way to the detection and strategic approach towards
repeti-
tive crime, the support of preventative policing models, and the
disrup-
tion of criminal enterprises in crime reduction.
The first generation of intelligence-led policing systems was
much
more based on the results of research in criminology, that
36. clearly
showed that a few minority of offenders were responsible for a
high
proportion of crimes reported [42].
Targeting and neutralising these so-called prolific offenders
would
hopefully significantly reduce crime. Obviously, the problem
was how
to target prolific offenders. Traditional police solutions can be
intrusive,
and predicting recidivism is far from obvious. How forensic
science can
support this process in a more neutral way is thus a critical
question to
be evaluated within this framework.
This way of considering forensic science in policing changes
the
metrics, and even the econometrics, for evaluating its
efficiency. In
this framework, assessing the following proposition takes an
evident
importance.
Proposition 8. The adoption of intelligence-led policing changes
how to
consider the effectiveness of forensic science. Intelligence-led
crime scene
processing and crime scene linking become central.
Let us take one example to obtain an understanding of the
dimen-
sion of the challenge.
1.5. Forensic science and intelligence-led policing: an example
37. A crime scene investigator attends scenes of residential
burglaries
into the same …
RESEARCH ARTICLE
Rethinking the Compstat process to enhance problem-solving
responses: insights from a randomized field experiment
Brenda J. Bonda* and Anthony A. Bragab
aSawyer Business School, Suffolk University, Boston, MA
02108, USA; bSchool of Criminal
Justice, Rutgers University, Newark, NJ 07102, USA
Compstat is an important administrative innovation in policing
that provides a
much-needed mechanism for holding mid-level managers
accountable for controlling
crime rates. Research evidence suggests that Compstat is more
likely to generate
reactive crime control responses rather than more creative
problem-solving responses.
A randomized field experiment in Lowell, Massachusetts found
that ‘problem-solving
meetings’ produced more innovative responses to crime
problems and generated
stronger crime control gains when compared to the Compstat
process. Analysis of
qualitative data collected to monitor the implementation of the
experiment revealed
that important differences in meeting dynamics were associated
with observed differ-
ences and suggests promising avenues to improve Compstat
38. processes.
Keywords: Compstat; problem-solving; police management;
crime control
Introduction
Compstat has been hailed as one of the most prominent police
innovations of the past
20 years (see, e.g. McDonald, 2002; Silverman, 1999). While it
has many features,
Compstat can be generally viewed as a combined technical and
managerial system that
embeds the technical system for the collection and distribution
of police performance
data in a broader managerial system designed to focus the
organization on specific
objectives, usually involving crime reduction, by holding a
subset of managers account-
able for using organizational resources appropriately in pursuit
of these objectives
(Moore, 2003; Moore & Braga, 2003). Since the approach was
first implemented by the
New York City Police Department (NYPD) in 1994 (Bratton,
1998), Compstat has been
adopted by various police organizations, where police
executives attempt to improve
their performance by embracing data-based decision-making,
enhanced problem-solving,
and management accountability (Weisburd, Mastrofski,
McNally, Greenspan, & Willis,
2003).
Despite the extensive diffusion of Compstat across police
agencies in the USA and
other countries, the crime control benefits of Compstat remain
40. In this paper, we reflect upon the outcomes of a randomized
field experiment in
Lowell, Massachusetts that found ‘problem-solving meetings’
designed to ensure
adequate treatment dosage in treatment crime hot spots resulted
in far more problem-
solving responses and greater crime control gains when
compared to the crime-reduction
responses implemented at control hot spots naturally generated
by a citywide Compstat
process (Braga & Bond, 2008). Using qualitative data collection
and analysis methods,
we compare meeting dynamics to understand why the problem-
solving meetings yielded
more innovative and effective crime-reduction interventions
relative to Compstat
meetings. The results of our analyses suggest that the inputs and
processes of the prob-
lem-solving meetings accounted for the observed differences in
strategies and outcomes.
By integrating these dynamics into Compstat meetings, these
managerial systems could
be used to good effect in moving police departments towards
more robust community
problem-solving activities.
Compstat and problem-solving
Herman Goldstein (1979) argued that the crime control failures
of the standard model of
policing could be explained by the fact that police departments
were poorly organized
to do something about crime. Compstat sought to overcome this
organizational problem
by empowering the command structure to do something about
41. crime problems (Bratton,
1998; Weisburd et al., 2003). As originated by the NYPD,
Compstat operates as a stra-
tegic control system implemented to collect and disseminate
information on crime prob-
lems and track responses used to control them (McDonald,
2002; Silverman, 1999).
These elements are most visibly displayed in Compstat meetings
during which precinct
commanders appear before the department’s top brass to report
on crime problems in
their precincts and what they are doing about them (Bratton,
1998; Silverman, 1999;
Weisburd, Mastrofski, Willis, & Greenspan, 2006).
A recent Police Foundation study of the implementation of
Compstat by US police
departments defined Compstat as a ‘strategic problem-solving’
model that seeks to focus
police organizations on specific crime problems and to empower
police organizations to
identify and solve those problems (Weisburd et al., 2003). When
compared to common
conceptions of problem-oriented policing programs that tend to
focus on line-level prac-
tice (Eck & Spelman, 1987; Goldstein, 1990), Compstat focuses
on the ways in which
police agencies can be organized as problem-solving institutions
rather than on the spe-
cific problem-solving strategies that police use to address crime
problems (Weisburd
et al., 2006). The Police Foundation identified six key elements
of Compstat that form a
comprehensive approach for mobilizing police agencies to
identify, analyze, and solve
public safety problems: mission clarification; internal
42. accountability; geographic organi-
zation of command; organizational flexibility; data-driven
problem identification and
assessment; and innovative problem-solving (Weisburd et al.,
2003).
In practice, however, these core elements do not seem to
translate into enhanced
problem-solving responses in Compstat agencies. A Police
Foundation survey found that
Compstat police agencies were not any more likely to
implement innovative
Police Practice and Research: An International Journal 23
problem-solving responses than non-Compstat police agencies
(Weisburd et al., 2003).
The on-site observations documented a preponderance of
traditional responses, such as
saturation patrol and increasing arrests in problem areas. The
Police Foundation research
team also conducted deeper ethnographic assessments of three
‘model’ police depart-
ments – including the Lowell Police Department (LPD) – that
closely followed the
NYPD Compstat model (Willis, Mastrofski, Weisburd, &
Greenspan, 2004). Compstat
police agencies tended to place the greatest emphasis on
mission clarification and inter-
nal accountability elements. Unfortunately, the reinforcement of
the traditional hierarchi-
cal command structure interfered with the decision-making
authority of mid-level
managers and diminished creative problem-solving efforts.
43. The LPD and Compstat
Lowell, Massachusetts is a small city of some 105,000 residents
located about 30 miles
northeast of Boston and has a geographic expanse of 14.5
square miles. After his
appointment in 1995, Superintendent Edward F. Davis adopted
Compstat as a central
component of his departmental reforms and closely followed the
model developed by
the NYPD; as such, this makes Lowell an ideal research site as
the LPD engaged a
model that was widely replicated in police agencies across the
USA and many other
nations. As described by Willis et al. (2004), the LPD’s
Compstat goals included, ‘elicit-
ing collective input on crime patterns and problem-solving
strategies, encouraging infor-
mation sharing on crime locations, victims, and suspects, and
facilitating the
deployment of department resources’ (p. 474). LPD Compstat
meetings were held on a
bi-weekly basis, led by Superintendent Davis or one of the two
Deputy Superintendents,
and typically included 25–30 attendees.2 The captains who led
the LPD’s three policing
sectors were the focal point of the Compstat meetings and other
mid-level managers
would also be queried as crime problems intersected with their
locus of responsibility.
Citywide and sector-level crime trends and hot spot maps were
closely reviewed; the
presentation of the data was accompanied by questioning by
Davis and the Deputy
Superintendents on the nature of concerning crime trends and
44. concentrations and the
captains’ strategies to address recurring crime problems.
Willis et al. (2004) found that the LPD’s Compstat fostered a
clear sense of mission
and accountability relative to crime control. However, they also
reported that the process
did not realign decision-making toward street supervisors, nor
did it provide sector cap-
tains with greater flexibility in using organizational resources.
Although the use of crime
data and analyses for problem and hot spot identification were a
centerpiece of the
Compstat process, the captains rarely referenced data beyond
personal perceptions and
police reports to understand the conditions that cultivate crime
patterns and hot spots.
Further, the Willis et al. (2004) study revealed that captains
habitually relied on tradi-
tional crime control tactics rather than engage in more creative
and innovative strategies
to deal with crime hot spots. While the LPD’s Compstat was
established, in part, to
encourage information sharing and innovative problem-solving,
Willis et al. (2004) sug-
gested that Lowell fell short of achieving these goals because
the meeting reinforced tra-
ditional, hierarchical command and control constitutions that
impeded the reforms and
innovation that they had hoped to achieve.
The current study
This research analyzes process data collected during the
implementation of a
randomized controlled trial to test the impact of problem-
45. oriented policing on crime and
24 B.J. Bond and A.A. Braga
disorder hot spots in Lowell (Braga & Bond, 2008). Using
computerized mapping tech-
nology, 34 crime and disorder hot spots were identified and
subsequently matched into
17 like pairs; one member of each pair was randomly allocated
to treatment and control
conditions. The intervention period lasted for one year (1
September 2005 through 31
August 2006). Superintendent Davis assigned ultimate
responsibility for the implementa-
tion of the problem-oriented policing intervention at the
treatment places to the captains
that managed the LPD three policing sectors. The problem-
oriented policing intervention
was managed through monthly ‘problem-solving meetings’
designed to ensure adequate
treatment dosage in treatment crime hot spots. The control hot
spot areas experienced
the routine amount and kinds of police strategies that such areas
in Lowell would expe-
rience without focused intervention – arbitrary patrol
interventions, routine follow-up
investigations by detectives, and ad hoc community problem-
solving attention.
Policing actions at the control hot spots were managed through
the LPD’s bi-weekly
Compstat meetings. These meetings were attended by the
research team to document
possible contamination issues – whether the control hot spots
46. were receiving concen-
trated police actions that were similar to the interventions
implemented at the treatment
hot spots. While control hot spots were not acknowledged as
such, these locations were
routine subjects of Compstat meetings as persistent problem
places that required ongo-
ing police attention. When control hot spots were addressed, the
research team took
careful notes on the discussion that followed. It is worth noting
here that treatment hot
spots would occasionally be mentioned during the Compstat
process.
Analytical framework and data collection
The randomized controlled trial design facilitated a structured
comparison between the
problem-solving meetings that guided the implementation of the
problem-oriented polic-
ing intervention at the treatment hot spots and the Compstat
meetings that governed
problem-solving attention in the comparison hot spots.
Qualitative data collected to
monitor treatment and control conditions were analyzed to
understand the key character-
istics and dynamics of the two sets of management
accountability meetings. The analyti-
cal framework draws on group/team3 effectiveness research to
examine whether meeting
characteristics and dynamics had an influence on the observed
differences. The
Inputs-Process-Outcome (IPO) framework is applied to the LPD
meetings to explore the
connection among the inputs into group work, group process
behaviors to develop
47. strategies and tactics to address crime and disorder, and their
impact on working group
outcomes (Campion, Medsker & Higgs, 1993; Gladstein, 1984).
The application of the
IPO framework to this research is appropriate for two reasons.
First, since the LPD was
the site for both sets of meetings, organizational factors were
constant. Variations in
organizational culture, hierarchy, policies, and procedures can
have strong impacts on
group dynamics. Second, the Compstat and the treatment
problem-solving meetings had
very similar crime-reduction and accountability objectives.
Qualitative data were collected using two basic techniques: (1)
overt participant
observation; and (2) intensive interviewing of LPD
commanders, managers, and officers.
As described by Lofland and Lofland (1984), participant
observation is the process in
which a researcher gains a close and intimate familiarity with a
given group of individu-
als and their practices through an intensive involvement with
people in their natural
environment, usually over an extended period of time. In this
study, the LPD was
overtly observed by the research team in two sets of crime
control meetings and field
settings as researchers monitoring the implementation of an
experiment. Intensive
Police Practice and Research: An International Journal 25
interviewing, also described by Lofland and Lofland (1984) as
48. ‘unstructured
interviewing,’ involves recurring guided conversations to
discover the subject’s experi-
ence of a particular topic or situation.
Over the course of the experiment, N = 14 monthly problem-
solving meetings and
N = 22 bi-monthly Compstat meetings were observed.4 In both
meetings, the number of
participants and their level and nature of participation, patterns
of participation, partici-
pant roles within the agency, and the content of conversations
involving strategies to
address hot spot locations were carefully documented. The
research team also
interviewed key LPD staff at scheduled meetings and through
informal conversations.5
Qualitative data on the genesis and implementation of crime
control strategies were also
collected during N = 52 weekly ride-alongs to monitor progress
at treatment hot spots
and N = 12 monthly researcher site observations to document
actions taken at control
hot spots.6 We sought to improve reliability of the qualitative
data by cross-checking
and probing study participants’ responses to the interview
questions. Interview and
meeting observation data were recorded in the form of
handwritten notes, transcribed,
and analyzed by the authors.
In the analysis, we selected statements that illustrated themes
consistently found
throughout the data. The quotes used were not atypical, with the
exception of a few
49. issues that we indicate a small number of respondents
mentioned. We were also careful
throughout the data analysis to ensure that the emerging themes
correctly reflected
respondents’ descriptions. Thus, the research team utilized
grounded theory methods to
identify recurrent topics in addition to less common but salient
issues (Strauss, 1987).
Results
Meeting inputs
While the problem-solving meetings were based on the LPD’s
Compstat process, there
were some obvious differences. The problem-solving meetings
were held on a monthly
rather than bi-weekly basis. Compstat centered on the
identification of crime patterns and
hot spots across the city and within sectors, while problem-
solving meetings focused on
17 persistent crime and disorder hot spots. The problem-solving
meetings were also
smaller, with a mean of 13 participants that included Davis,
then-Deputy Superintendent
Kenneth Lavallee, the three sector captains and selected officers
from their commands,
the Community Liaison, the Director of Research and
Development, and a civilian ana-
lyst from the Crime Analysis Unit. Compstat meetings averaged
27 participants; the addi-
tional meeting members included other members of the LPD
command staff and external
agency representatives (such as probation officers, prosecutors,
and others).
50. It is also important to note here that the Compstat meetings
were held in a large
room with the LPD command staff seated around a U-shaped
table facing a screen with
projected computerized crime statistics for presentation
purposes. Lowering ranking offi-
cers, civilian staff, and members of outside agencies were
seated around the table.
Superintendent Davis or one of the Deputy Superintendents led
the meeting as a formal
question-and-answer session for particular sector captains with
occasional input from
other high-ranking LPD officers on specific issues. In contrast,
the problem-solving
meetings were held in a smaller room with all participants
(regardless of rank, civilian/
sworn status, or external observer status) sat around a single
rectangular table. While
Superintendent Davis or Deputy Superintendent Lavallee led the
meetings, the format
was much less formal and there was an expectation that
everyone around the table
needed to participate in the discussion.
26 B.J. Bond and A.A. Braga
At each problem-solving meeting, the crime analyst presented
simple trend analyses
of citizen calls for service and crime incidents in each of the
treatment hot spots to
determine whether crime and disorder problems were being
positively impacted. If the
data revealed that calls for service were decreasing,
Superintendent Davis praised the
51. captains and their officers and asked them to explain why they
believed their actions
were producing the desired effects, and what else could be done
to keep calls for ser-
vice decreasing. If the analysis revealed that the number of
citizen calls for service had
remained the same or increased, Superintendent Davis peppered
the captains with ques-
tions about their plans for dealing with recurring problems in
the hot spot areas. The
problem-solving meetings also served as a venue for the
command staff, captains, offi-
cers, and other LPD staff to explore and share ideas on
plausibly effective prevention
strategies for persistent problems in the treatment places.
While the performance measurement accountability principles
were borrowed from
Compstat, the activities at the problem-solving meetings
represented an ongoing scan-
ning, analysis, response, and assessment process (see Eck &
Spelman, 1987). The routine
measurement and review of strategies in the treatment places
served as an important
mechanism to ensure that there was a strong treatment dosage
for the experiment. The
problem-solving meetings were designed to ensure that the
captains and their officers
were implementing the problem-oriented policing program and
adhering to the require-
ments of the experimental research design. These meetings were
explicitly focused on
implementing the approach by addressing local community
concerns as measured by
trends in citizen calls for service in the treatment hot spot areas,
holding police managers
52. accountable for dealing with identified problems, and serving as
a venue to enhance the
creativity of implemented responses through open discussion
and idea sharing.
Research on group work suggests that inputs such as group size,
group composition,
and task design influence the outcomes of working groups
(Campion et al., 1993;
Stewart, 2006). Our analysis documented that the Compstat
meetings were larger and
group composition was slightly more varied than the problem-
solving meetings. Our
analyses of the qualitative data also suggested neither group
size nor composition seem
to exert noteworthy independent effects on the meetings. The
smaller size of the
problem-solving meetings may have made it easier to conduct
intimate conversations of
particular problems. However, as will be discussed further
below, the meeting processes
were much more influential in explaining variations in outcomes
between the Compstat
and problem-solving meetings.
Task design represents what the group is attempting to
accomplish (Hackman &
Oldham, 1980). In the Compstat meetings, Superintendent Davis
tended to guide con-
versations towards clusters of crime incidents within a
particular sector, specifically
including the 17 comparison hot spots. In this way, the task
designs of the two meetings
were broadly similar as both meetings were intended to produce
the same outcomes –
increased problem-solving responses and reduced crime at
53. specific problem places.
However, the geography of targeted crime problems were
clearly more variable in the
Compstat meetings as discussions, at times, ranged from
specific addresses to neighbor-
hoods. Another important difference was the explicit
identification of specific problems
within each targeted treatment hot spot in the problem-solving
meetings. On average,
the sector captains identified four problems per treatment hot
spot that seemed to
generate recurring crimes. These problems became a ‘caseload’
of work: underlying
conditions associated with these problems were dissected,
appropriate responses were
discussed, and response performance was measured repeatedly
over the course of the
experiment.
Police Practice and Research: An International Journal 27
Meeting process
Meeting process elements include a variety of group dynamics,
including communica-
tion and cooperation behaviors, constructive feedback systems,
collaborative planning
practices, the level of interdependence and trust among
participants, and the functional
diversity and roles participants represent in the organization and
group (Williams &
Allen, 2008). Analysis of our qualitative data from the
Compstat and problem-solving
meetings suggested that the two working groups had the greatest
54. differences in three
key areas: communication and information sharing,
collaborative planning, and the
appreciation of the roles and skill sets of a broader range of
group members in
achieving group goals.
Communication and information sharing
Communication and information sharing are recognized as
influencing group
effectiveness (Woolley, Gerbasi, Chabris, Kosslyn, & Hackman,
2008). Woolley et al.
(2008) asserts that it is more than just information sharing that
matters, but rather the
revealing, organizing, and pooling of information that matters
most to outcomes. The
LPD Compstat meetings almost always involved one-to-one
communication between
the lead executive officer and the sector captains in a
mechanical and, often, superficial
manner. Similar to the observations made by Willis et al.
(2004), communication
exchanges were usually perfunctory, involving quick reviews of
identified problems and
brief reports on responses by the sector captains. While we did
not observe any
instances where sector captains were publicly humiliated, the
communications by the
lead executive officer were highly authoritarian in nature and
occasionally dismissive
when the sector captains provided answers that were believed to
be uninformed or
incorrect.
Unless the Superintendent prompted another meeting member to
55. contribute, the
captain of the reporting sector was the only person discussing
problems at these varying
high-crime places. Moreover, these discussions often did not
lead to conversations on
appropriate problem-solving responses that were linked to
underlying conditions and
dynamics. Over the course of the study, we documented N = 170
distinct discussions of
spatial crime problems at Compstat meetings. Only 25.8% (N =
44) of these discussions
were followed by a problem-oriented conversation about the
varied ways LPD officers
could impact these persistent spatial crime problems.
Unfortunately, the resulting
responses usually included a preponderance of traditional
enforcement actions.
Many instances were noted where deficient problem-solving was
driven by a lack of
engagement of low-ranking officers and civilian staff. For
instance, in Compstat meeting
1, the Superintendent asked the North Sector captain to report
on his plans for address-
ing community concerns over an assault hot spot in the
downtown area. The captain
responded by simply stating that he was ‘redeploying officers to
address community
concerns and complaints.’ The community liaison was not asked
to report on commu-
nity concerns and substance of the LPD’s response to the
problem. In fact, across the
observed Compstat Meetings, this important LPD staff member
was rarely asked to
comment on any police-community communication issues.
56. In Compstat meeting 19, the Superintendent requested the East
Sector captain to
explain some concerning increases in sector-wide property and
violent crime trends by
reflecting on the content of the underlying crime incident
reports. The captain responded
by stating, ‘Chief, I don’t know how these statistics are
generated, and I’m not sure I
28 B.J. Bond and A.A. Braga
ever will.’ The crime analyst who was managing the
presentation of crime statistics for
the Compstat meetings was not asked to provide any insights on
the underlying crime
incident reports. Rather than engage in what could have been a
valuable conversation
about the data, the conversation moved to the next topic. After
each of these Compstat
meetings, we asked the community liaison and crime analyst
why they did not offer any
insights. Both expressed concerns that it would be detrimental
to their careers if they
offered information that contradicted their superiors. This
parallels previous research
findings that most Compstat participants do not contribute
information to avoid the
perception of questioning authority (Weisburd et al., 2006;
Willis et al., 2004).
Problem-solving meetings fostered a more participatory and
democratic problem-
solving approach, without minimizing the accountability of
captains. The communica-
57. tion tone of the lead executive officer was less formal, more
engaging, and inclusive.
Captains were encouraged to discuss crime problems and their
problem-solving ideas,
without a fear of being embarrassed if an idea was incomplete
or failed. All meeting
members were expected to contribute and share information. In
problem-solving meet-
ing 5, the crime analyst began the conversation on treatment hot
spots in the West Sec-
tor by observing, ‘Three hot spot areas seem to be driving the
numbers, so maybe we
should focus on those areas.’ The West Sector captain and two
patrol officers then fol-
lowed this observation by identifying the underlying problems
that might be driving the
increases and the entire group contributed to the search for
potential responses. In prob-
lem-solving meeting 5, Superintendent Davis suggested, ‘Let’s
look at the hot spots
with crime reductions so we can try to understand why other hot
spots are not showing
the same decreases.’ Instead of offering the same perfunctory
replies used in Compstat
meetings, the sector captains engaged in a thoughtful discourse
on the observed differ-
ences. Other participants, such as the community liaison,
enriched the discussion by
contributing information based on what they knew from their
work in the hot spots.
Problem-solving meeting members were encouraged to
participate with the intent of
offering feedback in order to improve upon, rather than simply
criticize, ideas. In orga-
nizational research, this is known as ‘voice behavior’ (LePine &
58. Dyne, 1998 and this
manner of risk-taking communication has been found to
influence group outcomes posi-
tively (Edmondson, 1999). For instance, in problem-solving
meeting 3, Deputy Superin-
tendent Lavallee asked participating officers if their strategies
at their various treatment
hot spots included serving warrants. The East Sector lieutenant
responded by stating
‘we are focusing on car break problems in this hot spot because
that is our biggest
problem, and while warrant checks are important, they are not
of greatest concern to the
police or the community at the moment.’ Deputy Lavallee
accepted this explanation
without questioning the lieutenant’s judgment, suggesting a
dynamic in support of open
and honest communication without fear of reprimand. Risk-
taking communication was
rarely observed at Compstat Meetings. Captains …
THE NUMBERS DILEMMA: THE CHIMERA OF MODERN
POLICE
ACCOUNTABILITY SYSTEMS
JAMES F. GILSINAN*
INTRODUCTION
In the lexicon of dyadic American folk sayings, "motherhood
and apple
pie" is. being joined by "transparency and accotmtability."
Similarly, like
"motherhood and apple pie," one takes on the iconic nature of
59. the saying at
considerable risk. After all, who could be against transparency
and
accountability? Management gum Stephen R. Covey argues that,
"[ajccountability breeds response-ability."^ This formulation
neatly captures,
the assumed relationship between accountability and
performance. There is
also an assumed relationship between transparency and a robust
democratic
system.̂ Joumalist Peter Finn notes, a "basic tenet of a healthy
democracy is
open dialogue and transparency." Finally, accountability and
transparency are
seen as reinforcing each other." Being held accountable
assvunes that one's
actions are available for review and critique.' Indeed, the Dodd-
Fratik Wall
Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act, passed in the wake
of the recent
financial meltdown, attempts to regulate the disclosure
requirements of
fmancial firms on the asstimption that such mandated
transparency will result
in better performance on the part of banks and other financial
institutions.^
Police departments in the United States and elsewhere have
been quick to
jump on the transparency and accountability bandwagon.^ The
increasing use
* E. Desmond Lee Professor in Collaborative Regional
Education, Department of Public Policy
Studies, Saint Louis University.
60. 1. STEPHEN R. COVEY, PRINCIPLE-CENTERED
LEADERSHIP 49 (1990).
2. Elizabeth Garrett, Accountability and Restraint: The Federal
Budget Process and the
Line Item Veto Act, 20 CARDOZO L. REV. 871, 924 (1999).
3. Peter Fenn, POLITICO: THE ARENA (Apr. 23, 2009),
http://www.politico.com/arena/
perm/Peter_Fenn_l 49A409A-FDA2-41EA-ACA1-
41133DF86F66.html.
4. Joshua N. Auerbach, Police Accountability in Kenya, 3 AFR.
HUM. RTS. L. J. 275, 282
(2003).
5. Ruth W. Grant & Robert O. Keohane, Accountability and
Abuses of Power in World
Politics, 99 AM. POL. SCI. R. 29, 29 (2005). .
6. Cody Vitello, The Wall Street Reform Act of 2010 & What it
Means for Joe & Jane
Consumer, 23 LOY. CONSUMER L. REV. 99, 101 (2010).
7. Erik Luna, Transparent Policing, 85 IOWA L. REV. .1107,
1163 (2000).
93
94 SAINT LOUIS UNIVERSITY PUBLIC LAW REVIEW [Vol.
XXX11:93
of accessible, web-based, real time crime data, using geographic
information
61. system (GIS) technology to display neighborhood crime
pattems, represents
the move toward transparency on the part of major city police
departments.^
Similarly, the rapid adoption of COMPSTAT-like programs in
mid to large
size departments speaks to a willingness to be held accountable
for crime
occurrences and their control.' Unfortunately, there are a
multitude of reasons
why systems designed to increase transparency and
accountability will not
work and, in fact, may make the very goals sought by programs
of
organizational reform less likely to be achieved.
In this Article, I argue that there are five obstacles facing police
reformers
seeking to increase transparency and accountability in law
enforcement
organizations.' Moreover, these obstacles are nearly
insurmountable." The
phrase "nearly insurmountable" means that while change can
and will occur,
the changes will, at best, be at the margins of the organization—
and, at worst,
such changes may make situations in need of correction more
problematic.'^
This pessimistic assessment is due to the nature of the numbers
themselves; the
nature of organizations, particularly those that do not produce
an objective
product; the culture of policing; the institutional environment in
which the
police operate; and the larger cultures' failure to distinguish
among the
62. concepts of data, information, and knowledge.'^
I. THE SIREN SONG OF COUNTING AND NUMBERS
When presented with a table of numbers that purport to
objectively
measure or describe a phenomenon, in keeping with the dictates
of
accountability or transparency, or both, the reader is often
lulled into a state of
process amnesia. Numbers are always the end product of a
series of decisions,
many of which are subjective and somewhat arbitrary.''' There
are at least six
decision points that affect the "objective" nature of the numbers
being
reported.'^ The first is obviously the decision to count one thing
rather than
another.'^
8. W. at 1175.
9. John R. Firman, Deconstructing COMPSTAT to Clarify its
Intent, 2 CRIMINOLOGY &
PUB. POL'Y 457, 458 (2003).
10. See m/ra Parts I-V.
11. See Gary W. Sykes, The Functional Nature of Police
Reform: The 'Myth' of Controlling
the Police, 2 JUST. Q. 51, 53 (1985).
12. Id
13. See infra nott 111.
14. Craig D. Uchida, Carol Bridgeforth & Charles F. Wellford,
Law Enforcement Statistics:
63. The State of the Art, 5 AM. J. POLICE 23, 29 (1986).
15. Id
16. Id
2012] THE NUMBERS DILEMMA 95
The simple act of deciding to count or not count something
confers or
denies a certain importance to an object or outcome. A number
of criminal
justice examples illustrate the point.
Until the early 1970s, domestic assault did not "coiinf as a
serious
offense.'̂ On the other hand, homosexual activity between
consenting adults
did "count" as a crime. In fact, why do we bother to count crime
at all? Those
familiar with the history and the development of the FBI
Uniform Crime
Reports (UCR) know the reason certain kinds of crime were
counted was
motivated by a political goal: shielding top police officials from
the periodic
crime cmsades of the tabloid press." The sensationalism of
crime reporting,
and the consequent threat to the job stability of a police chief,
literally could be
count-ered by the "objectivity" of numbers.^" Of course, since
its beginning,
the UCR has been plagued by a second subjective decision point
prior to
arriving at a number: What counts as an instance of a
phenomenon?^'
64. The specifically political nature of this decision point is noted
by Deborah
Stone who points out that counting requires classification,
which in tum
requires judgments about inclusion and exclusion—who or what
is in or out.̂ ^
Again, the history of the UCR nicely illustrates this dilemma.
Crime categories
have been known to expand or contract depending on the
circumstances at
hand. Thus, a mtinicipality heavily dependent on tourism may
employ very
narrow definitions of what constitutes a criminal act, thereby
keeping crime
rates low. At budget time, a crime wave, based on expanding the
category of
what coimts as a crime, may be helpful in obtaining additional
resources.
The third decision point that illustrates the subjective nature of
a number is
the choice of a procedure for counting to one. '̂' This may seem
straightforward—one thing is one thing. But alas, one thing may
be made up of
multiple parts; thus, the question becomes whether to count the
parts separately
or as a unit. The UCR solves this dilemma by introducing a time
dimension in
17. Faith E. Lutze & Megan L. Symons, The Evolution of
Domestic Violence Policy
Through Masculine Institutions: From Discipline to Protection
to Collaborative Empowerment, 2
CRIMINOLOGY & PUB. POL'Y 319,322 (2003).
65. 18. Bennett Wolff, Expanding the Right of Sexual Privacy, 27
LOY. L. REV. 1279, 1281
(1981).
19. Michael D. Maltz, Crime Statistics: A Historical
Perspective, 23 CRIME &
DELINQUENCY 32, 33 (1977).
20. /¿a t33-34.
21. Id
22. DEBORAH STONE, POLICY PARADOX: THE ART OF
POLITICAL DECISION MAKING 146
(3d ed. 2002).
23. Crime Reporting in the Age of Technology, CRIMINAL
JUSTICE INFO. SERVS. (Fed.
Bureau of Investigation, U.S. Dep't of Justice, Washington,
D.C), 2000, at 12.
24. See supra note 14 and accompanying text.
96 SAINT LOUIS UNIVERSITY PUBLIC LAW REVIEW [Vol.
XXXI1:93
deciding how to count to one.̂ ^ For example, if a car is
vandalized as part of a
series of auto vandalisms that all occurred within the same,
designated time
period, then that incident is counted as one occurrence of
vandalism, even if
twenty cars were involved.̂ *
The above example introduces the fourth challenge to numeric
objectivity—the inability to understand what a number means
66. unless the
context in which the number was produced is also provided.^'
Put another way,
this is the siren song of numbers. Numbers appear to be
objective and not
tainted by context. Moreover, with too much contextual
description, the
elegant efficiency of numeric description is lost. This is a
particular problem in
attempting to use numbers either to provide transparency or to
improve
performance through accountability.^' There is a well-known
aphorism that
attests to the need for context:
The Govemment are very keen on amassing statistics—they
collect them, add
them, raise them to the nth power, take the cube root and
prepare wonderful
diagrams. But you must never forget that every one of those
figures comes in
the first instance from chowly dar (village watchman), who just
puts down
what he damn pleases.
This nineteenth century British waming continues to be of
relevance in
assessing modem, twenty-first century police intelligence units
charged with
analyzing data for the constmction of actionable law
enforcement
interventions.^ ' In a recent study of British police intelligence
analysis units,
one analyst is quoted as saying, "the quota of information that
we work on is as
good as the officer puts on there. If you look at the standards of
67. the [officers']
reports, they're absolutely appalling. You know, and they've got
the house
number wrong, they've got the beat wrong."''̂ The respondent
goes on to note
that these mistakes result in the identification of false hot
spots—^places of
peak crime occurrences. The important point of this, however,
is that the
analysts make the best of the data they are given and report a
de-contextualized
version of an event (a series of numbers). As the authors note,
those numbers
fail to convey either the fluid nature of a criminal occurrence,
and, thus, some
25. FED. BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION, U.S. DEP'T OF
JUSTICE, UNIFORM CRIME REPORTING
HANDBOOK 12 (2004).
26. Id
27. See supra note 14 and accompanying text.
28. 5eeUchida, Bridgeforth & Wellford, .yt/pra note 14, at 25.
29. See Martin Innes et al., 'The Appliance of Science?' The
Theory and Practice of Crime
Intelligence Analysis, 45 BRIT. J. CRIMINOLOGY 50-52
(2005).
30. JosiAH STAMP, SOME ECONOMIC FACTORS OF
MODERN LIFE 258-59 (1929).
31. Innes et al., supra note 29, at 50-52.
32. Id
33. Id
68. 2012] THE NUMBERS DILEMMA . 97
of its underlying causes, or the interpretive work of the analyzer
who fills in
gaps in the data so that it becomes "sensical."^''
The inability to convey context exacerbates a fifth characteristic
of
numbers, the objectification of evaluative criteria—i.e.,
disguising judgment as
measurement.̂ ^ Deborah Stone gives a wonderful example of
this process:
"Paul Samuelson's best-selling (economic) textbook declared in
its 1970
edition that ftill-employment was about 3.5 percent
tmemployment; by the
time of its 1985 edition, the natural rate of tmemployment had
grown to around
6 percent."^*
Of course, today, the Obama administration would celebrate a 7
percent
tmemployment rate. The tendency of numbers to disguise a
judgment as a
measurement makes it difficult to hold the entities reporting the
numbers
accountable and to ensure organizational transparency.'"
Finally, as noted previously, the act of counting something
confers a status
on, or suggests the importance of, the thing counted.''̂
Therefore, both the
counter and the coimted react to the process of numbering.^'
Organizationally,
69. this refers to producing good numbers whether the entity is a
police agency
employing COMPSTAT or a school system participating in high
stakes testing.
The number becomes a goal in and of itself—separate from what
the number
represents. This unfortunately became the experience of the
NYPD over the
course of implementing COMPSTAT."" In a study by John
Etemo and Eli
Silverman, field commanders quickly leamed that they needed
to look good
(i.e. have good numbers) when presenting at COMPSTAT
meetings if they
wanted to avoid public humiliation.'" This resulted first in
commanders
spending inordinate amounts of time constmcting data charts,
rather than
actually implementing the crime control sfrategies that the
analysis might have
suggested.''̂ Secondly, there was a strong temptation to
manipulate the
numbers.''̂ Thus, to tmly understand what a number means, it is
necessary to
know about the organization that produces the number. It is to
this issue that
we now tum.
34. Id
35. See supra note 14 and accompanying text.
36. STONE, supra note 22, at 169.
37. Id at 176-77.
38. Id at 178.
39. Wat 187.
40. See John A. Etemo & Eli B. Silverman, The New York City
70. Police Department's
Compstat: Dream or Nightmare?, 8 INT'L J. OF POLICE SCI. &
MGMT. 218, 219-26 (2006).
41. /¿at223.
42. Id at 228.
43. Id at 227.
98 SAINT LOUIS UNIVERSITY PUBLIC LAW REVIEW [Vol.
XXX11:93
II. ORGANIZATIONAL DYNAMICS AND THE PROBLEM OF
REFORM
Daniel Kahneman, in a popular sutnmary of current brain
research,
suggests that there are, at least metaphorically, two systems that
control
thitiking.'*'* System one is intuitive, quick thinking, and bases
conclusions on
mental frames developed through past experience.'" These
fVames or beliefs
are the templates used to explain the world as someone
encounters it.'*̂ System
two is slower and engages in deliberative assessments of
information.'*'
However, system two responses require effort, and according to
Kahneman,
system two often lacks the requisite effort."^ Therefore, if
system one presents
an explanation that seems to make sense and accords with past
experience,
system two will accept the conclusions of system one without
ftirther analysis
71. and cntique.
This observation is parallel to an observation made by Herbert
Simon
about organizational decision-making. Decision-making in
organizations
does not involve analyzing all of the information available, but,
instead, is
represented by a process of "satisficing."" The decision-maker
uses mies of
thumb, that is, how this current situation is like a previous
situation and what
the appropriate response was in that previous situation.'^ The
use of analogous
situations to make decisions mirror what has been discovered by
brain
research—neither as individuals nor as members of
organizations do we
optimize our decision-making, picking the best of all possible
altematives.
Instead, we satisfice, picking the altemative that best seems to
fit, without
expending a great deal of energy to review—in a systematic
way—all other
possible choices.'^
Of course, this approach, both individually and
organizationally, has some
advantages.''* It conserves energy and allows for efficient
decision-making."
In most cases, such decision-making processes or standard
operating
44. DANIEL KAHNEMAN, THINKING, FASTAND SLOW 20
(2011).
72. 45. Id at 105.
46. / ¿a t 21-22.
47. /¿a t49 .
48. / ¿ a t31 .
49. Id. at 24.
50. KEVIN B. SMITH & CHRISTOPHER W. LARIMER, THE
PUBLIC POLICY THEORY PRIMER
54 (2009).
51. Id
52. Id at 52.
53. Id at 52-53.
54. See id. at 53.
55. / ¿ a t 54.
2012] THE NUMBERS DILEMMA 99
procedures result in the individual or the organization moving
forward to
accomplish the task at hand.̂ ^
The disadvantage of this course of action is that often
individuals and
organizations do not engage in an analytical process that would
prevent major
problems.̂ ^ Higher order analytical routines are most often
employed after the
CO
fact—what went wrong and why? Post-mortems sometimes
result in changed
ways of behaving, but these soon become standard operating
procedures and
73. satisficing once again becomes the preferred mode of decision-
making.^'
This suggests that changing the core activity of an organization
and its
routines of decision-making is very, very difficult. This may be
particularly
tme in the public sector, where assessing performance is
hindered by the lack
of a concrete product or outcome.* '̂ Performance criteria are
instead infiuenced
by political considerations, budgets, and the public
In this kind of decision environment, it makes sense to ask
whether any
particular decision is based on technical or institutional criteria.
A decision
based on technical criteria responds to a change in the outside
environment. '̂'
A new product or service is required to keep the organization
competitive.^"
Therefore, stmctures are designed or redesigned to efficiently
and effectively
meet this demand.̂ ^ The organization that successfully
navigates its
environment's technical demands is rewarded with more
resources.*^ Failure to
do so jeopardizes resources.̂ ^ When an organization employs
technical
decision processes, it is engaging in a more sophisticated and
analytical routine
than simply satisficing.*^
A decision based on institutional criteria is much closer to the
satisficing
model or the system one brain model.*' The criteria for judging
74. the success of
56. KEVIN B. SMITH & CHRISTOPHER W. LARIMER, THE
PUBLIC POLICY THEORY PRIMER
54 (2009).
57. See id. at 53; K. A. Arehibald, Three Views of the Expert's
Role in Policymaking:
Systems Analysis, Incrementalism, and the Clinical Approach, 1
POL'Y SCI. 73, 76, 82 (1970).
58. See Archibald, supra note 57, at 76.
59. Id
60. / ¿ a t 8 2 .
61. SMITH & LARIMER, supra note 50, at 114-15.
62. See id.
63. See Sidney G. Winter, The Satisficing Principle in
Capability Learning, 21 STRATEGIC
MGMT. J., 981,982(2000).
64. See id.
65. See id.
66. See id. at 983; James Willis et al.. Making Sense of
COMPSTAT: A Theory-Based
Analysis of Organizational Change in Three Police
Departments, 41 LAW & SOC'Y REV. 147,
150(2007).
67. See Winter, supra note 63, at 982.
68. W. at 983.
69. See Willis et al.,5«pra note 66, at 151.
75. 100 SAINT LOUIS UNIVERSITY PUBLIC LAW REVIEW
[Vol. XXXI1:93
the organization involve neither efficiency nor effectiveness.'"
The criteria
instead involve judging the legitimacy of the organization based
on cultural
beliefs about how an organization should look and act.''
Perceived legitimacy
rather than efficacy is what counts.'^ Organizations operating in
this kind of
decision climate gain recognition and resoiu-ces by: conforming
to cultural
beliefs and expectations about what it is they are supposed to
do; and by
becoming isomorphic with other institutions in their
environment that have
been rewarded for particular behaviors."
Research describing the adoption of COMPSTAT suggests that
the
adoption has been spurred primarily by institutional
considerations.''' The rapid
deployment of COMPSTAT mirrors an almost fadlike
acceptance of the
process rather than a careñil and analytical investigation of how
the process
might adopt to a particular local situation or what pros and cons
such adoption
might entail.'^
Change spurred by the dynamic of institutional isomorphism is
likely to be
superficial. Core technologies and procedures are unlikely to be
impacted."
76. This certainly seems to be the case with COMPSTAT.'̂
In a study of three police departments that had adopted
COMPSTAT,
James Willis and his colleagues concluded that COMPSTAT
simply raised
reactive policing strategies to new levels. Police would respond
quickly to a
spike in crime, producing what the authors called a "whack-a-
mole" effect.""
Contrary to the assumptions of careful plarming and the
development of long
term strategies, COMPSTAT simply encouraged business as
usual, only even
more so. Further, while commanders felt responsible for crime
in their
districts, there was very little communication to beat officers
conceming
COMPSTAT trends—with the result that officers' daily routines
were not
impacted by the analysis derived from the gathered data. '̂
70. Id
71. Id.
72. Matthew J. Giblin, Structural Elaboration and Institutional
Isomorphism: The Case of
Crime Analysis Units, 29 POLICING: INT'L J. POLICE
STRATEGIES & MGMT. 643, 645 (2006).
73. Id
74. Willis et al., supra note 66, at 161.
75. Eterno & Silverman, supra note 40, at 219.
76. Matthew J. Giblin & George W. Burruss, Developing a
Measurement Model of
77. Institutional Processes in Policing, 32 POLICING: INT'L J.
POLICE STRATEGIES & MGMT., 351,
355 (2009).
77. See id
78. See Willis et al. supra note 66, at 152, 174-75.
79. / ¿a t 174.
80. / ¿a t 175.
81. / ¿a t 164-65.
2012] THE NUMBERS DILEMMA 101
Other studies have suggested that COMPSTAT also increased
the gulf
between the command culture and the street cop culture.̂ ^ For
example, in
New York, commanders took credit for dips in the crime rate,
while passing
blame to subordinates if the crime rate spiked in an area.̂ ^
The concept of work culture is an important element in trying to
understand why organizational change in general, and change
toward more
accountability and transparency, in particular, is difficult to
achieve. '̂' In public
sector agencies, the organizational dynamics just described,
together with the
cultural dynamics of such organizations, make the likelihood of
fundamental
change even more remote.̂ ^ We ttim to the role of cultural
dynamics next.
78. III. THE CULTURES OF MODERN DAY POLICING
Our understanding of the cultural complexity of the modem
police agency
has come a long way from the studies of the 1970s, which
concentrated
primarily on the culture of the street officer.̂ * By the end of the
decade, it was
clear that police organizations had at least two distinct culttires:
a street cop
culture and a management culttire.̂ ^ Today, it is recognized
that there are
multiple cultures within police agencies consisting not only of
beat officers and
higher ranked managers—but civilian cultures which span a
fairly large
professional hierarchy from clerical support staff, through 911
call-takers and
dispatchers, to highly trained and credentialed personnel in such
vmits as
research and development, human resource management, and
forensics.̂ ^
Although not studied quite as intensively as the police
subcultures, these
other subcultures are beginning to receive more attention.^' In a
study this
Author conducted on police call-takers, it was evident their
work culture was
influenced by the stress and strains of being sfreet level
bureaucrats with too
82. Eterno & Silverman, supra note 40, at 222-23.
83. W. at 224.
84. Linda Smircich, Concepts of Culture and Organizational
Analysis, 28 ADMIN. SCI. Q.
79. 339,346(1983).
85. Peter J. Robertson & Sonal J. Senevir, Outcomes of Planned
Organizational Change in
the Public Sector: A Meta-Analytic Comparison to the Private
Sector, 55 PUB. ADMIN. REV. 547,
548(1995).
86. See JEROME SKOLNICK, JUSTICE WITHOUT TRIAL 57
(4th ed. 2011).
87. ELIZABETH REUSS-IANNI, TWO CULTURES OF
POLICING: STREET COPS AND
MANAGEMENT COPS 1 (1983).
88. David A. Sklansky, Not Your Father's Police Department:
Making Sense of the New
Demographics of Law Enforcement, 96 J. CRIM. L. &
CRIMINOLOGY 1209, 1209-10, 1229-30
(2006).
89. See, e.g., WESLEY G. SKOGAN & MEGAN A.
ALDERDEN, NAT'L. INST. OF JUSTICE, JOB
SATISFACTION AMONG CIVILIANS IN POLICING l (2011),
available at http://www.nationalpolice
research.org/job-satisfaction-among-civilia/.
102 SAINT LOUIS UNIVERSITY PUBLIC LAW REVIEW
[Vol. XXX1I:93
few resources to meet increasing demands.'" Many of the
80. sfrategies they
adopted were attempts to gain greater confrol over their work
situation while
still trying to meet the demands for service emanating from 911
calls." Chief
among the sfrategies they employed was attempting to fit a
caller's demand
into a pre-existing definition of a situation that permitted the
dispatch of a
car.'^ Call-takers would often prompt callers as to how to
appropriately frame
their request.'^ A key conclusion of this study was that police
agencies do not
respond directly to a situation, but instead respond to an
organizationally
projected frame that takes ambiguous information and forms it
into an
understandable pattem to which the agency can then respond in
a routine
fashion.'"
A similar conclusion was reached in a study conducted by this
Author and
a colleague focused on a police research and development
(R&D) unit.'^ The
source of the ambiguous information for this unit was demands
for data that
would help other organizational units within the department
make a decision
about a problematic situation.'* Interestingly, the problem-
solving sequence for
the R&D tmit did not start with an analysis of the problem they
were supposed
to research, but with an analysis of the political situation and
the agenda of the
person making the request." Once there was consensus on the
81. real agenda and
on a solution that would meet both political and practical
realities, "research"
OR
was conducted to support this solution. Often, the research
consisted of
calling other police R&D units to see what they suggested in
similar
circumstances." This closed system of information processing
allowed the
organization to do what it would normally do anyway.
"Research" simply
reinforced standard operating procedures.
More recent research on police research units reinforces these
initial
observations.'"^ Martin Itmes and his colleagues adopt the term
"bricolage" to
describe the tasks performed by crime analysts in two British
police
90. See James F. Gilsinan, They is Clowning Tough: 911 and
the Social Construction of
Reality, 27 CRIMINOLOGY 329, 332 (1989).
91. See id
92. Id at 332-33.
93. See id. at 340.
94. Id at 341.
95. See generally James F. Gilsinan & J.R. Valentine, Bending
Granite: Attempts to Change
the Management Perspective of American Criminologists and
Police Reformers, 15 J. POLICE
82. SCI. & ADMIN. 196(1987).
96. SeeW. at 197-98.
97. Wat 198-99.
98. See/'rf. atl99.
99. W. at 197.
100. / ¿ a t 202, 203.
101. James F. Gilsinan & J.R. Valentine, iwpra note'95, at 203.
(1987).
102. Innes et al., supra note 29, at 54-55.
2012] THE NUMBERS DILEMMA 103
agencies.'"^ Crime analysts work with what they are given and
take messy,
contingent, and incomplete data to constmct an objective,
scientific product.'°'*
They put together the bric-a-brac of what they receive from
field reports and
constmct a coherent pattem of events."" The gaps in data are
filled in by what
everybody knows to be "tme" about how criminals operate.'"^
The resulting
product is a reproduction of the world that allows the
department to enact its
environment, i.e. project an image of a situation that allows for
the carrying out
of standard operating procedures.""
While units that can contribute to transparency and
accountability do not
operate in ways that can easily achieve either characteristic,