Mobile Money Agent Networks

  Examining the NGO Sector’s Role
What is an Agent?
 A person or business that is contracted to facilitate transactions for users. The most important of
     these are cash-in and cash-out (deposits/withdrawals). Agents bridge the gap between
          traditional brick and mortar bank branches and potential down market clients.




                                                                        MNO
 Client




                                            Agent




Source: Sarah Rotman, “Branchless Banking 101” March 2012               Bank
Roles of an Agent
1) Promoting the product




                               2) Educating and Registering Costumers




3) Facilitating Transactions
Mobile Money Agent Hierarchy
                    (illustrative)




         “Super Agents”              Financial Institutions
                                         (e.g. MFIs)


                                              Large Merchants /
         “Agents”                           Specialized Companies



“Sub Agents”                                      Local Retailers /
                                                   Small Vendors
Who can be an Agent?
National Post Office (Super Agent)        Aggregator networks (Agent)




 Your local bookstore (sub-agent)    Your local convenience store (sub agent)
Agent Business Case
      Being an agent can help small merchants generate more
                  revenue for their local business




Source: CGAP: “Agent Management Toolkit” 2011
Agent Network Development:
The Mercy Corps Haiti Experience
Table of Contents
• Background & Context
   Funding
   Financial Inclusion
   Unique Operating Environment
• Haiti Case Study
   Strategy
   Approach
   Execution
   Lessons Learned
   Potential Roles for NGOs
Background & Context

• Funding – Sizable flows of donor funds
  in response to the earthquake; flexible
  funding for innovation
• Financial Inclusion – Core mission
  objective for Mercy Corps: enhancing
  market-driven financial inclusion among
  underserved communities
Background & Context

• Unique Operating Environment –
  Logistical/implementation challenges on
   the ground created an opportunity to
   explore alternative delivery channels
  Distinct context for mobile money
   integration : massive earthquake, no prior
   country office presence, staff “churn”, etc.
Haiti Case Study

• Strategy – a) Focus activities in regions
  that received large influxes of IDPs
  post-earthquake; b) Provide financial
  assistance via alternative delivery
  mechanisms c) flexible funding and a
  TA grant from USAID allowed us more
  room to experiment
Haiti Case Study



    Mercy Corps ERP
      Operations
Haiti Case Study
• Approach
  Which partners?
     Trilogy/Voila
     Proactive relationship development
  Which programs?
     Cash-for-work
     Unconditional cash transfers
     Food security (Kenbe-La)
  Which participants?
     Selecting beneficiaries and merchants
     Aligning program objectives with funding parameters
Haiti Case Study
• Kenbe-La Program Overview
  – Recurring conditional cash transfer program to
    alleviate food security concerns among
    vulnerable HHs
  – 9 month program that targeted 5 districts in St.
    Marc and 2 surrounding towns,
  – Engaged ~7,000 beneficiaries and ~100
    merchants; monthly disbursements = 1,618
    HTG (~40 USD)
  – Program parameters allowed for incubation of
    merchants from acceptance points to agents
Haiti Case Study
                  Bocozelle

                                Blockhaus
              Centre Ville



Mac Donald
Haiti Case Study

• Execution
  Mobilization & Sensitization
     • Airtime purchase/transfer as “the bridge” to mobile-$
  Mobile Money Training
     • Pictograms and simulation
  Disbursements
     • Who hits send, to whom, when, and for how much?
  Mobile Money Agent Training
     • Interactive exercises, explaining “buckets of money”
Haiti Case Study
  m-$
                  1. Cash-out                        2. Change in Liquidity
                                           m-$
Sub Agent                                Sub Agent
                                                                 • e-wallet balance
                              m-$ User                             increases
                   m-$

              2           1
                                                                 • Cash on-hand
                                                                   decreases

            3. Sub-Agent Rebalances                  4. Additional Cash-outs
                                           m-$
  m-$
                                  m-$    Sub Agent
Sub Agent
                                 Agent
                                                           m-$      m-$ User
                    m-$
              1                                       2           1
                          2
Blockhaus Vendor Profile:
       Lundy Myslande
Sex / Age:
 • Female / NA
Name of Business / Launch Date:
 • Rosie Boutique / 2009 (3 yrs)
Source of Start-up Capital & Plans for Business:
 • Source: Personal savings then small loan to grow her inventory
 • Plans: Increase her inventory; diversify products to include “brand
   name” items; purchase refrigerator to sell meats (poultry, beef)
Average cash sales pre-Kenbe La program (monthly):
 • ~$1,925 USD (~77,000 HTG)
Average T-Cash sales from Kenbe La clients (monthly):
 • ~$2,900 USD (~116,050 HTG)
Average number of Kenbe La clients (monthly):
 • 70
Centre Ville Vendor Profile:
         Alexis Moise
Sex / Age:
 • Male / 50
Name of Business / Launch Date:
 • Betabara Store / 2004 (8 yrs)
Source of Start-up Capital & Plans for Business:
 • Source: Personal savings
 • Plans: Increase the size of the store and offer an even wider selection of
   products
Average cash sales pre-Kenbe La program (monthly):
 • ~$6,750 USD (~270,000 HTG)
Average T-Cash sales from Kenbe La clients (monthly):
 • ~$18,420 USD (~737,035 HTG)
Average number of Kenbe La clients (monthly):
 • 302
Average Monthly T-Cash Sales in HTG
         (Dec ‘11 – Sep ’12)
300,000


250,000                                               248,056


           188,164    Avg = 190,621 (~$4,766 USD)                    199,026
200,000


150,000
                                127,240

100,000


 50,000


     -
          Bocozelle          Blockhaus              Centre Ville   Mac Donald
Perceived Disruption of Cash Sales
          due to T-Cash
                             Yes         No

      100%                                          100%
                                                                91%
                    83%            82%




              17%          18%
                                                           9%
 0%                                            0%

Bocozelle    Blockhaus    Centre Ville        Mac Donald   Overall
Time to Conduct T-Cash Transactions
      (Start vs. End of Program)
Sense of Preparedness to be a Mobile
    Money Agent Post Program
Haiti Case Study

• Lessons Learned
  – Agent Mobilization & Training
  – Integrating Mobile Money
  – External Partnership Management
Haiti Case Study

• Potential NGO Role(s)
  – Financier
  – Acquirer
  – Trainer
  – Service Promoter

Mobile Money Agent Network Development- Haiti

  • 1.
    Mobile Money AgentNetworks Examining the NGO Sector’s Role
  • 2.
    What is anAgent? A person or business that is contracted to facilitate transactions for users. The most important of these are cash-in and cash-out (deposits/withdrawals). Agents bridge the gap between traditional brick and mortar bank branches and potential down market clients. MNO Client Agent Source: Sarah Rotman, “Branchless Banking 101” March 2012 Bank
  • 3.
    Roles of anAgent 1) Promoting the product 2) Educating and Registering Costumers 3) Facilitating Transactions
  • 4.
    Mobile Money AgentHierarchy (illustrative) “Super Agents” Financial Institutions (e.g. MFIs) Large Merchants / “Agents” Specialized Companies “Sub Agents” Local Retailers / Small Vendors
  • 5.
    Who can bean Agent? National Post Office (Super Agent) Aggregator networks (Agent) Your local bookstore (sub-agent) Your local convenience store (sub agent)
  • 6.
    Agent Business Case Being an agent can help small merchants generate more revenue for their local business Source: CGAP: “Agent Management Toolkit” 2011
  • 7.
    Agent Network Development: TheMercy Corps Haiti Experience
  • 8.
    Table of Contents •Background & Context  Funding  Financial Inclusion  Unique Operating Environment • Haiti Case Study  Strategy  Approach  Execution  Lessons Learned  Potential Roles for NGOs
  • 9.
    Background & Context •Funding – Sizable flows of donor funds in response to the earthquake; flexible funding for innovation • Financial Inclusion – Core mission objective for Mercy Corps: enhancing market-driven financial inclusion among underserved communities
  • 10.
    Background & Context •Unique Operating Environment – Logistical/implementation challenges on the ground created an opportunity to explore alternative delivery channels Distinct context for mobile money integration : massive earthquake, no prior country office presence, staff “churn”, etc.
  • 11.
    Haiti Case Study •Strategy – a) Focus activities in regions that received large influxes of IDPs post-earthquake; b) Provide financial assistance via alternative delivery mechanisms c) flexible funding and a TA grant from USAID allowed us more room to experiment
  • 12.
    Haiti Case Study Mercy Corps ERP Operations
  • 13.
    Haiti Case Study •Approach Which partners?  Trilogy/Voila  Proactive relationship development Which programs?  Cash-for-work  Unconditional cash transfers  Food security (Kenbe-La) Which participants?  Selecting beneficiaries and merchants  Aligning program objectives with funding parameters
  • 14.
    Haiti Case Study •Kenbe-La Program Overview – Recurring conditional cash transfer program to alleviate food security concerns among vulnerable HHs – 9 month program that targeted 5 districts in St. Marc and 2 surrounding towns, – Engaged ~7,000 beneficiaries and ~100 merchants; monthly disbursements = 1,618 HTG (~40 USD) – Program parameters allowed for incubation of merchants from acceptance points to agents
  • 15.
    Haiti Case Study Bocozelle Blockhaus Centre Ville Mac Donald
  • 16.
    Haiti Case Study •Execution Mobilization & Sensitization • Airtime purchase/transfer as “the bridge” to mobile-$ Mobile Money Training • Pictograms and simulation Disbursements • Who hits send, to whom, when, and for how much? Mobile Money Agent Training • Interactive exercises, explaining “buckets of money”
  • 17.
    Haiti Case Study m-$ 1. Cash-out 2. Change in Liquidity m-$ Sub Agent Sub Agent • e-wallet balance m-$ User increases m-$ 2 1 • Cash on-hand decreases 3. Sub-Agent Rebalances 4. Additional Cash-outs m-$ m-$ m-$ Sub Agent Sub Agent Agent m-$ m-$ User m-$ 1 2 1 2
  • 18.
    Blockhaus Vendor Profile: Lundy Myslande Sex / Age: • Female / NA Name of Business / Launch Date: • Rosie Boutique / 2009 (3 yrs) Source of Start-up Capital & Plans for Business: • Source: Personal savings then small loan to grow her inventory • Plans: Increase her inventory; diversify products to include “brand name” items; purchase refrigerator to sell meats (poultry, beef) Average cash sales pre-Kenbe La program (monthly): • ~$1,925 USD (~77,000 HTG) Average T-Cash sales from Kenbe La clients (monthly): • ~$2,900 USD (~116,050 HTG) Average number of Kenbe La clients (monthly): • 70
  • 19.
    Centre Ville VendorProfile: Alexis Moise Sex / Age: • Male / 50 Name of Business / Launch Date: • Betabara Store / 2004 (8 yrs) Source of Start-up Capital & Plans for Business: • Source: Personal savings • Plans: Increase the size of the store and offer an even wider selection of products Average cash sales pre-Kenbe La program (monthly): • ~$6,750 USD (~270,000 HTG) Average T-Cash sales from Kenbe La clients (monthly): • ~$18,420 USD (~737,035 HTG) Average number of Kenbe La clients (monthly): • 302
  • 20.
    Average Monthly T-CashSales in HTG (Dec ‘11 – Sep ’12) 300,000 250,000 248,056 188,164 Avg = 190,621 (~$4,766 USD) 199,026 200,000 150,000 127,240 100,000 50,000 - Bocozelle Blockhaus Centre Ville Mac Donald
  • 21.
    Perceived Disruption ofCash Sales due to T-Cash Yes No 100% 100% 91% 83% 82% 17% 18% 9% 0% 0% Bocozelle Blockhaus Centre Ville Mac Donald Overall
  • 22.
    Time to ConductT-Cash Transactions (Start vs. End of Program)
  • 23.
    Sense of Preparednessto be a Mobile Money Agent Post Program
  • 24.
    Haiti Case Study •Lessons Learned – Agent Mobilization & Training – Integrating Mobile Money – External Partnership Management
  • 25.
    Haiti Case Study •Potential NGO Role(s) – Financier – Acquirer – Trainer – Service Promoter

Editor's Notes

  • #3 Highlight difference between an agent and merchant agents…
  • #7 Be honest and clear regarding how much actual income diversification