This document summarizes research on measuring the return on investment (ROI) of rural broadband investments in 5 counties in Minnesota. It discusses the methodology used, which included collecting existing data and holding community meetings. It provides examples of broadband's benefits according to local stakeholders. The numbers show populations and incomes rising in counties with broadband. ROI formulas calculate the annual economic benefits and increases in real estate values exceeding the public investments in each county. Broadband access was found to boost local economies and conclusions state that community adoption efforts can further increase ROI.
Updated Policy Brief: Cooperatives Bring Fiber Internet Access to Rural AmericaEd Dodds
ย
Originally published in 2017, our report, Cooperatives Fiberize Rural America: A Trusted Model for the Internet Era, focuses on cooperatives as a proven model for deploying fiber optic Internet access across the country. An update in the spring of 2019 included additional information about the rate co-ops are expanding Internet service, and now weโve updated it again, with a new map and personal stories from areas where co-ops have drastically impacted local life.
100713 GOSE Big Society presentation to Consortia Coordinators July 2010Mark Walker
ย
What is this Big Society stuff all about? Is it a smokescreen for Government cuts or a game-changing attempt to change the way our communities are run?
Vicky Westhorp of GOSE provided an excellent summary of what it's all about at a Capacitybuilders meeting of the Coordinators of ChangeUp Consortia in the south east. In other words people who work in the voluntary and community sector at a local level.
This presentation covers a lot of the background as well as the latest news and announcements.
Please use the comments space below the presentation to ask questions or add your thoughts about what is being proposed. I've offered to help moderate a discussion via this page, and/or via the email forum for the Coordinators [contact me for details]
Mark Walker
ICT Champion for the third sector in south east England
Challenges To Womenโs Access To Natural ResourcesGilbert Makore
ย
Presentation i did at a National Women and Land Conference organised by ActionAid Zimbabwe and the Women\'s Coalition. Looks the legal, policy and institutional challenges limiting women\'s access to natural resources including lan, mineral resources, water, forestry and forestry products
Introductory slides from the โParticipatory Budgetingโ workshop hosted by Alan Budge at We're Not In Westminster Any More on Saturday 7th February 2015. This event was for everyone who has something positive to say about local democracy and for anyone who is up for a challenge.
Much like the construction of broadband networks across municipality borders, community development efforts often rely upon collaborations between multiple local governments and other organizations to produce the best outcomes. This session will focus on best practices for regional collaboration around broadband and community development. This session will also highlight a success story about reaching universal broadband coverage in Grayson County, Virginia.
Adapting to future trends is not just about understanding what they are and their impacts. It is about who has the power to do something. This presentation was given to the RTPI / TPS Network Annual Conference in November 2019
Updated Policy Brief: Cooperatives Bring Fiber Internet Access to Rural AmericaEd Dodds
ย
Originally published in 2017, our report, Cooperatives Fiberize Rural America: A Trusted Model for the Internet Era, focuses on cooperatives as a proven model for deploying fiber optic Internet access across the country. An update in the spring of 2019 included additional information about the rate co-ops are expanding Internet service, and now weโve updated it again, with a new map and personal stories from areas where co-ops have drastically impacted local life.
100713 GOSE Big Society presentation to Consortia Coordinators July 2010Mark Walker
ย
What is this Big Society stuff all about? Is it a smokescreen for Government cuts or a game-changing attempt to change the way our communities are run?
Vicky Westhorp of GOSE provided an excellent summary of what it's all about at a Capacitybuilders meeting of the Coordinators of ChangeUp Consortia in the south east. In other words people who work in the voluntary and community sector at a local level.
This presentation covers a lot of the background as well as the latest news and announcements.
Please use the comments space below the presentation to ask questions or add your thoughts about what is being proposed. I've offered to help moderate a discussion via this page, and/or via the email forum for the Coordinators [contact me for details]
Mark Walker
ICT Champion for the third sector in south east England
Challenges To Womenโs Access To Natural ResourcesGilbert Makore
ย
Presentation i did at a National Women and Land Conference organised by ActionAid Zimbabwe and the Women\'s Coalition. Looks the legal, policy and institutional challenges limiting women\'s access to natural resources including lan, mineral resources, water, forestry and forestry products
Introductory slides from the โParticipatory Budgetingโ workshop hosted by Alan Budge at We're Not In Westminster Any More on Saturday 7th February 2015. This event was for everyone who has something positive to say about local democracy and for anyone who is up for a challenge.
Much like the construction of broadband networks across municipality borders, community development efforts often rely upon collaborations between multiple local governments and other organizations to produce the best outcomes. This session will focus on best practices for regional collaboration around broadband and community development. This session will also highlight a success story about reaching universal broadband coverage in Grayson County, Virginia.
Adapting to future trends is not just about understanding what they are and their impacts. It is about who has the power to do something. This presentation was given to the RTPI / TPS Network Annual Conference in November 2019
Tools, Resources & Strategies for Co-op Advocates
Advocating for co-ops can be challenging. Where do you start? Whom do you contact? What do you say?
In this complimentary webinar, co-produced by the National Cooperative Business Association (NCBA) and the Campaign for Cooperation, youโll get insights and strategies you can use immediately โ from contacting and engaging with elected officials and staff to following up for maximum effect. Participants will receive:
- A comprehensive overview of the advocacy process
- Talking points for discussing co-ops with legislators
- Insights into the National Cooperative Development Act and its impact on jobs and the economy
- A Public Policy Toolkit for the 2012 International Year of Cooperatives
- The opportunity to interact with experts
Moderator
- Peter Frank, Cooperation Works!
Presenters
- R.L. Condra, NCBA
- Amy Johnson, US Federation of Worker Cooperatives
- Andrew McLeod, Cooperation Works! Urban Circle
- Bob Noble, Philadelphia Area Cooperative Alliance
- Lisa Stolarski, NCBA
Who Should Participate?
- Cooperative developers, representatives and volunteers
- Members of community service organizations
- All who want to support the co-op movement
A presentation given to broadband leaders in Minnesota who might have an interest in coordinating efforts to bring federal stimulus funding to the state.
Blandin Foundation Project: an Application for Sustainable BroadbandAnn Treacy
ย
The Blandin Foundation talks about their ARRA broadband stimulus fund application to the TISP (Telecommunications and Information Society Policy) Forum
Where's the Broadband? Inter-County Coordinating Committee, 4.21.14WI Broadband
ย
Where's the Broadband?
Presentation by the Broadband & E-Commerce Education Center to the Inter-county Coordinating Committee, April 21,2014 Green Lake, WI
Green Lake Training Center
Adam Langley, senior research analyst at the Lincoln Institute of Land Policy, explores a potential role for nonprofit payments in lieu of taxes (PILOTs) in addressing fiscal stress and suggested that localities approach PILOTs in a collaborative way marked by respectful dialogue, careful use of terminology, and justification for PILOT requests.
Adam Langley of the Lincoln Institute of Land Policy surveys the landscape payments in lieu of taxes (PILOTs), payments made voluntarily by tax-exempt nonprofits as a substitute for property taxes, in New England.
"๐ฉ๐ฌ๐ฎ๐ผ๐ต ๐พ๐ฐ๐ป๐ฏ ๐ป๐ฑ ๐ฐ๐บ ๐ฏ๐จ๐ณ๐ญ ๐ซ๐ถ๐ต๐ฌ"
๐๐ ๐๐จ๐ฆ๐ฌ (๐๐ ๐๐จ๐ฆ๐ฆ๐ฎ๐ง๐ข๐๐๐ญ๐ข๐จ๐ง๐ฌ) is a professional event agency that includes experts in the event-organizing market in Vietnam, Korea, and ASEAN countries. We provide unlimited types of events from Music concerts, Fan meetings, and Culture festivals to Corporate events, Internal company events, Golf tournaments, MICE events, and Exhibitions.
๐๐ ๐๐จ๐ฆ๐ฌ provides unlimited package services including such as Event organizing, Event planning, Event production, Manpower, PR marketing, Design 2D/3D, VIP protocols, Interpreter agency, etc.
Sports events - Golf competitions/billiards competitions/company sports events: dynamic and challenging
โญ ๐ ๐๐๐ญ๐ฎ๐ซ๐๐ ๐ฉ๐ซ๐จ๐ฃ๐๐๐ญ๐ฌ:
โข 2024 BAEKHYUN [Lonsdaleite] IN HO CHI MINH
โข SUPER JUNIOR-L.S.S. THE SHOW : Th3ee Guys in HO CHI MINH
โขFreenBecky 1st Fan Meeting in Vietnam
โขCHILDREN ART EXHIBITION 2024: BEYOND BARRIERS
โข WOW K-Music Festival 2023
โข Winner [CROSS] Tour in HCM
โข Super Show 9 in HCM with Super Junior
โข HCMC - Gyeongsangbuk-do Culture and Tourism Festival
โข Korean Vietnam Partnership - Fair with LG
โข Korean President visits Samsung Electronics R&D Center
โข Vietnam Food Expo with Lotte Wellfood
"๐๐ฏ๐๐ซ๐ฒ ๐๐ฏ๐๐ง๐ญ ๐ข๐ฌ ๐ ๐ฌ๐ญ๐จ๐ซ๐ฒ, ๐ ๐ฌ๐ฉ๐๐๐ข๐๐ฅ ๐ฃ๐จ๐ฎ๐ซ๐ง๐๐ฒ. ๐๐ ๐๐ฅ๐ฐ๐๐ฒ๐ฌ ๐๐๐ฅ๐ข๐๐ฏ๐ ๐ญ๐ก๐๐ญ ๐ฌ๐ก๐จ๐ซ๐ญ๐ฅ๐ฒ ๐ฒ๐จ๐ฎ ๐ฐ๐ข๐ฅ๐ฅ ๐๐ ๐ ๐ฉ๐๐ซ๐ญ ๐จ๐ ๐จ๐ฎ๐ซ ๐ฌ๐ญ๐จ๐ซ๐ข๐๐ฌ."
Kseniya Leshchenko: Shared development support service model as the way to ma...Lviv Startup Club
ย
Kseniya Leshchenko: Shared development support service model as the way to make small projects with small budgets profitable for the company (UA)
Kyiv PMDay 2024 Summer
Website โ www.pmday.org
Youtube โ https://www.youtube.com/startuplviv
FB โ https://www.facebook.com/pmdayconference
Personal Brand Statement:
As an Army veteran dedicated to lifelong learning, I bring a disciplined, strategic mindset to my pursuits. I am constantly expanding my knowledge to innovate and lead effectively. My journey is driven by a commitment to excellence, and to make a meaningful impact in the world.
RMD24 | Retail media: hoe zet je dit in als je geen AH of Unilever bent? Heid...BBPMedia1
ย
Grote partijen zijn al een tijdje onderweg met retail media. Ondertussen worden in dit domein ook de kansen zichtbaar voor andere spelers in de markt. Maar met die kansen ontstaan ook vragen: Zelf retail media worden of erop adverteren? In welke fase van de funnel past het en hoe integreer je het in een mediaplan? Wat is nu precies het verschil met marketplaces en Programmatic ads? In dit half uur beslechten we de dilemma's en krijg je antwoorden op wanneer het voor jou tijd is om de volgende stap te zetten.
Tata Group Dials Taiwan for Its Chipmaking Ambition in Gujaratโs DholeraAvirahi City Dholera
ย
The Tata Group, a titan of Indian industry, is making waves with its advanced talks with Taiwanese chipmakers Powerchip Semiconductor Manufacturing Corporation (PSMC) and UMC Group. The goal? Establishing a cutting-edge semiconductor fabrication unit (fab) in Dholera, Gujarat. This isnโt just any project; itโs a potential game changer for Indiaโs chipmaking aspirations and a boon for investors seeking promisingย residential projects in dholera sir.
Visit : https://www.avirahi.com/blog/tata-group-dials-taiwan-for-its-chipmaking-ambition-in-gujarats-dholera/
Buy Verified PayPal Account | Buy Google 5 Star Reviewsusawebmarket
ย
Buy Verified PayPal Account
Looking to buy verified PayPal accounts? Discover 7 expert tips for safely purchasing a verified PayPal account in 2024. Ensure security and reliability for your transactions.
PayPal Services Features-
๐ข Email Access
๐ข Bank Added
๐ข Card Verified
๐ข Full SSN Provided
๐ข Phone Number Access
๐ข Driving License Copy
๐ข Fasted Delivery
Client Satisfaction is Our First priority. Our services is very appropriate to buy. We assume that the first-rate way to purchase our offerings is to order on the website. If you have any worry in our cooperation usually You can order us on Skype or Telegram.
24/7 Hours Reply/Please Contact
usawebmarketEmail: support@usawebmarket.com
Skype: usawebmarket
Telegram: @usawebmarket
WhatsApp: +1โช(218) 203-5951โฌ
USA WEB MARKET is the Best Verified PayPal, Payoneer, Cash App, Skrill, Neteller, Stripe Account and SEO, SMM Service provider.100%Satisfection granted.100% replacement Granted.
VAT Registration Outlined In UAE: Benefits and Requirementsuae taxgpt
ย
Vat Registration is a legal obligation for businesses meeting the threshold requirement, helping companies avoid fines and ramifications. Contact now!
https://viralsocialtrends.com/vat-registration-outlined-in-uae/
Attending a job Interview for B1 and B2 Englsih learnersErika906060
ย
It is a sample of an interview for a business english class for pre-intermediate and intermediate english students with emphasis on the speking ability.
Improving profitability for small businessBen Wann
ย
In this comprehensive presentation, we will explore strategies and practical tips for enhancing profitability in small businesses. Tailored to meet the unique challenges faced by small enterprises, this session covers various aspects that directly impact the bottom line. Attendees will learn how to optimize operational efficiency, manage expenses, and increase revenue through innovative marketing and customer engagement techniques.
RMD24 | Debunking the non-endemic revenue myth Marvin Vacquier Droop | First ...BBPMedia1
ย
Marvin neemt je in deze presentatie mee in de voordelen van non-endemic advertising op retail media netwerken. Hij brengt ook de uitdagingen in beeld die de markt op dit moment heeft op het gebied van retail media voor niet-leveranciers.
Retail media wordt gezien als het nieuwe advertising-medium en ook mediabureaus richten massaal retail media-afdelingen op. Merken die niet in de betreffende winkel liggen staan ook nog niet in de rij om op de retail media netwerken te adverteren. Marvin belicht de uitdagingen die er zijn om echt aansluiting te vinden op die markt van non-endemic advertising.
The world of search engine optimization (SEO) is buzzing with discussions after Google confirmed that around 2,500 leaked internal documents related to its Search feature are indeed authentic. The revelation has sparked significant concerns within the SEO community. The leaked documents were initially reported by SEO experts Rand Fishkin and Mike King, igniting widespread analysis and discourse. For More Info:- https://news.arihantwebtech.com/search-disrupted-googles-leaked-documents-rock-the-seo-world/
LA HUG - Video Testimonials with Chynna Morgan - June 2024Lital Barkan
ย
Have you ever heard that user-generated content or video testimonials can take your brand to the next level? We will explore how you can effectively use video testimonials to leverage and boost your sales, content strategy, and increase your CRM data.๐คฏ
We will dig deeper into:
1. How to capture video testimonials that convert from your audience ๐ฅ
2. How to leverage your testimonials to boost your sales ๐ฒ
3. How you can capture more CRM data to understand your audience better through video testimonials. ๐
LA HUG - Video Testimonials with Chynna Morgan - June 2024
ย
Measuring ROI of Rural Broadband Investments: Stories of Success in Five Rural Minnesota Counties
1. Measuring ROI of
Rural Broadband
Investments: in 5
Rural Minnesota
Counties
Ann Treacy & Bill Coleman
2. โข Blandin Foundation for
community capacity building and
engagement
โข Office of Broadband Development
for coordination of public
investments
โข State broadband goals and task
force โ in Legislation
โข Role of cooperatives
MNโs Unique Broadband Environment
3. 1. What does a connected rural
community look like?
2. What are the providers and
communities doing right?
3. What is the community ROI
on public investments?
Research questions
4. Methodology
โข Collect and analyze existing data from 5 communities
โข Look at ROI formulas
โข Hold community meetings/interviews with key
interlocutors
5. Beltrami/Bemidji โ Hip and Happening
Provider โ Paul
Bunyan
Fiber (Gig)
DSL (50/40)
Community Partners
Bemidji Leads and
Greater Bemidji
6. Crow Wing/Brainerd โ Work Hard, Play Hard
Provider โ CTC
Fiber (Gig)
DSL (50/1.5)
Community Partners
Brainerd Lakes Chamber
of Commerce, Brainerd
Lakes Area EDC
(BLAEDC), Schools
7. Goodhue/Red Wing โ Hotbed of Entrepreneurs
Provider โ HBC
Fiber (Gig)
Fixed Wireless (40/40)
Community Partners
Red Wing Ignite
8. Lake โ Remote but Global
Provider โ Lake
Connections
Fiber (Gig)
Community Partners
County Commissioners,
Lake County
10. โI get two questions: do you have the โI get two questions: do you
have the people we need to succeed here; the second do we
have the broadband.โ - Economic Developer
11. โBusiness involvement is key in any successful economic
development program.โ โ Economic Developer
12. โโฆthat [new location in same town] coupled with
online marketing, weโve grown 400% over my dadโs
record year.โ โ Business owner
13. โAs we work with commercial real estate agents, they
tell us thatโs a leading question โ is fiber available at
that location?โ โ Broadband provider
14. โHaving good internet makes everything move more
smoothlyโฆ bill payโฆaccounting โฆ camera feeds in
our hog sitesโฆโ - Farmer
15. โWe use drones to do investigating โฆ into the jungle
[Puerto Rico] instead of sending employees.โ โ Xcel
Energy
16. โBroadband helps efficiency by allowing us to do things
at such a rapid pace. Before โฆyouโd sit and wait for
things.โ โ Winthrop News
17. โPatients can easily be 200 miles from the
nearest health facilityโฆ the patient portal
โฆ is tremendously convenient.โ โ
Healthcare
20. Beltrami โ Census Stats
โข 2016 Population up 3.7% (2010)
โ The statewide average was 4.1
โ Similar counties have seen decline
โข 2015 Median Income is $44,757
โ Compared $40,700 for similar
โข Beltramiโs DDI is the second best
out of the counties
22. ROI Details
County Public Investment Annual
Econ Benefit*
Real Estate
Increase*
Beltrami $1,432,000 $38,631700 $102,593,266
Crow Wing $15,123,450 $67,412,150 $214,662,149
Goodhue $542,262 $32,774,600 $104,825,572
Lake $83,418,170 $13,695,550 $38,547,421
Sibley $9,850,011 $8,604,350 $20,162,085
โข Annual economic benefit - $1850/household x HH
served
โข Community real estate increase โ 3% increase of market
(median value x HH served)
23. โข Public costs?
โ Minnesota Super Bowl Host
Committee (nonprofit) $60M
โ Stadium (taxpayer) $500M
โ Tax savings, free parking,
closed public transportโฆ
โข ROI?
โ Rockport Analytics estimated
$338M
โ Sports economist Victor
Matheson suspects $30M to
$130M
Just to compare
24. โข Two keys to economic benefit โ access and adoption
โข The community benefits from broadband quickly; the
providerโs ROI may not be as โtimelyโ
โข Public funding shortens ROI for the provider
โข Adoption efforts increases ROI for community
โข Access the report
Conclusions
25. Thank you!
โข Bill Coleman
Community Technology Advisors
bill@communitytechnologyadvisors.com
www.communitytechnologyadvisors.com
Ann Treacy
Treacy Information Services
atreacy@treacyinfo.com
treacyinfo.com - blandinonbroadband.org
Editor's Notes
Area of extremes
Provider - Paul Bunyan Communication (Cooperative)
Voted Bemidji their Best City by Minnesota Monthly
Recently wooed Delta Dental (150 jobs!)
Beltrami Stats
Youngest population of the cohort
Highest level of education
Highest population of Indigenous
Smallest population of White (73%)
Greatest percentage in poverty
Greatest growth percentage since 2012
Highest number of housing building permits, despite being third largest county
Whatโs happening
Bemidji State University
Gaming Championship
GigaZone
Minnesota Innovation Institute
Launchpad
Growing Art Scene
County partner role - Been meeting for 15 years to plan from the Future. Broadband was key. They still meet regularly.
Lots of tourism, but big enough to need other industries
Crow Wing Stats
Largest population
Greatest population density
Second highest median home value
Tourism location but big enough to have other industries
Whatโs happening?
Concerted focus on shifting to tech industry after closure of Potlatch
Community Tech Recruiter position created
Schools offering tech training
Seasonal homes are becoming year-round residents
Attracting people who can work anywhere
Hackfest to convene techies
County partner role - Held a conference of leaders in 1999. In 2001, the school took the lead to getting broadband. Joined BBC.
Goodhue Stats
Highest median income
Highest median home value
Closest to Twin Cities
Whatโs happening?
Red Wing Ignite
Bringing โcoolโ events to Red Wing such as hackfest and the MN Ignite Cup
Promoting innovation and entrepreneurs in schools
Programs to support existing entrepreneurs
County partner role - Founded in 2013 through local foundations and the City to support better broadband use. Joined BBC.
Lake Stats
Lowest population (and pop density)
Largest percentage of population over 65
Smallest percentage of population under 18
Second largest land area
Most remote, although proximity to Duluth
Whatโs happening?
Attracting people who can work anywhere
Extending vacations
Making area away from the lake attractive
Creating intergenerational interaction
Dealing with haves/have-nots in the school
County partner role - Stimulated with ARRA funds in 2010. Founded to bring better broadband. Joined BBC to spur adoption.
Sibley Stats
Second highest median income
Second lowest population
Highest population of foreign born (4.6%)
Lowest percentage of college degrees
Smallest number of building permits
Whatโs happening?
Broadband is still new โ but receiving a lot of attention for the approach
Saved the newspaper and found a way to reach millennials
Attracted a medical school (to open in 2018)
County partner role - Started in 2015 โ after 10 years of striving for broadband. Joined BBC to spur adoption.
Our challenge was to try to quantify some of the success that weโre seeing. Like website stats โ we have to balance quantitative and qualitative. AND unlike website site we need to recognize that the stat lag behind reality.
First โ itโs helpful to look at progress over time to help determine where these counties are in the process.
One problem with broadband mapping is changing definitions
Another problem with broadband mapping is reliability
The problem with census data is that it lags behind broadband updates
2016 Populationย (46,101) is up 3.7 percent from 2010.ย
The statewide average was 4.1
Town/Rural counties as a group have seen a decline
2015 Median Income is $44,757
Compares favorably to similar communities where median is $40,700.
Beltramiโs Digital Divide Index Scoreย is the second best out of the counties we are tracking