Laporan Hasil Penelitian Putusan Hakim Tentang Kasus Pembunuhan Berencana di Timika

1. ra

2. tuLshidrbidj&tu@iiturFBiy4ft dobi!*bjh
a N@n !*E Fe rtjdFEiei I
B. Dirtur tu i!+'[h Mrnft Ek
46dih3dr@Nlgi,fuMt
cfuc4bnenrfuF,4lfu
DftenPulE@Ffuifur
E $dlehjdircbddni
r adi NldiE s B. (3e kb,
, tuFb,s.s oribtued)
3. (,!$k@sBortuA@b)

4. erdl6c!iPfu
,64RfffuMrh|4bh@Mini]4r@
rdMtuiu vl!@86o:m&8r d!@r.'tme!'!4 d&
a@d,F6hi!h!4J@ru:@ov.fu,rl,lwM"[x,
EEd,T.!u@FqM6ib!!dddend&hFdfu6g!@[6fue
kbyLF Eiq, EtuhB!@ de
eldu r6d erub sd rd h6
p 6€6ls Ns6Dr (FN) ri! O@ $n P@ M@. (oPM), hp4 kri

5. EB E n FrFd 4r neBer nh rd&p
sipn E* edu4 i Ni Ftr, &qd n@n disis, dipi hhu etunu
hiiP4glin3pM]oPMklly(yjtr
ri &fin 4i F. Mn6 h&d ,0 msEr eisi FruD, kF& roteft annh r
ui &ojBr qij!tu ssr eikd i0 ruwei bd Ftu. &! GF& EDi lb r Di
*trn! 4ini* Mdss &nb, x hh FI
&3 M Fdlju LdF4 kvdi
TlnegNo6Fikddkli*hm!hfu
e&s' hsn*, uhi robDq &n nr

6. ngng.mNhcrumhv!!dhntr
DeihE, hn&r ei s l.ciun
unF4K'!D!neujuhiLo rseFPh
r no6 Fdt Ddhdi iahi rlh r
denhr $hij!bF, rddbr tuftiitu
IItfthi!ehi^hi46kkb
dimkuddkihd{AcEyLF
@4 s au*e eij.d a/ 16[ Mn

7. RidqLri,IEtddindiNhdldw0lno0nobgddllb.
d!!n'&E'trhhhrF&kFnd
dDen@gFsiis((doheoD
ndih6IFwiLlDfis*pdkdm
$n. Dij{$ Mr6, ssr, di Mdss
&n d6 hrmr nehi hmD jahn

8. &bc ei &6 tuii! m{uj! rlmery
tui
^in
rE n{nq.rdq n@Dh snh,pij!ft Mn6. sn, &i Mos,
dd r$
'@r
!*qL[ uDtrnLr
&rojurE hdiG rdr Dup r{cr d4i im6 r@hq Dr! }d3
&bi8 dE rd ttu Eruju roesp
!d!d.pijdr Mn6. ssr, du Ma$6
bdx&]!Fc6€dldimb tru 6m6ry oH4{ irddr oqll),
ddbtriFhqspBedsnrE@
hh. siinr .6di s( k&hnr
,6eLni hh Fe ktslr b! e! b@ ev ii e$ 34 e b3ih

9. o'sDB&nsnra.pdlfuosh
s,4!d F b!u. itls ene d ndi n
,h]ir4i.kundLd4&Pibi
kl[khhkrdiF[nB!e

10. khiFahglDorbe,mTd
FjrE krcD dr@ r6uhi kdr
@ish ejldi b.4 hka eD d@F ehn ter uNk dip@uui
!0 KUn F ker $ 0) b1 (uHP, eb
mHp D*ratrtr tunxi cixumhhur$(r)E I ruHP
dlnLi u @e e[ F4
insEpdaldbuhihlilo
P srini P@PM kly (v t ,s Fd G nh, idf4 D@'r nhi
e@, n@r dies4, mpi btr! rM

11. Y,ruKql(dLmP&0tei$[)
hdhTdelnoe@iaNi'qd
* bbu, _kni ru! km hD( ilhi
Fepd!dFiidhPeglimTPNfuly(v!
naiayi, .Y! bFa jus Frk thj jdi kmu !to! qr, $Lijuhts
nortuiu de@ n4Ds4hbah&d!$ Dodbi loun&@ k!
sLD{itlh,gru'bMyri&bil6drhJ!6zeqkwDb|t@&
di hngrm! m kll} ({d* qtor E@h!tun jlh Fre+( jdi k6u
bb4 emr rq&M v meDj,vd, "Y
@6{!br,sll,!ti,nirr
3orc4,&itqte&IgerliAiooiukfl
ddsbki ur F4 liqE !4 ditui rqekN, M.
4h @r I & &i kq 5 eD3L!3
Lly(vd]tfuitsn*{hF&
rqdLu 1 rn &!jsu 4ijc,i Mr6 &dhr ,0 D.sar &isi Fro, t+&
reene si r ui senld +r ioi s

12. si hsi'iL e6 mir@ d&iein
&IEhsx!l*,n{&.4ihkjn!&
e @! jlhD rifrlb rlnhsFn Fq
.&$.iFindKdlyRdP4liE
sibF!k,@futq]$pd'Tdj
drd !&sh ndi pii mdih! nhr
&i&i!hF rcdkEi oeDbr 6,tuu r+6

13. e&u od*vl r!!]m! kt'! eD tui ain) m[ b !k b44r jabi nib d
rinib neoj! rokepua Fq
dlmdihokhRir'LFisPjde4m
e-sirutr&mE4 e@E[n Enr + id !v'6 rs' d v@tr di
&@ I@q L@N4 u ri, &d aDi rim , No!j! ,!n&sprD Fc
DtryB3,cdhh.UhBh3}q*

14. .lB@!4R]ymdF4&neijndj
&Piqsq&uis((dohgnl
Edlhhllcdlgi5F&Ldl
idlhDu]drhqsDB&iRsPT
F!. huD G &4r Fchi Fh! tuir n'4o hli
vni},@'sPB&iBnl@pd
loljl}ostbinlhhh}!,qikei
s r. sioj!1rin F4 triyekbh

15. diePhbEodbnedlu&{6gt@lF&6biNtn6!dfuFl
dirhqspB&iRsnr@
Fiiesh4Lh r i4etr
6 &e$i [r Fire hrq Lh[ 5 n
wMM@:6@rn ds5c

16. d& D. wdnh. sPB 6 B r k
Ffuufu!i&6ndfuFlhko&kFdMefug!b6n,x]
eM eLtuh ddpd@ kjebi Fttun tu! tu @dF
.kdErdhdtdtur
ehnreuqMnr&nFiidT.lietM!dl@,Mi3d!,3h
&j!nh5{qbhi6edl4nenhtuF&otudiFutu&hE
Ad@, dhb@i 0idt h6n dh Eeeiffii
dtpifuy0gbh6
kd lojo hd $ 0) cl RUm
todr!jotuer$0)6ix@
kb 3 " i tu5rrsioP,ar$b:(u0
de hk turuhdrarttrdr, nik Mnb ffi & o@Fh&ncbn

17. : Mrb!@i Psd x0 h Psd $ o) rlr {uP.
e,dreN'uh6 eNuned qrD ji,! dr3 h4
r tuiFi lonii &i dtuD6 trb &hd!,
r Mmor4bijrM o6q bh.
hnishF,dde0n!9IUfui3
o']!hF&r'iFqDsiTedfiaAdo
G!&i*b,hbhineojrqb r ,&r d!@bilq k,, tu bp, ed
pkfl n NnjNunimoBrylii6*d4dFF hoq &, &! Gi3r{

18. uneMmNmq6nid.d4dD4d
djdi diF6ru@D 5tu tuo+ hi4usi!v!6
M{imeq tdu &de,h Ftuh@
Lhsrt4@lleltllnsalltqltt iL!!L
a{@ Fsjri Enu &ru ve'44 w, IGhr,{ (Mrr) dh hoedh
tq&i@i!'*e$i tro @ we,,i! ftisrrdki ei n4edll
Mtubmr Mdn eFdFi *ituirEer *oi &i &FtdiPbi &hei
&$e&. (Eajlhtutr rqik4rjs) l
rum Fid htur kei4j@ Fq
b rm!$r ruliiki s4rn seei
rljvn topt bi @srq4 rlnburqa de, &roF En i, tqbrb6n
n!n!4deki&dee$iDduhlndaMtui6d hd
ho5&FlenFijbqr-oh
kji,Di y&g nuugrr*m utor
kP*i (R , Mrd D@) tsd n khd &4m !&ry! 6rd F4 rruqr4

19. mrcfudlhB€Utr4iN4q
n4s* nbi r4e@n rinfi,
h&rokr 6iri E* F&uq u!p, Fh edn,eD disi@, &'Pl hh!
nFItsFdfuhbEhihl3]ihl
&sFn4F&phFhkW|F]!d
!&iB{IFdT!d*qIuFdI
&ik'oni9a&d!iFlufu,&,
L@EijAihl6ieq&aF}GMq

20. n M+y, EliG kd]! d6 Mdq
Mom,6!d" &iiurk rPM bnrqbri kpi4Nju tu@hdti
r@eotsod@ilqJoui.hnr!4
mn! 6 ldhgbF rD& &tu E@
tu b@r ,, r, dr 2e A@6u ro rde 6E rdkv! r odnor
hh!), rdhr tr { sdM
^ryriu),
TinbgFq$pil*&q*iiDihtsl
ib 626r nLn tuih roes!
oBd[esiFn.ihqtu
]T&&fuEhqqrnenib6d,
th@r di F r lmn qul &rjEFj@ tu !6ybphn n!km! tuslo
TNE&fui,eikifu14Bi4.ssc
inkh jd sn6 blBmr hh, M!
hldsi niuju s& o6 rmhsFo ,4 suFi ei* F6i r s wr

21. iE!6h 6d aryob N, r,F
ereilhla rd,{P!
^!mm
etui I
djndikerid@nmrkdsNlh
tsEneb! kn h erck (r!d[!!, runle Ahi di En] ain) D*
Mijhe{hh9lM4bikh4$
hneq 0r r{ di rn6 r6ib ftNju rqlb+E
r!@ ilru &d d riDib ssuiu
rini6 n6uju r4$4Du 14

22. DkD sjib qi joi M !6, ss r,
Dn j,h dd !s inu i6qu
bn @uo
'4ir,
dhmrd nh
Ffufu,!dkqeeldiekn&@
rnsq,rh rq rchrFnj4 du pd
biiwiFs@nqlrfuubri+&
Ftue@ rFh dnbs, Mjc'*
DL lt!!-!&4!!sr!!!l!3-Dski
.MdEe4eMFEnebF4dilh

23. :m,yDsdibidudiddabl4iddD!wi'!ib,spE&RsPT
+lL&i&d!4no}&*u
tt.LfitsdkD9ik}dudihl*4
oei r&6r dn4 n& Mrir !

24. kinb4b*wrdbEnklNrinqhjdei6FL
hnruHPFasEi@yi"di*!n&hsrELhdd
I sm'ii. mb Mrnh eEo&Fi &@tr rPU w abi
MsihEi3 hiw! ud4 ldq tur neri
"d ,e,r db kjel, tu k+dotu! Fd smh h!tum hh Ftu
Fqldli!d!661e!Fi@&
d+ i &!4t roh lier nnF nu4hi lNr rv hi. r&sibib':
MdquqeivtMo]ne4El&{knh!
rcBsr nh r.nhsNn
nrrylkr3ip efi Fo&k4 r&pD Nh &6h j4D dtsi@, ruli hh!

25. gbLimi&FiFiin]ieiP0glin
AsdmqA,gnkr(EI4(yJ&&iMc[f
ldh!IAsNskplMfuT!
rdkq r uin soja, 4 jd Mi6 ffi
ru4! Mi'i r 4i lijEb +i Fr ss r
bF&EniAiojulqlkry]FEMd
FEtrikg'ElitKslj]qe!Mdra
Moi, !64rd &. roik DM k@4 ki Kqi no!j! b4p!4 kldli
eoiab er !{tos}nN rd &tu Fdr
iD4e&m&@tr^eulhu

26. idutuhn jrh rr
rL o d nli rinrb rdk4Fn
r{r E$er s@i Finlh eldrnr
k+dhteT$@d,Td]
irssr di tsr sflbn 0dr &t.s F di
hiEinFgNsiqn{i.
b4bt ftruj! oit 4n3 rsusFn yq lsei eln Nd
'0
e vd
DdiBi ldp rinrh r€EesFn !q dFL

27. tsidrhD kndh n@h 1Tqd6. rr!@q hni, d{ Emi Ain) Drk
Lne4 dn4s dd !d nEtL iorju r6h
DiF6bebH,l.dheir
hLn, eD Eni Ain &qn nsi&irh8 nq$6bi einb 4ijdtr Mn6,
bmnh 6.!h rimh n uj!
rEib tuiuju r66&Pdr ys3
PGberliEoph6'P*rcnLFsPiqd&3'du3fuvlnos€e!&F
er Em ain d@si,44.n4rc m{ssDh mr6 4r jqu M h, ss 1,
Bn nh ed uh rinih no!j!
rEhr &$, nL5 seld e6a
,Ek(qlilqhliNhihqdn

28. AslA4eihtthiftlfuhikqr
furcbk[ldnjTtdkipdrrl@h@
Mdn&4MP'd!@i4u,rylllNrdqdbEbnd!ry.forui
d bt
'ro
db'e Fdr Fhb
!.Fd+duq(Ivi]4ikhhtroii,
Mojnh4hu&i4tldl6€hPt
6}s&q dLn P6d M io h&r $ tr) bn ruHP Fe drwi hsb
Ddnqn*!Mldukr&*'Tddky
M&.se! hsr sr o lo P.er $ 0) k r Kp.

29. Mflinb4ei$@ddkMd@"h4i+Jdluonus!d.q.
ud4 H*!f Peu dLi sn eir ,4 arn nda&n eb,!L Fkh
ritur Dd r dn &b]!L rEhr dFr diFturylldlvdh $r! pi r
roeD tu, iu rhh mojiv bnidryd€@&i(ew,&ibF,!d
uElr (rPU) EBudm iurdlkqdF
oeii DoB, nruoi n!@ryii i,r ehr
.rjd, dipeddi$n !d umN 6@qnqd

30. d&tsl6kF4etslcfuh4!6uI$6Fiedh]
Mdsq!dy!l|i&tFtnbhru
h &@r F4j! di dtusnr
Iie*:bdhN&llqPtbr{
(Ftu!s), i6 sti /pt, abu hb
F4 ddk iFl dik![ i6r
'j:

31. no@. d* qkp hgi mehhhi nhh &! Fhj&,, r * Lsi neDrkr
lnpdr he6 prlni ltbD lri
&i4ri@,n@!ue&tr u@mbu
M{jne4bilihdlafuiihlBtoishpdp6tside
AintrihoidtraD@ihfu:{fiN6NBlqPitkhLFseq,

32. si&nftrltu!4h'664! m
Mdjnh4hhv!kqrtdN!d!
kdqmkneEdrydbik'fuendiDd!
Fhi Fq &8 n.adu6iq Pioi
Mfu&4hNshFrTddudei6hdndi9id['nrb'd&p
h6h[fudiDd@n*kfud'
kimbq hilr ekrun ManB lBj!trMr pdD r*d4 r.d**4
r umr n4grnh roewur

33. n@!htsd@I@gkd!!
eN rqdhi dii bs.hmry ulu
!deiD!44ithtun@b
a&h6sD.Fh!j6iidd$eutr
s6dhF*n!Fifidh}Lit+&
iuF meh eLei &i rdiF jrii b
e, dibiuh k4d ,oddlr 5qr
T.ehihrudijiNhiplqsF4elinFjasF6uMI
rykitlui4ryrdi*uLit*
Mrjetr' $mFi Fe

34. r si& rljtutr w d &hn dd rcdb! &Fr dLb3(fu .Lsi
rljdrtrDtuiFiwd
dfibMun .eei eidr &i eidd dru.
4Pduhlld&lhibld@i,gry&64nIs.m.fuofr
,r+u D&r d dirdtu dln 6ryld kile Edn P& M
,'MH@ruliq@tiqsEsihnir
0@bhfuu!ndiE+6Fdri&@qfufu!E!Eqd
sE,s@ifu@oqdfuokiNlhF@dd46dfuddnI
.t@ddfuotitdfufuTttPl!@fugfuF

35. Fei cE6u hbm imyhdi
DluE@FurofoFdsiPfupb[b.44@iF&PBl!1
ble Ditu N dirnr &d ) AFtu

36. !,u 4bisF dbqi4
'd
Fdh d.
dr.6n donld! e;r h+i porM
oLh @dih Fq r4bb! Lbih,hgd !
i &rn kEfr& P.ir re7 0) pHAP
b@&nildlDegn&L4ahh
ebm BineiF hldt H*in wn@
n4iiLq*d Ia @ hh. dn d tuba
HdhbddeidihirtuFtu@n@ijlbiduBr6tuw
jd* Mn6 ssn, dq MN&i Peohh
rtu4 rh yq3 cM! Fi!4 &n eh hri !i thn a4sd' ,m, $rr
Tddv!fuF.tsiid&dfudim
FdEid0 obh Micri tu 14
'!{inbq ehe Mai.ri &FirFl &

37. k nelubi d^u diured "
Fdqb,ry eh surD bjiv&, F4
&fuL,n9qim4kryli@qL;,d
diFin&4b d M&Lb He dhi
n@Finb4r1i @srlEr rEhr, Mljrk Heh jus rih ih( e,
bili&r,{ncstrF]tNEh[t6ull
Dq{ kr tu Minh Hri, &Lh ryni
kddHdjh[grudqDi|re,aBlEEmuddilnPru&bnskB
(ehsb3j{6[biuhnh!!Fi
&ii,n6&@,,t!n{eiedll
sd4ti&trmrimeis!MldtrHl
ahninir0rrij@diie! ei
44uiuei d Fr!E's

38. &@i r4in er dreEe&i
td9bjhdddu&Ffrtaoidn6dielte
LP!s|d.$!dBHq}jE,sk!6{FhN
(Fddrsl E! -ri iPr, lnu rb "
h4bpdFdepi
(fuhN&tr,Pr6cnLF&sp]q,
q disBkn yiu lonh {ile,i
b@siD, Bdsk f FiFinFs, fud
s6'Di!na &!@ ini to0' &fr jls

39. Fijn kndni kjlrL H*ih n{ntoih w,r o!tu@) 'r!fu &qur
te dd kny (yj&, rs&ru d!!ii,ei ud h!tuer jqhn rq&s@r
eoi n@ iio@, mpi hhu henu N ho' hh rnhd "
turt i, amehi Frbu6i &h]*4 d4 eer N F,g &Boj!"
&rtdrtelmn'E]!hiwrh.Ek
drtt4ru'4nrgitilk&i3u6tdh
E{mF hr n! 4!enbr, &hie ,l@kl
aeF hbro hLtu du diF nd' !
"DesltoH*!nPm.!d[6iTdb,
Md u6nrFirn&4 Mijcr* kkin rrcbr dre Fq n{nd &sr
!dobmmlcrorydbtplki

40. orsi(w&40:tulrFhryqNddMnwro4MdiFtutu
ddi 6L @isdi nr@F l,Ilq ri&e el@i rord Fners
diffin tu ]Erui dittb ob bire ts&q b'pide dh@Dbi oh
D!9 &en tuiltm d! uL &mq e, ru djdh bF&
rdrtu dn@, dd.!bDn)!en iolJrrLrL8ir.dr{ d:i

41. 'rmi!€urPqd
re70)RUkP
:aLn.."Puarytrh,!1F4
dnu, &hD F,e1 F7 o) xutuP, dn8ts
d@! rtu F6dn$n &itu$ netrdsih kinph &in erutuh
uk, rPU Fs dijdibi kh&p
!tdiadfughEan..@'hi
dd!+tqidi|lmNNsbhs*|,.!d

42. Mhhi !@3 Bhll@ffii leer(FB!!@r) 6Fb Mrnb Hdn
E*|[14.nd!n*iDq!j6hv!d@ikl
Fid@ kiLd a3u3
ElIlsBi kdlr kjdt Hlhn dh mr F6 d &h {Eh