SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 15
Rape Culture – Issues,
methods, and counselling
implications
By Gia Lam
Rape Culture…?
“A complex of beliefs that encourages sexual aggression and
supports violence… It is a society where violence is seen as sexy and
sexuality as violent… It is a continuum of threatened violence that
ranges from sexual remarks to sexual touching to rape itself. A rape
culture condones physical and emotional terrorism… as the norm”
(as cited in Buchwald, 1993, viii)
The Controversy
Why it matters
 1/4 of women will be raped in their lifetime
 92% of sexual assault victims are female
 472,000 females reported having been sexually assaulted in 2009
 204,000 males reported having been sexually assaulted in 2009
 Sexual attacks account for 1 in 5 incidents
 9% of sexual assaults are reported to police
 5 % of reported sexual assaults result in criminal prosecution
(Brennan & Taylor-Butts, 2008; Fisher, et al., 2000; Statistics Canada, 2004, 2009)
Sexual Violence – forced
sexual acts
• Forcefully touching or
kissing someone
• Threatening someone to
engage in intercourse
• Physically forced vaginal,
oral, and anal penetration
(Abbey, 2002, p. 119; Yeater & O’Donahue, 1999)
 25% of female college students have been victims of sexual violence
 Adolescents are more likely to be victims of sexual violence
Rape Myths
“You were asking for it”
“You wanted the attention”
“But you said yes before”
“Shouldn’t have drank so much”
“Is it really rape though?”
“Prejudicial, stereotyped or
false beliefs about rape, rape
victims and rapists”
(as cited in Payne, Lonsway, & Fitzgerald, 1999, p. 28)
Victim Blaming
• Victim Blaming often occurs in the
Criminal Justice System
• Victims are interrogated and
often face blame, judgement
and disbelief
(Banyard, et al., 2004; Greeson, et al. 2015)
Stanford Rape Case
Stanford Rape
Case - Trial
Judge Aaron Persky sentenced Brock Allen Turner to
3 counts of felony:
1. Assault with intent to commit rape
2. Sexual penetration of an intoxicated
person
3. Sexual penetration of an unconscious
person
(Time, 2016; The Guardian, 2015, 2016; The Stanford Daily, 2016)
The maximum penalty was 14 years in prison.
Brock Allen Turner was sentenced to 6 months in prison.
“A prison sentence would have a severe impact on him. I
think he will not be a danger to others” – Aaron Persky
(CNN, 2016; New York times, 2016)
Rape Culture?
“That is a steep price to pay for 20 minutes of action” –
Dan A. Turner
“The night after it happened, he said he thought I liked it
because I rubbed his back. A back rub. Never mentioned me
voicing consent” – Victim Statement
“… find details about my personal life to use
against me ” – Victim Statement
“I was told because I couldn’t remember, I
technically could not prove it was
unwanted.” – Victim Statement
“I am no longer a swimmer, a student, a resident of California, or the
product of the work that I put into accomplish the goals that I set out
in the first nineteen years of my life.” – Brock Allen Turner in his
statement
Rape Culture?
“I am the sole proprietor of what happened on the night” –
Brock Allen Turner in his statement
(New York Times , 2016)
“They say: tell your judge he can go to hell, and
I hope his kids get raped and he rots in hell” –
Gary Goodman, Supervising attorney
The Purpose
To explore the socio-cultural phenomenon
of rape culture
• How can Rape Culture be brought to the foreground for
analysis?
• How can this foregrounding make the assumptions and
forces that perpetrate this culture available to the
counsellor who works with both perpetrators and victims of
this culture?
Methodology
Rape Myth Acceptance Scale
Date Rape Attitude Survey
Attitude Towards Rape Survey
(Payne, Lonsway, & Fitzgerald, 1999; McMahon & Farmer, 2011)
Methodological Issues
Rape Culture is persistent and normalized
Biases
Media
Public Opinion
Conflict between men’s rights groups verses feminists
Credibility, Transferability, Dependability, Confirmability
Counselling Implication &
Conclusion…?
Therapy is being “threatened with becoming the
servant of the surrounding culture rather than its
participant/observer and critic”
So where do we start?
(McWilliams, 2015)
Questions?

More Related Content

What's hot

Hall elizabeth unit nine project
Hall elizabeth unit nine projectHall elizabeth unit nine project
Hall elizabeth unit nine projectElizabeth Hall
 
Presentation. victimology
Presentation. victimologyPresentation. victimology
Presentation. victimologyAbu Bakkar
 
Unit 9 Hall Elizabeth Social Construction Essay
Unit 9 Hall Elizabeth Social Construction EssayUnit 9 Hall Elizabeth Social Construction Essay
Unit 9 Hall Elizabeth Social Construction EssayElizabeth Hall
 
Rape myths and beliefs.ppt
Rape myths and beliefs.pptRape myths and beliefs.ppt
Rape myths and beliefs.pptshreyansh pandey
 
Wrongful_Convections[1]
Wrongful_Convections[1]Wrongful_Convections[1]
Wrongful_Convections[1]Sam Brandt
 
Reaction Paper 2
Reaction Paper 2Reaction Paper 2
Reaction Paper 2Karl Sather
 
Learning Unit 7: Stalking and D.V.-CRJ 461
Learning Unit 7: Stalking and D.V.-CRJ 461Learning Unit 7: Stalking and D.V.-CRJ 461
Learning Unit 7: Stalking and D.V.-CRJ 461Bonnie Black
 
The grim sleeper nyree williams
The grim sleeper nyree williamsThe grim sleeper nyree williams
The grim sleeper nyree williamsNyreeWilliams
 
The Effect of Vehicle theft and hijacking - Dr Jaco Barkhuizen
The Effect of Vehicle theft and hijacking - Dr Jaco BarkhuizenThe Effect of Vehicle theft and hijacking - Dr Jaco Barkhuizen
The Effect of Vehicle theft and hijacking - Dr Jaco BarkhuizenTracker Connect
 
Anti death penalty, Zahir
Anti death penalty, ZahirAnti death penalty, Zahir
Anti death penalty, ZahirGP10
 
Stalking
StalkingStalking
Stalkingcitinfo
 
Rape Victims Are A Class Of Persons Often Defined By Gender Medical ...
Rape  Victims Are A  Class Of  Persons  Often  Defined  By  Gender  Medical  ...Rape  Victims Are A  Class Of  Persons  Often  Defined  By  Gender  Medical  ...
Rape Victims Are A Class Of Persons Often Defined By Gender Medical ...MedicalWhistleblower
 
Victimology and Survivor Studies
Victimology and Survivor StudiesVictimology and Survivor Studies
Victimology and Survivor StudiesCOHERE2012
 
Law Education Program Proposal
Law Education Program ProposalLaw Education Program Proposal
Law Education Program Proposallarryrgray
 
E2a2 signall and ostrove (1975) attractiveness
E2a2 signall and ostrove (1975) attractivenessE2a2 signall and ostrove (1975) attractiveness
E2a2 signall and ostrove (1975) attractivenessAarono1979
 
More Guns, Less Crime
More Guns, Less CrimeMore Guns, Less Crime
More Guns, Less Crimetwnicely
 
Handout: Talking to Men and Boys About Rape
Handout: Talking to Men and Boys About RapeHandout: Talking to Men and Boys About Rape
Handout: Talking to Men and Boys About RapeJulie Graber
 
E3a1 offender profiling
E3a1 offender profilingE3a1 offender profiling
E3a1 offender profilingAarono1979
 
Cultivation analysis
Cultivation analysisCultivation analysis
Cultivation analysisezmacbowl
 

What's hot (20)

Hall elizabeth unit nine project
Hall elizabeth unit nine projectHall elizabeth unit nine project
Hall elizabeth unit nine project
 
Presentation. victimology
Presentation. victimologyPresentation. victimology
Presentation. victimology
 
Unit 9 Hall Elizabeth Social Construction Essay
Unit 9 Hall Elizabeth Social Construction EssayUnit 9 Hall Elizabeth Social Construction Essay
Unit 9 Hall Elizabeth Social Construction Essay
 
Rape myths and beliefs.ppt
Rape myths and beliefs.pptRape myths and beliefs.ppt
Rape myths and beliefs.ppt
 
Wrongful_Convections[1]
Wrongful_Convections[1]Wrongful_Convections[1]
Wrongful_Convections[1]
 
Reaction Paper 2
Reaction Paper 2Reaction Paper 2
Reaction Paper 2
 
Learning Unit 7: Stalking and D.V.-CRJ 461
Learning Unit 7: Stalking and D.V.-CRJ 461Learning Unit 7: Stalking and D.V.-CRJ 461
Learning Unit 7: Stalking and D.V.-CRJ 461
 
The grim sleeper nyree williams
The grim sleeper nyree williamsThe grim sleeper nyree williams
The grim sleeper nyree williams
 
The Effect of Vehicle theft and hijacking - Dr Jaco Barkhuizen
The Effect of Vehicle theft and hijacking - Dr Jaco BarkhuizenThe Effect of Vehicle theft and hijacking - Dr Jaco Barkhuizen
The Effect of Vehicle theft and hijacking - Dr Jaco Barkhuizen
 
Anti death penalty, Zahir
Anti death penalty, ZahirAnti death penalty, Zahir
Anti death penalty, Zahir
 
Stalking
StalkingStalking
Stalking
 
Rape Victims Are A Class Of Persons Often Defined By Gender Medical ...
Rape  Victims Are A  Class Of  Persons  Often  Defined  By  Gender  Medical  ...Rape  Victims Are A  Class Of  Persons  Often  Defined  By  Gender  Medical  ...
Rape Victims Are A Class Of Persons Often Defined By Gender Medical ...
 
Victimology and Survivor Studies
Victimology and Survivor StudiesVictimology and Survivor Studies
Victimology and Survivor Studies
 
Grim Sleeper
Grim SleeperGrim Sleeper
Grim Sleeper
 
Law Education Program Proposal
Law Education Program ProposalLaw Education Program Proposal
Law Education Program Proposal
 
E2a2 signall and ostrove (1975) attractiveness
E2a2 signall and ostrove (1975) attractivenessE2a2 signall and ostrove (1975) attractiveness
E2a2 signall and ostrove (1975) attractiveness
 
More Guns, Less Crime
More Guns, Less CrimeMore Guns, Less Crime
More Guns, Less Crime
 
Handout: Talking to Men and Boys About Rape
Handout: Talking to Men and Boys About RapeHandout: Talking to Men and Boys About Rape
Handout: Talking to Men and Boys About Rape
 
E3a1 offender profiling
E3a1 offender profilingE3a1 offender profiling
E3a1 offender profiling
 
Cultivation analysis
Cultivation analysisCultivation analysis
Cultivation analysis
 

Similar to Lam_Presentation

Rape culture
Rape cultureRape culture
Rape cultureAM Oh
 
Rape culture and_media[1]
Rape culture and_media[1]Rape culture and_media[1]
Rape culture and_media[1]Karoline Khamis
 
Rape culture and_media[1]
Rape culture and_media[1]Rape culture and_media[1]
Rape culture and_media[1]Karoline Khamis
 
Sex Offender Sense - New Name Ministries
Sex Offender Sense - New Name MinistriesSex Offender Sense - New Name Ministries
Sex Offender Sense - New Name Ministriessoissues
 
Effects of sex in the media - a book chapter by Jackson and Barlett
Effects of sex in the media - a book chapter by Jackson and BarlettEffects of sex in the media - a book chapter by Jackson and Barlett
Effects of sex in the media - a book chapter by Jackson and BarlettXanat V. Meza
 
R A P E V I C T I M S A R E A C L A S S O F P E R S O N S O F T E N D...
R A P E  V I C T I M S  A R E  A  C L A S S  O F  P E R S O N S  O F T E N  D...R A P E  V I C T I M S  A R E  A  C L A S S  O F  P E R S O N S  O F T E N  D...
R A P E V I C T I M S A R E A C L A S S O F P E R S O N S O F T E N D...MedicalWhistleblower
 
Gender/LGBT Issues presentation update 2
Gender/LGBT Issues presentation update 2Gender/LGBT Issues presentation update 2
Gender/LGBT Issues presentation update 2RabbitHabits
 
Shade tree training media and pop culture 7 19 10
Shade tree training  media and pop culture 7 19 10Shade tree training  media and pop culture 7 19 10
Shade tree training media and pop culture 7 19 10Karoline Khamis
 
Contents lists available atScienceDirectAggression and Vio.docx
Contents lists available atScienceDirectAggression and Vio.docxContents lists available atScienceDirectAggression and Vio.docx
Contents lists available atScienceDirectAggression and Vio.docxdickonsondorris
 
Contents lists available atScienceDirectAggression and Vio.docx
Contents lists available atScienceDirectAggression and Vio.docxContents lists available atScienceDirectAggression and Vio.docx
Contents lists available atScienceDirectAggression and Vio.docxbobbywlane695641
 
What do we_know_about_sexual_abuse
What do we_know_about_sexual_abuseWhat do we_know_about_sexual_abuse
What do we_know_about_sexual_abuseKaterina Kolnogorova
 
Dominic Willmott at the 2019 re:shape #PreventSexualHarm conference
Dominic Willmott at the 2019 re:shape #PreventSexualHarm conferenceDominic Willmott at the 2019 re:shape #PreventSexualHarm conference
Dominic Willmott at the 2019 re:shape #PreventSexualHarm conferencere:shape
 
Sexual terrorism
Sexual terrorismSexual terrorism
Sexual terrorismAsra Qadeer
 
Domestic Violence PPT final
Domestic Violence PPT finalDomestic Violence PPT final
Domestic Violence PPT finalNishita Patolia
 
Group3 slides
Group3 slidesGroup3 slides
Group3 slidescowgiller
 
Chapter 12Elder Abuse VictimsCase ExampleM
Chapter 12Elder Abuse VictimsCase ExampleMChapter 12Elder Abuse VictimsCase ExampleM
Chapter 12Elder Abuse VictimsCase ExampleMEstelaJeffery653
 

Similar to Lam_Presentation (19)

Rape culture
Rape cultureRape culture
Rape culture
 
Rape culture and_media[1]
Rape culture and_media[1]Rape culture and_media[1]
Rape culture and_media[1]
 
Rape culture and_media[1]
Rape culture and_media[1]Rape culture and_media[1]
Rape culture and_media[1]
 
Hargitay100520
Hargitay100520Hargitay100520
Hargitay100520
 
Sex Offender Sense - New Name Ministries
Sex Offender Sense - New Name MinistriesSex Offender Sense - New Name Ministries
Sex Offender Sense - New Name Ministries
 
Effects of sex in the media - a book chapter by Jackson and Barlett
Effects of sex in the media - a book chapter by Jackson and BarlettEffects of sex in the media - a book chapter by Jackson and Barlett
Effects of sex in the media - a book chapter by Jackson and Barlett
 
A rape culture
A rape cultureA rape culture
A rape culture
 
De-mystifying Rape and Sexual Assault Encounters for Medical Interpreters
De-mystifying Rape and Sexual Assault Encounters for Medical InterpretersDe-mystifying Rape and Sexual Assault Encounters for Medical Interpreters
De-mystifying Rape and Sexual Assault Encounters for Medical Interpreters
 
R A P E V I C T I M S A R E A C L A S S O F P E R S O N S O F T E N D...
R A P E  V I C T I M S  A R E  A  C L A S S  O F  P E R S O N S  O F T E N  D...R A P E  V I C T I M S  A R E  A  C L A S S  O F  P E R S O N S  O F T E N  D...
R A P E V I C T I M S A R E A C L A S S O F P E R S O N S O F T E N D...
 
Gender/LGBT Issues presentation update 2
Gender/LGBT Issues presentation update 2Gender/LGBT Issues presentation update 2
Gender/LGBT Issues presentation update 2
 
Shade tree training media and pop culture 7 19 10
Shade tree training  media and pop culture 7 19 10Shade tree training  media and pop culture 7 19 10
Shade tree training media and pop culture 7 19 10
 
Contents lists available atScienceDirectAggression and Vio.docx
Contents lists available atScienceDirectAggression and Vio.docxContents lists available atScienceDirectAggression and Vio.docx
Contents lists available atScienceDirectAggression and Vio.docx
 
Contents lists available atScienceDirectAggression and Vio.docx
Contents lists available atScienceDirectAggression and Vio.docxContents lists available atScienceDirectAggression and Vio.docx
Contents lists available atScienceDirectAggression and Vio.docx
 
What do we_know_about_sexual_abuse
What do we_know_about_sexual_abuseWhat do we_know_about_sexual_abuse
What do we_know_about_sexual_abuse
 
Dominic Willmott at the 2019 re:shape #PreventSexualHarm conference
Dominic Willmott at the 2019 re:shape #PreventSexualHarm conferenceDominic Willmott at the 2019 re:shape #PreventSexualHarm conference
Dominic Willmott at the 2019 re:shape #PreventSexualHarm conference
 
Sexual terrorism
Sexual terrorismSexual terrorism
Sexual terrorism
 
Domestic Violence PPT final
Domestic Violence PPT finalDomestic Violence PPT final
Domestic Violence PPT final
 
Group3 slides
Group3 slidesGroup3 slides
Group3 slides
 
Chapter 12Elder Abuse VictimsCase ExampleM
Chapter 12Elder Abuse VictimsCase ExampleMChapter 12Elder Abuse VictimsCase ExampleM
Chapter 12Elder Abuse VictimsCase ExampleM
 

Lam_Presentation

  • 1. Rape Culture – Issues, methods, and counselling implications By Gia Lam
  • 2. Rape Culture…? “A complex of beliefs that encourages sexual aggression and supports violence… It is a society where violence is seen as sexy and sexuality as violent… It is a continuum of threatened violence that ranges from sexual remarks to sexual touching to rape itself. A rape culture condones physical and emotional terrorism… as the norm” (as cited in Buchwald, 1993, viii)
  • 4. Why it matters  1/4 of women will be raped in their lifetime  92% of sexual assault victims are female  472,000 females reported having been sexually assaulted in 2009  204,000 males reported having been sexually assaulted in 2009  Sexual attacks account for 1 in 5 incidents  9% of sexual assaults are reported to police  5 % of reported sexual assaults result in criminal prosecution (Brennan & Taylor-Butts, 2008; Fisher, et al., 2000; Statistics Canada, 2004, 2009)
  • 5. Sexual Violence – forced sexual acts • Forcefully touching or kissing someone • Threatening someone to engage in intercourse • Physically forced vaginal, oral, and anal penetration (Abbey, 2002, p. 119; Yeater & O’Donahue, 1999)  25% of female college students have been victims of sexual violence  Adolescents are more likely to be victims of sexual violence
  • 6. Rape Myths “You were asking for it” “You wanted the attention” “But you said yes before” “Shouldn’t have drank so much” “Is it really rape though?” “Prejudicial, stereotyped or false beliefs about rape, rape victims and rapists” (as cited in Payne, Lonsway, & Fitzgerald, 1999, p. 28) Victim Blaming • Victim Blaming often occurs in the Criminal Justice System • Victims are interrogated and often face blame, judgement and disbelief (Banyard, et al., 2004; Greeson, et al. 2015)
  • 8. Stanford Rape Case - Trial Judge Aaron Persky sentenced Brock Allen Turner to 3 counts of felony: 1. Assault with intent to commit rape 2. Sexual penetration of an intoxicated person 3. Sexual penetration of an unconscious person (Time, 2016; The Guardian, 2015, 2016; The Stanford Daily, 2016) The maximum penalty was 14 years in prison. Brock Allen Turner was sentenced to 6 months in prison.
  • 9. “A prison sentence would have a severe impact on him. I think he will not be a danger to others” – Aaron Persky (CNN, 2016; New York times, 2016) Rape Culture? “That is a steep price to pay for 20 minutes of action” – Dan A. Turner “The night after it happened, he said he thought I liked it because I rubbed his back. A back rub. Never mentioned me voicing consent” – Victim Statement “… find details about my personal life to use against me ” – Victim Statement “I was told because I couldn’t remember, I technically could not prove it was unwanted.” – Victim Statement
  • 10. “I am no longer a swimmer, a student, a resident of California, or the product of the work that I put into accomplish the goals that I set out in the first nineteen years of my life.” – Brock Allen Turner in his statement Rape Culture? “I am the sole proprietor of what happened on the night” – Brock Allen Turner in his statement (New York Times , 2016) “They say: tell your judge he can go to hell, and I hope his kids get raped and he rots in hell” – Gary Goodman, Supervising attorney
  • 11. The Purpose To explore the socio-cultural phenomenon of rape culture • How can Rape Culture be brought to the foreground for analysis? • How can this foregrounding make the assumptions and forces that perpetrate this culture available to the counsellor who works with both perpetrators and victims of this culture?
  • 12. Methodology Rape Myth Acceptance Scale Date Rape Attitude Survey Attitude Towards Rape Survey (Payne, Lonsway, & Fitzgerald, 1999; McMahon & Farmer, 2011)
  • 13. Methodological Issues Rape Culture is persistent and normalized Biases Media Public Opinion Conflict between men’s rights groups verses feminists Credibility, Transferability, Dependability, Confirmability
  • 14. Counselling Implication & Conclusion…? Therapy is being “threatened with becoming the servant of the surrounding culture rather than its participant/observer and critic” So where do we start? (McWilliams, 2015)

Editor's Notes

  1. https://georgilindsey.files.wordpress.com/2013/10/3sy1jl.jpg
  2. http://www.debate.org/opinions/does-rape-culture-exist http://time.com/30545/its-time-to-end-rape-culture-hysteria/
  3. http://www.statcan.gc.ca/pub/85f0033m/2008019/findings-resultats-eng.htm http://www.statcan.gc.ca/pub/85-002-x/2010002/article/11340/tbl/tbl4-eng.htm http://www.wavaw.ca/mythbusting/statistics/
  4. https://timedotcom.files.wordpress.com/2016/06/brock-turner2.jpg http://www.pedestrian.tv/images/article/2016/06/06/stanford-uni-619-386.jpg http://assets.nydailynews.com/polopoly_fs/1.2673175.1465915717!/img/httpImage/image.jpg_gen/derivatives/landscape_1200/stanford-swimmer-rape.jpg Lead lawmaker away from enacting appropriate legislation (Maxwell & Graham, 2014)
  5. http://cdn2-b.examiner.com/sites/default/files/styles/article_large/hash/c5/89/c589c809919768bf4b594172db1789d9.jpg?itok=7uRDHdCT
  6. http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/06/08/us/document-Defendantstatement.html http://www.newyorker.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/Suk-TheOutcomeoftheStanfordRapeCasePetitions-1200.jpg
  7. http://www.hhs.gov/ash/oah/oah-initiatives/paf/508-assets/conf-2011-herman-irma.pdf And of course you could interview certain populations on their attitudes towards rape. There have been a number of studies in which Law enforcers, police officers, and physicians are interviewed on their attitudes of rape.
  8. 4. Methodological issues: one challenge is how do we research a socio-cultural phenomenon that can be so pervasive that it is accepted as a norm? How do we bring this phenomenon forward enough that someone lost in it can suddenly see the reality? How do we account for biases in the content? If rape culture is subtle and pervasive, can we trust media reports? Can we trust the public opinion? How do we explore this without being sucked into a fight for our minds by two opposed sides (men's rights groups vs feminists?) How do we ensure that research criteria such as credibility, transferability, dependability and confirmability are honoured in this exploration?
  9. 5.The big "so what?" Counseling implications.... so what does this mean for me as a counsellor when I work with a woman who has experienced this, or more interestingly, how does this help when I am working with a man who denies this reality - like a male in a mandated violence treatment group? By educating ourselves and opening our minds to all possibilities – not just the possibilities given by society.