SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Sheeba Viswarajan,
Senior Lecturer, Cass School of Education
Does the new GCSE science curriculum
improve the effectiveness of practical work in
Key Stage 4 classes?
What is meant by ‘effectiveness
of practical work’?
Purpose of practical work?
domain of
objects and
observables
domain of
ideas
Practical work is the bridge between these two domains
Hands-on
Minds-on
http://toreto.co/chemistry-titration/ https://www.chronicle.com/article/Beyond-Critical-
Thinking/63288
Practical work: linking two domains (from Tiberghien, 2000)
What is ‘effectiveness’?
Task
specification
(what the pupils are
meant to do)
Teacher’s
objectives
(what the pupils are
meant to learn)
Classroom
activities
(what the pupils actually
do)
Learning
outcomes
(what the pupils actually
learn)
effectiveness
(1)
(2)
‘Effectiveness’,
relates to how
well the
objectives are
met.
Two-level model of effectiveness (adapted from Millar et al, 1999, p.37)
Effectiveness of a practical activity
Effective in the domain of
objects and
observables
in the domain of ideas
at level (1)
(While they carry out the
practical task)
What I want pupils to do in
the task..
Can they do this?
What concepts/ideas I
want pupils to think about
during the task….
Are they doing this?
at level (2)
(post-practical)
Can pupils later recall
what they did in the task?
Do they do this?
Do pupils later show
understanding of the ideas
the task meant to help
them learn…
Do they do this?
2x 2 effectiveness matrix
2x 2 effectiveness matrix :Analytical framework for considering the effectiveness of a
practical task (adapted from Abrahams and Millar, 2008, p.1949)
• Previous research findings(Abrahams &
Millar, 2008) have highlighted the
ineffectiveness of practical work in the
domain of ideas.
• The practical work that teachers opt to do
is influenced by the science curriculum
particularly by the method of assessment
of the practical work, as highlighted in the
studies on practical work (Abrahams and
Reiss, 2012) and in the assessment of
science education (Bernholt, Neumann
and Nentwig, 2012).
The new GCSE science curriculum has
removed the internal assessment of
practical work in the schools but the exam
papers will include 15% worth questions on
understanding of practical work in both
domains.
There are concerns..
• ..that schools will reduce funding for practical work
in school (Gatsby Charitable Foundation, the Nuffield
Foundation and the Wellcome Trust Consultation
Response, 2015).
• ..that students will be shown demonstrations or
watch videos of the practical at a fraction of the cost,
resulting in weaker manipulative skills gained by
students.
• ..that universities already struggle with the weak
practical skills of their first year students (Grant,
2011) and 39% of businesses say they had difficulty
in recruiting staff with good STEM skills (CBI, 2014).
On the other hand…
• It is possible that teachers may now have the
autonomy to re-evaluate their reasons for doing
practical work, moving away from the practice of
rehearsing practical work for highest marks
procurement.
• Learners require proficiency in domains of
observables as well as ideas therefore teachers
may be encouraged to deliver practical tasks
effectively in both domains.
The research questions guiding my study are:
• In the new GCSE science curriculum ,what strategies
do teachers use to develop effectiveness in the two
domains of practical work?
• In the new GCSE science curriculum, is the practical
work effective in achieving intended objectives in
domain of observables?
• In the new GCSE science curriculum, is the practical
work effective in achieving the intended objectives in
domain of ideas?
• How do science teachers view the changes to the
assessment policy on GCSE science practical work?
Research methods:
• Observations,
• Semi-structured interviews
• Focus group interviews.
The 10 benchmarks for good practical science
Initial findings
• More stress given for domain of ideas-
focus on exam style questions
• Lab books
• Retention and recall
• Revision
• Support- external and internal
• Equipment
• Funding
• Qualitative analysis
• Waiting period till exam
• Extended projects/investigations
References
Abrahams, I., and R. Millar. 2008. “Does Practical Work Really Work? A Study of the Effectiveness
of Practical Work as a Teaching and Learning Method in School Science.” International
Journal of Science Education 30 (14): 1945–1969.
Abrahams, I. and Reiss, M. J. (2012) Practical work: its effectiveness in primary and secondary
schools in England. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 49(8), 1035–1055.
CBI (2014). Gateway to growth CBI/Pearson education and skills survey 2014.
London: Pearson. Available at:
http://www.ucml.ac.uk/sites/default/files/shapingthefuture/101/gateway-to-growth.pdf [Accessed 7
Jan. 2017].
Gatsby Charitable Foundation (2017). Good practical science.
[online] London: Gatsby. Available at: https://www.gatsby.org.uk/education/programmes/support-
for-practical-science-in-schools [Accessed 6 Oct. 2017].
Gatsby Charitable Foundation, the Nuffield Foundation and the Wellcome Trust
CONSULTATION RESPONSE. (2015). GCSE Science: Consultation on Conditions and
Guidance. [online] Available at: https://wellcome.ac.uk/sites/default/files/wtp059205.pdf
[Accessed 11 May 2017].
Millar, R., J.-F. Le Maréchal, and A. Tiberghien. 1999. “‘Mapping’ the Domain: Varieties of
Practical Work.” In Practical Work in Science Education – Recent Research Studies, edited
by J. Leach and A. Paulsen, 33–59. Roskilde/Dordrecht: Roskilde University Press/
Kluwer.

More Related Content

Similar to ITE2019-Sheeba-Viswarajan.pptx

Making time for learning: managing student workload
Making time for learning: managing student workloadMaking time for learning: managing student workload
Making time for learning: managing student workload
Liz Norman
 
Adoption of generic skills in the process of teaching and learning in college...
Adoption of generic skills in the process of teaching and learning in college...Adoption of generic skills in the process of teaching and learning in college...
Adoption of generic skills in the process of teaching and learning in college...
Alexander Decker
 
EL7001-8
EL7001-8EL7001-8
EL7001-8
eckchela
 
Education Technology
Education TechnologyEducation Technology
Education Technology
Jane Dulos
 
TESTA, Presentation to the SDG Course Leaders, University of West of Scotlan...
 TESTA, Presentation to the SDG Course Leaders, University of West of Scotlan... TESTA, Presentation to the SDG Course Leaders, University of West of Scotlan...
TESTA, Presentation to the SDG Course Leaders, University of West of Scotlan...
TESTA winch
 
Presentation1
Presentation1Presentation1
Presentation1
shahidashadygani
 
The effect of project based learning model with kwl worksheet on student crea...
The effect of project based learning model with kwl worksheet on student crea...The effect of project based learning model with kwl worksheet on student crea...
The effect of project based learning model with kwl worksheet on student crea...
Alexander Decker
 
Cómo el aprendizaje inverso, el diseño adaptativo y la gamificación favorecen...
Cómo el aprendizaje inverso, el diseño adaptativo y la gamificación favorecen...Cómo el aprendizaje inverso, el diseño adaptativo y la gamificación favorecen...
Cómo el aprendizaje inverso, el diseño adaptativo y la gamificación favorecen...
Alfredo Prieto Martín
 
Stephen Phillips - Implementing an inquiry based approach into our school
Stephen Phillips - Implementing an inquiry based approach into our schoolStephen Phillips - Implementing an inquiry based approach into our school
Stephen Phillips - Implementing an inquiry based approach into our school
Sails-project
 
Trainee Teacher's Readiness Towards Teaching Practice: The Case of Malaysia
Trainee Teacher's Readiness Towards Teaching Practice: The Case of MalaysiaTrainee Teacher's Readiness Towards Teaching Practice: The Case of Malaysia
Trainee Teacher's Readiness Towards Teaching Practice: The Case of Malaysiaanisahtahir
 
Increasing Grade 9 Students TLE MPS using a Blended Approach with Manychat
Increasing Grade 9 Students TLE MPS using a Blended Approach with ManychatIncreasing Grade 9 Students TLE MPS using a Blended Approach with Manychat
Increasing Grade 9 Students TLE MPS using a Blended Approach with Manychat
ijtsrd
 
Pedagogy for Today's Professor - New Faculty Orientation
Pedagogy for Today's Professor - New Faculty OrientationPedagogy for Today's Professor - New Faculty Orientation
Pedagogy for Today's Professor - New Faculty Orientation
Learning Enhancement Center @ University of Southern Mississippi
 
Evidence of Success: A Review of Flipped Learning
Evidence of Success: A Review of Flipped LearningEvidence of Success: A Review of Flipped Learning
Evidence of Success: A Review of Flipped Learning
Rob Kadel
 
Metacognitive Strategies: Instructional Approaches in Teaching and Learning o...
Metacognitive Strategies: Instructional Approaches in Teaching and Learning o...Metacognitive Strategies: Instructional Approaches in Teaching and Learning o...
Metacognitive Strategies: Instructional Approaches in Teaching and Learning o...
IJAEMSJORNAL
 
Hambly brendan 0061096423_edr8802_task1parta
Hambly brendan 0061096423_edr8802_task1partaHambly brendan 0061096423_edr8802_task1parta
Hambly brendan 0061096423_edr8802_task1parta
Brendan Hambly
 
Flipped Classroom - Literature Review
Flipped Classroom - Literature ReviewFlipped Classroom - Literature Review
Flipped Classroom - Literature Review
Katie Jaehnke
 
Online Assignment
Online AssignmentOnline Assignment
Online Assignment
Arun Murali
 
EL7003-8 Assignment 1: Instructional Design and Engaging E-Learning Activities
EL7003-8 Assignment 1: Instructional Design and Engaging E-Learning ActivitiesEL7003-8 Assignment 1: Instructional Design and Engaging E-Learning Activities
EL7003-8 Assignment 1: Instructional Design and Engaging E-Learning Activities
eckchela
 
Enhancing Practical Knowledge
Enhancing Practical KnowledgeEnhancing Practical Knowledge
Enhancing Practical KnowledgeLinu George
 
Enhancing students' learning through blended learning for engineering mathema...
Enhancing students' learning through blended learning for engineering mathema...Enhancing students' learning through blended learning for engineering mathema...
Enhancing students' learning through blended learning for engineering mathema...
Dann Mallet
 

Similar to ITE2019-Sheeba-Viswarajan.pptx (20)

Making time for learning: managing student workload
Making time for learning: managing student workloadMaking time for learning: managing student workload
Making time for learning: managing student workload
 
Adoption of generic skills in the process of teaching and learning in college...
Adoption of generic skills in the process of teaching and learning in college...Adoption of generic skills in the process of teaching and learning in college...
Adoption of generic skills in the process of teaching and learning in college...
 
EL7001-8
EL7001-8EL7001-8
EL7001-8
 
Education Technology
Education TechnologyEducation Technology
Education Technology
 
TESTA, Presentation to the SDG Course Leaders, University of West of Scotlan...
 TESTA, Presentation to the SDG Course Leaders, University of West of Scotlan... TESTA, Presentation to the SDG Course Leaders, University of West of Scotlan...
TESTA, Presentation to the SDG Course Leaders, University of West of Scotlan...
 
Presentation1
Presentation1Presentation1
Presentation1
 
The effect of project based learning model with kwl worksheet on student crea...
The effect of project based learning model with kwl worksheet on student crea...The effect of project based learning model with kwl worksheet on student crea...
The effect of project based learning model with kwl worksheet on student crea...
 
Cómo el aprendizaje inverso, el diseño adaptativo y la gamificación favorecen...
Cómo el aprendizaje inverso, el diseño adaptativo y la gamificación favorecen...Cómo el aprendizaje inverso, el diseño adaptativo y la gamificación favorecen...
Cómo el aprendizaje inverso, el diseño adaptativo y la gamificación favorecen...
 
Stephen Phillips - Implementing an inquiry based approach into our school
Stephen Phillips - Implementing an inquiry based approach into our schoolStephen Phillips - Implementing an inquiry based approach into our school
Stephen Phillips - Implementing an inquiry based approach into our school
 
Trainee Teacher's Readiness Towards Teaching Practice: The Case of Malaysia
Trainee Teacher's Readiness Towards Teaching Practice: The Case of MalaysiaTrainee Teacher's Readiness Towards Teaching Practice: The Case of Malaysia
Trainee Teacher's Readiness Towards Teaching Practice: The Case of Malaysia
 
Increasing Grade 9 Students TLE MPS using a Blended Approach with Manychat
Increasing Grade 9 Students TLE MPS using a Blended Approach with ManychatIncreasing Grade 9 Students TLE MPS using a Blended Approach with Manychat
Increasing Grade 9 Students TLE MPS using a Blended Approach with Manychat
 
Pedagogy for Today's Professor - New Faculty Orientation
Pedagogy for Today's Professor - New Faculty OrientationPedagogy for Today's Professor - New Faculty Orientation
Pedagogy for Today's Professor - New Faculty Orientation
 
Evidence of Success: A Review of Flipped Learning
Evidence of Success: A Review of Flipped LearningEvidence of Success: A Review of Flipped Learning
Evidence of Success: A Review of Flipped Learning
 
Metacognitive Strategies: Instructional Approaches in Teaching and Learning o...
Metacognitive Strategies: Instructional Approaches in Teaching and Learning o...Metacognitive Strategies: Instructional Approaches in Teaching and Learning o...
Metacognitive Strategies: Instructional Approaches in Teaching and Learning o...
 
Hambly brendan 0061096423_edr8802_task1parta
Hambly brendan 0061096423_edr8802_task1partaHambly brendan 0061096423_edr8802_task1parta
Hambly brendan 0061096423_edr8802_task1parta
 
Flipped Classroom - Literature Review
Flipped Classroom - Literature ReviewFlipped Classroom - Literature Review
Flipped Classroom - Literature Review
 
Online Assignment
Online AssignmentOnline Assignment
Online Assignment
 
EL7003-8 Assignment 1: Instructional Design and Engaging E-Learning Activities
EL7003-8 Assignment 1: Instructional Design and Engaging E-Learning ActivitiesEL7003-8 Assignment 1: Instructional Design and Engaging E-Learning Activities
EL7003-8 Assignment 1: Instructional Design and Engaging E-Learning Activities
 
Enhancing Practical Knowledge
Enhancing Practical KnowledgeEnhancing Practical Knowledge
Enhancing Practical Knowledge
 
Enhancing students' learning through blended learning for engineering mathema...
Enhancing students' learning through blended learning for engineering mathema...Enhancing students' learning through blended learning for engineering mathema...
Enhancing students' learning through blended learning for engineering mathema...
 

Recently uploaded

Role of Remote Sensing and Monitoring in Mining
Role of Remote Sensing and Monitoring in MiningRole of Remote Sensing and Monitoring in Mining
Role of Remote Sensing and Monitoring in Mining
Naaraayani Minerals Pvt.Ltd
 
falcon-invoice-discounting-a-premier-platform-for-investors-in-india
falcon-invoice-discounting-a-premier-platform-for-investors-in-indiafalcon-invoice-discounting-a-premier-platform-for-investors-in-india
falcon-invoice-discounting-a-premier-platform-for-investors-in-india
Falcon Invoice Discounting
 
RMD24 | Debunking the non-endemic revenue myth Marvin Vacquier Droop | First ...
RMD24 | Debunking the non-endemic revenue myth Marvin Vacquier Droop | First ...RMD24 | Debunking the non-endemic revenue myth Marvin Vacquier Droop | First ...
RMD24 | Debunking the non-endemic revenue myth Marvin Vacquier Droop | First ...
BBPMedia1
 
20240425_ TJ Communications Credentials_compressed.pdf
20240425_ TJ Communications Credentials_compressed.pdf20240425_ TJ Communications Credentials_compressed.pdf
20240425_ TJ Communications Credentials_compressed.pdf
tjcomstrang
 
5 Things You Need To Know Before Hiring a Videographer
5 Things You Need To Know Before Hiring a Videographer5 Things You Need To Know Before Hiring a Videographer
5 Things You Need To Know Before Hiring a Videographer
ofm712785
 
Buy Verified PayPal Account | Buy Google 5 Star Reviews
Buy Verified PayPal Account | Buy Google 5 Star ReviewsBuy Verified PayPal Account | Buy Google 5 Star Reviews
Buy Verified PayPal Account | Buy Google 5 Star Reviews
usawebmarket
 
Enterprise Excellence is Inclusive Excellence.pdf
Enterprise Excellence is Inclusive Excellence.pdfEnterprise Excellence is Inclusive Excellence.pdf
Enterprise Excellence is Inclusive Excellence.pdf
KaiNexus
 
Cree_Rey_BrandIdentityKit.PDF_PersonalBd
Cree_Rey_BrandIdentityKit.PDF_PersonalBdCree_Rey_BrandIdentityKit.PDF_PersonalBd
Cree_Rey_BrandIdentityKit.PDF_PersonalBd
creerey
 
Premium MEAN Stack Development Solutions for Modern Businesses
Premium MEAN Stack Development Solutions for Modern BusinessesPremium MEAN Stack Development Solutions for Modern Businesses
Premium MEAN Stack Development Solutions for Modern Businesses
SynapseIndia
 
Set off and carry forward of losses and assessment of individuals.pptx
Set off and carry forward of losses and assessment of individuals.pptxSet off and carry forward of losses and assessment of individuals.pptx
Set off and carry forward of losses and assessment of individuals.pptx
HARSHITHV26
 
Digital Transformation in PLM - WHAT and HOW - for distribution.pdf
Digital Transformation in PLM - WHAT and HOW - for distribution.pdfDigital Transformation in PLM - WHAT and HOW - for distribution.pdf
Digital Transformation in PLM - WHAT and HOW - for distribution.pdf
Jos Voskuil
 
Search Disrupted Google’s Leaked Documents Rock the SEO World.pdf
Search Disrupted Google’s Leaked Documents Rock the SEO World.pdfSearch Disrupted Google’s Leaked Documents Rock the SEO World.pdf
Search Disrupted Google’s Leaked Documents Rock the SEO World.pdf
Arihant Webtech Pvt. Ltd
 
Unveiling the Secrets How Does Generative AI Work.pdf
Unveiling the Secrets How Does Generative AI Work.pdfUnveiling the Secrets How Does Generative AI Work.pdf
Unveiling the Secrets How Does Generative AI Work.pdf
Sam H
 
Exploring Patterns of Connection with Social Dreaming
Exploring Patterns of Connection with Social DreamingExploring Patterns of Connection with Social Dreaming
Exploring Patterns of Connection with Social Dreaming
Nicola Wreford-Howard
 
What are the main advantages of using HR recruiter services.pdf
What are the main advantages of using HR recruiter services.pdfWhat are the main advantages of using HR recruiter services.pdf
What are the main advantages of using HR recruiter services.pdf
HumanResourceDimensi1
 
Sustainability: Balancing the Environment, Equity & Economy
Sustainability: Balancing the Environment, Equity & EconomySustainability: Balancing the Environment, Equity & Economy
Sustainability: Balancing the Environment, Equity & Economy
Operational Excellence Consulting
 
Project File Report BBA 6th semester.pdf
Project File Report BBA 6th semester.pdfProject File Report BBA 6th semester.pdf
Project File Report BBA 6th semester.pdf
RajPriye
 
PriyoShop Celebration Pohela Falgun Mar 20, 2024
PriyoShop Celebration Pohela Falgun Mar 20, 2024PriyoShop Celebration Pohela Falgun Mar 20, 2024
PriyoShop Celebration Pohela Falgun Mar 20, 2024
PriyoShop.com LTD
 
Introduction to Amazon company 111111111111
Introduction to Amazon company 111111111111Introduction to Amazon company 111111111111
Introduction to Amazon company 111111111111
zoyaansari11365
 
Improving profitability for small business
Improving profitability for small businessImproving profitability for small business
Improving profitability for small business
Ben Wann
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Role of Remote Sensing and Monitoring in Mining
Role of Remote Sensing and Monitoring in MiningRole of Remote Sensing and Monitoring in Mining
Role of Remote Sensing and Monitoring in Mining
 
falcon-invoice-discounting-a-premier-platform-for-investors-in-india
falcon-invoice-discounting-a-premier-platform-for-investors-in-indiafalcon-invoice-discounting-a-premier-platform-for-investors-in-india
falcon-invoice-discounting-a-premier-platform-for-investors-in-india
 
RMD24 | Debunking the non-endemic revenue myth Marvin Vacquier Droop | First ...
RMD24 | Debunking the non-endemic revenue myth Marvin Vacquier Droop | First ...RMD24 | Debunking the non-endemic revenue myth Marvin Vacquier Droop | First ...
RMD24 | Debunking the non-endemic revenue myth Marvin Vacquier Droop | First ...
 
20240425_ TJ Communications Credentials_compressed.pdf
20240425_ TJ Communications Credentials_compressed.pdf20240425_ TJ Communications Credentials_compressed.pdf
20240425_ TJ Communications Credentials_compressed.pdf
 
5 Things You Need To Know Before Hiring a Videographer
5 Things You Need To Know Before Hiring a Videographer5 Things You Need To Know Before Hiring a Videographer
5 Things You Need To Know Before Hiring a Videographer
 
Buy Verified PayPal Account | Buy Google 5 Star Reviews
Buy Verified PayPal Account | Buy Google 5 Star ReviewsBuy Verified PayPal Account | Buy Google 5 Star Reviews
Buy Verified PayPal Account | Buy Google 5 Star Reviews
 
Enterprise Excellence is Inclusive Excellence.pdf
Enterprise Excellence is Inclusive Excellence.pdfEnterprise Excellence is Inclusive Excellence.pdf
Enterprise Excellence is Inclusive Excellence.pdf
 
Cree_Rey_BrandIdentityKit.PDF_PersonalBd
Cree_Rey_BrandIdentityKit.PDF_PersonalBdCree_Rey_BrandIdentityKit.PDF_PersonalBd
Cree_Rey_BrandIdentityKit.PDF_PersonalBd
 
Premium MEAN Stack Development Solutions for Modern Businesses
Premium MEAN Stack Development Solutions for Modern BusinessesPremium MEAN Stack Development Solutions for Modern Businesses
Premium MEAN Stack Development Solutions for Modern Businesses
 
Set off and carry forward of losses and assessment of individuals.pptx
Set off and carry forward of losses and assessment of individuals.pptxSet off and carry forward of losses and assessment of individuals.pptx
Set off and carry forward of losses and assessment of individuals.pptx
 
Digital Transformation in PLM - WHAT and HOW - for distribution.pdf
Digital Transformation in PLM - WHAT and HOW - for distribution.pdfDigital Transformation in PLM - WHAT and HOW - for distribution.pdf
Digital Transformation in PLM - WHAT and HOW - for distribution.pdf
 
Search Disrupted Google’s Leaked Documents Rock the SEO World.pdf
Search Disrupted Google’s Leaked Documents Rock the SEO World.pdfSearch Disrupted Google’s Leaked Documents Rock the SEO World.pdf
Search Disrupted Google’s Leaked Documents Rock the SEO World.pdf
 
Unveiling the Secrets How Does Generative AI Work.pdf
Unveiling the Secrets How Does Generative AI Work.pdfUnveiling the Secrets How Does Generative AI Work.pdf
Unveiling the Secrets How Does Generative AI Work.pdf
 
Exploring Patterns of Connection with Social Dreaming
Exploring Patterns of Connection with Social DreamingExploring Patterns of Connection with Social Dreaming
Exploring Patterns of Connection with Social Dreaming
 
What are the main advantages of using HR recruiter services.pdf
What are the main advantages of using HR recruiter services.pdfWhat are the main advantages of using HR recruiter services.pdf
What are the main advantages of using HR recruiter services.pdf
 
Sustainability: Balancing the Environment, Equity & Economy
Sustainability: Balancing the Environment, Equity & EconomySustainability: Balancing the Environment, Equity & Economy
Sustainability: Balancing the Environment, Equity & Economy
 
Project File Report BBA 6th semester.pdf
Project File Report BBA 6th semester.pdfProject File Report BBA 6th semester.pdf
Project File Report BBA 6th semester.pdf
 
PriyoShop Celebration Pohela Falgun Mar 20, 2024
PriyoShop Celebration Pohela Falgun Mar 20, 2024PriyoShop Celebration Pohela Falgun Mar 20, 2024
PriyoShop Celebration Pohela Falgun Mar 20, 2024
 
Introduction to Amazon company 111111111111
Introduction to Amazon company 111111111111Introduction to Amazon company 111111111111
Introduction to Amazon company 111111111111
 
Improving profitability for small business
Improving profitability for small businessImproving profitability for small business
Improving profitability for small business
 

ITE2019-Sheeba-Viswarajan.pptx

  • 1. Sheeba Viswarajan, Senior Lecturer, Cass School of Education Does the new GCSE science curriculum improve the effectiveness of practical work in Key Stage 4 classes?
  • 2. What is meant by ‘effectiveness of practical work’?
  • 3. Purpose of practical work? domain of objects and observables domain of ideas Practical work is the bridge between these two domains Hands-on Minds-on http://toreto.co/chemistry-titration/ https://www.chronicle.com/article/Beyond-Critical- Thinking/63288 Practical work: linking two domains (from Tiberghien, 2000)
  • 4. What is ‘effectiveness’? Task specification (what the pupils are meant to do) Teacher’s objectives (what the pupils are meant to learn) Classroom activities (what the pupils actually do) Learning outcomes (what the pupils actually learn) effectiveness (1) (2) ‘Effectiveness’, relates to how well the objectives are met. Two-level model of effectiveness (adapted from Millar et al, 1999, p.37)
  • 5. Effectiveness of a practical activity Effective in the domain of objects and observables in the domain of ideas at level (1) (While they carry out the practical task) What I want pupils to do in the task.. Can they do this? What concepts/ideas I want pupils to think about during the task…. Are they doing this? at level (2) (post-practical) Can pupils later recall what they did in the task? Do they do this? Do pupils later show understanding of the ideas the task meant to help them learn… Do they do this? 2x 2 effectiveness matrix 2x 2 effectiveness matrix :Analytical framework for considering the effectiveness of a practical task (adapted from Abrahams and Millar, 2008, p.1949)
  • 6. • Previous research findings(Abrahams & Millar, 2008) have highlighted the ineffectiveness of practical work in the domain of ideas.
  • 7. • The practical work that teachers opt to do is influenced by the science curriculum particularly by the method of assessment of the practical work, as highlighted in the studies on practical work (Abrahams and Reiss, 2012) and in the assessment of science education (Bernholt, Neumann and Nentwig, 2012).
  • 8. The new GCSE science curriculum has removed the internal assessment of practical work in the schools but the exam papers will include 15% worth questions on understanding of practical work in both domains.
  • 9. There are concerns.. • ..that schools will reduce funding for practical work in school (Gatsby Charitable Foundation, the Nuffield Foundation and the Wellcome Trust Consultation Response, 2015). • ..that students will be shown demonstrations or watch videos of the practical at a fraction of the cost, resulting in weaker manipulative skills gained by students. • ..that universities already struggle with the weak practical skills of their first year students (Grant, 2011) and 39% of businesses say they had difficulty in recruiting staff with good STEM skills (CBI, 2014).
  • 10. On the other hand… • It is possible that teachers may now have the autonomy to re-evaluate their reasons for doing practical work, moving away from the practice of rehearsing practical work for highest marks procurement. • Learners require proficiency in domains of observables as well as ideas therefore teachers may be encouraged to deliver practical tasks effectively in both domains.
  • 11. The research questions guiding my study are: • In the new GCSE science curriculum ,what strategies do teachers use to develop effectiveness in the two domains of practical work? • In the new GCSE science curriculum, is the practical work effective in achieving intended objectives in domain of observables? • In the new GCSE science curriculum, is the practical work effective in achieving the intended objectives in domain of ideas? • How do science teachers view the changes to the assessment policy on GCSE science practical work?
  • 12. Research methods: • Observations, • Semi-structured interviews • Focus group interviews.
  • 13. The 10 benchmarks for good practical science
  • 14. Initial findings • More stress given for domain of ideas- focus on exam style questions • Lab books • Retention and recall • Revision • Support- external and internal • Equipment • Funding • Qualitative analysis • Waiting period till exam • Extended projects/investigations
  • 15. References Abrahams, I., and R. Millar. 2008. “Does Practical Work Really Work? A Study of the Effectiveness of Practical Work as a Teaching and Learning Method in School Science.” International Journal of Science Education 30 (14): 1945–1969. Abrahams, I. and Reiss, M. J. (2012) Practical work: its effectiveness in primary and secondary schools in England. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 49(8), 1035–1055. CBI (2014). Gateway to growth CBI/Pearson education and skills survey 2014. London: Pearson. Available at: http://www.ucml.ac.uk/sites/default/files/shapingthefuture/101/gateway-to-growth.pdf [Accessed 7 Jan. 2017]. Gatsby Charitable Foundation (2017). Good practical science. [online] London: Gatsby. Available at: https://www.gatsby.org.uk/education/programmes/support- for-practical-science-in-schools [Accessed 6 Oct. 2017]. Gatsby Charitable Foundation, the Nuffield Foundation and the Wellcome Trust CONSULTATION RESPONSE. (2015). GCSE Science: Consultation on Conditions and Guidance. [online] Available at: https://wellcome.ac.uk/sites/default/files/wtp059205.pdf [Accessed 11 May 2017]. Millar, R., J.-F. Le Maréchal, and A. Tiberghien. 1999. “‘Mapping’ the Domain: Varieties of Practical Work.” In Practical Work in Science Education – Recent Research Studies, edited by J. Leach and A. Paulsen, 33–59. Roskilde/Dordrecht: Roskilde University Press/ Kluwer.

Editor's Notes

  1. Although the final assessment and grade will be exam only, there will be a greater focus on practical skills. Students will be questioned on experience that they have gained from practical work and required to demonstrate their understanding of scientific experimentation. The mathematical content is also taking a step up and there will be a higher expectation that students can utilise their maths skills within science. In physics for example 30% of exam marks will test maths skills! . Practical work is an essential part of science training. it should be embedded across the science curriculum with specific details on which experimental skills and strategies are included in each area. The current system of controlled practical assessment is deeply flawed: it consumes valuable teaching time and is vulnerable to widespread malpractice The current norm at GCSE is ‘controlled assessment’, whereby, in science, candidates have to carry out one or two investigations from a small number set by the Awarding Organisation under highly controlled conditions. There is universal agreement among those we consulted that this assessment method is deeply flawed. It makes teachers focus on a narrow range of externally-set practicals as they hone students to do well in what constitutes 25% of their final grade. Students are internally assessed on their planning and analytical abilities (not on their technical skills) by their teachers who, under our high stakes system, are under enormous pressure to give students maximum marks.
  2. The new GCSE science curriculum has removed the internal assessment of practical work in the schools but the exam papers will include 15% worth questions on understanding of practical work in both domains.
  3. The new GCSE science curriculum has removed the internal assessment of practical work in the schools but the exam papers will include 15% worth questions on understanding of practical work in both domains.
  4. My study will explore the validity of concerns about decline in practical work, by observing the current practices of teaching the practical work, under the new curriculum in schools. Gatsby 2011 identify the likely impact on practical work of the upcoming education policy changes, including the changes to the National Curriculum, funding mechanisms, Local Authority involvement and initial teacher education;