SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 15
Problems encountered in creating historical narratives  History is merely a list of surprises… Timothy Hensley  Virginia Holocaust Museum
Virginia Holocaust Museum Founded 1997 Moved into Climax warehouse in 2003 Exhibits are framed around the oral history of the Ipp family
Pre-War Anti-Jewish legislation Beginning World War II The Ipp (Ipson) Saga Kovno Ghetto Escape and hiding Killing (Industrialized killing) Liberation Palestine/Israel Nuremberg Trials Museum narrative
Problematizing history Untangling and reconstructing historical truth
First Thanksgiving?
Washington’s Birthplace?
Other examples?
Historical Problems  I Documents were destroyed Inaccessible archives Witnesses were killed or have died since Limited scope of photographic evidence
Historical Problems II Languages Funding is available for only specific topics Creates a limited scope VHMis in the wrong geographic area
Questions of representation Whose history? Told by whom? For what purpose?
Personal narratives (potato hole) VHM’s original text indicated the Ipp family were hiding in the Potato Hole for 9 months.
9 month origins
Document Narratives   Claims to have killed 137,346 Jews in a five month period (July – Nov 1941) Is there a reason EinsatzkommandoJager might have exaggerated?
Fictive Narratives Danish King and the Yellow Star Boy in the Stripped Pajamas Anne Frank The Painted Bird (JerzyKosiński)
The genocide divide Can you represent modern genocides “through” a Holocaust narrative framework? What are the complications?

More Related Content

What's hot

Holocaust presentation
Holocaust presentationHolocaust presentation
Holocaust presentation
Vjones89
 
F:\Holocaust Katie And Kelsey
F:\Holocaust Katie And KelseyF:\Holocaust Katie And Kelsey
F:\Holocaust Katie And Kelsey
norris445138
 
Anne Frank Courage Project
Anne Frank Courage ProjectAnne Frank Courage Project
Anne Frank Courage Project
wmsbierer
 
Targeting the polish nation reygin
Targeting the polish nation reyginTargeting the polish nation reygin
Targeting the polish nation reygin
Debbie Alcorn
 
Everyday life in the warsaw ghetto
Everyday life in the warsaw ghettoEveryday life in the warsaw ghetto
Everyday life in the warsaw ghetto
Alex Thompson
 
Intro to the holocaust
Intro to the holocaustIntro to the holocaust
Intro to the holocaust
msgilmore
 

What's hot (18)

Holocaust presentation
Holocaust presentationHolocaust presentation
Holocaust presentation
 
F:\Holocaust Katie And Kelsey
F:\Holocaust Katie And KelseyF:\Holocaust Katie And Kelsey
F:\Holocaust Katie And Kelsey
 
Lydia Munn
Lydia MunnLydia Munn
Lydia Munn
 
Concentration and death camps in Poland
Concentration and death camps in PolandConcentration and death camps in Poland
Concentration and death camps in Poland
 
Anne Frank Courage Project
Anne Frank Courage ProjectAnne Frank Courage Project
Anne Frank Courage Project
 
Targeting the polish nation reygin
Targeting the polish nation reyginTargeting the polish nation reygin
Targeting the polish nation reygin
 
Nazi Death Camps
Nazi Death CampsNazi Death Camps
Nazi Death Camps
 
The holocaust2
The holocaust2The holocaust2
The holocaust2
 
The Rescuers
The RescuersThe Rescuers
The Rescuers
 
Camstaman and nathan
Camstaman and nathanCamstaman and nathan
Camstaman and nathan
 
Holocaust and WWII
Holocaust and WWIIHolocaust and WWII
Holocaust and WWII
 
Daily life in auschwitz
Daily life in auschwitzDaily life in auschwitz
Daily life in auschwitz
 
Everyday life in the warsaw ghetto
Everyday life in the warsaw ghettoEveryday life in the warsaw ghetto
Everyday life in the warsaw ghetto
 
Nazi propaganda by joe b
Nazi propaganda by joe bNazi propaganda by joe b
Nazi propaganda by joe b
 
Intro to the holocaust
Intro to the holocaustIntro to the holocaust
Intro to the holocaust
 
Countess von Stauffenberg
Countess von StauffenbergCountess von Stauffenberg
Countess von Stauffenberg
 
Lesson 4
Lesson 4Lesson 4
Lesson 4
 
Dnevnik ane frank
Dnevnik ane frankDnevnik ane frank
Dnevnik ane frank
 

Viewers also liked (8)

Elective : IPSA Rajkot : Semster 08 : Networked Environments
Elective : IPSA Rajkot : Semster 08 : Networked EnvironmentsElective : IPSA Rajkot : Semster 08 : Networked Environments
Elective : IPSA Rajkot : Semster 08 : Networked Environments
 
Australia day 1938
Australia day 1938Australia day 1938
Australia day 1938
 
Holocaust Photo Project Directions
Holocaust Photo Project   DirectionsHolocaust Photo Project   Directions
Holocaust Photo Project Directions
 
The Holocaust
The HolocaustThe Holocaust
The Holocaust
 
Dc parent 14 1
Dc parent 14 1Dc parent 14 1
Dc parent 14 1
 
Yow Book Report
Yow Book ReportYow Book Report
Yow Book Report
 
Holocaust Museum Sample
Holocaust Museum SampleHolocaust Museum Sample
Holocaust Museum Sample
 
Why Museums Matter (Tourism Educators Conference)
Why Museums Matter (Tourism Educators Conference)Why Museums Matter (Tourism Educators Conference)
Why Museums Matter (Tourism Educators Conference)
 

Similar to History is merely a list of surprises

Holocaust denials
Holocaust denialsHolocaust denials
Holocaust denials
Eva King
 
Ewrt 1 c class 25 night intro
Ewrt 1 c class 25 night introEwrt 1 c class 25 night intro
Ewrt 1 c class 25 night intro
jordanlachance
 
Declaration of mark weber and counsel for defendants facts, allegations, and ...
Declaration of mark weber and counsel for defendants facts, allegations, and ...Declaration of mark weber and counsel for defendants facts, allegations, and ...
Declaration of mark weber and counsel for defendants facts, allegations, and ...
RareBooksnRecords
 
Geschiedenis german racial policy
Geschiedenis   german racial policyGeschiedenis   german racial policy
Geschiedenis german racial policy
Jurgen Marechal
 
Page 1 of 9
Page 1 of 9Page 1 of 9
Page 1 of 9
Hieu Lai
 
2008vus11e holocaust
2008vus11e holocaust2008vus11e holocaust
2008vus11e holocaust
k0socha
 
Ewrt 1 c class 25 night intro
Ewrt 1 c class 25 night introEwrt 1 c class 25 night intro
Ewrt 1 c class 25 night intro
jordanlachance
 
Ewrt 1 c class 25 night intro
Ewrt 1 c class 25 night introEwrt 1 c class 25 night intro
Ewrt 1 c class 25 night intro
jordanlachance
 
Carlo mattogno the myth of the extermination of the jews - part ii - journa...
Carlo mattogno   the myth of the extermination of the jews - part ii - journa...Carlo mattogno   the myth of the extermination of the jews - part ii - journa...
Carlo mattogno the myth of the extermination of the jews - part ii - journa...
RareBooksnRecords
 
Non jewishvictimsoftheholocaust-110310103431-phpapp01[1]
Non jewishvictimsoftheholocaust-110310103431-phpapp01[1]Non jewishvictimsoftheholocaust-110310103431-phpapp01[1]
Non jewishvictimsoftheholocaust-110310103431-phpapp01[1]
danielleminyo
 

Similar to History is merely a list of surprises (19)

Anne Frank In Historical Perspective A Teaching Guide For Secondary Schools
Anne Frank In Historical Perspective  A Teaching Guide For Secondary SchoolsAnne Frank In Historical Perspective  A Teaching Guide For Secondary Schools
Anne Frank In Historical Perspective A Teaching Guide For Secondary Schools
 
The Holocaust
The HolocaustThe Holocaust
The Holocaust
 
Holocaust denials
Holocaust denialsHolocaust denials
Holocaust denials
 
Ewrt 1 c class 25 night intro
Ewrt 1 c class 25 night introEwrt 1 c class 25 night intro
Ewrt 1 c class 25 night intro
 
Reflection Paper On Museum Of Tolerance
Reflection Paper On Museum Of ToleranceReflection Paper On Museum Of Tolerance
Reflection Paper On Museum Of Tolerance
 
Declaration of mark weber and counsel for defendants facts, allegations, and ...
Declaration of mark weber and counsel for defendants facts, allegations, and ...Declaration of mark weber and counsel for defendants facts, allegations, and ...
Declaration of mark weber and counsel for defendants facts, allegations, and ...
 
Geschiedenis german racial policy
Geschiedenis   german racial policyGeschiedenis   german racial policy
Geschiedenis german racial policy
 
The National socialist racial policy
The National socialist racial policyThe National socialist racial policy
The National socialist racial policy
 
Page 1 of 9
Page 1 of 9Page 1 of 9
Page 1 of 9
 
Youth in nazi germany
Youth in nazi germanyYouth in nazi germany
Youth in nazi germany
 
2008vus11e holocaust
2008vus11e holocaust2008vus11e holocaust
2008vus11e holocaust
 
Ewrt 1 c class 25 night intro
Ewrt 1 c class 25 night introEwrt 1 c class 25 night intro
Ewrt 1 c class 25 night intro
 
Ewrt 1 c class 25 night intro
Ewrt 1 c class 25 night introEwrt 1 c class 25 night intro
Ewrt 1 c class 25 night intro
 
Ewrt 1 c class 40
Ewrt 1 c class 40Ewrt 1 c class 40
Ewrt 1 c class 40
 
Review of the Holocaust, Global Vision.-ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF IRAN - Tehran Int...
Review of the Holocaust, Global Vision.-ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF IRAN - Tehran Int...Review of the Holocaust, Global Vision.-ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF IRAN - Tehran Int...
Review of the Holocaust, Global Vision.-ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF IRAN - Tehran Int...
 
Carlo mattogno the myth of the extermination of the jews - part ii - journa...
Carlo mattogno   the myth of the extermination of the jews - part ii - journa...Carlo mattogno   the myth of the extermination of the jews - part ii - journa...
Carlo mattogno the myth of the extermination of the jews - part ii - journa...
 
Presentation
PresentationPresentation
Presentation
 
Non jewish victims of the holocaust
Non jewish victims of the holocaustNon jewish victims of the holocaust
Non jewish victims of the holocaust
 
Non jewishvictimsoftheholocaust-110310103431-phpapp01[1]
Non jewishvictimsoftheholocaust-110310103431-phpapp01[1]Non jewishvictimsoftheholocaust-110310103431-phpapp01[1]
Non jewishvictimsoftheholocaust-110310103431-phpapp01[1]
 

History is merely a list of surprises