2. 09/12/16 2
Objective
To focus attention on a few, clear and
actionable priorities that are geared
towards providing better manpower
training and consequently, satisfying
the needs of industry and the nation at
large.
3. 09/12/16 3
Recent positive changes
Improved pay of educators, especially in
universities
Much greater private sector participation at all
levels
Better spending of proceeds of Education Tax
Fund
Achievement of university enrolment
science/arts ratio of 60:401
University Autonomy bill
4. 09/12/16 4
University Graduates – Main
Identified Shortcomings1
Poor communication skills
Lack of analytical and problem-solving
skills
Narrow knowledge base
Inadequate professional carriage
Poor work and professional ethics
5. 09/12/16 5
Public Spending in Education
as Share of GDP1
Public Spending in Education as Share of GDP in OECDs and
Asian Tigers
0.7%
5.4%
6.0%
4.2%
6.5%
3.7%
3.0%
0.0%
1.0%
2.0%
3.0%
4.0%
5.0%
6.0%
7.0%
Nigeria USA France UK Singapore South Korea Hong Kong
Country
%ShareofGDP
6. 09/12/16 6
Public Spending in Education
as Share of GDP in Africa
Public Spending in Education as Share of GDPin Africa
0.7%
7.6%
2.6%
7.1%
5.0%
4.2%
3.6%
0.0%
1.0%
2.0%
3.0%
4.0%
5.0%
6.0%
7.0%
8.0%
Nigeria Soth Africa Uganda Zimbabwe Cote d'Ivoire Ghana Kenya
Country
%ShareofGDP
7. 09/12/16 7
Federal Government Budgetary Allocation to
Education2
Federal Government Budgetary Allocation to Education
40%
7.2%
12.3%
17.6%
10.3% 11.1%
8.4%
7.0%
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
30%
35%
40%
45%
1960 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001
Year
%Allocation
8. 09/12/16 8
Share of Public Education
Expenditure for Tertiary Education
Share of Public Education Expenditure for Tertiary Education
35.3%
25.2%
23.7%
14.3%
12.2% 13.2%
18.6%
0.0%
5.0%
10.0%
15.0%
20.0%
25.0%
30.0%
35.0%
40.0%
Nigeria USA UK South
Africa
Ghana Uganda Cote
d'Ivoire
Country
%Share
9. 09/12/16 9
A First Conclusion…
There is a very basic problem of lack of
adequate public funding of education in
Nigeria
Public funding of education is biased
towards the tertiary level to the neglect
of primary and secondary education
This underlays many other problems in
the educational system
10. 09/12/16 10
Tertiary Education in Nigeria
University enrolment 350,0001
Graduates per year 55,000
Expenditure/student/year $9002
Graduate unemployment 22%3
11. 09/12/16 11
Recommendations on
expenditure on education
Increase substantially public expenditure on
education
At least 2% of GDP
At least 20% of Federal Budget
Increase coverage and quality of primary and
secondary education1
Increase quality of tertiary education
12. 09/12/16 12
Input of Government to Tertiary
Education
Effective autonomy of universities
Streamline NUC functions to be in harmony
with university autonomy
Allocation of funds to meet capital
expenditure and part of operational costs
Scholarships for deserving students
13. 09/12/16 13
Input of Private Sector to
Tertiary Education
Provision of endowments in universities
Participation in the Students Industrial Work
Experience Scheme
Special donations to projects in universities
and patronage of consultancy services
Grants for contract research of university
staff and placement in industry during
sabbatical leaves
14. 09/12/16 14
Input of the Universities
Proper budget planning, implementation and
control
Review the curricula to meet industry needs
Deploy ICT’s for teaching, research and
administration.
Establish industrial advisory councils to
provide feedback to industry
Admissions in line with capacity
15. 09/12/16 15
Special problems ICT
education
Inability to retain qualified staff
Graduates do not know modern
programming languages
Disconnect between learning and
practical application
Lack of familiarity with software
development process
16. 09/12/16 16
Suggestions to upgrade
knowledge in ICT
Creation of “IT corridors” providing computer
equipment, servers, Internet access and training for
ICT entrepreneurs
Creation of ICT incubators
University/Industry partnerships to train
undergraduates in modern program-ming
languages and other ICT skills.
Special incentives/remuneration for ICT instructors
17. 09/12/16 17
Special problems technical-
vocational education
Collapse of existing public schools
Lack of qualified instructors, equipment,
and consumables
Low (and declining) private sector
participation
Low social appreciation
Result: acute shortage of trained
manpower at this level
18. 09/12/16 18
Suggestions on technical-
vocational education
Concentrate on transforming some existing technical
schools with focus on skills needed on selected
industrial sectors sucah as manufacturing,
construction, agriculture...
Review conditions of service of instructors:
comparability with industry
Review curriculum: emphasis on multiskilling
Give wide publicity to employment and remuneration
opportunities available to those with required
technical skills
1 Similar shortcomings were identified in “Labor Market Prospects for University Graduates in Nigeria”, Andrew Dabalen and Bankole Oni, The World Bank, November 2000.
1 Source: Human Development Report 2001
1 The National Capacity Assessment Report of Nigeria, carried out by the Federal Ministry of Finance in Collaboration with the World Bank (2000)
2 Reported by Victor Dike in www.afbis.com
UNESCO recommends minimum of 26% of the national budget (The National Capacity Assessment Report of Nigeria, carried out by the Federal Ministry of Finance in Collaboration with the World Bank (2000) )
1 The National Capacity Assessment Report of Nigeria, carried out by the Federal Ministry of Finance in Collaboration with the World Bank (2000) reports that in 1997/98 Academic Year it was 349,425 and that an additional 210,306 were enrolled in polytechnics
2 “Labor Market Prospects for University Graduates in Nigeria”, Ajndrew Dabalen and Bankole Oni, The World Bank, November 2000. Omoifo, C. N., G. A. Badmus and D. Awanbor, “Education and Achievement in the Early Career of the University of Benin Graduates”, 1997, Faculty of Education, University of Benin, Benin City report a graduate unemployment rate of 20%.
3 Federal Government of Nigeria: National manpower Board,”The Study of Nigerian Labor Market: Phase One – Lagos State” 1998, jAbuja
The National Capacity Assessment Report of Nigeria, carried out by the Federal Ministry of Finance in Collaboration with the World Bank (2000) reports that in 1998 there were 62 colleges of education and 45 polytechnics
1 the current U.N. Common Country Assessment (CCA) ON Nigeria reports that the adult litereacy rate declined in the last decade from 57% in 1991 to 49% in 1999. The National Capacity Assessment Report of Nigeria, carried out by the Federal Ministry of Finance in Collaboration with the World Bank (2000) reports that at least 38% of primary school class-rooms had no ceilings and that the average classroom in secondary schools had 69 pupils. A recent World Bank booklet on Universal Basic Education in Nigeria reports that just over half of all children complete primary school