How can we ensure a just transition to a green economy that benefits people and the planet?
- What are the opportunities and challenges for developing countries in transitioning to a green economy?
- How can we ensure the transition leaves no one behind and helps lift people out of poverty?
- What policies and initiatives have shown success in creating green jobs and livelihoods?
- How can we ensure a green economy respects environmental limits and helps restore ecosystems?
- What principles of equity and justice should guide the transition globally and nationally?
FORMAT of the Plenary Sessions
Each plenary session will follow the format below:
- Scene Setting: Short presentations from 2-3 panellists to set
How to Lobby at Intergovernmental MeetingsFelix Dodds
a power point used for a workshop at the December 2017 United Nations Environment Assembly by Felix Dodds and Jan Gustav Strandenaes on How to Lobby at Intergovernmental meetings. Training offered for staff of stakeholders
The "Joint Messages of Local and Sub-national Governmentsuncsd2012
The 8 recommendations stress the importance of acknowledging the positive role that urbanization plays in development. They advocate for a new multi-level governance that promotes effective partnerships in building sustainable cities and call on members-states to take into account the specific perspective of local and sub-national governments for addressing global challenges.
In our efforts to raise awareness around the themes of sustainable development, we devote this special issue to Jobs/Employment, one of the seven critical issues of Rio+20.
BUILDING ON THE KYOTO PROTOCOL: OPTIONS FOR PROTECTING THE CLIMATEDr Lendy Spires
An Architecture for Climate Protection Kevin A. Baumert and Nancy Kete Walls, windows, floors, and doors are some of the elements used in designing a house. Not just any mix of architectural elements will create a functional home.
Although there are many possible designs, making a home functional means assembling walls, windows, and other elements into a compatible whole that meets the needs of its inhabitants. So too, a climate protection treaty has its own set of “architectural elements” that must meet the needs of its stakeholders.
Elements of a climate protection treaty include provisions for controlling greenhouse gas emissions, man-aging economic costs, and promoting accountability, among other things. While the options for designing a home may seem limitless, the diversity of potentially effective climate agreements is not nearly as constrained as current international negotiations might lead us to believe.
As with homes, innovation and creativity are needed in treaty design. Since 1997, the debate over global climate change has focused narrowly on the Kyoto Protocol—an international treaty to control greenhouse gas emissions that are trapping heat in the Earth’s atmosphere.
The Protocol calls on industrialized countries to reduce their emissions of greenhouse gases by about 5 percent below 1990 levels between 2008 and 2012. Over the past 5 years, government officials, observers, and experts have been absorbed in the arcane details of the Protocol, arguing at great length about the treaty’s merits and demerits.
As the Kyoto Protocol comes to life, this debate will shift to include new ideas for future commitments to protect the global climate system. This volume explores a set of options for designing an international framework for climate protection “beyond Kyoto,” that is, beyond the Kyoto Protocol’s first commitment period.1 We pay special attention to achieving international cooperation across the so-called North-South divide.
These are the slides to the second webinar by the MGCY capacity building team: Introducing Rio+20, with a history of what the Summit is about in a basic and friendly manner.
For full coverage of the third prepcom and Rio+20, visit the IISD website at http://www.iisd.ca/uncsd/rio20/
or
Download the IISD Rio+20 mobile app for your apple or android devices: http://www.iisd.ca/enb-mobile/
How to Lobby at Intergovernmental MeetingsFelix Dodds
a power point used for a workshop at the December 2017 United Nations Environment Assembly by Felix Dodds and Jan Gustav Strandenaes on How to Lobby at Intergovernmental meetings. Training offered for staff of stakeholders
The "Joint Messages of Local and Sub-national Governmentsuncsd2012
The 8 recommendations stress the importance of acknowledging the positive role that urbanization plays in development. They advocate for a new multi-level governance that promotes effective partnerships in building sustainable cities and call on members-states to take into account the specific perspective of local and sub-national governments for addressing global challenges.
In our efforts to raise awareness around the themes of sustainable development, we devote this special issue to Jobs/Employment, one of the seven critical issues of Rio+20.
BUILDING ON THE KYOTO PROTOCOL: OPTIONS FOR PROTECTING THE CLIMATEDr Lendy Spires
An Architecture for Climate Protection Kevin A. Baumert and Nancy Kete Walls, windows, floors, and doors are some of the elements used in designing a house. Not just any mix of architectural elements will create a functional home.
Although there are many possible designs, making a home functional means assembling walls, windows, and other elements into a compatible whole that meets the needs of its inhabitants. So too, a climate protection treaty has its own set of “architectural elements” that must meet the needs of its stakeholders.
Elements of a climate protection treaty include provisions for controlling greenhouse gas emissions, man-aging economic costs, and promoting accountability, among other things. While the options for designing a home may seem limitless, the diversity of potentially effective climate agreements is not nearly as constrained as current international negotiations might lead us to believe.
As with homes, innovation and creativity are needed in treaty design. Since 1997, the debate over global climate change has focused narrowly on the Kyoto Protocol—an international treaty to control greenhouse gas emissions that are trapping heat in the Earth’s atmosphere.
The Protocol calls on industrialized countries to reduce their emissions of greenhouse gases by about 5 percent below 1990 levels between 2008 and 2012. Over the past 5 years, government officials, observers, and experts have been absorbed in the arcane details of the Protocol, arguing at great length about the treaty’s merits and demerits.
As the Kyoto Protocol comes to life, this debate will shift to include new ideas for future commitments to protect the global climate system. This volume explores a set of options for designing an international framework for climate protection “beyond Kyoto,” that is, beyond the Kyoto Protocol’s first commitment period.1 We pay special attention to achieving international cooperation across the so-called North-South divide.
These are the slides to the second webinar by the MGCY capacity building team: Introducing Rio+20, with a history of what the Summit is about in a basic and friendly manner.
For full coverage of the third prepcom and Rio+20, visit the IISD website at http://www.iisd.ca/uncsd/rio20/
or
Download the IISD Rio+20 mobile app for your apple or android devices: http://www.iisd.ca/enb-mobile/
Global health trends and lessons learned towards better advocacy and develo...Farooq Khan
Written from the perspective of a Canadian Emergency Medicine Resident in July 2013 as a presentation to peers and colleagues for academic purposes only.
Part 1: Advocacy in Emergency Medicine
- Patients, communities and the world at large
Part 2: Global Health trends
- Political, social, economic and environmental determinants
- Emergency Medicine as a global priority
Part 3: Examples of Emergency Medicine development and activism
- Global Emergency Care Collaborative - Uganda
- International Emergency Medicine research at WHO
- Getting involved without leaving the country
By Michel de Kemmeter. Presented at Crowdsourcing Week Europe 2016. For more information and details on our next event, visit www.crowdsourcingweek.com.
This unique event, which debuted in Charlotte, has become a major fund-raising event around the country for other World Affairs Councils. Teams from local businesses, schools and other organizations compete for prizes in this international trivia competition held each year in January. Challenging questions are prepared for the competition relating to current events, geography, and international issues.
Tennessee World Affairs Council 2015-16 Programstnwac
A photo presentation providing an overview of the public affairs programs hosted by the Tennessee World Affairs Council in an effort to inspire and educate the public to know more about global affairs.
Academic WorldQuest
Teams from each local public and private high school in the greater Charlotte region are invited to compete in this international knowledge competition on questions relating to foreign policy, geography, current events, and more.
Academic WorldQuest has grown in popularity that participating schools have assigned coaches and teams who compete for the honor of representing their school in this competition. This program encourages an understanding for global issues and team building in a very engaging (and fun) way. The winning school is then invited to participate in the national Academic WorldQuest held in Washington, D.C.
Teams from each local public and private high school in the greater Charlotte region are invited to compete in this international knowledge competition on questions relating to foreign policy, geography, current events, and more.
Academic WorldQuest has grown in popularity that participating schools have assigned coaches and teams who compete for the honor of representing their school in this competition. This program encourages an understanding for global issues and team building in a very engaging (and fun) way. The winning school is then invited to participate in the national Academic WorldQuest held in Washington, D.C.
powerpoint presentiation for sustainable development powerpoint presentiation for sustainable development powerpoint presentiation for sustainable development powerpoint presentiation for sustainable development powerpoint presentiation for sustainable development powerpoint presentiation for sustainable development
Hi, This is my first presentation on the covid 19 global pandemics, which was an social threat for the 8 billion people of our humanity in 2019-2020.
I was very to make a PPT presentation because of the complexity of Covid 19. Life has so many reasons to not show us what it is really. We are using these variables are likely not to be precise as a mathematical data.
The power of UN Secretary General Antonio Guterres Cvoid 19 management method was to separate the main data from the monitor and not efficient data.
It would be a real utopia to build a covid theory to understand what is covid. There are already an infinite world of viruses that we know already enough about them that helped us to make models of hazard management, resiliency... Models are our best friends. So, I have used quite a number of them to see the covid mechanism and other issues (that were not the main initially, however, they have been reinitiate recently with the UN response. The method use is a bit risky, because it can introduce some mistakes. Otherwise, there would no need to sue a response for covid 19 an dit would be difficult to manage the covid 19 hazard during the peak of crisis, from start to end.
The business modeling that I used can answer to the coivd 19 issue and various other issues, which are not presented in the response, including the Sendai, however, it was important to mention them in the research and development.
Therefore, I started with general data presentation related to the efficient models. Then, I showed how to use these models, in order to response with practical actions to the covid 19. Ultimately, I have integrated the United Nations response.
Australia at Rio+20 Seminar Facilitator, Rosemary Sainty
Former Head, Secretariat UN Global Compact Network Australia and
Adviser, Corporate Engagement, Transparency Australia
This presentation outlines the Brundtland Commission Report's pivotal role in defining sustainable development. It covers the report's context, highlighting global environmental and developmental challenges. Key concepts like sustainable development and interconnectedness are explored, leading to the report's findings on unsustainable practices and recommendations for change. The legacy of the report in shaping global policy-making and contemporary relevance are discussed. Through this presentation, we aim to underscore the urgency of adopting sustainable practices and the ongoing need for international cooperation in addressing pressing environmental issues.
A commitment to provide social protection to all workers, ensuring that all workers and their families are protected against the multiple environmental and economic crises they face. This we call the Social Protection Floor.
UiPath Test Automation using UiPath Test Suite series, part 3DianaGray10
Welcome to UiPath Test Automation using UiPath Test Suite series part 3. In this session, we will cover desktop automation along with UI automation.
Topics covered:
UI automation Introduction,
UI automation Sample
Desktop automation flow
Pradeep Chinnala, Senior Consultant Automation Developer @WonderBotz and UiPath MVP
Deepak Rai, Automation Practice Lead, Boundaryless Group and UiPath MVP
Neuro-symbolic is not enough, we need neuro-*semantic*Frank van Harmelen
Neuro-symbolic (NeSy) AI is on the rise. However, simply machine learning on just any symbolic structure is not sufficient to really harvest the gains of NeSy. These will only be gained when the symbolic structures have an actual semantics. I give an operational definition of semantics as “predictable inference”.
All of this illustrated with link prediction over knowledge graphs, but the argument is general.
Builder.ai Founder Sachin Dev Duggal's Strategic Approach to Create an Innova...Ramesh Iyer
In today's fast-changing business world, Companies that adapt and embrace new ideas often need help to keep up with the competition. However, fostering a culture of innovation takes much work. It takes vision, leadership and willingness to take risks in the right proportion. Sachin Dev Duggal, co-founder of Builder.ai, has perfected the art of this balance, creating a company culture where creativity and growth are nurtured at each stage.
Kubernetes & AI - Beauty and the Beast !?! @KCD Istanbul 2024Tobias Schneck
As AI technology is pushing into IT I was wondering myself, as an “infrastructure container kubernetes guy”, how get this fancy AI technology get managed from an infrastructure operational view? Is it possible to apply our lovely cloud native principals as well? What benefit’s both technologies could bring to each other?
Let me take this questions and provide you a short journey through existing deployment models and use cases for AI software. On practical examples, we discuss what cloud/on-premise strategy we may need for applying it to our own infrastructure to get it to work from an enterprise perspective. I want to give an overview about infrastructure requirements and technologies, what could be beneficial or limiting your AI use cases in an enterprise environment. An interactive Demo will give you some insides, what approaches I got already working for real.
LF Energy Webinar: Electrical Grid Modelling and Simulation Through PowSyBl -...DanBrown980551
Do you want to learn how to model and simulate an electrical network from scratch in under an hour?
Then welcome to this PowSyBl workshop, hosted by Rte, the French Transmission System Operator (TSO)!
During the webinar, you will discover the PowSyBl ecosystem as well as handle and study an electrical network through an interactive Python notebook.
PowSyBl is an open source project hosted by LF Energy, which offers a comprehensive set of features for electrical grid modelling and simulation. Among other advanced features, PowSyBl provides:
- A fully editable and extendable library for grid component modelling;
- Visualization tools to display your network;
- Grid simulation tools, such as power flows, security analyses (with or without remedial actions) and sensitivity analyses;
The framework is mostly written in Java, with a Python binding so that Python developers can access PowSyBl functionalities as well.
What you will learn during the webinar:
- For beginners: discover PowSyBl's functionalities through a quick general presentation and the notebook, without needing any expert coding skills;
- For advanced developers: master the skills to efficiently apply PowSyBl functionalities to your real-world scenarios.
GDG Cloud Southlake #33: Boule & Rebala: Effective AppSec in SDLC using Deplo...James Anderson
Effective Application Security in Software Delivery lifecycle using Deployment Firewall and DBOM
The modern software delivery process (or the CI/CD process) includes many tools, distributed teams, open-source code, and cloud platforms. Constant focus on speed to release software to market, along with the traditional slow and manual security checks has caused gaps in continuous security as an important piece in the software supply chain. Today organizations feel more susceptible to external and internal cyber threats due to the vast attack surface in their applications supply chain and the lack of end-to-end governance and risk management.
The software team must secure its software delivery process to avoid vulnerability and security breaches. This needs to be achieved with existing tool chains and without extensive rework of the delivery processes. This talk will present strategies and techniques for providing visibility into the true risk of the existing vulnerabilities, preventing the introduction of security issues in the software, resolving vulnerabilities in production environments quickly, and capturing the deployment bill of materials (DBOM).
Speakers:
Bob Boule
Robert Boule is a technology enthusiast with PASSION for technology and making things work along with a knack for helping others understand how things work. He comes with around 20 years of solution engineering experience in application security, software continuous delivery, and SaaS platforms. He is known for his dynamic presentations in CI/CD and application security integrated in software delivery lifecycle.
Gopinath Rebala
Gopinath Rebala is the CTO of OpsMx, where he has overall responsibility for the machine learning and data processing architectures for Secure Software Delivery. Gopi also has a strong connection with our customers, leading design and architecture for strategic implementations. Gopi is a frequent speaker and well-known leader in continuous delivery and integrating security into software delivery.
Accelerate your Kubernetes clusters with Varnish CachingThijs Feryn
A presentation about the usage and availability of Varnish on Kubernetes. This talk explores the capabilities of Varnish caching and shows how to use the Varnish Helm chart to deploy it to Kubernetes.
This presentation was delivered at K8SUG Singapore. See https://feryn.eu/presentations/accelerate-your-kubernetes-clusters-with-varnish-caching-k8sug-singapore-28-2024 for more details.
Slack (or Teams) Automation for Bonterra Impact Management (fka Social Soluti...Jeffrey Haguewood
Sidekick Solutions uses Bonterra Impact Management (fka Social Solutions Apricot) and automation solutions to integrate data for business workflows.
We believe integration and automation are essential to user experience and the promise of efficient work through technology. Automation is the critical ingredient to realizing that full vision. We develop integration products and services for Bonterra Case Management software to support the deployment of automations for a variety of use cases.
This video focuses on the notifications, alerts, and approval requests using Slack for Bonterra Impact Management. The solutions covered in this webinar can also be deployed for Microsoft Teams.
Interested in deploying notification automations for Bonterra Impact Management? Contact us at sales@sidekicksolutionsllc.com to discuss next steps.
Dev Dives: Train smarter, not harder – active learning and UiPath LLMs for do...UiPathCommunity
💥 Speed, accuracy, and scaling – discover the superpowers of GenAI in action with UiPath Document Understanding and Communications Mining™:
See how to accelerate model training and optimize model performance with active learning
Learn about the latest enhancements to out-of-the-box document processing – with little to no training required
Get an exclusive demo of the new family of UiPath LLMs – GenAI models specialized for processing different types of documents and messages
This is a hands-on session specifically designed for automation developers and AI enthusiasts seeking to enhance their knowledge in leveraging the latest intelligent document processing capabilities offered by UiPath.
Speakers:
👨🏫 Andras Palfi, Senior Product Manager, UiPath
👩🏫 Lenka Dulovicova, Product Program Manager, UiPath
Connector Corner: Automate dynamic content and events by pushing a buttonDianaGray10
Here is something new! In our next Connector Corner webinar, we will demonstrate how you can use a single workflow to:
Create a campaign using Mailchimp with merge tags/fields
Send an interactive Slack channel message (using buttons)
Have the message received by managers and peers along with a test email for review
But there’s more:
In a second workflow supporting the same use case, you’ll see:
Your campaign sent to target colleagues for approval
If the “Approve” button is clicked, a Jira/Zendesk ticket is created for the marketing design team
But—if the “Reject” button is pushed, colleagues will be alerted via Slack message
Join us to learn more about this new, human-in-the-loop capability, brought to you by Integration Service connectors.
And...
Speakers:
Akshay Agnihotri, Product Manager
Charlie Greenberg, Host
The Art of the Pitch: WordPress Relationships and SalesLaura Byrne
Clients don’t know what they don’t know. What web solutions are right for them? How does WordPress come into the picture? How do you make sure you understand scope and timeline? What do you do if sometime changes?
All these questions and more will be explored as we talk about matching clients’ needs with what your agency offers without pulling teeth or pulling your hair out. Practical tips, and strategies for successful relationship building that leads to closing the deal.
Let's dive deeper into the world of ODC! Ricardo Alves (OutSystems) will join us to tell all about the new Data Fabric. After that, Sezen de Bruijn (OutSystems) will get into the details on how to best design a sturdy architecture within ODC.
2. 2
DIALOGUE INFORMATION PACK1
Global Transition Dialogue #2 on the New Economy, Saturday 17 and 18 March 2012
Pace University, 18th Floor, 163 William Street, New York City, 10038
Dear Delegate 17th March 2012
It is with great pleasure that we welcome you to the Global Transition 2012 Dialogue on the new economy. This two day
dialogue, just ahead of the Rio +20 informal and intersessional, will bring you together with other thinkers, practitioners,
government and non-governmental stakeholders to develop ideas and generate solutions to the question of how we will
transition to the new economy. In light of the policy discussions for Rio +20, an important element of this dialogue is the
green economy in the context of sustainable development and poverty eradication, and so we hope you find this Dialogue
fruitful and informative.
Enclosed you will find a number of resources for the two-day Dialogue as well as a CD with all think pieces, background
papers, and challenge papers, that will be useful from now until Rio +20 – and beyond.
The papers will offer an in depth analysis of some of the key issues that will be discussed over the next few days and will, we
hope, enrich your discussions and debates.
We thank you for joining us and our colleagues, partners, and sponsors at this, the second Dialogue in the Global Transition
2012 series. We hope you find the dialogue useful and informative which has the shared aim of developing alternative
solutions to redress inequalities and global environmental change.
Kindest regards,
Felix Dodds Stewart Wallis
Executive Director, Stakeholder Forum Executive Director, nef (the new economics foundation)
1 This information pack has been printed on recycled paper by the Village Group, New York City
3. 3
CONTENTS
ABOUT THE GLOBAL TRANSITION 2012 INITIATIVE ……………………………………………………………. 5
GLOBAL TRANSITION 2012 DIALOGUE # 1
GLOBAL TRANSITION 2012 DIALOGUE # 2
PURPOSE OF THE DIALOGUES
DIALOGUE PANELLISTS AND SPEAKERS…………………………………………………………………………... 6
DIALOGUE PARTICIPANTS………………………………………………………………………………………….. 7
GLOBAL TRANSITION DIALOGUE #2 AGENDA……………………………………………………………………. 11
QUESTIONS to frame the day
FORMAT of the Plenary Sessions
DAY ONE: SATURDAY 17 MARCH, 13.30 – 18.00……………………………………………………………….... 12
SCENE SETTING: where are we in both policy terms and on the ground?
DAY TWO: 18th March, 10.30-16.00……………………………………………………………………………… 13
THE NEW ECONOMY IN PRACTICE: Practical development of the Rio +20 green economy
initiatives
GLOBAL TRANSITION 2012 DIALOGUE #2 BACKGROUND PAPERS SUMMARIES…………………………… 14
Making the Green Economy a Tool for Equity and Sustainable Development - Danish 92 Group
Analysis of zero draft submissions: Briefings on roadmaps and principles - Stakeholder Forum
Information Note on proposed Principles for a Green Economy – Green Economy Coalition and ITUC
A Green Economy Knowledge Sharing Platform: Exploring Options – United Nations Division of Sustainable
Development
Thematic briefing papers on the green economy - United National Environment Programme
GLOBAL TRANSITION 2012 CHALLENGE PAPERS ………………………………………………………………... 15
Green Economy – Tim Jenkins and Andrew Simms
Global Inequality - David Woodward, Saamah Abdallah
Beyond GDP - Charles Seaford, Sorcha Mahoney, Mathis Wackernagel, Joy Larson, Réne Ramírez
Gallegos
One Planet Living - Sue Riddlestone
Blue economy (oceans and fisheries) - Rupert Crilly, Aniol Esteban
Global Trade and outsourced emissions - Guy Shrubsole
Green and Decent Jobs and Skills - Anabella Rosemberg with Philip Pearson
4. 4
Energy resources and services - Viki Johnson, Niclas Hälström
Sustainable Agriculture and Food security - Aksel Nærstad
Global Finances and Banking - Simon Zadek
Valuing Natural Capital and Biodiversity/Ecosystems Services - Oliver Greenfield
ZERO DRAFT OF THE OUTCOME DOCUMENT FOR RIO +20 ……………………………………………………… 21
VENUE………………………………………………………………………………………………………............................... 22
About Pace University
Catering – sustainability policies
GLOBAL TRANSITION 2012 DIALOGUE #2 SUPPORTING ORGANISATIONS………………………………..... 23
SPONSPRHIP…………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 23
ABOUT THE GLOBAL TRANSITION 2012 COORDINATING ORGANISATIONS ………………………………..... 24
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS……………………………………………………………………………………………… 25
5. 5
ABOUT the Global Transition 2012 Initiative
The goal of the Global Transition 2012 Initiative is to achieve an outcome from the UNCSD Earth Summit 2012 that catalyses
a global transition to an economy that maximizes wellbeing, operates within environmental limits, and is capable of coping
and adapting to global environmental change in an equitable manner.
The aim of the Initiative is to build a global stakeholder movement that brings together governments and multilateral
agencies, non-governmental organisations, civil society organisations and other leading thinkers and practitioners to promote
alternative models of the economy that can deliver sustainable development to people, countries, and present and future
generations. This builds on and integrates the three pillars of sustainable development: social, environmental, and economic.
Stakeholder Forum and nef (the new economics foundation) are working in partnership with the New Economics Institute
and the Green Economy Coalition and to develop the Global Transition 2012 initiative towards the UN Conference on
Sustainable Development 2012 (Rio+20), and to bring the core concepts of achieving such a transition into the heart of the
process – through publishing ‘challenge papers’ and running dialogue workshops on the key issues.
Global Transition 2012 Dialogue # 1
New York, 13th October 2011: This one day event, hosted at the New Economics Institute, bought together 25 of the lead
authors, peer reviewers and other experts to discuss the ideas and proposals that had has been developed from the
Challenge Papers, and identify principles for the Global Transition to a Green Economy.
Following the dialogue, a core advocacy group presented initial findings from the dialogue to the Rio +20 secretariat – UN
DESA – as well as G77 missions to the UN and members of the Rio +20 bureau. This was an opportunity to test the
robustness of the outputs of the dialogue and develop the policy aspects of the
The emerging principles and policy recommendations from the day were synthesised into the Global Transition-Green
Economy element of the Stakeholder Forum submission to the UN zero draft. The zero draft will form the basis of the
negotiating text for the Rio+20 preparatory meetings, held between January and May 2012, resulting in the various outcomes
of Rio itself.
Global Transition 2012 Dialogue # 2
This weekend - March 17th and 18th - the Global Transition 2012 is hosting the second Global Transition Dialogue on the
new economy in collaboration with the following organisations:
CIVICUS New Economics Institute
Centre for Environment and Development (Sri Lanka) nrg4SD
Danish 92 Group Stakeholder Forum for a Sustainable Future
Green Economy Coalition UNDESA
Instituto Vitae Civilis UNDP
International Trade Union Confederation UNEP
new economics foundation (nef) UNITAR
UN-NGLS
Purpose of the Dialogue
A Global Transition from an economy that is unsustainable to one that supports wellbeing, equality, and operates within
environmental limits equitably is essential to achieving sustainable development. In light of the ‘priority areas’ of the green
economy in the context of sustainable development and poverty eradication that have been identified in the zero draft for Rio
+20 process so far, the Global Transition Dialogue will focus on practical and implementable approaches to these key areas.
The Dialogue will provide a forum for a range of actors to ‘cluster’ around some of the priority areas and develop thinking on
how the transition can be achieved for each.
6. 6
DIALOGUE PANELLISTS AND SPEAKERS
First name Last name Organisation
Derek Osborn Co-chair of Rio +5, former DG of UK Environment Ministry
Soledad Ghione Latin American Center of Social Ecology
Veerle Vandeweerd Director, Environment and Energy Group, UNDP
Victoria Johnson Head of Energy and Climate, new economics foundation
Tara Rao Lead author, Danish 92 group
Aron Belinky Coordinator, International Processes, Vitae Civilis
Nicole Leotaud CANARI
Vijay Chaturvedi Development Alternatives
Liz Thompson Executive Coordinator, Rio +20
Oliver Greenfield Coordinator, Green Economy Coalition
Anabella Rosemberg Senior Policy Adviser, International Trade Union Confederacy
Rick Clugstone Earth Charter
Carina Millstone Program Director, New Economics Institute
Jeff Huffines UN Representative, CIVICUS
Daniel Abreu National Climate Change Council of the Dominican Republic
Paul Dickinson Chairman, Carbon Disclosure Project
Fulai Sheng Senior Economist at UNEP’s Economics and Trade Branch
Roshni Dave Training Associate, UNITAR
Cameron Allen Associate expert – Green Economy, UN DESA
Farooq Ullah Head of Policy and Advocacy, Stakeholder Forum
Nis Christensen Chief Advisor to the Minister - Head of Rio+20 Secretariat, Danish Government
Dr Greg Julian Professor of Political Science, Pace University
Kirsty Schneeberger Global Transition Coordinator, Stakeholder Forum
7. 7
DIALOGUE PARTICIPANTS
First Name Last Name Organisation
Abayomi
Egbowon Moses BELS-MIRAL.NIG.LTD
Peter Adriance Baha'is of the U.S.
Faisal Alhashidi Dar Al-Salam Organization – CSON
Onuorah Aligbe Fight Against Desert Encroachment (FADE) Africa
Sena Alouka
Robynne Anderson
Maureen Anthony UNIVERSITY OF GLASGOW
Pauline Augustine
Barlach
Vivian Albertini New Economics Institute
Ed Barry
Jim Barton Smith Mill Creek Institute
Marlon Becker Ramapo College
Emily Benson Green Economy Coalition
Gerard Beralus
Genie Birch University of Pennsylvania
Eleanor Blomstrom
Marcia Borland The Young Women's Leadership School
Flore-Anne Bourgeois UNDP
Alexa Bradley On the Commons
Jocelyn Carino Tebtebba
Erica Carroll Christian Aid
Kim Carstensen Fairgreensolutions
Camilla Carstensen Fairgreensolutions
Maria Antonieta Castro-Cosio The New School
Stephen Chacha World Society for the Protection of Animals – WSPA
Rebecca Chan Columbia University
Voices of African Mothers/Rio+20 Women's Major Group Steering
Cecile Charles-King Committee
Patricia Connolly
Betty Cremmins CDP
Joey Cummings The Joey Company
Amy Cutter Stakeholder Forum
Elenita Dano Action Group on Erosion, Technology and Concentration (ETC Group)
Madhav Datt Green the Gene
Roshni Dave UNITAR
Eduardo De La Torre Permanent Mission of Mexico to the UN
Albert DETERVILLE THE ALDET CENTRE-SAINT LUCIA
Gbemiga Djossou
8. 8
Christophe
Felix Dodds Stakeholder Forum
Lauren Eastwood
Alf Christian Egge Norwegian Forum for Development and Environment
Jill Emerson Cornerstone Studio
Fatchima
Noura Djibrilla Association Nigérienne des Scouts de l'Environnement (ANSEN)
Olivia Frazao Mission Markets
Manuel GARABITO Permeant Mission of the Dominican Republic
Jairo Garcia
Soledad Ghione Latin American Center for Social Ecology
Mary Gilbert Quaker Earthcare Witness
Nathan Gilbert B Lab
Bakari Giorgadze
Sara Hambleton Amberjack solar energy
Duncan Hanks Baha'i Community of Canada
James Hanusa Stakeholder Forum
Grove Harris Interfaith Consortium for Ecological Civilization
Peter Hazlewood World Resources Institute
Johannes (John) Hontelez FSC International
Elisa Hugueney ActionAid
George Jambiya Danish 92 Group
Moses Jaokoo
Newton Jibunoh Fight Against Desert Encroachment
Victoria Johnson new economics foundation
Richard Jordan Intl. Council for Caring Communities
Eak Bahadur K.C.
Francis Keya
Aashish Khullar
Julie Kim U.S. Mission to the United Nations
Joan Kirby Temple of Understanding
Marcelo Kos Brazilian Chemical Industry Association – Abiquim
Georgios Kostakos United Nations Secretariat
Natalia Kostus IUCN
Plapa Koukpamou Young Volunteers for the Environment
Irene Krarup V. Kann Rasmussen Foundation
Srinivas Krishnaswamy Danish 92 Group
Rina Kuusipalo Harvard University
Krystal Laymon Columbia University
Bette Levy Soroptimist International
Jeannet Lingan Stakeholder Forum
David Livingston Carnegie Endowment for International Peace
9. 9
Patrick Lokwa Dueme INFOGROUP INTERANATIONAL
Georgie Macdonald Stakeholder Forum
Catherine Marcuccio FINRA
Laura Martin Murillo International Labour Foundation for Sustainable Development
Enrique Martinez Rhode Island School of Design
Livia Martini SustainAbility
Carina Millstone The New Economics Institute
Predrag Milosevic Economics
Mitachi
Mireille Kamana INFOGROUP INTERNATIONAL /SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT
Keneilwe Moseki Somarelang Tikologo
Barkha Mossae N/A
Anil Naidoo Blue Planet Project
Tanya Naiken St. John's University
Julia Naime World information transfer
George Ndungu
BIORESOURCES DEVELOPMENT AND CONSERVATION
Augustine B. Njamnshi PROGRAMME
Haron Oichoe
Jeremy Osborn
Daniel Perell Baha'i International Community
Miroslav Polzer
Kathleen Quain
Paul Quintos IBON
Tara Rao Danish 92 Group
Patricia Reis
Fatima Rodrigo International Presentation Association
Traci Romine Danish 92 Group
Anabella Rosemberg Trade Union Advisory Committee/ ITUC
Mayumi Sakoh World Society for the Protection of Animals
Ana Belen Sanchez Lopez International Labour Foundation for Sustainable Development
Andrew Schwartz
Freya Seath BioRegional
Diallo Shabazz Radical Ideas
Fulai Sheng UNEP
Catarina Faria
Alves Silveira International Labour Foundation for Sustainable Development
Sarah Singh Self
Melanie Sluyter Human Impacts Institute, MobilizeUS!, Occupy Earth Summit
Rose Sona Nzuanzu INFOGROUP INTERNATIONAL
Steven Stone UNEP
Jan-Gustav Strandenaes Stakeholder Forum
Sebastian Straube IOB
10. 10
Lo Sze Ping Danish 92 Group
Kirubel Teshome Tadele ETC Group
Kirubel Teshome ETC Group
Shin-Pei Tsay Carnegie Endowment for International Peace
Farooq Ullah Stakeholder Forum
Katherine Vargas Perth Amboy Bord of education
Ashwani Vasishth Ramapo College of New Jersey
Russell Weiss-Irwin Quaker Earthcare Witness
Willice Okoth Onyango IYCC
Ayse Yonder Pratt Institute PSPD
11. 11
GLOBAL TRANSITION DIALOGUE #2 AGENDA
QUESTIONS to frame the day
The two day dialogue will offer a chance for you to share your experiences as much as it will give you the chance to hear
from leading thinkers, practitioners, and experts in the field. To help frame the day, below is a list of a few questions that you
can answer in your roundtable sessions, and to also bear in mind when asking questions in the plenary sessions.
Green economy in the context of sustainable development and poverty eradication
The following questions will help to frame the overall discussions and ultimately are key elements of a transition to a
sustainable economy:
1) In what ways are green economy policies delivering poverty reduction?
2) How can we create resilient and resource-efficient sectors and industries?
Your experiences
Your experiences are very important to the dialogue, and will deepen the discussions. Please do share them with your
roundtables:
1. Your experience of the green economy at the national and local levels: What were the key elements of the project or
initiative you are involved in? Who else did it involve? What did you learn? What has happened since? What are the next
steps?
2. Based on your experience of the national/local level, are there any examples/glimpses of a green economy
transition already underway? E.g. valuing of ecosystems in national decision making?; introduction of more sustainable
infrastructure/transport systems?; or, natural resource management schemes that are helping to provide jobs and protect
local ecosystems?; or, introduction of new renewable energy supplies?; or green jobs schemes funded by the local council or
government?, etc.
3. In what ways are those different glimpses of a green economy helping the lives of the poorest communities? If
they are not, then what needs to change to ensure that the poor do benefit?
FORMAT of the Plenary Sessions
All plenary sessions will include presentations from a variety of speakers offering a range of perspectives. Following
presentations there will be a short Q & A from the audience participants.
After each short Q & A there will be time for participants to share reflections and reactions on their roundtables - these
breakout sessions will offer participants the chance to respond and reflect on the presentations and share their own
experiences.
The host on each table will then have the opportunity to feed back to the rest of the Dialogue participants in the ‘wrap up
session’ at the end of each day.
12. 12
DAY ONE: SATURDAY 17 MARCH, 13.30 – 18.00, followed by an evening reception
SCENE SETTING: where are we in both policy terms and on the ground?
Welcome Refreshments from 13.00
13.30 – 14.00 Welcome - Derek Osborn (Co-chair of Rio +5, former DG of UK
Setting the scene Environment Ministry)
Overview of the two days - Kirsty Schneeberger (Global Transition Coordinator)
14.00 – 15.00 Panel debate Panel debate, followed by roundtable discussions
Can the ‘green economy in the context of - Soledad Ghione (Latin American Center of Social
sustainable development and poverty Ecology)
eradication’ deliver? - Veerle Vanderweed (Director of the Group of Energy
and Environment, UNDP)
- Victoria Johnson (Head of Energy and Climate, new
economics foundation)
- Tara Rao (Lead author, Danish 92 group)
Chair: Aron Belinky (Coordinator, International
Processes, Vitae Civilis)
Coffee Break: 15.00 – 15.15
15.15 – 16.15 Plenary presentations Presentations, followed by roundtable discussions
Stories of the emerging new economy: - Nicole Leotaud (CANARI)
Presenting stories of new and green economy - Aron Belinky (Coordinator, International Processes,
initiatives from around the world. A grass roots Vitae Civilis)
approach. - Vijay Chaturvedi (Development Alternatives)
- Carina Millstone (Program Director New Economics
Institute)
Chair: Liz Thompson (Executive Coordinator, Rio
+20)
16.15 – 17.30 Plenary presentations (20minutes) followed Presentations, followed by roundtable discussions
by roundtable breakout discussions - Oliver Greenfield (Green Economy Coalition)
- Anabella Rosemberg (ITUC)
Principles for a new economy _Rick Clugstone (Earth Charter)
Chair: Jeff Huffines (CIVICUS UN Representative)
17.30 – 18.00 Plenary Feedback from chairs of roundtable discussions
Wrap up session: a synthesis of the day’s Derek Osborn: (Co-chair of Rio +5, former DG of UK
achievements Environment Ministry)
Overall wrap up
18:00 – 19:30 Evening reception and key note address from Liz Thompson, Executive Coordinator Rio +20
13. 13
DAY TWO: 18th March, 10.30-16.00
THE NEW ECONOMY IN PRACTICE: Practical development of the Rio +20 green economy initiatives
Welcome Refreshments from 10.00
10:30 – 10:45 Refresh of Day One - Derek Osborn (Co-chair of Rio +5, former DG of UK
Overview and plan for Day Two Environment Ministry)
- Kirsty Schneeberger (Global Transition Coordinator)
10.45 – 11.45 Plenary Panel debate, followed by roundtable discussions
- Daniel Abreu (National Climate Change Council of
Enabling conditions: the Dominican Republic)
How to foster a green transition, including Learning and Skills
learning and skills development, and - Paul Dickinson (Chairman, Carbon Disclosure
transparent and participatory governance? A Project)
systemic exploration of barriers to change and Convention for CSRA
addressing them. - Fulai Sheng (Senior Economist at UNEP’s
Economics and Trade Branch)
Briefings on the thematic areas
Chair: Roshni Dave (Training Associate UNITAR)
11.45 – 13.00 Roundtables Roundtables
Focussed roundtable discussions around key - Facilitator offers a short presentation
areas relating to the green economy: - Input from table participants
Sustainable Consumption & Production;Energy;
Green jobs ; Financial reform; Food; Cities;
Oceans; Water.
Brunch 13.00 – 14.00
14.00 – 15.00 Plenary Presentations, followed by roundtable discussions
Knowledge sharing and mapping the green - Cameron Allen (Associate expert – Green Economy,
economy: Developing thinking around an UN DESA)
international knowledge sharing platform to A Green Economy Knowledge Sharing Platform
support policy and action in countries, hosting - Farooq Ullah (Head of Policy and Advocacy,
for example, toolkits. Do we need a roadmap? Stakeholder Forum)
15.00 – 15.15 Reflections on the day and moving forward Nis Christensen (Chief Advisor to the Minister - Head
into the informals and intersessionals of Rio+20 Secretariat, Danish Government)
15.15 - 15.45 Plenary Feedback from chair of roundtables
Wrap up session: a synthesis of the day’s Derek Osborn (Co-chair of Rio +5, former DG of UK
achievements Environment Ministry)
15.45 – 16.00 Closing remarks and thanks Dr Greg Julian (Pace University)
14. 14
GLOBAL TRANSITION 2012 DIALOGUE #2 - BACKGROUND PAPER SUMMARIES
The Global Transition Dialogue #2 papers that will inform the discussions will be hosted at the Global Transition 2012 online
platform at http://globaltransition2012.org/dialogues/global-transition-dialogue-2-on-the-new-economy-resources/?ref=elink
The papers are also recorded on the CD enclosed in this Global Transition 2012 Dialogue #2 pack.
Building an equitable green economy - Danish 92 Group
This paper is the product of an independent, Southern drafting group commissioned by the Danish 92 Group. It lays out a
Southern perspective on how a Green Economy as discussed in the Rio + 20 context must be designed to contribute to –
rather than distract from – sustainable development.
Analysis of zero draft submissions: Briefings on roadmaps and principles - Stakeholder Forum
Using analysis of the official submissions to the Zero Draft, these briefing papers provide insight into two key concepts that
have emerged in relation to the green economy: roadmaps and principles. The papers highlight the stakeholder groups that
are engaged with these concepts, summarise the proposals that have been put forward, and explore how the discussions
around green economy roadmaps and principles fit into the Outcome Document.
Information Note on proposed Principles for a Green Economy – Green Economy Coalition and ITUC
At the UNEP Governing Council, thirty stakeholder organisations came together to draft a set of 9 principles for a green
economy. These 9 principles were then opened up as an online consultation to generate wider input from global
stakeholders. To date, 115 organisations from across the globe have contributed. The consultation will remain an open
process until Rio 2012 whereby the Green Economy Coalition will be hosting a global workshop on how to catalyse and
ensure the implementation of the principles for a green economy. This information note summarises the 9 green economy
principles and presents some highlights from the consultation so far.
A Green Economy Knowledge-Sharing Platform: Exploring Options – United Nations Division of Sustainable
Development
A potential deliverable that has emerged from the submissions to the Rio+20 compilation document is for the elaboration and
implementation of country-specific green economy strategies or the mainstreaming of the green economy into existing
development strategies. To assist with the development of such strategies, many submissions to the Zero Draft underline the
need to share experiences, lessons learned and good practices with regard to the implementation of green economy
policies. Some submissions go further to propose that Rio+20 should deliver a green economy knowledge-sharing platform
or a toolbox, toolkit or menu of policy options. This paper explores the aims and objectives, governance arrangements and
structural components that could make up a green economy knowledge-sharing platform.
This information note is intended to be a discussion paper around the proposal and will evolve as thinking develops in this
area during – and outside of -informal discussions and negotiations
Briefings on the green economy - United National Environment Programme
UNEP is launching a series of policy briefs on the green economy at the Global Transition 2012 Dialogue #2. These short
four page briefing papers focus on key issues for the transformation towards the Green Economy including:
Poverty Reduction
Continuing with business-as-usual is not an option in a world of increasing environmental scarcities, growing economic
uncertainty and inequalities, and the continued existence of widespread poverty. The Millennium Development Goal of
halving extreme poverty is still far from reach despite decades of economic growth and efforts for poverty eradication.
15. 15
Advisory Services
For governments, having a clear assessment of resource constraints and ecological risks they face, as well as a sound
understanding of sectors of their economies that offer the largest potential for green growth, employment creation and
efficiency gains, while securing public support, are critical to orient public policy. UNEP’s green economy advisory services
are geared towards providing tailored support to countries for them to take appropriate responses
Health
In the transition path towards the green economy, health is a powerful tool and a key precondition in harnessing sustainable
economic development, as well as in eradicating poverty and in ensuring an economically equitable and socially inclusive
society.
Indicators
Building on the existing indicators, UNEP, in consultation with national and other international agencies and stakeholders, is
developing options for measuring progress towards a green and inclusive economy
Trade
Trade has the potential to drive a green economy by fostering the exchange of environmentally friendly goods and services,
increasing resource efficiency, generating economic opportunities and employment, and contributing to poverty eradication.
If managed poorly, however, unrestrained trade can contribute to environmental degradation, unsustainable resource use,
and increased wealth disparities, all of which hinder a green economy transition and sustainable development objectives.
Finance
The financing required for a green economy transition is substantial, but it can be mobilized by smart public policy and
innovative financing mechanisms. Supportive public finance and policy, the growing green orientation of capital markets, and
the evolution of emerging market instruments are opening up the space for large-scale financing that will bolster national
initiatives to green economies. But these flows are still small compared to total volumes, and urgently need to be magnified
for the transition to be successful in the near-term
Employment
One of the key challenges facing policymakers in transforming their economies is creating decent and meaningful
employment. According to the International Labor Organization (ILO), over 600 million new jobs would be needed in the next
10 years.
Valuing nature
At a more fundamental level, healthy ecosystems represent the foundation of economic activity and a prerequisite for
achieving a green economic transition. Given this, it is essential that the economic value of these services are recognized,
demonstrated and captured in the accounts and decision-making of governments, the private sector and consumers.
16. 16
GLOBAL TRANSITION 2012 CHALLENGE PAPERS
Dialogue #2 builds upon earlier work of the Global Transition 2012 initiative and available online. A series of peer
reviewed challenge papers are available on key themes of the Global Transition to the new economy online:
http://globaltransition2012.org/challenge-papers/ and included in the CD in this pack.
Green Economy – Tim Jenkins and Andrew Simms2
Two decades after the Earth Summit in 1992, attempts to govern, sustainably, the global environment and manage the world
economy without destabilising crises, are hopelessly disconnected. Since the original Earth Summit conference we have
lived with an economic model based on debt-fuelled over consumption that co-exists with vast levels of poverty and
inequality. Comparable dynamics are visible in most economic sectors. Many working in the fields of environment and
development now find that systematic problems require a systemic solution.
This paper puts forward 6 challenges to lay the foundations for systemic change: Develop a national transition plan that puts
countries on paths to operate within planetary boundaries, and on timescales sufficiently quick to preserve key, ecological life
support functions; don’t start from a growth perspective; agree to develop and implement new measures of economic
success; commit to reduce income and wealth inequalities between and within nations; put fiscal policy and public
expenditure centre stage in managing economic transition; and recapture the financial sector for the public good. Other
worlds are possible but the task is to shape and fashion them in the course of the next decade before ‘business-as-usual’
locks in catastrophic climatic upheaval.
Global Inequality - David Woodward3, Saamah Abdallah4
This paper proposes the establishment of a “plenty line” as a counterpart to the poverty line, as a means of focusing public
and political attention on the issue of over-consumption. In other words, is there a level of income such that people with
incomes above this level have minimally greater well-being than those with incomes at this level?
While our analysis is complicated by the nature of the data available (viz. its reliance on self-reporting of income, and more
specifically self-attribution to a limited range of income bands) and the relatively small sample sizes in most relevant surveys,
we find indicative evidence for the existence of “plenty lines” ranging between household incomes of $35,000 and $107,000
in six Western European countries (and at $20,000 in one Eastern European country), where well-being is defined in terms
of life satisfaction. While the reliability of these findings for individual countries is limited by the sample sizes, the fact that in
only one of 22 countries (Switzerland) do the data appear clearly inconsistent with the existence of an (overall income) plenty
line at some level of income would appear to suggest that such a line exists in at least some European countries. So, while
we cannot yet identify where the plenty line lies with great precision, it seems clear that there is one. This is consistent with
research in the United States which showed that there was no increase in well-being (defined in terms of affect) once
household incomes reached $75,000.
This suggests a case for policies designed to limit the growth of incomes beyond societal plenty lines – primarily higher
incomes in developed countries (but also those of elites, particularly in highly unequal middle-income developing countries).
However, the implications of the plenty line concept potentially reach much further. By highlighting – and potentially allowing
us to quantify – the divergence between total income and societal well-being, the plenty line has the potential to provide a
basis for a whole new economics, directed towards the achievement of our ultimate goals as society and not merely the
maximisation of total production.
2 Independent Researcher and Fellow, nef (the new economics foundation)
3 Independent Researcher and Fellow, nef (the new economics foundation)
4 Centre for Well-Being, nef (the new economics foundation)
17. 17
Beyond GDP - Charles Seaford5, Sorcha Mahoney1, Mathis Wackernagel6, Joy Larson2, Réne Ramírez Gallegos7
For decades governments have allowed a single indicator, Gross Domestic Product (GDP), to assume dominance as the
critical measure of a nation’s progress. It is now widely recognised by politicians and officials across the world that we must
move beyond GDP and recognise it for what it is – a measure of economic exchange, which is itself a means to an end; the
‘end’ being the achievement of high well-being for all within environmental limits (‘sustainable well-being’).
Here, we focus on ways of measuring environmental sustainability and well-being, as well as offering a view from the global
South which entails measures of both of these. We call for governments around the world to:
Amend their national accounting systems to align what they measure with what really matters, and
Use those measures as a guide for policy and political action.
First we outline the conceptual and measurement frameworks used, which draw on the work of nef, and in particular on the
Centre for Well-being’s publication Measuring our Progress. Second, we address measuring environmental sustainability.
Third we examine the measurement of human well-being. Finally, we present a proposal by René Ramirez Gallegos,
National Secretary of Planning of Development in Ecuador, for the measurement of Buen Vivir, or Good Living.
Once governments move beyond GDP to measure what matters, they can turn their attention to the equally important
business of ensuring that these new measures are used as the basis of policy and political action. Then, the global
community can be hopeful that lives really will improve and that improvements are made within environmental limits.
One Planet Living - Sue Riddlestone8
If everyone lived the global middle class lifestyle of London or Shanghai we would need three planets to support us. And yet,
the average citizen of Bangladesh consumes the equivalent of just a third of a planet. In this paper we argue that what we
need is One Planet Living, a way of life that engenders happy healthy lives within a fair share of the world’s resources, whilst
leaving sufficient space for wildlife and wilderness. Sustainable communities and businesses around the world show how
One Planet Living is attractive and achievable. And, a simple approach and framework makes it easy to deliver. We argue
that at The Earth Summit 2012, world leaders should agree to recognise planetary boundaries in world with a large, growing
human population and commit to take action through a multilateral framework to enable the world to define and deliver a safe
operating space within the time frame that science and morality tell us is necessary. Key components of this multilateral
framework would include: Global and national roadmaps to enable citizens to achieve One Planet Living supported by a new
‘Intergovernmental Panel on Resources’; a peer-reviewed ‘Solutions Bank’; and a raft of policy solutions to support the
transition to a One Planet Living with a fair and green economy.
Blue economy (oceans and fisheries) - Rupert Crilly9, Aniol Esteban 8
The marine world has been a cornerstone of human economic activity for centuries. Once the realm of inexhaustible
abundance, the Blue Economy has become one of scarcity and unsustainable human impacts. Fisheries, for example, are
plagued by endemic overfishing, discarding, and an increasingly inefficient and subsidy-dependent fishing industry. Marine
resources, from fish to broader ecosystem services, should be used for public benefit. Using profits or financial returns alone
rarely serve as complete indicators of an activity’s public value, and can in some cases be entirely misleading. Alternative
uses of marine resources must be independently weighed against each other based on their economic, social and
environmental impacts, particularly with an emphasis on sustainability. To make them comparable, it can be helpful to
monetise these impacts using an extended cost-benefit analysis framework. We illustrate this with a case study of cod fishing
5 Centre for Well-Being, nef (the new economics foundation)
6 Global Footprint Network
7 National Secretary for Planning and Development, Ecuador. See “El vivir (bien) como riqueza de las sociedades. Hacia una socio-ecología pol{itica del
tiempo”, Senplades
8 Sue Riddlestone, Director of BioRegional and Freya Seath, Researcher for the Director
9 Centre for Interdependence, Natural Economies Programme, nef (the new economics foundation)
18. 18
in the North Sea, where the principles are equally applicable not just in global fisheries but all marine resources. With a
complete picture of their associated impacts, economic activities and their public resource requirements can then be planned
to ensure the most beneficial ones are prioritised with access to marine resources.
Global Trade and outsourced emissions - Guy Shrubsole10
Outsourced emissions are a major loophole in current efforts to tackle climate change and build a green economy.
International flows of carbon embedded in trade have grown considerably since the original Rio summit, with developed
northern nations benefiting unjustly from effectively outsourcing pollution to developing southern states.
Next year in Rio, the world needs to agree to the principle of Clean Trade Agreements. These arrangements, negotiated
between states and regions, would come to replace Free Trade Areas and build mutually-agreed carbon constraints into the
terms of trade.
Clean Trade Agreements would aim to halt the ‘race to the bottom’ witnessed as globalisation has unfolded – where industry
invariably migrates to regions with the least stringent environmental regulations – and reverse the growth in outsourced
emissions.
Green and Decent Jobs and Skills - Anabella Rosemberg11 with Philip Pearson12
When leaders meet in Rio de Janeiro for the Earth Summit in June this year, unemployment, precarious work and inequality
will be central to their domestic agendas. At the same time, global environmental change is increasing stress on the most
vulnerable, affecting all domains of society. If the Summit is going to deliver for people, it needs to take all these elements
into account. It will also need to take concrete steps that will lead to changes on the ground.
The proposal presented in this Challenge Paper calls on all governments to take a country-based ‘policy package’ to Rio+20.
This should include a target on decent job creation in the next 5-10 years, achieved by environmentally-friendly investments
and regulations accounting for 2% of GDP, and a series of social and decent work policies which will ensure green jobs
contribute to workers’ and communities’ prosperity.
Generating millions of new green and decent jobs and transforming existing ones into more greener and more decent ones
could be one of the most positive consequences of a Rio+20 summit. This agenda could kick start the Global Transition,
giving people hope about the positive impacts of a more sustainable society, particularly those suffering from poverty,
precarious employment or unemployment.
A green/decent job pledge would also be part of a solution to environmental and social imbalances created by the current
unsustainable production mode. This would occur by driving a new kind of investments in developing countries whilst giving
them access to a new model of development.
Energy resources and services - Viki Johnson13, Niclas Hälström 14
Three perspectives frame this challenge paper: 1) energy is at the very core of sustainable development, and not just a
sector among others; 2) the combined challenges of inadequate access to energy among the world’s poor, the imperative to
avoid climate catastrophe and the need to deal with rising and volatile energy prices require an unprecedented, fundamental
transformation of the world’s energy system, and 3) that there are technological solutions that already exist that can
effectively tackle these challenges over the course of 10-15 years.
The wide development benefit from access to modern energy services, specifically electricity, implies this is a vital social
10 Director, Public Interest Research Centre (PIRC)
11 Policy Adviser, International Trade Union Confederation (ITUC) and Trade Union Advisory Committee to the OECD (TUAC)
12 Climate Change policy expert and adviser, Trade Union Confederacy
13 Centre for Interdependence, Climate Change and Energy Programme, nef (the new economics foundation)
14 What Next Forum
19. 19
investment. As such increase access to modern energy services should not be assessed on just the financial costs and
benefits alone, but rather a framework that takes into account the multiple additional benefits and/or costs of different energy
sources. In the following paper, we argue that it is not simply access to energy services that matters, but how that access is
delivered from the planning, installation and operation stage.
Further, we propose a bold, transformative approach to set up a global programme of national feed-in tariffs formulated by
UN-DESA and supported by an increasing number of organisations. We argue that:
Public policies can help produce a decline in the global price of renewable energy that will make it affordable within
a decade.
A “big push” in investment to scale up renewable energy will lead to rapid cost reduction, technology improvement,
and learning by doing. This will generate a “virtuous cycle” of additional investment, economic growth, employment
generation, etc.
In the first decade, investments will have to be subsidized through globally funded guarantees or price supports
(e.g. feed-in tariffs). The “virtuous cycle” will then make renewable energy the default option for new energy
investment worldwide.
Price supports will be complemented by a global extension program: research, technical, and policy support
designed to accelerate the process.
Energy and the kind of solution we outline here must be at the centre of the Earth Summit 2012 process, and that,
as a minimum, it provides an impetus to move along the lines we sketch out here.
Sustainable Agriculture and Food security - Aksel Nærstad15
Agriculture is the main problem in the nexus of food security. Industrial food systems and other unsustainable practices are
causing dramatic environmental damage, including reduction of biodiversity and soil fertility, overuse and pollution of water,
and are substantially contributing to climate change. These kinds of food systems and food production undermine the
possibilities for producing enough and healthy food for actual and future generations. At the same time these industrial food
systems impoverish millions of small-scale food producers, are creating increasingly bigger waves of poverty, hunger and
migration, and are causing health problems at a large scale. There are one billion people food insecure but at the same time
abundant unhealthy foods and diets are affecting at least 2 billion people, causing obesity, heart disease, cancer, type 2
diabetes and other diseases, and serious pandemics are likely to occur in the near future.
But, it is also the main solution. Viable food systems exist. They have evolved and adapted over millennia in traditional forms
of agriculture and are now more relevant than ever. They can be combined, if appropriate, with latest knowledge on agro
ecology and other forms of sustainable production. Small scale food producers provide the food for about 70% of the
population today, and small scale agroecological and other forms of sustainable agriculture and food production, developed
in the framework of food sovereignty, can
eliminate most of the hunger and poverty,
drastically reduce climate change and its impact, restore biodiversity, soil fertility and water resources,
improve livelihoods and provide rewarding employment for billions of people,
produce enough, high quality, diverse and nutritious food for 9 billion people or more.
Global Finances and Banking - Simon Zadek16
Current financial market reform efforts have focused on securing stable and resilient financial markets. The public purpose of
financial markets, however, concerns the resilience of the broader economic, social and ecological systems within which
15Senior policy adviser, The Development Fund, Norway (www.utviklingsfondet.no)
16Senior Fellow at the Centre for International Governance Innovation, and the Global Green Growth Institute. Views offered in this paper are exclusively
those of the author, who takes responsibility for errors and omissions.
20. 20
financial markets operate, a purpose largely ignored in the current policy debate and practice. Sustainable investing has
demonstrated proof of concept but will not have systemic impacts in its current forms and trajectories. Needed is a ‘public
fiduciary’ for financial markets that reflects more effectively the interests of existing, intended beneficiaries and also those
without influential voice: future generations, excluded communities and natural capital.
Advancing a public fiduciary for the world’s invested financial assets would require a multi-faceted programme of policy
interventions, including fiscal, regulatory and voluntary. Described here are six high-potential policy proposals focused on
changes in fund managers’ basis of remuneration, investors’ fiduciary arrangements, investment principles of sovereign
wealth funds, sovereign and corporate credit rating methods, fiscal interventions and transparency requirements. These
proposals are all based on existing practice that demonstrates technically feasibility and indications of likely impacts.
Advancing such an extensive, high-impact programme to secure an alignment of financial markets to sustainability outcomes
clearly requires further debate and analysis. Crucially, its implementation raises profound governance issues resulting from
the political influence of financial market actors, and associated and competitive constraints to co-ordinated action. Financial
market reform requires action on governance internationally if serious progress is to be made in the face of plain-to-see
threats and practice of regulatory arbitrage by leading actors in today’s financial markets.
Aligning financial markets to sustainability outcomes will not be easy, but without it, too little progress, too late, will be made
in shaping a sustainable economy. Progress will require real political and business leadership without at all levels and across
geographies and forums. Internationally, such leadership can be demonstrated for example through the UN High Level
Panel.
Valuing Natural Capital and Biodiversity/Ecosystems Services - Oliver Greenfield17
The natural world has a lot to teach us. Above all, it teaches us about systems and cycles; that altering one component of a
system, however small, can have wider implications within and beyond a given cycle. Human society, the planet and the
economy are all systems and are all bound together in intricate relationships. Only when we begin to understand this bigger
picture can we tackle the systemic problems facing us. Here we take a short journey through planetary science to grasp
some of the dimensions of those relationships, and posit a series of solutions for affecting the kind of systemic transformation
that we urgently need to ensure the health of the planet and of people.
Economic theory (and common sense) tells us that when something is valuable, and it is free, its use tends to infinity - this
explains why trees, biodiversity, freshwater and atmospheric space for carbon are all being used ‘like there is no tomorrow’.
It also assumes that when something is exhausted (or too expensive), a substitute is almost certain to be found.
Economic theory then takes this substitution concept up to a macro level and thinks of the ‘trade-off’ between environment
and economy. The logic is that we can have ‘more environment’ if we are prepared to put up with ‘less economy’, or we can
have ‘less environment’ if we want a bigger economy. The traditional economic world view that dominates the political
spectrum is based on infinite resources, substitution, and ultimately this trade-off between environment and economy.
In this paper we take a systemic view of natural capital and the role that it plays in sustaining the human species and our
economic system. We will start with a brief journey into planetary science then, taking stock of the solutions being offered by
current economic thinking, posit the role of green economy for transforming the current trajectory. Here, we are tackling
problems not from the perspective of ‘what is politically feasible?’ but from that of ‘what is absolutely necessary?’: what is
necessary in order to ensure that the operating system on which we all depend continues to provide people, communities
and all economic activity with a safe space in which to exist.
17 Convener, Green Economy Coalition.
21. 21
ZERO DRAFT OF THE OUTCOME DOCUMENT FOR RIO +20 – THE FUTURE WE WANT18
The second Rio+20 Preparatory Committee Meeting of the UNCSD (Rio +20) process invited all member States,
relevant United Nations (UN) system organisations, and relevant stakeholders to provide inputs and contributions
to the Secretariat in writing by 1 November 2011, for inclusion in a compilation text to be presented by the UN
secretariat to member States and other stakeholders for their comments and further guidance. This compilation
document served as the basis for the preparation of a Zero Draft of the outcome document, which was presented
for consideration to member States and other stakeholders in January 2012.
The Global Transition 2012 Dialogue #2 will focus primarily on Section III: Green Economy in the context of
sustainable development and poverty eradication, as well as aspects of Section V: Framework for action and
follow-up. However, many of the ideas, proposals, and discussions of the Dialogue will be cross-cutting in their
nature and may apply to other sections of the Zero Draft – as well as a broader context outside of the Rio +20
process.
I. Preamble/Stage setting
Vision
II. Renewing Political Commitment
A. Reaffirming Rio principles and past action plans
B. Assessing the progress to date and the remaining gaps in the implementation of the outcomes of the major
summits on sustainable development and addressing new and emerging challenges (Integration,
Implementation, Coherence)
C. Engaging major groups
D. Framework for action
III. Green Economy in the context of sustainable development and poverty eradication
A. Framing the context of the green economy, challenges and opportunities
B. Toolkits and experience sharing
C. Framework for action
IV. Institutional Framework for Sustainable Development
A. Strengthening/reforming/integrating the three pillars
B. GA, ECOSOC, CSD, SDC proposal
C. UNEP, specialized agency on environment proposal, IFIs, United Nations operational activities at country level
D. Regional, National, Local
V. Framework for action and follow-up
A. Priority/key/thematic/cross-sectoral issues and areas
B. Accelerating and measuring progress (SDGs, GDP and others)
C. Means of Implementation (finance, access to and transfer of technology, capacity building)
18 As of 10 January 2012, this is the structure of the Zero Draft of the Outcome Document, see:
http://www.uncsd2012.org/rio20/content/documents/370The%20Future%20We%20Want%2010Jan%20clean%20_no%20brackets.pdf
22. 22
VENUE - About Pace University
Since 1906 Pace has produced thinking professionals by providing high quality education for the professions on a firm base
of liberal learning amid the advantages of the New York metropolitan area. A private university, Pace has campuses in New
York City and Westchester County, New York, enrolling nearly 13,000 students in bachelor’s, master’s, and doctoral
programs in its Lubin School of Business, Dyson College of Arts and Sciences, College of Health Professions, School of
Education, School of Law, and Seidenberg School of Computer Science and Information Systems. www.pace.edu
Catering – sustainability policies
23. 23
GLOBAL TRANSITION 2012 DIALOGUE #2 SUPPORTING ORGANISATIONS
The Global Transition 2012 coordinating team is extremely grateful to all the support that has been given and shown in
preparation for the Dialogue. Many people have contributed their time, expertise, thoughts and suggestions; and the
programme and panel discussions/presentations will be all the more interesting for this shared knowledge.
The Global Transition Dialogue # 2 was supported by the following partners:
SPONSORSHIP
The first and second Global Transition Dialogues, including supporting participants from the global south, have been made
possible by the generous support of the VELUX Foundations; the broader initiative activities are made possible by the
generous support of the Ford Foundation and the EU. The venue and catering is kindly being co-sponsored by Pace
University, NYC.
24. 24
ABOUT THE GLOBAL TRANSITION 2012 COORDINATING ORGANISATIONS
Green Economy Coalition
The Green Economy Coalition (GEC) is a diverse set of organisations and sectors from NGOs, research institutes, UN
organisations, business to trade unions. We have come together because we recognise that our economy is failing to deliver
either environmental sustainability or social equity. In short, our economic system is failing people and the planet.
Global Transition 2012 contact: Emily Benson, Programme Manager emily.benson@greeneconomycoalition.org
http://www.greeneconomycoalition.org/
new economics foundation (nef)
nef (the new economics foundation) is an independent think-and-do tank that inspires and demonstrates real economic well-
being. nef aims to improve quality of life by promoting innovative solutions that challenge mainstream thinking on economic,
environment and social issues. We work in partnership and put people and the planet first.
Global Transition 2012 contact: Viki Johnson, Head of Climate and Energy victoria.johnson@neweconomics.org
http://neweconomics.org/
New Economics Institute
The New Economics Institute is a US organization that uniquely combines vision, theory, action, and communication to effect
a transition to a new economy -- an economy that gives priority to supporting human well-being and Earth’s natural systems.
Our multidisciplinary approach employs research, applied theory, public campaigns, and educational events to describe an
alternative socio-economic system that is capable of addressing the enormous challenges of our times. Our premise is that
a fair and sustainable economy is possible and that ways must be found to realize it.
Global Transition 2012 contact: Carina Millstone, Program Director carinamillstone@neweconomicsinstitute.org
http://neweconomicsinstitute.org/
Stakeholder Forum
Stakeholder Forum is an international organisation working to advance sustainable development and promote stakeholder
democracy at a global level. Our work aims to enhance open, accountable and participatory international decision-making on
sustainable development. Stakeholder Forum works across four key areas: Global Policy and Advocacy; Stakeholder
Engagement; Media and Communications; and Capacity Building. Our Global Transition 2012 initiative sits within our work
on Global Policy and Advocacy.
Global Transition 2012 contact: Kirsty Schneeberger, Senior Project Officer kirstys@stakeholderforum.org
http://www.stakeholderforum.org/sf/
Global Transition 2012
http://globaltransition2012.org/
Global Transition online interactive map
http://www.gtne.org/
25. 25
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Particular thanks to the following individuals (in no particular order)
To Chantal line Carpentier, Bernhard Frey, Flore-Anne Bourgeois, Farooq Ullah, David Payton, Yvonne Lodico, Achim
Halpaap, Felix Haas, Emily Benson, Carina Millstone, Viki Johnson, Elizabeth Cox, Jeff Huffines, Kim Carstensen, and Tara
Rao for your valuable and thoughtful contributions to the programme for the Dialogue.
All the speakers, presenters, and chairs of the sessions have offered their weekends to share with the Dialogue
participants their perspectives on and experiences of the relevant issues discussed and debated this weekend. Your input
will no doubt spark conversations that last from now until Rio +20 – and beyond!
The background papers and challenge papers are extremely useful resources and the authors and peer reviewers are to
be commended for the insight, knowledge, and thought leadership that shines throughout the papers that serve to challenge
the status quo in ways that are both inspiring and solutions focused.
The Global Transition 2012 initiative was able to sponsor 15 participants from the Green Economy Coalition and other
new economy initiatives to attend and share a global south perspective, thanks to the Velux Foundation. The Danish
government, through the Danish 92 group, has also sponsored a number of participants from the global south to attend
not only the Global Transition Dialogue, but also the informal sessions in New York from 19th March. In particular, thanks go
to Amy Cutter and Jack Cornforth for booking and organising all travel arrangements and supporting with VISA applications.
The Global Transition 2012 online platform is, we hope you agree, a useful hub of knowledge and information sharing on
the topics covered in the dialogue and many more. Thanks to Tom Harrisson, Viki Johnson and Matt Reading-Smith for
keeping it fresh and updated. Thanks also to the White October team who designed and created the website.
To Felix Dodds for his words of experience and wisdom, and for the leadership that he has shown – and will no doubt
continue to show – in the next 95 days on the road to Rio +20 (and beyond!).
The venue and catering has been expertly organised by Dr Greg Julian, Idalia Soto, and Tom Murray. You helped bring the
idea to a reality and served us delicious locally produced and organic food.
The printing has been done by the Village Group, New York; and the information pack is printed on recycled paper. Thanks
to Nicole Anderson and Tony Viola for their work on this.
Finally – to all dialogue participants; thank you for joining us and giving up your weekends. Your perspective is incredibly
valuable and your experiences will help to shape the way that we all approach the exciting opportunity that transitioning to
the new economy offers us. Please do stay in touch, keep up the excellent work, and together we will transition to the new
economy that we aspire to. After all:
If future generations are to remember us with more gratitude than sorrow, we must achieve more than just the miracles of
technology. We must also leave them a glimpse of the world as it was created, not just as it looked when we go through with
it.
- Lyndon B. Johnson, 1964
Sincerest thanks, once more.
Kirsty Schneeberger
Global Transition 2012 Coordinator, Stakeholder Forum