Dr. Krassen Stanchev, Sofia University and the
Institute for Market Economics (www.ime.bg )




      1st globar flat tax conference, Bratislava, 4-5 OCT
      2012                                                  1
The idea and its exploration and
  implementation in contemporary Bulgaria
1990-1991 – Constitutional
 Assembly
1994-1997 Crisis
Post 1997 – 10 years of campaign
2007 – to present day

           1st globar flat tax conference, Bratislava, 4-5 OCT
           2012                                                  2
SOURCE : National Statistics, IME.




Indicators (average)                                            1998-       2002-2004
                                              1990-1997           2004
Inflation (%)                                    210.1               7.5                 4.8
Inflationary tax rate (%)                        57.7               6.9                  4.5
GDP growth (%)                                   -4.7               4.4                  5.0
GVA growth (%)                                   n.a.               4.0                 4.9
Investment growth (%)                            -8.8               18.2                11.4
Budget deficit/surplus (% of                                         0.2                 0.4
   GDP)                                          -6.3
Government debt (% of GDP)                       168               65.9                 48.3
FDI (USD million)                                168            1,253.4             1,867.7
FDI (% of GDP)                                     3                 7.4                 9.1
Subsidies (% of GDP)                             n.a.
                  1st globar flat tax conference, Bratislava, 4-5 OCT
                                                                      2.1                2.5
                        2012                                                               3
Inflation /GDP Dynamics: February 1991 - February 1997
 



         4.00%                                                                       500%
                                                                                     450%
         2.00%
                                                                                     400%
         0.00%                                                                       350%
                  1991   1992    1993       1994      1995      1996          1997   300%
         -2.00%
                                                                                            GD P
                                                                                     250%
         -4.00%
                                                                                            Inflatio
                                                                                     200%   n


         -6.00%                                                                      150%
                                                                                     100%
         -8.00%
                                                                                     50%
        -10.00%                                                                      0%




                            1st globar flat tax conference, Bratislava, 4-5
                            OCT 2012                                                                   4
Current situation
Fiscal deficit – 0.7%
Inflation – 2%
Government debt – 16.7%, CDS – goes down
Growth – 2%
Banks: 17% CAR, deposits cover the credits, non-
 performing loans – 12%
Longest period of economic growth since 1878
Accumulated FDI since 1997 – 49 times higher that
 FDIs for 1992-1997
              1st globar flat tax conference, Bratislava, 4-5 OCT
              2012                                                  5
Flat tax campaign 1997-2007
Bratislava – 1997-1998
Sofia – 1997-2001 – unified corporate tax rates, from
 40 to 28%
Gradualism, justification of 10% rate
Flat tax bulletin and alternative state budget – 2003
 and after; focus on social taxes, especially after 2007
Since 2004 – annual determination of contributions
 to pay-as-you-go
2005 elections
2005-2009 tri-party coalition
               1st globar flat tax conference, Bratislava, 4-5 OCT
                  2012                                               6
Year/rate 2001   2002            2003             2004            2005   2006   2007
    s
Corporate 28%    23.5%          19.5%            19.5%             15%   10%    10%
   tax
 Income     20- 18-29%         15-29%           12-29%            10- 10-24% 10%
   tax      38%                                                   24%
  Social   42.7% 42.7%          42.7%            42.7%           42.7% 36.6  16.9%

  VAT      20%   20%              20%              20%             20%   20%    20%




                  1st globar flat tax conference, Bratislava, 4-5 OCT
                  2012                                                                 7
SOURCE : Yavor Alexiev, IME.




                1st globar flat tax conference, Bratislava, 4-5 OCT
                2012                                                  8
SOURCE : Yavor Alexiev, IME.




                1st globar flat tax conference, Bratislava, 4-5 OCT
                2012                                                  9
SOURCE : Yavor Alexiev, IME.




                1st globar flat tax conference, Bratislava, 4-5 OCT
                2012                                                  10
SOURCE : Yavor Alexiev, IME.




                1st globar flat tax conference, Bratislava, 4-5 OCT
                2012                                                  11
Help from abroad and domestic challenges                            ?
Knowledge of other countries
Parsson, Schreuder, Unker
EU dimension:
a)Taxes and EU subsidies
b)Rhetoric against tax competition
Domestic issues:
a. Unfinished reforms
b. Expenditures and competition for privileges

              1st globar flat tax conference, Bratislava, 4-5 OCT
              2012                                                      12
Prospects
Socialist already campaign for progressive taxation
Incumbent government is rather populist and faces
  electoral challenge next year
President Plevneliev at CNBC:
http://video.cnbc.com/gallery/?video=3000117945
Among authoritative economist-commentators there
  is one person who campaigns against the flat tax
Overall left-populist mood in the media
Welfare system malfunctions
              1st globar flat tax conference, Bratislava, 4-5 OCT
              2012                                                  13

Krasen Stanchev on Flat Tax Forum 2012

  • 1.
    Dr. Krassen Stanchev,Sofia University and the Institute for Market Economics (www.ime.bg ) 1st globar flat tax conference, Bratislava, 4-5 OCT 2012 1
  • 2.
    The idea andits exploration and implementation in contemporary Bulgaria 1990-1991 – Constitutional Assembly 1994-1997 Crisis Post 1997 – 10 years of campaign 2007 – to present day 1st globar flat tax conference, Bratislava, 4-5 OCT 2012 2
  • 3.
    SOURCE : NationalStatistics, IME. Indicators (average) 1998- 2002-2004 1990-1997 2004 Inflation (%) 210.1 7.5 4.8 Inflationary tax rate (%) 57.7 6.9 4.5 GDP growth (%) -4.7 4.4 5.0 GVA growth (%) n.a. 4.0 4.9 Investment growth (%) -8.8 18.2 11.4 Budget deficit/surplus (% of 0.2 0.4 GDP) -6.3 Government debt (% of GDP) 168 65.9 48.3 FDI (USD million) 168 1,253.4 1,867.7 FDI (% of GDP) 3 7.4 9.1 Subsidies (% of GDP) n.a. 1st globar flat tax conference, Bratislava, 4-5 OCT 2.1 2.5 2012 3
  • 4.
    Inflation /GDP Dynamics:February 1991 - February 1997   4.00% 500% 450% 2.00% 400% 0.00% 350% 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 300% -2.00% GD P 250% -4.00% Inflatio 200% n -6.00% 150% 100% -8.00% 50% -10.00% 0% 1st globar flat tax conference, Bratislava, 4-5 OCT 2012 4
  • 5.
    Current situation Fiscal deficit– 0.7% Inflation – 2% Government debt – 16.7%, CDS – goes down Growth – 2% Banks: 17% CAR, deposits cover the credits, non- performing loans – 12% Longest period of economic growth since 1878 Accumulated FDI since 1997 – 49 times higher that FDIs for 1992-1997 1st globar flat tax conference, Bratislava, 4-5 OCT 2012 5
  • 6.
    Flat tax campaign1997-2007 Bratislava – 1997-1998 Sofia – 1997-2001 – unified corporate tax rates, from 40 to 28% Gradualism, justification of 10% rate Flat tax bulletin and alternative state budget – 2003 and after; focus on social taxes, especially after 2007 Since 2004 – annual determination of contributions to pay-as-you-go 2005 elections 2005-2009 tri-party coalition 1st globar flat tax conference, Bratislava, 4-5 OCT 2012 6
  • 7.
    Year/rate 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 s Corporate 28% 23.5% 19.5% 19.5% 15% 10% 10% tax Income 20- 18-29% 15-29% 12-29% 10- 10-24% 10% tax 38% 24% Social 42.7% 42.7% 42.7% 42.7% 42.7% 36.6 16.9% VAT 20% 20% 20% 20% 20% 20% 20% 1st globar flat tax conference, Bratislava, 4-5 OCT 2012 7
  • 8.
    SOURCE : YavorAlexiev, IME. 1st globar flat tax conference, Bratislava, 4-5 OCT 2012 8
  • 9.
    SOURCE : YavorAlexiev, IME. 1st globar flat tax conference, Bratislava, 4-5 OCT 2012 9
  • 10.
    SOURCE : YavorAlexiev, IME. 1st globar flat tax conference, Bratislava, 4-5 OCT 2012 10
  • 11.
    SOURCE : YavorAlexiev, IME. 1st globar flat tax conference, Bratislava, 4-5 OCT 2012 11
  • 12.
    Help from abroadand domestic challenges ? Knowledge of other countries Parsson, Schreuder, Unker EU dimension: a)Taxes and EU subsidies b)Rhetoric against tax competition Domestic issues: a. Unfinished reforms b. Expenditures and competition for privileges 1st globar flat tax conference, Bratislava, 4-5 OCT 2012 12
  • 13.
    Prospects Socialist already campaignfor progressive taxation Incumbent government is rather populist and faces electoral challenge next year President Plevneliev at CNBC: http://video.cnbc.com/gallery/?video=3000117945 Among authoritative economist-commentators there is one person who campaigns against the flat tax Overall left-populist mood in the media Welfare system malfunctions 1st globar flat tax conference, Bratislava, 4-5 OCT 2012 13