SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Final Reflective Overview– 10%
Written Reflective Journal Entry (1500 word max)*
Final reflective overview of yourself with respect to conduct and learnings in the course and in development of your project proposal. Reflection will
show evidence of balanced and honest critique, self-awareness, and exploration of issues, implications, and insights. Reflections can be scaled along
two main dimensions: concrete, behavioural, and observable phenomena, which are largely external; and interior, more subjective aspects including
feelings and thoughts. Some reflectors favour one at the cost of the other, and both are important. It is hard to strike a balance, but balance is
needed.
For this assignment, your reflection must include: (a) major lessons learned, particularly for going forward with your project and in terms of your
professional practice; (b) reflections on feedback received from peers and other stakeholders over the semester; (c) what you are proud of or
pleased with; (d) your greatest learning challenges and why; (e) what you would do differently could you do it again; and (f) interpretations /
observations on classmates, instructors, other stakeholders, and how these may have changed over the course of the semester.
Also valued will be any specific plans you have for implementing your project and any concerns you might have that were not stated in your
proposal, along with implications and how they might be dealt with.
As an individual set of reflections, you could “free form” write, dwelling on issues (taking the above as reference) that are most relevant and
interesting to you and bringing in whatever additional topics you like. You will not be penalised for doing so. To make it even more personal and
unique, you might prefer to digitally film yourself speaking your reflections or do some other kind of presentation that effectively conveys your
insights and observations. Some students may prefer just to write, using the template provided below. This is entirely your choice. If you have a
creative or novel idea for presenting your reflections, but feel uncertain about how to proceed, you might wish to talk it through with your facilitator.
Assessors of your reflection will be looking for awareness of and attention to perceptions, attitudes, beliefs, biases, assumptions, values,
expectations, and motives (PABBAVEM), and the role they play in your problem-solving, decision-making, and the way to interact with and respond
to others.
Remember that reflection is not merely an internally-directed process as might be conceived of as introspection. And, while the power of insight
should not be underestimated, and reflection can lead to it, reflection also has outward and future-oriented dimensions such as foresight and
multiple-perspective taking. Reflection, quite naturally, has a hindsight quality to it, and permits learning from the past. The most important aspect
of reflection—and a focus that is often neglected—is that reflection is not limited to thought process but is wedded to thoughtful action.
Reflective Journal
Entry 10%
8-10 3-7 0-3
Depth Reflectionfocusesonone ormore actions
or situationsandexploresit /themdeeply
and thoroughly,drawingoutinferencesand
implicationsandrelatingthemtowhatis
beinglearntinthe course.
Actionsandsituationsare depictedfrom
variousvantage pointsandthrough
multiple lenses.
Interpretationsare thoroughlydissected
and defended,withdue considerationto
perceptions,biases,andfeelings—notjust
carefullydescribedbutcriticallyexamined.
Reflectionsfocusonone or more actionsor
situationsandexploresthemata basicbut
sufficientlevel.
Actionsandsituationsare depictedfrom
some vantage pointsorthroughmore than
one lens,butsome perspectivesare missing
or dealtwithat onlya general level.
Interpretationsandimplicationsare dealt
withat a highlevel withsome
considerationgiventoperceptions,biases,
and feelings.
Lessevidence ordefensible descriptionis
providedforassertionsandconclusions
than wouldbe the case at the exceptional
level.
Reflectionsfail tofocus onone or more
actionsor situationsatany level of scrutiny
and / or little detailisprovided.
Seeminglyirrelevantissuesorsituationsare
introducedandnotcontextualised. Links
are notclearlymade to the practice area or
individual’sprofessional practice or
development.
Actionsandsituationsare depictedfrom
limitedperspectives,andappearbiased,
subjective,andnotcriticallyexamined.
Fewif any interpretationsandimplications
and / or no evidence tojustifythem.
Breadth Reflections coveravarietyof actionsor
situationsthattogetherorseparately
addressissuesof concerntothe individual
studentintermsof hisor herarea of
practice,professional development,or
course learningandprogress.
Areasof learningconcernare clearly
identifiedanddiscussed,aswellaslinkedto
one anotherwhenrelevant: conflicts,
contradictions,andincompatibilitiesare
dealtwith,aswell assynergies,parallels,
and leverage.
Actionsandsituationsare depictedfrom
variousvantage pointsandthrough
multiple lenses.
Reflections include more thanone actionor
situationandexplore thematabasic but
sufficientlevel. Range of actionsor
situationsissufficientbutnarrowerthanit
couldbe.
Linkingandrelevance of observationsand
insightsismodestandfail toshowintense
or continuingthoughtorcritical
examination.
Actionsandsituationsare depictedfrom
some vantage pointsorthroughmore than
one lens,butsome perspectivesare missing
or dealtwithat onlya general level.
Interpretationsandimplicationsare dealt
withat a highlevel withsome
considerationgiventoperceptions,biases,
and feelings.
Lessevidence ordefensible descriptionis
providedforassertionsandconclusions
than wouldbe the case at the exceptional
level.
Numberof actionsor situationsreflected
uponis insufficientand/or barely
explored.
There islittle tono linkingandrelevance of
observationsandinsightsmade andlittle
indicationof critical examination.
Actionsandsituationsare depictedfrom
onlythe individual’spointof view,and/or
appearbiasedor unfounded.
There are fewif anymeaningful
interpretations discussedorimplicationsfor
practice or professional development
drawnout.
There islittle tono evidenceordefensible
descriptionprovidedforobservations,
assertions,orconclusions.
Specificity Behaviourorsituationisdescribedin
exquisite detail. The readercan literallysee
or experience the same behaviouror
situationthroughthe eyes(andwritingor
verbal description) of the author.
Relationshipsandlinkagesare clear,direct,
and convincing. There isnoconfusion
betweenevents,times,individuals
concerned,interactions,causes,
consequences. Everythingisclearly
separate or aligned,asrelevant.
The story istoldusingexceptionally
descriptive andunambiguousdetails—what
exactlywashappening? Whowasinvolved
and how? What ledto what?
Behaviorsituationisdescribedin sufficient
detail.
Authorstrivestohelp readersee or
experience the same behaviourorsituation
throughhisor her eyes,thoughsome
necessarydetail of perspectivemaybe
missing.
Most relationshipsandlinkages between
and amongstevents,times,individuals
concerned,interactions,causes,
consequencesare clear.
Minor confusionsandambiguitiesmayexist
inthe pointsauthorattemptstomake.
There isan interestingandbelievablestory
beingtold,thoughsometimesdetails,
meanings,andimplicationsare unclear.
Behaviorsituationisdescribedinsufficient
detail.
Authorstrivestohelp readersee or
experience the same behaviourorsituation
throughhisor her eyes,thoughsome
necessarydetail of perspectivemaybe
missing.
Most relationshipsandlinkages between
and amongstevents,times,individuals
concerned,interactions,causes,
consequencesare clear.
Minor confusionsandambiguitiesmayexist
inthe pointsauthorattemptstomake.
There isan interestingandbelievablestory
beingtold,thoughsometimesdetails,
meanings,andimplicationsare unclear.
Authenticity Reflectionsjudgedgenuine andcredible
throughthe author’seffortandabilityto
describe anddefendwithclearandrelevant
detail,evidence,andexamples.
There isconveyedaveryreal sense of
experience,notjustinoutward,observable,
and describable terms,butintermsof how
the eventor interactionwasperceived,felt,
and thoughtabout.
There are few,if any,assumptionsor
attributionsmade thatare not backed-up
withextensive,defensible,andrelevant
detail andexample.
Whilstlevel of detailiscrucial,its
compellingnature isevenmore important
to conveyingasense of authenticity.
Whatdoesit mean to me and whatmightit
meanforothers are critical questionsthat,
if addressed,lendcredibilityandrelevance
to the reflection.
Reflections judgedgenerally genuine and
credible throughthe author’seffortand
abilitytodescribe anddefendwithclear
and relevantdetail,evidence,and
examples. Some detail islackingand/or
examplesare incompleteorsuperficially
describedorinterpreted.
There issufficientbalance betweenthe
outward,observable,anddescribable detail
and examplesusedandthe language used
to describe internal perceptions,feelings,
interpretations,andthoughtaboutgiven
events.
Some assumptionsorattributions are made
or conclusionsdrawn thatare notbacked-
up withextensive,defensible,andrelevant
detail andexample.
On the whole,the storyorelements
thereof are lessconvincingorcompelling
than theymightbe if more evidence and
richerdescriptionwere offered.
Minor questionsremainastothe lessons
drawnfrom the author’srecountingof
events: meaning,relevance,and
implicationsare notentirely addressedor
resolved.
Authenticityof the reflectionsisnot
demonstrated throughthe author’seffort
and abilitytodescribe anddefendwith
clearand relevantdetail,evidence,and
examples. Detail providedisinsufficient
and / or examplesare incompleteor
superficiallydescribedorinterpreted.
There islittle tono balance betweenthe
outward,observable,anddescribable detail
and examplesusedandthe language used
to describe internal perceptions,feelings,
interpretations,andthoughtaboutgiven
events.
Many assumptionsorattributions are made
or conclusionsdrawn thatare notbacked-
up withextensive,defensible,andrelevant
detail andexample.
There isno coherentor credible story.
Serious questionsremainasto the
student’sinvestmentinorabilitytothink
aboutand / or write up genuine reflections
concerningeventsandthe lessonsthat
mightbe learntfromthem.There issimply
not enoughtogo on.
Format and
Presentation
Nearflawlesspresentationof publishable
qualityinneatness, appearance,
punctuation,grammar,spelling,syntax,
structure / organisation,flow).
Acceptable presentationinneatness,
appearance,punctuation,grammar,
spelling,syntax,structure /organisation,
flow).
Insufficient,unacceptable,orborderline
presentationhavingsignificanterrorsin
one or more of the followingattributes:
neatness,appearance,punctuation,
grammar, spelling,syntax,structure /
organisation,flow).
Suggested Outline for Final Reflection
Personal Learning Journey. This isa writtenarticulationof yourlearningthroughthe course,includingreferral toyourInitial OrientingReflection. Whathave
youlearnedaboutyourself,others,yourprofessional practice anditscontext,andhowdidthisoccur (whatfacilitated it)? Mostimportant: are you changingor
have youchanged,and howand why? Change couldbe in behaviour,attitudes,values,perspectives. Whatmightbe the benefits(andcosts) of thischange?
You will be assessedonyourcompleteness,depth,andinclusionof examples. ~200-300 words.
Learning Applications. Of all the knowledgeyouacquired,skillsyoubuilt,ordispositionsdeveloped,howare yougoingto(ormight you) applythemto your
professionalpractice developmentandyourorganisation orcommunitycontext? Of particularinterestishowyouinteractwithpeople andyourcollaboration
skillsandorientations,andthe implicationsthese have foryourprofessionalpractice. ~200-300 words.
Major Learning ChallengesandOpportunities. What didyoufindmostchallenging, andhowdidyourespondtothese challenges? Whatare the implications
for yourcontinuingdevelopmentasa professionalpractitioner? Whatcan or shouldyoudoto furtheryourprofessionaldevelopment? ~200-300 words.
Feedbackfrom Peers,Teachers,and otherStakeholders. What feedbackhave youreceivedandinferredthissemesterwithrespecttoyourperformance,and
howare youcontendingwithit? What are the implicationsforyourprofessional practice and development? Howmightfeedbackonyourperformance impact
on thisand / or otherprojectsandtasks? What othersourcesof performance feedbackmightyouseektofurtherinformwhat youare hearingorsurmising?
~200-300 words.
Insights,Observations,Discoveries,and InterpretationsofOthers. What are some of the keybehavioursyouhave observedin/fromclassmates,teachers,and
otherstakeholdersthissemesterinsofaras theybear on professional practice andyoureffectivenessasa professional practitioner? Howdoyouinterpret
these behavioursandwhy? Specifically,discussyourownperceptions,attitudes,beliefs,biases,assumptions,values,expectations,andmotives(PABBAVEM),
and the role theyplayinyour decision-makingandbehaviour,andresponse-patterns. ~200-300 words.

More Related Content

What's hot

2015 reflective writing workshop for 271256
2015 reflective writing workshop for 2712562015 reflective writing workshop for 271256
2015 reflective writing workshop for 271256
Martin McMorrow
 
Pp feedbac kpresbanyulenetworkversion3
Pp feedbac kpresbanyulenetworkversion3Pp feedbac kpresbanyulenetworkversion3
Pp feedbac kpresbanyulenetworkversion3
thsieh
 
CD Meeting June 7 2012 for slideshare
CD Meeting June 7 2012 for slideshareCD Meeting June 7 2012 for slideshare
CD Meeting June 7 2012 for slideshare
V
 
2016 254102 writing workshop 2
2016 254102  writing workshop 22016 254102  writing workshop 2
2016 254102 writing workshop 2
Martin McMorrow
 
Authentic Institutional Assessment
Authentic Institutional AssessmentAuthentic Institutional Assessment
Authentic Institutional Assessment
wsm8851
 
Adaptive-Style-Inventory_Heba-Saleh_LSI4_2015-9-3-16-30-57-368
Adaptive-Style-Inventory_Heba-Saleh_LSI4_2015-9-3-16-30-57-368Adaptive-Style-Inventory_Heba-Saleh_LSI4_2015-9-3-16-30-57-368
Adaptive-Style-Inventory_Heba-Saleh_LSI4_2015-9-3-16-30-57-368
Heba Mohamed
 
One to one work in Learning Development
One to one work in Learning DevelopmentOne to one work in Learning Development
One to one work in Learning Development
Helen Webster
 
Reflective and Supportive Supervision
Reflective and Supportive SupervisionReflective and Supportive Supervision
Reflective and Supportive Supervision
Children’s Trust of South Carolina
 

What's hot (8)

2015 reflective writing workshop for 271256
2015 reflective writing workshop for 2712562015 reflective writing workshop for 271256
2015 reflective writing workshop for 271256
 
Pp feedbac kpresbanyulenetworkversion3
Pp feedbac kpresbanyulenetworkversion3Pp feedbac kpresbanyulenetworkversion3
Pp feedbac kpresbanyulenetworkversion3
 
CD Meeting June 7 2012 for slideshare
CD Meeting June 7 2012 for slideshareCD Meeting June 7 2012 for slideshare
CD Meeting June 7 2012 for slideshare
 
2016 254102 writing workshop 2
2016 254102  writing workshop 22016 254102  writing workshop 2
2016 254102 writing workshop 2
 
Authentic Institutional Assessment
Authentic Institutional AssessmentAuthentic Institutional Assessment
Authentic Institutional Assessment
 
Adaptive-Style-Inventory_Heba-Saleh_LSI4_2015-9-3-16-30-57-368
Adaptive-Style-Inventory_Heba-Saleh_LSI4_2015-9-3-16-30-57-368Adaptive-Style-Inventory_Heba-Saleh_LSI4_2015-9-3-16-30-57-368
Adaptive-Style-Inventory_Heba-Saleh_LSI4_2015-9-3-16-30-57-368
 
One to one work in Learning Development
One to one work in Learning DevelopmentOne to one work in Learning Development
One to one work in Learning Development
 
Reflective and Supportive Supervision
Reflective and Supportive SupervisionReflective and Supportive Supervision
Reflective and Supportive Supervision
 

Similar to Final Reflective Overview - jay

Assignment 6.2- Response Paper #2Compose your response paper adh.docx
Assignment 6.2- Response Paper #2Compose your response paper adh.docxAssignment 6.2- Response Paper #2Compose your response paper adh.docx
Assignment 6.2- Response Paper #2Compose your response paper adh.docx
rock73
 
1000 - 1500 word argumentative essay PROMPT Is putting yourse.docx
1000 - 1500 word argumentative essay PROMPT Is putting yourse.docx1000 - 1500 word argumentative essay PROMPT Is putting yourse.docx
1000 - 1500 word argumentative essay PROMPT Is putting yourse.docx
alisondakintxt
 
C2 l reflective pedagogy spring 2011
C2 l reflective pedagogy   spring 2011C2 l reflective pedagogy   spring 2011
C2 l reflective pedagogy spring 2011
making_connections
 
What is reflection
What is reflectionWhat is reflection
What is reflection
Aamir Ali
 
Reflecting on Reflective Writing Analytics (LAK16)
Reflecting on Reflective Writing Analytics (LAK16)Reflecting on Reflective Writing Analytics (LAK16)
Reflecting on Reflective Writing Analytics (LAK16)
Simon Buckingham Shum
 
Reflective Practice E portfolio
Reflective Practice E portfolioReflective Practice E portfolio
Reflective Practice E portfolio
rmg6449
 
Dispositions Self-Assessment SurveyFor each of the followi
Dispositions Self-Assessment SurveyFor each of the followiDispositions Self-Assessment SurveyFor each of the followi
Dispositions Self-Assessment SurveyFor each of the followi
DustiBuckner14
 
MODULE 1 CASE ASSIGNMENTManaging Individual BehaviorAssignment O.docx
MODULE 1 CASE ASSIGNMENTManaging Individual BehaviorAssignment O.docxMODULE 1 CASE ASSIGNMENTManaging Individual BehaviorAssignment O.docx
MODULE 1 CASE ASSIGNMENTManaging Individual BehaviorAssignment O.docx
clairbycraft
 
Rounding up assessment, ending a course
Rounding up  assessment, ending a courseRounding up  assessment, ending a course
Rounding up assessment, ending a course
ferlop73
 
BIZ102 Assessment 1 Brief Page 1 of 6 ASSESSMENT BRI.docx
BIZ102 Assessment 1 Brief  Page 1 of 6  ASSESSMENT BRI.docxBIZ102 Assessment 1 Brief  Page 1 of 6  ASSESSMENT BRI.docx
BIZ102 Assessment 1 Brief Page 1 of 6 ASSESSMENT BRI.docx
jasoninnes20
 
BIZ102 Assessment 1 Brief Page 1 of 6 ASSESSMENT BRI.docx
BIZ102 Assessment 1 Brief  Page 1 of 6  ASSESSMENT BRI.docxBIZ102 Assessment 1 Brief  Page 1 of 6  ASSESSMENT BRI.docx
BIZ102 Assessment 1 Brief Page 1 of 6 ASSESSMENT BRI.docx
moirarandell
 
Essay #3 Social Media EssayHow does social media (and your use .docx
Essay #3 Social Media EssayHow does social media (and your use .docxEssay #3 Social Media EssayHow does social media (and your use .docx
Essay #3 Social Media EssayHow does social media (and your use .docx
SALU18
 
Reflective Piece Final assignment portfolio
Reflective Piece Final assignment  portfolioReflective Piece Final assignment  portfolio
Reflective Piece Final assignment portfolio
rmg6449
 
Principles of reflective writing
Principles of reflective writingPrinciples of reflective writing
Principles of reflective writing
Martin McMorrow
 
Cheap assignment help USA
Cheap assignment help USACheap assignment help USA
Cheap assignment help USA
Nicole Valerio
 
Critical Reflection Essay
Critical Reflection EssayCritical Reflection Essay
Critical Reflection Essay
Custom Paper Services
 
2.28.11 webinar
2.28.11 webinar2.28.11 webinar
2.28.11 webinar
making_connections
 
Erma's presentation
Erma's presentationErma's presentation
Erma's presentation
St. John's Anglican School
 
FeedBACK OF COMMUNICATION
FeedBACK OF COMMUNICATIONFeedBACK OF COMMUNICATION
FeedBACK OF COMMUNICATION
Gagan Gouda
 
Reflective Essay 101
Reflective Essay 101Reflective Essay 101
Reflective Essay 101
OnlinePaperWritingSe
 

Similar to Final Reflective Overview - jay (20)

Assignment 6.2- Response Paper #2Compose your response paper adh.docx
Assignment 6.2- Response Paper #2Compose your response paper adh.docxAssignment 6.2- Response Paper #2Compose your response paper adh.docx
Assignment 6.2- Response Paper #2Compose your response paper adh.docx
 
1000 - 1500 word argumentative essay PROMPT Is putting yourse.docx
1000 - 1500 word argumentative essay PROMPT Is putting yourse.docx1000 - 1500 word argumentative essay PROMPT Is putting yourse.docx
1000 - 1500 word argumentative essay PROMPT Is putting yourse.docx
 
C2 l reflective pedagogy spring 2011
C2 l reflective pedagogy   spring 2011C2 l reflective pedagogy   spring 2011
C2 l reflective pedagogy spring 2011
 
What is reflection
What is reflectionWhat is reflection
What is reflection
 
Reflecting on Reflective Writing Analytics (LAK16)
Reflecting on Reflective Writing Analytics (LAK16)Reflecting on Reflective Writing Analytics (LAK16)
Reflecting on Reflective Writing Analytics (LAK16)
 
Reflective Practice E portfolio
Reflective Practice E portfolioReflective Practice E portfolio
Reflective Practice E portfolio
 
Dispositions Self-Assessment SurveyFor each of the followi
Dispositions Self-Assessment SurveyFor each of the followiDispositions Self-Assessment SurveyFor each of the followi
Dispositions Self-Assessment SurveyFor each of the followi
 
MODULE 1 CASE ASSIGNMENTManaging Individual BehaviorAssignment O.docx
MODULE 1 CASE ASSIGNMENTManaging Individual BehaviorAssignment O.docxMODULE 1 CASE ASSIGNMENTManaging Individual BehaviorAssignment O.docx
MODULE 1 CASE ASSIGNMENTManaging Individual BehaviorAssignment O.docx
 
Rounding up assessment, ending a course
Rounding up  assessment, ending a courseRounding up  assessment, ending a course
Rounding up assessment, ending a course
 
BIZ102 Assessment 1 Brief Page 1 of 6 ASSESSMENT BRI.docx
BIZ102 Assessment 1 Brief  Page 1 of 6  ASSESSMENT BRI.docxBIZ102 Assessment 1 Brief  Page 1 of 6  ASSESSMENT BRI.docx
BIZ102 Assessment 1 Brief Page 1 of 6 ASSESSMENT BRI.docx
 
BIZ102 Assessment 1 Brief Page 1 of 6 ASSESSMENT BRI.docx
BIZ102 Assessment 1 Brief  Page 1 of 6  ASSESSMENT BRI.docxBIZ102 Assessment 1 Brief  Page 1 of 6  ASSESSMENT BRI.docx
BIZ102 Assessment 1 Brief Page 1 of 6 ASSESSMENT BRI.docx
 
Essay #3 Social Media EssayHow does social media (and your use .docx
Essay #3 Social Media EssayHow does social media (and your use .docxEssay #3 Social Media EssayHow does social media (and your use .docx
Essay #3 Social Media EssayHow does social media (and your use .docx
 
Reflective Piece Final assignment portfolio
Reflective Piece Final assignment  portfolioReflective Piece Final assignment  portfolio
Reflective Piece Final assignment portfolio
 
Principles of reflective writing
Principles of reflective writingPrinciples of reflective writing
Principles of reflective writing
 
Cheap assignment help USA
Cheap assignment help USACheap assignment help USA
Cheap assignment help USA
 
Critical Reflection Essay
Critical Reflection EssayCritical Reflection Essay
Critical Reflection Essay
 
2.28.11 webinar
2.28.11 webinar2.28.11 webinar
2.28.11 webinar
 
Erma's presentation
Erma's presentationErma's presentation
Erma's presentation
 
FeedBACK OF COMMUNICATION
FeedBACK OF COMMUNICATIONFeedBACK OF COMMUNICATION
FeedBACK OF COMMUNICATION
 
Reflective Essay 101
Reflective Essay 101Reflective Essay 101
Reflective Essay 101
 

More from Jay Hays

Hays and helmling applied practice
Hays and helmling   applied practiceHays and helmling   applied practice
Hays and helmling applied practice
Jay Hays
 
Systems Thinking The Orange Metaphor
Systems Thinking The Orange MetaphorSystems Thinking The Orange Metaphor
Systems Thinking The Orange Metaphor
Jay Hays
 
Knowledge Economy - Knowledge Ecology
Knowledge Economy - Knowledge EcologyKnowledge Economy - Knowledge Ecology
Knowledge Economy - Knowledge Ecology
Jay Hays
 
Faculty Teaching and Learning Seminar - ESP
Faculty Teaching and Learning Seminar - ESPFaculty Teaching and Learning Seminar - ESP
Faculty Teaching and Learning Seminar - ESP
Jay Hays
 
CLD Development and Coaching Workshop
CLD Development and Coaching WorkshopCLD Development and Coaching Workshop
CLD Development and Coaching Workshop
Jay Hays
 
Traffic Metaphor with Images
Traffic Metaphor with ImagesTraffic Metaphor with Images
Traffic Metaphor with Images
Jay Hays
 
Two to Tango - October 2016
Two to Tango - October 2016Two to Tango - October 2016
Two to Tango - October 2016
Jay Hays
 
Hays - HUMAN BODY METAPHOR
Hays - HUMAN BODY METAPHORHays - HUMAN BODY METAPHOR
Hays - HUMAN BODY METAPHOR
Jay Hays
 
Systems Thinking, Human Body Metaphor, and Causal Loop Diagramming
Systems Thinking, Human Body Metaphor, and Causal Loop DiagrammingSystems Thinking, Human Body Metaphor, and Causal Loop Diagramming
Systems Thinking, Human Body Metaphor, and Causal Loop Diagramming
Jay Hays
 
Formal Written Proposal Rubric - jay
Formal Written Proposal Rubric - jayFormal Written Proposal Rubric - jay
Formal Written Proposal Rubric - jay
Jay Hays
 
Rubric Context Analysis - final
Rubric Context Analysis - finalRubric Context Analysis - final
Rubric Context Analysis - final
Jay Hays
 
Initial Reflection Rubric - jay
Initial Reflection Rubric - jayInitial Reflection Rubric - jay
Initial Reflection Rubric - jay
Jay Hays
 
The Journey Metaphor
The Journey MetaphorThe Journey Metaphor
The Journey Metaphor
Jay Hays
 
The Journey Metaphor (2)
The Journey Metaphor (2)The Journey Metaphor (2)
The Journey Metaphor (2)
Jay Hays
 
Collaboration Rubric
Collaboration RubricCollaboration Rubric
Collaboration Rubric
Jay Hays
 
Compare and Contrast Suitable Methods of Data Rubric 1
Compare and Contrast Suitable Methods of Data Rubric 1Compare and Contrast Suitable Methods of Data Rubric 1
Compare and Contrast Suitable Methods of Data Rubric 1
Jay Hays
 
8002 Research Project Faciltator Manual
8002 Research Project Faciltator Manual8002 Research Project Faciltator Manual
8002 Research Project Faciltator Manual
Jay Hays
 
Critical Thinking Presentation
Critical Thinking PresentationCritical Thinking Presentation
Critical Thinking Presentation
Jay Hays
 
Hays - Zen and the Interview
Hays - Zen and the InterviewHays - Zen and the Interview
Hays - Zen and the Interview
Jay Hays
 
Hays - The Predictable Failure of Strategic Planning
Hays - The Predictable Failure of Strategic PlanningHays - The Predictable Failure of Strategic Planning
Hays - The Predictable Failure of Strategic Planning
Jay Hays
 

More from Jay Hays (20)

Hays and helmling applied practice
Hays and helmling   applied practiceHays and helmling   applied practice
Hays and helmling applied practice
 
Systems Thinking The Orange Metaphor
Systems Thinking The Orange MetaphorSystems Thinking The Orange Metaphor
Systems Thinking The Orange Metaphor
 
Knowledge Economy - Knowledge Ecology
Knowledge Economy - Knowledge EcologyKnowledge Economy - Knowledge Ecology
Knowledge Economy - Knowledge Ecology
 
Faculty Teaching and Learning Seminar - ESP
Faculty Teaching and Learning Seminar - ESPFaculty Teaching and Learning Seminar - ESP
Faculty Teaching and Learning Seminar - ESP
 
CLD Development and Coaching Workshop
CLD Development and Coaching WorkshopCLD Development and Coaching Workshop
CLD Development and Coaching Workshop
 
Traffic Metaphor with Images
Traffic Metaphor with ImagesTraffic Metaphor with Images
Traffic Metaphor with Images
 
Two to Tango - October 2016
Two to Tango - October 2016Two to Tango - October 2016
Two to Tango - October 2016
 
Hays - HUMAN BODY METAPHOR
Hays - HUMAN BODY METAPHORHays - HUMAN BODY METAPHOR
Hays - HUMAN BODY METAPHOR
 
Systems Thinking, Human Body Metaphor, and Causal Loop Diagramming
Systems Thinking, Human Body Metaphor, and Causal Loop DiagrammingSystems Thinking, Human Body Metaphor, and Causal Loop Diagramming
Systems Thinking, Human Body Metaphor, and Causal Loop Diagramming
 
Formal Written Proposal Rubric - jay
Formal Written Proposal Rubric - jayFormal Written Proposal Rubric - jay
Formal Written Proposal Rubric - jay
 
Rubric Context Analysis - final
Rubric Context Analysis - finalRubric Context Analysis - final
Rubric Context Analysis - final
 
Initial Reflection Rubric - jay
Initial Reflection Rubric - jayInitial Reflection Rubric - jay
Initial Reflection Rubric - jay
 
The Journey Metaphor
The Journey MetaphorThe Journey Metaphor
The Journey Metaphor
 
The Journey Metaphor (2)
The Journey Metaphor (2)The Journey Metaphor (2)
The Journey Metaphor (2)
 
Collaboration Rubric
Collaboration RubricCollaboration Rubric
Collaboration Rubric
 
Compare and Contrast Suitable Methods of Data Rubric 1
Compare and Contrast Suitable Methods of Data Rubric 1Compare and Contrast Suitable Methods of Data Rubric 1
Compare and Contrast Suitable Methods of Data Rubric 1
 
8002 Research Project Faciltator Manual
8002 Research Project Faciltator Manual8002 Research Project Faciltator Manual
8002 Research Project Faciltator Manual
 
Critical Thinking Presentation
Critical Thinking PresentationCritical Thinking Presentation
Critical Thinking Presentation
 
Hays - Zen and the Interview
Hays - Zen and the InterviewHays - Zen and the Interview
Hays - Zen and the Interview
 
Hays - The Predictable Failure of Strategic Planning
Hays - The Predictable Failure of Strategic PlanningHays - The Predictable Failure of Strategic Planning
Hays - The Predictable Failure of Strategic Planning
 

Final Reflective Overview - jay

  • 1. Final Reflective Overview– 10% Written Reflective Journal Entry (1500 word max)* Final reflective overview of yourself with respect to conduct and learnings in the course and in development of your project proposal. Reflection will show evidence of balanced and honest critique, self-awareness, and exploration of issues, implications, and insights. Reflections can be scaled along two main dimensions: concrete, behavioural, and observable phenomena, which are largely external; and interior, more subjective aspects including feelings and thoughts. Some reflectors favour one at the cost of the other, and both are important. It is hard to strike a balance, but balance is needed. For this assignment, your reflection must include: (a) major lessons learned, particularly for going forward with your project and in terms of your professional practice; (b) reflections on feedback received from peers and other stakeholders over the semester; (c) what you are proud of or pleased with; (d) your greatest learning challenges and why; (e) what you would do differently could you do it again; and (f) interpretations / observations on classmates, instructors, other stakeholders, and how these may have changed over the course of the semester. Also valued will be any specific plans you have for implementing your project and any concerns you might have that were not stated in your proposal, along with implications and how they might be dealt with. As an individual set of reflections, you could “free form” write, dwelling on issues (taking the above as reference) that are most relevant and interesting to you and bringing in whatever additional topics you like. You will not be penalised for doing so. To make it even more personal and unique, you might prefer to digitally film yourself speaking your reflections or do some other kind of presentation that effectively conveys your insights and observations. Some students may prefer just to write, using the template provided below. This is entirely your choice. If you have a creative or novel idea for presenting your reflections, but feel uncertain about how to proceed, you might wish to talk it through with your facilitator. Assessors of your reflection will be looking for awareness of and attention to perceptions, attitudes, beliefs, biases, assumptions, values, expectations, and motives (PABBAVEM), and the role they play in your problem-solving, decision-making, and the way to interact with and respond to others. Remember that reflection is not merely an internally-directed process as might be conceived of as introspection. And, while the power of insight should not be underestimated, and reflection can lead to it, reflection also has outward and future-oriented dimensions such as foresight and multiple-perspective taking. Reflection, quite naturally, has a hindsight quality to it, and permits learning from the past. The most important aspect of reflection—and a focus that is often neglected—is that reflection is not limited to thought process but is wedded to thoughtful action.
  • 2. Reflective Journal Entry 10% 8-10 3-7 0-3 Depth Reflectionfocusesonone ormore actions or situationsandexploresit /themdeeply and thoroughly,drawingoutinferencesand implicationsandrelatingthemtowhatis beinglearntinthe course. Actionsandsituationsare depictedfrom variousvantage pointsandthrough multiple lenses. Interpretationsare thoroughlydissected and defended,withdue considerationto perceptions,biases,andfeelings—notjust carefullydescribedbutcriticallyexamined. Reflectionsfocusonone or more actionsor situationsandexploresthemata basicbut sufficientlevel. Actionsandsituationsare depictedfrom some vantage pointsorthroughmore than one lens,butsome perspectivesare missing or dealtwithat onlya general level. Interpretationsandimplicationsare dealt withat a highlevel withsome considerationgiventoperceptions,biases, and feelings. Lessevidence ordefensible descriptionis providedforassertionsandconclusions than wouldbe the case at the exceptional level. Reflectionsfail tofocus onone or more actionsor situationsatany level of scrutiny and / or little detailisprovided. Seeminglyirrelevantissuesorsituationsare introducedandnotcontextualised. Links are notclearlymade to the practice area or individual’sprofessional practice or development. Actionsandsituationsare depictedfrom limitedperspectives,andappearbiased, subjective,andnotcriticallyexamined. Fewif any interpretationsandimplications and / or no evidence tojustifythem.
  • 3. Breadth Reflections coveravarietyof actionsor situationsthattogetherorseparately addressissuesof concerntothe individual studentintermsof hisor herarea of practice,professional development,or course learningandprogress. Areasof learningconcernare clearly identifiedanddiscussed,aswellaslinkedto one anotherwhenrelevant: conflicts, contradictions,andincompatibilitiesare dealtwith,aswell assynergies,parallels, and leverage. Actionsandsituationsare depictedfrom variousvantage pointsandthrough multiple lenses. Reflections include more thanone actionor situationandexplore thematabasic but sufficientlevel. Range of actionsor situationsissufficientbutnarrowerthanit couldbe. Linkingandrelevance of observationsand insightsismodestandfail toshowintense or continuingthoughtorcritical examination. Actionsandsituationsare depictedfrom some vantage pointsorthroughmore than one lens,butsome perspectivesare missing or dealtwithat onlya general level. Interpretationsandimplicationsare dealt withat a highlevel withsome considerationgiventoperceptions,biases, and feelings. Lessevidence ordefensible descriptionis providedforassertionsandconclusions than wouldbe the case at the exceptional level. Numberof actionsor situationsreflected uponis insufficientand/or barely explored. There islittle tono linkingandrelevance of observationsandinsightsmade andlittle indicationof critical examination. Actionsandsituationsare depictedfrom onlythe individual’spointof view,and/or appearbiasedor unfounded. There are fewif anymeaningful interpretations discussedorimplicationsfor practice or professional development drawnout. There islittle tono evidenceordefensible descriptionprovidedforobservations, assertions,orconclusions.
  • 4. Specificity Behaviourorsituationisdescribedin exquisite detail. The readercan literallysee or experience the same behaviouror situationthroughthe eyes(andwritingor verbal description) of the author. Relationshipsandlinkagesare clear,direct, and convincing. There isnoconfusion betweenevents,times,individuals concerned,interactions,causes, consequences. Everythingisclearly separate or aligned,asrelevant. The story istoldusingexceptionally descriptive andunambiguousdetails—what exactlywashappening? Whowasinvolved and how? What ledto what? Behaviorsituationisdescribedin sufficient detail. Authorstrivestohelp readersee or experience the same behaviourorsituation throughhisor her eyes,thoughsome necessarydetail of perspectivemaybe missing. Most relationshipsandlinkages between and amongstevents,times,individuals concerned,interactions,causes, consequencesare clear. Minor confusionsandambiguitiesmayexist inthe pointsauthorattemptstomake. There isan interestingandbelievablestory beingtold,thoughsometimesdetails, meanings,andimplicationsare unclear. Behaviorsituationisdescribedinsufficient detail. Authorstrivestohelp readersee or experience the same behaviourorsituation throughhisor her eyes,thoughsome necessarydetail of perspectivemaybe missing. Most relationshipsandlinkages between and amongstevents,times,individuals concerned,interactions,causes, consequencesare clear. Minor confusionsandambiguitiesmayexist inthe pointsauthorattemptstomake. There isan interestingandbelievablestory beingtold,thoughsometimesdetails, meanings,andimplicationsare unclear.
  • 5. Authenticity Reflectionsjudgedgenuine andcredible throughthe author’seffortandabilityto describe anddefendwithclearandrelevant detail,evidence,andexamples. There isconveyedaveryreal sense of experience,notjustinoutward,observable, and describable terms,butintermsof how the eventor interactionwasperceived,felt, and thoughtabout. There are few,if any,assumptionsor attributionsmade thatare not backed-up withextensive,defensible,andrelevant detail andexample. Whilstlevel of detailiscrucial,its compellingnature isevenmore important to conveyingasense of authenticity. Whatdoesit mean to me and whatmightit meanforothers are critical questionsthat, if addressed,lendcredibilityandrelevance to the reflection. Reflections judgedgenerally genuine and credible throughthe author’seffortand abilitytodescribe anddefendwithclear and relevantdetail,evidence,and examples. Some detail islackingand/or examplesare incompleteorsuperficially describedorinterpreted. There issufficientbalance betweenthe outward,observable,anddescribable detail and examplesusedandthe language used to describe internal perceptions,feelings, interpretations,andthoughtaboutgiven events. Some assumptionsorattributions are made or conclusionsdrawn thatare notbacked- up withextensive,defensible,andrelevant detail andexample. On the whole,the storyorelements thereof are lessconvincingorcompelling than theymightbe if more evidence and richerdescriptionwere offered. Minor questionsremainastothe lessons drawnfrom the author’srecountingof events: meaning,relevance,and implicationsare notentirely addressedor resolved. Authenticityof the reflectionsisnot demonstrated throughthe author’seffort and abilitytodescribe anddefendwith clearand relevantdetail,evidence,and examples. Detail providedisinsufficient and / or examplesare incompleteor superficiallydescribedorinterpreted. There islittle tono balance betweenthe outward,observable,anddescribable detail and examplesusedandthe language used to describe internal perceptions,feelings, interpretations,andthoughtaboutgiven events. Many assumptionsorattributions are made or conclusionsdrawn thatare notbacked- up withextensive,defensible,andrelevant detail andexample. There isno coherentor credible story. Serious questionsremainasto the student’sinvestmentinorabilitytothink aboutand / or write up genuine reflections concerningeventsandthe lessonsthat mightbe learntfromthem.There issimply not enoughtogo on. Format and Presentation Nearflawlesspresentationof publishable qualityinneatness, appearance, punctuation,grammar,spelling,syntax, structure / organisation,flow). Acceptable presentationinneatness, appearance,punctuation,grammar, spelling,syntax,structure /organisation, flow). Insufficient,unacceptable,orborderline presentationhavingsignificanterrorsin one or more of the followingattributes: neatness,appearance,punctuation, grammar, spelling,syntax,structure / organisation,flow).
  • 6. Suggested Outline for Final Reflection Personal Learning Journey. This isa writtenarticulationof yourlearningthroughthe course,includingreferral toyourInitial OrientingReflection. Whathave youlearnedaboutyourself,others,yourprofessional practice anditscontext,andhowdidthisoccur (whatfacilitated it)? Mostimportant: are you changingor have youchanged,and howand why? Change couldbe in behaviour,attitudes,values,perspectives. Whatmightbe the benefits(andcosts) of thischange? You will be assessedonyourcompleteness,depth,andinclusionof examples. ~200-300 words. Learning Applications. Of all the knowledgeyouacquired,skillsyoubuilt,ordispositionsdeveloped,howare yougoingto(ormight you) applythemto your professionalpractice developmentandyourorganisation orcommunitycontext? Of particularinterestishowyouinteractwithpeople andyourcollaboration skillsandorientations,andthe implicationsthese have foryourprofessionalpractice. ~200-300 words. Major Learning ChallengesandOpportunities. What didyoufindmostchallenging, andhowdidyourespondtothese challenges? Whatare the implications for yourcontinuingdevelopmentasa professionalpractitioner? Whatcan or shouldyoudoto furtheryourprofessionaldevelopment? ~200-300 words. Feedbackfrom Peers,Teachers,and otherStakeholders. What feedbackhave youreceivedandinferredthissemesterwithrespecttoyourperformance,and howare youcontendingwithit? What are the implicationsforyourprofessional practice and development? Howmightfeedbackonyourperformance impact on thisand / or otherprojectsandtasks? What othersourcesof performance feedbackmightyouseektofurtherinformwhat youare hearingorsurmising? ~200-300 words. Insights,Observations,Discoveries,and InterpretationsofOthers. What are some of the keybehavioursyouhave observedin/fromclassmates,teachers,and otherstakeholdersthissemesterinsofaras theybear on professional practice andyoureffectivenessasa professional practitioner? Howdoyouinterpret these behavioursandwhy? Specifically,discussyourownperceptions,attitudes,beliefs,biases,assumptions,values,expectations,andmotives(PABBAVEM), and the role theyplayinyour decision-makingandbehaviour,andresponse-patterns. ~200-300 words.