Travel and Tourism for All




Mr. Ivor Ambrose, Managing Director
European Network for Accessible Tourism (ENAT)

Global Forum on Accessible Cities
Fondazione CRT, Torino, 16th June 2011
                                                 1
Overview
1. Who needs accessible travel and tourism?
2. Accessible Tourism in Europe: Challenges and Trends
   a. Market Potential
   b. Demographics & Human Rights
   c. The Business Case – Examples of Good Practices
3. Spotlight on Policies and Actions for Accessible Cities




                                                             2
Part 1.
Who needs accessible travel and tourism?




                    Toegankelijkheidsbureau vzw. Belgium




                                                           3
When do customers need
accessible tourism?
Throughout the “visitor journey” and the whole value
chain!




                          National Conference on
            The Right to Access for Persons With Disabilities
       To the Built Environment and Transportation, Design for All
Demand                                         Supply
Access requirements:                                        Accessible provisions in:

                                                                 • Travel offers
                                                                 • Information (www…)

                                                                 • Booking

                                                                 • Transport

                                                                 • Accommodation
• Hearing impairments         • Frail, elderly
                                                                 • Facilities
• Visual impairments          • Small children
                                                                 • Diet meals
• Wheelchair users            • Long-term illness
                                                                 • Attractions
• Walking difficulties        • Service animal
                                                                 • Excursions, activities
• Allergies / Diets           • Understanding the
                              language                           • Care Services
• Small or large stature

• Learning difficulties Right to National Conference on Disabilities
                      The        Access for Persons With
                To the Built Environment and Transportation, Design for All
Tourism Services
 Accessible… throughout entire delivery chain
                 • Information      - search, bookings, Websites,
                                     mobile…

                 • Transport        - vehicles, terminals, transfers,
                                    assistance…


                 • Infrastructure   - attractions, accommodation
                                    restaurants, streets, beaches…


                 •Services          - hospitality, packages, guiding,
                                    excursions, special menus,
                                    activities, tech-aids, assistance…
The Problem:
 For visitors
    • Travel for people with disabilities is unpredictable,
      difficult or sometimes even impossible
    • Quality of infrastructure, transport, services, and
      information varies widely from place to place as
      well as between EU Member States
    • Lack of access standards increases uncertainty,
      reduces travel options and allows a lack of
      accountability to prevail.
The Problem:

 For the tourism industry
   • The accessible tourism market is relatively unknown
     and it seems difficult to attract with existing
     channels.
   • Visitors’ needs and requirements are unknown or
     misunderstood. Therefore the market is avoided.
   • Investment costs are misunderstood, exaggerated
   • Access is seen mainly as a ”problem” rather than a
     ”golden opportunity”.
Quiz time!
… can you see it?
Part 2.
Accessible Tourism in Europe: Challenges and Trends
   a. Demographics and Market Potential
   b. Human Rights
   c. The Business Case – Good Practices




                                                      17
Demographics

Demographic ageing in Europe




 … Age pyramid
Demographics

Demographic ageing in Europe
… Age pyramid?


Link: Ageing and Disability
Prevalence of disability and long-standing
health problems by age (Europe)




                            National Conference on
              The Right to Access for Persons With Disabilities
         To the Built Environment and Transportation, Design for All
Demand for accessible tourism in Europe
40

             % over 65 years with disabilities and long-term health difficulties                                                                                   37.1


35                                                                                                                                                            34

                                                                                                                                                  32   32.4

                                                                                                                                    30.4   30.6
                                                                                                                 29.1   29.5 30.3
30                                                                                                        28.6
                                                                                                   28.2
                                                                                            26.3
                                                                                25.2 25.7
                                                                         24.5
25
                                                           23.5   23.8
                                             22.9   23.2
                                        22

                                 20.4
                          19.4
20
            18.6   18.6
     17.6



15




10




 5


                                                     National Conference on
 0                                      The Right to Access for Persons With Disabilities
     SK     MT     RO     CY      To the Built Environment and Transportation, Design for All
                                 LT  LU  HU  IE  ES   IT NO  AT  GR  DE DK  CZ  SI  BE   PT SE                                             NL     EE   FR     UK   FI
Potential market for accessible tourism in Europe
   • If:
        70% of the population that requires accessible tourism
          provisions has both the physical and the financial means to
          travel.
        – The potential travel market is: > 89 million

   • But:
      – people with accessibility needs seldom travel alone:
      – With a multiplier effect for friends and family members: x 1.5

   • Then the general demand for accessible tourism is:
                                          127.5 million persons
   • Which is 27% of the European population
Total potential travel market in Europe:
         > 133 million tourists

                          National Conference on
            The Right to Access for Persons With Disabilities
       To the Built Environment and Transportation, Design for All
Total potential travel market in Europe:
              > €89 billion

                          National Conference on
            The Right to Access for Persons With Disabilities
       To the Built Environment and Transportation, Design for All
In brief:
                          100
                           90
                           80
                           70
                           60
                           50
                           40
                           30
                           20
                           10
                            0

  Like “Design-for-All”,        Essential   Desirable   Good to have



  …accessible tourism provisions are:

      Essential for at least 10% of the population
      Desirable for 40%
      Good for 100%
A Matter of Human Rights
The rights of persons with disabilities to equal
  participation in society must be respected by travel
  and tourism providers
• Overall strengthening of rights in EU states with legal powers
• Europe has signed the UN Declaration on the Rights of
  Persons with Disabilities
• The European Commission has proposed a Regulation on
  equal access to goods and services for disabled people.
• Tourism providers must be equipped with the confidence
  and ability to meet their legal responsibilities.
Business Case



• Good Practices in accessible tourism are found in
  many EU member States.
• The important thing is to learn from them and to
  improve, by following the good examples.

• Projects and Good Practices on the ENAT website:
  http://www.accessibletourism.org/?i=enat.en.projects




                                                         27
Business Case


• “VisitEngland” is the national tourist board for England, responsible for
marketing England to domestic and established overseas markets and for
improving England’s tourism product.

• It provides advice to tourism enterprises, publishes market data and
promotes England as a destination.

• The 2012 Olympics and Paralympic Games in London are the focus of
many initiatives to improve accessibility – and not only in London.

• Compliance with the UK Disability Discrimination Act impacts the sector.

                       http://www.visitengland.org/

                                                                              28
Business Case
       In 2009 the UK Visitor Survey asked:

       • Do you or does anyone travelling with you have a
       disability or a long-term health problem?

         11% of all visitors answered “yes”.

          Disabled visitors contributed almost £2bn to the
       English domestic visitor economy in 2009. (11% of
       total spending)

          Disabled visitors stay longer and spend more per
       visit, on average.



           http://www.visitengland.org/

                                                             29
Business Case

  Great Britain
Accessibility information on tourist-travel booking websites

• In Britain, over 7000 hotels and Bed & Breakfast establishments publish
accessibility information on their websites, enabling customers to find out what
to expect before they book.

• The access information is collected as part of the VB Quality Scheme, using
the access audit questions developed by the EU-funded OSSATE project
(“One-Stop-Shop for Accessible Tourism in Europe”) www.ossate.org

• Web statistics have shown that in 2010, sites which display access
information achieve 25% more “click-through-to-booking” than sites
which have no access information.
                      http://www.visitbritain.org/
                                                                                30
Business Case
             EUROTAXI – White Paper 2011
             1. Design and development of a Taxi for All
                customers
             2. A national support programme for
                procurement of accessible taxis
             3. Development of systems of taxi concessions
                and services at Municipal level
             4. Industrial production programme, cost
                reduction, standards.




       http://www.accessibletourism.org/?i=enat.en.news.1118


                                                               31
Business Case

      Spain
       Spanish Provinces: provision of taxis per 1,000 inhabitants

3.5
3.0
2.5
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0




                     http://www.accessibletourism.org/?i=enat.en.news.1118
        ________________ shows national average: 1.5 taxis per 1,000 inhabitants



                                                                                   32
Business Case



EUROTAXI




           http://www.accessibletourism.org/?i=enat.en.news.1118
                                                                   33
Business Case

   Spain

EUROTAXI: procurement > service > requirement
Stage 1. Public-private support for technical development and procurement
Stage 2. Service development and increasing customer use / demand
Stage 3. Legislated targets and full implementation in specified communities
2017 – Status review




                    http://www.accessibletourism.org/?i=enat.en.news.1118
                                                                               34
Business Case

   Portugal
Accessible Portugal Travel Agency
1. SME – small beginnings, fast growth
2. Inclusive holidays for people with disabilities, families and friends
3. Entrepreneur and Tourism Awards
4. “Accessible Destination” development partner




                         http://www.accessibleportugal.com/

                                                                           35
Business Case

Portugal




           http://www.accessibleportugal.com/

                                                36
Business Case

Portugal




                      Accessible Portugal is contributing to:
                   Infrastructure analysis & access upgrading,
                     Information, Activities, Services, Events,
                    Marketing, and ENAT Access Certification

           http://www.accessibleportugal.com/

                                                                  37
Part 3.
Spotlight on Policies and Actions for
Accessible Cities




                                        38
Incentives, Marketing, Awards…
         ENAT Code of Good Conduct
         Accessible Tourism Standards development
         ENAT Accessible Tourism Certification


         EU Access City awards


         EU EDEN Destinations of Excellence Awards


         UNWTO Ulysses Awards
                                                    39
Campaigns and initiatives
               EU Passenger Rights


               EDF Freedom of Movement


               EU Europa Nostra


               EU Calypso Social Tourism


                                           40
Networks and Projects
               eAccessplus ICT and Web Access

               League of Historical and
             Accessible Cities


              European Greenways Association

               Eurocities

               and more…

                                                41
Areas for development
  Enterprise level

  Cities and Destinations

  Regions

  Countries

  Global regions: Europe, Asia, North & South America,
Australasia, Africa


                                                         42
ENAT -Strategic developments
 UNWTO – ENAT – Fundación ONCE
 • Accessible Tourism Guidelines for States + Enterprises
 • Training - Themis Foundation
 • Employment insertion of persons with disabilities

 OECD Programme for Tourism
    • Actions for Accessible Tourism development

 EU Tourism Strategy 2010 – 2020
  • Requires accessibility tourism mainstreaming!


 EU Disability Strategy 2011 - 2020
                                                        43
What Defines Successful Accessible
Tourism Enterprises, Cities and
Destinations?
   1. Work out a policy and a strategy
      - Leadership comes from the top of the organisation
   2. Use networks and form partnerships
      - Discuss ideas, find partners, collaborate with NGOs and
      experts
   3. Address the whole access chain
      - Connect with other suppliers, develop new synergies
   4. Develop and market the destination
      - work from local to global level to improve facilities to high
      standards and reach target markets
   5. Deliver accessible tourism experiences
      - Aim to give every visitor a good, accessible experience!
In practical terms….
• Be prepared to welcome all visitors
• Question and revise ‘normal’ policies and practices
• Show leadership, find your allies
• Get access to resources and expertise
• Network with suppliers, stakeholders and supporters
• Encourage new businesses, focusing on access
• Invest in training and planning
• And don’t forget to tell what you have done!



                                                        45
The Rewards of
Accessible Tourism
  More visitors
  Longer tourist season
  New business and employment opportunities
  Increased income
  General improvements for the local citizens, the
  environment and society
  Happy customers, coming back again!
Networking & partnering for success

 Accessible Tourism “to do” list
 For Foundations and Cities...
   Join LHAC and ENAT networks
   Engage with other networks, form partnerships
   Participate in accessible tourism events
   Include the tourism sector in your strategies and
   projects
   Inform about your plans and share your experience
   Tell us your wishes! So we can support you…
ENAT Website   www.accessibletourism.org


                                               ENAT Code
                                               News
                                               Events
                                               Projects
                                               Good Practices
                                               Links
                                               Themes
                                               Library
                                               Forums
                                               Contacts
                 Powered by Google Translate   in 50+ languages
Contact: Ivor Ambrose
Email: enat@accessibletourism.org   Thankyou
Websites of National Tourist Boards
in Europe – Accessibility Information
Countries - Web Info                      YES   NO
Information on accessibility               19   20
Resources for policymakers                 8    31
Resources for business                     5    34
Resources for visitors                     17   22
Booking for accessible accommodation       8    31
Booking for accessible events /
attractions                                3    36
Link(s) to dedicated accessible tourism
website                                   12    27
E-mail contact for Accessible Tourism
webpages                                  28    11

                                                     50

Enat- Global Forum on Accessible Cities

  • 1.
    Travel and Tourismfor All Mr. Ivor Ambrose, Managing Director European Network for Accessible Tourism (ENAT) Global Forum on Accessible Cities Fondazione CRT, Torino, 16th June 2011 1
  • 2.
    Overview 1. Who needsaccessible travel and tourism? 2. Accessible Tourism in Europe: Challenges and Trends a. Market Potential b. Demographics & Human Rights c. The Business Case – Examples of Good Practices 3. Spotlight on Policies and Actions for Accessible Cities 2
  • 3.
    Part 1. Who needsaccessible travel and tourism? Toegankelijkheidsbureau vzw. Belgium 3
  • 4.
    When do customersneed accessible tourism? Throughout the “visitor journey” and the whole value chain! National Conference on The Right to Access for Persons With Disabilities To the Built Environment and Transportation, Design for All
  • 5.
    Demand Supply Access requirements: Accessible provisions in: • Travel offers • Information (www…) • Booking • Transport • Accommodation • Hearing impairments • Frail, elderly • Facilities • Visual impairments • Small children • Diet meals • Wheelchair users • Long-term illness • Attractions • Walking difficulties • Service animal • Excursions, activities • Allergies / Diets • Understanding the language • Care Services • Small or large stature • Learning difficulties Right to National Conference on Disabilities The Access for Persons With To the Built Environment and Transportation, Design for All
  • 6.
    Tourism Services Accessible…throughout entire delivery chain • Information - search, bookings, Websites, mobile… • Transport - vehicles, terminals, transfers, assistance… • Infrastructure - attractions, accommodation restaurants, streets, beaches… •Services - hospitality, packages, guiding, excursions, special menus, activities, tech-aids, assistance…
  • 7.
    The Problem: Forvisitors • Travel for people with disabilities is unpredictable, difficult or sometimes even impossible • Quality of infrastructure, transport, services, and information varies widely from place to place as well as between EU Member States • Lack of access standards increases uncertainty, reduces travel options and allows a lack of accountability to prevail.
  • 8.
    The Problem: Forthe tourism industry • The accessible tourism market is relatively unknown and it seems difficult to attract with existing channels. • Visitors’ needs and requirements are unknown or misunderstood. Therefore the market is avoided. • Investment costs are misunderstood, exaggerated • Access is seen mainly as a ”problem” rather than a ”golden opportunity”.
  • 9.
  • 16.
    … can yousee it?
  • 17.
    Part 2. Accessible Tourismin Europe: Challenges and Trends a. Demographics and Market Potential b. Human Rights c. The Business Case – Good Practices 17
  • 18.
    Demographics Demographic ageing inEurope … Age pyramid
  • 19.
    Demographics Demographic ageing inEurope … Age pyramid? Link: Ageing and Disability
  • 20.
    Prevalence of disabilityand long-standing health problems by age (Europe) National Conference on The Right to Access for Persons With Disabilities To the Built Environment and Transportation, Design for All
  • 21.
    Demand for accessibletourism in Europe 40 % over 65 years with disabilities and long-term health difficulties 37.1 35 34 32 32.4 30.4 30.6 29.1 29.5 30.3 30 28.6 28.2 26.3 25.2 25.7 24.5 25 23.5 23.8 22.9 23.2 22 20.4 19.4 20 18.6 18.6 17.6 15 10 5 National Conference on 0 The Right to Access for Persons With Disabilities SK MT RO CY To the Built Environment and Transportation, Design for All LT LU HU IE ES IT NO AT GR DE DK CZ SI BE PT SE NL EE FR UK FI
  • 22.
    Potential market foraccessible tourism in Europe • If: 70% of the population that requires accessible tourism provisions has both the physical and the financial means to travel. – The potential travel market is: > 89 million • But: – people with accessibility needs seldom travel alone: – With a multiplier effect for friends and family members: x 1.5 • Then the general demand for accessible tourism is: 127.5 million persons • Which is 27% of the European population
  • 23.
    Total potential travelmarket in Europe: > 133 million tourists National Conference on The Right to Access for Persons With Disabilities To the Built Environment and Transportation, Design for All
  • 24.
    Total potential travelmarket in Europe: > €89 billion National Conference on The Right to Access for Persons With Disabilities To the Built Environment and Transportation, Design for All
  • 25.
    In brief: 100 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 Like “Design-for-All”, Essential Desirable Good to have …accessible tourism provisions are: Essential for at least 10% of the population Desirable for 40% Good for 100%
  • 26.
    A Matter ofHuman Rights The rights of persons with disabilities to equal participation in society must be respected by travel and tourism providers • Overall strengthening of rights in EU states with legal powers • Europe has signed the UN Declaration on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities • The European Commission has proposed a Regulation on equal access to goods and services for disabled people. • Tourism providers must be equipped with the confidence and ability to meet their legal responsibilities.
  • 27.
    Business Case • GoodPractices in accessible tourism are found in many EU member States. • The important thing is to learn from them and to improve, by following the good examples. • Projects and Good Practices on the ENAT website: http://www.accessibletourism.org/?i=enat.en.projects 27
  • 28.
    Business Case • “VisitEngland”is the national tourist board for England, responsible for marketing England to domestic and established overseas markets and for improving England’s tourism product. • It provides advice to tourism enterprises, publishes market data and promotes England as a destination. • The 2012 Olympics and Paralympic Games in London are the focus of many initiatives to improve accessibility – and not only in London. • Compliance with the UK Disability Discrimination Act impacts the sector. http://www.visitengland.org/ 28
  • 29.
    Business Case In 2009 the UK Visitor Survey asked: • Do you or does anyone travelling with you have a disability or a long-term health problem? 11% of all visitors answered “yes”. Disabled visitors contributed almost £2bn to the English domestic visitor economy in 2009. (11% of total spending) Disabled visitors stay longer and spend more per visit, on average. http://www.visitengland.org/ 29
  • 30.
    Business Case Great Britain Accessibility information on tourist-travel booking websites • In Britain, over 7000 hotels and Bed & Breakfast establishments publish accessibility information on their websites, enabling customers to find out what to expect before they book. • The access information is collected as part of the VB Quality Scheme, using the access audit questions developed by the EU-funded OSSATE project (“One-Stop-Shop for Accessible Tourism in Europe”) www.ossate.org • Web statistics have shown that in 2010, sites which display access information achieve 25% more “click-through-to-booking” than sites which have no access information. http://www.visitbritain.org/ 30
  • 31.
    Business Case EUROTAXI – White Paper 2011 1. Design and development of a Taxi for All customers 2. A national support programme for procurement of accessible taxis 3. Development of systems of taxi concessions and services at Municipal level 4. Industrial production programme, cost reduction, standards. http://www.accessibletourism.org/?i=enat.en.news.1118 31
  • 32.
    Business Case Spain Spanish Provinces: provision of taxis per 1,000 inhabitants 3.5 3.0 2.5 1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 http://www.accessibletourism.org/?i=enat.en.news.1118 ________________ shows national average: 1.5 taxis per 1,000 inhabitants 32
  • 33.
    Business Case EUROTAXI http://www.accessibletourism.org/?i=enat.en.news.1118 33
  • 34.
    Business Case Spain EUROTAXI: procurement > service > requirement Stage 1. Public-private support for technical development and procurement Stage 2. Service development and increasing customer use / demand Stage 3. Legislated targets and full implementation in specified communities 2017 – Status review http://www.accessibletourism.org/?i=enat.en.news.1118 34
  • 35.
    Business Case Portugal Accessible Portugal Travel Agency 1. SME – small beginnings, fast growth 2. Inclusive holidays for people with disabilities, families and friends 3. Entrepreneur and Tourism Awards 4. “Accessible Destination” development partner http://www.accessibleportugal.com/ 35
  • 36.
    Business Case Portugal http://www.accessibleportugal.com/ 36
  • 37.
    Business Case Portugal Accessible Portugal is contributing to: Infrastructure analysis & access upgrading, Information, Activities, Services, Events, Marketing, and ENAT Access Certification http://www.accessibleportugal.com/ 37
  • 38.
    Part 3. Spotlight onPolicies and Actions for Accessible Cities 38
  • 39.
    Incentives, Marketing, Awards… ENAT Code of Good Conduct Accessible Tourism Standards development ENAT Accessible Tourism Certification EU Access City awards EU EDEN Destinations of Excellence Awards UNWTO Ulysses Awards 39
  • 40.
    Campaigns and initiatives EU Passenger Rights EDF Freedom of Movement EU Europa Nostra EU Calypso Social Tourism 40
  • 41.
    Networks and Projects eAccessplus ICT and Web Access League of Historical and Accessible Cities European Greenways Association Eurocities and more… 41
  • 42.
    Areas for development Enterprise level Cities and Destinations Regions Countries Global regions: Europe, Asia, North & South America, Australasia, Africa 42
  • 43.
    ENAT -Strategic developments UNWTO – ENAT – Fundación ONCE • Accessible Tourism Guidelines for States + Enterprises • Training - Themis Foundation • Employment insertion of persons with disabilities OECD Programme for Tourism • Actions for Accessible Tourism development EU Tourism Strategy 2010 – 2020 • Requires accessibility tourism mainstreaming! EU Disability Strategy 2011 - 2020 43
  • 44.
    What Defines SuccessfulAccessible Tourism Enterprises, Cities and Destinations? 1. Work out a policy and a strategy - Leadership comes from the top of the organisation 2. Use networks and form partnerships - Discuss ideas, find partners, collaborate with NGOs and experts 3. Address the whole access chain - Connect with other suppliers, develop new synergies 4. Develop and market the destination - work from local to global level to improve facilities to high standards and reach target markets 5. Deliver accessible tourism experiences - Aim to give every visitor a good, accessible experience!
  • 45.
    In practical terms…. •Be prepared to welcome all visitors • Question and revise ‘normal’ policies and practices • Show leadership, find your allies • Get access to resources and expertise • Network with suppliers, stakeholders and supporters • Encourage new businesses, focusing on access • Invest in training and planning • And don’t forget to tell what you have done! 45
  • 46.
    The Rewards of AccessibleTourism More visitors Longer tourist season New business and employment opportunities Increased income General improvements for the local citizens, the environment and society Happy customers, coming back again!
  • 47.
    Networking & partneringfor success Accessible Tourism “to do” list For Foundations and Cities... Join LHAC and ENAT networks Engage with other networks, form partnerships Participate in accessible tourism events Include the tourism sector in your strategies and projects Inform about your plans and share your experience Tell us your wishes! So we can support you…
  • 48.
    ENAT Website www.accessibletourism.org ENAT Code News Events Projects Good Practices Links Themes Library Forums Contacts Powered by Google Translate in 50+ languages
  • 49.
    Contact: Ivor Ambrose Email:enat@accessibletourism.org Thankyou
  • 50.
    Websites of NationalTourist Boards in Europe – Accessibility Information Countries - Web Info YES NO Information on accessibility 19 20 Resources for policymakers 8 31 Resources for business 5 34 Resources for visitors 17 22 Booking for accessible accommodation 8 31 Booking for accessible events / attractions 3 36 Link(s) to dedicated accessible tourism website 12 27 E-mail contact for Accessible Tourism webpages 28 11 50