12. The Smart Move Case Studies - Fleets
• Short journey length: 1.4 km
• EV was recharged every 5-7 days
Kitchen appliance
• Low temperature operation
manufacturer
Security patrol
• Poor staff induction caused a barrier to
Supermarket acceptance and operational difficulties
• Max journey length was just 27 km
Pool vehicle
•Solar PV for recharging
Charity
•Showcased green mobility at education
events and schools
Pool and educational
demonstration
19. The Smart Move Case Studies - Range
The trial range distribution
consists of three main and
separate components, the
smart, i_MiEV, the smart ed
and the smart minus the
Indesit range distribution
• 70 km i_MiEV
• 86 km smart ed
• 103 km smart ed (excluding Indesit)
21. The Smart Move Case Studies – Fleet Managers’
Questionnaire
• Purchase price assessment
• 100% of fleet managers accept EVs would be purchased at a premium – but the
maximum considered premium was 50%
22. The Smart Move Case Studies – Economics
• TOC analysis for smart ed and smart diesel
• Undertaken in the Cenex fleet carbon reduction tool
• Usage data feeds in to Economics
Fixed costs
Maintenance cost Vehicle cost
• Includes scheduled maintenance • Diesel £8,625
• Excludes unscheduled maintenance • Smart ed £15,000
• £20k insurance value minus PiCG
• Residual values set at 40%, 32%, 22% yrs
3, 5 and 7
• £0 road tax
• No BIK (Pool vehicle use)
• No additional insurance cost
Variable costs
Energy cost Mileage
•Fixed cost • Base case (312 days/annum)
•118 ppl • Increased mileage (Base case x 2)
•8.4 p/kWh
• Stretched mileage (12,000 MPA)
•Linear extrapolation
•204 ppl in year 7
•14.7 p/kWh in year 7
23. The Smart Move Case Studies – Economics
Mileage scenarios Case study Energy price scenario and annualised TCO differential (£)
Fixed energy prices Linear rising energy prices
Low
Yr 3 Yr 5 Yr 7 Yr 3 Yr 5 Yr 7
Base case Indesit 303 272 287 237 152 113
Asda 280 250 264 209 119 73
Mileage
Groundwork 401 370 385 362 300 282
Increased mileage Indesit 65 35 49 -66 -205 -299
Asda 20 -10 4 -122 -273 -378
Groundwork 261 230 245 184 89 39
Stretched mileage Indesit -269 -299 -285 -492 -708 -878
Asda 15 -15 -1 -129 -280 -387
High
Groundwork -11 -42 -27 -163 -320 -433
Energy price
Low High
27. Midlands PiP
EV/PHEV market development via charge point deployment in the East and
West Midlands
Plan to oversee installation of > 500
public and 200 domestic charge
posts + 1 new housing development,
all with common back office system
> 50 Partners including Local Authorities,
Central Networks, Rail Operators, Shopping
Centres, Science Parks, Car Companies, etc
28. Challenges – Standards / Technology
Types of Charging Point
Standard or Fast Quick Home
(Post or Wall)
29. Finances
• Total project value of £6.3m
• Grant awarded £2.95m
FY 11/12 £1.40m
FY 12/13 £1.55m
• 40% grant contribution towards
host infrastructure capital costs
96. Help!
Cenex
Powastation
Smarter Travel Leicester
Go Travel Solutions
Fit 4 Business
…..each other
97. Social Media
You can now follow Go Travel Solutions on
Twitter, LinkedIn & Slideshare
Smarter Travel Leicester is now on Facebook and
you can now follow us on Slideshare
Psssst….. This workshop presentation will be uploaded on to
Slideshare
98. Thank you
Thank you to John Lewis, Chris, Mick, Graham & Patrick
and Highcross
Green Motion – Prize Draw
Help to spread the word
Next workshop: Thursday 10th May – 10:30
Show me the money
Cost busting measures for business travel & commuting
with RSM Tenon
Feedback – e-mail in the next day