SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Research Report
Submitted by: Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo), a Division of Science at The Field Museum
To: The City of Chicago Department of Environment
COMMUNITY #5: WEST RIDGE’S SOUTH ASIAN COMMUNITY
Engaging Chicago’s Diverse Communities in
the Chicago Climate Action Plan
City of Chicago
Richard M. Daley, Mayor
Department of Environment
tableofcontents
Sponsored by
1	 PROJECT OVERVIEW
4	 COMMUNITY OVERVIEW
6	 STAKEHOLDERS, PARTNERSHIPS,
	 AND RELATIONSHIP-BUILDING
8	 AWARENESS OF CLIMATE
	 CHANGE AND INTEREST IN
	 ADDRESSING IT
11	 COMMUNITY CONCERNS:
	 SPRINGBOARDS FOR CLIMATE
	ACTION
16	ENVIRONMENTALLY-FRIENDLY
	 PRACTICES, VALUES, AND
	TRADITIONS
19	 COMMUNICATION AND
	DISSEMINATION
20	 CREATIVE MODELS FOR
	 COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT
21	CONCLUSION
22	 COMMUNITY ASSET MAP
23	 REGIONAL ASSET MAP
24	 OUR TEAM
	BIBLIOGRAPHY
	 LIST OF PARTICIPATING
	ORGANIZATIONS	
This research was commissioned by the
City of Chicago Department of Environment.
Research was conducted by:
Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo),
a Division of Science at The Field Museum
with our partners:
City of Chicago Department of Environment
Chicago Cultural Alliance
Indo-American Center
Indo-American Heritage Museum
May 2011
Visit our Web site to download the Community and Regional
Asset Maps, and reports about other communities:
http://fieldmuseum.org/climateaction
Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report 1
project overview
Engaging Chicago Communities in the Chicago Climate Action
Plan—Community #5: The South Asian Community of West Ridge is
the fifth community study commissioned by the City of Chicago Department
of Environment (DOE) to identify strategies for effectively engaging diverse
communities throughout the city in the implementation of the Chicago Climate
Action Plan (CCAP). This report presents the results from one site of a two-
sited mini study that also included the Mexican community of Chicago’s Pilsen
neighborhood.
Our first two studies had a geographic focus, one on South Chicago––a
working class, racially diverse area on Chicago’s far South Side––and the other
on North Kenwood-Oakland/Bronzeville, an economically diverse, African-
American area of the city situated just three miles south of Chicago’s downtown.
The third study was the first to focus on an ethnic group––Chicago’s Polish
community––and was concentrated in three Chicago regions with large Polish
populations. The West Ridge and Pilsen studies are the first to be delineated
by both neighborhood geography and ethnicity, and they are also the first to
incorporate community-led storytelling as a data gathering technique.
All of our studies are participatory action research projects that have been
conducted by a team including The Field Museum anthropologists, staff from
the Chicago Department of Environment, and leaders of community-based
organizations in the research communities. In this study, our research was
designed and conducted collaboratively, in English, Urdu and Hindi, by a team
including anthropologists from The Field Museum’s division of Environment,
Culture, and Conservation (ECCo), the Chicago Cultural Alliance (CCA),
and leaders from the Indo-American Heritage Museum (IAHM), a cultural
organization in West Ridge. While the anthropologist from CCA collected
qualitative data through traditional ethnographic methods, the anthropologists
from The Field Museum trained leaders from IAHM in story collecting
techniques and worked with them to facilitate focus groups throughout the
study.
Located just off of Devon Avenue where the Indian-Pakistani business district
defines the character of the area, the Indo-American Heritage Museum is a
relatively new organization that was formed by board members of the Indo-
American Center (IAC), a center that serves hundreds of South Asian clients
daily through classes in ESL, civics, computers, immigration assistance, as well
as senior and youth programs. The Indo-American Heritage Museum offers
cultural programs that promote understanding of the diversity, history, and
culture of Indian Americans in the Chicago area. IAHM is currently located
at the Indo-American Center on California and Devon, where they offer
educational programs and display a modest collection that represents life in
members’ homelands and their Chicago diaspora. IAHM’s programs include
cultural performances, inter-ethnic dialogues, tours of Devon Avenue, and
workshops about the Indian American immigration story for educators and the
general public. While they expand their space and build their collection, IAHM
has launched a “virtual museum” where website visitors can explore Chicago’s
Indo-American culture and community members can share personal stories on
selected themes.
West Ridge
RESEARCH AREA
2 Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report
This research project combined traditional ethnographic methods, such as
interviewing and participant observation, with the innovative technique of
community-led story collecting. Through workshops, sharing research tools,
and personal mentoring ethnographers at The Field Museum worked closely
with staff members at Indo-American Heritage Museum to develop their skills as
story collectors. This collaborative approach allowed us to pair complementary
methods of gathering data. While the project ethnographer was working to
complete a rapid inventory of both the West Ridge and Pilsen neighborhoods,
our community partners were busy collecting stories from their clients and peers.
Touching base regularly along the way, the ethnographer and local leaders
supported one another’s work through the exchange of contacts, leads, ideas,
and tools. For the duration of the fieldwork season, both the ethnographer
and local partners used a variety of creative tools developed by ECCo to learn
about how residents relate to the environment and climate change, such as
using objects and photos to prompt discussion.
Incorporating the methods of story collecting has enhanced both the research
product and the resources and knowledge of our community partners. Story
collecting techniques enriched the study by contributing narrative stories
to semi-structured interview data gathered by the ethnographer. This has
provided a more nuanced and holistic understanding of community dynamics
and has broadened the contribution of community members and leaders
in the research process. In addition, learning and applying story collecting
techniques strengthened the social capital of our community partners, who
said that gathering stories has improved their understanding of community
concerns and resources. Modhurima Mukherjee of IAHM told us that she has a
deeper understanding of the community as a result of her experience collecting
stories. Just as importantly, she says, the merchants and residents whom she
talked with are now more aware of the resources and events offered by IAHM.
Ultimately, the experience of collecting stories, identifying community assets,
and strengthening organizing skills will help our community partners to create
programs and services which better address community concerns including
environmental issues and climate change.
Field research for this project lasted four months, from May through August
2010. During this time, The Field Museum researchers and community
partners conducted interviews, gathered stories, and held focus groups to
better understand research participants’ beliefs and practices related to the
environment and climate change. Because these study communities are
defined by participants’ ethnic identity as well as their geographic location, we
recruited participants who fall into one of three main categories. Our primary
focus was South Asian residents of the West Ridge neighborhood. Secondarily,
we spoke with a number of Chicago-area South Asians who work, shop, or
use services in West Ridge but who reside elsewhere. Thirdly, we spoke with
neighbors, workers, and community leaders who live or work in West Ridge,
but who are not of South Asian origin. This recruitment strategy recognizes that
our target populations do not live in any single urban area, but are socially
integrated into Chicago’s multi-cultural metropolitan region. It also allows us
to gain perspectives from local residents and leaders that helped to deepen our
awareness of neighborhood dynamics.
One of our goals in studying ethnic communities is to better understand the
ways in which cultural values and traditions in communities of origin might
facilitate or hamper participation in climate action strategies in Chicago.
Another goal is to understand how ethnic heritage intersects with community
activities and creates patterns of interaction that reach from Devon Avenue to
Delhi. As a result of having both an ethnic and a geographic focus, this study
also highlights the social networks that connect urban immigrants with Chicago
communities.
The majority of this research was ethnographic, with the goal of gaining an
understanding of people’s behaviors and attitudes by studying them in the
context of their everyday lives. Like most research, ethnographic research aims
to identify patterns and linkages between issues; but it is also based on the
notion that people are experts on their own lives and, as such, aims to highlight
local knowledge and practices as the building blocks for creating more
sustainable communities.
PROJECT OVERVIEW
In total, we directly engaged approximately 135 people through interviews,
focus groups, surveys, and story collecting that included residents, business
owners, civil leaders, and leaders of community organizations. Our research
included:
•	 23 semi-structured interviews;
•	 3 focus groups with a total of 64 participants;
•	 72 surveys;
•	 Over 50 stories collected; and,
•	 Participant-observation at 9 community events and meetings that involved
approximately 250 people.
Due to the high concentration of immigrants among the adult population
of West Ridge and because of the organizational networks that we used for
recruitment, an overwhelming majority of our study participants were first
generation immigrants. All were adults and many were clients of the Indo-
American Center.
The goals of this study were to:
1.	 Document attitudes and knowledge related to climate change;
2.	 Identify climate-friendly practices and values;
3.	 Describe community concerns that link environment to quality of life;
4.	 Identify key organizations that can act as catalysts for larger scale adoption
of climate action strategies;
5.	 Highlight creative models of engagement that can be adopted for climate
action;
6.	 Determine effective communication strategies for disseminating information.
Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report 3
PROJECT OVERVIEW
Engaging the Community Our partners at the Indo-American
Heritage Museum participated in community meetings, focus groups, and
interviews to gather stories from a wide variety of West Ridge residents
and business owners. In these pictures, West Ridge residents share stories
about themselves, their culture, and their concerns, as well as their
aspirations to create a sustainable community.
4 Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report
community overview
West Ridge on Chicago’s far North Side has a rich tradition as an
immigrant community. Historically known for its large Jewish population, West
Ridge has become home to many different ethnic groups over the past half
century. Nearly half of its current residents are foreign-born, making it one of
the city’s most ethnically diverse neighborhoods. As we heard from residents of
West Ridge, this diversity is a great asset that attracts customers to the area’s
vibrant commercial corridors and enhances its cultural life. Yet, residents also
say that ethnic diversity presents challenges; community members with divergent
origins, customs, and habits must learn how to work together toward common
community goals.
The area is home to Devon Avenue, one of the city’s most popular commercial
corridors. The Devon corridor, also known as “The International Marketplace,”
is lined with ethnic retail shops, grocery stores, and vegetarian restaurants. It is
the commercial and symbolic center of Chicagoland’s South Asian population,
with a concentration of businesses and organizations that cater to members of
Chicago’s Indian, Pakistani, and Bangladeshi communities. The neighborhood
also features strong commercial corridors along Touhy and Western Avenues.
Along with its ethnic diversity, West Ridge is also very diverse socio-
economically. While West Ridge is popularly identified as a relatively
prosperous, middle-class neighborhood, residents have a wide range of
income and living conditions. Nearly ten percent of West Ridge residents live in
households with an annual income under $10,000, while the top ten percent of
households earn over $100,000 annually. Within the South Asian community
more broadly, there is a bifurcation in regards to socioeconomic status, where
more affluent South Asians tend to be longer-term U.S. residents, who often
live in Chicago’s suburbs. Conversely, working-class and poor South Asians
are more likely to be new immigrants and to live in apartments near the Devon
corridor and on the margins of the neighborhood.
These socio-economic factors influence what residents are able to do regarding
the environment, with wealthier residents having more control over the decisions
that shape their home environments. While some low-income West Ridge
residents still find ways to invest in eco-friendly practices such as gardening,
recycling, and composting, they often live in apartment buildings with strict
regulations on these practices. In contrast, residents who own their own homes
have greater financial and regulatory freedom to bridge the built and natural
environments.
WAVES OF SOUTH ASIAN
IMMIGRATION TO CHICAGO
1940 1960 1980 2000
pre-1946:
no significant immigration of
South Asians due to restrictive
quotas (called “Asian
Exclusions”) and “racially
ineligibility” for citizenship
1946-1965:
India allotted 100 visas annually;
Indian population of Chicago grew
to approximately 350 by 1960
1965- mid-1980s:
restrictions on Asian immigration lifted;
dramatic increase in South Asian immigration,
facilitated by family reunification visas and H-1
visas for skilled workers; worked in medicine,
infrastructure, and research
1950 1970 1990 2010
mid-1980s-present:
rise in low-skilled and unauthorized
migration; rapid suburbanization
					One local business
					owner told us that
					she has invested a
					great deal of time and
					effort into beautifying
				 her restaurant. She has
	 	 	 	        installed flower boxes
		 	 and planters in front and hopes that
this will motivate neighboring merchants to invest in the
appearance of their storefronts as well.
Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report 5
COMMUNITY OVERVIEW
There is a large senior population of South Asians in West Ridge. As
established South Asian professionals send for their elderly parents under family
reunification visas, the proportion of newly arrived seniors in the South Asian
community is large and growing. Many of the services provided by area civic
organizations are geared toward helping these new arrivals adjust to life in the
United States, and they offer classes in civics, English, and computers, as well
as space where seniors can be part of a social and cultural community. The
stories of these elders reveal that age also influences local residents’ ability to
initiate or maintain eco-friendly practices. West Ridge also has a large youth
population among South Asians, as middle-age residents are likely to have
children under the age of eighteen.
While constricted due to building and association
policies, one man described several ways that he has
been able to live a more environmentally-friendly lifestyle.
His routine includes drying clothes next to the windows
instead of spending money at the laundromat. He also
recycles old and unused items instead of throwing them
away.
One community organizer told us that the
mobility of her elderly clients is constrained
by a lack of transportation options that
link the suburbs and the city. She said
that one of her clients, who is 76 years
old, broke down and sobbed when he
informed her that his son had bought a
house in the suburbs. The distance
would make it impossible for the man
to socialize with his friends near Devon.
Rec ommendation:
Develop initiatives that help West Ridge elders to build community
while engaging in eco-friendly activities. Create and support
spaces that can link the ethnic diversity of the West Ridge area
to green efforts, such as recycling, walking, gardening, and
beautification.
COMMUNITY OVERVIEW
6 Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report
For many South Asian immigrants the City of Chicago served as
a temporary home where they could get settled enough to establish work
and support their families. After spending years or decades in the city, a
large number of affluent South Asians immigrants have chosen to migrate
to surrounding suburbs. This has resulted in dispersed community resources
throughout Chicago’s city and suburbs. Social service resources for new
immigrants tend to be concentrated near working-class residences in the city,
while large temples and heritage centers have followed more affluent South
Asians to suburban locations. More affluent South Asians donate time and
resources to many of the civic and service organizations that cater to newer
waves of immigrants concentrated near Devon. Relatedly, while Indian stores
and places of worship are increasingly common in Chicago’s suburbs, Devon
Avenue remains a primary commercial hub of South Asian goods and services.
In all, the South Asian community of greater Chicago is connected by social
and professional networks, an extensive civic sector, and a thriving business
district along Devon Avenue.
The shops along Devon Avenue are identified as particularly important for
Chicago-area South Asians, many of whom regularly travel from the suburbs to
Devon to shop for food and clothing, and to get news and entertainment from
the various video shops, bookstores, and restaurants. Devon is not just for South
Asians, however; ethnic restaurants attract diners from all over Chicago who
are looking to enjoy Indian, Bangladeshi, Pakistani, and vegetarian cuisine. This
region-wide investment in Devon helps to sustain West Ridge residents, which
includes patrons, business owners, and workers.
West Ridge is home to much more than just commercial businesses. It is also
a hub of civic organizations that service new South Asian and Middle Eastern
immigrants through ESL classes, computer classes, job training, assistance
with immigration status adjustment, and media and information in Hindi and
Urdu, among other languages. Because of the large elderly population in the
South Asian community, organizations such as the Indo-American Center and
Metropolitan Asian Family Services also provide health care, free lunches, and
social events that cater to seniors. The Indo-American Center also has a youth
program that takes advantage of local assets, such as the West Ridge YMCA
and neighborhood parks, to engage South Asian children in outdoor activities.
In addition to these service providers, South Asian residents in West Ridge
have cultivated extensive social networks that supply crucial resources for their
financial security and emotional well-being. Hometown associations, such as
the Punjabi Cultural Society and Gujarati Samaj Chicago, bring together first
and second generation South Asians from particular Indian states to participate
in cultural events such as dinners, dances, and festivals. Organizations for
South Asian students and alumni have formed on the nearby campus of Loyola
University and downtown’s University of Illinois at Chicago and provide not only
social support, but educational resources as well. Social networks also provide
a means for South Asian residents to participate in Devon’s business community,
as interest-free or informal business loans are made by established business
people to select network members, enabling them to open small businesses and
to maintain Devon’s ethnic enclaves.
stakeholders,
PARTNERSHIPS, AND RELATIONSHIP-BUILDING
Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report 7
Religious beliefs and practices among South Asians are as diverse as the South
Asian community itself, and West Ridge is home to several centers of worship
that serve Chicago’s South Asian population. Though the largest Hindu temples
are located in Chicago suburbs, there is a Hare Krishna temple, a Sikh temple,
an Indo-Pak Methodist Church, and several mosques located in or around
Devon Avenue. Our study participants also noted that, while many South Asians
visit temples to celebrate religious holidays, most frequently they worship in
private or with family and friends at home. Religious worship is thus also social
interaction that bolsters the informal networks that are critical for the well-being
of Chicago’s South Asians.
STAKEHOLDERS, PARTNERSHIPS,
AND RELATIONSHIP-BUILDING
Rec ommendation:
Work with area organizations including hometown associations,
civic organizations, centers of worship and Devon’s business
community for developing a West Ridge climate action plan.
Encourage leaders in all of these arenas to model eco-friendly
living for others in the community, and create networking
opportunities that highlight what local green leaders are
already doing.
STAKEHOLDERS, PARTNERSHIPS,
AND RELATIONSHIP-BUILDING
8 Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report
Many of our study participants were aware of climate change and
expressed an interest in addressing it. We found a broad range of beliefs
regarding climate change and the environment, with many participants
reminiscing about living “naturally” in India but also concerned about what they
consider to be more immediate problems in the United States. Younger study
participants routinely expressed a higher degree of awareness and interest in
climate action programs than their elderly counterparts, who frequently said
that climate change was not among their most pressing concerns. Nevertheless,
older study participants were enthusiastic in recounting stories about
environmentally-friendly lifestyles and practices in India.
When discussing the environment, participants frequently spoke of
environmental issues in India, with far less attention to environmental
concerns in the Chicago region. Many remembered their childhoods in India
and expressed concern about how changing weather patterns are affecting
traditional life ways. For example, participants worried that changes such as
rising sea levels, waste, and water contamination have already had serious
impacts on both the health and economic activities of people who live in South
Asia. Older participants often linked climate change to the scarcity of local
resources like clean water, rather than to global environmental changes. As one
participant observed, “In India [climate change] is a big concern, but here it is
less of a concern because it’s so much better here in terms of clean water and
the environment.” Another noted that people use rain barrels in India, but since
there is no apparent water shortage in Chicago, there is no perception of a
need for water conservation here. This story reveals a deeper trend: many South
Asians in West Ridge see the threat that Climate Change poses to India, but not
to the Chicago area. For these residents, perceptions of resource abundance in
Chicago can make conservation efforts seem superfluous.
There was broad recognition among our study participants that climate change
is caused by human activities. However, participants diverged on the question of
who is responsible for taking action to address it. While the majority of younger
interviewees asserted that all global residents share in the responsibility to be
environmentally responsible, many of our older participants identified industry
and government as the major polluters and felt that individual responses to
climate change are largely insignificant.
awareness
OF CLIMATE CHANGE AND
interestIN ADDRESSING IT
One young staff person at a local community
center said that she tried to pilot a program
to reduce paper waste, but she encountered
obstacles from her organization. Her manager
believed that initiating a recycling program would
incur extra cost to their organization. Thus,
she now separates the paper in her office and
takes it to a recycling center across the street.
One immigrant from a coastal town in India told us that
many people in his home community survive by fishing. He
worries about the impact that depleted fish stores will
have on his hometown economy and said that his family
members in India are growing
concerned about rising sea
levels and changes in the weather.
Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report 9
AWARENESS AND INTEREST
WHAT THREE WORDS COME TO MIND WHEN YOU HEAR “CLIMATE CHANGE”?
Participants were asked this
question during our interviews. In
this word cloud, words that were
most often mentioned appear
larger. This reveals significant
patterns:
1.	 RISING TEMPERATURES:
Respondents frequently
associated climate change with
changes in the composition
of the earth, as triggered
by warmer temperatures.
Concerns about these shifts
are represented in the high
occurrences of “Global
Warming,” “Sea Levels,” and
“Glaciers” in participants’
responses. Also prominent
were responses like “rising,”
“hot,” and “melting.”
2.	 HUMAN AGENCY: It is clear that many participants believe that humans can have an impact on Climate Change. Words like “Recycling,” “Education,” and
“Structural Policy” reflect respondents awareness of the positive actions people can take in the face of climate destabilization. Additionally, participants pointed
to a “lack of government support.”
3.	 FUTURE DANGERS: Respondents frequently drew a link between climate change and the potential dangers it holds for our future. They regularly invoked the
following words, “famine,” “starvation,” “children,” “doomsday scenario,” and “animal habitat extinctions.”
AWARENESS AND INTEREST
10 Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report
RANKING THE CCAP STRATEGIES
improved
energy15
waste22
reduction
transportation
efficiency
adaptation
14
19
Respondents ranked waste reduction and improved
transportation highest, which makes sense for a high-traffic areas
with high levels of consumption. Adaptation ranked last, reflecting a poor
understanding of the concept and/or the higher cost that participants fear
that adaptation strategies would incur.
Research participants were asked to rank each of these CCAP strategies
according to their level of interest:
Rec ommendations:
1.	 Work with local leaders to make Climate Change feel local
among to the South Asian community, promoting its potential
impacts on the Chicago area. Take advantage of popular
awareness regarding resource scarcity and conservation
practices in South Asia, and work with organizations along
Devon to promote opportunities for taking climate actions.
2.	 Identify young community members through the Indo-
American Center, YMCA, and other local agencies. Connect
them to climate educators and organizers who could help
them to see themselves as climate action leaders.
AWARENESS OF CLIMATE CHANGE
AND INTEREST IN ADDRESSING IT
Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report 11
Our research identified a number of important community concerns
in the South Asian community of West Ridge that could serve as springboards
for community involvement in climate action. The concerns that we highlight in
this section include:
1.	 Immigration
2.	 Economic development
•	 Small Business Viability
•	 Housing
•	 Jobs
3.	 Heritage/identity
4.	 Health
5.	 Use of public space
Immigration was a serious concern of many of our study participants,
particularly those who live and work near Devon Avenue. Undocumented
status and English-language difficulties were cited as serious barriers to upward
mobility and social well-being for many new South Asian immigrants in West
Ridge. Immigration is a theme that was mentioned by study participants in
relation to all of the following concerns.
Our participants see the ability to have successful businesses that provide jobs
as key to community stability overall, from creating steady work to alleviating
crime and the problem of abandoned buildings. Study participants linked
their financial concerns with a variety of more specific preoccupations, such
as crowded and abandoned housing, underemployment of new immigrants,
as well as economic development along West Ridge’s commercial corridors .
These corridors – along Devon, Touhy, and Western Avenues – are all important
sources of revenue for the neighborhood. Residents expressed concern about
economic decline of small businesses along these corridors, concerned with the
impact that the current economic recession is having on the financial health of
West Ridge. Several interviewees were also very concerned about disinvestment
in the community on the part of local politicians.
SMALL BUSINESS VIABILITY
In particular, participants are concerned that Devon’s poor appearance, traffic
congestion, and lack of parking will drive customers elsewhere, as South Asian
stores become more prevalent in the suburbs. Business owners and residents
offered many suggestions for beautifying Devon and making it more accessible,
including the addition of more parking, trees and green spaces, planters, more
attractive street lamps, and “plazas” where shoppers can sit in comfort. Though
congestion is already a problem, interviewees also offered ideas for further
increasing visitors to Devon. Several suggested capitalizing on the area’s ethnic
diversity and creating an “Indian Village” akin to Chicago’s Chinatown or
Greektown, with a formal gateway and pedestrian paths. Such a beautification
plan would draw “tourists” from outside the neighborhood and emphasize the
community concernsSPRINGBOARDS FOR CLIMATE ACTION
	IMMIGRATION
	 ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
South Asian assets of the Devon corridor. Participants would also like to see
more diverse offerings among the shops on Devon, citing a lack of variety as a
source of unhealthy business competition and high business turnover.
HOUSING
West Ridge is known for its comfortable homes on tree-lined residential streets,
and is sometimes referred to as a “suburb within the city.” Yet, West Ridge
residents who live near the Devon corridor often live in crowded apartment
complexes, far away from the parks and trees that make the community so
attractive. Crowded housing complexes were disdained by several of our study
participants, who identified them as hubs of crime and poverty, while others
noted that these buildings offer affordable housing for low-income families
in the area. Several participants also complained that developers had begun
converting neighborhood apartment buildings to condominium units, but
abandoned the projects when the housing market contracted in 2008, leaving
behind a glut of unfinished and deserted buildings.
JOBS
Underemployment and low wages for workers along the Devon corridor was
a source of concern for many of our study participants. Many new immigrants
from South Asia face serious barriers to upward mobility when they arrive
in Chicago, including limited English proficiency, low or obsolete job skills,
unauthorized status, and advanced age. Many of these new immigrants become
engaged in informal labor practices within Devon’s ethnic enclaves, where
they earn low wages and have little job security. Even when new immigrants
held skilled or semi-skilled jobs in India, these skills are not always easily
adaptable to the job market in Chicago. To help with the integration needs of
new South Asian immigrants, the Indo-American Center offers literacy classes,
computer classes, and job training programs. Moving forward, it will be vital
for local businesses and agencies to create green training and employment
opportunities, ideally in ways that strengthen local businesses relationship to the
environment.
The ethnic diversity of West Ridge is considered both an asset and a challenge,
depending in part on who is offering their opinion. While the diversity of
shops and restaurants is one of the main attractions of Devon’s “International
Marketplace,” neighborhood residents are still learning to relate to one another
across divergent beliefs and practices. Other participants noted that longer-term
demographic change in the community presents a challenge for older or more
established West Ridge residents. One interviewee said, “People don’t recognize
this neighborhood. It used to be an Irish neighborhood, then Eastern European
Jews came, now South Asians, most of the Anglos have moved out. There is
some tension about these changes in the neighborhood, and there has been
gentrification for the last four to five years.”
Several participants expressed concern about the loss of Indian heritage and
identity among second-generation Indians in Chicago. Participants worried that
their children are losing their Indian heritage as they assimilate to American
culture. “In India, the young people cover their skin more and do not spend so
much time on the street,” one mother said, explaining her concern over a loss
of modesty and tradition among the second generation. Yet, young participants
explain that social organizations and events for young South Asians, such as
“Desi Nights” at Chicago restaurants and clubs, help second generation youth
deal with their “in between” status as both Americans and Asians. Programs
and events sponsored by the IAHM highlight Indian culture and heritage and
promote linkages among South Asian community members in the wider
Chicago area.
Many study participants mentioned that the relative affluence of South Asian
immigrants compared to other immigrant groups has contributed to a “model
minority” stereotype of South Asians as upwardly mobile, educated, and
well-to-do. While this reputation can be a source of pride, many participants
SPRINGBOARDS FOR CLIMATE ACTION
	HERITAGE/IDENTITY
12 Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report
Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report 13
SPRINGBOARDS FOR CLIMATE ACTION
described it a “burden” as well. In particular, widespread perceptions of South
Asians as upwardly mobile contribute to a reticence to acknowledge and invest
resources in a growing population of poor and undocumented South Asian
immigrants. Interviewees who work closely with immigrants who live and work
near Devon told us that a greater awareness of the problems and obstacles
facing new South Asian immigrants is critical to a more nuanced understanding
of the South Asian community as a whole.
Health was one of the most important concerns cited by study participants.
Interviewees noted that conditions such as diabetes and high blood pressure
occur at very high frequencies among South Asian immigrants. While genetic
factors play a role in the onset of these diseases, participants also said
that high-fat diets, an aging population, and sedentary lifestyles contribute
to community health concerns. While the vegetarian diet of many Hindu
participants provides a healthful dietary foundation, some interviewees
noted that deep frying vegetarian dishes exacerbate heart disease among
South Asians. Among new and poor immigrants, health problems are often
exacerbated by a lack of access to medical coverage and affordable health
care. One interviewee told us that an acquaintance returned to India to have
surgery because the cost of the procedure here was prohibitively expensive.
Participants also noted that there are serious mental health concerns in the
community––particularly among the elderly. A move from South Asia to the
United States is frequently associated with a loss in social status, isolation,
and boredom for elderly immigrants. This problem is particularly acute for
seniors who live with their adult children who are working full-time, leaving
them alone for long hours during the day. One participant explained, “There
is a lot of senior dependency which leads to mental health issues; these have
to do with the kinds of opportunities that are available here and with moving
down in status. Seniors often have a sense of isolation and boredom when they
come here.” Elderly South Asians who live near Devon can take advantage
of programs offered by the Indo-American Center and Metropolitan Family
Health Services, where they receive free lunches and participate in social events.
The free lunch program at IAC alone services between fifty and eighty seniors
daily. Suburban seniors have limited access to these centers, leading many
interviewees to emphasize the importance of having affordable and convenient
public transportation that links the suburbs and the city.
A group of three women told us that their families
practiced numerous environmentally-friendly activities
in India, such as raising chickens and air drying
clothes. They have found it difficult to continue these
practices in Chicago due to space constraints and
strict policies in the buildings where they live. They
further fear that their neighbors would perceive them
as uneducated and incapable of behaving in American
society if they resumed these practices. Without this
fear of judgment they were all interested in returning to
these traditional activities.
	HEALTH
SPRINGBOARDS FOR CLIMATE ACTION
There are several neighborhood organizations that provide free health care
services for the South Asian community. For example, the Indo-American
Center and Metropolitan Family Services regularly bring in doctors who screen
their clients for various conditions. Asian Family Services on Peterson Avenue
provides medical care for low-income West Ridge residents, about eighty
percent of whom lack health insurance and about twenty percent of whom are
of South Asian origin. These organizations are thus vital sources for information
and assistance with health issues for the entire South Asian community and its
elderly population in particular. While study participants touted the benefits of
accessible health care, our participants also noted that rapid diagnoses without
any long-term follow-up do not always lead to improvements in their clients’
health.
Study participants who work and shop along Devon frequently commented on
its appearance, and in particular expressed concern about garbage and litter
along the street and sidewalks, a lack of shade and trees, and parking problems
and traffic congestion. Nevertheless, many of our study participants also noted
the popularity of the Devon corridor among Chicago-area South Asians who
enjoy browsing, shopping, and socializing there. Several interviewees pointed
out that the benches along Devon were particularly popular spots for sitting and
socializing, but also said that shade trees would enhance the benches’ usability.
Many participants felt that there were adequate garbage cans along Devon for
trash disposal, and many expressed appreciation for the solar compactors that
have been recently installed. However, several also said that Devon’s trash cans
do not get emptied frequently enough and are often overflowing with garbage.
Similarly, one business owner said that bins for clothing donations located in
his parking lot are emptied very rarely, and, as a consequence, there are often
bags spilling over with clothing littering the lot. “It is a nuisance,” he said,
adding that, rather than being an asset, the donation bins actually contribute to
the dirty appearance of Devon.
While many participants expressed appreciation for area parks such as Indian
Boundary Park and Rogers Park, they also commented that illicit activities in the
parks––and drug dealing in particular in Warren Park––make them unusable in
the evenings. Some participants also felt that park equipment, such as courts
and playgrounds, suffer from a lack of upkeep. Still, many of our participants
use the parks regularly for exercise and recreation, and the youth program
coordinator at IAC frequently takes the children to the park during the summer,
where they can play games and engage in physical activities.
One man reminisced about his beautiful farmhouse in
India, where he had a variety of flowers and cereals. He
says he misses that here, and he laments that space-
constraints and age-related ailments have prevented him
form taking up gardening in Chicago.
	 USE OF PUBLIC SPACE
14 Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report
Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report 15
SPRINGBOARDS FOR CLIMATE ACTION
1.	 Invest in green spaces projects along Devon Avenue that bring nature to the corridor.
2.	 Provide incentives to empty lot owners, especially along Western Avenue where many car dealerships have closed down, to lease private property to
community organizations for beautification and gardening.
3.	 Support local organizations that:
•	 Implement programs that encourage outdoor activities, such as walking and using the nearby parks.
•	 Provide educational support to families, especially to seniors related to healthy eating and exercising, and eco-friendly practices like water
conservation, repairing and reusing equipment, and energy reduction.
4.	 Work with hometown and civic organizations and businesses to:
•	 Increase awareness and knowledge of green options for energy conservation practices, including reducing Styrofoam, using energy efficient
appliances, and repairing instead of replacing broken items.
•	 Promote vegetarianism and the myriad of restaurants along Devon Avenue that specialize in vegetarian dishes.
5.	 Appeal to traditional values regarding conservation and living “naturally” and help develop parallel practices that can be undertaken in Chicago.
Offer inter-generational programming between seniors and youth, where traditional cultural knowledge is exchanged with fresh perspectives on
contemporary needs and the environment.
COMMUNITY CONCERNS SPRINGBOARDS FOR CLIMATE ACTION
ec ommendations:R
16 Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report
Study participants engage in a variety of environmentally-friendly
practices. Participants often linked environmentally-friendly habits to broader
cultural and geographical contexts, including their experiences living in a more
“natural” way and adapting to resource scarcity in India. Additionally, many
study participants are motivated by the cost savings certain practices confer.
However, other participants expressed reluctance to engage in certain practices,
such as hanging clothes out to dry or raising chickens, that might affect the
ways they are perceived by their neighbors. Finally, the concentration of
resources along Devon lends itself to certain environmentally-friendly practices,
such as walking, eating vegetarian food, and buying locally, that are particularly
popular among the South Asian community.
Interviewees drew a strong relationship between environmentally-friendly
practices and lifestyles in South Asia. They emphasized:
•	 vegetarianism,
•	 water conservation,
•	 cooking methods (pressure cooker, solar cooker, etc), and
•	 repairing, reusing, or repurposing equipment.
Vegetarianism is hallmark of the Indian diet, and Devon is home to many
restaurants that feature meat-free cuisine. This diet is free of the carbon
footprint associated with the livestock industry, and is among West Ridge’s most
popular environmentally-friendly practices. Our study participants noted that
local concerns surrounding pollution, scarcity, and water contamination in India
led many of them to adopt environmentally-friendly practices that they would
like to continue in Chicago.
Among our study participants, resource access and distribution was often
discussed as a political issue and not necessarily an environmental one.
For example, the poor in India frequently lack access to clean water but the
wealthy do not, leading many of our study participants to identify resource
scarcity as a result of inequality or poverty. In the United States, this translates
into consumption practices that tend to reflect class position. This may help
to explain why several interviewees said that they would hesitate to do certain
practices, such as hang clothing out to dry or use second-hand items, because
of associated stigma.
environmentally-
friendly
PRACTICES, VALUES, AND TRADITIONS
One woman described how she could use a solar
	 cooker to prepare large meals for her family,
	 and to heat water for baths. Back in India this
was an essential technology for her, allowing her
to turn her roof into a functional stove on hot days.
It also helped her to conserve energy and time. Because
of differences in temperature and space, she has not
continued this practice in Chicago.
VEGETARIAN RESTAURANTS ALONG DEVON AVE.
Vegetarian Restaurant
Vegetarian-Friendly Restaurant
Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report 17
ENVIRONMENTALLY-FRIENDLY PRACTICES,
VALUES, AND TRADITIONS
In major Indian cities like Deli there are countless scrap dealers where you can
sell household items like plastic and glass. Without the same incentive system
here, this gentleman has felt little motivation to go out of his way to recycle.
Other community members shared similar stories. A woman from Pakistan
shared that she used to store her bottles and newspapers separately in order to
sell them to a scrap dealer. Several community members suggested that scrap
dealers who purchase recyclable materials should be encouraged, as they are
in India and Pakistan. They agreed this would be a strong motivating factor for
South Asian immigrants to recycle, as recycling confers economic benefits in
their homelands.
Participants drew a strong connection between energy conservation and
frugality, lamenting U.S. consumption practices that make wastefulness
normative and resource conservation difficult and expensive. For example,
several participants remarked that it is often easier to replace broken equipment
than to have it repaired. While many of our interviewees said that they do not
have enough information about the cost savings related to energy efficient
practices, others said that they planned to take advantage of government
rebates and tax credits toward the purchase of energy efficient appliances in
their homes.
Our research revealed the following community patterns, in relationship to the
practices listed in the box:
1.	 The most popular practices combine several advantages: they are cost-
effective, convenient to do, and widely socially acceptable among the South
Asian community. These include: walking as transit, buying local, using
curtains/drapes, and using energy-efficient light bulbs.
2.	 Other practices that rank high among our West Ridge study participants are
linked to conservation habits that deal with resource scarcity in Asia, such
as water conservation and turning off appliances.
3.	 Using energy-efficient appliances and retrofitting homes appear near the
middle of the list, indicating that the initial capital investment required for
these practices may be a barrier to some. Also, this positioning may reflect
a need for greater awareness regarding the economic benefits of energy-
saving devices, as many of our participants stated in interviews.
4.	 The least popular practices are the most difficult and expensive to
undertake: green roofs, building green, and using renewable energy.
		 		 An elderly community
				 member said that he used
				 to recycle regularly while
				 living in India. When he did
				 so, he was rewarded with
			 payments from nearby garbage
		 collectors and recyclers. Since moving
		 to the United States, he has not discovered
any recycling programs that compare to India’s system.
One study participant told us that she believes that
people in the U.S. have a “throw away” mentality that
exacerbates waste production. An elderly man agreed and,
pointing to his watch, said that it is easier to buy things
new in the United States than it is to have them repaired.
18 Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report
ENVIRONMENTALLY-FRIENDLY PRACTICES,
VALUES, AND TRADITIONS
ENVIRONMENTALLY-FRIENDLY
PRACTICES IN WEST RIDGE’S SOUTH
ASIAN COMMUNITY
1.	 Using Curtains/Drapes to Control Temperature
2.	 Turning Off Lights, Appliance, TV
3.	 Using Energy Efficient Light Bulbs
4.	 Opening Windows
5.	 Walking as Transit
6.	 Buying Local
7.	 Outdoor Relaxation/Recreation
8.	 Conserving Water
9.	 Riding Public Transportation
10.	 Recycling
11.	 Repairing Instead of Replacing
12.	 Using Manual Instead of Power Tools
13.	 Exchanging or Sharing Used Items with Family/Friends/Neighbors
14.	 Using Energy Efficient Appliance, Devices
15.	 Car Pooling
16.	 Bringing Your Own Shopping Bag
17.	 Buying Organic
18.	 Living Close to Open/Natural Space
19.	 Hanging Clothes to Dry
20.	 Reusing/Re-purposing
21.	 Beautifying the Community
22.	 Gardening: community, school, home
23.	 Biking as Transit
24.	 Retrofitting Homes/Buildings
25.	 Capturing or Diverting Rain Water
26.	 Using Renewable Energy
27.	 Green Roofs
28.	 Preserving Historic Buildings/Places
29.	 Raising Chickens
30.	 Restoring Native Habitats
31.	 Building Green
32.	 Other (Vegetarian )
33.	 Driving and maintaining a speed of 55 mph
LEAST				MOST
Environmentally-friendly practices are listed below in order from most to least reported by
residents and representatives of businesses, schools, and community organizations. Many
reflect inherent community values that may be building blocks for further involving residents
in CCAP implementation.
BARRIERS TO ENVIRONMENTALLY-FRIENDLY PRACTICES
Our research revealed a number of barriers that study participants face in
attempting to engage environmentally-friendly practices. These include:
•	 Financial constraints, particularly for practices with up-front costs;
•	 Cultural norms that make certain practices, such as hanging clothes out
to dry or bicycling, unappealing or difficult. Some study participants said
they did not think these practices would become popular with middle-class
South Asians even if they were made more convenient.
•	 Inconvenience, especially associated with recycling;
•	 Preoccupations with concerns that are more apparent or immediate; and
•	 Lack of information related to environmentally-friendly practices, especially
in languages other than English.
Rec ommendations:
1.	 Create an educational campaign that validates traditional
practices that can be challenging to maintain in an urban
environment, such as water conservation, frugality, reusing
and repurposing, and spending time outdoors.
2.	 Encourage the greening of the Devon Corridor, building
upon the area’s tradition of eco-friendly food preparation.
Highlight the potential environmental benefits of a vegetarian
diet, finding public ways to explain its ecological benefits,
and bolstering the efforts of local vegetarian restaurants.
ENVIRONMENTALLY-FRIENDLY
PRACTICES, VALUES, AND
TRADITIONS
Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report 19
South Asians in West Ridge have access to a variety of sources of
information. Many of these sources do not focus on climate change per se, but
offer news and information related to the environment. Still, many of our study
participants felt like they were lacking information on climate change and the
environment and, in particular, about the economic benefits of climate action
programs.
There are a number of newspapers––such as the India Times and Indian
Tribune––that are geared toward the South Asian community, free of cost, and
widely available on Devon. Most of these are published in English to appeal
to a wider readership among South Asia’s diverse language speakers, though
some are also published in Hindi and Urdu. Videos and movies that are sold
in ubiquitous video and bookstores along Devon are also popular sources of
entertainment and communication among elderly members of the South Asian
community.
Service organizations, such as IAC and Metropolitan Family Health Services,
as well as cultural organizations and religious institutions are also places
where information is disseminated. While much of this information is centered
around financial and immigration assistance, the cost-savings benefits of
environmentally-friendly practices could be integrated into center programs.
Many South Asians rely on their informal social networks, including family
members and friends, for communication about local events and transnational
community concerns. Devon Avenue itself is also a rich source of information,
as South Asians socialize with each other here on benches and in restaurants
and stores, and browse notices in retail shops along Devon.
communication
 AND DISSEMINATION
1.	 Take advantage of the local organizations and businesses
along the Devon corridor to disseminate information
throughout the South Asian community, including suburban
residents who shop on Devon.
2.	 Provide information related to climate change and climate
action programs that is printed in Hindi and Urdu and that
is easy to read quickly or scan––such as bulleted text. Create
attractive posters that can be displayed in shop windows.
3.	 Engage local organizations in a conversation on the
community’s stake in addressing climate change. Identify ways
that the organizations can communicate and engage residents
around climate action, emphasizing the potential cost-savings
associated with environmentally-friendly practices.
COMMUNICATION AND
DISSEMINATION
Rec ommendations:
20 Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report
FOR COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT
MODEL ONE: LINKING FORMAL AND INFORMAL RESOURCES
Devon’s business community is linked both by common interests and by social
and kinship networks. There are established organizations in place, such as
the West Ridge Chamber of Commerce, that work to advance the interests of
businesses along Devon; there are also more informal resources, such as family
loans, that business owners tap into to improve their businesses. Together,
formal and informal networking have created a well-established system of
communication and resource distribution in the Devon business community.
These resources and networks could be mobilized to reduce the carbon
footprint of the businesses on the corridor.
MODEL TWO: INDIA IN CHICAGO
The Devon corridor is a hub for Indian and South Asian heritage practices,
as seen through local festivals, events, clothing, and cuisine. These practices
are potentially powerful allies of climate change action. As the South Asian
community engages in heritage celebrations, there is tremendous potential
to promote environmentally-friendly practices like vegetarianism, walking as
transit, and eating locally. For many of our interviewees, these practices were
already a source of great pride.
MODEL THREE: ECONOMIC EDUCATION
Most of the institutions that serve immigrants, seniors, and low income residents
in West Ridge offer information and resources related to financial assistance to
large numbers of South Asians. Many of our study participants who lamented
a lack of information in the community surrounding the cost-benefits of energy
conservation also noted that integrating climate change information into these
institutions’ programs is entirely consistent with their missions. The outreach of
these institutions could be utilized to educate community members about the
economic benefits of environmentally-friendly practices.
creative models
1.	 Promote the CCAP by stressing the connection between
climate action and community and individual well-being.
Use this connection to develop the “India in Chicago” model,
creating a heritage corridor that emphasizes a holistic view of
the natural environment and a healthy community.
2.	 Foster linkages within West Ridge’s business community
to help business owners share information and implement
collective projects, such as to beautify and “green” the spaces
in front of their businesses along major commercial corridors.
3.	 Mobilize the resources and networks of West Ridge’s business
community to reduce the carbon footprint of the businesses
along the Devon corridor, to help businesses stop using
environmentally-toxic materials such as styrofoam.
CREATIVE MODELS FOR
COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT
Rec ommendations:
21 Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report
conclusion
With its thriving business district, the West Ridge neighborhood is a cultural and
commercial hub of metropolitan Chicago’s South Asian community. Though
socio-economically and ethnically diverse, West Ridge business owners, service
providers, and residents broadly agree that climate action strategies could
enhance the attractiveness, livability, and financial vitality of their community. By
linking their efforts to climate action and the CCAP, West Ridge organizations
can address shared concerns and core values—like beautification, health, and
safety—as they mobilize West Ridge’s human and cultural resources around
climate action projects.
22 Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report
Businesses
1.	 Daata Darbar
2.	 Money Dart
3.	 National Republic Bank
4.	 Punjabi Dhabha
5.	 Raja Vegetarian Fast Food
6.	 Sahil Boutique
7.	 Salvation Army Store
8.	 Udupi Palace
9.	 Uru Swati
10.	 Viceroy of India
Community Organizations
1.	 High Ridge YMCA
2.	 Indo-American Heritage
Center and Indo-American
Heritage Museum
3.	 Metropolitan Asian Family
Services
4.	 Muslim Women’s Resource
Center
5.	 Patel Brothers
Public Parks/Natural Areas
1.	 Indian Boundary Park
2.	 Warren Park
Vegetarian Restaurant
1.	 Arya Bhavan
2.	 Charmin Fine Dining &
Grill
3.	 Copal Kabob & Steak
4.	 Dasaprakash
5.	 Devon Pizza
6.	 Ghareeb Nawaz
7.	 India Garden
8.	 Motimoti Mahi Restaurant
9.	 Mysore Woodlands
10.	 Sabri Nehari
11.	 Sher Punjab Indian
Restaurant
12.	 Tahoora LLC
13.	 Usmania Fine Dining
Albion Ave
NWESTERNAVE
NCALIFORNIAAVE
W ARTHUR AVE
W LUNT AVE
W GRANVILLE AVE
NROCKWELLST
NWASHTENAWAVE
NCAMPBELLAVE
W ROSEMONT AVE
NARTESIANAVE
W JARVIS AVE
W FARGO AVE
NFAIRFIELDAVE
NMAPLEWOODAVE
NMOZARTST
W BIRCHWOOD AVE
W NORTH SHORE AVE
W SHERWIN AVE
NHOYNEAVE
W MORSE AVE
NVIRGINIAAVE
ESTES AVE
NRAVENSWOODAVE
NWOLCOTTAVE
NFRANCISCOAVE
NOAKLEYAVE
NWINCHESTERAVE
NCLAREMONTAVE
NSACRAMENTOAVE
DEVON
PRATT
TOUHY
PETERSON
KEDZIE
50th Ward
Bernard L. Stone
40th Ward
Patrick J O'Conner
49th Ward
Joe Moore
5
4
3
2
1
2
1
9 8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
10
4
2
9
8
7 6
5
3
1
13
1211
10
5
4
3
2
1
2
1
9 8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
10
4
2
9
8
7 6
5
3
1
13
1211
10
5
4
3
2
1
2
1
9 8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
10
9th Ward
aret Laurino Legend
Community Organization
Public Parks/Natural Are
Businesses
Vegetarian Restaurant
Chicago Park District
community asset map
Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report 23
CHICAGO
138TH
55TH
119TH
47TH
103RD
71ST
87TH
T
WESTERN
63RD
MADISON
YN MAWR
111TH
HALSTED
95TH
PULASKI
NORTH
FULLERTON
DEVON
PERSHING
79TH
NARRAGANSETT
ROOSEVELT
STONYISLAND
CERMAK
127TH
COTTAGEGROVE
ASHLAND
TORRENCE
CENTRAL
31ST
CICERO
HARLEM
KEDZIE
31ST
3
2
1
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
24
33
32
31
30
29
28
27
25
23
26
22
21
20
19
18
17
16
15
14
13
12
11
10
1
3
2
1
1
Legend
Businesses
Community Organization
Schools/Universities
Government Agecy
West Ridge
Businesses
1.	 Air India
2.	 Etihad Airlines
3.	 Globetrotting Engineering
Community Organizations
1.	 American Indian Center
2.	 Arab American Action
Network
3.	 Balzekas Museum of
Lithuanian Culture
4.	 Bronzeville Children’s
Museum
5.	 Bronzeville/Black
Chicagoan Historical
6.	 Cambodian American
Heritage Museum and
Killing Fields Memorial
7.	 Casa Aztlán
8.	 Casa Michoacán
9.	 Changing Worlds
10.	 Chicago History Museaum
11.	 Children’s Memorial
Hospital
12.	 Chinese American
Museum of Chicago
13.	 Chinese Mutual Aid
Associon
14.	 DANK Haus German
American Cultural Center
15.	 Ethiopian Community
Association
16.	 Filipino American
Historical Society of
Chicago
17.	 Greater Chicago
18.	 Institute of Puerto Rican
Arts & Culture
19.	 Irish American Heritage
Center
20.	 Jane Addams Hull-House
Museum
21.	 Jesse White Tumbling Team
22.	 Korean American Resource
and Cultural Center
23.	 Latvian Folk Art Museum
24.	 Peggy Notebaert Nature
Museum
25.	 Polish Museum of America
26.	 Project on Civic Reflection
27.	 Pullman State Historic Site
28.	 Serbian Cultural and Arts
Center St. Sava
29.	 Swahili Institute of Chicago
30.	 Swedish American
Museum
31.	 The Field Museum
32.	 Ukrainian Institute of
Modern Art
33.	 Ukrainian National
Museum
Government Agencies
1.	 Toni Preckwinkle-Cook
County Board President
Schools/Universities
1.	 Center for International
Studies (University of
Chicago)
2.	 North Park University
3.	 Student Activities & Greek
Affair
ASSETS OUTSIDE OF THIS
MAP
Businesses
1.	 Asian American Hotel
Owners Association
2.	 Big Cinemas Golf Glen 5
3.	 Desi Junction Radio
Community Organizations
1.	 Bengali Association of
Greater Chicago
2.	 Chicago Zoological
Society--Brookfield
3.	 Gujarati Samaj Chicago
4.	 Illinois Saint Andrews
Society
5.	 Italian Cultural Center at
Casa Italia
6.	 Maharashtra Mandal
Restaurant
7.	 Mitchell Museum of the
American Indian
8.	 Punjabi Cultural Society
9.	 Science of Spirituality
10.	 Shree Jalaram Mandir
Other Non-profit
Organization
1.	 Federation of Indian
Associations
2.	 Sardar Patel Foundation
regional asset map
24 Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report
PARTICIPATING ORGANIZATIONS
Our research with Indo-American Heritage Museum involved leaders and residents affiliated with
over 30 organizations, which represent a diversity of geographic areas, sectors, and issues.
These include:
Indo-American Heritage Museum
Indo-American Center
West Ridge YMCA
Punjabi Cultural Society
Gujarati Samaj Chicago
Metropolitan Family Health Services
Asian Family Services
Devon Bank
Uncommon Ground Restaurant
Indian Garden
Hansa Chaharia
BIBLIOGRAPHY
* All image rights reserved. Visit fieldmuseum.org/explore/department/ecco for more information.
OUR TEAM
Chicago Fact Finder: Your Census Information Resource for Chicagoland Communities. Area 2: West Ridge.
	 Institute for Latino Studies, University of Notre Dame, 2005. Web. June 2010.
Holi, Melvin G., and Peter D’Alroy Jones. Ethnic Chicago: A Multicultural Portrait. Grand Rapids: Wm. B. Eerdmans
	 Publishing Co, 1994.
Indo-American Center. Images of America: Asian Indians of Chicago. Arcadia Publishers, 2002.
Kalayil et al. Developing Devon. Self-published manuscript.
University of Illinois at Chicago. The West Ridge Community Survey. Self-publishedmanuscript.
PRINCIPAL INVESTIGATORS:
Dr. Jennifer Hirsch, Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo), The Field Museum
Commissioner Suzanne Malec-McKenna, City of Chicago Department of Environment
PROJECT MANAGER:
Dr. Rosa Cabrera, Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo), The Field Museum
PROJECT TEAM:
Mannan Bandukwala, Indo-American Heritage Museum 
Nafisa Bandukwala, Indo-American Heritage Museum
Dr. Ruth Gomberg-Muñoz, Chicago Cultural Alliance
Ryan Lugalia-Hollon, Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo), The Field Museum
Lisa See Kim, Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo), The Field Museum
Modhurima Mukherjee, Indo-American Heritage Museum
Rebeccah Sanders, Chicago Cultural Alliance
Dorothie Shah, Indo-American Heritage Museum
Mimosa Shah, Chicago Cultural Alliance
Renuka Sharma, Indo-American Center
Sarah Sommers, Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo), The Field Museum
INTERNS:
Izabela Grobelna, Alyssa Pfluger, Hannah Porst, Ylanda Wilhite, Juliana Wilhoit
DOE West Ridge Full Report_1

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

CAPABILITY STATEMENT OF META ARCH 2016
CAPABILITY STATEMENT OF META ARCH 2016CAPABILITY STATEMENT OF META ARCH 2016
CAPABILITY STATEMENT OF META ARCH 2016Gunjan Mangtani
 
Mood classification of songs based on lyrics
Mood classification of songs based on lyricsMood classification of songs based on lyrics
Mood classification of songs based on lyricsFrancesco Cucari
 
DOE Polish Community Full Report_0
DOE Polish Community Full Report_0DOE Polish Community Full Report_0
DOE Polish Community Full Report_0Izabela Grobelna
 
Machine Learning techniques for the Task Planning of the Ambulance Rescue Team
Machine Learning techniques for the Task Planning of the Ambulance Rescue TeamMachine Learning techniques for the Task Planning of the Ambulance Rescue Team
Machine Learning techniques for the Task Planning of the Ambulance Rescue TeamFrancesco Cucari
 
We're Going Global - With or without you! by Melissa Powell, Founder & CEO, ...
We're Going Global - With or without you!  by Melissa Powell, Founder & CEO, ...We're Going Global - With or without you!  by Melissa Powell, Founder & CEO, ...
We're Going Global - With or without you! by Melissa Powell, Founder & CEO, ...Melissa Powell
 
Art Everywhere: progetto per workshop Google. Sviluppo di sistemi di pattern ...
Art Everywhere: progetto per workshop Google. Sviluppo di sistemi di pattern ...Art Everywhere: progetto per workshop Google. Sviluppo di sistemi di pattern ...
Art Everywhere: progetto per workshop Google. Sviluppo di sistemi di pattern ...Francesco Cucari
 
Evolution of the Boathouse Summer 2016 Annual Display
Evolution of the Boathouse Summer 2016 Annual DisplayEvolution of the Boathouse Summer 2016 Annual Display
Evolution of the Boathouse Summer 2016 Annual DisplayPatrick Greenwald
 
How to succeed in the AU REU program taneja
How to succeed in the AU REU program   tanejaHow to succeed in the AU REU program   taneja
How to succeed in the AU REU program tanejaShubbhi Taneja
 
Educating the STEM leaders of Tomorrow
Educating the STEM leaders of TomorrowEducating the STEM leaders of Tomorrow
Educating the STEM leaders of TomorrowShubbhi Taneja
 
Software Design Patterns and Quality Assurance
Software Design Patterns and Quality AssuranceSoftware Design Patterns and Quality Assurance
Software Design Patterns and Quality AssuranceShubbhi Taneja
 
Office_365_brochure_121216_TPAC_fields
Office_365_brochure_121216_TPAC_fieldsOffice_365_brochure_121216_TPAC_fields
Office_365_brochure_121216_TPAC_fieldsMartin G. Lee
 
Prueba de evaluación 2017
Prueba de evaluación 2017Prueba de evaluación 2017
Prueba de evaluación 2017iesboliches2
 

Viewers also liked (15)

SWS-Full-Report
SWS-Full-ReportSWS-Full-Report
SWS-Full-Report
 
DOE Austin Full Report
DOE Austin Full ReportDOE Austin Full Report
DOE Austin Full Report
 
CAPABILITY STATEMENT OF META ARCH 2016
CAPABILITY STATEMENT OF META ARCH 2016CAPABILITY STATEMENT OF META ARCH 2016
CAPABILITY STATEMENT OF META ARCH 2016
 
Mood classification of songs based on lyrics
Mood classification of songs based on lyricsMood classification of songs based on lyrics
Mood classification of songs based on lyrics
 
DOE Polish Community Full Report_0
DOE Polish Community Full Report_0DOE Polish Community Full Report_0
DOE Polish Community Full Report_0
 
DOE Pilsen At A Glance_0
DOE Pilsen At A Glance_0DOE Pilsen At A Glance_0
DOE Pilsen At A Glance_0
 
Machine Learning techniques for the Task Planning of the Ambulance Rescue Team
Machine Learning techniques for the Task Planning of the Ambulance Rescue TeamMachine Learning techniques for the Task Planning of the Ambulance Rescue Team
Machine Learning techniques for the Task Planning of the Ambulance Rescue Team
 
We're Going Global - With or without you! by Melissa Powell, Founder & CEO, ...
We're Going Global - With or without you!  by Melissa Powell, Founder & CEO, ...We're Going Global - With or without you!  by Melissa Powell, Founder & CEO, ...
We're Going Global - With or without you! by Melissa Powell, Founder & CEO, ...
 
Art Everywhere: progetto per workshop Google. Sviluppo di sistemi di pattern ...
Art Everywhere: progetto per workshop Google. Sviluppo di sistemi di pattern ...Art Everywhere: progetto per workshop Google. Sviluppo di sistemi di pattern ...
Art Everywhere: progetto per workshop Google. Sviluppo di sistemi di pattern ...
 
Evolution of the Boathouse Summer 2016 Annual Display
Evolution of the Boathouse Summer 2016 Annual DisplayEvolution of the Boathouse Summer 2016 Annual Display
Evolution of the Boathouse Summer 2016 Annual Display
 
How to succeed in the AU REU program taneja
How to succeed in the AU REU program   tanejaHow to succeed in the AU REU program   taneja
How to succeed in the AU REU program taneja
 
Educating the STEM leaders of Tomorrow
Educating the STEM leaders of TomorrowEducating the STEM leaders of Tomorrow
Educating the STEM leaders of Tomorrow
 
Software Design Patterns and Quality Assurance
Software Design Patterns and Quality AssuranceSoftware Design Patterns and Quality Assurance
Software Design Patterns and Quality Assurance
 
Office_365_brochure_121216_TPAC_fields
Office_365_brochure_121216_TPAC_fieldsOffice_365_brochure_121216_TPAC_fields
Office_365_brochure_121216_TPAC_fields
 
Prueba de evaluación 2017
Prueba de evaluación 2017Prueba de evaluación 2017
Prueba de evaluación 2017
 

Similar to DOE West Ridge Full Report_1

Outreach Strategies to Engage Citizen Scientists: Insights from the Biodivers...
Outreach Strategies to Engage Citizen Scientists: Insights from the Biodivers...Outreach Strategies to Engage Citizen Scientists: Insights from the Biodivers...
Outreach Strategies to Engage Citizen Scientists: Insights from the Biodivers...costantinog
 
Pratt SILS Cultural Heritage: Description and Access Spring 2011
Pratt SILS Cultural Heritage: Description and Access Spring 2011Pratt SILS Cultural Heritage: Description and Access Spring 2011
Pratt SILS Cultural Heritage: Description and Access Spring 2011PrattSILS
 
Into the Night - Citizen Science Training day - introduction to citizen science
Into the Night - Citizen Science Training day - introduction to citizen scienceInto the Night - Citizen Science Training day - introduction to citizen science
Into the Night - Citizen Science Training day - introduction to citizen scienceMuki Haklay
 
UAKN_AR15-16_DIGITAL (1)
UAKN_AR15-16_DIGITAL (1)UAKN_AR15-16_DIGITAL (1)
UAKN_AR15-16_DIGITAL (1)Jennifer Rankin
 
Ethnographic Research
Ethnographic ResearchEthnographic Research
Ethnographic ResearchAmenahGondal1
 
Sonia Yaco CV June 2016
Sonia Yaco CV June 2016Sonia Yaco CV June 2016
Sonia Yaco CV June 2016Sonia Yaco
 
LEGACY PROJECT: Countering Heteronormativity through Advocacy of Gay, Lesbia...
 LEGACY PROJECT: Countering Heteronormativity through Advocacy of Gay, Lesbia... LEGACY PROJECT: Countering Heteronormativity through Advocacy of Gay, Lesbia...
LEGACY PROJECT: Countering Heteronormativity through Advocacy of Gay, Lesbia...Gerri Spinella
 
Call and Response- Arts Administration Praxis through an Autoethnographic Acc...
Call and Response- Arts Administration Praxis through an Autoethnographic Acc...Call and Response- Arts Administration Praxis through an Autoethnographic Acc...
Call and Response- Arts Administration Praxis through an Autoethnographic Acc...Anna Festa
 
research matrix-pagbasa at pagsuri.docx
research matrix-pagbasa at pagsuri.docxresearch matrix-pagbasa at pagsuri.docx
research matrix-pagbasa at pagsuri.docxalenmarie10
 
E:\Lirg Agm Presentations July 2010\P3 Rankin
E:\Lirg Agm Presentations July 2010\P3 RankinE:\Lirg Agm Presentations July 2010\P3 Rankin
E:\Lirg Agm Presentations July 2010\P3 Rankinlirg
 
Africashowcaseprice
AfricashowcasepriceAfricashowcaseprice
AfricashowcasepriceRenee Price
 
SOC-481Textbook Case Study Critical ReviewsBased o.docx
SOC-481Textbook Case Study Critical ReviewsBased o.docxSOC-481Textbook Case Study Critical ReviewsBased o.docx
SOC-481Textbook Case Study Critical ReviewsBased o.docxpbilly1
 

Similar to DOE West Ridge Full Report_1 (20)

Outreach Strategies to Engage Citizen Scientists: Insights from the Biodivers...
Outreach Strategies to Engage Citizen Scientists: Insights from the Biodivers...Outreach Strategies to Engage Citizen Scientists: Insights from the Biodivers...
Outreach Strategies to Engage Citizen Scientists: Insights from the Biodivers...
 
OSS#01_Jan8
OSS#01_Jan8OSS#01_Jan8
OSS#01_Jan8
 
Pratt SILS Cultural Heritage: Description and Access Spring 2011
Pratt SILS Cultural Heritage: Description and Access Spring 2011Pratt SILS Cultural Heritage: Description and Access Spring 2011
Pratt SILS Cultural Heritage: Description and Access Spring 2011
 
Into the Night - Citizen Science Training day - introduction to citizen science
Into the Night - Citizen Science Training day - introduction to citizen scienceInto the Night - Citizen Science Training day - introduction to citizen science
Into the Night - Citizen Science Training day - introduction to citizen science
 
UAKN_AR15-16_DIGITAL (1)
UAKN_AR15-16_DIGITAL (1)UAKN_AR15-16_DIGITAL (1)
UAKN_AR15-16_DIGITAL (1)
 
HirschJennifer-ChicagoClimateActionPlan
HirschJennifer-ChicagoClimateActionPlanHirschJennifer-ChicagoClimateActionPlan
HirschJennifer-ChicagoClimateActionPlan
 
Ethnographic Research
Ethnographic ResearchEthnographic Research
Ethnographic Research
 
FINAL PDF Rural Heritage Initiative
FINAL PDF Rural Heritage InitiativeFINAL PDF Rural Heritage Initiative
FINAL PDF Rural Heritage Initiative
 
Sonia Yaco CV June 2016
Sonia Yaco CV June 2016Sonia Yaco CV June 2016
Sonia Yaco CV June 2016
 
Miles
MilesMiles
Miles
 
Orion Open Science
Orion Open ScienceOrion Open Science
Orion Open Science
 
LEGACY PROJECT: Countering Heteronormativity through Advocacy of Gay, Lesbia...
 LEGACY PROJECT: Countering Heteronormativity through Advocacy of Gay, Lesbia... LEGACY PROJECT: Countering Heteronormativity through Advocacy of Gay, Lesbia...
LEGACY PROJECT: Countering Heteronormativity through Advocacy of Gay, Lesbia...
 
Call and Response- Arts Administration Praxis through an Autoethnographic Acc...
Call and Response- Arts Administration Praxis through an Autoethnographic Acc...Call and Response- Arts Administration Praxis through an Autoethnographic Acc...
Call and Response- Arts Administration Praxis through an Autoethnographic Acc...
 
research matrix-pagbasa at pagsuri.docx
research matrix-pagbasa at pagsuri.docxresearch matrix-pagbasa at pagsuri.docx
research matrix-pagbasa at pagsuri.docx
 
E:\Lirg Agm Presentations July 2010\P3 Rankin
E:\Lirg Agm Presentations July 2010\P3 RankinE:\Lirg Agm Presentations July 2010\P3 Rankin
E:\Lirg Agm Presentations July 2010\P3 Rankin
 
Connected communities capital town meeting collated presentations
Connected communities capital town meeting collated presentationsConnected communities capital town meeting collated presentations
Connected communities capital town meeting collated presentations
 
Africashowcaseprice
AfricashowcasepriceAfricashowcaseprice
Africashowcaseprice
 
SOC-481Textbook Case Study Critical ReviewsBased o.docx
SOC-481Textbook Case Study Critical ReviewsBased o.docxSOC-481Textbook Case Study Critical ReviewsBased o.docx
SOC-481Textbook Case Study Critical ReviewsBased o.docx
 
DPI-22-slides.pptx
DPI-22-slides.pptxDPI-22-slides.pptx
DPI-22-slides.pptx
 
Summary Cultural Stages
Summary Cultural StagesSummary Cultural Stages
Summary Cultural Stages
 

DOE West Ridge Full Report_1

  • 1. Research Report Submitted by: Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo), a Division of Science at The Field Museum To: The City of Chicago Department of Environment COMMUNITY #5: WEST RIDGE’S SOUTH ASIAN COMMUNITY Engaging Chicago’s Diverse Communities in the Chicago Climate Action Plan City of Chicago Richard M. Daley, Mayor Department of Environment
  • 2. tableofcontents Sponsored by 1 PROJECT OVERVIEW 4 COMMUNITY OVERVIEW 6 STAKEHOLDERS, PARTNERSHIPS, AND RELATIONSHIP-BUILDING 8 AWARENESS OF CLIMATE CHANGE AND INTEREST IN ADDRESSING IT 11 COMMUNITY CONCERNS: SPRINGBOARDS FOR CLIMATE ACTION 16 ENVIRONMENTALLY-FRIENDLY PRACTICES, VALUES, AND TRADITIONS 19 COMMUNICATION AND DISSEMINATION 20 CREATIVE MODELS FOR COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 21 CONCLUSION 22 COMMUNITY ASSET MAP 23 REGIONAL ASSET MAP 24 OUR TEAM BIBLIOGRAPHY LIST OF PARTICIPATING ORGANIZATIONS This research was commissioned by the City of Chicago Department of Environment. Research was conducted by: Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo), a Division of Science at The Field Museum with our partners: City of Chicago Department of Environment Chicago Cultural Alliance Indo-American Center Indo-American Heritage Museum May 2011 Visit our Web site to download the Community and Regional Asset Maps, and reports about other communities: http://fieldmuseum.org/climateaction
  • 3. Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report 1 project overview Engaging Chicago Communities in the Chicago Climate Action Plan—Community #5: The South Asian Community of West Ridge is the fifth community study commissioned by the City of Chicago Department of Environment (DOE) to identify strategies for effectively engaging diverse communities throughout the city in the implementation of the Chicago Climate Action Plan (CCAP). This report presents the results from one site of a two- sited mini study that also included the Mexican community of Chicago’s Pilsen neighborhood. Our first two studies had a geographic focus, one on South Chicago––a working class, racially diverse area on Chicago’s far South Side––and the other on North Kenwood-Oakland/Bronzeville, an economically diverse, African- American area of the city situated just three miles south of Chicago’s downtown. The third study was the first to focus on an ethnic group––Chicago’s Polish community––and was concentrated in three Chicago regions with large Polish populations. The West Ridge and Pilsen studies are the first to be delineated by both neighborhood geography and ethnicity, and they are also the first to incorporate community-led storytelling as a data gathering technique. All of our studies are participatory action research projects that have been conducted by a team including The Field Museum anthropologists, staff from the Chicago Department of Environment, and leaders of community-based organizations in the research communities. In this study, our research was designed and conducted collaboratively, in English, Urdu and Hindi, by a team including anthropologists from The Field Museum’s division of Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo), the Chicago Cultural Alliance (CCA), and leaders from the Indo-American Heritage Museum (IAHM), a cultural organization in West Ridge. While the anthropologist from CCA collected qualitative data through traditional ethnographic methods, the anthropologists from The Field Museum trained leaders from IAHM in story collecting techniques and worked with them to facilitate focus groups throughout the study. Located just off of Devon Avenue where the Indian-Pakistani business district defines the character of the area, the Indo-American Heritage Museum is a relatively new organization that was formed by board members of the Indo- American Center (IAC), a center that serves hundreds of South Asian clients daily through classes in ESL, civics, computers, immigration assistance, as well as senior and youth programs. The Indo-American Heritage Museum offers cultural programs that promote understanding of the diversity, history, and culture of Indian Americans in the Chicago area. IAHM is currently located at the Indo-American Center on California and Devon, where they offer educational programs and display a modest collection that represents life in members’ homelands and their Chicago diaspora. IAHM’s programs include cultural performances, inter-ethnic dialogues, tours of Devon Avenue, and workshops about the Indian American immigration story for educators and the general public. While they expand their space and build their collection, IAHM has launched a “virtual museum” where website visitors can explore Chicago’s Indo-American culture and community members can share personal stories on selected themes. West Ridge RESEARCH AREA
  • 4. 2 Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report This research project combined traditional ethnographic methods, such as interviewing and participant observation, with the innovative technique of community-led story collecting. Through workshops, sharing research tools, and personal mentoring ethnographers at The Field Museum worked closely with staff members at Indo-American Heritage Museum to develop their skills as story collectors. This collaborative approach allowed us to pair complementary methods of gathering data. While the project ethnographer was working to complete a rapid inventory of both the West Ridge and Pilsen neighborhoods, our community partners were busy collecting stories from their clients and peers. Touching base regularly along the way, the ethnographer and local leaders supported one another’s work through the exchange of contacts, leads, ideas, and tools. For the duration of the fieldwork season, both the ethnographer and local partners used a variety of creative tools developed by ECCo to learn about how residents relate to the environment and climate change, such as using objects and photos to prompt discussion. Incorporating the methods of story collecting has enhanced both the research product and the resources and knowledge of our community partners. Story collecting techniques enriched the study by contributing narrative stories to semi-structured interview data gathered by the ethnographer. This has provided a more nuanced and holistic understanding of community dynamics and has broadened the contribution of community members and leaders in the research process. In addition, learning and applying story collecting techniques strengthened the social capital of our community partners, who said that gathering stories has improved their understanding of community concerns and resources. Modhurima Mukherjee of IAHM told us that she has a deeper understanding of the community as a result of her experience collecting stories. Just as importantly, she says, the merchants and residents whom she talked with are now more aware of the resources and events offered by IAHM. Ultimately, the experience of collecting stories, identifying community assets, and strengthening organizing skills will help our community partners to create programs and services which better address community concerns including environmental issues and climate change. Field research for this project lasted four months, from May through August 2010. During this time, The Field Museum researchers and community partners conducted interviews, gathered stories, and held focus groups to better understand research participants’ beliefs and practices related to the environment and climate change. Because these study communities are defined by participants’ ethnic identity as well as their geographic location, we recruited participants who fall into one of three main categories. Our primary focus was South Asian residents of the West Ridge neighborhood. Secondarily, we spoke with a number of Chicago-area South Asians who work, shop, or use services in West Ridge but who reside elsewhere. Thirdly, we spoke with neighbors, workers, and community leaders who live or work in West Ridge, but who are not of South Asian origin. This recruitment strategy recognizes that our target populations do not live in any single urban area, but are socially integrated into Chicago’s multi-cultural metropolitan region. It also allows us to gain perspectives from local residents and leaders that helped to deepen our awareness of neighborhood dynamics. One of our goals in studying ethnic communities is to better understand the ways in which cultural values and traditions in communities of origin might facilitate or hamper participation in climate action strategies in Chicago. Another goal is to understand how ethnic heritage intersects with community activities and creates patterns of interaction that reach from Devon Avenue to Delhi. As a result of having both an ethnic and a geographic focus, this study also highlights the social networks that connect urban immigrants with Chicago communities. The majority of this research was ethnographic, with the goal of gaining an understanding of people’s behaviors and attitudes by studying them in the context of their everyday lives. Like most research, ethnographic research aims to identify patterns and linkages between issues; but it is also based on the notion that people are experts on their own lives and, as such, aims to highlight local knowledge and practices as the building blocks for creating more sustainable communities. PROJECT OVERVIEW
  • 5. In total, we directly engaged approximately 135 people through interviews, focus groups, surveys, and story collecting that included residents, business owners, civil leaders, and leaders of community organizations. Our research included: • 23 semi-structured interviews; • 3 focus groups with a total of 64 participants; • 72 surveys; • Over 50 stories collected; and, • Participant-observation at 9 community events and meetings that involved approximately 250 people. Due to the high concentration of immigrants among the adult population of West Ridge and because of the organizational networks that we used for recruitment, an overwhelming majority of our study participants were first generation immigrants. All were adults and many were clients of the Indo- American Center. The goals of this study were to: 1. Document attitudes and knowledge related to climate change; 2. Identify climate-friendly practices and values; 3. Describe community concerns that link environment to quality of life; 4. Identify key organizations that can act as catalysts for larger scale adoption of climate action strategies; 5. Highlight creative models of engagement that can be adopted for climate action; 6. Determine effective communication strategies for disseminating information. Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report 3 PROJECT OVERVIEW Engaging the Community Our partners at the Indo-American Heritage Museum participated in community meetings, focus groups, and interviews to gather stories from a wide variety of West Ridge residents and business owners. In these pictures, West Ridge residents share stories about themselves, their culture, and their concerns, as well as their aspirations to create a sustainable community.
  • 6. 4 Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report community overview West Ridge on Chicago’s far North Side has a rich tradition as an immigrant community. Historically known for its large Jewish population, West Ridge has become home to many different ethnic groups over the past half century. Nearly half of its current residents are foreign-born, making it one of the city’s most ethnically diverse neighborhoods. As we heard from residents of West Ridge, this diversity is a great asset that attracts customers to the area’s vibrant commercial corridors and enhances its cultural life. Yet, residents also say that ethnic diversity presents challenges; community members with divergent origins, customs, and habits must learn how to work together toward common community goals. The area is home to Devon Avenue, one of the city’s most popular commercial corridors. The Devon corridor, also known as “The International Marketplace,” is lined with ethnic retail shops, grocery stores, and vegetarian restaurants. It is the commercial and symbolic center of Chicagoland’s South Asian population, with a concentration of businesses and organizations that cater to members of Chicago’s Indian, Pakistani, and Bangladeshi communities. The neighborhood also features strong commercial corridors along Touhy and Western Avenues. Along with its ethnic diversity, West Ridge is also very diverse socio- economically. While West Ridge is popularly identified as a relatively prosperous, middle-class neighborhood, residents have a wide range of income and living conditions. Nearly ten percent of West Ridge residents live in households with an annual income under $10,000, while the top ten percent of households earn over $100,000 annually. Within the South Asian community more broadly, there is a bifurcation in regards to socioeconomic status, where more affluent South Asians tend to be longer-term U.S. residents, who often live in Chicago’s suburbs. Conversely, working-class and poor South Asians are more likely to be new immigrants and to live in apartments near the Devon corridor and on the margins of the neighborhood. These socio-economic factors influence what residents are able to do regarding the environment, with wealthier residents having more control over the decisions that shape their home environments. While some low-income West Ridge residents still find ways to invest in eco-friendly practices such as gardening, recycling, and composting, they often live in apartment buildings with strict regulations on these practices. In contrast, residents who own their own homes have greater financial and regulatory freedom to bridge the built and natural environments. WAVES OF SOUTH ASIAN IMMIGRATION TO CHICAGO 1940 1960 1980 2000 pre-1946: no significant immigration of South Asians due to restrictive quotas (called “Asian Exclusions”) and “racially ineligibility” for citizenship 1946-1965: India allotted 100 visas annually; Indian population of Chicago grew to approximately 350 by 1960 1965- mid-1980s: restrictions on Asian immigration lifted; dramatic increase in South Asian immigration, facilitated by family reunification visas and H-1 visas for skilled workers; worked in medicine, infrastructure, and research 1950 1970 1990 2010 mid-1980s-present: rise in low-skilled and unauthorized migration; rapid suburbanization One local business owner told us that she has invested a great deal of time and effort into beautifying her restaurant. She has installed flower boxes and planters in front and hopes that this will motivate neighboring merchants to invest in the appearance of their storefronts as well.
  • 7. Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report 5 COMMUNITY OVERVIEW There is a large senior population of South Asians in West Ridge. As established South Asian professionals send for their elderly parents under family reunification visas, the proportion of newly arrived seniors in the South Asian community is large and growing. Many of the services provided by area civic organizations are geared toward helping these new arrivals adjust to life in the United States, and they offer classes in civics, English, and computers, as well as space where seniors can be part of a social and cultural community. The stories of these elders reveal that age also influences local residents’ ability to initiate or maintain eco-friendly practices. West Ridge also has a large youth population among South Asians, as middle-age residents are likely to have children under the age of eighteen. While constricted due to building and association policies, one man described several ways that he has been able to live a more environmentally-friendly lifestyle. His routine includes drying clothes next to the windows instead of spending money at the laundromat. He also recycles old and unused items instead of throwing them away. One community organizer told us that the mobility of her elderly clients is constrained by a lack of transportation options that link the suburbs and the city. She said that one of her clients, who is 76 years old, broke down and sobbed when he informed her that his son had bought a house in the suburbs. The distance would make it impossible for the man to socialize with his friends near Devon. Rec ommendation: Develop initiatives that help West Ridge elders to build community while engaging in eco-friendly activities. Create and support spaces that can link the ethnic diversity of the West Ridge area to green efforts, such as recycling, walking, gardening, and beautification. COMMUNITY OVERVIEW
  • 8. 6 Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report For many South Asian immigrants the City of Chicago served as a temporary home where they could get settled enough to establish work and support their families. After spending years or decades in the city, a large number of affluent South Asians immigrants have chosen to migrate to surrounding suburbs. This has resulted in dispersed community resources throughout Chicago’s city and suburbs. Social service resources for new immigrants tend to be concentrated near working-class residences in the city, while large temples and heritage centers have followed more affluent South Asians to suburban locations. More affluent South Asians donate time and resources to many of the civic and service organizations that cater to newer waves of immigrants concentrated near Devon. Relatedly, while Indian stores and places of worship are increasingly common in Chicago’s suburbs, Devon Avenue remains a primary commercial hub of South Asian goods and services. In all, the South Asian community of greater Chicago is connected by social and professional networks, an extensive civic sector, and a thriving business district along Devon Avenue. The shops along Devon Avenue are identified as particularly important for Chicago-area South Asians, many of whom regularly travel from the suburbs to Devon to shop for food and clothing, and to get news and entertainment from the various video shops, bookstores, and restaurants. Devon is not just for South Asians, however; ethnic restaurants attract diners from all over Chicago who are looking to enjoy Indian, Bangladeshi, Pakistani, and vegetarian cuisine. This region-wide investment in Devon helps to sustain West Ridge residents, which includes patrons, business owners, and workers. West Ridge is home to much more than just commercial businesses. It is also a hub of civic organizations that service new South Asian and Middle Eastern immigrants through ESL classes, computer classes, job training, assistance with immigration status adjustment, and media and information in Hindi and Urdu, among other languages. Because of the large elderly population in the South Asian community, organizations such as the Indo-American Center and Metropolitan Asian Family Services also provide health care, free lunches, and social events that cater to seniors. The Indo-American Center also has a youth program that takes advantage of local assets, such as the West Ridge YMCA and neighborhood parks, to engage South Asian children in outdoor activities. In addition to these service providers, South Asian residents in West Ridge have cultivated extensive social networks that supply crucial resources for their financial security and emotional well-being. Hometown associations, such as the Punjabi Cultural Society and Gujarati Samaj Chicago, bring together first and second generation South Asians from particular Indian states to participate in cultural events such as dinners, dances, and festivals. Organizations for South Asian students and alumni have formed on the nearby campus of Loyola University and downtown’s University of Illinois at Chicago and provide not only social support, but educational resources as well. Social networks also provide a means for South Asian residents to participate in Devon’s business community, as interest-free or informal business loans are made by established business people to select network members, enabling them to open small businesses and to maintain Devon’s ethnic enclaves. stakeholders, PARTNERSHIPS, AND RELATIONSHIP-BUILDING
  • 9. Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report 7 Religious beliefs and practices among South Asians are as diverse as the South Asian community itself, and West Ridge is home to several centers of worship that serve Chicago’s South Asian population. Though the largest Hindu temples are located in Chicago suburbs, there is a Hare Krishna temple, a Sikh temple, an Indo-Pak Methodist Church, and several mosques located in or around Devon Avenue. Our study participants also noted that, while many South Asians visit temples to celebrate religious holidays, most frequently they worship in private or with family and friends at home. Religious worship is thus also social interaction that bolsters the informal networks that are critical for the well-being of Chicago’s South Asians. STAKEHOLDERS, PARTNERSHIPS, AND RELATIONSHIP-BUILDING Rec ommendation: Work with area organizations including hometown associations, civic organizations, centers of worship and Devon’s business community for developing a West Ridge climate action plan. Encourage leaders in all of these arenas to model eco-friendly living for others in the community, and create networking opportunities that highlight what local green leaders are already doing. STAKEHOLDERS, PARTNERSHIPS, AND RELATIONSHIP-BUILDING
  • 10. 8 Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report Many of our study participants were aware of climate change and expressed an interest in addressing it. We found a broad range of beliefs regarding climate change and the environment, with many participants reminiscing about living “naturally” in India but also concerned about what they consider to be more immediate problems in the United States. Younger study participants routinely expressed a higher degree of awareness and interest in climate action programs than their elderly counterparts, who frequently said that climate change was not among their most pressing concerns. Nevertheless, older study participants were enthusiastic in recounting stories about environmentally-friendly lifestyles and practices in India. When discussing the environment, participants frequently spoke of environmental issues in India, with far less attention to environmental concerns in the Chicago region. Many remembered their childhoods in India and expressed concern about how changing weather patterns are affecting traditional life ways. For example, participants worried that changes such as rising sea levels, waste, and water contamination have already had serious impacts on both the health and economic activities of people who live in South Asia. Older participants often linked climate change to the scarcity of local resources like clean water, rather than to global environmental changes. As one participant observed, “In India [climate change] is a big concern, but here it is less of a concern because it’s so much better here in terms of clean water and the environment.” Another noted that people use rain barrels in India, but since there is no apparent water shortage in Chicago, there is no perception of a need for water conservation here. This story reveals a deeper trend: many South Asians in West Ridge see the threat that Climate Change poses to India, but not to the Chicago area. For these residents, perceptions of resource abundance in Chicago can make conservation efforts seem superfluous. There was broad recognition among our study participants that climate change is caused by human activities. However, participants diverged on the question of who is responsible for taking action to address it. While the majority of younger interviewees asserted that all global residents share in the responsibility to be environmentally responsible, many of our older participants identified industry and government as the major polluters and felt that individual responses to climate change are largely insignificant. awareness OF CLIMATE CHANGE AND interestIN ADDRESSING IT One young staff person at a local community center said that she tried to pilot a program to reduce paper waste, but she encountered obstacles from her organization. Her manager believed that initiating a recycling program would incur extra cost to their organization. Thus, she now separates the paper in her office and takes it to a recycling center across the street. One immigrant from a coastal town in India told us that many people in his home community survive by fishing. He worries about the impact that depleted fish stores will have on his hometown economy and said that his family members in India are growing concerned about rising sea levels and changes in the weather.
  • 11. Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report 9 AWARENESS AND INTEREST WHAT THREE WORDS COME TO MIND WHEN YOU HEAR “CLIMATE CHANGE”? Participants were asked this question during our interviews. In this word cloud, words that were most often mentioned appear larger. This reveals significant patterns: 1. RISING TEMPERATURES: Respondents frequently associated climate change with changes in the composition of the earth, as triggered by warmer temperatures. Concerns about these shifts are represented in the high occurrences of “Global Warming,” “Sea Levels,” and “Glaciers” in participants’ responses. Also prominent were responses like “rising,” “hot,” and “melting.” 2. HUMAN AGENCY: It is clear that many participants believe that humans can have an impact on Climate Change. Words like “Recycling,” “Education,” and “Structural Policy” reflect respondents awareness of the positive actions people can take in the face of climate destabilization. Additionally, participants pointed to a “lack of government support.” 3. FUTURE DANGERS: Respondents frequently drew a link between climate change and the potential dangers it holds for our future. They regularly invoked the following words, “famine,” “starvation,” “children,” “doomsday scenario,” and “animal habitat extinctions.”
  • 12. AWARENESS AND INTEREST 10 Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report RANKING THE CCAP STRATEGIES improved energy15 waste22 reduction transportation efficiency adaptation 14 19 Respondents ranked waste reduction and improved transportation highest, which makes sense for a high-traffic areas with high levels of consumption. Adaptation ranked last, reflecting a poor understanding of the concept and/or the higher cost that participants fear that adaptation strategies would incur. Research participants were asked to rank each of these CCAP strategies according to their level of interest: Rec ommendations: 1. Work with local leaders to make Climate Change feel local among to the South Asian community, promoting its potential impacts on the Chicago area. Take advantage of popular awareness regarding resource scarcity and conservation practices in South Asia, and work with organizations along Devon to promote opportunities for taking climate actions. 2. Identify young community members through the Indo- American Center, YMCA, and other local agencies. Connect them to climate educators and organizers who could help them to see themselves as climate action leaders. AWARENESS OF CLIMATE CHANGE AND INTEREST IN ADDRESSING IT
  • 13. Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report 11 Our research identified a number of important community concerns in the South Asian community of West Ridge that could serve as springboards for community involvement in climate action. The concerns that we highlight in this section include: 1. Immigration 2. Economic development • Small Business Viability • Housing • Jobs 3. Heritage/identity 4. Health 5. Use of public space Immigration was a serious concern of many of our study participants, particularly those who live and work near Devon Avenue. Undocumented status and English-language difficulties were cited as serious barriers to upward mobility and social well-being for many new South Asian immigrants in West Ridge. Immigration is a theme that was mentioned by study participants in relation to all of the following concerns. Our participants see the ability to have successful businesses that provide jobs as key to community stability overall, from creating steady work to alleviating crime and the problem of abandoned buildings. Study participants linked their financial concerns with a variety of more specific preoccupations, such as crowded and abandoned housing, underemployment of new immigrants, as well as economic development along West Ridge’s commercial corridors . These corridors – along Devon, Touhy, and Western Avenues – are all important sources of revenue for the neighborhood. Residents expressed concern about economic decline of small businesses along these corridors, concerned with the impact that the current economic recession is having on the financial health of West Ridge. Several interviewees were also very concerned about disinvestment in the community on the part of local politicians. SMALL BUSINESS VIABILITY In particular, participants are concerned that Devon’s poor appearance, traffic congestion, and lack of parking will drive customers elsewhere, as South Asian stores become more prevalent in the suburbs. Business owners and residents offered many suggestions for beautifying Devon and making it more accessible, including the addition of more parking, trees and green spaces, planters, more attractive street lamps, and “plazas” where shoppers can sit in comfort. Though congestion is already a problem, interviewees also offered ideas for further increasing visitors to Devon. Several suggested capitalizing on the area’s ethnic diversity and creating an “Indian Village” akin to Chicago’s Chinatown or Greektown, with a formal gateway and pedestrian paths. Such a beautification plan would draw “tourists” from outside the neighborhood and emphasize the community concernsSPRINGBOARDS FOR CLIMATE ACTION IMMIGRATION ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
  • 14. South Asian assets of the Devon corridor. Participants would also like to see more diverse offerings among the shops on Devon, citing a lack of variety as a source of unhealthy business competition and high business turnover. HOUSING West Ridge is known for its comfortable homes on tree-lined residential streets, and is sometimes referred to as a “suburb within the city.” Yet, West Ridge residents who live near the Devon corridor often live in crowded apartment complexes, far away from the parks and trees that make the community so attractive. Crowded housing complexes were disdained by several of our study participants, who identified them as hubs of crime and poverty, while others noted that these buildings offer affordable housing for low-income families in the area. Several participants also complained that developers had begun converting neighborhood apartment buildings to condominium units, but abandoned the projects when the housing market contracted in 2008, leaving behind a glut of unfinished and deserted buildings. JOBS Underemployment and low wages for workers along the Devon corridor was a source of concern for many of our study participants. Many new immigrants from South Asia face serious barriers to upward mobility when they arrive in Chicago, including limited English proficiency, low or obsolete job skills, unauthorized status, and advanced age. Many of these new immigrants become engaged in informal labor practices within Devon’s ethnic enclaves, where they earn low wages and have little job security. Even when new immigrants held skilled or semi-skilled jobs in India, these skills are not always easily adaptable to the job market in Chicago. To help with the integration needs of new South Asian immigrants, the Indo-American Center offers literacy classes, computer classes, and job training programs. Moving forward, it will be vital for local businesses and agencies to create green training and employment opportunities, ideally in ways that strengthen local businesses relationship to the environment. The ethnic diversity of West Ridge is considered both an asset and a challenge, depending in part on who is offering their opinion. While the diversity of shops and restaurants is one of the main attractions of Devon’s “International Marketplace,” neighborhood residents are still learning to relate to one another across divergent beliefs and practices. Other participants noted that longer-term demographic change in the community presents a challenge for older or more established West Ridge residents. One interviewee said, “People don’t recognize this neighborhood. It used to be an Irish neighborhood, then Eastern European Jews came, now South Asians, most of the Anglos have moved out. There is some tension about these changes in the neighborhood, and there has been gentrification for the last four to five years.” Several participants expressed concern about the loss of Indian heritage and identity among second-generation Indians in Chicago. Participants worried that their children are losing their Indian heritage as they assimilate to American culture. “In India, the young people cover their skin more and do not spend so much time on the street,” one mother said, explaining her concern over a loss of modesty and tradition among the second generation. Yet, young participants explain that social organizations and events for young South Asians, such as “Desi Nights” at Chicago restaurants and clubs, help second generation youth deal with their “in between” status as both Americans and Asians. Programs and events sponsored by the IAHM highlight Indian culture and heritage and promote linkages among South Asian community members in the wider Chicago area. Many study participants mentioned that the relative affluence of South Asian immigrants compared to other immigrant groups has contributed to a “model minority” stereotype of South Asians as upwardly mobile, educated, and well-to-do. While this reputation can be a source of pride, many participants SPRINGBOARDS FOR CLIMATE ACTION HERITAGE/IDENTITY 12 Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report
  • 15. Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report 13 SPRINGBOARDS FOR CLIMATE ACTION described it a “burden” as well. In particular, widespread perceptions of South Asians as upwardly mobile contribute to a reticence to acknowledge and invest resources in a growing population of poor and undocumented South Asian immigrants. Interviewees who work closely with immigrants who live and work near Devon told us that a greater awareness of the problems and obstacles facing new South Asian immigrants is critical to a more nuanced understanding of the South Asian community as a whole. Health was one of the most important concerns cited by study participants. Interviewees noted that conditions such as diabetes and high blood pressure occur at very high frequencies among South Asian immigrants. While genetic factors play a role in the onset of these diseases, participants also said that high-fat diets, an aging population, and sedentary lifestyles contribute to community health concerns. While the vegetarian diet of many Hindu participants provides a healthful dietary foundation, some interviewees noted that deep frying vegetarian dishes exacerbate heart disease among South Asians. Among new and poor immigrants, health problems are often exacerbated by a lack of access to medical coverage and affordable health care. One interviewee told us that an acquaintance returned to India to have surgery because the cost of the procedure here was prohibitively expensive. Participants also noted that there are serious mental health concerns in the community––particularly among the elderly. A move from South Asia to the United States is frequently associated with a loss in social status, isolation, and boredom for elderly immigrants. This problem is particularly acute for seniors who live with their adult children who are working full-time, leaving them alone for long hours during the day. One participant explained, “There is a lot of senior dependency which leads to mental health issues; these have to do with the kinds of opportunities that are available here and with moving down in status. Seniors often have a sense of isolation and boredom when they come here.” Elderly South Asians who live near Devon can take advantage of programs offered by the Indo-American Center and Metropolitan Family Health Services, where they receive free lunches and participate in social events. The free lunch program at IAC alone services between fifty and eighty seniors daily. Suburban seniors have limited access to these centers, leading many interviewees to emphasize the importance of having affordable and convenient public transportation that links the suburbs and the city. A group of three women told us that their families practiced numerous environmentally-friendly activities in India, such as raising chickens and air drying clothes. They have found it difficult to continue these practices in Chicago due to space constraints and strict policies in the buildings where they live. They further fear that their neighbors would perceive them as uneducated and incapable of behaving in American society if they resumed these practices. Without this fear of judgment they were all interested in returning to these traditional activities. HEALTH
  • 16. SPRINGBOARDS FOR CLIMATE ACTION There are several neighborhood organizations that provide free health care services for the South Asian community. For example, the Indo-American Center and Metropolitan Family Services regularly bring in doctors who screen their clients for various conditions. Asian Family Services on Peterson Avenue provides medical care for low-income West Ridge residents, about eighty percent of whom lack health insurance and about twenty percent of whom are of South Asian origin. These organizations are thus vital sources for information and assistance with health issues for the entire South Asian community and its elderly population in particular. While study participants touted the benefits of accessible health care, our participants also noted that rapid diagnoses without any long-term follow-up do not always lead to improvements in their clients’ health. Study participants who work and shop along Devon frequently commented on its appearance, and in particular expressed concern about garbage and litter along the street and sidewalks, a lack of shade and trees, and parking problems and traffic congestion. Nevertheless, many of our study participants also noted the popularity of the Devon corridor among Chicago-area South Asians who enjoy browsing, shopping, and socializing there. Several interviewees pointed out that the benches along Devon were particularly popular spots for sitting and socializing, but also said that shade trees would enhance the benches’ usability. Many participants felt that there were adequate garbage cans along Devon for trash disposal, and many expressed appreciation for the solar compactors that have been recently installed. However, several also said that Devon’s trash cans do not get emptied frequently enough and are often overflowing with garbage. Similarly, one business owner said that bins for clothing donations located in his parking lot are emptied very rarely, and, as a consequence, there are often bags spilling over with clothing littering the lot. “It is a nuisance,” he said, adding that, rather than being an asset, the donation bins actually contribute to the dirty appearance of Devon. While many participants expressed appreciation for area parks such as Indian Boundary Park and Rogers Park, they also commented that illicit activities in the parks––and drug dealing in particular in Warren Park––make them unusable in the evenings. Some participants also felt that park equipment, such as courts and playgrounds, suffer from a lack of upkeep. Still, many of our participants use the parks regularly for exercise and recreation, and the youth program coordinator at IAC frequently takes the children to the park during the summer, where they can play games and engage in physical activities. One man reminisced about his beautiful farmhouse in India, where he had a variety of flowers and cereals. He says he misses that here, and he laments that space- constraints and age-related ailments have prevented him form taking up gardening in Chicago. USE OF PUBLIC SPACE 14 Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report
  • 17. Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report 15 SPRINGBOARDS FOR CLIMATE ACTION 1. Invest in green spaces projects along Devon Avenue that bring nature to the corridor. 2. Provide incentives to empty lot owners, especially along Western Avenue where many car dealerships have closed down, to lease private property to community organizations for beautification and gardening. 3. Support local organizations that: • Implement programs that encourage outdoor activities, such as walking and using the nearby parks. • Provide educational support to families, especially to seniors related to healthy eating and exercising, and eco-friendly practices like water conservation, repairing and reusing equipment, and energy reduction. 4. Work with hometown and civic organizations and businesses to: • Increase awareness and knowledge of green options for energy conservation practices, including reducing Styrofoam, using energy efficient appliances, and repairing instead of replacing broken items. • Promote vegetarianism and the myriad of restaurants along Devon Avenue that specialize in vegetarian dishes. 5. Appeal to traditional values regarding conservation and living “naturally” and help develop parallel practices that can be undertaken in Chicago. Offer inter-generational programming between seniors and youth, where traditional cultural knowledge is exchanged with fresh perspectives on contemporary needs and the environment. COMMUNITY CONCERNS SPRINGBOARDS FOR CLIMATE ACTION ec ommendations:R
  • 18. 16 Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report Study participants engage in a variety of environmentally-friendly practices. Participants often linked environmentally-friendly habits to broader cultural and geographical contexts, including their experiences living in a more “natural” way and adapting to resource scarcity in India. Additionally, many study participants are motivated by the cost savings certain practices confer. However, other participants expressed reluctance to engage in certain practices, such as hanging clothes out to dry or raising chickens, that might affect the ways they are perceived by their neighbors. Finally, the concentration of resources along Devon lends itself to certain environmentally-friendly practices, such as walking, eating vegetarian food, and buying locally, that are particularly popular among the South Asian community. Interviewees drew a strong relationship between environmentally-friendly practices and lifestyles in South Asia. They emphasized: • vegetarianism, • water conservation, • cooking methods (pressure cooker, solar cooker, etc), and • repairing, reusing, or repurposing equipment. Vegetarianism is hallmark of the Indian diet, and Devon is home to many restaurants that feature meat-free cuisine. This diet is free of the carbon footprint associated with the livestock industry, and is among West Ridge’s most popular environmentally-friendly practices. Our study participants noted that local concerns surrounding pollution, scarcity, and water contamination in India led many of them to adopt environmentally-friendly practices that they would like to continue in Chicago. Among our study participants, resource access and distribution was often discussed as a political issue and not necessarily an environmental one. For example, the poor in India frequently lack access to clean water but the wealthy do not, leading many of our study participants to identify resource scarcity as a result of inequality or poverty. In the United States, this translates into consumption practices that tend to reflect class position. This may help to explain why several interviewees said that they would hesitate to do certain practices, such as hang clothing out to dry or use second-hand items, because of associated stigma. environmentally- friendly PRACTICES, VALUES, AND TRADITIONS One woman described how she could use a solar cooker to prepare large meals for her family, and to heat water for baths. Back in India this was an essential technology for her, allowing her to turn her roof into a functional stove on hot days. It also helped her to conserve energy and time. Because of differences in temperature and space, she has not continued this practice in Chicago. VEGETARIAN RESTAURANTS ALONG DEVON AVE. Vegetarian Restaurant Vegetarian-Friendly Restaurant
  • 19. Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report 17 ENVIRONMENTALLY-FRIENDLY PRACTICES, VALUES, AND TRADITIONS In major Indian cities like Deli there are countless scrap dealers where you can sell household items like plastic and glass. Without the same incentive system here, this gentleman has felt little motivation to go out of his way to recycle. Other community members shared similar stories. A woman from Pakistan shared that she used to store her bottles and newspapers separately in order to sell them to a scrap dealer. Several community members suggested that scrap dealers who purchase recyclable materials should be encouraged, as they are in India and Pakistan. They agreed this would be a strong motivating factor for South Asian immigrants to recycle, as recycling confers economic benefits in their homelands. Participants drew a strong connection between energy conservation and frugality, lamenting U.S. consumption practices that make wastefulness normative and resource conservation difficult and expensive. For example, several participants remarked that it is often easier to replace broken equipment than to have it repaired. While many of our interviewees said that they do not have enough information about the cost savings related to energy efficient practices, others said that they planned to take advantage of government rebates and tax credits toward the purchase of energy efficient appliances in their homes. Our research revealed the following community patterns, in relationship to the practices listed in the box: 1. The most popular practices combine several advantages: they are cost- effective, convenient to do, and widely socially acceptable among the South Asian community. These include: walking as transit, buying local, using curtains/drapes, and using energy-efficient light bulbs. 2. Other practices that rank high among our West Ridge study participants are linked to conservation habits that deal with resource scarcity in Asia, such as water conservation and turning off appliances. 3. Using energy-efficient appliances and retrofitting homes appear near the middle of the list, indicating that the initial capital investment required for these practices may be a barrier to some. Also, this positioning may reflect a need for greater awareness regarding the economic benefits of energy- saving devices, as many of our participants stated in interviews. 4. The least popular practices are the most difficult and expensive to undertake: green roofs, building green, and using renewable energy. An elderly community member said that he used to recycle regularly while living in India. When he did so, he was rewarded with payments from nearby garbage collectors and recyclers. Since moving to the United States, he has not discovered any recycling programs that compare to India’s system. One study participant told us that she believes that people in the U.S. have a “throw away” mentality that exacerbates waste production. An elderly man agreed and, pointing to his watch, said that it is easier to buy things new in the United States than it is to have them repaired.
  • 20. 18 Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report ENVIRONMENTALLY-FRIENDLY PRACTICES, VALUES, AND TRADITIONS ENVIRONMENTALLY-FRIENDLY PRACTICES IN WEST RIDGE’S SOUTH ASIAN COMMUNITY 1. Using Curtains/Drapes to Control Temperature 2. Turning Off Lights, Appliance, TV 3. Using Energy Efficient Light Bulbs 4. Opening Windows 5. Walking as Transit 6. Buying Local 7. Outdoor Relaxation/Recreation 8. Conserving Water 9. Riding Public Transportation 10. Recycling 11. Repairing Instead of Replacing 12. Using Manual Instead of Power Tools 13. Exchanging or Sharing Used Items with Family/Friends/Neighbors 14. Using Energy Efficient Appliance, Devices 15. Car Pooling 16. Bringing Your Own Shopping Bag 17. Buying Organic 18. Living Close to Open/Natural Space 19. Hanging Clothes to Dry 20. Reusing/Re-purposing 21. Beautifying the Community 22. Gardening: community, school, home 23. Biking as Transit 24. Retrofitting Homes/Buildings 25. Capturing or Diverting Rain Water 26. Using Renewable Energy 27. Green Roofs 28. Preserving Historic Buildings/Places 29. Raising Chickens 30. Restoring Native Habitats 31. Building Green 32. Other (Vegetarian ) 33. Driving and maintaining a speed of 55 mph LEAST MOST Environmentally-friendly practices are listed below in order from most to least reported by residents and representatives of businesses, schools, and community organizations. Many reflect inherent community values that may be building blocks for further involving residents in CCAP implementation. BARRIERS TO ENVIRONMENTALLY-FRIENDLY PRACTICES Our research revealed a number of barriers that study participants face in attempting to engage environmentally-friendly practices. These include: • Financial constraints, particularly for practices with up-front costs; • Cultural norms that make certain practices, such as hanging clothes out to dry or bicycling, unappealing or difficult. Some study participants said they did not think these practices would become popular with middle-class South Asians even if they were made more convenient. • Inconvenience, especially associated with recycling; • Preoccupations with concerns that are more apparent or immediate; and • Lack of information related to environmentally-friendly practices, especially in languages other than English. Rec ommendations: 1. Create an educational campaign that validates traditional practices that can be challenging to maintain in an urban environment, such as water conservation, frugality, reusing and repurposing, and spending time outdoors. 2. Encourage the greening of the Devon Corridor, building upon the area’s tradition of eco-friendly food preparation. Highlight the potential environmental benefits of a vegetarian diet, finding public ways to explain its ecological benefits, and bolstering the efforts of local vegetarian restaurants. ENVIRONMENTALLY-FRIENDLY PRACTICES, VALUES, AND TRADITIONS
  • 21. Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report 19 South Asians in West Ridge have access to a variety of sources of information. Many of these sources do not focus on climate change per se, but offer news and information related to the environment. Still, many of our study participants felt like they were lacking information on climate change and the environment and, in particular, about the economic benefits of climate action programs. There are a number of newspapers––such as the India Times and Indian Tribune––that are geared toward the South Asian community, free of cost, and widely available on Devon. Most of these are published in English to appeal to a wider readership among South Asia’s diverse language speakers, though some are also published in Hindi and Urdu. Videos and movies that are sold in ubiquitous video and bookstores along Devon are also popular sources of entertainment and communication among elderly members of the South Asian community. Service organizations, such as IAC and Metropolitan Family Health Services, as well as cultural organizations and religious institutions are also places where information is disseminated. While much of this information is centered around financial and immigration assistance, the cost-savings benefits of environmentally-friendly practices could be integrated into center programs. Many South Asians rely on their informal social networks, including family members and friends, for communication about local events and transnational community concerns. Devon Avenue itself is also a rich source of information, as South Asians socialize with each other here on benches and in restaurants and stores, and browse notices in retail shops along Devon. communication  AND DISSEMINATION 1. Take advantage of the local organizations and businesses along the Devon corridor to disseminate information throughout the South Asian community, including suburban residents who shop on Devon. 2. Provide information related to climate change and climate action programs that is printed in Hindi and Urdu and that is easy to read quickly or scan––such as bulleted text. Create attractive posters that can be displayed in shop windows. 3. Engage local organizations in a conversation on the community’s stake in addressing climate change. Identify ways that the organizations can communicate and engage residents around climate action, emphasizing the potential cost-savings associated with environmentally-friendly practices. COMMUNICATION AND DISSEMINATION Rec ommendations:
  • 22. 20 Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report FOR COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT MODEL ONE: LINKING FORMAL AND INFORMAL RESOURCES Devon’s business community is linked both by common interests and by social and kinship networks. There are established organizations in place, such as the West Ridge Chamber of Commerce, that work to advance the interests of businesses along Devon; there are also more informal resources, such as family loans, that business owners tap into to improve their businesses. Together, formal and informal networking have created a well-established system of communication and resource distribution in the Devon business community. These resources and networks could be mobilized to reduce the carbon footprint of the businesses on the corridor. MODEL TWO: INDIA IN CHICAGO The Devon corridor is a hub for Indian and South Asian heritage practices, as seen through local festivals, events, clothing, and cuisine. These practices are potentially powerful allies of climate change action. As the South Asian community engages in heritage celebrations, there is tremendous potential to promote environmentally-friendly practices like vegetarianism, walking as transit, and eating locally. For many of our interviewees, these practices were already a source of great pride. MODEL THREE: ECONOMIC EDUCATION Most of the institutions that serve immigrants, seniors, and low income residents in West Ridge offer information and resources related to financial assistance to large numbers of South Asians. Many of our study participants who lamented a lack of information in the community surrounding the cost-benefits of energy conservation also noted that integrating climate change information into these institutions’ programs is entirely consistent with their missions. The outreach of these institutions could be utilized to educate community members about the economic benefits of environmentally-friendly practices. creative models 1. Promote the CCAP by stressing the connection between climate action and community and individual well-being. Use this connection to develop the “India in Chicago” model, creating a heritage corridor that emphasizes a holistic view of the natural environment and a healthy community. 2. Foster linkages within West Ridge’s business community to help business owners share information and implement collective projects, such as to beautify and “green” the spaces in front of their businesses along major commercial corridors. 3. Mobilize the resources and networks of West Ridge’s business community to reduce the carbon footprint of the businesses along the Devon corridor, to help businesses stop using environmentally-toxic materials such as styrofoam. CREATIVE MODELS FOR COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT Rec ommendations:
  • 23. 21 Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report conclusion With its thriving business district, the West Ridge neighborhood is a cultural and commercial hub of metropolitan Chicago’s South Asian community. Though socio-economically and ethnically diverse, West Ridge business owners, service providers, and residents broadly agree that climate action strategies could enhance the attractiveness, livability, and financial vitality of their community. By linking their efforts to climate action and the CCAP, West Ridge organizations can address shared concerns and core values—like beautification, health, and safety—as they mobilize West Ridge’s human and cultural resources around climate action projects.
  • 24. 22 Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report Businesses 1. Daata Darbar 2. Money Dart 3. National Republic Bank 4. Punjabi Dhabha 5. Raja Vegetarian Fast Food 6. Sahil Boutique 7. Salvation Army Store 8. Udupi Palace 9. Uru Swati 10. Viceroy of India Community Organizations 1. High Ridge YMCA 2. Indo-American Heritage Center and Indo-American Heritage Museum 3. Metropolitan Asian Family Services 4. Muslim Women’s Resource Center 5. Patel Brothers Public Parks/Natural Areas 1. Indian Boundary Park 2. Warren Park Vegetarian Restaurant 1. Arya Bhavan 2. Charmin Fine Dining & Grill 3. Copal Kabob & Steak 4. Dasaprakash 5. Devon Pizza 6. Ghareeb Nawaz 7. India Garden 8. Motimoti Mahi Restaurant 9. Mysore Woodlands 10. Sabri Nehari 11. Sher Punjab Indian Restaurant 12. Tahoora LLC 13. Usmania Fine Dining Albion Ave NWESTERNAVE NCALIFORNIAAVE W ARTHUR AVE W LUNT AVE W GRANVILLE AVE NROCKWELLST NWASHTENAWAVE NCAMPBELLAVE W ROSEMONT AVE NARTESIANAVE W JARVIS AVE W FARGO AVE NFAIRFIELDAVE NMAPLEWOODAVE NMOZARTST W BIRCHWOOD AVE W NORTH SHORE AVE W SHERWIN AVE NHOYNEAVE W MORSE AVE NVIRGINIAAVE ESTES AVE NRAVENSWOODAVE NWOLCOTTAVE NFRANCISCOAVE NOAKLEYAVE NWINCHESTERAVE NCLAREMONTAVE NSACRAMENTOAVE DEVON PRATT TOUHY PETERSON KEDZIE 50th Ward Bernard L. Stone 40th Ward Patrick J O'Conner 49th Ward Joe Moore 5 4 3 2 1 2 1 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 10 4 2 9 8 7 6 5 3 1 13 1211 10 5 4 3 2 1 2 1 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 10 4 2 9 8 7 6 5 3 1 13 1211 10 5 4 3 2 1 2 1 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 10 9th Ward aret Laurino Legend Community Organization Public Parks/Natural Are Businesses Vegetarian Restaurant Chicago Park District community asset map
  • 25. Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report 23 CHICAGO 138TH 55TH 119TH 47TH 103RD 71ST 87TH T WESTERN 63RD MADISON YN MAWR 111TH HALSTED 95TH PULASKI NORTH FULLERTON DEVON PERSHING 79TH NARRAGANSETT ROOSEVELT STONYISLAND CERMAK 127TH COTTAGEGROVE ASHLAND TORRENCE CENTRAL 31ST CICERO HARLEM KEDZIE 31ST 3 2 1 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 24 33 32 31 30 29 28 27 25 23 26 22 21 20 19 18 17 16 15 14 13 12 11 10 1 3 2 1 1 Legend Businesses Community Organization Schools/Universities Government Agecy West Ridge Businesses 1. Air India 2. Etihad Airlines 3. Globetrotting Engineering Community Organizations 1. American Indian Center 2. Arab American Action Network 3. Balzekas Museum of Lithuanian Culture 4. Bronzeville Children’s Museum 5. Bronzeville/Black Chicagoan Historical 6. Cambodian American Heritage Museum and Killing Fields Memorial 7. Casa Aztlán 8. Casa Michoacán 9. Changing Worlds 10. Chicago History Museaum 11. Children’s Memorial Hospital 12. Chinese American Museum of Chicago 13. Chinese Mutual Aid Associon 14. DANK Haus German American Cultural Center 15. Ethiopian Community Association 16. Filipino American Historical Society of Chicago 17. Greater Chicago 18. Institute of Puerto Rican Arts & Culture 19. Irish American Heritage Center 20. Jane Addams Hull-House Museum 21. Jesse White Tumbling Team 22. Korean American Resource and Cultural Center 23. Latvian Folk Art Museum 24. Peggy Notebaert Nature Museum 25. Polish Museum of America 26. Project on Civic Reflection 27. Pullman State Historic Site 28. Serbian Cultural and Arts Center St. Sava 29. Swahili Institute of Chicago 30. Swedish American Museum 31. The Field Museum 32. Ukrainian Institute of Modern Art 33. Ukrainian National Museum Government Agencies 1. Toni Preckwinkle-Cook County Board President Schools/Universities 1. Center for International Studies (University of Chicago) 2. North Park University 3. Student Activities & Greek Affair ASSETS OUTSIDE OF THIS MAP Businesses 1. Asian American Hotel Owners Association 2. Big Cinemas Golf Glen 5 3. Desi Junction Radio Community Organizations 1. Bengali Association of Greater Chicago 2. Chicago Zoological Society--Brookfield 3. Gujarati Samaj Chicago 4. Illinois Saint Andrews Society 5. Italian Cultural Center at Casa Italia 6. Maharashtra Mandal Restaurant 7. Mitchell Museum of the American Indian 8. Punjabi Cultural Society 9. Science of Spirituality 10. Shree Jalaram Mandir Other Non-profit Organization 1. Federation of Indian Associations 2. Sardar Patel Foundation regional asset map
  • 26. 24 Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo) • The Field Museum • Research Report PARTICIPATING ORGANIZATIONS Our research with Indo-American Heritage Museum involved leaders and residents affiliated with over 30 organizations, which represent a diversity of geographic areas, sectors, and issues. These include: Indo-American Heritage Museum Indo-American Center West Ridge YMCA Punjabi Cultural Society Gujarati Samaj Chicago Metropolitan Family Health Services Asian Family Services Devon Bank Uncommon Ground Restaurant Indian Garden Hansa Chaharia BIBLIOGRAPHY * All image rights reserved. Visit fieldmuseum.org/explore/department/ecco for more information. OUR TEAM Chicago Fact Finder: Your Census Information Resource for Chicagoland Communities. Area 2: West Ridge. Institute for Latino Studies, University of Notre Dame, 2005. Web. June 2010. Holi, Melvin G., and Peter D’Alroy Jones. Ethnic Chicago: A Multicultural Portrait. Grand Rapids: Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing Co, 1994. Indo-American Center. Images of America: Asian Indians of Chicago. Arcadia Publishers, 2002. Kalayil et al. Developing Devon. Self-published manuscript. University of Illinois at Chicago. The West Ridge Community Survey. Self-publishedmanuscript. PRINCIPAL INVESTIGATORS: Dr. Jennifer Hirsch, Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo), The Field Museum Commissioner Suzanne Malec-McKenna, City of Chicago Department of Environment PROJECT MANAGER: Dr. Rosa Cabrera, Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo), The Field Museum PROJECT TEAM: Mannan Bandukwala, Indo-American Heritage Museum  Nafisa Bandukwala, Indo-American Heritage Museum Dr. Ruth Gomberg-Muñoz, Chicago Cultural Alliance Ryan Lugalia-Hollon, Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo), The Field Museum Lisa See Kim, Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo), The Field Museum Modhurima Mukherjee, Indo-American Heritage Museum Rebeccah Sanders, Chicago Cultural Alliance Dorothie Shah, Indo-American Heritage Museum Mimosa Shah, Chicago Cultural Alliance Renuka Sharma, Indo-American Center Sarah Sommers, Environment, Culture, and Conservation (ECCo), The Field Museum INTERNS: Izabela Grobelna, Alyssa Pfluger, Hannah Porst, Ylanda Wilhite, Juliana Wilhoit