Winning Back Trust Through Mail
A creative perspective
Who is this person?
www.directnewideas.com
What’s happened to brands?
What’s happened to brands? Mercedes make a car that falls over Ford make cars that crash Firestone make tyres that burst
On the subject of cars…
Brands are up to no good Nestle dressed women up as nurses to hand out free samples of powder milk to breast-feeding mums. Just enough for them to stop lactating. And then have to buy the Nestle formula. Nike exploit child labour
Poisoning our children
 
Poisoning us
Brands are dishonest
Coca-Cola tried to fool us
Kraft lied
There will be consequences
The banks…
The banks
The people we don’t trust don’t trust each other
Dick Fuld
Politicians lie
Politicians lie
Lack of trust In 2000 4 in 10 consumers showed preference to one brand. In 2007, fewer than 1 in 10. Carlson Marketing: trust in brands is down 50% since 2000. The Henley centre reports that trust in 16 of the UK’s 17 largest, brands is reduced. Only 20% of brands are trustworthy according to Gerzema and Lebar
A big brand crash waiting to happen
How do people tell brands what they feel?
 
 
 
 
 
Brands have powerful enemies
And these are tough times
So, what is trust? It develops over time So it’s a relationship In which you can be wrong as well as right With give and take Being open and honest
5 ways to rebuild trust 1. Through values 2. Through ethics 3. Through constancy 4. Through intimacy 5. Through creativity
Brands have to have values Values provide a platform for a consistent message An ongoing conversation Create talkability A theme with which to interact with customers/staff
Not just attributes
 
Recognisable values
In everything they do
Virgin
The letter as brand communication
Honda
It starts with the brand
Keeping the relationship going
Dirt is good
But better in Direct Mail
How to start talking about values? Repositioning helps Some brands have turned disaster into triumph And found their values
Jet Blue screwed up
They wrote to say sorry
Innocent’s ethics looked dodgy
They wrote to explain Mitchell and his colleagues tirelessly tracked down and contacted every negative blogger on their web site, to personally explain the logic of the deal.  “ H aving the blog, as well as inviting people to ring us on the Banana Phone, is all about keeping in touch with our customers and inviting them to engage with us, ”  says Mitchell. He believes such communication is key to keeping Innocent grounded as it grows.
Eurostar stranded passengers  .
Mail is fundamental to their recovery
2. The importance of ethics
Ethical brands Most ethical The Co-Op The Bodyshop BBC Marks & Spencer Waitrose Least ethical McDonald’s Burger King Ryan Air Nike Shell
Better get some ethics Brands are learning they had better get some ethics fast Or face the consequences
Nestle goes Fairtrade
Ethics – not for everyone
Yet! The digital revolution is making business more accountable
Compare and contrast
Corporate social responsibility
 
HD loves HB
Musica
3. Trust through constancy Most of the money goes on acquisition Few awards for retention You shouldn’t be surprised your customers desert you
Retention v acquisition
CRM doesn’t come cheap
Baileys
 
Surprise and Delight
Saying thank you goes a long way
Saying thank you goes a long way
4. Through intimacy  It’s about being personal The connection real people make with each other
Real people saved Microsoft
A real farmer for Birdseye
A real farmer for Birdseye
The chubby grocer
Conversation
Dole introduce you to the real grower
What does personal mean?
PersonALITY
Having a distinct tone of voice
 
 
It’s knowing
 
Personal means you know me
5. Through creativity Creativity has been democratised It shows you care You’ve spent time and money
Is any response more direct than a laugh?
 
It engages at once
The envelope is a poster
The beginning of an experience
 
It tells a story
Involves you
It engages the senses
A postcard that purrs
A letter you can eat
Why are these exceptions? Authenticity Reality Personality
Problem: data or creativity? Clients are buying data Not creativity Aided and abetted by media agencies Media agencies sell success as a result of appropriate placement  All summed up in ROI
ROI Who doesn’t want a return on their investment? It is such a reductive concept Trying to be predictive i.e.  Let’s do what we did last time Based on what everyone else is doing Allows marketers to feel in control Unambitious
Return on Idea You need an idea about the brand You need an idea about who you are talking to and what you want to say to them Finally you need a creative idea that will engage
Burger King’s idea
Return on idea. From….
To….
Return on Idea from Cadbury
Return on Idea from Cadbury
Dove
Dove - Return on Idea
Strategem - Return on Idea
In summary: Be a bit more human Ask, how can we do stuff that people will like? So they will want us as a brand friend?
The creative perspective

Trust me I'm Marketing

Editor's Notes

  • #2 Actually…through a combination of media. No medium can exist on its own any longer…but certainly, if brands are to win back trust, then mail as part of an integrated comms strategy makes much sense, as I will show, I hope.
  • #4 I’m here to preach to the converted. And to do a bit of direct marketing … I am the new publisher of Directory and am keen to offer subscriptions
  • #5 In return for this shameless bit of advertising, I will endeavour to spend the next hour Being almost interesting while showing some great work…
  • #14 And they are a building society, a mutual, not even a bank….
  • #17 And they are a building society, a mutual, not even a bank….
  • #20 Not just corporations, but their leaders have been letting us down. The CEO of Lehman Brothers- has just been revealed as hiding a $50 billion hole. Repo 105 transactions He has been described as the worst US CEO of all time.
  • #21 I did not have sex with that woman
  • #22 I did not have sex with that woman
  • #23 Brands are also in trouble because own label looks better value
  • #32 The rise and rise of own label
  • #33 Relationship - spot that word. It’s the word around which the future of direct marketing revolves
  • #34 Relationship - spot that word. It’s the word around which the future of direct marketing revolves
  • #43 When you know what the brand is all about, then you can do great work across all media Guinness
  • #44 When you know what the brand is all about, then you can do great work across all media Guinness
  • #45 Persil repositioned the brand around ‘Dirt Is Good’ – a brilliant insight. – and Mums responded well. BUT the moment their kids came home messy they went berserk.
  • #46 The only way Mums will let kids get messy is if they get messy with them. A campaign idea that really should be direct driven…
  • #47 How do you start sharing your values with your customers????? The psychology of apology is interesting.
  • #49 They wrote a letter Issued advertising to spell out the 7 Day plan and the 30 day plan….
  • #51 Again, please note that this is one-to-one communication
  • #53 one-to-one communication to the 20% of regular passengers who are responsible for 80% of their income
  • #54 This is the FT looking at companies and asking how they choose their suppliers. Well, consumers are pretty much the same as finance directors
  • #57 Niot because they WANT to, but because they HAVE to
  • #58 Gore-Tex
  • #59 Manchester United currently has £703m of debt. The Glazers can take out £63m next year. They can sell the training facilities and lease them back…they are regarded as evil
  • #60 As I said, people want their brands to have recognisable values. And it is no surprise The Red Knights want to create a structure similar to that of Barcelona
  • #61 Brands are acquiring a conscience.
  • #62 Brands are acquiring a conscience.
  • #64 Musica is a retailer selling DVDs. They asked people to rate the Greatest Song Ever. Every visit to the website, they would donate money towards hearing aids for deaf children.
  • #65 I want to go back to relationships a moment. And trust. It’s like my marriage.Back in the 1980s I met a gorgeous Danish blonde and I spent a bloody fortune getting her into bed. If I thought she was going to get any cheaper once I married her, I was hideously horribly wrong. Retention is expensive But worth it…even though I don’t get any sex any more. The point is, I am able to nurture the relationship because we are Able to share certain values. We value our children highly…so
  • #67 But then, losing customers is expensive too. MTN sent you a solar powered phone recharger if you had a phone contract with them for 10 years….
  • #68 Ideas about how to look busy but actually have a relaxed Christmas…
  • #69 Surprise and delight
  • #70 If you donated money to the Ant-Nazi League they sent you an egg-cup. And that turned you into a recruiter
  • #71 If you had put your dog into the Tribis kennels in the year, at Christmas you were sent a box of chocs…
  • #72 Except they were biscuits for your dog
  • #74 2. Real people ---- that’s what makes direct work best In 2006 the BBC reported “the man who made Microsoft more human is leaving for a technology Start-up….
  • #75 In 2006 the BBC reported “the man who made Microsoft more human is leaving for a technology Start-up….
  • #76 In 2006 the BBC reported “the man who made Microsoft more human is leaving for a technology Start-up….
  • #77 He blogged for a year about losing weight…and finished on 24th December 2008
  • #79 In 2006 the BBC reported “the man who made Microsoft more human is leaving for a technology Start-up….
  • #80 As a consumer, I will engage with brands that have a distinct personality
  • #81 It means REAL PEOPLE
  • #83 This is wry…because that’s the way parenthood is.
  • #84 This is witty. It knows that life is boring…that spectacles are boring…that going to the optician is boring…so It tries to be just a little bit HUMAN about it
  • #86 You’re charmed, entertained
  • #87 And you know what’s happening to me.
  • #88 Everyone understands creativity. They also understand when you don’t give a shit…
  • #93 Mil is the original interactive medium, the original experiential medium… Here I experience a sense of violation which the advertiser wants me to experience…
  • #99 The interesting thing about this pioece is it was mailed out to 3,000 marketers and 8,000 said they had received it.
  • #100 Lt’s recap. For you to make your DM work, you need it to be branded. And that means I want to know and share your values. It needs to be grounded in reality. And it needs to have personality. So why is so little DM any of the above????
  • #102 Unambitious. Lazy. And amazingly 20th Century. Wise up guys, it’s 2009. And there are new rules of communication.
  • #103 As I have said - that idea may emerge from a sense of the brand’s values - Dove. Or from its
  • #104 Burger King had a huge positioning idea - that they are an entertainment brand
  • #106 20th consecutive quarter of growth, $634m for the quarter, up 3% on 2008
  • #107 Cadbury had a huge strategic idea – let’s get people to look elsewhere
  • #108 But you can bet that when the gorilla idea was bought by the board, no-one was asking for the projected ROI. They NEEDED an idea to survive. When you don’t need an idea because everything seems to be going okay, That[‘s when you treat your consumers like morons…
  • #111 This DVD was mailed out to 15 clients. It led to 13 pitches
  • #112 To answer my own questions – it’s about being nice; thoughtful; spending a bit of money; and taking nothing for granted. But get it right and the rewards of being a trusted brand will last you and protect you for many many years
  • #113 Today has been a slightly different perspective. I hope you have enjoyed it