Customizable CSA
shares

Michael Kilpatrick
Kilpatrick Family Farm
today’s outline
•

History and overview of the farm

•

What is CCSA (customizable
community supported
agriculture)

•

How our farm does CCSA

•

Case study 1 (JBG Organics)

•

Case Study 2 (Wishing Stone
Farm)

•

Questions
Blog
www.michael-kilpatrick.com
KFF’s Mission
Provide the best produce possible to our
customers at a fair price
Provide a good income for the farmer - and
good life- we need to love what we do
Provide a fair wage to employees
Middle Granville, NY Zone 4b
12-15 acres in
vegetables
25-30 Acres in Cover Crop
Land and Soil profile
Soil type

Crops

Acres

stays dry, early and late greens, melons,
tomatoes, stony

4

Hamlin Silt loam

root crops, great for radishes, beets,
carrots- no stones

8

Hartland sandy
loam

class 1,general purpose, no stones

4

Vergennes Silty
Clay

somewhat heavy, winter squash,
brassicas, spinach, beans

5

Hoosick Gravelly
sandy Loam

Sweet potato heaven...

1

Bernardston-shaly
silt loams
8 full time employees, 3 interns
1/3rd acre of
Tunnels
3 Summer Markets
2 winter markets
over 30 crops for
the Christmas
market

9 greens

Lettuce Mix
Mesclun Mix
Spinach
baby spinach
Arugula
Kale
Swiss chard
braising mix
bunched turnips
250 member Freechoice, Year-round CSA
3 acres of mulched
crops
5 row system

5 rows for spinach, radish, salad, other small
crops (9”)
3 rows beets, carrots, beans (18”)
2 rows broccoli, cauliflower, potatoes (36”)
1 row tomatoes, artichokes (72”) (plasticulture)
Storage #4
Ruby Perfection
FMC carrot and beet harvester
55 tons of Root
Storage
Free-choice,
Customizable CSA’s
(CCSA)
How is CSA changing
•

CSA Market getting more crowded, more farms

•

Large players entering the field (full circle, 40,000
members)

•

Consumers have wide variety of sources for
purchasing local/organic produce

•

The consumer is changing as well as we’re looking
to reach a wider audience….
Who is your
consumer?
Mcdonalds
Junkie

starting to
think about it

Health
conscious

drinks only soda

drinks diet or
vitamin water

drinks straight
water

kids birthday
party is at
Burger King

owns and may
use cookbooks

Has only
“healthy”
cookbooks in
the kitchen

Eco

earth-muffin
Tree-hugger

Drinks raw milk
Drinks raw milk
kefir excessively

Nourishing
traditions is sole
cookbook

is head of her
Weston a Price
chapter and
soaks nuts

nuts
drives an SUV

is concerned
about climate
change

kids get vitamins

thinks local or
buys corn from
Shops at the
organic food is a the conventional
farmers market
scam
road-side stand

Questions
homebirths and
immunizing kids breastfeeds kids

buys 2 veggie, 1
has tried a CSA
meat, and a raw
in the past
milk share….
Who is your
consumer?
Mcdonalds
Junkie

starting to
think about it

Health
conscious

Eco

earth-muffin
Tree-hugger

drinks only soda

drinks diet or
vitamin water

drinks straight
water

Drinks raw milk

Drinks raw milk
kefir excessively

owns and may
use cookbooks

Has only
“healthy”
cookbooks in
the kitchen

is concerned
about climate
change

kids get vitamins

kids birthday
party is at
Burger King

drives an SUV

thinks local or
buys corn from
Shops at the
organic food is a the conventional
farmers market
scam
road-side stand

Market
penetratio
is head of her
Nourishing
n
Weston a Price
traditions is sole
chapter and
cookbook
with
ferments nuts
normal
Questions
homebirths and
CSA
immunizing kids breastfeeds kids
share
buys 2 veggie, 1
has tried a CSA
meat, and a raw
in the past
milk share….
Who is your
consumer?
Mcdonalds
Junkie

starting to
think about it

Health
conscious

Eco

earth-muffin
Tree-hugger

drinks only soda

drinks diet or
vitamin water

drinks straight
water

Drinks raw milk

Drinks raw milk
kefir excessively

kids birthday
party is at
Burger King

drives an SUV

owns and may
use cookbooks
is concerned
about climate
change

Market
Has only
Nourishing
penetration
“healthy”
traditions is sole
cookbooks in
cookbook
with
the kitchen
CCSA
Questions
share!!!! kids
kids get vitamins
immunizing

thinks local or
buys corn from
Shops at the
organic food is a the conventional
farmers market
scam
road-side stand

is head of her
Weston a Price
chapter and
ferments nuts
homebirths and
breastfeeds kids

buys 2 veggie, 1
has tried a CSA
meat, and a raw
in the past
milk share….
Common Barriers to CSA
•

Too much or too weird food (not everyone likes kohlrabi or
black spanish radishes

•

I don’t like beets, cauliflower, brussel sprouts- picky
consumers and their kids

•

time/date not conducive to ease of pickup.

•

produce not like the grocery store- bunch/size different
What consumers want

….
Common barriers for farmers
•

not automating the system…. poor organization will kill you.

•

There is a higher cost associated with this.. so charge more

•

having to provide variety all the time.

•

if share is picked at site(not predetermined) , less sales
efficiency (more waste)
Customizable basics- what
does this look like?
•

Customer picks up at a site where they can swap out items in
their share for more appealing ones

•

Customer uses up pre-purchased credit (dollar amount or
points) at a farmstand, farmer’s market or other site.

•

Customer can shop online for the items that they want in
their share and a partially or fully customized share is
delivered
Customer picks up at FM or
site where they pick out their
share
Do you include everything?
•

What about high-value crops such as Greenhouse tomatoes,
Strawberries.

•

For us at Farmers markets those “first fruits” are often big
money makers

•

We have chosen to make those worth more for our CSA (one
tomato, limit one pint strawberry, etc)

•

Have swap bin where if a customer can’s use or doesn’t
want an item they can swap it out with another member
Point system
•

members get 20, 30 or 40 points a week

•

Can fluctuate during season as the bounty comes in

•

different number points for produce, eggs, chicken baked
goods)

•

works well for members with dietary restrictions.
Debit card system
•

using a custom POS (point-of-sale)system to track customer
purchases

•

or a giant filebox with each customer on a 4X6 index card (I
would do iPad and google doc)

•

Credit expires at end of year. Or not.
Sources for cards/readers
•

square (gift card module coming soon)

•

chargeanywhere.com (readers)

•

plasticresource.com

•

duracard.com

http://marcelbrown.comphoto
Web placed, farm filled shares
•

least waste, shares are harvested/filled after amounts
known.

•

Must have a strong software program in place to make it
work smoothly

•

Ultimate control, you decide what to offer
What program to use?
•

super small CSA’s may want to do all communication by blog
and email.

•

We have used Google forms or Wofoo for smaller items.

•

Large CSA’s may want to use Zen cart, a custom software
solution, or Small Farm Central’s shopping cart software,.
Setting up a good online store
•

Allows complete customization (or not)

•

intuitive for customer as well as farmer

•

can easily export data to usable pick/pack sheets

•

beware of % use models (you pay % of sales)
How we do CSA
Our CSA is a free-choice share, in which the
customer picks most of their share right up off the
market table. We usually select 1 item per week the
members have to take.
We also deliver Boxed (none-customized) shares
to business drop sites
Year- Round CSA
Sell root crops, onions, squash, frozen foods!!!
Helps to have greens
keep customers year-round
year-round members are best cheerleaders
you are on the road during the worst time of
the year
Shares we Offer
JAN

FEB

MAR

APR

MAY JUNE JULY AUG

SEP

SUMMER (26
WINTER (17 wks)
wks)
FULL YEAR (52
weeks)

OCT

NOV

DEC

FALL (9
wks)
2 SIZES OF SHARES
FULL (6-9 items) $25 per week -we say will feed a family of 4
MICRO (4-6 items) $17 per week
-will feed a couple or vegetarian
single
Share types
Year-Round Share
Summer Share
Fall Share
Winter/Spring Share
Skidmore share
Cancellation Policy
A 2-week trial period is offered to confirm the suitability, as
we understand a CSA Membership is not for everyone and
every situation. We will give a prorated refund during the
first or second week of that specific CSA Season
(Summer, Fall, Winter or Year-Round). Please allow two
to four weeks for your refund. After two pickups refunds
will be granted if we have a waiting list and can find a new
member to take your place. Thank you for your
understanding.
Advantages of freechoice CSA
don’t have to have 250 items of 6 + crops per
week
we reach wider audience and edge over
competition
still allows us to move extra crop each week
We don’t have to have the same items for
every pickup/market
very busy market stand
Disadvantages of freechoice CSA
specialty crops aren’t available for retail (early
tomatoes, strawberries)
wide variety of crops necessary all the time
(harvest inefficiency)
Very busy market stand!
have to watch quantities
CSA management at
KFF
Farmer
CSA coordinator
bookkeeper
Farmer’s responsibilities
Strategic meetings with other management to
plan upcoming season
All production aspects, planning, seeding,
harvesting, sending to market
Face, or rainmaker of the farm.
Planning the CCSA
We grow a wide variety of crops to support our
Farmer’s markets and wholesale already
We started small with the CCSA and grew it
based on feedback every year- 2012 we grew
too quickly
Some markets just don’t have some crops
We spend a lot of time planning…
Planning the CCSA
We grow a wide variety of crops to support our
Farmer’s markets and wholesale already
We started small with the CCSA and grew it
based on feedback every year- 2012 we grew
too quickly
Some markets just don’t have some crops
CSA coordinator
responsibilities
all member inquiries
organizing bulk product sales (tomatoes,
cucumbers, etc)
CSA software setup and maintenance
marketing emails
Bookkeeper
responsibilities
applying payments
helping members setup payment plans
tracking expenses/profits of the CSA
Check out information online
www.michael-kilpatrick.com/csa-scho
Member Agreement
CSA handbook
2011, 12, 13 master plans
Sample recipe cards
CSA calendar
CSA surveys
Localvore club card
•

Bought in the spring with our CSA shares

•

Usable for anything on the farm eggs, chickens,
frozen foods

•

Customers get 5% off - pay $95 for a $100 card
Other systems we have played
with….
•

Home delivery, with orders placed through a % CSA
service

•

Mini-store added on- dairy products, eggs, olive oil,
etc

•

Orders delivered to a hospital, with semicustomization through email

•

Adding frozen vegetables to Shares (Pesto, Frozen
or dried tomatoes, eggs when abundant)
Foxy shopping cart with
custom back end
•

2000 member CSA

•

20 farmers markets weekly

•

Wholesale into a 5 hour radius (17 M)

•

right now customer can select between 4 different
box sizes. And can swap out unwanted items at the
farmers market pickup
Customizable CSA at JBG
•

Software is being built and is completely custom

•

truck has to be loaded in reverse of how you want
to pull shares out

•

at the start, customer will be able pick several of
their items, by summer it will hopefully be
completely customizable.
Debit-card CCSA System
•

Customers buy in winter at decreasing credit levels
(get 10% extra January, 8% extra Feb, etc)

•

Cards are kept at markets in a file box

•

After card is used at market or farm, credit is
subtracted from card

•

What members have left on Oct 31st goes to help
fund food bank.
Takeaways
•

CCSA can help you reach new customers and
increased overall vegetable efficiency (customers
throw away less).

•

CCSA is doable, although there are a lot more
decisions to make

•

CCSA requires efficiencies and figuring mechanics

•

Invest in software and hardware to make your
transition easier.
Thank you!!!
Michael Kilpatrick
www.michael-kilpatrick.com
www.kilpatrickfamilyfarm.com

Customizable Community Supported Agriculture

  • 1.
  • 2.
    today’s outline • History andoverview of the farm • What is CCSA (customizable community supported agriculture) • How our farm does CCSA • Case study 1 (JBG Organics) • Case Study 2 (Wishing Stone Farm) • Questions
  • 3.
  • 4.
    KFF’s Mission Provide thebest produce possible to our customers at a fair price Provide a good income for the farmer - and good life- we need to love what we do Provide a fair wage to employees
  • 7.
  • 15.
  • 16.
    25-30 Acres inCover Crop
  • 18.
    Land and Soilprofile Soil type Crops Acres stays dry, early and late greens, melons, tomatoes, stony 4 Hamlin Silt loam root crops, great for radishes, beets, carrots- no stones 8 Hartland sandy loam class 1,general purpose, no stones 4 Vergennes Silty Clay somewhat heavy, winter squash, brassicas, spinach, beans 5 Hoosick Gravelly sandy Loam Sweet potato heaven... 1 Bernardston-shaly silt loams
  • 19.
    8 full timeemployees, 3 interns
  • 20.
  • 21.
  • 22.
  • 23.
    over 30 cropsfor the Christmas market 9 greens Lettuce Mix Mesclun Mix Spinach baby spinach Arugula Kale Swiss chard braising mix bunched turnips
  • 24.
    250 member Freechoice,Year-round CSA
  • 28.
    3 acres ofmulched crops
  • 35.
    5 row system 5rows for spinach, radish, salad, other small crops (9”) 3 rows beets, carrots, beans (18”) 2 rows broccoli, cauliflower, potatoes (36”) 1 row tomatoes, artichokes (72”) (plasticulture)
  • 37.
  • 39.
    FMC carrot andbeet harvester
  • 44.
    55 tons ofRoot Storage
  • 48.
  • 49.
    How is CSAchanging • CSA Market getting more crowded, more farms • Large players entering the field (full circle, 40,000 members) • Consumers have wide variety of sources for purchasing local/organic produce • The consumer is changing as well as we’re looking to reach a wider audience….
  • 50.
    Who is your consumer? Mcdonalds Junkie startingto think about it Health conscious drinks only soda drinks diet or vitamin water drinks straight water kids birthday party is at Burger King owns and may use cookbooks Has only “healthy” cookbooks in the kitchen Eco earth-muffin Tree-hugger Drinks raw milk Drinks raw milk kefir excessively Nourishing traditions is sole cookbook is head of her Weston a Price chapter and soaks nuts nuts drives an SUV is concerned about climate change kids get vitamins thinks local or buys corn from Shops at the organic food is a the conventional farmers market scam road-side stand Questions homebirths and immunizing kids breastfeeds kids buys 2 veggie, 1 has tried a CSA meat, and a raw in the past milk share….
  • 51.
    Who is your consumer? Mcdonalds Junkie startingto think about it Health conscious Eco earth-muffin Tree-hugger drinks only soda drinks diet or vitamin water drinks straight water Drinks raw milk Drinks raw milk kefir excessively owns and may use cookbooks Has only “healthy” cookbooks in the kitchen is concerned about climate change kids get vitamins kids birthday party is at Burger King drives an SUV thinks local or buys corn from Shops at the organic food is a the conventional farmers market scam road-side stand Market penetratio is head of her Nourishing n Weston a Price traditions is sole chapter and cookbook with ferments nuts normal Questions homebirths and CSA immunizing kids breastfeeds kids share buys 2 veggie, 1 has tried a CSA meat, and a raw in the past milk share….
  • 52.
    Who is your consumer? Mcdonalds Junkie startingto think about it Health conscious Eco earth-muffin Tree-hugger drinks only soda drinks diet or vitamin water drinks straight water Drinks raw milk Drinks raw milk kefir excessively kids birthday party is at Burger King drives an SUV owns and may use cookbooks is concerned about climate change Market Has only Nourishing penetration “healthy” traditions is sole cookbooks in cookbook with the kitchen CCSA Questions share!!!! kids kids get vitamins immunizing thinks local or buys corn from Shops at the organic food is a the conventional farmers market scam road-side stand is head of her Weston a Price chapter and ferments nuts homebirths and breastfeeds kids buys 2 veggie, 1 has tried a CSA meat, and a raw in the past milk share….
  • 53.
    Common Barriers toCSA • Too much or too weird food (not everyone likes kohlrabi or black spanish radishes • I don’t like beets, cauliflower, brussel sprouts- picky consumers and their kids • time/date not conducive to ease of pickup. • produce not like the grocery store- bunch/size different
  • 54.
  • 56.
    Common barriers forfarmers • not automating the system…. poor organization will kill you. • There is a higher cost associated with this.. so charge more • having to provide variety all the time. • if share is picked at site(not predetermined) , less sales efficiency (more waste)
  • 57.
    Customizable basics- what doesthis look like? • Customer picks up at a site where they can swap out items in their share for more appealing ones • Customer uses up pre-purchased credit (dollar amount or points) at a farmstand, farmer’s market or other site. • Customer can shop online for the items that they want in their share and a partially or fully customized share is delivered
  • 58.
    Customer picks upat FM or site where they pick out their share
  • 59.
    Do you includeeverything? • What about high-value crops such as Greenhouse tomatoes, Strawberries. • For us at Farmers markets those “first fruits” are often big money makers • We have chosen to make those worth more for our CSA (one tomato, limit one pint strawberry, etc) • Have swap bin where if a customer can’s use or doesn’t want an item they can swap it out with another member
  • 60.
    Point system • members get20, 30 or 40 points a week • Can fluctuate during season as the bounty comes in • different number points for produce, eggs, chicken baked goods) • works well for members with dietary restrictions.
  • 61.
    Debit card system • usinga custom POS (point-of-sale)system to track customer purchases • or a giant filebox with each customer on a 4X6 index card (I would do iPad and google doc) • Credit expires at end of year. Or not.
  • 62.
    Sources for cards/readers • square(gift card module coming soon) • chargeanywhere.com (readers) • plasticresource.com • duracard.com http://marcelbrown.comphoto
  • 63.
    Web placed, farmfilled shares • least waste, shares are harvested/filled after amounts known. • Must have a strong software program in place to make it work smoothly • Ultimate control, you decide what to offer
  • 64.
    What program touse? • super small CSA’s may want to do all communication by blog and email. • We have used Google forms or Wofoo for smaller items. • Large CSA’s may want to use Zen cart, a custom software solution, or Small Farm Central’s shopping cart software,.
  • 65.
    Setting up agood online store • Allows complete customization (or not) • intuitive for customer as well as farmer • can easily export data to usable pick/pack sheets • beware of % use models (you pay % of sales)
  • 69.
    How we doCSA Our CSA is a free-choice share, in which the customer picks most of their share right up off the market table. We usually select 1 item per week the members have to take. We also deliver Boxed (none-customized) shares to business drop sites
  • 73.
    Year- Round CSA Sellroot crops, onions, squash, frozen foods!!! Helps to have greens keep customers year-round year-round members are best cheerleaders you are on the road during the worst time of the year
  • 74.
    Shares we Offer JAN FEB MAR APR MAYJUNE JULY AUG SEP SUMMER (26 WINTER (17 wks) wks) FULL YEAR (52 weeks) OCT NOV DEC FALL (9 wks)
  • 75.
    2 SIZES OFSHARES FULL (6-9 items) $25 per week -we say will feed a family of 4 MICRO (4-6 items) $17 per week -will feed a couple or vegetarian single
  • 76.
    Share types Year-Round Share SummerShare Fall Share Winter/Spring Share Skidmore share
  • 78.
    Cancellation Policy A 2-weektrial period is offered to confirm the suitability, as we understand a CSA Membership is not for everyone and every situation. We will give a prorated refund during the first or second week of that specific CSA Season (Summer, Fall, Winter or Year-Round). Please allow two to four weeks for your refund. After two pickups refunds will be granted if we have a waiting list and can find a new member to take your place. Thank you for your understanding.
  • 79.
    Advantages of freechoiceCSA don’t have to have 250 items of 6 + crops per week we reach wider audience and edge over competition still allows us to move extra crop each week We don’t have to have the same items for every pickup/market very busy market stand
  • 80.
    Disadvantages of freechoiceCSA specialty crops aren’t available for retail (early tomatoes, strawberries) wide variety of crops necessary all the time (harvest inefficiency) Very busy market stand! have to watch quantities
  • 81.
    CSA management at KFF Farmer CSAcoordinator bookkeeper
  • 82.
    Farmer’s responsibilities Strategic meetingswith other management to plan upcoming season All production aspects, planning, seeding, harvesting, sending to market Face, or rainmaker of the farm.
  • 83.
    Planning the CCSA Wegrow a wide variety of crops to support our Farmer’s markets and wholesale already We started small with the CCSA and grew it based on feedback every year- 2012 we grew too quickly Some markets just don’t have some crops We spend a lot of time planning…
  • 84.
    Planning the CCSA Wegrow a wide variety of crops to support our Farmer’s markets and wholesale already We started small with the CCSA and grew it based on feedback every year- 2012 we grew too quickly Some markets just don’t have some crops
  • 86.
    CSA coordinator responsibilities all memberinquiries organizing bulk product sales (tomatoes, cucumbers, etc) CSA software setup and maintenance marketing emails
  • 87.
    Bookkeeper responsibilities applying payments helping memberssetup payment plans tracking expenses/profits of the CSA
  • 88.
    Check out informationonline www.michael-kilpatrick.com/csa-scho Member Agreement CSA handbook 2011, 12, 13 master plans Sample recipe cards CSA calendar CSA surveys
  • 89.
    Localvore club card • Boughtin the spring with our CSA shares • Usable for anything on the farm eggs, chickens, frozen foods • Customers get 5% off - pay $95 for a $100 card
  • 91.
    Other systems wehave played with…. • Home delivery, with orders placed through a % CSA service • Mini-store added on- dairy products, eggs, olive oil, etc • Orders delivered to a hospital, with semicustomization through email • Adding frozen vegetables to Shares (Pesto, Frozen or dried tomatoes, eggs when abundant)
  • 100.
    Foxy shopping cartwith custom back end • 2000 member CSA • 20 farmers markets weekly • Wholesale into a 5 hour radius (17 M) • right now customer can select between 4 different box sizes. And can swap out unwanted items at the farmers market pickup
  • 101.
    Customizable CSA atJBG • Software is being built and is completely custom • truck has to be loaded in reverse of how you want to pull shares out • at the start, customer will be able pick several of their items, by summer it will hopefully be completely customizable.
  • 119.
    Debit-card CCSA System • Customersbuy in winter at decreasing credit levels (get 10% extra January, 8% extra Feb, etc) • Cards are kept at markets in a file box • After card is used at market or farm, credit is subtracted from card • What members have left on Oct 31st goes to help fund food bank.
  • 123.
    Takeaways • CCSA can helpyou reach new customers and increased overall vegetable efficiency (customers throw away less). • CCSA is doable, although there are a lot more decisions to make • CCSA requires efficiencies and figuring mechanics • Invest in software and hardware to make your transition easier.
  • 124.