Critical                 Investigation By: Yusra K
Critical Investigation Question:Why do music videos construct certain narratives around female artists?&To what extent is this being challenged by contemporary female artists?
Point1:Discuses of the different narratives constructed around female artists in music videos:WHY are they constructed this way: Appeal to audience/ Laura Maulvey 'Male Gaze'/patriarchal society/male dominated industry
Point 2: Effects on audience: How and Why?Relevant theory’s that relate to the topic:David Gauntlett- Gender identity, lifestyle Laura Mulvey- Visual pleasure and narrative cinema.Gaye Tuchman- symbolic annihilation of women Antonio- Gramsci-HegemonyJudith Butler- Gender as performance
Point 3:How has this been challenged by contemporary female artists? such as (Lady Gaga and Pink)
Point 4:What type of changes has been made and does it have any issues and debates surrounding the changes or artists.
Point 5: Discuss the success of women (female artists) in today’s society:• What has been achieved and consider whether it’s negative or positive.Articles:Positive:http://www.nowmagazine.co.uk/celebrity-news/505923/lady-gaga-to-get-8-madame-tussauds-wax-figures/1/   ‘iconic’/significant to society’http://www.nowmagazine.co.uk/celebrity-news/505857/lady-gaga-wins-3-mtv-ema-prizes/1/ ‘Gaga won awards’ Negative: http://www.media-awareness.ca/english/issues/stereotyping/women_and_girls/Arguable: http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/1107540/the_portrayal_of_women_in_music_videos.htmlhttp://www.suite101.com/content/media-portrayal-of-women-a189870
Representation in music videos Used as a decorationSexually objectifiedDegraded  Subordinated Exploitation of female body to please men!
Audience + Audience TheoryA wide range of audiences. Demographics: C1,C2,D,EYoung girls: (idolize / inspiration)Cultivation / hypodermic needleCopycat / desensitization.Judith B– ‘Fix Gender roles’ or stereotypes   Gaga  copy's one of Madonna's many images during her dance sequence in prison from the ‘Telephone’ song.  (Copycat)
Theorists Quotes: ‘Women as images. Men as bearer of the look’ –Laura Mulvey.Rise in ‘Girl Power’. OR ‘The number of housewives in advertising began to decrease after the 1950’s’.- David Gauntlett.  Female are represented far less than men’.-Gaye Tuchman‘the matter of representation determines how we are seen or treated in society’. – Richard Dyer‘Identities are the names we give to the different  ways we are positioned and position ourselves within that narrative od the past’- Stuart hall
S.H.E.PSocial- change in attitude in society are taken place. Historical-Throughout history and even today we see women who need/feel to dress and act a certain way or they will not be accepted by men and the rest of society.Economical-The artist wants to make money, the producers, the writers, the dancers; they all want to make money.”- people will do anything if they get enough money. Political-?
Contemporary media landscape  Media industry is mostly owned by men. (male dominated industry).David Gauntlett: rise in ‘Girl Power’.Covers the HOW and WHY.Contemporary issues in society. (body image)(stereotyped)
Analysis of contemporary artists: Alejandro
Analysis of contemporary artistsSo What!
Linked Production • A short advert (moving image)Interview with a up coming female star (moving image) A magazine cover (photo shoot)Opening sequence that challenge the stereotypical representation of women.
Bibliography:Media Studies AS & A2 Bookhttp://www.nowmagazine.co.uk/celebrity-news/505923/lady-gaga-to-get-8-madame-tussauds-wax-figures/1/http://www.nowmagazine.co.uk/celebrity-news/505857/lady-gaga-wins-3-mtv-ema-prizes/1/http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/1107540/the_portrayal_of_women_in_music_videos.htmlhttp://www.suite101.com/content/media-portrayal-of-women-a189870http://www.media-awareness.ca/english/issues/stereotyping/women_and_girls/

Critical investigation!

  • 1.
    Critical Investigation By: Yusra K
  • 2.
    Critical Investigation Question:Whydo music videos construct certain narratives around female artists?&To what extent is this being challenged by contemporary female artists?
  • 3.
    Point1:Discuses of thedifferent narratives constructed around female artists in music videos:WHY are they constructed this way: Appeal to audience/ Laura Maulvey 'Male Gaze'/patriarchal society/male dominated industry
  • 4.
    Point 2: Effectson audience: How and Why?Relevant theory’s that relate to the topic:David Gauntlett- Gender identity, lifestyle Laura Mulvey- Visual pleasure and narrative cinema.Gaye Tuchman- symbolic annihilation of women Antonio- Gramsci-HegemonyJudith Butler- Gender as performance
  • 5.
    Point 3:How hasthis been challenged by contemporary female artists? such as (Lady Gaga and Pink)
  • 6.
    Point 4:What typeof changes has been made and does it have any issues and debates surrounding the changes or artists.
  • 7.
    Point 5: Discussthe success of women (female artists) in today’s society:• What has been achieved and consider whether it’s negative or positive.Articles:Positive:http://www.nowmagazine.co.uk/celebrity-news/505923/lady-gaga-to-get-8-madame-tussauds-wax-figures/1/ ‘iconic’/significant to society’http://www.nowmagazine.co.uk/celebrity-news/505857/lady-gaga-wins-3-mtv-ema-prizes/1/ ‘Gaga won awards’ Negative: http://www.media-awareness.ca/english/issues/stereotyping/women_and_girls/Arguable: http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/1107540/the_portrayal_of_women_in_music_videos.htmlhttp://www.suite101.com/content/media-portrayal-of-women-a189870
  • 8.
    Representation in musicvideos Used as a decorationSexually objectifiedDegraded Subordinated Exploitation of female body to please men!
  • 9.
    Audience + AudienceTheoryA wide range of audiences. Demographics: C1,C2,D,EYoung girls: (idolize / inspiration)Cultivation / hypodermic needleCopycat / desensitization.Judith B– ‘Fix Gender roles’ or stereotypes Gaga copy's one of Madonna's many images during her dance sequence in prison from the ‘Telephone’ song.  (Copycat)
  • 10.
    Theorists Quotes: ‘Womenas images. Men as bearer of the look’ –Laura Mulvey.Rise in ‘Girl Power’. OR ‘The number of housewives in advertising began to decrease after the 1950’s’.- David Gauntlett. Female are represented far less than men’.-Gaye Tuchman‘the matter of representation determines how we are seen or treated in society’. – Richard Dyer‘Identities are the names we give to the different ways we are positioned and position ourselves within that narrative od the past’- Stuart hall
  • 11.
    S.H.E.PSocial- change inattitude in society are taken place. Historical-Throughout history and even today we see women who need/feel to dress and act a certain way or they will not be accepted by men and the rest of society.Economical-The artist wants to make money, the producers, the writers, the dancers; they all want to make money.”- people will do anything if they get enough money. Political-?
  • 12.
    Contemporary media landscape Media industry is mostly owned by men. (male dominated industry).David Gauntlett: rise in ‘Girl Power’.Covers the HOW and WHY.Contemporary issues in society. (body image)(stereotyped)
  • 13.
    Analysis of contemporaryartists: Alejandro
  • 14.
  • 15.
    Linked Production •A short advert (moving image)Interview with a up coming female star (moving image) A magazine cover (photo shoot)Opening sequence that challenge the stereotypical representation of women.
  • 16.
    Bibliography:Media Studies AS& A2 Bookhttp://www.nowmagazine.co.uk/celebrity-news/505923/lady-gaga-to-get-8-madame-tussauds-wax-figures/1/http://www.nowmagazine.co.uk/celebrity-news/505857/lady-gaga-wins-3-mtv-ema-prizes/1/http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/1107540/the_portrayal_of_women_in_music_videos.htmlhttp://www.suite101.com/content/media-portrayal-of-women-a189870http://www.media-awareness.ca/english/issues/stereotyping/women_and_girls/