1) A high school student was suspended for 10 days for creating a "Top 10" list ridiculing his school's athletic director that he wrote and emailed at home to other students. 2) The student sued the school district alleging violation of his free speech and due process rights. 3) The US District Court ruled in favor of the student, finding that the list did not disrupt school operations and the school's policy against abuse was overly broad and vague. The court set boundaries for what speech a school can punish.