SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Competition from honey
bees on wild bees
- effects, knowledge gaps and interventions
SANDRA LINDSTRÖM, CENTRE FOR ENVIRONMENTAL AND
CLIMATE SCIENCE
Status and trends for wild bees
• 1/3 of the 299 wild bee species is on the swedish red-list
• Indications that many species' populations are declining nationally
- Ranges are greatly reduced
• Specialists are over-represented
• Arable and urban landscapes
• Several causes, lack of forage potentially one
(Borgström m.fl. 2018. Pollinatörer och pollinering i Sverige – värden, förutsättningar och påverkansfaktorer. Naturvårdsverket)
Number of honey bee hives
(Potts m.fl. 2010. Journal of Apicultural Research)
(IBPES 2016 chapter 3)
Year 2019: 160 000-170 000 honey bee hives in Sweden
(SJV, 2019. Det ekonomiska värdet av honungsbin i Sverige)
2019
Food resource competition
(Mallinger et al. 2017)
When does competition between bees
have negative effects on the long-term
development of populations?
(Kleijn et al. 2018, Science)
Bees have a lot in common
-
Joint efforts to benefit the bees have
greater potential to be successful!
Records identified in
data base search:
(n=891)
Title and abstract
screening
(n=875)
Full-text screening
(n=609)
Exkluded records,
based on criteria
(n=266)
Exkluded records,
based on criteria
(n=549)
Duplicates excluded
(n=14)
For analysis
(n=57)
European empirical
records
(n=33)
Systematic map of the
European empirical
evidence
NO
IMPACT
Wild bees
Honey bees
Floral resource
overlap
Unchanged wild
bee visitation
rate
Reduced wild
bee visitation
rate
Unchanged
resource
harvest
Reduced
resource
harvest
Alternative
floral
resource
Reduced
survival
Reduced
fecundity
Reduced
population
size/extinction
NEGATIVE
IMPACT
(Following Fig. 1 in Paini et al. 2004)
Competition mechanisms
Empirical evidence for competition
• 24 reviews & 33 empirical European studies
- Floral resource overlap
- Effects on foraging and resource intake
- Effects on densities and diversity
- Effects on reproduction and survival
Negative effects shown on several aspecs of wild bees resources, foraging and
abundance.
Lack of strong evidence on effects on reproduction, survival and populations.
Empirical findings
Critical levels of honey bees:
Few studies, depends on flower resource availability.
Modifying factors:
A few studies on landscape character and flower resource availability.
Sensitive species and species traits.
Number of wild bee species that has foraging
overlap in % with honey bees in intervals of 10
Rasmussen C, Dupont YL, Madsen HB, Bogusch P, Goulson D, et al. (2021) Evaluating competition for forage plants between honey bees and wild bees in Denmark. PLOS ONE 16(4): e0250056.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0250056
https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0250056
Competition from a Swedish perspective
• Generally low densities of honey bees (0,4 honey bee hives per km2)
• Average European density (4,2 honey bee hives per km2)
• But ~70% of the Swedish honey bee hives is in the south of Sweden
• Batavsandbi Andrena batava, fältsandbi A. morawitzi are oligolectic
on sälg Salix and red-listed species.
• A danish study identified that the red listed bees Vialsandbi Andrena
lathyri, monkesolbi Dufourea halictula, klocksolbi Dufourea inermis,
stengnagbi Hoplitis anthocopoides guldbyxbi Dasypoda suripes had
very large (>90%) overlap with honey bees. (Rasmussen et al. 2021)
Potential interventions
Suggestions:
- Increase floral resources (no studies)
- Adjust the distance to protected areas (Henry & Rodet 2020)
- Adjust densities or avoid honeybees in protected areas
- Apply the precautionary principle in areas with threatened wild bee species (Mallinger et al. 2017)
- or threatened wild bee species with high overlap with honey bees (Rasmussen et al. 2021)
Evaluation tools:
- “HUM” – Hive units monthly (Cane & Tepedino 2017)
- Parameterized models (Sörensen et al. 2020)
- “AIR” – Apiary Influence Range (Henry & Rodet 2020)
Knowledge gaps
• More studies on reproduction and survival are needed for more species
• Context dependent effects
- Honey bee distances and densities
- Floral resource availability
- Networks of wild bees and plants
- Spatial and temporal scales
- Interactions with nest sites
- Interaction with other stressors, e.g. pesticides
• What regulates bee populations? How important is competition in relation to other
threats?
Summary
• Plenty of studies relating to food choices and abundance
- mixed effects
• Few studies examine effects on reproduction - the
knowledge gaps are large
• Long-term effects studies - completely missing
• Species specific studies – lacking
• Correlative studies – weak evidence
• WANTED: Experimental, well-replicated studies with
controls, several levels of honey bee densities and
floral resources measuring reproduction.
Extra slides
Photo: Mårten Sjöbeck. 1934… … 90 years later
Spjutstorp 1940 Spjutstorp 2014
Altered landscapes
Nectar availability in relation to bumble bee needs over the season
on four british farms
Journal of Applied Ecology, Volume: 56, Issue: 7, Pages: 1585-1596, First published: 19 April 2019, DOI: (10.1111/1365-2664.13403)
Heterogeneous landscape
Small scales
More flowers
Short distances between nest-sites and flowers
More homogenous landscape
Larger scale
Fewer flowers
Longer distances between nest-sites and flowers

More Related Content

What's hot

Multiple stressors
Multiple stressorsMultiple stressors
Multiple stressors
EFSA EU
 
Sub-lethal effects of neonicotinoids under different climate conditions_Nielsen
Sub-lethal effects of neonicotinoids under different climate conditions_NielsenSub-lethal effects of neonicotinoids under different climate conditions_Nielsen
Sub-lethal effects of neonicotinoids under different climate conditions_Nielsen
La Humla Suse
 
Data publication presentation at SIL2013
Data publication presentation at SIL2013Data publication presentation at SIL2013
Data publication presentation at SIL2013
Aaike De Wever
 
EOL in context
EOL in contextEOL in context
EOL in context
Cyndy Parr
 
2014 esa brewsternotes8042014
2014 esa brewsternotes80420142014 esa brewsternotes8042014
2014 esa brewsternotes8042014
Connie Rinaldo
 
Botany Resources @ Warner Memorial Library
Botany Resources @ Warner Memorial LibraryBotany Resources @ Warner Memorial Library
Botany Resources @ Warner Memorial Library
Warner Memorial Library
 
Encyclopedia of Life: Use cases for phenotypes
Encyclopedia of Life: Use cases for phenotypesEncyclopedia of Life: Use cases for phenotypes
Encyclopedia of Life: Use cases for phenotypesCyndy Parr
 
Missouri China Programme: Science Communication
Missouri China Programme: Science CommunicationMissouri China Programme: Science Communication
Missouri China Programme: Science Communication
Global Plant Council
 
Session 06, Introduction to biodiversity sample-based data publishing at the ...
Session 06, Introduction to biodiversity sample-based data publishing at the ...Session 06, Introduction to biodiversity sample-based data publishing at the ...
Session 06, Introduction to biodiversity sample-based data publishing at the ...
Alberto González-Talaván
 
Presentazione Slope by boku
Presentazione Slope by bokuPresentazione Slope by boku
Presentazione Slope by bokuSLOPE Project
 
Kavana rangeland society presentation
Kavana rangeland society presentationKavana rangeland society presentation
Kavana rangeland society presentation
Pius Kavana
 
iEvoBio Keynote: Frontiers of discovery with Encyclopedia of Life -- TRAITBANK
iEvoBio Keynote: Frontiers of discovery with Encyclopedia of Life -- TRAITBANK iEvoBio Keynote: Frontiers of discovery with Encyclopedia of Life -- TRAITBANK
iEvoBio Keynote: Frontiers of discovery with Encyclopedia of Life -- TRAITBANK
Cyndy Parr
 

What's hot (13)

Multiple stressors
Multiple stressorsMultiple stressors
Multiple stressors
 
Sub-lethal effects of neonicotinoids under different climate conditions_Nielsen
Sub-lethal effects of neonicotinoids under different climate conditions_NielsenSub-lethal effects of neonicotinoids under different climate conditions_Nielsen
Sub-lethal effects of neonicotinoids under different climate conditions_Nielsen
 
Data publication presentation at SIL2013
Data publication presentation at SIL2013Data publication presentation at SIL2013
Data publication presentation at SIL2013
 
EOL in context
EOL in contextEOL in context
EOL in context
 
2014 esa brewsternotes8042014
2014 esa brewsternotes80420142014 esa brewsternotes8042014
2014 esa brewsternotes8042014
 
Botany Resources @ Warner Memorial Library
Botany Resources @ Warner Memorial LibraryBotany Resources @ Warner Memorial Library
Botany Resources @ Warner Memorial Library
 
Encyclopedia of Life: Use cases for phenotypes
Encyclopedia of Life: Use cases for phenotypesEncyclopedia of Life: Use cases for phenotypes
Encyclopedia of Life: Use cases for phenotypes
 
Missouri China Programme: Science Communication
Missouri China Programme: Science CommunicationMissouri China Programme: Science Communication
Missouri China Programme: Science Communication
 
Session 06, Introduction to biodiversity sample-based data publishing at the ...
Session 06, Introduction to biodiversity sample-based data publishing at the ...Session 06, Introduction to biodiversity sample-based data publishing at the ...
Session 06, Introduction to biodiversity sample-based data publishing at the ...
 
Presentazione Slope by boku
Presentazione Slope by bokuPresentazione Slope by boku
Presentazione Slope by boku
 
Kavana rangeland society presentation
Kavana rangeland society presentationKavana rangeland society presentation
Kavana rangeland society presentation
 
jackals
jackalsjackals
jackals
 
iEvoBio Keynote: Frontiers of discovery with Encyclopedia of Life -- TRAITBANK
iEvoBio Keynote: Frontiers of discovery with Encyclopedia of Life -- TRAITBANK iEvoBio Keynote: Frontiers of discovery with Encyclopedia of Life -- TRAITBANK
iEvoBio Keynote: Frontiers of discovery with Encyclopedia of Life -- TRAITBANK
 

Similar to Competition from honey bees on wild bees_Lindström

how to read a scientific paper.pdf
how to read a scientific paper.pdfhow to read a scientific paper.pdf
how to read a scientific paper.pdf
ChristianMartinezSan1
 
Examining the spatial distribution pattern and optimum sample size for monito...
Examining the spatial distribution pattern and optimum sample size for monito...Examining the spatial distribution pattern and optimum sample size for monito...
Examining the spatial distribution pattern and optimum sample size for monito...
AI Publications
 
Pollinators and infrastructure - Johan Rydlov
Pollinators and infrastructure - Johan RydlovPollinators and infrastructure - Johan Rydlov
Pollinators and infrastructure - Johan Rydlov
La Humla Suse
 
Seminar on Forest and Plant Health_Abstracts.pdf
Seminar on Forest and Plant Health_Abstracts.pdfSeminar on Forest and Plant Health_Abstracts.pdf
Seminar on Forest and Plant Health_Abstracts.pdf
Natural Resources Institute Finland (Luke) / Luonnonvarakeskus (Luke)
 
Seminar on forest and plant health 10032021 abstracts
Seminar on forest and plant health 10032021 abstractsSeminar on forest and plant health 10032021 abstracts
Seminar on forest and plant health 10032021 abstracts
Natural Resources Institute Finland (Luke) / Luonnonvarakeskus (Luke)
 
An Analysis of Possible Causes of Worldwide Apis
An Analysis of Possible Causes of Worldwide ApisAn Analysis of Possible Causes of Worldwide Apis
An Analysis of Possible Causes of Worldwide ApisJonathan Spence
 
Simultaneous pollinator occurence (hymenoptera, agaoninae) in a threatened sp...
Simultaneous pollinator occurence (hymenoptera, agaoninae) in a threatened sp...Simultaneous pollinator occurence (hymenoptera, agaoninae) in a threatened sp...
Simultaneous pollinator occurence (hymenoptera, agaoninae) in a threatened sp...
Robert Mts
 
ES_COMMUNICATION_2014_9_Mick_20141214
ES_COMMUNICATION_2014_9_Mick_20141214ES_COMMUNICATION_2014_9_Mick_20141214
ES_COMMUNICATION_2014_9_Mick_20141214Michael Manton
 
The SLU and CIAT-TSBF collaboration
The SLU and CIAT-TSBF collaborationThe SLU and CIAT-TSBF collaboration
The SLU and CIAT-TSBF collaboration
CIAT
 
EuFMDiS Meetings 01/2020 - Wild boar distribution maps for Spain + Contact be...
EuFMDiS Meetings 01/2020 - Wild boar distribution maps for Spain + Contact be...EuFMDiS Meetings 01/2020 - Wild boar distribution maps for Spain + Contact be...
EuFMDiS Meetings 01/2020 - Wild boar distribution maps for Spain + Contact be...
EuFMD
 
Ecological indicators
Ecological indicatorsEcological indicators
Ecological indicators
GreengoldMongolia
 
Tree diversityday2012 looj.pptx
Tree diversityday2012 looj.pptxTree diversityday2012 looj.pptx
Tree diversityday2012 looj.pptx
World Agroforestry (ICRAF)
 
Food security and nutrition: The role of forests
Food security and nutrition: The role of forestsFood security and nutrition: The role of forests
Food security and nutrition: The role of forests
IIED
 
PGR (plant genetic resources) Secure project
PGR (plant genetic resources) Secure project PGR (plant genetic resources) Secure project
PGR (plant genetic resources) Secure project
tarbiat modares university
 
CESAB-Disco-Weed-sfe2018
CESAB-Disco-Weed-sfe2018CESAB-Disco-Weed-sfe2018
CESAB-Disco-Weed-sfe2018
CESAB-FRB
 
bird and mammal biodiversity SW Ethiopia, Patricia, Jimma 2018
bird and mammal biodiversity SW Ethiopia, Patricia, Jimma 2018bird and mammal biodiversity SW Ethiopia, Patricia, Jimma 2018
bird and mammal biodiversity SW Ethiopia, Patricia, Jimma 2018
joernfischer
 
Farming and the geography of nutrient production for human use: a transdiscip...
Farming and the geography of nutrient production for human use: a transdiscip...Farming and the geography of nutrient production for human use: a transdiscip...
Farming and the geography of nutrient production for human use: a transdiscip...
CCAFS | CGIAR Research Program on Climate Change, Agriculture and Food Security
 
Seminar on Forest Pathology Abstracts (November 2nd, 2017)
Seminar on Forest Pathology Abstracts (November 2nd, 2017)Seminar on Forest Pathology Abstracts (November 2nd, 2017)
Seminar on Forest Pathology Abstracts (November 2nd, 2017)
Natural Resources Institute Finland (Luke) / Luonnonvarakeskus (Luke)
 
Benefits Over Traditional Wired Sensing Technology
Benefits Over Traditional Wired Sensing TechnologyBenefits Over Traditional Wired Sensing Technology
Benefits Over Traditional Wired Sensing Technology
Christina Valadez
 

Similar to Competition from honey bees on wild bees_Lindström (20)

how to read a scientific paper.pdf
how to read a scientific paper.pdfhow to read a scientific paper.pdf
how to read a scientific paper.pdf
 
Examining the spatial distribution pattern and optimum sample size for monito...
Examining the spatial distribution pattern and optimum sample size for monito...Examining the spatial distribution pattern and optimum sample size for monito...
Examining the spatial distribution pattern and optimum sample size for monito...
 
Pollinators and infrastructure - Johan Rydlov
Pollinators and infrastructure - Johan RydlovPollinators and infrastructure - Johan Rydlov
Pollinators and infrastructure - Johan Rydlov
 
Seminar on Forest and Plant Health_Abstracts.pdf
Seminar on Forest and Plant Health_Abstracts.pdfSeminar on Forest and Plant Health_Abstracts.pdf
Seminar on Forest and Plant Health_Abstracts.pdf
 
Seminar on forest and plant health 10032021 abstracts
Seminar on forest and plant health 10032021 abstractsSeminar on forest and plant health 10032021 abstracts
Seminar on forest and plant health 10032021 abstracts
 
An Analysis of Possible Causes of Worldwide Apis
An Analysis of Possible Causes of Worldwide ApisAn Analysis of Possible Causes of Worldwide Apis
An Analysis of Possible Causes of Worldwide Apis
 
Simultaneous pollinator occurence (hymenoptera, agaoninae) in a threatened sp...
Simultaneous pollinator occurence (hymenoptera, agaoninae) in a threatened sp...Simultaneous pollinator occurence (hymenoptera, agaoninae) in a threatened sp...
Simultaneous pollinator occurence (hymenoptera, agaoninae) in a threatened sp...
 
SeniorCapstone_DiTullio
SeniorCapstone_DiTullio SeniorCapstone_DiTullio
SeniorCapstone_DiTullio
 
ES_COMMUNICATION_2014_9_Mick_20141214
ES_COMMUNICATION_2014_9_Mick_20141214ES_COMMUNICATION_2014_9_Mick_20141214
ES_COMMUNICATION_2014_9_Mick_20141214
 
The SLU and CIAT-TSBF collaboration
The SLU and CIAT-TSBF collaborationThe SLU and CIAT-TSBF collaboration
The SLU and CIAT-TSBF collaboration
 
EuFMDiS Meetings 01/2020 - Wild boar distribution maps for Spain + Contact be...
EuFMDiS Meetings 01/2020 - Wild boar distribution maps for Spain + Contact be...EuFMDiS Meetings 01/2020 - Wild boar distribution maps for Spain + Contact be...
EuFMDiS Meetings 01/2020 - Wild boar distribution maps for Spain + Contact be...
 
Ecological indicators
Ecological indicatorsEcological indicators
Ecological indicators
 
Tree diversityday2012 looj.pptx
Tree diversityday2012 looj.pptxTree diversityday2012 looj.pptx
Tree diversityday2012 looj.pptx
 
Food security and nutrition: The role of forests
Food security and nutrition: The role of forestsFood security and nutrition: The role of forests
Food security and nutrition: The role of forests
 
PGR (plant genetic resources) Secure project
PGR (plant genetic resources) Secure project PGR (plant genetic resources) Secure project
PGR (plant genetic resources) Secure project
 
CESAB-Disco-Weed-sfe2018
CESAB-Disco-Weed-sfe2018CESAB-Disco-Weed-sfe2018
CESAB-Disco-Weed-sfe2018
 
bird and mammal biodiversity SW Ethiopia, Patricia, Jimma 2018
bird and mammal biodiversity SW Ethiopia, Patricia, Jimma 2018bird and mammal biodiversity SW Ethiopia, Patricia, Jimma 2018
bird and mammal biodiversity SW Ethiopia, Patricia, Jimma 2018
 
Farming and the geography of nutrient production for human use: a transdiscip...
Farming and the geography of nutrient production for human use: a transdiscip...Farming and the geography of nutrient production for human use: a transdiscip...
Farming and the geography of nutrient production for human use: a transdiscip...
 
Seminar on Forest Pathology Abstracts (November 2nd, 2017)
Seminar on Forest Pathology Abstracts (November 2nd, 2017)Seminar on Forest Pathology Abstracts (November 2nd, 2017)
Seminar on Forest Pathology Abstracts (November 2nd, 2017)
 
Benefits Over Traditional Wired Sensing Technology
Benefits Over Traditional Wired Sensing TechnologyBenefits Over Traditional Wired Sensing Technology
Benefits Over Traditional Wired Sensing Technology
 

Recently uploaded

Mammalian Pineal Body Structure and Also Functions
Mammalian Pineal Body Structure and Also FunctionsMammalian Pineal Body Structure and Also Functions
Mammalian Pineal Body Structure and Also Functions
YOGESH DOGRA
 
erythropoiesis-I_mechanism& clinical significance.pptx
erythropoiesis-I_mechanism& clinical significance.pptxerythropoiesis-I_mechanism& clinical significance.pptx
erythropoiesis-I_mechanism& clinical significance.pptx
muralinath2
 
role of pramana in research.pptx in science
role of pramana in research.pptx in sciencerole of pramana in research.pptx in science
role of pramana in research.pptx in science
sonaliswain16
 
Structural Classification Of Protein (SCOP)
Structural Classification Of Protein  (SCOP)Structural Classification Of Protein  (SCOP)
Structural Classification Of Protein (SCOP)
aishnasrivastava
 
in vitro propagation of plants lecture note.pptx
in vitro propagation of plants lecture note.pptxin vitro propagation of plants lecture note.pptx
in vitro propagation of plants lecture note.pptx
yusufzako14
 
extra-chromosomal-inheritance[1].pptx.pdfpdf
extra-chromosomal-inheritance[1].pptx.pdfpdfextra-chromosomal-inheritance[1].pptx.pdfpdf
extra-chromosomal-inheritance[1].pptx.pdfpdf
DiyaBiswas10
 
THE IMPORTANCE OF MARTIAN ATMOSPHERE SAMPLE RETURN.
THE IMPORTANCE OF MARTIAN ATMOSPHERE SAMPLE RETURN.THE IMPORTANCE OF MARTIAN ATMOSPHERE SAMPLE RETURN.
THE IMPORTANCE OF MARTIAN ATMOSPHERE SAMPLE RETURN.
Sérgio Sacani
 
Lab report on liquid viscosity of glycerin
Lab report on liquid viscosity of glycerinLab report on liquid viscosity of glycerin
Lab report on liquid viscosity of glycerin
ossaicprecious19
 
insect taxonomy importance systematics and classification
insect taxonomy importance systematics and classificationinsect taxonomy importance systematics and classification
insect taxonomy importance systematics and classification
anitaento25
 
platelets_clotting_biogenesis.clot retractionpptx
platelets_clotting_biogenesis.clot retractionpptxplatelets_clotting_biogenesis.clot retractionpptx
platelets_clotting_biogenesis.clot retractionpptx
muralinath2
 
Lateral Ventricles.pdf very easy good diagrams comprehensive
Lateral Ventricles.pdf very easy good diagrams comprehensiveLateral Ventricles.pdf very easy good diagrams comprehensive
Lateral Ventricles.pdf very easy good diagrams comprehensive
silvermistyshot
 
NuGOweek 2024 Ghent - programme - final version
NuGOweek 2024 Ghent - programme - final versionNuGOweek 2024 Ghent - programme - final version
NuGOweek 2024 Ghent - programme - final version
pablovgd
 
general properties of oerganologametal.ppt
general properties of oerganologametal.pptgeneral properties of oerganologametal.ppt
general properties of oerganologametal.ppt
IqrimaNabilatulhusni
 
Multi-source connectivity as the driver of solar wind variability in the heli...
Multi-source connectivity as the driver of solar wind variability in the heli...Multi-source connectivity as the driver of solar wind variability in the heli...
Multi-source connectivity as the driver of solar wind variability in the heli...
Sérgio Sacani
 
Comparative structure of adrenal gland in vertebrates
Comparative structure of adrenal gland in vertebratesComparative structure of adrenal gland in vertebrates
Comparative structure of adrenal gland in vertebrates
sachin783648
 
Nucleic Acid-its structural and functional complexity.
Nucleic Acid-its structural and functional complexity.Nucleic Acid-its structural and functional complexity.
Nucleic Acid-its structural and functional complexity.
Nistarini College, Purulia (W.B) India
 
platelets- lifespan -Clot retraction-disorders.pptx
platelets- lifespan -Clot retraction-disorders.pptxplatelets- lifespan -Clot retraction-disorders.pptx
platelets- lifespan -Clot retraction-disorders.pptx
muralinath2
 
The ASGCT Annual Meeting was packed with exciting progress in the field advan...
The ASGCT Annual Meeting was packed with exciting progress in the field advan...The ASGCT Annual Meeting was packed with exciting progress in the field advan...
The ASGCT Annual Meeting was packed with exciting progress in the field advan...
Health Advances
 
Cancer cell metabolism: special Reference to Lactate Pathway
Cancer cell metabolism: special Reference to Lactate PathwayCancer cell metabolism: special Reference to Lactate Pathway
Cancer cell metabolism: special Reference to Lactate Pathway
AADYARAJPANDEY1
 
PRESENTATION ABOUT PRINCIPLE OF COSMATIC EVALUATION
PRESENTATION ABOUT PRINCIPLE OF COSMATIC EVALUATIONPRESENTATION ABOUT PRINCIPLE OF COSMATIC EVALUATION
PRESENTATION ABOUT PRINCIPLE OF COSMATIC EVALUATION
ChetanK57
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Mammalian Pineal Body Structure and Also Functions
Mammalian Pineal Body Structure and Also FunctionsMammalian Pineal Body Structure and Also Functions
Mammalian Pineal Body Structure and Also Functions
 
erythropoiesis-I_mechanism& clinical significance.pptx
erythropoiesis-I_mechanism& clinical significance.pptxerythropoiesis-I_mechanism& clinical significance.pptx
erythropoiesis-I_mechanism& clinical significance.pptx
 
role of pramana in research.pptx in science
role of pramana in research.pptx in sciencerole of pramana in research.pptx in science
role of pramana in research.pptx in science
 
Structural Classification Of Protein (SCOP)
Structural Classification Of Protein  (SCOP)Structural Classification Of Protein  (SCOP)
Structural Classification Of Protein (SCOP)
 
in vitro propagation of plants lecture note.pptx
in vitro propagation of plants lecture note.pptxin vitro propagation of plants lecture note.pptx
in vitro propagation of plants lecture note.pptx
 
extra-chromosomal-inheritance[1].pptx.pdfpdf
extra-chromosomal-inheritance[1].pptx.pdfpdfextra-chromosomal-inheritance[1].pptx.pdfpdf
extra-chromosomal-inheritance[1].pptx.pdfpdf
 
THE IMPORTANCE OF MARTIAN ATMOSPHERE SAMPLE RETURN.
THE IMPORTANCE OF MARTIAN ATMOSPHERE SAMPLE RETURN.THE IMPORTANCE OF MARTIAN ATMOSPHERE SAMPLE RETURN.
THE IMPORTANCE OF MARTIAN ATMOSPHERE SAMPLE RETURN.
 
Lab report on liquid viscosity of glycerin
Lab report on liquid viscosity of glycerinLab report on liquid viscosity of glycerin
Lab report on liquid viscosity of glycerin
 
insect taxonomy importance systematics and classification
insect taxonomy importance systematics and classificationinsect taxonomy importance systematics and classification
insect taxonomy importance systematics and classification
 
platelets_clotting_biogenesis.clot retractionpptx
platelets_clotting_biogenesis.clot retractionpptxplatelets_clotting_biogenesis.clot retractionpptx
platelets_clotting_biogenesis.clot retractionpptx
 
Lateral Ventricles.pdf very easy good diagrams comprehensive
Lateral Ventricles.pdf very easy good diagrams comprehensiveLateral Ventricles.pdf very easy good diagrams comprehensive
Lateral Ventricles.pdf very easy good diagrams comprehensive
 
NuGOweek 2024 Ghent - programme - final version
NuGOweek 2024 Ghent - programme - final versionNuGOweek 2024 Ghent - programme - final version
NuGOweek 2024 Ghent - programme - final version
 
general properties of oerganologametal.ppt
general properties of oerganologametal.pptgeneral properties of oerganologametal.ppt
general properties of oerganologametal.ppt
 
Multi-source connectivity as the driver of solar wind variability in the heli...
Multi-source connectivity as the driver of solar wind variability in the heli...Multi-source connectivity as the driver of solar wind variability in the heli...
Multi-source connectivity as the driver of solar wind variability in the heli...
 
Comparative structure of adrenal gland in vertebrates
Comparative structure of adrenal gland in vertebratesComparative structure of adrenal gland in vertebrates
Comparative structure of adrenal gland in vertebrates
 
Nucleic Acid-its structural and functional complexity.
Nucleic Acid-its structural and functional complexity.Nucleic Acid-its structural and functional complexity.
Nucleic Acid-its structural and functional complexity.
 
platelets- lifespan -Clot retraction-disorders.pptx
platelets- lifespan -Clot retraction-disorders.pptxplatelets- lifespan -Clot retraction-disorders.pptx
platelets- lifespan -Clot retraction-disorders.pptx
 
The ASGCT Annual Meeting was packed with exciting progress in the field advan...
The ASGCT Annual Meeting was packed with exciting progress in the field advan...The ASGCT Annual Meeting was packed with exciting progress in the field advan...
The ASGCT Annual Meeting was packed with exciting progress in the field advan...
 
Cancer cell metabolism: special Reference to Lactate Pathway
Cancer cell metabolism: special Reference to Lactate PathwayCancer cell metabolism: special Reference to Lactate Pathway
Cancer cell metabolism: special Reference to Lactate Pathway
 
PRESENTATION ABOUT PRINCIPLE OF COSMATIC EVALUATION
PRESENTATION ABOUT PRINCIPLE OF COSMATIC EVALUATIONPRESENTATION ABOUT PRINCIPLE OF COSMATIC EVALUATION
PRESENTATION ABOUT PRINCIPLE OF COSMATIC EVALUATION
 

Competition from honey bees on wild bees_Lindström

  • 1. Competition from honey bees on wild bees - effects, knowledge gaps and interventions SANDRA LINDSTRÖM, CENTRE FOR ENVIRONMENTAL AND CLIMATE SCIENCE
  • 2. Status and trends for wild bees • 1/3 of the 299 wild bee species is on the swedish red-list • Indications that many species' populations are declining nationally - Ranges are greatly reduced • Specialists are over-represented • Arable and urban landscapes • Several causes, lack of forage potentially one (Borgström m.fl. 2018. Pollinatörer och pollinering i Sverige – värden, förutsättningar och påverkansfaktorer. Naturvårdsverket)
  • 3. Number of honey bee hives (Potts m.fl. 2010. Journal of Apicultural Research) (IBPES 2016 chapter 3) Year 2019: 160 000-170 000 honey bee hives in Sweden (SJV, 2019. Det ekonomiska värdet av honungsbin i Sverige) 2019
  • 4. Food resource competition (Mallinger et al. 2017) When does competition between bees have negative effects on the long-term development of populations?
  • 5. (Kleijn et al. 2018, Science) Bees have a lot in common - Joint efforts to benefit the bees have greater potential to be successful!
  • 6. Records identified in data base search: (n=891) Title and abstract screening (n=875) Full-text screening (n=609) Exkluded records, based on criteria (n=266) Exkluded records, based on criteria (n=549) Duplicates excluded (n=14) For analysis (n=57) European empirical records (n=33) Systematic map of the European empirical evidence
  • 7. NO IMPACT Wild bees Honey bees Floral resource overlap Unchanged wild bee visitation rate Reduced wild bee visitation rate Unchanged resource harvest Reduced resource harvest Alternative floral resource Reduced survival Reduced fecundity Reduced population size/extinction NEGATIVE IMPACT (Following Fig. 1 in Paini et al. 2004) Competition mechanisms
  • 8. Empirical evidence for competition • 24 reviews & 33 empirical European studies - Floral resource overlap - Effects on foraging and resource intake - Effects on densities and diversity - Effects on reproduction and survival Negative effects shown on several aspecs of wild bees resources, foraging and abundance. Lack of strong evidence on effects on reproduction, survival and populations.
  • 9. Empirical findings Critical levels of honey bees: Few studies, depends on flower resource availability. Modifying factors: A few studies on landscape character and flower resource availability. Sensitive species and species traits.
  • 10. Number of wild bee species that has foraging overlap in % with honey bees in intervals of 10 Rasmussen C, Dupont YL, Madsen HB, Bogusch P, Goulson D, et al. (2021) Evaluating competition for forage plants between honey bees and wild bees in Denmark. PLOS ONE 16(4): e0250056. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0250056 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0250056
  • 11. Competition from a Swedish perspective • Generally low densities of honey bees (0,4 honey bee hives per km2) • Average European density (4,2 honey bee hives per km2) • But ~70% of the Swedish honey bee hives is in the south of Sweden • Batavsandbi Andrena batava, fältsandbi A. morawitzi are oligolectic on sälg Salix and red-listed species. • A danish study identified that the red listed bees Vialsandbi Andrena lathyri, monkesolbi Dufourea halictula, klocksolbi Dufourea inermis, stengnagbi Hoplitis anthocopoides guldbyxbi Dasypoda suripes had very large (>90%) overlap with honey bees. (Rasmussen et al. 2021)
  • 12. Potential interventions Suggestions: - Increase floral resources (no studies) - Adjust the distance to protected areas (Henry & Rodet 2020) - Adjust densities or avoid honeybees in protected areas - Apply the precautionary principle in areas with threatened wild bee species (Mallinger et al. 2017) - or threatened wild bee species with high overlap with honey bees (Rasmussen et al. 2021) Evaluation tools: - “HUM” – Hive units monthly (Cane & Tepedino 2017) - Parameterized models (Sörensen et al. 2020) - “AIR” – Apiary Influence Range (Henry & Rodet 2020)
  • 13. Knowledge gaps • More studies on reproduction and survival are needed for more species • Context dependent effects - Honey bee distances and densities - Floral resource availability - Networks of wild bees and plants - Spatial and temporal scales - Interactions with nest sites - Interaction with other stressors, e.g. pesticides • What regulates bee populations? How important is competition in relation to other threats?
  • 14. Summary • Plenty of studies relating to food choices and abundance - mixed effects • Few studies examine effects on reproduction - the knowledge gaps are large • Long-term effects studies - completely missing • Species specific studies – lacking • Correlative studies – weak evidence • WANTED: Experimental, well-replicated studies with controls, several levels of honey bee densities and floral resources measuring reproduction.
  • 15.
  • 17. Photo: Mårten Sjöbeck. 1934… … 90 years later Spjutstorp 1940 Spjutstorp 2014 Altered landscapes
  • 18. Nectar availability in relation to bumble bee needs over the season on four british farms Journal of Applied Ecology, Volume: 56, Issue: 7, Pages: 1585-1596, First published: 19 April 2019, DOI: (10.1111/1365-2664.13403)
  • 19. Heterogeneous landscape Small scales More flowers Short distances between nest-sites and flowers More homogenous landscape Larger scale Fewer flowers Longer distances between nest-sites and flowers