SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Allocation of Resources
Between Bridge Replacement
and Preservation
Final Presentation
Presented by Austin Chudyk
Background
• Over 25% of US bridges are structurally deficient or functionally obsolete1
• Over 30% of US bridges have exceeded their 50-yr design life1
• At the same time, funding for infrastructure maintenance is stagnant2
“We’re in a situation where we have declining funding/revenues to replace and
repair bridges, and at the same time we have a huge group of
bridges…requiring rehab. So at the same time we have funding going down,
we have needs going up.”
-Bruce Johnson, PE, 2011
1- FHWA Bridge Preservation Guide (2011), 2-Transportation for America.org
Structurally Deficient / Functionally Obsolete
• Structurally deficient3: “Bridges
are considered [structurally
deficient] if significant load
carrying elements are found to
be in poor condition due to
deterioration and/or damage...”
• “Poor condition” = deck, super- or
substructure NBI rating < 4
3- FHWA Bridge Preservation Guide
Photo courtesy streetsblog.org
Structurally Deficient / Functionally Obsolete
• Functionally obsolete3: “..deck
geometry, load carrying capacity,
clearance, or approach roadway
alignment no longer meet the usual
criteria for the system of which it is an
integral part.”
• Alignment, clearance, etc. have NBI rating
<3
• No longer compatible with current
standards
• May have restrictions as a result
3- FHWA Bridge Preservation Guide
Photo courtesy mediatrackers.org
• Replacement constitutes the “total
replacement …with a new facility”4
• Preservation is a practice that seeks to
extend service life through maintenance
and rehabilitation as an alternative to
bridge replacement
• Rehabilitation is a preservative action
involving major work required to restore
the structural integrity of a bridge as well
as work necessary to correct major
safety defects3
Photo: rehabilitative activity (www.swiveltime.com)
4- 23 CFR Part 650, Subpart D - Highway Bridge Replacement and Rehabilitation Program
Addressing Deficient/Obsolete Bridges
Addressing Deficient/Obsolete Bridges
• Regular preventative maintenance can postpone bridge deterioration
• Sealing, patching, lubricating, painting, washing, etc.
• Activities should be performed before
• Replacement or rehabilitation are typically considered once a structure is
determined to be structurally deficient or functionally obsolete
• All bridges have a finite life span and eventually require either replacement or
major rehabilitation that goes far beyond preventative maintenance.
Addressing Deficient/Obsolete Bridges
Article courtesy www.nydailynews.com
Deciding Rehabilitation vs. Replacement
1) Structural Condition / Functionality
• Sufficiency rating5 uses weighted values
of factors regarding structural
adequacy, serviceability, and
essentiality
• Sufficiency Rating <80% = rehab
• Sufficiency rating <50% = replacement
or rehab
2) Cost/Funding
• Federal Aid distributed based on
sufficiency ratings
5- FHWA Recording and Coding Guide for the Structure, Inventory and Appraisal of the Nation’s Bridges
3) Social, Economic, Environmental
Impacts
4) Historic Structures
5) Effect on Public Safety
6) Emergency Repair/Replacement
7) Lifespan/Reliability of Alternative
8) Compliance with Regulations
9) Remaining Life and Functionality
10) Feasibility /Available Alternatives
11) CurrentAgency Practice
Deciding Rehabilitation vs. Replacement
• Many of these factors are
interdependent, further
complicating the decision process
• Bridge owners must prioritize
replacement vs rehabilitation
considerations based on agency
goals
• It may not be possible to create a
definitive algorithm/plan that
includes each factor
Deciding Rehabilitation vs. Replacement
• Excerpt from a decision matrix6
which only takes into account:
• NBI rating
• Load capacity
• General cost effectiveness
• Several feasible alternatives for
improving functionality
• Note: no definitive solutions are
claimed. Matrix only discerns
the potential for rehabilitation
6- Lichtenstein Consulting , Inc.
Recommendations & Conclusions
• Preservative (rehabilitative) actions are often cheaper, but often more
challenging than complete replacements
• Bridge owners should thoroughly investigate and prioritize replacement vs
rehabilitation considerations based on agency goals
• It seems to be more effective to implement decisions based on experience
Questions?
Austin Chudyk
(716) 208-0341
amchudyk@buffalo.edu

More Related Content

What's hot

column jacketing
 column jacketing column jacketing
column jacketing
mamilli
 
Scour around bridge piers
Scour around bridge piersScour around bridge piers
Scour around bridge piers
Ayman Mansour
 
Stress ribbon bridges stiffened by arches or cables
Stress ribbon bridges stiffened by arches or cablesStress ribbon bridges stiffened by arches or cables
Stress ribbon bridges stiffened by arches or cables
Masum Majid
 
4 stress ribbon & arch pedestrian bridges
4 stress ribbon & arch pedestrian bridges4 stress ribbon & arch pedestrian bridges
4 stress ribbon & arch pedestrian bridges
Masum Majid
 
Bridge design seminar colombo 2016 na topic1
Bridge design seminar colombo 2016 na topic1Bridge design seminar colombo 2016 na topic1
Bridge design seminar colombo 2016 na topic1
jose bonifacio de souza leite cuadros
 
Stress ribbon bridge
Stress ribbon bridgeStress ribbon bridge
Stress ribbon bridge
Shreya Thusoo
 
Bridge
BridgeBridge
Bridge
anbuvsb
 
Tony
TonyTony
Tony
TONY ROSE
 
Design and analysis of stress ribbon bridges
Design and analysis of stress ribbon bridgesDesign and analysis of stress ribbon bridges
Design and analysis of stress ribbon bridges
eSAT Journals
 
Bridge engnineering
Bridge engnineeringBridge engnineering
Bridge engnineering
ecep nurali
 
Pre-Fabricated Steel Bridges for Accelerated Bridge Construction (ABC)
Pre-Fabricated Steel Bridges for Accelerated Bridge Construction (ABC)Pre-Fabricated Steel Bridges for Accelerated Bridge Construction (ABC)
Pre-Fabricated Steel Bridges for Accelerated Bridge Construction (ABC)
AISC/NSBA
 
stress ribbon bridge by kaiser malik
stress ribbon bridge by kaiser  malikstress ribbon bridge by kaiser  malik
stress ribbon bridge by kaiser malik
junaid bashir
 
Poster
PosterPoster
CE 72.32 (January 2016 Semester) Lecture 4 - Selection of Structural Systems
CE 72.32 (January 2016 Semester) Lecture 4 - Selection of Structural SystemsCE 72.32 (January 2016 Semester) Lecture 4 - Selection of Structural Systems
CE 72.32 (January 2016 Semester) Lecture 4 - Selection of Structural Systems
Fawad Najam
 
Chapter2
Chapter2Chapter2
Chapter2
shaymaa17
 
PPT On Bridge Construction
PPT On Bridge ConstructionPPT On Bridge Construction
PPT On Bridge Construction
Robin Nirwal
 
Flow diversion and storage
Flow diversion and storageFlow diversion and storage
Flow diversion and storage
shaymaa17
 
Eg unit v
Eg unit vEg unit v
Eg unit v
shaymaa17
 
Framed structures
Framed structures Framed structures
Framed structures
Shivangi Saini
 
Dam engineering i 2
Dam engineering i 2Dam engineering i 2
Dam engineering i 2
FeteneBefekadu
 

What's hot (20)

column jacketing
 column jacketing column jacketing
column jacketing
 
Scour around bridge piers
Scour around bridge piersScour around bridge piers
Scour around bridge piers
 
Stress ribbon bridges stiffened by arches or cables
Stress ribbon bridges stiffened by arches or cablesStress ribbon bridges stiffened by arches or cables
Stress ribbon bridges stiffened by arches or cables
 
4 stress ribbon & arch pedestrian bridges
4 stress ribbon & arch pedestrian bridges4 stress ribbon & arch pedestrian bridges
4 stress ribbon & arch pedestrian bridges
 
Bridge design seminar colombo 2016 na topic1
Bridge design seminar colombo 2016 na topic1Bridge design seminar colombo 2016 na topic1
Bridge design seminar colombo 2016 na topic1
 
Stress ribbon bridge
Stress ribbon bridgeStress ribbon bridge
Stress ribbon bridge
 
Bridge
BridgeBridge
Bridge
 
Tony
TonyTony
Tony
 
Design and analysis of stress ribbon bridges
Design and analysis of stress ribbon bridgesDesign and analysis of stress ribbon bridges
Design and analysis of stress ribbon bridges
 
Bridge engnineering
Bridge engnineeringBridge engnineering
Bridge engnineering
 
Pre-Fabricated Steel Bridges for Accelerated Bridge Construction (ABC)
Pre-Fabricated Steel Bridges for Accelerated Bridge Construction (ABC)Pre-Fabricated Steel Bridges for Accelerated Bridge Construction (ABC)
Pre-Fabricated Steel Bridges for Accelerated Bridge Construction (ABC)
 
stress ribbon bridge by kaiser malik
stress ribbon bridge by kaiser  malikstress ribbon bridge by kaiser  malik
stress ribbon bridge by kaiser malik
 
Poster
PosterPoster
Poster
 
CE 72.32 (January 2016 Semester) Lecture 4 - Selection of Structural Systems
CE 72.32 (January 2016 Semester) Lecture 4 - Selection of Structural SystemsCE 72.32 (January 2016 Semester) Lecture 4 - Selection of Structural Systems
CE 72.32 (January 2016 Semester) Lecture 4 - Selection of Structural Systems
 
Chapter2
Chapter2Chapter2
Chapter2
 
PPT On Bridge Construction
PPT On Bridge ConstructionPPT On Bridge Construction
PPT On Bridge Construction
 
Flow diversion and storage
Flow diversion and storageFlow diversion and storage
Flow diversion and storage
 
Eg unit v
Eg unit vEg unit v
Eg unit v
 
Framed structures
Framed structures Framed structures
Framed structures
 
Dam engineering i 2
Dam engineering i 2Dam engineering i 2
Dam engineering i 2
 

Similar to Chudyk, Austin_CIE 579_FINAL Presentation

PIC 2 Display Boards
PIC 2 Display BoardsPIC 2 Display Boards
PIC 2 Display Boards
Toronto Public Consultation Unit
 
ANALYSIS OF VIADUCT REHABILITATION PROJECTS IN MASSACHUSETTS AND CALIFORNIA: ...
ANALYSIS OF VIADUCT REHABILITATION PROJECTS IN MASSACHUSETTS AND CALIFORNIA: ...ANALYSIS OF VIADUCT REHABILITATION PROJECTS IN MASSACHUSETTS AND CALIFORNIA: ...
ANALYSIS OF VIADUCT REHABILITATION PROJECTS IN MASSACHUSETTS AND CALIFORNIA: ...
Lucas de Brito Nascimento
 
Intro to Marine Structures.pptx
Intro to Marine Structures.pptxIntro to Marine Structures.pptx
Intro to Marine Structures.pptx
SameerAdnanAnsari
 
Components, Advantages, Disadvantages of Bridges & Structures.pdf
Components, Advantages, Disadvantages of Bridges & Structures.pdfComponents, Advantages, Disadvantages of Bridges & Structures.pdf
Components, Advantages, Disadvantages of Bridges & Structures.pdf
Satec Envir Engineering Pvt. Ltd.
 
Bridge
BridgeBridge
Bridge
Bobby Hanes
 
CCMPO - Local Transportation Funding Options
CCMPO - Local Transportation Funding OptionsCCMPO - Local Transportation Funding Options
CCMPO - Local Transportation Funding Options
mpipe
 
Bridging History
Bridging HistoryBridging History
Crook at Mantua Elementary School Stream Restoration
Crook at Mantua Elementary School Stream RestorationCrook at Mantua Elementary School Stream Restoration
Crook at Mantua Elementary School Stream Restoration
Fairfax County
 

Similar to Chudyk, Austin_CIE 579_FINAL Presentation (8)

PIC 2 Display Boards
PIC 2 Display BoardsPIC 2 Display Boards
PIC 2 Display Boards
 
ANALYSIS OF VIADUCT REHABILITATION PROJECTS IN MASSACHUSETTS AND CALIFORNIA: ...
ANALYSIS OF VIADUCT REHABILITATION PROJECTS IN MASSACHUSETTS AND CALIFORNIA: ...ANALYSIS OF VIADUCT REHABILITATION PROJECTS IN MASSACHUSETTS AND CALIFORNIA: ...
ANALYSIS OF VIADUCT REHABILITATION PROJECTS IN MASSACHUSETTS AND CALIFORNIA: ...
 
Intro to Marine Structures.pptx
Intro to Marine Structures.pptxIntro to Marine Structures.pptx
Intro to Marine Structures.pptx
 
Components, Advantages, Disadvantages of Bridges & Structures.pdf
Components, Advantages, Disadvantages of Bridges & Structures.pdfComponents, Advantages, Disadvantages of Bridges & Structures.pdf
Components, Advantages, Disadvantages of Bridges & Structures.pdf
 
Bridge
BridgeBridge
Bridge
 
CCMPO - Local Transportation Funding Options
CCMPO - Local Transportation Funding OptionsCCMPO - Local Transportation Funding Options
CCMPO - Local Transportation Funding Options
 
Bridging History
Bridging HistoryBridging History
Bridging History
 
Crook at Mantua Elementary School Stream Restoration
Crook at Mantua Elementary School Stream RestorationCrook at Mantua Elementary School Stream Restoration
Crook at Mantua Elementary School Stream Restoration
 

Chudyk, Austin_CIE 579_FINAL Presentation

  • 1. Allocation of Resources Between Bridge Replacement and Preservation Final Presentation Presented by Austin Chudyk
  • 2. Background • Over 25% of US bridges are structurally deficient or functionally obsolete1 • Over 30% of US bridges have exceeded their 50-yr design life1 • At the same time, funding for infrastructure maintenance is stagnant2 “We’re in a situation where we have declining funding/revenues to replace and repair bridges, and at the same time we have a huge group of bridges…requiring rehab. So at the same time we have funding going down, we have needs going up.” -Bruce Johnson, PE, 2011 1- FHWA Bridge Preservation Guide (2011), 2-Transportation for America.org
  • 3. Structurally Deficient / Functionally Obsolete • Structurally deficient3: “Bridges are considered [structurally deficient] if significant load carrying elements are found to be in poor condition due to deterioration and/or damage...” • “Poor condition” = deck, super- or substructure NBI rating < 4 3- FHWA Bridge Preservation Guide Photo courtesy streetsblog.org
  • 4. Structurally Deficient / Functionally Obsolete • Functionally obsolete3: “..deck geometry, load carrying capacity, clearance, or approach roadway alignment no longer meet the usual criteria for the system of which it is an integral part.” • Alignment, clearance, etc. have NBI rating <3 • No longer compatible with current standards • May have restrictions as a result 3- FHWA Bridge Preservation Guide Photo courtesy mediatrackers.org
  • 5. • Replacement constitutes the “total replacement …with a new facility”4 • Preservation is a practice that seeks to extend service life through maintenance and rehabilitation as an alternative to bridge replacement • Rehabilitation is a preservative action involving major work required to restore the structural integrity of a bridge as well as work necessary to correct major safety defects3 Photo: rehabilitative activity (www.swiveltime.com) 4- 23 CFR Part 650, Subpart D - Highway Bridge Replacement and Rehabilitation Program Addressing Deficient/Obsolete Bridges
  • 6. Addressing Deficient/Obsolete Bridges • Regular preventative maintenance can postpone bridge deterioration • Sealing, patching, lubricating, painting, washing, etc. • Activities should be performed before • Replacement or rehabilitation are typically considered once a structure is determined to be structurally deficient or functionally obsolete • All bridges have a finite life span and eventually require either replacement or major rehabilitation that goes far beyond preventative maintenance.
  • 7. Addressing Deficient/Obsolete Bridges Article courtesy www.nydailynews.com
  • 8. Deciding Rehabilitation vs. Replacement 1) Structural Condition / Functionality • Sufficiency rating5 uses weighted values of factors regarding structural adequacy, serviceability, and essentiality • Sufficiency Rating <80% = rehab • Sufficiency rating <50% = replacement or rehab 2) Cost/Funding • Federal Aid distributed based on sufficiency ratings 5- FHWA Recording and Coding Guide for the Structure, Inventory and Appraisal of the Nation’s Bridges
  • 9. 3) Social, Economic, Environmental Impacts 4) Historic Structures 5) Effect on Public Safety 6) Emergency Repair/Replacement 7) Lifespan/Reliability of Alternative 8) Compliance with Regulations 9) Remaining Life and Functionality 10) Feasibility /Available Alternatives 11) CurrentAgency Practice Deciding Rehabilitation vs. Replacement • Many of these factors are interdependent, further complicating the decision process • Bridge owners must prioritize replacement vs rehabilitation considerations based on agency goals • It may not be possible to create a definitive algorithm/plan that includes each factor
  • 11. • Excerpt from a decision matrix6 which only takes into account: • NBI rating • Load capacity • General cost effectiveness • Several feasible alternatives for improving functionality • Note: no definitive solutions are claimed. Matrix only discerns the potential for rehabilitation 6- Lichtenstein Consulting , Inc.
  • 12. Recommendations & Conclusions • Preservative (rehabilitative) actions are often cheaper, but often more challenging than complete replacements • Bridge owners should thoroughly investigate and prioritize replacement vs rehabilitation considerations based on agency goals • It seems to be more effective to implement decisions based on experience