SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Chemical Injuries
of the Cornea
Kathryn Colby, MD, PhD
VOLUME XXVIII NUMBER 1
MARCH 2010 (MODULE 1 OF 3)
Reviewers and Contributing Editor
George A. Stern, MD, Editor for Cornea & External Disease
Kenneth M. Goins, MD, Basic and Clinical Science, Course Faculty, Section 8
Ron W. Pelton, MD, PhD, Practicing Ophthalmologists Advisory Committee for Education
FocalPoints
Consultants
Roswell R. Pfister, MD
Scheffer C.G. Tseng, MD, PhD
Clinical Modules for Ophthalmologists
Claiming CME Credit
Academy members: To claim Focal Points CME cred-
its, visit the Academy web site and access CME Central
(http://one.aao.org/CE/MyCMEPortfolio/default.aspx)
to view and print your Academy transcript and report
CME credit you have earned. You can claim up to two
AMA PRA Category 1 Credits™ per module. This will give
you a maximum of 24 credits for the 2010 subscrip-
tion year. CME credit may be claimed for up to three (3)
years from date of issue. Non-Academy members: For
assistance please send an e-mail to customer_service
@aao.org or a fax to (415) 561-8575.
Focal Points (ISSN 0891-8260) is published quarterly by the American Acad-
emy of Ophthalmology at 655 Beach St., San Francisco, CA 94109-1336. For
domestic subscribers, print with online 1-year subscription is $187 for Academy
members (2 years, $337; 3 years, $477) and $252 for nonmembers (2 years,
$455; 3 years, $642). International subscribers, please visit www.aao.org/
focalpoints for more information. Online-only 1-year subscription is $155 for
Academy members (2 years, $277; 3 years, $395) and $209 for nonmembers
(2 years, $375; 3 years, $535). Periodicals postage paid at San Francisco, CA,
and additional mailing offices. POSTMASTER: Send address changes to Focal
Points, P.O. Box 7424, San Francisco, CA 94120-7424.
The American Academy of Ophthalmology is accredited by the Accredita-
tion Council for Continuing Medical Education to provide continuing medical
education for physicians.
The American Academy of Ophthalmology designates this educational
activity for a maximum of two AMA PRA Category 1 Credits™. Physicians
should only claim credit commensurate with the extent of their participation
in the activity.
Reporting your CME online is one benefit of Academy membership. Non-
members may request a Focal Points CME Claim Form by contacting Focal
Points, 655 Beach St., San Francisco, CA 94109-1336.
The Academy provides this material for educational purposes only. It is not
intended to represent the only or best method or procedure in every case, nor
to replace a physician’s own judgment or give specific advice for case manage-
ment. Including all indications, contraindications, side effects, and alternative
agents for each drug or treatment is beyond the scope of this material. All
information and recommendations should be verified, prior to use, with current
information included in the manufacturers’ package inserts or other indepen-
dent sources and considered in light of the patient’s condition and history.
Reference to certain drugs, instruments, and other products in this publica-
tion is made for illustrative purposes only and is not intended to constitute
an endorsement of such. Some material may include information on applica-
tions that are not considered community standard, that reflect indications not
included in approved FDA labeling, or that are approved for use only in restricted
research settings. The FDA has stated that it is the responsibility of the physi-
cian to determine the FDA status of each drug or device he or she wishes to
use, and to use them with appropriate informed patient consent in compliance
with applicable law. The Academy specifically disclaims any and all liability for
injury or other damages of any kind, from negligence or otherwise, for any
and all claims that may arise out of the use of any recommendations or other
information contained herein. The author(s) listed made a major contribution
to this module. Substantive editorial revisions may have been made based on
reviewer recommendations.
Subscribers requesting replacement copies 6 months and later from the
cover date of the issue being requested will be charged the current module
replacement rate.
©2010 American Academy of Ophthalmology®. All rights reserved.
ii FOCAL POINTS : MODULE 1, 2010
This icon in text denotes video clips in the online edition.
http://one.aao.org/CE/EducationalProducts/FocalPoints.aspx
Focal Points Editorial Review Board
George A. Stern, MD, Missoula, MT
Editor in Chief; Cornea & External Disease
William S. Clifford, MD, Garden City, KS
Glaucoma Surgery; Liaison for Practicing Ophthalmologists Advisory
Committee for Education
D. Michael Colvard, MD, FACS, Encino, CA
Cataract Surgery
Bradley S. Foster, MD, Springfield, MA
Retina & Vitreous
Anil D. Patel, MD, Oklahoma City, OK
Neuro-Ophthalmology
Eric P. Purdy, MD, Fort Wayne, IN
Oculoplastic, Lacrimal, & Orbital Surgery
Steven I. Rosenfeld, MD, FACS, Delray Beach, FL
Refractive Surgery, Optics & Refraction
C. Gail Summers, MD, Minneapolis, MN
Pediatric Ophthalmology & Strabismus
Albert T. Vitale, MD, Salt Lake City, UT
Ocular Inflammation & Tumors
Focal Points Staff
Susan R. Keller, Acquisitions Editor
Kim Torgerson, Publications Editor
Clinical Education Secretaries and Staff
Gregory L. Skuta, MD, Senior Secretary for Clinical Education,
Oklahoma City, OK
Louis B. Cantor, MD, Secretary for Ophthalmic Knowledge,
Indianapolis, IN
Richard A. Zorab, Vice President, Ophthalmic Knowledge
Hal Straus, Director of Print Publications
FOCAL POINTS : MODULE 1, 2010 1
Introduction
Chemical injuries of the cornea are ophthalmic emergen-
cies. These injuries often result in significant ocular mor-
bidity and generally strike young adults in the prime of
life. Classification schemes enable the ophthalmologist
to determine the severity of the injury and the prognosis
for the injured eye. Immediate management consists of
copious irrigation following the exposure. Effective man-
agement in the intermediate and late phases requires an
understanding of the cellular events occurring during
each phase. Appropriate medical and surgical care helps
ensure the best outcomes for these potentially blinding
injuries.
Epidemiology of Chemical Injuries
Similar to open globe injuries, most chemical injuries
occur in young men. In published series of chemical inju-
ries, approximately two-thirds of patients are men. The
visual impact of chemical injuries is magnified because
they generally occur in patients in the prime of life.
While a small percentage of chemical injuries are delib-
erately inflicted during an assault, the vast majority (90%)
are accidental. Approximately two-thirds of chemical
injuries occur in the workplace. The bulk of workplace-
related chemical injuries occur at construction sites,
Contents
Introduction 1
Epidemiology of Chemical Injuries• 1
Causative Agents 2
Classification Schemes 2
Stages of Ocular Surface Recovery
Following Chemical Injury 3
Management Strategies 4
Medical Therapies• 4
Role and Timing of Surgical Treatment•
Following Chemical Injury 6
Putting It All Together: A Case Report 8
Conclusion 9
Clinicians’ Corner 10
Financial Disclosures
The authors, reviewers, and consultants disclose the following finan-
cial relationships. Kathryn Colby, MD, PhD: (C) Alcon Laboratories,
Vistakon Johnson & Johnson Visioncare; (E) Novartis Pharmaceuticals
Corporation. D. Michael Colvard, MD, FACS: (C) Advanced Medical
Optics, Bausch & Lomb; (P) OASIS Medical. Ron W. Pelton, MD,
PhD: (L) AO-ASIF. Steven I. Rosenfeld, MD, FACS: (L) Allergan.
Scheffer C.G. Tseng, MD, PhD: (C) Bio-Tissue; (E) TissueTech;
(O, P) Bio-Tissue, TissueTech. C. Gail Summers, MD: (C) McKesson.
Albert T. Vitale, MD: (C) Bausch & Lomb Surgical.
The following contributors state that they have no significant financial
interest or other relationship with the manufacturer of any commer-
cial product discussed in their contributions to this module or with
the manufacturer of any competing commercial product: William
S. Clifford, MD; Bradley S. Foster, MD; Kenneth M. Goins, MD; Anil
D. Patel, MD; Roswell R. Pfister, MD, Eric P. Purdy, MD; George A.
Stern, MD.
C = Consultant fee, paid advisory boards or fees for attending a
meeting
E = Employed by a commercial entity
L = Lecture fees (honoraria), travel fees or reimbursements when
speaking at the invitation of a commercial entity
O = Equity ownership/stock options of publicly or privately traded
firms (excluding mutual funds)
P = Patents and/or royalties that might be viewed as creating a
potential conflict of interest
S = Grant support
Learning Objectives
Upon completion of this module,
the reader should be able to:
Describe the classification scheme and•
epidemiology of chemical injuries of the cornea
Consider management strategies for each stage of•
healing after a chemical injury of the cornea
Appraise the surgical approaches to chemical•
injuries of the cornea in acute and late phases of
management
2 FOCAL POINTS : MODULE 1, 2010
chemical plants, and machine factories. Safety glasses,
the best defense against chemical injuries, are unfortu-
nately no match for strong chemicals under high pressure
that characterize many industrial accidents. The remain-
ing one-third of injuries occur at home, with only a small
percentage occurring at school. In contrast to industrial
accidents, chemical injuries in the home can often be pre-
vented by the use of appropriate safety glasses.
Causative Agents
Injuries caused by alkali agents are more common and
generally more serious than those caused by acids. Alka-
lis penetrate tissue more readily than acids due to their
ability to saponify cell membranes. Strong alkali agents
can reach the anterior chamber within 15 seconds of
exposure, causing cell death and corneal hydrolysis
along the way.
Alkali agents that cause ocular injuries include ammo-
nia, lye (sodium hydroxide), potassium hydroxide, magne-
sium hydroxide, and lime. Ammonia, found in fertilizers,
refrigerants, and cleaning solutions, is especially danger-
ous because it penetrates tissues almost instantaneously
and can liberate toxic fumes when combined with water.
Lye, present in drain cleaners, is almost as dangerous as
ammonia. Potassium hydroxide, found in caustic potash,
does not penetrate as rapidly as lye and is a less com-
mon cause of serious injury. Magnesium hydroxide, found
in firework sparklers and flares, produces damage
through both chemical and thermal mechanisms. Lime,
a component of plaster, mortar, cement, and whitewash,
is the most common cause of workplace chemical inju-
ries overall. Lime’s slow speed of penetration lessens the
severity of the injury. However, solid particles of lime
can become lodged in the conjunctiva (especially the
upper palpebral conjunctiva or fornix) and can act as a
reservoir, slowly releasing damaging chemicals.
Ocular injuries are caused by multiple acid agents,
including sulfuric acid, sulfurous acid, hydrofluoric acid,
acetic acid, and hydrochloric acid. Exploding car batter-
ies are a source of sulfuric acid; these injuries can be asso-
ciated with ocular lacerations from released particulate
matter. Sulfurous acid, found in bleach and refrigerant,
penetrates more easily than other acids due to its high
lipid and water solubility. Hydrofluoric acid, used in glass
polishing and mineral refining, causes severe injury due
to the rapid penetration of the fluoride ion into the cor-
nea, which rivals that of the alkali agents. Systemic burns,
even ones involving a tiny percentage of the body’s sur-
face area (2%), can be fatal due to uncontrolled metabolic
perturbations. Acetic acid, found in vinegar and as glacial
acetic acid, generally only produces injury if the eye is
exposed to a high-concentration form for an extended
period of time. Finally, hydrochloric acid penetrates poorly
and only causes damage following prolonged exposure.
Classification Schemes
The severity of a chemical injury and its prognosis can
usually be determined based upon the initial examina-
tion. To grade an injury, the physician determines the
extent of damage to the corneal epithelium, limbus, and
conjunctiva. The presence or absence (and the magni-
tude) of limbal ischemia is noted, as is the quality of the
view through the cornea. These features are then used
to classify the injury (Table 1).
Table 1. Prognostic Features of Chemical Injury
GRADE OF INJURY CLINICAL FINDINGS PROGNOSIS
Grade I Corneal epithelial defect
No corneal haze
No loss of limbal stem cells
Excellent
Grade II Cornea mildly hazy
Focal limbal ischemia
Generally good; may have focal conjunctivalization
of cornea in area of limbal stem cell loss
Grade III Severe corneal haze limits view of anterior segment
structures
Extensive limbal ischemia with loss of most limbal
stem cells
Guarded; cornea must be repopulated with
conjunctiva; surgery needed for visual
rehabilitation
Grade IV Complete loss of corneal and proximal conjunctival
epithelium
Cornea opaque
Complete limbal ischemia and loss of all limbal
stem cells
Extremely poor; melting likely; globe salvage may
not be possible
FOCAL POINTS : MODULE 1, 2010 3
grade IV injuries despite aggressive medical and surgical
management.
A recently described classification scheme by Bagley
and colleagues also suggests the importance of the depth
of the corneal injury and the involvement of the corneal
endothelium in the prognosis of chemical injuries.
Stages of
Ocular Surface
Recovery Following
Chemical Injury
An understanding of the biological events that take place
following a chemical exposure will aid the clinician in
The Hughes classification scheme (as modified by
Thoft) divides chemical injuries into 4 categories. A grade I
injury involves the corneal epithelium only. In a grade I
injury, the limbal stem cells, which serve as the source of
differentiated corneal epithelium, are spared. The cornea,
although denuded of epithelium, remains clear. There is
no limbal ischemia. The prognosis for a full recovery of
normal corneal appearance and function is excellent.
A grade II injury is characterized by a partial loss of the
limbal stem cells with focal limbal ischemia. The cornea
is hazy, but anterior segment structures (iris, lens) can
still be visualized (Figure 1). The prognosis for grade II
injuries is generally good, but there may be long-term
persistent epithelial dysfunction in the area that sus-
tained stem cell loss, with focal replacement of corneal
epithelium with conjunctival epithelium (conjunctival-
ization), haze, and neovascularization.
Grade III injuries have a guarded prognosis due to com-
plete loss of the corneal epithelium and loss of most, if
not all, of the limbal stem cells (Figure 2). Up to 50% of
the limbus is frankly ischemic and corneal haze limits
visualization of the iris and lens. Following grade III inju-
ries, resurfacing of the cornea can only be accomplished
by growth of conjunctival epithelium over the corneal
stroma. While conjunctival ingrowth will restore the
tectonic stability of the globe, it does not allow for good
vision due to vascularization and scarring.
The prognosis of grade IV injuries is extremely poor.
In these injuries, there is complete loss of corneal epi-
thelium and limbal stem cells plus loss of the proximal
conjunctival epithelium (Figure 3). The injured cornea
is opaque, allowing no view into the anterior cham-
ber. More than 50% of the limbus is ischemic. With no
endogenous source of epithelium to repopulate the cor-
neal surface, sterile ulceration is a common sequela of
Figure 1 Acute grade II burn with focal (approximately
3 clock hours) of limbal stem cell loss.
Figure 2 Acute grade III burn showing extensive corneal
haze impeding visualization of the iris and limbal ischemia of
approximately 6 clock hours.
Figure 3 Acute grade IV burn with porcelainization of the
cornea and bulbar conjunctiva.
4 FOCAL POINTS : MODULE 1, 2010
managing these injuries. One can divide the events into
4 phases: initial (day 0), acute (days 0 to 7), intermediate or
early repair (days 7 to 21), and late repair (after day 21).
In the weeks immediately following a chemical injury,
there is interplay of multiple events as the cornea
attempts to repair itself. These events include epithelial
regrowth and migration, collagen synthesis and degrada-
tion, and activation and migration of keratocytes.
During the first week, epithelial regrowth begins if
there are sufficient undamaged limbal stem cells to
provide a source of healthy corneal epithelium. Treat-
ment efforts are directed at encouraging this growth,
by quelling inflammation and avoiding topical medica-
tions that might damage the fragile epithelium. Kerato-
cyte activation begins in response to the injury, allowing
the initiation of collagen synthesis. Little or no collagen
breakdown occurs in the first week following injury.
Epithelial migration continues during the early repair
phase (days 7 to 21). Mild injuries may show complete
re-epithelialization during this phase, while grade II
injuries may display a focal persistent epithelial defect,
corresponding to the area of limbal stem cell destruc-
tion (Figure 4a). More severe injuries typically show little
or no re-epithelialization during this period. Eyes with
grade IV injuries typically retain their ischemic appear-
ance. Ocular surface inflammation persists as long as
the corneal surface remains denuded. Keratocytes con-
tinue to function during this phase to repair damage to
the corneal stroma. Activity of collagenases (produced
by both keratocytes and invading inflammatory cells)
peaks by day 14 to 21 while collagen synthesis contin-
ues. The relative strength of these opposing forces deter-
mines whether corneal melting will occur. Treatment
approaches in this phase attempt to maximize collagen
synthesis while minimizing collagenase activation to
reduce the risk of sterile ulceration of the cornea. Cor-
neal perforation will ensue if sterile melting cannot be
arrested. Once the corneal surface is intact, collagenase
activity decreases as does the risk of corneal melting.
The late repair phase occurs after day 21. In mild inju-
ries in which the limbal stem cell population is intact,
a normal corneal surface is re-established. Focal limbal
stem cell loss (grade II) may lead to focal conjunctivaliza-
tion of the cornea in the area of the stem cell defect (Fig-
ure 4b). For grade III injuries, delayed re-epithelialization
is the norm, although with proper medical and surgi-
cal management, eventually the corneal surface will be
repopulated with conjunctival epithelium. Grade IV inju-
ries have an extremely poor prognosis due to the com-
plete loss of limbal stem cells and adjacent conjunctiva.
Despite optimal management, these eyes often cannot
be saved.
Management Strategies
There are 3 main goals in managing a chemical injury:
enhance recovery of the corneal epithelium; augment
collagen synthesis while minimizing collagen break-
down and sterile ulceration; and control inflammation.
In severe cases, surgical treatment may be indicated.
Table 2 summarizes initial treatments based on the
grade of the injury.
Medical Therapies
Irrigation. Initial management of an acute chemical
injury is relatively straightforward. The severity of a
chemical burn is a function of both the toxicity of the
agent involved and the duration of exposure. Time is of
the essence, since chemical burns are one of the only
true ophthalmic emergencies. The eye should be copi-
ously irrigated as quickly as possible after the exposure
Figure 4 Grade II burn. a. Twenty-nine days following
grade II burn with focal thinning and impending perforation.
Tissue adhesive and a bandage contact lens were applied.
Same patient as Figure 1. b. Final result following grade II
burn with focal corneal melt, treated with tissue adhesive.
Vision 20/20 but patient complains of photophobia.
a
b
FOCAL POINTS : MODULE 1, 2010 5
with whatever clean fluid is available. Irrigation should
be repeated upon arrival to the hospital, since irriga-
tion at the location of the injury or in the ambulance is
often insufficient to entirely remove the offending agent.
Once irrigation is complete, the pH of the ocular surface
is checked with expanded range pH paper. If the pH has
normalized (7.0 to 7.2), then the rest of the history can be
taken and the eye examined. If the pH is still abnormal,
then irrigation should be continued and the pH measure-
ment repeated. The pH should be rechecked every 15 to
30 minutes to ensure that it remains normal. A pH that
rises after initial normalization suggests that trapped par-
ticulate matter (for example, particles of plaster) is con-
tinuing to leach chemical onto the surface of the eye.
Exam. A complete ophthalmic exam is performed, includ-
ing inspection and sweeping of the inferior and superior
fornix to remove trapped particles. Intraocular pressure
is checked, since chemical injuries may cause an acute
pressure increase. The injury is graded based upon the
extent of damage to the cornea, limbus, and conjunctiva.
In an acute chemical injury, a white “porcelainized” eye
typically denotes extensive limbal ischemia, represent-
ing severe damage. This is occasionally misinterpreted
as a mild injury by an inexperienced observer. Similarly,
a cornea that is completely denuded of epithelium will
take up fluorescein stain poorly, leading the examiner
to underestimate the initial extent of the damage. One
should also inspect the chemical safety sheet for the
agent in question. Certain agents such as hydrofluoric
acid can cause life-threatening metabolic imbalances;
patients injured by this agent need concurrent medical
evaluation.
Initial Treatment. During the acute phase of recovery
(first week after the injury), the goal is to encourage
epithelial healing while controlling inflammation and
preventing superinfection. Patients with mild injuries
(grade I) can be placed on a topical antibiotic ointment
such as erythromycin 4 times a day. A cycloplegic agent
can be given to help with comfort (cyclopentolate 2 to
3 times daily or a single dose of scopolamine given by
the examiner). Preservative-free artificial tears can also
provide comfort following a chemical injury. Even mild
chemical injuries have significant associated inflamma-
tion, and we would typically give topical corticosteroids,
usually prednisolone acetate 1% 4 times a day, with a
rapid taper to off once the corneal epithelium is healed.
Patients with mild chemical injuries are followed every
1 to 2 days until the ocular surface is stable. Patients
may experience ocular discomfort even months after a
relatively minor chemical injury. Supportive measures
such as lubrication and treatment of any associated
Table 2. Initial Treatment Paradigms Based on Grade of Injury
GRADE OF INJURY RECOMMENDED TREATMENT
Grade I Topical antibiotic ointment (erythromycin or similar) qid
Prednisolone acetate 1% qid
Preservative-free artificial tears as needed
Consider short-acting cycloplegia (cyclopentolate tid or a single drop of scopolamine)
Grade II Topical antibiotic drop (fluoroquinolone) qid
Prednisolone acetate 1% hourly while awake (first 7–10 days); taper corticosteroids if epithelium not healed by
day 10–14
Atropine sulfate bid
Sodium ascorbate drops (10%) hourly while awake
Vitamin C, 2 grams po qid
Doxycycline, 100 mg po bid
Preservative-free artificial tears as needed
Oral pain medicines as needed
Progestational steroids (1% medroxyprogesterone) qid if epithelial defect persists after day 10
Debridement of necrotic epithelium as needed
Application of tissue adhesive as needed
Grade III As for grade II
Amniotic membrane considered if epithelial healing halts
Grade IV As for grades II/III
Early surgery (amniotic membrane, advancement of posterior conjunctiva) usually necessary given severity of
ocular surface damage
6 FOCAL POINTS : MODULE 1, 2010
meibomian gland dysfunction or dry eye will help return
the ocular surface to its pre-injury state.
For burns of grade II and above, the importance of
intensive topical corticosteroids in the acute phase can-
not be overemphasized. There is concern that topical
corticosteroids can exacerbate corneal melting. While
this is true in the later stages of chemical injury man-
agement, in the acute stage topical corticosteroids are
very beneficial for controlling the severe inflammatory
sequelae and should be used in an appropriately aggres-
sive fashion. Corneal melting from activation of corneal
collagenases typically does not begin before 10 to 14 days
after the injury. Therefore, the first week represents a
window in which corticosteroids can and should be used
to quell the raging inflammation and give the ocular sur-
face a chance to heal. For grade II burns and above, we
typically use prednisolone acetate 1% hourly while the
patient is awake.
Additional considerations include the following:
Long-acting cycloplegia (ie, atropine sulfate 2 times•
daily) is beneficial.
Oral narcotics are often required for pain control.•
A stronger topical antibiotic (such as a fluoroqui-•
nolone) is given at least 4 times daily to reduce the
risk of bacterial superinfection.
Topical sodium ascorbate (10%) and oral vitamin C•
supplementation are given to promote collagen syn-
thesis. Ascorbate, a cofactor in the rate-limiting step of
collagen synthesis, may be depleted following a chemi-
cal injury. Animal data suggests that ascorbate admin-
istration may reduce corneal ulceration.
Oral tetracycline derivatives are given to reduce the•
risk of ulceration due to their inhibitory effects on cor-
neal matrix metalloproteinases. They may also help to
reduce ocular surface inflammation.
Preservative-free tear supplements may be adminis-•
tered as needed.
Glaucoma medications (topical or oral) are prescribed•
if the intraocular pressure is elevated.
There is little role for topical nonsteroidal agents in•
a severe chemical injury. Their anti-inflammatory
power is dwarfed by that of the recommended topical
corticosteroids and they have the potential to cause
issues with epithelial healing.
Similarly, bandage contact lenses are of marginal util-•
ity in the acute management of chemical burns, as the
eye is usually too inflamed to tolerate a foreign body
on its surface.
Monitoring and Follow-Up. Patients with severe chem-
ical injuries (grade II and above) should be followed
daily initially. If there is a concern about compliance,
consideration should be given to inpatient admission.
Once epithelial healing is progressing, then follow-up
visits can be reduced accordingly. However, it is impor-
tant to maintain close observation while patients remain
on topical corticosteroids.
The real “art” of managing chemical burns comes
after the first week. For milder injuries (grade I and less
severe grade II), epithelial regrowth within the first 7 to
10 days is typical. Once epithelial regrowth is progress-
ing, topical corticosteroids can be tapered, with cessa-
tion of therapy once the epithelium is completely intact
and the eye is quiet. Lubrication and management of co-
existing dry eye and meibomian gland dysfunction will
help with post-injury discomfort.
For more severe grade II injuries and all grade III inju-
ries, complete epithelial healing usually takes longer
than 10 days. At this point, the risk of corneal melting
increases due to the shift towards collagen breakdown
at the expense of collagen synthesis. Topical corticoster-
oids must be tapered if the epithelium is not intact. Low-
dose corticosteroids (prednisolone acetate 1% once or
twice daily) may be continued if the patient is followed
closely, because corneal melting can occur precipitously
in these patients. In place of corticosteroids, topical pro-
gestational steroids such as 1% medroxyprogesterone
can be started to provide some anti-inflammatory effect
without inducing corneal melting. Other medicines are
continued. If epithelial healing falters or comes to a com-
plete halt or progressive corneal melting occurs, then
one must resort to the surgical maneuvers described in
the next section.
In grade IV injuries, medical therapy alone will not
restore the epithelial integrity of the eye, and surgery is
virtually always required. One may begin medical man-
agement initially to quiet the eye, but with the knowl-
edge that this is purely a temporizing measure.
Role and Timing of Surgical Treatment
Following Chemical Injury
Debridement. Mild chemical injuries rarely require sur-
gery for management. More severe grade II injuries may
require focal debridement of necrotic corneal or conjunc-
tival epithelium. This should be done as early as possible,
because the necrotic tissue serves as a source of inflam-
matory mediators that can inhibit re-epithelialization.
Necrotic corneal epithelium can be removed at the slit
lamp with surgical sponges. Extensive necrotic conjunc-
tiva can be excised with scissors using topical anesthesia
with the aid of a slit lamp or under an operating micro-
scope. Occasionally grade II injuries show focal corneal
melting that can usually be managed with the appli-
FOCAL POINTS : MODULE 1, 2010 7
cation of cyanoacrylate tissue adhesive covered with a
bandage contact lens.
Grade III injuries often require surgery for both acute
and long-term management. In the acute phase, necrotic
tissue should be debrided whenever needed, for the rea-
sons detailed above.
Restoration of the Corneal Surface. If epithelium
(either corneal or conjunctival) does not begin to grow
in to cover the cornea or if regrowth begins but then fails
to progress, placement of an amniotic membrane within
the first several weeks after the injury may be useful.
Amniotic membrane has anti-inflammatory properties
and can provide a scaffold for the regrowth of epithe-
lium. It can be sutured (using either 10.0 Vicryl or 10.0
nylon) or glued (using Tisseel fibrin glue) into place.
Amniotic membrane on a conformer ring (ProKera, Bio-
Tissue, Miami, FL) can also be used in this setting, often
with a tarsorrhaphy to prevent dislocation of the mem-
brane. However, despite the useful properties of amniotic
membrane in this setting, it does not replace limbal stem
cells, but may allow conjunctival epithelium to grow in
to cover the cornea. In severe injuries, one often must
be satisfied, in the short-term at least, with an eye that
is resurfaced by vascularized, conjunctival epithelium.
While this is not compatible with good vision, at least
this restores tectonic stability to the eye and eliminates
the risk of progressive corneal melting.
ONLINE VIDEO:
Amniotic Membrane in Acute Chemical Burn, 8 min 26 sec
ONLINE VIDEO:
Use of Sutureless Amniotic Membrane, 1 min 25 sec
Some clinicians advocate the use of amniotic mem-
brane transplantation acutely in all serious chemical
injuries (grade II and above). In our hospital, we gen-
erally reserve amniotic membrane for chemical inju-
ries that do not respond to initial medical management.
Amniotic membrane is a useful adjunct, but it is quite
expensive and not covered by some insurers in our area,
so we prefer to limit its use to situations in which we
know it is required.
The same management strategies can be used in
grade IV injuries, although the complete destruction of
the limbal stem cell population and limbal conjunctiva
makes it unlikely that they will be successful. Mobiliza-
tion and advancement of more posterior conjunctiva and
Tenon’s capsule can be used to bring healthy tissue into
the damaged area and may increase the likelihood of ini-
tial stabilization of these badly damaged globes.
Eyelid issues such as malpositions or trichiasis may
accompany severe chemical injuries and need to be
addressed to prevent further damage to the cornea and
inhibition of epithelial healing.
Ongoing Suppression of Inflammation. Once the cor-
neal surface has been restored, either with corneal
epithelium in less severe burns, or with conjunctival
epithelium in more severe burns, the frequency of fol-
low-up can be reduced. Severely burned eyes will benefit
from ongoing suppression of inflammation with low-
dose corticosteroids or topical cyclosporine. Bland oph-
thalmic ointment and preservative-free artificial tears
will help improve ocular comfort.
Stem Cell Transplantation. Following a severe unilateral
chemical injury in which there has been loss of most
or all of the limbal stem cell population, one can con-
sider an autologous limbal stem cell transplant from the
patient’s other eye, described in detail by Nordlund et al.
Caution should be exercised if the other eye was dam-
aged as well, since even mild injuries can deplete the
stem cell reserve to the point that harvesting some of
the stem cells may lead to the surface epitheliopathy in
the good eye.
If the original injury was bilateral or there is concern
about the viability of the stem cell population in the
good eye, then there are several options. One can con-
sider a living-related stem cell graft from a family mem-
ber or a cadaveric donor. Both of these require systemic
immunosuppression, which adds to the complexity of
postoperative management. Cultured buccal mucosa has
shown some utility in this situation, although again, like
amniotic membrane alone, buccal mucosa does not con-
tain limbal stem cells. A novel approach involves the use
of the patient’s own limbal stem cells that have been
expanded in culture in vitro and then transplanted back
on to the injured eye. This allows harvesting of a much
smaller amount of limbal stem cells, which can be useful
when one is unsure of the status of the stem cell popula-
tion in the good eye.
Additional Measures and Follow-Up. Once the health of
the ocular surface has been restored, then a corneal trans-
plant can be considered if needed. Supportive measures
including concurrent amniotic membrane transplanta-
tion and suture tarsorrhaphy may also be performed to
promote epithelial healing of the corneal transplant. The
graft should be secured with interrupted sutures (rather
than with a running suture) to allow selective suture
removal if corneal neovascularization ensues. Postoper-
ative management includes topical steroids, antibiotics
8 FOCAL POINTS : MODULE 1, 2010
membrane was sutured over the cornea and proximal
conjunctiva on day 12. Epithelial healing was first noted
25 days after the injury (Figure 6) and melting did not
occur. Six weeks following the injury, a small epithelial
defect remained without thinning. The superior conjunc-
tiva remained ischemic (Figure 7). Ten weeks following
the injury, the surface was completely intact (although
covered by conjunctiva), with 20/400 vision and a nor-
mal intraocular pressure (Figure 8). Prednisolone acetate
(1%) was continued once daily. The patient was unable
to return to her occupation due to her poor vision in
this eye and reduced stereopsis, and she sought career
retraining during this time.
The eye was allowed to quiet during the months follow-
ing the injury. Neovascularization progressed, reducing
and possibly cyclosporine. Occasionally restoration of
the ocular surface is enough to allow acceptable vision,
however, and a penetrating keratoplasty is not required
(see below).
Permanent Boston keratoprostheses have been used
in chemical burn patients with reasonable success. This
type of device is especially useful in bilateral severe
burns, because its success is not dependent upon limbal
stem cell function and it does not require the use of sys-
temic immunosuppression.
Putting It All Together:
A Case Report
A healthy, 27-year-old chef presented to the Massachu-
setts Eye and Ear Infirmary after a high-pressure ammo-
nium chloride burn to the right eye. Her eye was irrigated
at work immediately after the injury. Ocular pH upon
arrival was 7.1. Further irrigation was performed; the pH
remained stable. Vision was count fingers and intraocu-
lar pressure was 18. Slit-lamp exam revealed virtually
complete limbal ischemia (Figure 5) and loss of all proxi-
mal conjunctival epithelium, consistent with a grade IV
injury. The left eye was uninjured. Hourly 1% predni-
solone acetate was started, along with topical antibiot-
ics, atropine, and 10% sodium ascorbate. Oral vitamin C
(2 grams daily) and doxycycline (100 mg twice daily) were
begun. She was followed daily. She did not tolerate the
doxycycline, which was discontinued.
By day 10, there was no epithelial healing and corti-
costeroids were tapered to 4 times daily. An amniotic
Figure 7 Six weeks following injury; epithelial healing is
progressing, with a small central epithelial defect remain-
ing without corneal thinning. Superior conjunctiva remains
ischemic in appearance.
Figure 5 Acute grade IV burn from high-pressure ammo-
nium chloride injury at work.
Figure 6 Twenty-five days following injury, 13 days following
amniotic membrane transplantation.
FOCAL POINTS : MODULE 1, 2010 9
postoperative course was uneventful. Five months after
reconstructive surgery, vision was 20/70 uncorrected
with an intact corneal epithelium and a white and quiet
eye (Figure 10). No further surgery was recommended.
Conclusion
With appropriate management, it is possible to restore
vision to all but the most severely burned eyes. While
our current understanding of these injuries allows us to
save many of these eyes, more work is needed to improve
the prognosis of grade IV injuries. Ongoing animal and
human research is investigating the use of novel topi-
cal agents to reduce angiogenesis, inhibit inflammation,
promote repair, and reduce the risk of corneal melting.
Efforts at preventing ocular chemical burns are equally
important and deserve emphasis.
Kathryn Colby, MD, PhD, is a practicing cornea spe-
cialist at Massachusetts Eye and Ear Infirmary and
Children’s Hospital, Boston, and an assistant professor
of ophthalmology at Harvard Medical School, Boston,
Massachusetts.
vision to counting fingers, but the eye remained tectoni-
cally stable (Figure 9) with a normal intraocular pres-
sure. One year after the original injury, the patient was
ready to proceed with ocular surface reconstruction. A
superficial keratectomy and conjunctival resection was
performed OD. Two limbal stem cells grafts were har-
vested from the left eye and sutured into place on the
right eye. An amniotic membrane was sutured into place
over the right cornea and proximal conjunctiva. Her
Figure 9 One year following injury, immediately before ocu-
lar surface reconstruction. Vision is hand motion.
Figure 10 Five months following ocular surface reconstruc-
tion. Vision is 20/70.
Figure 8 Ten weeks following grade IV injury; the ocular
surface is conjunctivalized, but intact.
10 FOCAL POINTS : MODULE 1, 2010
Clinicians’Corner
1. Following a chemical injury, what is the preferred
method for irrigating the eye? Does the chemical
agent dictate the method?
Dr. Pfister: At the site of the injury, any clean source of
water can be used to lavage the eye, but ideally a bottle of
solution is already prepared for such emergencies. In the
emergency room, hand-held irrigation from intravenous
tubing is sufficient, but it is much more effective and
efficient to insert a contact lens with a fitting to accom-
modate the IV tubing (Morgan lens), delivering fluid into
the eye continuously over a 2-hour period.
Alkali and acid chemical injuries are best lavaged with
Ringer’s lactate solution, although most sterile isotonic
irrigants are acceptable. The pultaceous character of lime
(calcium hydroxide) often requires bulk removal with a
cotton-tipped applicator, facilitated by intermittent irri-
gation with a solution of EDTA, 0.01 M. EDTA should not
be used as a long-term irrigant because, in the presence
of an epithelial defect, penetration to endothelium might
well add additional damage by calcium chelation.
Dr. Tseng: For liquid chemicals, irrigation with clean
water or saline is usually sufficient if the conjunctival cul-
de-sac is well rinsed. This can be hard to achieve because
of the patient’s blepharospasm and pain. To circumvent
this concern, a Morgan lens is a good choice. For solid
chemicals (especially pressurized), including cement, sim-
ple irrigation is insufficient. All embedded debris needs to
be removed by forceps and if necessary by surgery.
2. Following irrigation, what is your immediate man-
agement of a grade II to IV alkali injury?
Dr. Pfister: Topical antibiotics and mydriatics/cyclople-
gics are “de rigeuer” shortly after the injury. The use
of a topical corticosteroid to suppress the inflammatory
response is controversial, but if a topical corticosteroid is
used, it must not be continued for more than 7 to 10 days
after the injury to avoid inhibition of wound repair and
Clinicians’ Corner provides additional viewpoints on
the subject covered in this issue of Focal Points. Con-
sultants have been invited by the Editorial Review
Board to respond to questions posed by the Acade-
my’s Practicing Ophthalmologists Advisory Committee
for Education. While the advisory committee reviews
the modules, consultants respond without reading the
module or one another’s responses. –Ed.
FOCAL POINTS : MODULE 1, 2010 11
of amniotic membrane over the cornea and conjunctiva
to determine the best fit. For fixation I place 4 vertical
mattress 9-0 Vicryl sutures through the amniotic mem-
brane and episclera in each quadrant at the limbus. I
use the remaining skirts of amniotic membrane to line
the cul-de-sacs, passing 8-0 Vicryl suture through the
upper and lower lids, temporally and nasally, to secure
the membrane to the conjunctival reflection. I can place
additional sutures, where needed, to further secure the
membrane in place.
When the acute process has subsided, I perform a sec-
ond, more definitive operation with amniotic membrane
as a base. These are my steps. (1) Resect any corneal pan-
nus and allow it to retract 4 to 6 mm from the limbus.
(2) Cut amniotic membrane to fit this corneoscleral
defect and use sutures and biologic adhesive (Tisseel) to
secure to the episclera. (3) Harvest 2 or 3 patches of cor-
neal stem cells, if available, from the patient’s other eye
or use patches from a blood relative or cadaver, in that
order of desirability. (4) Secure the stem cell patches at
the limbus using 10-0 nylon sutures through amniotic
membrane into the episclera.
Dr. Tseng: I use amniotic membrane whenever the epi-
thelium is not healing (if the defect is mostly within
the cornea), or if the defect involves most of the lim-
bus or beyond. In general, to resurrect the remaining
stem cells, the surgeon should transplant amniotic mem-
brane within 7 to 10 days. One layer of cryopreserved
amniotic membrane serves as a biological bandage cov-
ering cornea and involved conjunctiva, using a perilim-
bal 10-0 nylon purse-string suture. Alternatively, this
technique can now be simplified by insertion of a Pro-
Kera device (Bio-Tissue, Miami, FL), which is amniotic
membrane stretched across a symblepharon ring. If the
defect involves the fornix or tarsal conjunctiva, mem-
brane is best to be sutured from lid margin to lid margin
by anchoring sutures from the fornix through the lid
and tied across a bolster.
4. What is your management of corneal melting fol-
lowing chemical injury? What about descemeto-
cele or perforation?
Dr. Pfister: Corneal ulceration after chemical injury is
the result of destruction of both the devitalized and
acceleration of ulceration. In chemical injuries, inflam-
matory cell suppression must be balanced against dimin-
ished host keratocyte and fibroblast cell repair.
Treatment with EDTA, cysteine, or acetylcysteine has
been advocated as prevention against corneal ulceration,
based on their ability to inhibit metalloproteinases. Met-
alloproteinases act by degrading native and denatured
collagen, hence promoting ulceration.
Animal research has shown that topical 10% ascor-
bate and 10% citrate dramatically reduce the frequency
of corneal ulceration by inhibiting the effects of neutro-
phils and enhancing normal collagen synthesis. A combi-
nation of citrate and ascorbate, both 10%, results in only
a 4% incidence of corneal ulcer in animal eyes. Clinical
studies in humans bear out this favorable effect, espe-
cially in grade III or higher alkali injuries.
Dr. Tseng: My initial management is topical cortico-
steroids q2h, prophylactic antibiotics (preferably a fluo-
roquinolone) tid, oral vitamin C 2 grams/day, and oral
doxycycline 100 mg qd. Most important is to document
the extent of fluorescein-stained epithelial defects includ-
ing the cornea, limbus, and conjunctiva (from lid margin
to lid margin), and look for blanching of blood vessels,
indicating ischemia. This should be repeated in less than
1 week to determine whether there is acceptable healing
or an increase in ischemia, which frequently will take a
few days to weeks to become obvious.
3. What are the indications and timing for the use of
amniotic membrane? Describe your technique of
amniotic membrane transplantation.
Dr. Pfister: Amniotic membrane is commonly used in the
early phases after chemical injury to suppress the initial
inflammatory process and later to additionally create a
new substrate upon which epithelium can migrate. It
can be performed within a week or 2 of injury, but could
also be performed several weeks or even months later.
Later, amniotic membrane is commonly used in conjunc-
tion with stem cell transplants to encourage reformation
of an intact epithelial layer. It has been shown that, in
the absence of corneal stem cells, amniotic membrane
alone cannot heal the corneal epithelial surface.
My technique is to prepare the ocular surface by
removing any loose epithelial tissue. I place a large piece
12 FOCAL POINTS : MODULE 1, 2010
Clinicians’Corner
a melt. Both a neurotrophic state and ischemia can be
aggravated by limbal stem cell deficiency. However, the
stem cell deficiency tends to bring in conjunctivalization
with vascularization, which can prevent a melt.
5. What are the best ways to prevent symblepharon?
Dr. Pfister: If extensive alkali or acid injury of the con-
junctiva occurs, especially involving the cul-de-sacs, then
some degree of symblepharon is inevitable. Tradition-
ally a glass rod was used to separate raw conjunctival
surfaces shortly after the injury, only to have fibrin-
ous exudates tend to reform adhesions. Placement of a
thin plastic wrap, lining the cul-de-sacs, and suturing it
through the eyelid has been supplanted with amniotic
membrane sutured in a similar fashion, further limit-
ing the formation of symblephara. Lateral contraction
of subconjunctival scar, formed from fibrocytes invading
conjunctiva as part of the healing process, can obliterate
the cul-de-sacs and make visual rehabilitation very dif-
ficult. Amniotic membrane contains anti-inflammatory
factors, possibly limiting this propensity to scar.
Dr. Tseng: The best way to prevent symblepharon is to
perform amniotic membrane transplantation within the
first 10 days after injury. For patients with ischemia,
Tenonplasty is the only way to avoid symblepharon. For
those without ischemia and beyond 10 days from injury,
when granulation tissue is formed around the conjuncti-
val epithelial defect, prompt subconjunctival injection of
triamcinolone acetonide is effective in preventing sym-
blepharon. After a certain stage, there is no effective way
to prevent symblepharon.
6. Is there a role for topical cyclosporine to control
dry eye following chemical injury?
Dr. Pfister: Dry eye developing after chemical injury is
the consequence of destruction of goblet cells of the con-
junctiva and cicatricial closure of aqueous and lipid tear
gland orifices onto the surface of the conjunctiva. Unless
dry eye was present prior to the injury, it is difficult to
know how cyclosporine might improve tear dynamics
after chemical injury. Preservative-free artificial tears,
ointments, and gels would improve dry eye conditions,
but only by adding fluid to the eye. It is possible that top-
ical mucomimetics might improve mucus production—a
matter worthy of trial.
vital tissue framework of the cornea. Inflammatory cells
(principally polymorphonuclear cells, PMN) discharging
enzymes, including collagenases as well as superoxide
radicals, act as the proximal effecting agent. Although
EDTA, cysteine, and acetylcysteine inhibit collagenases,
they do not affect the PMN itself, allowing it to con-
tinue to produce degrading enzymes. A more direct and
orthomolecular approach is to employ 10% citrate (neu-
tralized) every hour, 14 hours a day to inhibit all activi-
ties of PMNs including chemoattraction, degranulation,
enzyme activation, and superoxide radical production. In
animals, this approach has lead to a significant statistical
reduction in corneal ulceration.
Topical drops prepared as a 25% to 40% solution, from
the patient’s own serum, can be helpful in closing persis-
tent epithelial defects and limiting ulceration. However,
when there is a total absence of stem cells, then serum
drops are not likely to result in epithelial closure.
Descemetocele or perforation is the end result of loss
of most or all corneal stroma in a localized area, hence
treatment is often the same for both. If the adjacent tis-
sues are not vascularized and are of good quality, then an
acceptable approach is immediate closure of the leak by
cyanoacrylate adhesive, covered by a contact lens. When
the adjacent tissues are of poor quality or are vascular-
ized, a surgical course is advised. Cleaning the wound of
necrotic and devitalized tissues is followed by placement,
and suture, of a lamellar graft into the stromal defect site
and then covering the entire cornea with fresh amniotic
membrane, sutured at the limbus. Alternately, suturing
layers of amniotic membrane into the ulcer bed, and cov-
ering with amniotic membrane, is acceptable. I favor the
former to achieve immediate and strong establishment
of ocular integrity.
Dr. Tseng: A severe neurotrophic state and ischemia are
the major causes of corneal or scleral melt in chemical
injury. For the former, the management starts with punc-
tal occlusion followed by autologous serum drops and a
bandage contact lens. If these treatments do not yield
improvement, one should move to amniotic membrane,
if within the first 10 days post-injury, or to tarsorrhaphy.
For the latter, a Tenonplasty is done to correct ischemia, at
the same time using amniotic membrane to promote epi-
thelialization. If a persistent epithelial defect has not led
to a corneal melt, another temporizing measure is to glue
a hard contact lens onto the corneal surface to prevent
FOCAL POINTS : MODULE 1, 2010 13
then clear-cut evidence of stem cell deficiency is present
and stem cell transplantation should be contemplated.
Naturally, all other potential causes of a persistent epi-
thelial defect must be eliminated.
The inflammatory response and mediators excited
by chemical injuries is severe and long lasting. Prior
data showed that waiting 18 months to perform corneal
transplantation improved the outcome by allowing the
inflammatory process to diminish. This delay might also
reduce the incidence of immune rejection in these high-
risk patients by reducing the number of immunoreac-
tive cells.
Dr. Tseng: For transplantation of either autologous (in
the form of conjunctival limbal autograft) or allogenic
(in the form of keratolimbal allograft) limbal stem cells,
transplantation is best performed when inflammation is
under control. Therefore, one should avoid performing
stem cell transplantation during the acute stage. Even at
the chronic stage, measures should be taken to restore
the ocular surface before such transplantation. For
example, all abnormalities of the lid margin, tarsus, and
lashes should be corrected; blinking should be restored
by symblepharon lysis and fornix reconstruction; and
dry eye linked to neurotrophic state should be effectively
managed. Except for such emergent situations as corneal
melt or perforation, when corneal transplantation may
be performed in the acute (inflamed) stage of chemical
injury to provide tectonic support, it should be deferred
for several months after limbal stem cell transplantation
corrects limbal stem cell deficiency.
9. When is a keratoprosthesis indicated? What ker-
atoprosthesis do you prefer following chemical
injuries?
Dr. Pfister: Over the years our success with conventional
corneal transplantation has improved considerably by
control of inflammation, maintenance of stromal integ-
rity, and stem cell transplantation. Nevertheless, kerato-
prostheses serve an important population of patients who
have not benefited from conventional corneal transplan-
tation. Keratoprostheses are considered as a last resort
after chemical injury when repeated corneal transplan-
tation fails on 2 or more occasions.
The Dohlman keratoprosthesis has the longest record
of success using a standardized protocol. There is 1 type
Dr. Tseng: No. Dry eye is caused by a neurotrophic state
following chemical burns. The chronic inflammation
caused by chemical burns is not lymphocytic.
7. When is cicatricial entropion commonly seen and
how do you manage this? Can it be prevented?
Dr. Pfister: Cicatricial entropion is commonly encoun-
tered weeks to months after the injury as scar tissue
near the tarsal conjunctival surface contracts, causing
inward rotation of the lid margin. Often this is associ-
ated with symblephara between the eyelid and eyeball.
In milder cases, lysis of symblephara and lining the raw
surfaces with buccal mucosa or amniotic membrane
might release the pressures of lid rotation and reduce
their reformation. More severe cases additionally require
splitting the eyelid at the gray line and advancing the
tarsus ahead of the eyelashes. Lysis of symblephara and
lining the conjunctival surface with amniotic membrane
offers the best opportunity for minimizing entropion.
Dr. Tseng: Cicatricial entropion is a late (several months)
complication of chemical burns that occurs when fornix
or tarsal injury has not been appropriately managed in
the acute stage. It can be prevented only by the measures
advised above including AMT, Tenonplasty, and control
of inflammation. Once formed at the chronic stage, cica-
tricial entropion can gradually cause corneal blindness;
hence, it should be surgically corrected by amniotic
membrane transplantation with or without oral mucosal
graft depending on the severity.
8. What is the proper timing of limbal stem cell trans-
plantation and corneal transplantation following
chemical injury?
Dr. Pfister: Successful limbal stem cell transplantation is
dependent on an intact episcleral vascular system, evi-
denced by the absence of necrosis or whitening of peril-
imbal tissues. Revascularization of these tissues normally
takes several weeks, allowing time to determine the true
extent of stem cell damage. It is very important to record
perilimbal fluorescein staining at the time of injury,
indicating stem cell loss. Whatever damage to stem cells
might have occurred, time should be allowed to give sur-
viving cells an opportunity to recover. When a persis-
tent epithelial defect is present for a period of 2 weeks
or more, despite conservative efforts to heal epithelium,
14 FOCAL POINTS : MODULE 1, 2010
Clinicians’Corner
odonto-keratoprosthesis (OOKP) procedure followed by
Dohlman’s KPro device (also called the Boston K-Pro,
developed at Massachusetts Eye and Ear Infirmary).
Roswell R. Pfister, MD, is a practicing ophthalmolo-
gist, Pfister Vision Correction Center, Birmingham,
Alabama.
Scheffer C.G. Tseng, MD, PhD, is director, Ocular Sur-
face Center, medical director, Ocular Surface Research &
Education Foundation, and director, R & D, TissueTech,
Miami, FL.
for an eye with normal tear film, and another type for a
dry eye. There are significant complications potentially
developing after the surgery, in addition to the inability
to reliably measure intraocular pressure. Despite this,
recent developments have significantly improved the
prognosis so that many patients have now been followed
for years with acceptable vision.
Dr. Tseng: A keratoprosthesis can be considered fol-
lowing chemical injury when ischemia is absent and
inflammation is at a chronic stage. The best indica-
tion is for eyes where the ocular surface cannot be
restored (eg, severe dry eye, intense inflammation, or
keratinization). For chemical burns, I prefer the osteo-
Wagoner MD, Kenyon KR. Chemical injuries. In: Shingleton
BJ, Hersh PS and Kenyon KR, eds. Eye Trauma. St Louis, MO:
Mosby; 1991:79–94.
Wagoner MD, Al-Swailem S, Al-Jastaneiah S, Kenyon KR.
Chemical injuries of the eye. In: Miller JW, Azar DT, Blodi B,
eds. Principles and Practice of Ophthalmology, 3rd ed. Philadel-
phia: WB Saunders; 2008:761–772.
Yaghouti F, Nouri M, Abad JC, Power WJ, Doane MG, Dohlman
CH. Keratoprosthesis: preoperative prognostic categories.
Cornea. 2001;20:19–23.
Zerbe BL, Belin MW, Ciolino JB; Boston Type 1 Keratoprosthe-
sis Study Group. Results from the multi-center Boston Type I
keratoprosthesis study. Ophthalmology. 2006;113:1779.
Related Academy Materials
Chemical injuries. In: External Disease and Cornea. Basic and
Clinical Science Course, Section 8, 2009–2010.
Nordlund ML, Brilakis HS, Holland EJ. Surgical Techniques for
Ocular Surface Reconstruction. Focal Points, Clinical Modules for
Ophthalmologists, Module 12, 2006.
Suggested Reading
Bagley DM, Casterton PL, Dressler WE, et al. Proposed new
classification scheme for chemical injury to the human eye.
Regul Toxicol Pharmacol. 2006;45:206–213.
Barouch F, Colby KA. Evaluation and initial management of
patients with ocular and adnexal trauma. In: Miller JW, Azar
DT, Blodi B, eds. Principles and Practice of Ophthalmology, 3rd ed.
Philadelphia: WB Saunders; 2008:5071–5092.
Holland EJ, Croasdale CR. Epithelial transplantation for the
management of severe ocular surface disease. In: Brightbill
FS, ed. Corneal Surgery: Theory, Technique & Tissue, 3rd ed.
St. Louis, MO: Mosby; 2009:488–499.
Hosseini H, Nejabat M, Mehryar M, Yazdchi T, Sedaghat A,
Noori F. Bevacizumab inhibits corneal neovascularization in
an alkali burn induced model of corneal angiogenesis.
Clin Experiment Ophthalmol. 2007;35:745–748.
Pfister RR. Chemical trauma. In: Foster CS, Azar DT, Dohlman
CH, eds. Smolin and Thoft’s The Cornea, 4th ed. Philadelphia, PA:
Lippincott, Williams and Wilkins; 2005:781–796.
Tejwani S, Kolari RS, Sangwan VS, Rao GN. Role of amniotic
membrane graft for ocular chemical and thermal injuries.
Cornea. 2007;26:21–26.
029032A

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Burns
BurnsBurns
Burns- chemical and pediatric by Dr. Sunil Keswani, National Burns Centre, Ai...
Burns- chemical and pediatric by Dr. Sunil Keswani, National Burns Centre, Ai...Burns- chemical and pediatric by Dr. Sunil Keswani, National Burns Centre, Ai...
Burns- chemical and pediatric by Dr. Sunil Keswani, National Burns Centre, Ai...
NationalBurnsCentre2000
 
Electricity and Electrical Injuries
Electricity and Electrical InjuriesElectricity and Electrical Injuries
Electricity and Electrical Injuries
SCGH ED CME
 
Ocular Chemical Burns - Pathophysiology and Evidence-Based Treatment
Ocular Chemical Burns - Pathophysiology and Evidence-Based TreatmentOcular Chemical Burns - Pathophysiology and Evidence-Based Treatment
Ocular Chemical Burns - Pathophysiology and Evidence-Based Treatment
Steven M. Christiansen
 
Electrical injuries
Electrical injuriesElectrical injuries
Electrical injuries
Sudhir Dev
 
Ocular chemical injury
Ocular chemical injuryOcular chemical injury
Ocular chemical injury
saanvi2011
 
математика1
математика1математика1
математика1DaryaF17
 
When does a lease start
When does a lease startWhen does a lease start
When does a lease start
George Azih
 
Jo chale tou_jaan_se_guzar_gaye_-_maha_malik
Jo chale tou_jaan_se_guzar_gaye_-_maha_malikJo chale tou_jaan_se_guzar_gaye_-_maha_malik
Jo chale tou_jaan_se_guzar_gaye_-_maha_malik
Dr.Muhammad Awais
 
雲端應用發展趨勢
雲端應用發展趨勢雲端應用發展趨勢
雲端應用發展趨勢佳芸 江
 
DOMA, Medicaid, and Asset Transfers
DOMA, Medicaid, and Asset TransfersDOMA, Medicaid, and Asset Transfers
DOMA, Medicaid, and Asset Transfers
Stephen Unsworth
 
5 creative uses of favicons
5 creative uses of favicons5 creative uses of favicons
5 creative uses of favicons
Arif Hossain
 
Becoming a nation
Becoming a nationBecoming a nation
Becoming a nation
Unice Jiaying
 
Breeding meat chickens
Breeding meat chickensBreeding meat chickens
Breeding meat chickens
Dr.Muhammad Awais
 
Matt Carpenter Visual Resume
Matt Carpenter Visual ResumeMatt Carpenter Visual Resume
Matt Carpenter Visual Resume
matty_carps
 

Viewers also liked (17)

Burns
BurnsBurns
Burns
 
Electric Burn
Electric BurnElectric Burn
Electric Burn
 
Burns- chemical and pediatric by Dr. Sunil Keswani, National Burns Centre, Ai...
Burns- chemical and pediatric by Dr. Sunil Keswani, National Burns Centre, Ai...Burns- chemical and pediatric by Dr. Sunil Keswani, National Burns Centre, Ai...
Burns- chemical and pediatric by Dr. Sunil Keswani, National Burns Centre, Ai...
 
Electricity and Electrical Injuries
Electricity and Electrical InjuriesElectricity and Electrical Injuries
Electricity and Electrical Injuries
 
Ocular Chemical Burns - Pathophysiology and Evidence-Based Treatment
Ocular Chemical Burns - Pathophysiology and Evidence-Based TreatmentOcular Chemical Burns - Pathophysiology and Evidence-Based Treatment
Ocular Chemical Burns - Pathophysiology and Evidence-Based Treatment
 
Electrical injuries
Electrical injuriesElectrical injuries
Electrical injuries
 
Ocular chemical injury
Ocular chemical injuryOcular chemical injury
Ocular chemical injury
 
математика1
математика1математика1
математика1
 
When does a lease start
When does a lease startWhen does a lease start
When does a lease start
 
Jo chale tou_jaan_se_guzar_gaye_-_maha_malik
Jo chale tou_jaan_se_guzar_gaye_-_maha_malikJo chale tou_jaan_se_guzar_gaye_-_maha_malik
Jo chale tou_jaan_se_guzar_gaye_-_maha_malik
 
雲端應用發展趨勢
雲端應用發展趨勢雲端應用發展趨勢
雲端應用發展趨勢
 
DOMA, Medicaid, and Asset Transfers
DOMA, Medicaid, and Asset TransfersDOMA, Medicaid, and Asset Transfers
DOMA, Medicaid, and Asset Transfers
 
5 creative uses of favicons
5 creative uses of favicons5 creative uses of favicons
5 creative uses of favicons
 
Becoming a nation
Becoming a nationBecoming a nation
Becoming a nation
 
Breeding meat chickens
Breeding meat chickensBreeding meat chickens
Breeding meat chickens
 
Jurnal cathrine0806083206
Jurnal cathrine0806083206Jurnal cathrine0806083206
Jurnal cathrine0806083206
 
Matt Carpenter Visual Resume
Matt Carpenter Visual ResumeMatt Carpenter Visual Resume
Matt Carpenter Visual Resume
 

Similar to Chemical burn

fundamental AAO .pdf
fundamental AAO .pdffundamental AAO .pdf
fundamental AAO .pdf
elizabeth242961
 
Point Value Descriptive TitlePurpose and Analytical .docx
Point Value Descriptive TitlePurpose and Analytical .docxPoint Value Descriptive TitlePurpose and Analytical .docx
Point Value Descriptive TitlePurpose and Analytical .docx
LeilaniPoolsy
 
Global Pharma Primer (Syllabus)
Global Pharma Primer (Syllabus)Global Pharma Primer (Syllabus)
Global Pharma Primer (Syllabus)
Arete-Zoe, LLC
 
Medical error health bizindia april-11-page-1
Medical error health bizindia april-11-page-1Medical error health bizindia april-11-page-1
Medical error health bizindia april-11-page-1
Dr.Ashok Khandelwal
 
Current Clinical Case Reorts & Research You Should Incorporate into Your Mode...
Current Clinical Case Reorts & Research You Should Incorporate into Your Mode...Current Clinical Case Reorts & Research You Should Incorporate into Your Mode...
Current Clinical Case Reorts & Research You Should Incorporate into Your Mode...
Dominick Maino
 
A paradigm shift from blame to fair and just culture –a middle east hospital ...
A paradigm shift from blame to fair and just culture –a middle east hospital ...A paradigm shift from blame to fair and just culture –a middle east hospital ...
A paradigm shift from blame to fair and just culture –a middle east hospital ...
Krishnan Sankara Narayanan MS, MBA, CPHQ, FASHRM, LHRM
 
AAO 219 RT
AAO 219 RTAAO 219 RT
AAO 219 RT
Nick Andrews
 
Murase2014
Murase2014Murase2014
Compliance Issues WorksheetYour Name First and lastYour E-m.docx
Compliance Issues WorksheetYour Name First and lastYour E-m.docxCompliance Issues WorksheetYour Name First and lastYour E-m.docx
Compliance Issues WorksheetYour Name First and lastYour E-m.docx
skevin488
 
Immuno-Oncology Course, organized by Healthcare Education Services
Immuno-Oncology Course, organized by Healthcare Education ServicesImmuno-Oncology Course, organized by Healthcare Education Services
Immuno-Oncology Course, organized by Healthcare Education Services
James Prudhomme
 
1 week 6 assignment ebp change process form ace star model
1 week 6 assignment  ebp change process form ace star model 1 week 6 assignment  ebp change process form ace star model
1 week 6 assignment ebp change process form ace star model
SUKHI5
 
Medication error
Medication errorMedication error
Medication error
Sandipkumar Bhatt
 
Novel treatment options for acute hf a multidisciplinary approach (printer f...
Novel treatment options for acute hf  a multidisciplinary approach (printer f...Novel treatment options for acute hf  a multidisciplinary approach (printer f...
Novel treatment options for acute hf a multidisciplinary approach (printer f...
drucsamal
 
Optometry as a Career Choice
Optometry as a Career ChoiceOptometry as a Career Choice
Optometry as a Career Choice
Brainware University
 
Scenarios to Define the Relationship Between Alcohol Use and Burnout for Medi...
Scenarios to Define the Relationship Between Alcohol Use and Burnout for Medi...Scenarios to Define the Relationship Between Alcohol Use and Burnout for Medi...
Scenarios to Define the Relationship Between Alcohol Use and Burnout for Medi...
Clinical Tools, Inc
 
Defining What is Value-Based Care for Patients with ​Relapsed/Refractory Chro...
Defining What is Value-Based Care for Patients with ​Relapsed/Refractory Chro...Defining What is Value-Based Care for Patients with ​Relapsed/Refractory Chro...
Defining What is Value-Based Care for Patients with ​Relapsed/Refractory Chro...
Carevive
 
A study of provision of Facilities and Fallacies of Eye Camps in India
A study of provision of Facilities and Fallacies of Eye Camps in IndiaA study of provision of Facilities and Fallacies of Eye Camps in India
A study of provision of Facilities and Fallacies of Eye Camps in India
SSR Institute of International Journal of Life Sciences
 
How to be an evidence-based practitioner
How to be an evidence-based practitionerHow to be an evidence-based practitioner
How to be an evidence-based practitioner
K. Challinor
 
Electronic Media Use in Academic Medical Center Patient Recruitment
Electronic Media Use in Academic Medical Center Patient RecruitmentElectronic Media Use in Academic Medical Center Patient Recruitment
Electronic Media Use in Academic Medical Center Patient Recruitment
Industry Standard Research
 
ARMB21.pptx
ARMB21.pptxARMB21.pptx
ARMB21.pptx
AdelSallam6
 

Similar to Chemical burn (20)

fundamental AAO .pdf
fundamental AAO .pdffundamental AAO .pdf
fundamental AAO .pdf
 
Point Value Descriptive TitlePurpose and Analytical .docx
Point Value Descriptive TitlePurpose and Analytical .docxPoint Value Descriptive TitlePurpose and Analytical .docx
Point Value Descriptive TitlePurpose and Analytical .docx
 
Global Pharma Primer (Syllabus)
Global Pharma Primer (Syllabus)Global Pharma Primer (Syllabus)
Global Pharma Primer (Syllabus)
 
Medical error health bizindia april-11-page-1
Medical error health bizindia april-11-page-1Medical error health bizindia april-11-page-1
Medical error health bizindia april-11-page-1
 
Current Clinical Case Reorts & Research You Should Incorporate into Your Mode...
Current Clinical Case Reorts & Research You Should Incorporate into Your Mode...Current Clinical Case Reorts & Research You Should Incorporate into Your Mode...
Current Clinical Case Reorts & Research You Should Incorporate into Your Mode...
 
A paradigm shift from blame to fair and just culture –a middle east hospital ...
A paradigm shift from blame to fair and just culture –a middle east hospital ...A paradigm shift from blame to fair and just culture –a middle east hospital ...
A paradigm shift from blame to fair and just culture –a middle east hospital ...
 
AAO 219 RT
AAO 219 RTAAO 219 RT
AAO 219 RT
 
Murase2014
Murase2014Murase2014
Murase2014
 
Compliance Issues WorksheetYour Name First and lastYour E-m.docx
Compliance Issues WorksheetYour Name First and lastYour E-m.docxCompliance Issues WorksheetYour Name First and lastYour E-m.docx
Compliance Issues WorksheetYour Name First and lastYour E-m.docx
 
Immuno-Oncology Course, organized by Healthcare Education Services
Immuno-Oncology Course, organized by Healthcare Education ServicesImmuno-Oncology Course, organized by Healthcare Education Services
Immuno-Oncology Course, organized by Healthcare Education Services
 
1 week 6 assignment ebp change process form ace star model
1 week 6 assignment  ebp change process form ace star model 1 week 6 assignment  ebp change process form ace star model
1 week 6 assignment ebp change process form ace star model
 
Medication error
Medication errorMedication error
Medication error
 
Novel treatment options for acute hf a multidisciplinary approach (printer f...
Novel treatment options for acute hf  a multidisciplinary approach (printer f...Novel treatment options for acute hf  a multidisciplinary approach (printer f...
Novel treatment options for acute hf a multidisciplinary approach (printer f...
 
Optometry as a Career Choice
Optometry as a Career ChoiceOptometry as a Career Choice
Optometry as a Career Choice
 
Scenarios to Define the Relationship Between Alcohol Use and Burnout for Medi...
Scenarios to Define the Relationship Between Alcohol Use and Burnout for Medi...Scenarios to Define the Relationship Between Alcohol Use and Burnout for Medi...
Scenarios to Define the Relationship Between Alcohol Use and Burnout for Medi...
 
Defining What is Value-Based Care for Patients with ​Relapsed/Refractory Chro...
Defining What is Value-Based Care for Patients with ​Relapsed/Refractory Chro...Defining What is Value-Based Care for Patients with ​Relapsed/Refractory Chro...
Defining What is Value-Based Care for Patients with ​Relapsed/Refractory Chro...
 
A study of provision of Facilities and Fallacies of Eye Camps in India
A study of provision of Facilities and Fallacies of Eye Camps in IndiaA study of provision of Facilities and Fallacies of Eye Camps in India
A study of provision of Facilities and Fallacies of Eye Camps in India
 
How to be an evidence-based practitioner
How to be an evidence-based practitionerHow to be an evidence-based practitioner
How to be an evidence-based practitioner
 
Electronic Media Use in Academic Medical Center Patient Recruitment
Electronic Media Use in Academic Medical Center Patient RecruitmentElectronic Media Use in Academic Medical Center Patient Recruitment
Electronic Media Use in Academic Medical Center Patient Recruitment
 
ARMB21.pptx
ARMB21.pptxARMB21.pptx
ARMB21.pptx
 

Chemical burn

  • 1. Chemical Injuries of the Cornea Kathryn Colby, MD, PhD VOLUME XXVIII NUMBER 1 MARCH 2010 (MODULE 1 OF 3) Reviewers and Contributing Editor George A. Stern, MD, Editor for Cornea & External Disease Kenneth M. Goins, MD, Basic and Clinical Science, Course Faculty, Section 8 Ron W. Pelton, MD, PhD, Practicing Ophthalmologists Advisory Committee for Education FocalPoints Consultants Roswell R. Pfister, MD Scheffer C.G. Tseng, MD, PhD Clinical Modules for Ophthalmologists
  • 2. Claiming CME Credit Academy members: To claim Focal Points CME cred- its, visit the Academy web site and access CME Central (http://one.aao.org/CE/MyCMEPortfolio/default.aspx) to view and print your Academy transcript and report CME credit you have earned. You can claim up to two AMA PRA Category 1 Credits™ per module. This will give you a maximum of 24 credits for the 2010 subscrip- tion year. CME credit may be claimed for up to three (3) years from date of issue. Non-Academy members: For assistance please send an e-mail to customer_service @aao.org or a fax to (415) 561-8575. Focal Points (ISSN 0891-8260) is published quarterly by the American Acad- emy of Ophthalmology at 655 Beach St., San Francisco, CA 94109-1336. For domestic subscribers, print with online 1-year subscription is $187 for Academy members (2 years, $337; 3 years, $477) and $252 for nonmembers (2 years, $455; 3 years, $642). International subscribers, please visit www.aao.org/ focalpoints for more information. Online-only 1-year subscription is $155 for Academy members (2 years, $277; 3 years, $395) and $209 for nonmembers (2 years, $375; 3 years, $535). Periodicals postage paid at San Francisco, CA, and additional mailing offices. POSTMASTER: Send address changes to Focal Points, P.O. Box 7424, San Francisco, CA 94120-7424. The American Academy of Ophthalmology is accredited by the Accredita- tion Council for Continuing Medical Education to provide continuing medical education for physicians. The American Academy of Ophthalmology designates this educational activity for a maximum of two AMA PRA Category 1 Credits™. Physicians should only claim credit commensurate with the extent of their participation in the activity. Reporting your CME online is one benefit of Academy membership. Non- members may request a Focal Points CME Claim Form by contacting Focal Points, 655 Beach St., San Francisco, CA 94109-1336. The Academy provides this material for educational purposes only. It is not intended to represent the only or best method or procedure in every case, nor to replace a physician’s own judgment or give specific advice for case manage- ment. Including all indications, contraindications, side effects, and alternative agents for each drug or treatment is beyond the scope of this material. All information and recommendations should be verified, prior to use, with current information included in the manufacturers’ package inserts or other indepen- dent sources and considered in light of the patient’s condition and history. Reference to certain drugs, instruments, and other products in this publica- tion is made for illustrative purposes only and is not intended to constitute an endorsement of such. Some material may include information on applica- tions that are not considered community standard, that reflect indications not included in approved FDA labeling, or that are approved for use only in restricted research settings. The FDA has stated that it is the responsibility of the physi- cian to determine the FDA status of each drug or device he or she wishes to use, and to use them with appropriate informed patient consent in compliance with applicable law. The Academy specifically disclaims any and all liability for injury or other damages of any kind, from negligence or otherwise, for any and all claims that may arise out of the use of any recommendations or other information contained herein. The author(s) listed made a major contribution to this module. Substantive editorial revisions may have been made based on reviewer recommendations. Subscribers requesting replacement copies 6 months and later from the cover date of the issue being requested will be charged the current module replacement rate. ©2010 American Academy of Ophthalmology®. All rights reserved. ii FOCAL POINTS : MODULE 1, 2010 This icon in text denotes video clips in the online edition. http://one.aao.org/CE/EducationalProducts/FocalPoints.aspx Focal Points Editorial Review Board George A. Stern, MD, Missoula, MT Editor in Chief; Cornea & External Disease William S. Clifford, MD, Garden City, KS Glaucoma Surgery; Liaison for Practicing Ophthalmologists Advisory Committee for Education D. Michael Colvard, MD, FACS, Encino, CA Cataract Surgery Bradley S. Foster, MD, Springfield, MA Retina & Vitreous Anil D. Patel, MD, Oklahoma City, OK Neuro-Ophthalmology Eric P. Purdy, MD, Fort Wayne, IN Oculoplastic, Lacrimal, & Orbital Surgery Steven I. Rosenfeld, MD, FACS, Delray Beach, FL Refractive Surgery, Optics & Refraction C. Gail Summers, MD, Minneapolis, MN Pediatric Ophthalmology & Strabismus Albert T. Vitale, MD, Salt Lake City, UT Ocular Inflammation & Tumors Focal Points Staff Susan R. Keller, Acquisitions Editor Kim Torgerson, Publications Editor Clinical Education Secretaries and Staff Gregory L. Skuta, MD, Senior Secretary for Clinical Education, Oklahoma City, OK Louis B. Cantor, MD, Secretary for Ophthalmic Knowledge, Indianapolis, IN Richard A. Zorab, Vice President, Ophthalmic Knowledge Hal Straus, Director of Print Publications
  • 3. FOCAL POINTS : MODULE 1, 2010 1 Introduction Chemical injuries of the cornea are ophthalmic emergen- cies. These injuries often result in significant ocular mor- bidity and generally strike young adults in the prime of life. Classification schemes enable the ophthalmologist to determine the severity of the injury and the prognosis for the injured eye. Immediate management consists of copious irrigation following the exposure. Effective man- agement in the intermediate and late phases requires an understanding of the cellular events occurring during each phase. Appropriate medical and surgical care helps ensure the best outcomes for these potentially blinding injuries. Epidemiology of Chemical Injuries Similar to open globe injuries, most chemical injuries occur in young men. In published series of chemical inju- ries, approximately two-thirds of patients are men. The visual impact of chemical injuries is magnified because they generally occur in patients in the prime of life. While a small percentage of chemical injuries are delib- erately inflicted during an assault, the vast majority (90%) are accidental. Approximately two-thirds of chemical injuries occur in the workplace. The bulk of workplace- related chemical injuries occur at construction sites, Contents Introduction 1 Epidemiology of Chemical Injuries• 1 Causative Agents 2 Classification Schemes 2 Stages of Ocular Surface Recovery Following Chemical Injury 3 Management Strategies 4 Medical Therapies• 4 Role and Timing of Surgical Treatment• Following Chemical Injury 6 Putting It All Together: A Case Report 8 Conclusion 9 Clinicians’ Corner 10 Financial Disclosures The authors, reviewers, and consultants disclose the following finan- cial relationships. Kathryn Colby, MD, PhD: (C) Alcon Laboratories, Vistakon Johnson & Johnson Visioncare; (E) Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation. D. Michael Colvard, MD, FACS: (C) Advanced Medical Optics, Bausch & Lomb; (P) OASIS Medical. Ron W. Pelton, MD, PhD: (L) AO-ASIF. Steven I. Rosenfeld, MD, FACS: (L) Allergan. Scheffer C.G. Tseng, MD, PhD: (C) Bio-Tissue; (E) TissueTech; (O, P) Bio-Tissue, TissueTech. C. Gail Summers, MD: (C) McKesson. Albert T. Vitale, MD: (C) Bausch & Lomb Surgical. The following contributors state that they have no significant financial interest or other relationship with the manufacturer of any commer- cial product discussed in their contributions to this module or with the manufacturer of any competing commercial product: William S. Clifford, MD; Bradley S. Foster, MD; Kenneth M. Goins, MD; Anil D. Patel, MD; Roswell R. Pfister, MD, Eric P. Purdy, MD; George A. Stern, MD. C = Consultant fee, paid advisory boards or fees for attending a meeting E = Employed by a commercial entity L = Lecture fees (honoraria), travel fees or reimbursements when speaking at the invitation of a commercial entity O = Equity ownership/stock options of publicly or privately traded firms (excluding mutual funds) P = Patents and/or royalties that might be viewed as creating a potential conflict of interest S = Grant support Learning Objectives Upon completion of this module, the reader should be able to: Describe the classification scheme and• epidemiology of chemical injuries of the cornea Consider management strategies for each stage of• healing after a chemical injury of the cornea Appraise the surgical approaches to chemical• injuries of the cornea in acute and late phases of management
  • 4. 2 FOCAL POINTS : MODULE 1, 2010 chemical plants, and machine factories. Safety glasses, the best defense against chemical injuries, are unfortu- nately no match for strong chemicals under high pressure that characterize many industrial accidents. The remain- ing one-third of injuries occur at home, with only a small percentage occurring at school. In contrast to industrial accidents, chemical injuries in the home can often be pre- vented by the use of appropriate safety glasses. Causative Agents Injuries caused by alkali agents are more common and generally more serious than those caused by acids. Alka- lis penetrate tissue more readily than acids due to their ability to saponify cell membranes. Strong alkali agents can reach the anterior chamber within 15 seconds of exposure, causing cell death and corneal hydrolysis along the way. Alkali agents that cause ocular injuries include ammo- nia, lye (sodium hydroxide), potassium hydroxide, magne- sium hydroxide, and lime. Ammonia, found in fertilizers, refrigerants, and cleaning solutions, is especially danger- ous because it penetrates tissues almost instantaneously and can liberate toxic fumes when combined with water. Lye, present in drain cleaners, is almost as dangerous as ammonia. Potassium hydroxide, found in caustic potash, does not penetrate as rapidly as lye and is a less com- mon cause of serious injury. Magnesium hydroxide, found in firework sparklers and flares, produces damage through both chemical and thermal mechanisms. Lime, a component of plaster, mortar, cement, and whitewash, is the most common cause of workplace chemical inju- ries overall. Lime’s slow speed of penetration lessens the severity of the injury. However, solid particles of lime can become lodged in the conjunctiva (especially the upper palpebral conjunctiva or fornix) and can act as a reservoir, slowly releasing damaging chemicals. Ocular injuries are caused by multiple acid agents, including sulfuric acid, sulfurous acid, hydrofluoric acid, acetic acid, and hydrochloric acid. Exploding car batter- ies are a source of sulfuric acid; these injuries can be asso- ciated with ocular lacerations from released particulate matter. Sulfurous acid, found in bleach and refrigerant, penetrates more easily than other acids due to its high lipid and water solubility. Hydrofluoric acid, used in glass polishing and mineral refining, causes severe injury due to the rapid penetration of the fluoride ion into the cor- nea, which rivals that of the alkali agents. Systemic burns, even ones involving a tiny percentage of the body’s sur- face area (2%), can be fatal due to uncontrolled metabolic perturbations. Acetic acid, found in vinegar and as glacial acetic acid, generally only produces injury if the eye is exposed to a high-concentration form for an extended period of time. Finally, hydrochloric acid penetrates poorly and only causes damage following prolonged exposure. Classification Schemes The severity of a chemical injury and its prognosis can usually be determined based upon the initial examina- tion. To grade an injury, the physician determines the extent of damage to the corneal epithelium, limbus, and conjunctiva. The presence or absence (and the magni- tude) of limbal ischemia is noted, as is the quality of the view through the cornea. These features are then used to classify the injury (Table 1). Table 1. Prognostic Features of Chemical Injury GRADE OF INJURY CLINICAL FINDINGS PROGNOSIS Grade I Corneal epithelial defect No corneal haze No loss of limbal stem cells Excellent Grade II Cornea mildly hazy Focal limbal ischemia Generally good; may have focal conjunctivalization of cornea in area of limbal stem cell loss Grade III Severe corneal haze limits view of anterior segment structures Extensive limbal ischemia with loss of most limbal stem cells Guarded; cornea must be repopulated with conjunctiva; surgery needed for visual rehabilitation Grade IV Complete loss of corneal and proximal conjunctival epithelium Cornea opaque Complete limbal ischemia and loss of all limbal stem cells Extremely poor; melting likely; globe salvage may not be possible
  • 5. FOCAL POINTS : MODULE 1, 2010 3 grade IV injuries despite aggressive medical and surgical management. A recently described classification scheme by Bagley and colleagues also suggests the importance of the depth of the corneal injury and the involvement of the corneal endothelium in the prognosis of chemical injuries. Stages of Ocular Surface Recovery Following Chemical Injury An understanding of the biological events that take place following a chemical exposure will aid the clinician in The Hughes classification scheme (as modified by Thoft) divides chemical injuries into 4 categories. A grade I injury involves the corneal epithelium only. In a grade I injury, the limbal stem cells, which serve as the source of differentiated corneal epithelium, are spared. The cornea, although denuded of epithelium, remains clear. There is no limbal ischemia. The prognosis for a full recovery of normal corneal appearance and function is excellent. A grade II injury is characterized by a partial loss of the limbal stem cells with focal limbal ischemia. The cornea is hazy, but anterior segment structures (iris, lens) can still be visualized (Figure 1). The prognosis for grade II injuries is generally good, but there may be long-term persistent epithelial dysfunction in the area that sus- tained stem cell loss, with focal replacement of corneal epithelium with conjunctival epithelium (conjunctival- ization), haze, and neovascularization. Grade III injuries have a guarded prognosis due to com- plete loss of the corneal epithelium and loss of most, if not all, of the limbal stem cells (Figure 2). Up to 50% of the limbus is frankly ischemic and corneal haze limits visualization of the iris and lens. Following grade III inju- ries, resurfacing of the cornea can only be accomplished by growth of conjunctival epithelium over the corneal stroma. While conjunctival ingrowth will restore the tectonic stability of the globe, it does not allow for good vision due to vascularization and scarring. The prognosis of grade IV injuries is extremely poor. In these injuries, there is complete loss of corneal epi- thelium and limbal stem cells plus loss of the proximal conjunctival epithelium (Figure 3). The injured cornea is opaque, allowing no view into the anterior cham- ber. More than 50% of the limbus is ischemic. With no endogenous source of epithelium to repopulate the cor- neal surface, sterile ulceration is a common sequela of Figure 1 Acute grade II burn with focal (approximately 3 clock hours) of limbal stem cell loss. Figure 2 Acute grade III burn showing extensive corneal haze impeding visualization of the iris and limbal ischemia of approximately 6 clock hours. Figure 3 Acute grade IV burn with porcelainization of the cornea and bulbar conjunctiva.
  • 6. 4 FOCAL POINTS : MODULE 1, 2010 managing these injuries. One can divide the events into 4 phases: initial (day 0), acute (days 0 to 7), intermediate or early repair (days 7 to 21), and late repair (after day 21). In the weeks immediately following a chemical injury, there is interplay of multiple events as the cornea attempts to repair itself. These events include epithelial regrowth and migration, collagen synthesis and degrada- tion, and activation and migration of keratocytes. During the first week, epithelial regrowth begins if there are sufficient undamaged limbal stem cells to provide a source of healthy corneal epithelium. Treat- ment efforts are directed at encouraging this growth, by quelling inflammation and avoiding topical medica- tions that might damage the fragile epithelium. Kerato- cyte activation begins in response to the injury, allowing the initiation of collagen synthesis. Little or no collagen breakdown occurs in the first week following injury. Epithelial migration continues during the early repair phase (days 7 to 21). Mild injuries may show complete re-epithelialization during this phase, while grade II injuries may display a focal persistent epithelial defect, corresponding to the area of limbal stem cell destruc- tion (Figure 4a). More severe injuries typically show little or no re-epithelialization during this period. Eyes with grade IV injuries typically retain their ischemic appear- ance. Ocular surface inflammation persists as long as the corneal surface remains denuded. Keratocytes con- tinue to function during this phase to repair damage to the corneal stroma. Activity of collagenases (produced by both keratocytes and invading inflammatory cells) peaks by day 14 to 21 while collagen synthesis contin- ues. The relative strength of these opposing forces deter- mines whether corneal melting will occur. Treatment approaches in this phase attempt to maximize collagen synthesis while minimizing collagenase activation to reduce the risk of sterile ulceration of the cornea. Cor- neal perforation will ensue if sterile melting cannot be arrested. Once the corneal surface is intact, collagenase activity decreases as does the risk of corneal melting. The late repair phase occurs after day 21. In mild inju- ries in which the limbal stem cell population is intact, a normal corneal surface is re-established. Focal limbal stem cell loss (grade II) may lead to focal conjunctivaliza- tion of the cornea in the area of the stem cell defect (Fig- ure 4b). For grade III injuries, delayed re-epithelialization is the norm, although with proper medical and surgi- cal management, eventually the corneal surface will be repopulated with conjunctival epithelium. Grade IV inju- ries have an extremely poor prognosis due to the com- plete loss of limbal stem cells and adjacent conjunctiva. Despite optimal management, these eyes often cannot be saved. Management Strategies There are 3 main goals in managing a chemical injury: enhance recovery of the corneal epithelium; augment collagen synthesis while minimizing collagen break- down and sterile ulceration; and control inflammation. In severe cases, surgical treatment may be indicated. Table 2 summarizes initial treatments based on the grade of the injury. Medical Therapies Irrigation. Initial management of an acute chemical injury is relatively straightforward. The severity of a chemical burn is a function of both the toxicity of the agent involved and the duration of exposure. Time is of the essence, since chemical burns are one of the only true ophthalmic emergencies. The eye should be copi- ously irrigated as quickly as possible after the exposure Figure 4 Grade II burn. a. Twenty-nine days following grade II burn with focal thinning and impending perforation. Tissue adhesive and a bandage contact lens were applied. Same patient as Figure 1. b. Final result following grade II burn with focal corneal melt, treated with tissue adhesive. Vision 20/20 but patient complains of photophobia. a b
  • 7. FOCAL POINTS : MODULE 1, 2010 5 with whatever clean fluid is available. Irrigation should be repeated upon arrival to the hospital, since irriga- tion at the location of the injury or in the ambulance is often insufficient to entirely remove the offending agent. Once irrigation is complete, the pH of the ocular surface is checked with expanded range pH paper. If the pH has normalized (7.0 to 7.2), then the rest of the history can be taken and the eye examined. If the pH is still abnormal, then irrigation should be continued and the pH measure- ment repeated. The pH should be rechecked every 15 to 30 minutes to ensure that it remains normal. A pH that rises after initial normalization suggests that trapped par- ticulate matter (for example, particles of plaster) is con- tinuing to leach chemical onto the surface of the eye. Exam. A complete ophthalmic exam is performed, includ- ing inspection and sweeping of the inferior and superior fornix to remove trapped particles. Intraocular pressure is checked, since chemical injuries may cause an acute pressure increase. The injury is graded based upon the extent of damage to the cornea, limbus, and conjunctiva. In an acute chemical injury, a white “porcelainized” eye typically denotes extensive limbal ischemia, represent- ing severe damage. This is occasionally misinterpreted as a mild injury by an inexperienced observer. Similarly, a cornea that is completely denuded of epithelium will take up fluorescein stain poorly, leading the examiner to underestimate the initial extent of the damage. One should also inspect the chemical safety sheet for the agent in question. Certain agents such as hydrofluoric acid can cause life-threatening metabolic imbalances; patients injured by this agent need concurrent medical evaluation. Initial Treatment. During the acute phase of recovery (first week after the injury), the goal is to encourage epithelial healing while controlling inflammation and preventing superinfection. Patients with mild injuries (grade I) can be placed on a topical antibiotic ointment such as erythromycin 4 times a day. A cycloplegic agent can be given to help with comfort (cyclopentolate 2 to 3 times daily or a single dose of scopolamine given by the examiner). Preservative-free artificial tears can also provide comfort following a chemical injury. Even mild chemical injuries have significant associated inflamma- tion, and we would typically give topical corticosteroids, usually prednisolone acetate 1% 4 times a day, with a rapid taper to off once the corneal epithelium is healed. Patients with mild chemical injuries are followed every 1 to 2 days until the ocular surface is stable. Patients may experience ocular discomfort even months after a relatively minor chemical injury. Supportive measures such as lubrication and treatment of any associated Table 2. Initial Treatment Paradigms Based on Grade of Injury GRADE OF INJURY RECOMMENDED TREATMENT Grade I Topical antibiotic ointment (erythromycin or similar) qid Prednisolone acetate 1% qid Preservative-free artificial tears as needed Consider short-acting cycloplegia (cyclopentolate tid or a single drop of scopolamine) Grade II Topical antibiotic drop (fluoroquinolone) qid Prednisolone acetate 1% hourly while awake (first 7–10 days); taper corticosteroids if epithelium not healed by day 10–14 Atropine sulfate bid Sodium ascorbate drops (10%) hourly while awake Vitamin C, 2 grams po qid Doxycycline, 100 mg po bid Preservative-free artificial tears as needed Oral pain medicines as needed Progestational steroids (1% medroxyprogesterone) qid if epithelial defect persists after day 10 Debridement of necrotic epithelium as needed Application of tissue adhesive as needed Grade III As for grade II Amniotic membrane considered if epithelial healing halts Grade IV As for grades II/III Early surgery (amniotic membrane, advancement of posterior conjunctiva) usually necessary given severity of ocular surface damage
  • 8. 6 FOCAL POINTS : MODULE 1, 2010 meibomian gland dysfunction or dry eye will help return the ocular surface to its pre-injury state. For burns of grade II and above, the importance of intensive topical corticosteroids in the acute phase can- not be overemphasized. There is concern that topical corticosteroids can exacerbate corneal melting. While this is true in the later stages of chemical injury man- agement, in the acute stage topical corticosteroids are very beneficial for controlling the severe inflammatory sequelae and should be used in an appropriately aggres- sive fashion. Corneal melting from activation of corneal collagenases typically does not begin before 10 to 14 days after the injury. Therefore, the first week represents a window in which corticosteroids can and should be used to quell the raging inflammation and give the ocular sur- face a chance to heal. For grade II burns and above, we typically use prednisolone acetate 1% hourly while the patient is awake. Additional considerations include the following: Long-acting cycloplegia (ie, atropine sulfate 2 times• daily) is beneficial. Oral narcotics are often required for pain control.• A stronger topical antibiotic (such as a fluoroqui-• nolone) is given at least 4 times daily to reduce the risk of bacterial superinfection. Topical sodium ascorbate (10%) and oral vitamin C• supplementation are given to promote collagen syn- thesis. Ascorbate, a cofactor in the rate-limiting step of collagen synthesis, may be depleted following a chemi- cal injury. Animal data suggests that ascorbate admin- istration may reduce corneal ulceration. Oral tetracycline derivatives are given to reduce the• risk of ulceration due to their inhibitory effects on cor- neal matrix metalloproteinases. They may also help to reduce ocular surface inflammation. Preservative-free tear supplements may be adminis-• tered as needed. Glaucoma medications (topical or oral) are prescribed• if the intraocular pressure is elevated. There is little role for topical nonsteroidal agents in• a severe chemical injury. Their anti-inflammatory power is dwarfed by that of the recommended topical corticosteroids and they have the potential to cause issues with epithelial healing. Similarly, bandage contact lenses are of marginal util-• ity in the acute management of chemical burns, as the eye is usually too inflamed to tolerate a foreign body on its surface. Monitoring and Follow-Up. Patients with severe chem- ical injuries (grade II and above) should be followed daily initially. If there is a concern about compliance, consideration should be given to inpatient admission. Once epithelial healing is progressing, then follow-up visits can be reduced accordingly. However, it is impor- tant to maintain close observation while patients remain on topical corticosteroids. The real “art” of managing chemical burns comes after the first week. For milder injuries (grade I and less severe grade II), epithelial regrowth within the first 7 to 10 days is typical. Once epithelial regrowth is progress- ing, topical corticosteroids can be tapered, with cessa- tion of therapy once the epithelium is completely intact and the eye is quiet. Lubrication and management of co- existing dry eye and meibomian gland dysfunction will help with post-injury discomfort. For more severe grade II injuries and all grade III inju- ries, complete epithelial healing usually takes longer than 10 days. At this point, the risk of corneal melting increases due to the shift towards collagen breakdown at the expense of collagen synthesis. Topical corticoster- oids must be tapered if the epithelium is not intact. Low- dose corticosteroids (prednisolone acetate 1% once or twice daily) may be continued if the patient is followed closely, because corneal melting can occur precipitously in these patients. In place of corticosteroids, topical pro- gestational steroids such as 1% medroxyprogesterone can be started to provide some anti-inflammatory effect without inducing corneal melting. Other medicines are continued. If epithelial healing falters or comes to a com- plete halt or progressive corneal melting occurs, then one must resort to the surgical maneuvers described in the next section. In grade IV injuries, medical therapy alone will not restore the epithelial integrity of the eye, and surgery is virtually always required. One may begin medical man- agement initially to quiet the eye, but with the knowl- edge that this is purely a temporizing measure. Role and Timing of Surgical Treatment Following Chemical Injury Debridement. Mild chemical injuries rarely require sur- gery for management. More severe grade II injuries may require focal debridement of necrotic corneal or conjunc- tival epithelium. This should be done as early as possible, because the necrotic tissue serves as a source of inflam- matory mediators that can inhibit re-epithelialization. Necrotic corneal epithelium can be removed at the slit lamp with surgical sponges. Extensive necrotic conjunc- tiva can be excised with scissors using topical anesthesia with the aid of a slit lamp or under an operating micro- scope. Occasionally grade II injuries show focal corneal melting that can usually be managed with the appli-
  • 9. FOCAL POINTS : MODULE 1, 2010 7 cation of cyanoacrylate tissue adhesive covered with a bandage contact lens. Grade III injuries often require surgery for both acute and long-term management. In the acute phase, necrotic tissue should be debrided whenever needed, for the rea- sons detailed above. Restoration of the Corneal Surface. If epithelium (either corneal or conjunctival) does not begin to grow in to cover the cornea or if regrowth begins but then fails to progress, placement of an amniotic membrane within the first several weeks after the injury may be useful. Amniotic membrane has anti-inflammatory properties and can provide a scaffold for the regrowth of epithe- lium. It can be sutured (using either 10.0 Vicryl or 10.0 nylon) or glued (using Tisseel fibrin glue) into place. Amniotic membrane on a conformer ring (ProKera, Bio- Tissue, Miami, FL) can also be used in this setting, often with a tarsorrhaphy to prevent dislocation of the mem- brane. However, despite the useful properties of amniotic membrane in this setting, it does not replace limbal stem cells, but may allow conjunctival epithelium to grow in to cover the cornea. In severe injuries, one often must be satisfied, in the short-term at least, with an eye that is resurfaced by vascularized, conjunctival epithelium. While this is not compatible with good vision, at least this restores tectonic stability to the eye and eliminates the risk of progressive corneal melting. ONLINE VIDEO: Amniotic Membrane in Acute Chemical Burn, 8 min 26 sec ONLINE VIDEO: Use of Sutureless Amniotic Membrane, 1 min 25 sec Some clinicians advocate the use of amniotic mem- brane transplantation acutely in all serious chemical injuries (grade II and above). In our hospital, we gen- erally reserve amniotic membrane for chemical inju- ries that do not respond to initial medical management. Amniotic membrane is a useful adjunct, but it is quite expensive and not covered by some insurers in our area, so we prefer to limit its use to situations in which we know it is required. The same management strategies can be used in grade IV injuries, although the complete destruction of the limbal stem cell population and limbal conjunctiva makes it unlikely that they will be successful. Mobiliza- tion and advancement of more posterior conjunctiva and Tenon’s capsule can be used to bring healthy tissue into the damaged area and may increase the likelihood of ini- tial stabilization of these badly damaged globes. Eyelid issues such as malpositions or trichiasis may accompany severe chemical injuries and need to be addressed to prevent further damage to the cornea and inhibition of epithelial healing. Ongoing Suppression of Inflammation. Once the cor- neal surface has been restored, either with corneal epithelium in less severe burns, or with conjunctival epithelium in more severe burns, the frequency of fol- low-up can be reduced. Severely burned eyes will benefit from ongoing suppression of inflammation with low- dose corticosteroids or topical cyclosporine. Bland oph- thalmic ointment and preservative-free artificial tears will help improve ocular comfort. Stem Cell Transplantation. Following a severe unilateral chemical injury in which there has been loss of most or all of the limbal stem cell population, one can con- sider an autologous limbal stem cell transplant from the patient’s other eye, described in detail by Nordlund et al. Caution should be exercised if the other eye was dam- aged as well, since even mild injuries can deplete the stem cell reserve to the point that harvesting some of the stem cells may lead to the surface epitheliopathy in the good eye. If the original injury was bilateral or there is concern about the viability of the stem cell population in the good eye, then there are several options. One can con- sider a living-related stem cell graft from a family mem- ber or a cadaveric donor. Both of these require systemic immunosuppression, which adds to the complexity of postoperative management. Cultured buccal mucosa has shown some utility in this situation, although again, like amniotic membrane alone, buccal mucosa does not con- tain limbal stem cells. A novel approach involves the use of the patient’s own limbal stem cells that have been expanded in culture in vitro and then transplanted back on to the injured eye. This allows harvesting of a much smaller amount of limbal stem cells, which can be useful when one is unsure of the status of the stem cell popula- tion in the good eye. Additional Measures and Follow-Up. Once the health of the ocular surface has been restored, then a corneal trans- plant can be considered if needed. Supportive measures including concurrent amniotic membrane transplanta- tion and suture tarsorrhaphy may also be performed to promote epithelial healing of the corneal transplant. The graft should be secured with interrupted sutures (rather than with a running suture) to allow selective suture removal if corneal neovascularization ensues. Postoper- ative management includes topical steroids, antibiotics
  • 10. 8 FOCAL POINTS : MODULE 1, 2010 membrane was sutured over the cornea and proximal conjunctiva on day 12. Epithelial healing was first noted 25 days after the injury (Figure 6) and melting did not occur. Six weeks following the injury, a small epithelial defect remained without thinning. The superior conjunc- tiva remained ischemic (Figure 7). Ten weeks following the injury, the surface was completely intact (although covered by conjunctiva), with 20/400 vision and a nor- mal intraocular pressure (Figure 8). Prednisolone acetate (1%) was continued once daily. The patient was unable to return to her occupation due to her poor vision in this eye and reduced stereopsis, and she sought career retraining during this time. The eye was allowed to quiet during the months follow- ing the injury. Neovascularization progressed, reducing and possibly cyclosporine. Occasionally restoration of the ocular surface is enough to allow acceptable vision, however, and a penetrating keratoplasty is not required (see below). Permanent Boston keratoprostheses have been used in chemical burn patients with reasonable success. This type of device is especially useful in bilateral severe burns, because its success is not dependent upon limbal stem cell function and it does not require the use of sys- temic immunosuppression. Putting It All Together: A Case Report A healthy, 27-year-old chef presented to the Massachu- setts Eye and Ear Infirmary after a high-pressure ammo- nium chloride burn to the right eye. Her eye was irrigated at work immediately after the injury. Ocular pH upon arrival was 7.1. Further irrigation was performed; the pH remained stable. Vision was count fingers and intraocu- lar pressure was 18. Slit-lamp exam revealed virtually complete limbal ischemia (Figure 5) and loss of all proxi- mal conjunctival epithelium, consistent with a grade IV injury. The left eye was uninjured. Hourly 1% predni- solone acetate was started, along with topical antibiot- ics, atropine, and 10% sodium ascorbate. Oral vitamin C (2 grams daily) and doxycycline (100 mg twice daily) were begun. She was followed daily. She did not tolerate the doxycycline, which was discontinued. By day 10, there was no epithelial healing and corti- costeroids were tapered to 4 times daily. An amniotic Figure 7 Six weeks following injury; epithelial healing is progressing, with a small central epithelial defect remain- ing without corneal thinning. Superior conjunctiva remains ischemic in appearance. Figure 5 Acute grade IV burn from high-pressure ammo- nium chloride injury at work. Figure 6 Twenty-five days following injury, 13 days following amniotic membrane transplantation.
  • 11. FOCAL POINTS : MODULE 1, 2010 9 postoperative course was uneventful. Five months after reconstructive surgery, vision was 20/70 uncorrected with an intact corneal epithelium and a white and quiet eye (Figure 10). No further surgery was recommended. Conclusion With appropriate management, it is possible to restore vision to all but the most severely burned eyes. While our current understanding of these injuries allows us to save many of these eyes, more work is needed to improve the prognosis of grade IV injuries. Ongoing animal and human research is investigating the use of novel topi- cal agents to reduce angiogenesis, inhibit inflammation, promote repair, and reduce the risk of corneal melting. Efforts at preventing ocular chemical burns are equally important and deserve emphasis. Kathryn Colby, MD, PhD, is a practicing cornea spe- cialist at Massachusetts Eye and Ear Infirmary and Children’s Hospital, Boston, and an assistant professor of ophthalmology at Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts. vision to counting fingers, but the eye remained tectoni- cally stable (Figure 9) with a normal intraocular pres- sure. One year after the original injury, the patient was ready to proceed with ocular surface reconstruction. A superficial keratectomy and conjunctival resection was performed OD. Two limbal stem cells grafts were har- vested from the left eye and sutured into place on the right eye. An amniotic membrane was sutured into place over the right cornea and proximal conjunctiva. Her Figure 9 One year following injury, immediately before ocu- lar surface reconstruction. Vision is hand motion. Figure 10 Five months following ocular surface reconstruc- tion. Vision is 20/70. Figure 8 Ten weeks following grade IV injury; the ocular surface is conjunctivalized, but intact.
  • 12. 10 FOCAL POINTS : MODULE 1, 2010 Clinicians’Corner 1. Following a chemical injury, what is the preferred method for irrigating the eye? Does the chemical agent dictate the method? Dr. Pfister: At the site of the injury, any clean source of water can be used to lavage the eye, but ideally a bottle of solution is already prepared for such emergencies. In the emergency room, hand-held irrigation from intravenous tubing is sufficient, but it is much more effective and efficient to insert a contact lens with a fitting to accom- modate the IV tubing (Morgan lens), delivering fluid into the eye continuously over a 2-hour period. Alkali and acid chemical injuries are best lavaged with Ringer’s lactate solution, although most sterile isotonic irrigants are acceptable. The pultaceous character of lime (calcium hydroxide) often requires bulk removal with a cotton-tipped applicator, facilitated by intermittent irri- gation with a solution of EDTA, 0.01 M. EDTA should not be used as a long-term irrigant because, in the presence of an epithelial defect, penetration to endothelium might well add additional damage by calcium chelation. Dr. Tseng: For liquid chemicals, irrigation with clean water or saline is usually sufficient if the conjunctival cul- de-sac is well rinsed. This can be hard to achieve because of the patient’s blepharospasm and pain. To circumvent this concern, a Morgan lens is a good choice. For solid chemicals (especially pressurized), including cement, sim- ple irrigation is insufficient. All embedded debris needs to be removed by forceps and if necessary by surgery. 2. Following irrigation, what is your immediate man- agement of a grade II to IV alkali injury? Dr. Pfister: Topical antibiotics and mydriatics/cyclople- gics are “de rigeuer” shortly after the injury. The use of a topical corticosteroid to suppress the inflammatory response is controversial, but if a topical corticosteroid is used, it must not be continued for more than 7 to 10 days after the injury to avoid inhibition of wound repair and Clinicians’ Corner provides additional viewpoints on the subject covered in this issue of Focal Points. Con- sultants have been invited by the Editorial Review Board to respond to questions posed by the Acade- my’s Practicing Ophthalmologists Advisory Committee for Education. While the advisory committee reviews the modules, consultants respond without reading the module or one another’s responses. –Ed.
  • 13. FOCAL POINTS : MODULE 1, 2010 11 of amniotic membrane over the cornea and conjunctiva to determine the best fit. For fixation I place 4 vertical mattress 9-0 Vicryl sutures through the amniotic mem- brane and episclera in each quadrant at the limbus. I use the remaining skirts of amniotic membrane to line the cul-de-sacs, passing 8-0 Vicryl suture through the upper and lower lids, temporally and nasally, to secure the membrane to the conjunctival reflection. I can place additional sutures, where needed, to further secure the membrane in place. When the acute process has subsided, I perform a sec- ond, more definitive operation with amniotic membrane as a base. These are my steps. (1) Resect any corneal pan- nus and allow it to retract 4 to 6 mm from the limbus. (2) Cut amniotic membrane to fit this corneoscleral defect and use sutures and biologic adhesive (Tisseel) to secure to the episclera. (3) Harvest 2 or 3 patches of cor- neal stem cells, if available, from the patient’s other eye or use patches from a blood relative or cadaver, in that order of desirability. (4) Secure the stem cell patches at the limbus using 10-0 nylon sutures through amniotic membrane into the episclera. Dr. Tseng: I use amniotic membrane whenever the epi- thelium is not healing (if the defect is mostly within the cornea), or if the defect involves most of the lim- bus or beyond. In general, to resurrect the remaining stem cells, the surgeon should transplant amniotic mem- brane within 7 to 10 days. One layer of cryopreserved amniotic membrane serves as a biological bandage cov- ering cornea and involved conjunctiva, using a perilim- bal 10-0 nylon purse-string suture. Alternatively, this technique can now be simplified by insertion of a Pro- Kera device (Bio-Tissue, Miami, FL), which is amniotic membrane stretched across a symblepharon ring. If the defect involves the fornix or tarsal conjunctiva, mem- brane is best to be sutured from lid margin to lid margin by anchoring sutures from the fornix through the lid and tied across a bolster. 4. What is your management of corneal melting fol- lowing chemical injury? What about descemeto- cele or perforation? Dr. Pfister: Corneal ulceration after chemical injury is the result of destruction of both the devitalized and acceleration of ulceration. In chemical injuries, inflam- matory cell suppression must be balanced against dimin- ished host keratocyte and fibroblast cell repair. Treatment with EDTA, cysteine, or acetylcysteine has been advocated as prevention against corneal ulceration, based on their ability to inhibit metalloproteinases. Met- alloproteinases act by degrading native and denatured collagen, hence promoting ulceration. Animal research has shown that topical 10% ascor- bate and 10% citrate dramatically reduce the frequency of corneal ulceration by inhibiting the effects of neutro- phils and enhancing normal collagen synthesis. A combi- nation of citrate and ascorbate, both 10%, results in only a 4% incidence of corneal ulcer in animal eyes. Clinical studies in humans bear out this favorable effect, espe- cially in grade III or higher alkali injuries. Dr. Tseng: My initial management is topical cortico- steroids q2h, prophylactic antibiotics (preferably a fluo- roquinolone) tid, oral vitamin C 2 grams/day, and oral doxycycline 100 mg qd. Most important is to document the extent of fluorescein-stained epithelial defects includ- ing the cornea, limbus, and conjunctiva (from lid margin to lid margin), and look for blanching of blood vessels, indicating ischemia. This should be repeated in less than 1 week to determine whether there is acceptable healing or an increase in ischemia, which frequently will take a few days to weeks to become obvious. 3. What are the indications and timing for the use of amniotic membrane? Describe your technique of amniotic membrane transplantation. Dr. Pfister: Amniotic membrane is commonly used in the early phases after chemical injury to suppress the initial inflammatory process and later to additionally create a new substrate upon which epithelium can migrate. It can be performed within a week or 2 of injury, but could also be performed several weeks or even months later. Later, amniotic membrane is commonly used in conjunc- tion with stem cell transplants to encourage reformation of an intact epithelial layer. It has been shown that, in the absence of corneal stem cells, amniotic membrane alone cannot heal the corneal epithelial surface. My technique is to prepare the ocular surface by removing any loose epithelial tissue. I place a large piece
  • 14. 12 FOCAL POINTS : MODULE 1, 2010 Clinicians’Corner a melt. Both a neurotrophic state and ischemia can be aggravated by limbal stem cell deficiency. However, the stem cell deficiency tends to bring in conjunctivalization with vascularization, which can prevent a melt. 5. What are the best ways to prevent symblepharon? Dr. Pfister: If extensive alkali or acid injury of the con- junctiva occurs, especially involving the cul-de-sacs, then some degree of symblepharon is inevitable. Tradition- ally a glass rod was used to separate raw conjunctival surfaces shortly after the injury, only to have fibrin- ous exudates tend to reform adhesions. Placement of a thin plastic wrap, lining the cul-de-sacs, and suturing it through the eyelid has been supplanted with amniotic membrane sutured in a similar fashion, further limit- ing the formation of symblephara. Lateral contraction of subconjunctival scar, formed from fibrocytes invading conjunctiva as part of the healing process, can obliterate the cul-de-sacs and make visual rehabilitation very dif- ficult. Amniotic membrane contains anti-inflammatory factors, possibly limiting this propensity to scar. Dr. Tseng: The best way to prevent symblepharon is to perform amniotic membrane transplantation within the first 10 days after injury. For patients with ischemia, Tenonplasty is the only way to avoid symblepharon. For those without ischemia and beyond 10 days from injury, when granulation tissue is formed around the conjuncti- val epithelial defect, prompt subconjunctival injection of triamcinolone acetonide is effective in preventing sym- blepharon. After a certain stage, there is no effective way to prevent symblepharon. 6. Is there a role for topical cyclosporine to control dry eye following chemical injury? Dr. Pfister: Dry eye developing after chemical injury is the consequence of destruction of goblet cells of the con- junctiva and cicatricial closure of aqueous and lipid tear gland orifices onto the surface of the conjunctiva. Unless dry eye was present prior to the injury, it is difficult to know how cyclosporine might improve tear dynamics after chemical injury. Preservative-free artificial tears, ointments, and gels would improve dry eye conditions, but only by adding fluid to the eye. It is possible that top- ical mucomimetics might improve mucus production—a matter worthy of trial. vital tissue framework of the cornea. Inflammatory cells (principally polymorphonuclear cells, PMN) discharging enzymes, including collagenases as well as superoxide radicals, act as the proximal effecting agent. Although EDTA, cysteine, and acetylcysteine inhibit collagenases, they do not affect the PMN itself, allowing it to con- tinue to produce degrading enzymes. A more direct and orthomolecular approach is to employ 10% citrate (neu- tralized) every hour, 14 hours a day to inhibit all activi- ties of PMNs including chemoattraction, degranulation, enzyme activation, and superoxide radical production. In animals, this approach has lead to a significant statistical reduction in corneal ulceration. Topical drops prepared as a 25% to 40% solution, from the patient’s own serum, can be helpful in closing persis- tent epithelial defects and limiting ulceration. However, when there is a total absence of stem cells, then serum drops are not likely to result in epithelial closure. Descemetocele or perforation is the end result of loss of most or all corneal stroma in a localized area, hence treatment is often the same for both. If the adjacent tis- sues are not vascularized and are of good quality, then an acceptable approach is immediate closure of the leak by cyanoacrylate adhesive, covered by a contact lens. When the adjacent tissues are of poor quality or are vascular- ized, a surgical course is advised. Cleaning the wound of necrotic and devitalized tissues is followed by placement, and suture, of a lamellar graft into the stromal defect site and then covering the entire cornea with fresh amniotic membrane, sutured at the limbus. Alternately, suturing layers of amniotic membrane into the ulcer bed, and cov- ering with amniotic membrane, is acceptable. I favor the former to achieve immediate and strong establishment of ocular integrity. Dr. Tseng: A severe neurotrophic state and ischemia are the major causes of corneal or scleral melt in chemical injury. For the former, the management starts with punc- tal occlusion followed by autologous serum drops and a bandage contact lens. If these treatments do not yield improvement, one should move to amniotic membrane, if within the first 10 days post-injury, or to tarsorrhaphy. For the latter, a Tenonplasty is done to correct ischemia, at the same time using amniotic membrane to promote epi- thelialization. If a persistent epithelial defect has not led to a corneal melt, another temporizing measure is to glue a hard contact lens onto the corneal surface to prevent
  • 15. FOCAL POINTS : MODULE 1, 2010 13 then clear-cut evidence of stem cell deficiency is present and stem cell transplantation should be contemplated. Naturally, all other potential causes of a persistent epi- thelial defect must be eliminated. The inflammatory response and mediators excited by chemical injuries is severe and long lasting. Prior data showed that waiting 18 months to perform corneal transplantation improved the outcome by allowing the inflammatory process to diminish. This delay might also reduce the incidence of immune rejection in these high- risk patients by reducing the number of immunoreac- tive cells. Dr. Tseng: For transplantation of either autologous (in the form of conjunctival limbal autograft) or allogenic (in the form of keratolimbal allograft) limbal stem cells, transplantation is best performed when inflammation is under control. Therefore, one should avoid performing stem cell transplantation during the acute stage. Even at the chronic stage, measures should be taken to restore the ocular surface before such transplantation. For example, all abnormalities of the lid margin, tarsus, and lashes should be corrected; blinking should be restored by symblepharon lysis and fornix reconstruction; and dry eye linked to neurotrophic state should be effectively managed. Except for such emergent situations as corneal melt or perforation, when corneal transplantation may be performed in the acute (inflamed) stage of chemical injury to provide tectonic support, it should be deferred for several months after limbal stem cell transplantation corrects limbal stem cell deficiency. 9. When is a keratoprosthesis indicated? What ker- atoprosthesis do you prefer following chemical injuries? Dr. Pfister: Over the years our success with conventional corneal transplantation has improved considerably by control of inflammation, maintenance of stromal integ- rity, and stem cell transplantation. Nevertheless, kerato- prostheses serve an important population of patients who have not benefited from conventional corneal transplan- tation. Keratoprostheses are considered as a last resort after chemical injury when repeated corneal transplan- tation fails on 2 or more occasions. The Dohlman keratoprosthesis has the longest record of success using a standardized protocol. There is 1 type Dr. Tseng: No. Dry eye is caused by a neurotrophic state following chemical burns. The chronic inflammation caused by chemical burns is not lymphocytic. 7. When is cicatricial entropion commonly seen and how do you manage this? Can it be prevented? Dr. Pfister: Cicatricial entropion is commonly encoun- tered weeks to months after the injury as scar tissue near the tarsal conjunctival surface contracts, causing inward rotation of the lid margin. Often this is associ- ated with symblephara between the eyelid and eyeball. In milder cases, lysis of symblephara and lining the raw surfaces with buccal mucosa or amniotic membrane might release the pressures of lid rotation and reduce their reformation. More severe cases additionally require splitting the eyelid at the gray line and advancing the tarsus ahead of the eyelashes. Lysis of symblephara and lining the conjunctival surface with amniotic membrane offers the best opportunity for minimizing entropion. Dr. Tseng: Cicatricial entropion is a late (several months) complication of chemical burns that occurs when fornix or tarsal injury has not been appropriately managed in the acute stage. It can be prevented only by the measures advised above including AMT, Tenonplasty, and control of inflammation. Once formed at the chronic stage, cica- tricial entropion can gradually cause corneal blindness; hence, it should be surgically corrected by amniotic membrane transplantation with or without oral mucosal graft depending on the severity. 8. What is the proper timing of limbal stem cell trans- plantation and corneal transplantation following chemical injury? Dr. Pfister: Successful limbal stem cell transplantation is dependent on an intact episcleral vascular system, evi- denced by the absence of necrosis or whitening of peril- imbal tissues. Revascularization of these tissues normally takes several weeks, allowing time to determine the true extent of stem cell damage. It is very important to record perilimbal fluorescein staining at the time of injury, indicating stem cell loss. Whatever damage to stem cells might have occurred, time should be allowed to give sur- viving cells an opportunity to recover. When a persis- tent epithelial defect is present for a period of 2 weeks or more, despite conservative efforts to heal epithelium,
  • 16. 14 FOCAL POINTS : MODULE 1, 2010 Clinicians’Corner odonto-keratoprosthesis (OOKP) procedure followed by Dohlman’s KPro device (also called the Boston K-Pro, developed at Massachusetts Eye and Ear Infirmary). Roswell R. Pfister, MD, is a practicing ophthalmolo- gist, Pfister Vision Correction Center, Birmingham, Alabama. Scheffer C.G. Tseng, MD, PhD, is director, Ocular Sur- face Center, medical director, Ocular Surface Research & Education Foundation, and director, R & D, TissueTech, Miami, FL. for an eye with normal tear film, and another type for a dry eye. There are significant complications potentially developing after the surgery, in addition to the inability to reliably measure intraocular pressure. Despite this, recent developments have significantly improved the prognosis so that many patients have now been followed for years with acceptable vision. Dr. Tseng: A keratoprosthesis can be considered fol- lowing chemical injury when ischemia is absent and inflammation is at a chronic stage. The best indica- tion is for eyes where the ocular surface cannot be restored (eg, severe dry eye, intense inflammation, or keratinization). For chemical burns, I prefer the osteo- Wagoner MD, Kenyon KR. Chemical injuries. In: Shingleton BJ, Hersh PS and Kenyon KR, eds. Eye Trauma. St Louis, MO: Mosby; 1991:79–94. Wagoner MD, Al-Swailem S, Al-Jastaneiah S, Kenyon KR. Chemical injuries of the eye. In: Miller JW, Azar DT, Blodi B, eds. Principles and Practice of Ophthalmology, 3rd ed. Philadel- phia: WB Saunders; 2008:761–772. Yaghouti F, Nouri M, Abad JC, Power WJ, Doane MG, Dohlman CH. Keratoprosthesis: preoperative prognostic categories. Cornea. 2001;20:19–23. Zerbe BL, Belin MW, Ciolino JB; Boston Type 1 Keratoprosthe- sis Study Group. Results from the multi-center Boston Type I keratoprosthesis study. Ophthalmology. 2006;113:1779. Related Academy Materials Chemical injuries. In: External Disease and Cornea. Basic and Clinical Science Course, Section 8, 2009–2010. Nordlund ML, Brilakis HS, Holland EJ. Surgical Techniques for Ocular Surface Reconstruction. Focal Points, Clinical Modules for Ophthalmologists, Module 12, 2006. Suggested Reading Bagley DM, Casterton PL, Dressler WE, et al. Proposed new classification scheme for chemical injury to the human eye. Regul Toxicol Pharmacol. 2006;45:206–213. Barouch F, Colby KA. Evaluation and initial management of patients with ocular and adnexal trauma. In: Miller JW, Azar DT, Blodi B, eds. Principles and Practice of Ophthalmology, 3rd ed. Philadelphia: WB Saunders; 2008:5071–5092. Holland EJ, Croasdale CR. Epithelial transplantation for the management of severe ocular surface disease. In: Brightbill FS, ed. Corneal Surgery: Theory, Technique & Tissue, 3rd ed. St. Louis, MO: Mosby; 2009:488–499. Hosseini H, Nejabat M, Mehryar M, Yazdchi T, Sedaghat A, Noori F. Bevacizumab inhibits corneal neovascularization in an alkali burn induced model of corneal angiogenesis. Clin Experiment Ophthalmol. 2007;35:745–748. Pfister RR. Chemical trauma. In: Foster CS, Azar DT, Dohlman CH, eds. Smolin and Thoft’s The Cornea, 4th ed. Philadelphia, PA: Lippincott, Williams and Wilkins; 2005:781–796. Tejwani S, Kolari RS, Sangwan VS, Rao GN. Role of amniotic membrane graft for ocular chemical and thermal injuries. Cornea. 2007;26:21–26. 029032A