Globalization of markets refers to the gradual integration and growing interdependence of national economies. Globalization allows firms to view the world as an integrated marketplace that includes buyers, producers, suppliers, and governments in different countries. Market globalization is manifested by the production and marketing of branded products and services worldwide. Declining trade barriers and the ease with which international business transactions take place due to the Internet and other technologies are contributing to a gradual integration of most national economies into a unified global marketplace.
The first phase of globalization began about 1830 and peaked around 1880. International business became widespread due to the growth of railroads, efficient ocean transport, and the rise of large manufacturing and trading firms. Invention of the telegraph and telephone in the late 1800s facilitated information flows between and within nations and greatly aided early efforts to manage companies’ supply chains.
The second phase of globalization began around 1900 and was associated with the rise of electricity and steel production. This phase reached its height just before the Great Depression, a worldwide economic downturn that began in 1929. In 1900, Western Europe was the most industrialized world region. Europe’s colonization of countries in Asia, Africa, and the Middle East led to establishment of some of the earliest subsidiaries of multinational enterprises (MNEs). European companies such as BASF, Nestlé, Shell, Siemens, and British Petroleum had established foreign manufacturing plants by 1900.8 In the years before World War I (pre-1914), many firms were already operating globally. The Italian manufacturer Fiat supplied vehicles to nations on both sides of the war.
The third phase of globalization began after World War II. At war’s end in 1945, substantial pent-up demand existed for consumer products, as well as for input goods to rebuild Europe and Japan. The United States was least harmed by the war and became the world’s dominant economy. Substantial government aid helped stimulate economic activity in Europe. The pre-war years had been characterized by high tariffs and strict controls on currency and capital movements. After the war, leading industrialized countries, including Australia, Britain, and the United States, sought to reduce international trade barriers. transport, and the rise of large manufacturing and trading firms. Invention of the telegraph and telephone in the late 1800s facilitated information flows between and within nations and greatly aided early efforts to manage companies’ supply chains.
The fourth phase of globalization began in the early 1980s, which saw enormous growth in cross-border trade and investment. The phase was triggered by the development of personal computers, the Internet, and Web browsers; the collapse of the Soviet Union and ensuing market liberalization in Central and Eastern Europe; and industrialization and modernization in East Asian economies, including China.
The exhibit presents an organizing framework for examining market globalization. The exhibit makes a distinction between: (1) drivers or causes of globalization; (2) dimensions or manifestations of globalization; (3a) societal consequences of globalization; and (3b) firm level consequences of globalization. In the exhibit, the double arrows illustrate the interactive nature of the relationship between market globalization and its consequences. As market globalization intensifies, individual firms respond to the challenges and new advantages that it brings. However, keep in mind that firms do not expand abroad solely as a reaction to market globalization. They also internationalize proactively, in order to pursue new markets, find lower-cost inputs, or obtain other advantages. Often, adverse conditions in the home market, such as regulation or declining industry sales, push firms to boldly venture abroad. Firms that do so tend to be more successful in global competition than those that engage in international business as a reactive move.
Integration and interdependence of national economies. Internationally active firms devise multicountry operations through trade, investment, geographic dispersal of company resources, and integration and coordination of value-chain activities. A value chain is the sequence of value-adding activities performed by the firm in the course of developing, producing, marketing, and servicing a product. The aggregate activities of such firms give rise to economic integration. Governments have facilitated this integration by lowering barriers to international trade and investment, harmonizing their monetary and fiscal policies within regional economic integration blocs (also known as trade blocs), and developing supranational institutions—the World Bank, International Monetary Fund, World Trade Organization, and others—that seek further reductions in trade and investment barriers.
Rise of regional economic integration blocs. Closely related to the first trend is the emergence since the 1950s of regional economic integration blocs. Examples include the North American Free Trade Agreement area (NAFTA), the Asia Pacific Economic Cooperation zone (APEC), and Mercosur in Latin America. These blocs consist of groups of countries within which trade and investment flows are facilitated through reduced trade and investment barriers. In more advanced arrangements, such as the “common market,” barriers to the cross-border flow of factors of production (mostly labor and capital) are removed. For example, the European Union (www.europa.eu), in addition to adopting free trade among its member countries, is harmonizing fiscal and monetary policies and adopting common business regulations.
Growth of global investment and financial flows. In the process of conducting international transactions, firms and governments buy and sell large volumes of national currencies (such as dollars, euros, and yen). The free movement of capital around the world—the globalization of capital— extends economic activities across the globe and is fostering interconnectedness among world economies. Commercial and investment banking is a global industry. The bond market has gained worldwide scope, with foreign bonds representing a major source of debt financing for governments and firms. Information and communications networks facilitate heavy volumes of financial transactions every day, integrating national markets. Nevertheless, widespread integration can have negative effects. For example, when the United States experienced a banking crisis in 2008, the crisis quickly spread to Europe, Japan, and emerging markets, triggering a global recession.
Convergence of consumer lifestyles and preferences. Around the world, consumers spend their money and time in increasingly similar ways. Lifestyles and preferences are converging. Shoppers in Tokyo, New York, and Paris demand similar household goods, clothing, automobiles, and electronics. Teenagers everywhere are attracted to iPods, Levi’s jeans, and BlackBerry cell phones. Major brands have gained a global following, encouraged by greater international travel, movies, global media, and the Internet, which expose people to products, services, and living patterns from around the world. Movies such as The Lord of the Rings and Slumdog Millionaire receive much attention from a global audience. Convergence of preferences is also occurring in industrial markets, where professional buyers source raw materials, parts, and components that are increasingly standardized—that is, very similar in design and structure. Yet, even as converging tastes facilitate the marketing of highly standardized products and services to buyers worldwide, they also promote the loss of traditional lifestyles and values in individual countries.
Globalization of production. Intense global competition is forcing firms to reduce their costs of production and marketing. Companies strive to drive down prices through economies of scale, by standardizing what they sell, and by shifting manufacturing and procurement to foreign locations with inexpensive labor. For example, companies in the auto and textile industries have relocated their manufacturing to low labor-cost locations such as China, Mexico, and Eastern Europe.
Globalization of services. The services sector is undergoing widespread internationalization. First, banking, hospitality, retailing, and other service industries are rapidly expanding abroad. The real estate firm REMAX has established more than 5,000 offices in over fifty countries. Second, as noted in the opening vignette, firms increasingly outsource business processes and other services in the value chain to vendors located abroad. Finally, in a relatively new trend, many people go abroad to take advantage of low-cost services. For example, many U.S. consumers regularly travel to India, Latin America, and other international destinations to undergo medical procedures like cataract and knee surgeries. Several U.S. health insurance companies view international “medical tourism” as a means to reduce costs.
Worldwide reduction of barriers to trade and investment. The tendency of national governments to reduce trade and investment barriers has accelerated global economic integration. For example, tariffs on the import of automobiles, industrial machinery, and countless other products have declined nearly to zero in many countries, encouraging freer international exchange of goods and services. Falling trade barriers are facilitated by the WTO. After joining the WTO in 2001, China made its market more accessible to foreign firms. Reduction of trade barriers is also associated with the emergence of regional economic integration blocs, a key dimension of market globalization.
Market liberalization and adoption of free markets. Built in 1961, the Berlin Wall separated the communist East Berlin from the democratic West Berlin. The collapse of the Soviet Union’s economy in 1989, demolition of the Berlin Wall that same year, and China’s free-market reforms all signaled the end of the 50-year Cold War and smoothed the integration of former command economies into the global economy. Numerous East Asian economies, stretching from South Korea to Malaysia and Indonesia, had already embarked on ambitious market-based reforms. India joined the trend in 1991. These events opened roughly one-third of the world to freer international trade and investment. China, India, and Eastern Europe have become some of the most cost-effective locations for producing goods and services worldwide. Privatization of previously state-owned industries in these countries has encouraged economic efficiency and attracted massive foreign capital into their national economies.
Industrialization, economic development, and modernization. Industrialization implies that emerging markets—rapidly developing economies in Asia, Latin America, and Eastern Europe—are moving from being low value-adding commodity producers, dependent on low-cost labor, to sophisticated competitive producers and exporters of premium products such as electronics, computers, and aircraft. For example, Brazil is now a leading producer of private aircraft, and the Czech Republic excels in the manufacture of automobiles. As highlighted in the opening vignette, India has become a leading supplier of computer software. Economic development is enhancing standards of living and discretionary income in emerging markets.
Integration of world financial markets. Integration of world financial markets makes it possible for internationally active firms to raise capital, borrow funds, and engage in foreign currency transactions. Financial services firms follow their customers to foreign markets. Cross-border transactions are made easier partly as a result of the ease with which funds can be transferred between buyers and sellers, through a network of international commercial banks. For example, as an individual you can transfer funds to a friend in another country using the SWIFT network. The network facilitates global financial transactions. The globalization of finance contributes to firms’ abilities to develop and operate world-scale production and marketing operations. It enables companies to pay suppliers and collect payments from customers worldwide.
Ongoing advances in information, manufacturing, and transportation technologies, as well as the emergence of the Internet, have facilitated rapid and early internationalization of countless firms, such as Neogen (www.neogen .com). The firm’s founders developed diagnostic kits to test for food safety. Compared to test kits available from other firms, Neogen’s products were more accurate, more efficient, and easier to use. As word spread about the superiority of its products, Neogen was able to internationalize quickly and acquired a worldwide clientele. Farmers use Neogen test kits to test for pesticide residue; veterinarians use them for pharmaceuticals, vaccines, and topicals; government agencies use them to test for E. coli. Today, Neogen is a highly successful international firm. Modern technology is promoting a higher level of international business activity than ever before. For example, many companies in software, gaming, and entertainment maintain a presence only on the Web.
Technology greatly eases management of international operations. Now firms interact more efficiently with foreign partners and value-chain members than ever before. They transmit all kinds of data, information, and vital communications that help ensure the smooth running of their operations worldwide. They use information technology to improve the productivity of their operations, which provides substantial competitive advantages. For example, information technology allows firms to more efficiently adapt products for international markets or produce goods in smaller lots to target international niche markets. In addition, technological advances have made international operations affordable for all types of firms, explaining why so many SMEs have internationalized during the past two decades.
Managers use the latest technologies to manage international operations: iPads that combine laptop functionality with smartphone convenience; BlackBerry phones with crossnational Wi-Fi capability that can take phone calls from anywhere on earth; iPods for listening to audio books or mini Sony PlayStations for that ride home on the train after work. Technological advances have spurred the development of new products and services that appeal to a global audience. Leading examples include the Wii and iPhone. Emerging markets and developing economies also benefit from technological advances, partly due to technological leapfrogging. For example, Hungary and Poland went directly from old-style analog telecommunications (with rotary dial telephones) to cell phone technology, bypassing much of the early digital technology (push-button telephones) that characterized advanced economy telephone systems. China and India are the new beachheads for technological advances. India has become a focus of global Internet- and knowledge-based industries. Top management at Intel and Motorola, two leading technology companies, agree that China is the place to be when it comes to technological progress. Both firms generate substantial sales there. Management predicts double-digit increases in demand for technology products in China far into the future. Intel’s CEO commented, “I come back from visiting China and feel as if I’ve visited the fountain of youth of computing.”
Contagion: Rapid Spread of Monetary or Financial Crises Beginning in late 2008, the world economy experienced a severe financial crisis and global recession, the worst in decades.1 The crisis was precipitated by pricing bubbles (excessively high prices) in housing and commodities markets around the world. For example, by mid-2008, oil prices climbed to an all-time high of nearly $150 a barrel, and gasoline prices reached record levels in many countries. High commodity prices resulted partly from rising demand, especially in emerging markets such as China and India. As bubbles in real estate markets burst, home values crashed, leaving owners with mortgage debts greater than the value of their homes. Many homeowners found themselves unable to repay their debts, a situation that worsened as people lost jobs or experienced pay cuts. Meanwhile, thousands of mortgages had been securitized—that is, sold as investment vehicles on stock markets worldwide. As the value of these securities plunged or became uncertain, the stock markets crashed.
A recession occurs when a national economy undergoes a prolonged period of negative growth. GDP growth in advanced, developing, and emerging economies varies over time. It declined substantially in recent years, due to the global recession and the financial crisis. However, even following deep recessions, the global economy has always returned to net GDP growth.
The exhibit show how GDP growth in advanced, developing, and emerging economies varies over time. It declined substantially during the global recession and financial crisis. One lesson of the exhibit is that, even following deep recessions, the global economy has always returned to net GDP growth.
The crisis began in the United States and, like a contagious disease, spread around the world. In international economics, contagion refers to the tendency for a financial or monetary crisis in one country to spread rapidly to other countries, due to the ongoing integration of national economies.
Sovereignty, the ability of a nation to govern its own affairs, is a fundamental principle that underlies global relations. One country’s laws cannot be applied or enforced in another country. Globalization can threaten national sovereignty in various ways. MNE activities can interfere with the sovereign ability of governments to control their own economies, social structures, and political systems.
Some corporations are bigger than the economies of many nations. Indeed, Walmart’s internal economy—its total revenues—is larger than the GDPof most of the world’s nations, including Israel, Greece, and Poland.
Large multinationals can exert considerable influence on governments through lobbying or campaign contributions. They often lobby their government for, say, devaluation of the home currency, which gives them greater price competitiveness in export markets. MNEs influence the legislative process and extract special favors from government agencies.
But even the largest firms are constrained by market forces. In countries with many competing firms, one company cannot force customers to buy its products or force suppliers to supply it with raw materials and inputs. The resources that customers and suppliers control are the result of free choices made in the marketplace. Company performance depends on the firm’s skill at winning customers, working with suppliers, and dealing with competitors. Corporate dominance of individual markets is rare. In reality, market forces generally dominate companies. Gradual integration of the global economy and increased global competition, combined with privatization of industries in various nations, are making some companies less powerful within their national markets. For example, Ford, Chrysler, and GM once dominated the U.S. auto market. Today there are many more firms, including Toyota, Honda, Hyundai, Nissan, and BMW. In annual sales, Toyota now leads the U.S. market, and home-country market shares of domestic U.S. automakers have tumbled.
Today, globalization and the spread of financial crises compel governments to pursue sound economic policies and managers to manage their firms more effectively. To minimize globalization’s harm and reap its benefits, governments should strive for open and liberalized economic regimes. Specifically, governments should ensure the freedom to enter and compete in markets, protect private and intellectual property, enforce the rule of law, and support voluntary exchange through markets rather than through political processes. Banks and financial institutions should be regulated appropriately. Transparency in the affairs of business and regulatory agencies is critical. One example is the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, which the U.S. Congress passed in 2002. It addresses the flaws in financial reporting practices that became apparent following corporate and accounting scandals in such firms as Enron, Tyco International, and WorldCom. It introduced new and enhanced standards for all U.S. public company boards, management, and public accounting firms.
Globalization has created many new jobs and opportunities worldwide, but it has also cost many people their jobs. Ford, GM, and Volkswagen have all transferred thousands of jobs from their factories in Germany to countries in Eastern Europe. General Motors and Ford have also laid off thousands of workers in the US, partly the result of competitive pressures posed by carmakers from Europe, Japan, and South Korea.
Offshoring is the relocation of manufacturing and other value-chain activities to cost-effective locations abroad. Ernst & Young relocated much of its accounting support work to the Philippines. Massachusetts General Hospital has its CT scans and X-rays interpreted by radiologists in India. Many IT support services for customers in Germany are based in the Czech Republic and Romania. Offshoring has caused job losses in many mature economies.
High-profile plant closures and relocation of manufacturing have received much media attention in recent years. For example, Electrolux, the Swedish manufacturer of home appliances, recently moved its Greenville, Michigan, refrigerator plant to Mexico. Closure of the plant, which once provided 2,700 jobs, devastated the small Michigan community. Management shifted production to Mexico despite repeated appeals by the local community, the labor union, and the state of Michigan.
MNEs are often criticized for paying low wages, exploiting workers, and employing child labor. Child labor is particularly troubling because it denies children educational opportunities. In 2012, the International Labor Organization (www.ilo.org) reported there are approximately 215 million children aged 5–14 at work around the world.
Globalization can harm the environment by promoting increased manufacturing and economic activity that results in pollution, habitat destruction, and deterioration of the ozone layer. For example, economic development in China is attracting much inward FDI and stimulating the growth of numerous industries. However, the construction of factories, infrastructure, and modern housing can spoil previously pristine environments. In Eastern China, growing industrial demand for electricity led to construction of the Three Gorges Dam, which flooded agricultural lands and permanently altered the natural landscape.
While it is generally true that globalization-induced industrialization produces considerable environmental harm, this effect tends to decline over time. The evidence suggests that environmental destruction diminishes as economies develop, at least in the long run. As globalization stimulates rising living standards, people focus increasingly on improving their environment. Over time, governments pass legislation that promotes improved environmental conditions. For example, Japan endured polluted rivers and smoggy cities in the early decades of its economic development following World War II. But as their economy grew, the Japanese passed tough environmental standards to restore natural environments.
Evolving company values and concern for corporate reputations also lead firms to reduce or eliminate practices that harm the environment. For example, in Mexico, big U.S. automakers like Ford and GM have gradually improved their environmental standards. Benetton in Italy (clothing), Alcan in Canada (aluminum), and Kirin in Japan (beverages) are examples of firms that embrace practices that protect the environment, often at the expense of profits. The Conservation Coffee Alliance, a consortium of companies, has committed substantial financial support to environmentally friendly coffee cultivation in Central America, Peru, and Colombia.
Globalization exerts strong pressures on national culture. Market liberalization leaves the door open to foreign companies, global brands, unfamiliar products, and new values. Consumers increasingly wear similar clothing, drive similar cars, watch the same movies, and listen to the same recording stars. Advertising leads to the emergence of societal values modeled on Western countries, especially the United States. Hollywood dominates the global entertainment industry. In this way, globalization can alter people’s norms, values, and behaviors, which may tend to homogenize over time. Critics call these trends the “McDonaldization” or the “Coca-Colonization” of the world. To combat such trends, governments try to block cultural imperialism and prevent the erosion of local traditions. In Canada, France, and Germany, the public sector attempts to prevent U.S. ideals from diluting local traditions. Hollywood, McDonald’s, and Disneyland are seen as Trojan horses that permanently alter food preferences, lifestyles, and other aspects of traditional life. For better or worse, however, such trends are probably inevitable in a globalizing world. Information and communications technologies speed the homogenization of world cultures. People worldwide are exposed to movies, television, the Internet, and other information sources that promote lifestyles of people in the United States and other advanced economies. Appetites grow for Western products and services, which are seen to signal higher living standards. For example, despite low per-capita income, many Chinese buy consumer electronics such as cell phones and TV sets. Global media have a pervasive effect on local culture, gradually shifting it toward a universal norm.
At the same time, the flow of cultural influence often goes both ways. Advanced Fresh Concepts is a Japanese food company that is transforming fast food by selling sushi and other Japanese favorites in supermarkets throughout the United States. It sells some $250 million worth of sushi to U.S. buyers every year. As the influence of the Chinese economy grows over time, Western countries will likely adopt cultural norms from China as well. Chinese restaurants and some Chinese traditions are already a way of life in much of the world outside China.
The globalization of markets has opened up countless new business opportunities for internationalizing firms. At the same time, globalization means that firms must accommodate new risks and intense rivalry from foreign competitors. Globalization results in more demanding buyers who shop for the best deals worldwide. A purely domestic focus is no longer viable for firms in most industries. Managers should replace parochial attitudes with a more cosmopolitan orientation. Internationalization may take the form of global sourcing, exporting, or investment in key markets abroad. Proactive firms seek a simultaneous presence in major trading regions, especially Asia, Europe, and North America. The most direct implication of market globalization is on the firm’s value chain. Market globalization compels firms to organize their sourcing, manufacturing, marketing, and other value-adding activities on a global scale. In a typical value chain, the firm conducts research and product development (R&D), purchases production inputs, and assembles or manufactures a product or service. Next, the firm performs marketing activities such as pricing, promotion, and selling, followed by distribution of the product in targeted markets and after-sales service. The value-chain concept is useful in international business because it helps clarify what activities are performed where in the world. For instance, exporting firms perform most “upstream” value-chain activities (R&D and production) in the home market and most “downstream” activities (marketing and after-sales service) abroad. Each value-adding activity in the firm’s value chain is subject to internationalization; that is, it can be performed abroad instead of at home.