SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Visit: jgwiezor.wix.com/artmetawrite
1
Art+Meta+Write: Visuality and Second Language Writers / By Jan Wiezorek
Problem: Second language (L2) writers are often at a place that A. F. Wysocki and J. L.
Jasken (2004) call an interface—a borderland where systems meet. In this place between
understanding and misunderstanding, L2 writers profoundly desire to express themselves fully but
are uncertain how to do it in the moment. This uncertainty affects their confidence as writers.
One student from Benin, who witnessed a car accident in America three months ago, says,
“I was terrified and felt guilty because if I could speak English, I could have had done
something.” Other L2 writers use “confused,” “nervous,” “disappointed, and “fear” to describe
encounters with English speech and writing. Even when going to a movie, one student finds no
pleasure in it, writing, “I don’t understand, and I always misunderstand the moment.”
I argue that L2 writers “misunderstand the moment” offered to them for communicating
through writing. Such misunderstanding causes delay in their response, and delay is traumatic
when too much time elapses between reception of a message and a response to it (R. Barthes
[1977]). With practice in responding to the immediacy of visuality, students can learn to blend
systems in an interface situation, scaffold their understanding, and find a writer’s voice.
Visit: jgwiezor.wix.com/artmetawrite
2
Pedagogy from M. B. McVee et al. (2008) and F. Serafini (2011) suggests that L2 writers have
limited academic vocabulary and an unclear sense of the crossover between denotative and
connotative meanings, which reduces effectiveness in establishing a writer’s voice. McVee
(2008) advocates making meaning by “moving freely from one sign system to another.”
Method: By combining visuals with writing, students will “reimagine” contexts and
consequences (J. Shipka [2005]). Visuality provides entry into deeper understanding about
writing. In one activity, “metajournaling,” students look at images before writing what they see
and feel. Writers use denotation with images as a scaffold into the shifting cultural and contextual
aspects inherent in connotation. These connections provide a broader understanding of meaning-
making and help writers to draft reflections and discover voice. I enabled students to choose
images, write denotative and connotative expressions, and to “metajournal” about the connections
among images, thoughts, and writing. To assist students, I prepared a variety of worksheets that
posed questions concerning the interface of images, words, culture, and context.
Implications: Visuality offers useful implications for L2 students and compositionists.
 Visuality is a pathway for entering into vocabulary, rich associations, and complex ideas.
The ability to see an image and transfer it into words is a complex activity that echoes what
L2 learners do when they grapple with language skills. Images reinforce new language
acquisition, and they link writers to abstract, complex ideas.
Visit: jgwiezor.wix.com/artmetawrite
3
 Visuality enables students to question themselves and reflect upon experience. When students
use writing to talk about their own experience, they often require a prompt. The author
believes visuality is the best way to bring forth reflection, enabling students to discuss how
experiences relate to a culture they are learning to navigate.
 Visuality assists L2 writers in sharing emotions. Images open emotional floodgates. L2
writers become witnesses to the power of visuality to unleash emotions in writing. They use
image and alphabetic-text connections to wrestle with emotional and cultural situations.
 Visuality becomes a bit of knowledge to make meaning in an unstable world. The image is
one bit of information that assists in meaning-making. Art+Meta+Write connections enable
educators to generate assignments that rely on a combination of imagistic and alphabetic texts
to help L2 writers enhance meaning within shifting sociocultural contexts.
Acknowledgements: I thank L2 writers at BIR Training Center in Chicago for their willingness
to explore interfaces among images, metacognition, and writing. I especially thank my mentor, Marcia
Buell, Ph.D., English Professor at Northeastern Illinois University, Chicago, for her insights that
strengthen connections between theory and praxis.
Visit: jgwiezor.wix.com/artmetawrite
4
Works Cited
Barthes, Roland. Image – Music – Text. Trans. Stephen Heath. New York: Hill and Wang,
1977. Print.
McVee, Mary B. et al. “Using Digital Media to Interpret Poetry: Spiderman Meets Walt
Whitman.” Research in the Teaching of English. 43.2 (2008): 112-43. Print.
Serafini, Frank. “Expanding Perspectives for Comprehending Visual Images in Multimodal
Texts.” Journal of Adolescent & Adult Literacy. 54.5 (2011): 342-50. Print.
Shipka, Judy. “A Multimodal Task-Based Framework for Composing.” College Composition
and Communication. 57.2 (2005): 277-306. Print.
Wysocki, Anne Francis and Julia I. Jasken. “What should be an unforgettable face . . . .”
Computers and Composition. 21.1 (2004): 29-48. Print.
Jan Wiezorek (janwiezorek@comcast.net) teaches international L2 students as
faculty member at BIR Training Center in Chicago. He is an adjunct professor at St. Augustine
College, Chicago, and at Harper College, Palatine, Illinois. Jan authored Awesome Art Projects
That Spark Super Writing (Scholastic, 2011). Visit his website: jgwiezor.wix.com/artmetawrite

More Related Content

What's hot

Multimodal Methods for Analyzing Communication and Learning with Digital Tech...
Multimodal Methods for Analyzing Communication and Learning with Digital Tech...Multimodal Methods for Analyzing Communication and Learning with Digital Tech...
Multimodal Methods for Analyzing Communication and Learning with Digital Tech...
Laura Malinverni
 
Translingualism: Building a more Inclusive Writing Center
Translingualism: Building a more Inclusive Writing CenterTranslingualism: Building a more Inclusive Writing Center
Translingualism: Building a more Inclusive Writing Center
HaleyWilson22
 
3 a media, language and power
3 a   media, language and power3 a   media, language and power
3 a media, language and power
paulteusner
 
Unit 1 Communication as departing point: humans as social beings, sharing and...
Unit 1 Communication as departing point: humans as social beings, sharing and...Unit 1 Communication as departing point: humans as social beings, sharing and...
Unit 1 Communication as departing point: humans as social beings, sharing and...
Nadia Gabriela Dresscher
 
A Genre-Based Model Language
A Genre-Based Model LanguageA Genre-Based Model Language
A Genre-Based Model Language
Erica Gisela Delgado
 
Genre, text and grammar
Genre, text and grammarGenre, text and grammar
Genre, text and grammar
JezabelEscobar
 
Isfd 41 18-lee4-genre, text, grammar
Isfd 41 18-lee4-genre, text, grammarIsfd 41 18-lee4-genre, text, grammar
Isfd 41 18-lee4-genre, text, grammar
stellamso
 
Social factors, dimensions and explanations
Social factors, dimensions and explanationsSocial factors, dimensions and explanations
Social factors, dimensions and explanations
RodrigoDavidSurezSur
 
Presentation1
Presentation1Presentation1
Presentation1
Lelly Istiani
 
Approaches to studying language attitudes beyond labov
Approaches to studying language attitudes  beyond labovApproaches to studying language attitudes  beyond labov
Approaches to studying language attitudes beyond labov
Jacqueline Trademan
 
Edulearn 2014 - Barcelona/Spain
Edulearn 2014 - Barcelona/SpainEdulearn 2014 - Barcelona/Spain
Edulearn 2014 - Barcelona/Spain
Adolfo Tanzi Neto - University of Oxford
 
Sociolinguistics
SociolinguisticsSociolinguistics
Sociolinguistics
salah eddine El yamani
 
Group2 conceptmaps
Group2 conceptmapsGroup2 conceptmaps
Group2 conceptmaps
FALE - UFMG
 
Discourse and Society
Discourse and SocietyDiscourse and Society
Discourse and Society
JaviBarruetoF
 
Language and Identity: A Critique
Language and Identity: A CritiqueLanguage and Identity: A Critique
Language and Identity: A Critique
masoud5912
 
Cognitive Dimension Literacy
Cognitive Dimension LiteracyCognitive Dimension Literacy
Cognitive Dimension Literacy
noviarabbani
 
Comm skills & multiple intelligences approach to communicative teaching
Comm skills & multiple intelligences approach to communicative teachingComm skills & multiple intelligences approach to communicative teaching
Comm skills & multiple intelligences approach to communicative teaching
Shelia Ann Peace
 
Communicative competence
Communicative competenceCommunicative competence
Communicative competence
Annasta Tastha
 
Multimodal Texts
Multimodal TextsMultimodal Texts
Multimodal Texts
Carlo Casumpong
 
Briefly on Discourse and Cognition
Briefly on Discourse and CognitionBriefly on Discourse and Cognition
Briefly on Discourse and Cognition
Lily Anoshkina
 

What's hot (20)

Multimodal Methods for Analyzing Communication and Learning with Digital Tech...
Multimodal Methods for Analyzing Communication and Learning with Digital Tech...Multimodal Methods for Analyzing Communication and Learning with Digital Tech...
Multimodal Methods for Analyzing Communication and Learning with Digital Tech...
 
Translingualism: Building a more Inclusive Writing Center
Translingualism: Building a more Inclusive Writing CenterTranslingualism: Building a more Inclusive Writing Center
Translingualism: Building a more Inclusive Writing Center
 
3 a media, language and power
3 a   media, language and power3 a   media, language and power
3 a media, language and power
 
Unit 1 Communication as departing point: humans as social beings, sharing and...
Unit 1 Communication as departing point: humans as social beings, sharing and...Unit 1 Communication as departing point: humans as social beings, sharing and...
Unit 1 Communication as departing point: humans as social beings, sharing and...
 
A Genre-Based Model Language
A Genre-Based Model LanguageA Genre-Based Model Language
A Genre-Based Model Language
 
Genre, text and grammar
Genre, text and grammarGenre, text and grammar
Genre, text and grammar
 
Isfd 41 18-lee4-genre, text, grammar
Isfd 41 18-lee4-genre, text, grammarIsfd 41 18-lee4-genre, text, grammar
Isfd 41 18-lee4-genre, text, grammar
 
Social factors, dimensions and explanations
Social factors, dimensions and explanationsSocial factors, dimensions and explanations
Social factors, dimensions and explanations
 
Presentation1
Presentation1Presentation1
Presentation1
 
Approaches to studying language attitudes beyond labov
Approaches to studying language attitudes  beyond labovApproaches to studying language attitudes  beyond labov
Approaches to studying language attitudes beyond labov
 
Edulearn 2014 - Barcelona/Spain
Edulearn 2014 - Barcelona/SpainEdulearn 2014 - Barcelona/Spain
Edulearn 2014 - Barcelona/Spain
 
Sociolinguistics
SociolinguisticsSociolinguistics
Sociolinguistics
 
Group2 conceptmaps
Group2 conceptmapsGroup2 conceptmaps
Group2 conceptmaps
 
Discourse and Society
Discourse and SocietyDiscourse and Society
Discourse and Society
 
Language and Identity: A Critique
Language and Identity: A CritiqueLanguage and Identity: A Critique
Language and Identity: A Critique
 
Cognitive Dimension Literacy
Cognitive Dimension LiteracyCognitive Dimension Literacy
Cognitive Dimension Literacy
 
Comm skills & multiple intelligences approach to communicative teaching
Comm skills & multiple intelligences approach to communicative teachingComm skills & multiple intelligences approach to communicative teaching
Comm skills & multiple intelligences approach to communicative teaching
 
Communicative competence
Communicative competenceCommunicative competence
Communicative competence
 
Multimodal Texts
Multimodal TextsMultimodal Texts
Multimodal Texts
 
Briefly on Discourse and Cognition
Briefly on Discourse and CognitionBriefly on Discourse and Cognition
Briefly on Discourse and Cognition
 

Similar to cccc handout draft 2 FINAL

EDUC528 Poster
EDUC528 PosterEDUC528 Poster
EDUC528 Poster
Brandon Epstein
 
Taking it to the mic
Taking it to the micTaking it to the mic
Taking it to the mic
1st Ikhwezi Scout Group
 
Multimodality and publishing
Multimodality and publishingMultimodality and publishing
Multimodality and publishing
laserbrain2010
 
The Moving Image and Literacy in the Primary Classroom
The Moving Image and Literacy in the Primary Classroom The Moving Image and Literacy in the Primary Classroom
The Moving Image and Literacy in the Primary Classroom
joness6
 
Scott McCloud's Big Triangle and New Media Composition
Scott McCloud's Big Triangle and New Media CompositionScott McCloud's Big Triangle and New Media Composition
Scott McCloud's Big Triangle and New Media Composition
kabbie
 
Practical Nº 7 The Magic Bag Project
Practical Nº 7 The Magic Bag Project Practical Nº 7 The Magic Bag Project
Practical Nº 7 The Magic Bag Project
CristianYacopini
 
OBC | The lure of the media: Discourse as social cognition
OBC | The lure of the media: Discourse as social cognitionOBC | The lure of the media: Discourse as social cognition
OBC | The lure of the media: Discourse as social cognition
Out of The Box Seminar
 
Castagneto tp 7 the magic bag project
Castagneto   tp 7 the magic bag projectCastagneto   tp 7 the magic bag project
Castagneto tp 7 the magic bag project
Lujan Castagneto
 
What is this ‘new’ writing
What is this ‘new’ writingWhat is this ‘new’ writing
What is this ‘new’ writing
Lu Bodeman
 
Film literacy in a contemporary landscape
Film literacy in a contemporary landscapeFilm literacy in a contemporary landscape
Film literacy in a contemporary landscape
markreid1895
 
V6n12
V6n12V6n12
V6n12
V6n12V6n12
Reader Response Theory/Formalism
Reader Response Theory/Formalism Reader Response Theory/Formalism
Reader Response Theory/Formalism
Home
 
Expository techniques and rk narayan
Expository techniques and rk narayanExpository techniques and rk narayan
Expository techniques and rk narayan
RUKMINIJAMDAR1
 
New trends in literature and graphic novels in
New trends in literature and graphic novels inNew trends in literature and graphic novels in
New trends in literature and graphic novels in
Rose Hagar
 
EDUC681 Final Project
EDUC681 Final ProjectEDUC681 Final Project
EDUC681 Final Project
Brandon Epstein
 
Engaging The Eye Generation
Engaging The Eye GenerationEngaging The Eye Generation
Engaging The Eye Generation
Johanna Riddle
 
Edx 3270 literacies education assignment 1
Edx 3270 literacies education assignment 1Edx 3270 literacies education assignment 1
Edx 3270 literacies education assignment 1
Stella Leotta
 
AECT 2009 Social Presence
AECT 2009 Social PresenceAECT 2009 Social Presence
AECT 2009 Social Presence
Patrick Lowenthal
 
Critical Literacy.pptx
Critical Literacy.pptxCritical Literacy.pptx
Critical Literacy.pptx
jeremydoloso
 

Similar to cccc handout draft 2 FINAL (20)

EDUC528 Poster
EDUC528 PosterEDUC528 Poster
EDUC528 Poster
 
Taking it to the mic
Taking it to the micTaking it to the mic
Taking it to the mic
 
Multimodality and publishing
Multimodality and publishingMultimodality and publishing
Multimodality and publishing
 
The Moving Image and Literacy in the Primary Classroom
The Moving Image and Literacy in the Primary Classroom The Moving Image and Literacy in the Primary Classroom
The Moving Image and Literacy in the Primary Classroom
 
Scott McCloud's Big Triangle and New Media Composition
Scott McCloud's Big Triangle and New Media CompositionScott McCloud's Big Triangle and New Media Composition
Scott McCloud's Big Triangle and New Media Composition
 
Practical Nº 7 The Magic Bag Project
Practical Nº 7 The Magic Bag Project Practical Nº 7 The Magic Bag Project
Practical Nº 7 The Magic Bag Project
 
OBC | The lure of the media: Discourse as social cognition
OBC | The lure of the media: Discourse as social cognitionOBC | The lure of the media: Discourse as social cognition
OBC | The lure of the media: Discourse as social cognition
 
Castagneto tp 7 the magic bag project
Castagneto   tp 7 the magic bag projectCastagneto   tp 7 the magic bag project
Castagneto tp 7 the magic bag project
 
What is this ‘new’ writing
What is this ‘new’ writingWhat is this ‘new’ writing
What is this ‘new’ writing
 
Film literacy in a contemporary landscape
Film literacy in a contemporary landscapeFilm literacy in a contemporary landscape
Film literacy in a contemporary landscape
 
V6n12
V6n12V6n12
V6n12
 
V6n12
V6n12V6n12
V6n12
 
Reader Response Theory/Formalism
Reader Response Theory/Formalism Reader Response Theory/Formalism
Reader Response Theory/Formalism
 
Expository techniques and rk narayan
Expository techniques and rk narayanExpository techniques and rk narayan
Expository techniques and rk narayan
 
New trends in literature and graphic novels in
New trends in literature and graphic novels inNew trends in literature and graphic novels in
New trends in literature and graphic novels in
 
EDUC681 Final Project
EDUC681 Final ProjectEDUC681 Final Project
EDUC681 Final Project
 
Engaging The Eye Generation
Engaging The Eye GenerationEngaging The Eye Generation
Engaging The Eye Generation
 
Edx 3270 literacies education assignment 1
Edx 3270 literacies education assignment 1Edx 3270 literacies education assignment 1
Edx 3270 literacies education assignment 1
 
AECT 2009 Social Presence
AECT 2009 Social PresenceAECT 2009 Social Presence
AECT 2009 Social Presence
 
Critical Literacy.pptx
Critical Literacy.pptxCritical Literacy.pptx
Critical Literacy.pptx
 

cccc handout draft 2 FINAL

  • 1. Visit: jgwiezor.wix.com/artmetawrite 1 Art+Meta+Write: Visuality and Second Language Writers / By Jan Wiezorek Problem: Second language (L2) writers are often at a place that A. F. Wysocki and J. L. Jasken (2004) call an interface—a borderland where systems meet. In this place between understanding and misunderstanding, L2 writers profoundly desire to express themselves fully but are uncertain how to do it in the moment. This uncertainty affects their confidence as writers. One student from Benin, who witnessed a car accident in America three months ago, says, “I was terrified and felt guilty because if I could speak English, I could have had done something.” Other L2 writers use “confused,” “nervous,” “disappointed, and “fear” to describe encounters with English speech and writing. Even when going to a movie, one student finds no pleasure in it, writing, “I don’t understand, and I always misunderstand the moment.” I argue that L2 writers “misunderstand the moment” offered to them for communicating through writing. Such misunderstanding causes delay in their response, and delay is traumatic when too much time elapses between reception of a message and a response to it (R. Barthes [1977]). With practice in responding to the immediacy of visuality, students can learn to blend systems in an interface situation, scaffold their understanding, and find a writer’s voice.
  • 2. Visit: jgwiezor.wix.com/artmetawrite 2 Pedagogy from M. B. McVee et al. (2008) and F. Serafini (2011) suggests that L2 writers have limited academic vocabulary and an unclear sense of the crossover between denotative and connotative meanings, which reduces effectiveness in establishing a writer’s voice. McVee (2008) advocates making meaning by “moving freely from one sign system to another.” Method: By combining visuals with writing, students will “reimagine” contexts and consequences (J. Shipka [2005]). Visuality provides entry into deeper understanding about writing. In one activity, “metajournaling,” students look at images before writing what they see and feel. Writers use denotation with images as a scaffold into the shifting cultural and contextual aspects inherent in connotation. These connections provide a broader understanding of meaning- making and help writers to draft reflections and discover voice. I enabled students to choose images, write denotative and connotative expressions, and to “metajournal” about the connections among images, thoughts, and writing. To assist students, I prepared a variety of worksheets that posed questions concerning the interface of images, words, culture, and context. Implications: Visuality offers useful implications for L2 students and compositionists.  Visuality is a pathway for entering into vocabulary, rich associations, and complex ideas. The ability to see an image and transfer it into words is a complex activity that echoes what L2 learners do when they grapple with language skills. Images reinforce new language acquisition, and they link writers to abstract, complex ideas.
  • 3. Visit: jgwiezor.wix.com/artmetawrite 3  Visuality enables students to question themselves and reflect upon experience. When students use writing to talk about their own experience, they often require a prompt. The author believes visuality is the best way to bring forth reflection, enabling students to discuss how experiences relate to a culture they are learning to navigate.  Visuality assists L2 writers in sharing emotions. Images open emotional floodgates. L2 writers become witnesses to the power of visuality to unleash emotions in writing. They use image and alphabetic-text connections to wrestle with emotional and cultural situations.  Visuality becomes a bit of knowledge to make meaning in an unstable world. The image is one bit of information that assists in meaning-making. Art+Meta+Write connections enable educators to generate assignments that rely on a combination of imagistic and alphabetic texts to help L2 writers enhance meaning within shifting sociocultural contexts. Acknowledgements: I thank L2 writers at BIR Training Center in Chicago for their willingness to explore interfaces among images, metacognition, and writing. I especially thank my mentor, Marcia Buell, Ph.D., English Professor at Northeastern Illinois University, Chicago, for her insights that strengthen connections between theory and praxis.
  • 4. Visit: jgwiezor.wix.com/artmetawrite 4 Works Cited Barthes, Roland. Image – Music – Text. Trans. Stephen Heath. New York: Hill and Wang, 1977. Print. McVee, Mary B. et al. “Using Digital Media to Interpret Poetry: Spiderman Meets Walt Whitman.” Research in the Teaching of English. 43.2 (2008): 112-43. Print. Serafini, Frank. “Expanding Perspectives for Comprehending Visual Images in Multimodal Texts.” Journal of Adolescent & Adult Literacy. 54.5 (2011): 342-50. Print. Shipka, Judy. “A Multimodal Task-Based Framework for Composing.” College Composition and Communication. 57.2 (2005): 277-306. Print. Wysocki, Anne Francis and Julia I. Jasken. “What should be an unforgettable face . . . .” Computers and Composition. 21.1 (2004): 29-48. Print. Jan Wiezorek (janwiezorek@comcast.net) teaches international L2 students as faculty member at BIR Training Center in Chicago. He is an adjunct professor at St. Augustine College, Chicago, and at Harper College, Palatine, Illinois. Jan authored Awesome Art Projects That Spark Super Writing (Scholastic, 2011). Visit his website: jgwiezor.wix.com/artmetawrite