SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Austin City Council Business Summit
                                       Participant Responses


This document represents the consolidated feedback from three discussion questions
addressed by approximately fifty (50) local small business owners during the Austin City
Council Business Summit on March 23, 2010.



What steps could the City take to better assist small local business owners (SBO) with planning and
development?


Process               City permitting processes are cumbersome, disorganized and seemingly
                      random.

                          o   Agencies don’t coordinate, i.e., Fire Marshalls and Inspectors in
                              the Health Building are not following the same code. Consistency
                              of rules is important. We can’t plan if we don’t know the rules. We
                              need someone who is the “end answer,” who can get everyone
                              following the same rules. Someone needs to say “the buck stops
                              here” and be willing to stand behind what they tell a business
                              owner. The Health Department is the only department able to
                              communicate expectations.
                          o   More coordination is needed between city, county and state on
                              permitting processes.
                          o   Streamline the permitting process for businesses.
                          o   The business office could “fast track” permits and could provide
                              up-front checklists appropriate for each type of business.
                          o   SBO need an advocate (a single point of contact) to “shepherd”
                              them through the zoning and permitting processes. SBO need an
                              approval process “Ombudsman.”
                          o   SBO need a City of Austin “expert” like Richard Suttle who knows
                              how to get very quick City approvals.
                          o   SBO need a New Business Resource Office to provide better-
                              coordinated guidance.
                          o   There needs to be consistency of regulations, codes, and formats
                              amongst different permitting departments, including uniform
                              deadlines. Currently there are competing permit departments
                              (e.g., health vs. electrical, APD and Right of Way).
                          o   Site plan review requires a half-day, a big time commitment for
                              SBO. The process is set up to make changes/ corrections
                              piecemeal rather than all necessary changes at once.
                          o   The City has a staffing shortage.
                          o   Flood plan review needs to be consistent with other processes.




                                                                                                      1
Customer Service   Customer service could be improved. Make sure SBO are treated as
                   valued customers.

                       o   Ensure that a similar process is in place for old and new
                           businesses and that there is consistent enforcement for all.
                           Currently there is a perceived or real inequity.
                       o   We are getting different answers from different City employees.
                       o   There is too much inspector autonomy.
                       o   Inspectors need customer service training. Fear of inspectors
                           could be reduced.
                       o   Establish a single point of contact within the City to assist by
                           providing information for large-scale marketing /demographics
                           sharing, traffic counts, etc.
                       o   SBO need a better awareness of existing City resources, e.g., use
                           Twitter, Facebook to communicate.




                                                                                          2
Communication   Transform City Staff attitudes from “adversary” to “advocate.”

                    o   City offices should update forms. Copies are poor and content
                        and instructions could be improved.
                    o   A website with video instruction and links to all related
                        paperwork is needed. Facilitate online submission of documents.
                    o   SBO need faster dissemination of information when new rules will
                        be implemented, e.g., City Billboard.
                    o   Big development plans need to be better communicated to
                        everyone, businesses and residents, i.e., road closures have
                        affected local businesses negatively.
                    o   Conduct impact studies of City Ordinances before they are
                        passed.
                    o   Continue to improve and enhance City’s vendor program. This is
                        one of the few programs that really works in the City. Keep
                        making it a better program by getting feedback from the SBO
                        who use the program.



Other           City employees need an appreciation of how difficult it is to start or
                expand a business.

                    o Neighborhood Associations are too powerful. They have veto
                       power.
                    o SBO need a sliding scale for green standards. Give SBO credit for
                       the percentage of standards they can implement.
                    o Accountability of City Offices, especially inspections, should be by
                       an outside entity.
                    o Only large players can develop land because of budget/ resource
                       constraints.
                    o Big business gets special treatment that local businesses don’t
                       get. There should be consistent rules.
                    o Establish waivers for small businesses, similar to large businesses,
                       to even-out the playing field.
                    o Provide more support for cooperative, locally grown, organic food
                       distribution.
                    o Provide incentives for local incubator kitchens.
                    o Improve safety struggles with solicitors, panhandlers, shoplifters
                       that would encourage pedestrians and families to frequent
                       downtown.




                                                                                         3
What steps could the City take to help create a better overall environment for small local
business owners to succeed?


Services                   !   Develop a mentoring program, matching old and new
                               businesses in similar industry.
                           !   Create a welcome packet with helpful information for new
                               small businesses.
                           !   Create a City position to advise self-employed and
                               independent contractors about healthcare, retirement, etc.
                           !   Create a City Co-op for small business and the self-employed
                               to “bunch” and form larger groups for health insurance, 401(k),
                               financing and other benefits that big businesses with large
                               networks achieve through size (strength in numbers).
                           !   Create a Media Liaison to promote and “accentuate the
                               positives” in perceived “bad areas of town.” Consider
                               developing a COP (Cabs on Patrol) Program in these areas as a
                               way to supplement APD, e.g., cab drivers are “partnered” with
                               a specific Public Safety Officer and report crimes/issues they
                               see to their “partner.”
                           !   Simplify the process for getting permits/licenses for expanding
                               small businesses.
                           !   Establish a seminar/meeting with City Staff on food issues
                               where the standards are explained and inspectors and SBO
                               know the expectations.
                           !   Don’t use fear to enforce rules and requirements. Rules should
                               be transparent and clear and not left up to interpretation
                               where each city staffer can interpret the rules differently,
                               creating fear and uncertainty for the business owners.
                           !   Establish an Ombudsman to facilitate solutions to zoning and
                               permitting issues.
                           !   Establish an Advisor Program similar to SCORE for established
                               businesses.




                                                                                             4
Small Business   !   Ensure that the Council’s decision to support small business is
Promotion            consistent through member changes.
                 !   Ensure a percentage of outsourced projects are awarded to
                     local small businesses. Austin is one of the nation’s leaders for
                     “big box” retail.
                 !   Provide SBO protection/lobbying regarding tax increases.
                 !   Promote joint marketing for local small business owners.
                 !   Do more to show genuine “good faith” in sharing sourcing
                     contracts with local small businesses.
                         o Early identification and communication of upcoming
                             sourcing opportunities well before the RFP is ready to
                             hit the street, e.g., perhaps a January conference to
                             notify all small businesses of the bid categories for the
                             year
                         o In each category specifically identify the capabilities that
                             the selected supplier is required to have
                         o Notify prime or large suppliers that the successful large
                             business supplier will have to “mentor” and prove that
                             they have identified and closed any capability gaps of a
                             local small business so that the large supplier partners in
                             some way with the small supplier
                         o The Historically Underutilized Business (HUB)
                             Coordinators should be more proactive in developing
                             small businesses
                 !   Promote local “flavor.”
                 !   Assist with small business development funding.
                 !   Create an incubator for small business.
                 !   Help small businesses grow outside the City limits.
                 !   Help small businesses become great and sustainable thru
                     innovative marketing to target current and new customers.
                 !   Bridge tough times via streamlined city processes, create loan
                     programs, updated infrastructure, and assist with more access
                     to technology, business expansion and diversity.




                                                                                      5
Provide Incentives   !   Help small businesses expand by offering them similar
                         incentives to what big corporations get. Consider scalable or
                         percentage incentives.
                     !   Provide incentives or rebates for recycling. Better address
                         commercial recycling issues by paying a portion of the recycling
                         fee for restaurants that are recycling and saving the City money
                         by not using landfills. Help restaurants that are willing to put in
                         full dishwashing facilities with cost breaks to minimize the use
                         of disposable serving utensils.
                     !   Recognize and provide incentives for local business job
                         creation (create parity between “big box” job creation and
                         small business job creation). Local jobs are better than “big
                         box” jobs.


Communication        !   Provide timely communication and more advance notice on
                         meetings. An example: mandatory pre-bid meeting notices are
                         sent Friday for Monday 9:30 A.M. meeting.
                     !   Let small businesses be part of the process and in the
                         communication loop.
                     !   Bridge the communication gap between Public Works Project
                         Managers and Purchasing.
                     !   Develop better communication via neighborhood newsletters,
                         social networking, etc.
                     !   Ensure high-speed Internet access everywhere.



Environmental        !   Make parking requirements easier for SBO to meet. The
                         current parking requirements for small businesses are an
                         obstacle.
                     !   Minimize the selling of public parking spaces for private valet
                         parking.
                     !   Extend back-in, angle parking in congested areas such as South
                         Congress and Barton Springs Rd.
                     !   City of Austin should be consistent with the State on
                         handicapped parking space requirements.
                     !   Better traffic management is needed, especially of the East/
                         West artery. Talk to small business about upcoming traffic
                         changes, e.g., Nueces Bike Park.
                     !   Look at parking in terms of “zones” rather than individuals.
                         Help small businesses look at parking alternatives, e.g., AIBA’s
                         IBIZ plans.
                     !   Help address security issues in the North Loop, i.e., thefts, car
                         break-ins. Public Safety cannot respond quickly because of
                         traffic congestion.


                                                                                          6
!   Include Public Safety in City planning.
          !   Better balance public safety needs and business needs. APD
              and AFD often trump outright any viable business concerns.
              Find the compromise vs. just giving those departments carte
              blanche.
          !   Not all businesses benefit, and many actually suffer, during
              events like SXSW. Consider all small businesses when allowing/
              granting large scale street/ area closures.
          !   Promote more mixed-use neighborhoods.
          !   Demonstrate more flexibility in zoning and codes.
          !   Provide a budget for the new Sustainability Officer.
          !   Design the City for health and a healthy future.
          !   There should be a balance of power and transparency between
              local small business owners and Neighborhood Associations.
              Neighborhood Associations are not representative of the
              demographic they are supposed to represent in many cases.
              There is no appeals process for the small business owner.
          !   The VMU (Vertical Mixed-Use) process needs to be more small
              business friendly.

Funding   !   Re-evaluate the allocation of funds for City Services to small
              business. Problems include redundancy of City services for
              small businesses such as MBE/ WBE and Small Business
              programs.
          !   Help SBO access federal and state grants.
          !   Award some City contracts to for-profit businesses, giving
              small businesses priority.

Other     !   Stay out of the way of creative business minds. Welcome
              ingenuity and advancement.
          !   Honor the role of small business in Austin’s “uniqueness.”
          !   Create a local Job Longevity Award, maybe in the form of a
              rebate.
          !   Let SBO run their businesses without crazy rules and
              requirements.
          !   Reduce the focus on chain-friendly policies.
          !   Establish more collaborative efforts and outreach between City
              and small businesses.
          !   Keep a balance between high tech and health and wellness.
          !   A change of attitude is needed – we collect sales tax for the
              City but we are not appreciated and are given the run around.




                                                                               7
What are some specific obstacles you have encountered in interacting with the City, and how do
you believe these could be addressed?

                   Obstacles                                        Solutions

 Sidewalk/ roadside squatters – smaller           - Staff should have thorough knowledge of
 vendors want to set up in front of               codes that they are responsible for
 businesses                                       enforcing

                                                  - Modify antiquated allowances (permit and
                                                  enforcement of such businesses)

 Vagrancy                                        Establish new laws

 Austin is not pedestrian-friendly              Establish more crosswalks near small business
                                                sites (cheap, pedestrian-friendly move) and
                                                pedestrian bridges

 Lack of parking                                Fund a community parking plan

 Need mass transportation that works

 Austin is still resistant to growth            Encourage “small pocket” growth

 Focus of City Government is downtown           Develop better transportation in these areas.
 only; other areas get left out                 Facilitate conversations with UT and the State

 City-contracted development lacks diversity     Show a concentrated effort to diversify

 City Council overreacts in dealings with        New City Council Members must go out and
 established, regulated small business           visit those businesses to learn more about
 without full awareness of industry history      why history has led them to certain
                                                 operational choices

 Inconsistency in inspections processes          Inspect us all the same way. Have supervisors
 (health especially); SBO get multiple           shadow/ audit a number/ % of inspections
 answers
 Lack of urgency on the part of inspectors/      Service training is needed
 permitting department

 Unresponsive, non-accountable staff             - Establish on-line payments
 (electrical, permitting, health inspectors);
 health inspectors are not “food people”         - Give rewards for fast permits

                                                - Pay for off-hours or fast permits (like the fire
                                                department)



                                                                                               8
Relationships between the City and small      Teach Staff about benefits of local business
business owners feel adversarial              (reference “Small-Mart Revolution” Michael
                                              Shuman)

Code enforcement is a complaint-driven        Show of an “attitude of gratitude” -
system, making it easy for an individual to   listening, followed by action
wreck havoc

Our problems seem to be ignored until the     - Create more refined customer-friendly
Press gets involved                           pathways for City processes (Advocates vs.
                                              Adversaries)

                                              - Take action on studies that have been done
                                              rather than conducting redundant studies

                                              - The City Legal Department needs to
                                              benchmark other cities’ best practices
More communication of long-range plans

Communication lead time (bid solicitations)   - Give more time to respond, more time to
                                              plan attendance at pre-bid conference

                                              - Provide timetable for City response to
                                              inquiries. There should be both accountability
                                              and predictability that inquiries will be
                                              addressed and when

Accessibility to local goods and services     Identify creative ways to use local goods and
(low bid vs. local)                           services vs. low bid

Limited hours of access to Planning and       Expand hours for small business owners to
Development Dept.                             meet with staff

Neighborhood Associations dictate what        - Ensure communication early in the process
businesses must abide by. Associations        with businesses and Neighborhood
have too much power. Associations own         Associations. Consider single district
the Planning Board.                           representation, campaign/ influence reform

                                              - Find a compromise on design standards
                                              between neighborhoods and businesses as
                                              well as local small businesses and large chains
                                              when safety requirements can still be met




                                                                                           9
Planning and Development needs to             Have a COA Advocate to guide small business
 provide Project Advocates to help with        owners thru the process, start to finish
 business projects. There should be one
 Advocate for the whole project, not a
 different Advocate for each department as
 that would just add a layer

 Lack of support for small business growth     Help small business owners understand the
                                               different zoning levels

                                               Provide clarity on the SBDP
                                               `
                                               City Staff should have thorough knowledge
                                               of the codes they are responsible for
                                               enforcing

                                               Process needs to be more outcome-oriented

                                               Investigate what “sustainability” means to
                                               the City and for small business. It goes
                                               beyond environment. Expand the concept of
                                               “Sustainability Officer”

 Preferential treatment to large out-of-town   Demand accountability from these large
 corporations, like Simon                      corporations. They aren’t good landlords to
                                               small businesses, yet you and we subsidize
                                               them

                                               If the City gives money to large corporations,
                                               a certain % of space (maybe 10%) needs to
                                               be allotted and affordable for local
                                               businesses

                                               Rent control could level the playing field if
                                               City money is involved




Additional comment:

Simon is a bad landlord. They force us to use the use their trash collection and
offer no recycling. Simon does not pass on any savings the City gives them.
They don’t negotiate in good faith yet they now own the entire Arboretum.




                                                                                               10

More Related Content

Similar to Business Summit Participant Feedback Report

Future of customer onboarding in banks
Future of customer onboarding in banksFuture of customer onboarding in banks
Future of customer onboarding in banks
Nikunj Gundaniya
 
The Emerging Role Of The Cio
The Emerging Role Of The CioThe Emerging Role Of The Cio
The Emerging Role Of The Cio
Nirvesh Sooful
 
Presentation to the City of Austin Economic Opportunity Committee
Presentation to the City of Austin  Economic Opportunity CommitteePresentation to the City of Austin  Economic Opportunity Committee
Presentation to the City of Austin Economic Opportunity Committee
abcatexas
 
Technical Assistance to Cooperatives
Technical  Assistance to CooperativesTechnical  Assistance to Cooperatives
Technical Assistance to Cooperatives
jo bitonio
 
Policy makers as marketers of the industry - key considerations for desired i...
Policy makers as marketers of the industry - key considerations for desired i...Policy makers as marketers of the industry - key considerations for desired i...
Policy makers as marketers of the industry - key considerations for desired i...
Simon Aderinlola
 
08-09 Economic Development Report
08-09 Economic Development Report08-09 Economic Development Report
08-09 Economic Development Report
Ara Topouzian
 
Osbtf recommendations preso 012917_final
Osbtf recommendations preso 012917_finalOsbtf recommendations preso 012917_final
Osbtf recommendations preso 012917_final
E'ville Eye
 
Fiscal Year 2016 Green Book - Final Version
Fiscal Year 2016 Green Book - Final VersionFiscal Year 2016 Green Book - Final Version
Fiscal Year 2016 Green Book - Final Version
DC Department of Small & Local Business Development (DSLBD)
 
Job Order Contracting – Now More Than Ever!
Job Order Contracting – Now More Than Ever!Job Order Contracting – Now More Than Ever!
Job Order Contracting – Now More Than Ever!
Organizational Development & Change Management
 
CSR & HR - Presentation Pr. Chizu Nakajima
CSR & HR - Presentation Pr. Chizu NakajimaCSR & HR - Presentation Pr. Chizu Nakajima
CSR & HR - Presentation Pr. Chizu Nakajima
EChr
 
How To Write A Research Paper Step B. Online assignment writing service.
How To Write A Research Paper Step B. Online assignment writing service.How To Write A Research Paper Step B. Online assignment writing service.
How To Write A Research Paper Step B. Online assignment writing service.
Paula Smith
 
OCIC Business Plan
OCIC Business PlanOCIC Business Plan
OCIC Business Plan
jbgrant24
 
Retail banker intl
Retail banker intl Retail banker intl
Retail banker intl
Backbase
 
Rbap 59th annual convention 25 may2012 latest edits
Rbap 59th annual convention 25 may2012   latest editsRbap 59th annual convention 25 may2012   latest edits
Rbap 59th annual convention 25 may2012 latest edits
RBAPAT54
 
Elephant in the Room, 24 Jul 2023.pptx
Elephant in the Room, 24 Jul 2023.pptxElephant in the Room, 24 Jul 2023.pptx
Elephant in the Room, 24 Jul 2023.pptx
Kashif Mateen Ansari
 
4 Strategies for local content success
4 Strategies for local content success4 Strategies for local content success
4 Strategies for local content success
Wayne Dunn
 
Narrative Essay Topic Ideas For College
Narrative Essay Topic Ideas For CollegeNarrative Essay Topic Ideas For College
Narrative Essay Topic Ideas For College
Linda Graham
 
Corporate Social Responsibility”
Corporate Social Responsibility”Corporate Social Responsibility”
Corporate Social Responsibility”
Manjula Jagatramka
 
Mj csr hp
Mj csr hpMj csr hp
Mj csr hp
Mj csr hpMj csr hp

Similar to Business Summit Participant Feedback Report (20)

Future of customer onboarding in banks
Future of customer onboarding in banksFuture of customer onboarding in banks
Future of customer onboarding in banks
 
The Emerging Role Of The Cio
The Emerging Role Of The CioThe Emerging Role Of The Cio
The Emerging Role Of The Cio
 
Presentation to the City of Austin Economic Opportunity Committee
Presentation to the City of Austin  Economic Opportunity CommitteePresentation to the City of Austin  Economic Opportunity Committee
Presentation to the City of Austin Economic Opportunity Committee
 
Technical Assistance to Cooperatives
Technical  Assistance to CooperativesTechnical  Assistance to Cooperatives
Technical Assistance to Cooperatives
 
Policy makers as marketers of the industry - key considerations for desired i...
Policy makers as marketers of the industry - key considerations for desired i...Policy makers as marketers of the industry - key considerations for desired i...
Policy makers as marketers of the industry - key considerations for desired i...
 
08-09 Economic Development Report
08-09 Economic Development Report08-09 Economic Development Report
08-09 Economic Development Report
 
Osbtf recommendations preso 012917_final
Osbtf recommendations preso 012917_finalOsbtf recommendations preso 012917_final
Osbtf recommendations preso 012917_final
 
Fiscal Year 2016 Green Book - Final Version
Fiscal Year 2016 Green Book - Final VersionFiscal Year 2016 Green Book - Final Version
Fiscal Year 2016 Green Book - Final Version
 
Job Order Contracting – Now More Than Ever!
Job Order Contracting – Now More Than Ever!Job Order Contracting – Now More Than Ever!
Job Order Contracting – Now More Than Ever!
 
CSR & HR - Presentation Pr. Chizu Nakajima
CSR & HR - Presentation Pr. Chizu NakajimaCSR & HR - Presentation Pr. Chizu Nakajima
CSR & HR - Presentation Pr. Chizu Nakajima
 
How To Write A Research Paper Step B. Online assignment writing service.
How To Write A Research Paper Step B. Online assignment writing service.How To Write A Research Paper Step B. Online assignment writing service.
How To Write A Research Paper Step B. Online assignment writing service.
 
OCIC Business Plan
OCIC Business PlanOCIC Business Plan
OCIC Business Plan
 
Retail banker intl
Retail banker intl Retail banker intl
Retail banker intl
 
Rbap 59th annual convention 25 may2012 latest edits
Rbap 59th annual convention 25 may2012   latest editsRbap 59th annual convention 25 may2012   latest edits
Rbap 59th annual convention 25 may2012 latest edits
 
Elephant in the Room, 24 Jul 2023.pptx
Elephant in the Room, 24 Jul 2023.pptxElephant in the Room, 24 Jul 2023.pptx
Elephant in the Room, 24 Jul 2023.pptx
 
4 Strategies for local content success
4 Strategies for local content success4 Strategies for local content success
4 Strategies for local content success
 
Narrative Essay Topic Ideas For College
Narrative Essay Topic Ideas For CollegeNarrative Essay Topic Ideas For College
Narrative Essay Topic Ideas For College
 
Corporate Social Responsibility”
Corporate Social Responsibility”Corporate Social Responsibility”
Corporate Social Responsibility”
 
Mj csr hp
Mj csr hpMj csr hp
Mj csr hp
 
Mj csr hp
Mj csr hpMj csr hp
Mj csr hp
 

More from Business Success Center

Truths & Myths of Starting a Business
Truths & Myths of Starting a BusinessTruths & Myths of Starting a Business
Truths & Myths of Starting a Business
Business Success Center
 
What 3 Business Models are Scalable
What 3 Business Models are ScalableWhat 3 Business Models are Scalable
What 3 Business Models are Scalable
Business Success Center
 
More Successful Partners, A BOSS-Talks Webinar .pptx
 More Successful Partners, A BOSS-Talks Webinar .pptx More Successful Partners, A BOSS-Talks Webinar .pptx
More Successful Partners, A BOSS-Talks Webinar .pptx
Business Success Center
 
Businesses for Boomers BSC Rise Austin 2012
Businesses for Boomers BSC Rise Austin 2012Businesses for Boomers BSC Rise Austin 2012
Businesses for Boomers BSC Rise Austin 2012
Business Success Center
 
Customer in the window BSC Rise 2012
Customer in the window BSC Rise 2012Customer in the window BSC Rise 2012
Customer in the window BSC Rise 2012
Business Success Center
 
Partnering: Working Together Without Killing Each Other
 Partnering: Working Together Without Killing Each Other Partnering: Working Together Without Killing Each Other
Partnering: Working Together Without Killing Each Other
Business Success Center
 
Networking Success for Introverts
Networking Success for IntrovertsNetworking Success for Introverts
Networking Success for Introverts
Business Success Center
 
Introvert Networking Adds to Organizations
Introvert Networking Adds to OrganizationsIntrovert Networking Adds to Organizations
Introvert Networking Adds to Organizations
Business Success Center
 
Find Your Way
Find Your WayFind Your Way
Total Vision
Total VisionTotal Vision
Selective Marketing
Selective MarketingSelective Marketing
Selective Marketing
Business Success Center
 
Making Decisions in Tough Times
Making Decisions in Tough TimesMaking Decisions in Tough Times
Making Decisions in Tough Times
Business Success Center
 

More from Business Success Center (13)

Truths & Myths of Starting a Business
Truths & Myths of Starting a BusinessTruths & Myths of Starting a Business
Truths & Myths of Starting a Business
 
What 3 Business Models are Scalable
What 3 Business Models are ScalableWhat 3 Business Models are Scalable
What 3 Business Models are Scalable
 
More Successful Partners, A BOSS-Talks Webinar .pptx
 More Successful Partners, A BOSS-Talks Webinar .pptx More Successful Partners, A BOSS-Talks Webinar .pptx
More Successful Partners, A BOSS-Talks Webinar .pptx
 
Businesses for Boomers BSC Rise Austin 2012
Businesses for Boomers BSC Rise Austin 2012Businesses for Boomers BSC Rise Austin 2012
Businesses for Boomers BSC Rise Austin 2012
 
Customer in the window BSC Rise 2012
Customer in the window BSC Rise 2012Customer in the window BSC Rise 2012
Customer in the window BSC Rise 2012
 
Partnering: Working Together Without Killing Each Other
 Partnering: Working Together Without Killing Each Other Partnering: Working Together Without Killing Each Other
Partnering: Working Together Without Killing Each Other
 
Networking Success for Introverts
Networking Success for IntrovertsNetworking Success for Introverts
Networking Success for Introverts
 
Introvert Networking Adds to Organizations
Introvert Networking Adds to OrganizationsIntrovert Networking Adds to Organizations
Introvert Networking Adds to Organizations
 
Find Your Way
Find Your WayFind Your Way
Find Your Way
 
Summit resolution
Summit resolutionSummit resolution
Summit resolution
 
Total Vision
Total VisionTotal Vision
Total Vision
 
Selective Marketing
Selective MarketingSelective Marketing
Selective Marketing
 
Making Decisions in Tough Times
Making Decisions in Tough TimesMaking Decisions in Tough Times
Making Decisions in Tough Times
 

Recently uploaded

Maximise your Business Potential: Annual Planning Workshop
Maximise your Business Potential: Annual Planning WorkshopMaximise your Business Potential: Annual Planning Workshop
Maximise your Business Potential: Annual Planning Workshop
chris908327
 
Business Lessons From Emmanuel Katto Uganda
Business Lessons From Emmanuel Katto UgandaBusiness Lessons From Emmanuel Katto Uganda
Business Lessons From Emmanuel Katto Uganda
OliviaCox14
 
Benefits of Hiring Gen X Compared to Gen Z and Millennials.pptx
Benefits of Hiring Gen X Compared to Gen Z and Millennials.pptxBenefits of Hiring Gen X Compared to Gen Z and Millennials.pptx
Benefits of Hiring Gen X Compared to Gen Z and Millennials.pptx
Brian Frerichs
 
Path to the next normal collection McKinsey
Path to the next normal collection McKinseyPath to the next normal collection McKinsey
Path to the next normal collection McKinsey
MajIman2
 
Honoring and Understanding the Significance of Guru Purnima
Honoring and Understanding the Significance of Guru PurnimaHonoring and Understanding the Significance of Guru Purnima
Honoring and Understanding the Significance of Guru Purnima
Exotic India
 
ハワイ大学留学プログラム最終プレゼン「ハワイ大学マノア校におけるシェアリングモビリティの提案」
ハワイ大学留学プログラム最終プレゼン「ハワイ大学マノア校におけるシェアリングモビリティの提案」ハワイ大学留学プログラム最終プレゼン「ハワイ大学マノア校におけるシェアリングモビリティの提案」
ハワイ大学留学プログラム最終プレゼン「ハワイ大学マノア校におけるシェアリングモビリティの提案」
Katsuya Shiratori
 
Solution manual for canadian income taxation 20222023 25th edition by william...
Solution manual for canadian income taxation 20222023 25th edition by william...Solution manual for canadian income taxation 20222023 25th edition by william...
Solution manual for canadian income taxation 20222023 25th edition by william...
stanslausnzuki569
 
Top five predictions today, .
Top five predictions today,            .Top five predictions today,            .
Top five predictions today, .
Rupasingh82
 
FINAL PROJECT WORK PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT (2) hhh (1) (2) (5) (1) (1).doc
FINAL PROJECT WORK PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT (2)  hhh (1) (2) (5) (1) (1).docFINAL PROJECT WORK PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT (2)  hhh (1) (2) (5) (1) (1).doc
FINAL PROJECT WORK PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT (2) hhh (1) (2) (5) (1) (1).doc
bala krishna
 
Virtual Paralegal Services: Your Remote Legal Assistant
Virtual Paralegal Services: Your Remote Legal AssistantVirtual Paralegal Services: Your Remote Legal Assistant
Virtual Paralegal Services: Your Remote Legal Assistant
Eternity Paralegal Services
 
AI and Best Use Cases for Your Personal Life.pptx
AI and Best Use Cases for Your Personal Life.pptxAI and Best Use Cases for Your Personal Life.pptx
AI and Best Use Cases for Your Personal Life.pptx
Brian Frerichs
 
Mobile Application pentesting blog.docx.pdf
Mobile Application pentesting blog.docx.pdfMobile Application pentesting blog.docx.pdf
Mobile Application pentesting blog.docx.pdf
fortbridge4
 
Floating Pontoon | Premier marine solution
Floating Pontoon | Premier marine solutionFloating Pontoon | Premier marine solution
Floating Pontoon | Premier marine solution
PMSME
 
CLEARPATH SUBDIVISION AUCKLAND Optimize Your Land’s Potential
CLEARPATH SUBDIVISION AUCKLAND Optimize Your Land’s PotentialCLEARPATH SUBDIVISION AUCKLAND Optimize Your Land’s Potential
CLEARPATH SUBDIVISION AUCKLAND Optimize Your Land’s Potential
ROIX LIMITED
 
Standard Operating Procedure for Digital Marketing
Standard Operating Procedure for Digital MarketingStandard Operating Procedure for Digital Marketing
Standard Operating Procedure for Digital Marketing
Dipendra Prasad Poudel
 
2024's Top Chief Revenue Officers to Follow.pdf
2024's Top Chief Revenue Officers to Follow.pdf2024's Top Chief Revenue Officers to Follow.pdf
2024's Top Chief Revenue Officers to Follow.pdf
THECIOWORLD
 
Cracking the Corporate Social Responsibilty Code.pptx
Cracking the Corporate Social Responsibilty Code.pptxCracking the Corporate Social Responsibilty Code.pptx
Cracking the Corporate Social Responsibilty Code.pptx
Workforce Group
 
2024 BPMN MIWG Capability Demonstration
2024  BPMN MIWG Capability Demonstration2024  BPMN MIWG Capability Demonstration
2024 BPMN MIWG Capability Demonstration
Denis Gagné
 
84th Marketing Club (OTC Marketing) Dr.Mahmoud Hamed 23rd Cairo.pdf
84th Marketing Club (OTC Marketing) Dr.Mahmoud Hamed 23rd Cairo.pdf84th Marketing Club (OTC Marketing) Dr.Mahmoud Hamed 23rd Cairo.pdf
84th Marketing Club (OTC Marketing) Dr.Mahmoud Hamed 23rd Cairo.pdf
ahmed614380
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Maximise your Business Potential: Annual Planning Workshop
Maximise your Business Potential: Annual Planning WorkshopMaximise your Business Potential: Annual Planning Workshop
Maximise your Business Potential: Annual Planning Workshop
 
Business Lessons From Emmanuel Katto Uganda
Business Lessons From Emmanuel Katto UgandaBusiness Lessons From Emmanuel Katto Uganda
Business Lessons From Emmanuel Katto Uganda
 
Benefits of Hiring Gen X Compared to Gen Z and Millennials.pptx
Benefits of Hiring Gen X Compared to Gen Z and Millennials.pptxBenefits of Hiring Gen X Compared to Gen Z and Millennials.pptx
Benefits of Hiring Gen X Compared to Gen Z and Millennials.pptx
 
Path to the next normal collection McKinsey
Path to the next normal collection McKinseyPath to the next normal collection McKinsey
Path to the next normal collection McKinsey
 
Honoring and Understanding the Significance of Guru Purnima
Honoring and Understanding the Significance of Guru PurnimaHonoring and Understanding the Significance of Guru Purnima
Honoring and Understanding the Significance of Guru Purnima
 
ハワイ大学留学プログラム最終プレゼン「ハワイ大学マノア校におけるシェアリングモビリティの提案」
ハワイ大学留学プログラム最終プレゼン「ハワイ大学マノア校におけるシェアリングモビリティの提案」ハワイ大学留学プログラム最終プレゼン「ハワイ大学マノア校におけるシェアリングモビリティの提案」
ハワイ大学留学プログラム最終プレゼン「ハワイ大学マノア校におけるシェアリングモビリティの提案」
 
DEMO_Aboveground Storage Tank Inspection.pdf
DEMO_Aboveground Storage Tank Inspection.pdfDEMO_Aboveground Storage Tank Inspection.pdf
DEMO_Aboveground Storage Tank Inspection.pdf
 
Solution manual for canadian income taxation 20222023 25th edition by william...
Solution manual for canadian income taxation 20222023 25th edition by william...Solution manual for canadian income taxation 20222023 25th edition by william...
Solution manual for canadian income taxation 20222023 25th edition by william...
 
Top five predictions today, .
Top five predictions today,            .Top five predictions today,            .
Top five predictions today, .
 
FINAL PROJECT WORK PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT (2) hhh (1) (2) (5) (1) (1).doc
FINAL PROJECT WORK PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT (2)  hhh (1) (2) (5) (1) (1).docFINAL PROJECT WORK PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT (2)  hhh (1) (2) (5) (1) (1).doc
FINAL PROJECT WORK PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT (2) hhh (1) (2) (5) (1) (1).doc
 
Virtual Paralegal Services: Your Remote Legal Assistant
Virtual Paralegal Services: Your Remote Legal AssistantVirtual Paralegal Services: Your Remote Legal Assistant
Virtual Paralegal Services: Your Remote Legal Assistant
 
AI and Best Use Cases for Your Personal Life.pptx
AI and Best Use Cases for Your Personal Life.pptxAI and Best Use Cases for Your Personal Life.pptx
AI and Best Use Cases for Your Personal Life.pptx
 
Mobile Application pentesting blog.docx.pdf
Mobile Application pentesting blog.docx.pdfMobile Application pentesting blog.docx.pdf
Mobile Application pentesting blog.docx.pdf
 
Floating Pontoon | Premier marine solution
Floating Pontoon | Premier marine solutionFloating Pontoon | Premier marine solution
Floating Pontoon | Premier marine solution
 
CLEARPATH SUBDIVISION AUCKLAND Optimize Your Land’s Potential
CLEARPATH SUBDIVISION AUCKLAND Optimize Your Land’s PotentialCLEARPATH SUBDIVISION AUCKLAND Optimize Your Land’s Potential
CLEARPATH SUBDIVISION AUCKLAND Optimize Your Land’s Potential
 
Standard Operating Procedure for Digital Marketing
Standard Operating Procedure for Digital MarketingStandard Operating Procedure for Digital Marketing
Standard Operating Procedure for Digital Marketing
 
2024's Top Chief Revenue Officers to Follow.pdf
2024's Top Chief Revenue Officers to Follow.pdf2024's Top Chief Revenue Officers to Follow.pdf
2024's Top Chief Revenue Officers to Follow.pdf
 
Cracking the Corporate Social Responsibilty Code.pptx
Cracking the Corporate Social Responsibilty Code.pptxCracking the Corporate Social Responsibilty Code.pptx
Cracking the Corporate Social Responsibilty Code.pptx
 
2024 BPMN MIWG Capability Demonstration
2024  BPMN MIWG Capability Demonstration2024  BPMN MIWG Capability Demonstration
2024 BPMN MIWG Capability Demonstration
 
84th Marketing Club (OTC Marketing) Dr.Mahmoud Hamed 23rd Cairo.pdf
84th Marketing Club (OTC Marketing) Dr.Mahmoud Hamed 23rd Cairo.pdf84th Marketing Club (OTC Marketing) Dr.Mahmoud Hamed 23rd Cairo.pdf
84th Marketing Club (OTC Marketing) Dr.Mahmoud Hamed 23rd Cairo.pdf
 

Business Summit Participant Feedback Report

  • 1. Austin City Council Business Summit Participant Responses This document represents the consolidated feedback from three discussion questions addressed by approximately fifty (50) local small business owners during the Austin City Council Business Summit on March 23, 2010. What steps could the City take to better assist small local business owners (SBO) with planning and development? Process City permitting processes are cumbersome, disorganized and seemingly random. o Agencies don’t coordinate, i.e., Fire Marshalls and Inspectors in the Health Building are not following the same code. Consistency of rules is important. We can’t plan if we don’t know the rules. We need someone who is the “end answer,” who can get everyone following the same rules. Someone needs to say “the buck stops here” and be willing to stand behind what they tell a business owner. The Health Department is the only department able to communicate expectations. o More coordination is needed between city, county and state on permitting processes. o Streamline the permitting process for businesses. o The business office could “fast track” permits and could provide up-front checklists appropriate for each type of business. o SBO need an advocate (a single point of contact) to “shepherd” them through the zoning and permitting processes. SBO need an approval process “Ombudsman.” o SBO need a City of Austin “expert” like Richard Suttle who knows how to get very quick City approvals. o SBO need a New Business Resource Office to provide better- coordinated guidance. o There needs to be consistency of regulations, codes, and formats amongst different permitting departments, including uniform deadlines. Currently there are competing permit departments (e.g., health vs. electrical, APD and Right of Way). o Site plan review requires a half-day, a big time commitment for SBO. The process is set up to make changes/ corrections piecemeal rather than all necessary changes at once. o The City has a staffing shortage. o Flood plan review needs to be consistent with other processes. 1
  • 2. Customer Service Customer service could be improved. Make sure SBO are treated as valued customers. o Ensure that a similar process is in place for old and new businesses and that there is consistent enforcement for all. Currently there is a perceived or real inequity. o We are getting different answers from different City employees. o There is too much inspector autonomy. o Inspectors need customer service training. Fear of inspectors could be reduced. o Establish a single point of contact within the City to assist by providing information for large-scale marketing /demographics sharing, traffic counts, etc. o SBO need a better awareness of existing City resources, e.g., use Twitter, Facebook to communicate. 2
  • 3. Communication Transform City Staff attitudes from “adversary” to “advocate.” o City offices should update forms. Copies are poor and content and instructions could be improved. o A website with video instruction and links to all related paperwork is needed. Facilitate online submission of documents. o SBO need faster dissemination of information when new rules will be implemented, e.g., City Billboard. o Big development plans need to be better communicated to everyone, businesses and residents, i.e., road closures have affected local businesses negatively. o Conduct impact studies of City Ordinances before they are passed. o Continue to improve and enhance City’s vendor program. This is one of the few programs that really works in the City. Keep making it a better program by getting feedback from the SBO who use the program. Other City employees need an appreciation of how difficult it is to start or expand a business. o Neighborhood Associations are too powerful. They have veto power. o SBO need a sliding scale for green standards. Give SBO credit for the percentage of standards they can implement. o Accountability of City Offices, especially inspections, should be by an outside entity. o Only large players can develop land because of budget/ resource constraints. o Big business gets special treatment that local businesses don’t get. There should be consistent rules. o Establish waivers for small businesses, similar to large businesses, to even-out the playing field. o Provide more support for cooperative, locally grown, organic food distribution. o Provide incentives for local incubator kitchens. o Improve safety struggles with solicitors, panhandlers, shoplifters that would encourage pedestrians and families to frequent downtown. 3
  • 4. What steps could the City take to help create a better overall environment for small local business owners to succeed? Services ! Develop a mentoring program, matching old and new businesses in similar industry. ! Create a welcome packet with helpful information for new small businesses. ! Create a City position to advise self-employed and independent contractors about healthcare, retirement, etc. ! Create a City Co-op for small business and the self-employed to “bunch” and form larger groups for health insurance, 401(k), financing and other benefits that big businesses with large networks achieve through size (strength in numbers). ! Create a Media Liaison to promote and “accentuate the positives” in perceived “bad areas of town.” Consider developing a COP (Cabs on Patrol) Program in these areas as a way to supplement APD, e.g., cab drivers are “partnered” with a specific Public Safety Officer and report crimes/issues they see to their “partner.” ! Simplify the process for getting permits/licenses for expanding small businesses. ! Establish a seminar/meeting with City Staff on food issues where the standards are explained and inspectors and SBO know the expectations. ! Don’t use fear to enforce rules and requirements. Rules should be transparent and clear and not left up to interpretation where each city staffer can interpret the rules differently, creating fear and uncertainty for the business owners. ! Establish an Ombudsman to facilitate solutions to zoning and permitting issues. ! Establish an Advisor Program similar to SCORE for established businesses. 4
  • 5. Small Business ! Ensure that the Council’s decision to support small business is Promotion consistent through member changes. ! Ensure a percentage of outsourced projects are awarded to local small businesses. Austin is one of the nation’s leaders for “big box” retail. ! Provide SBO protection/lobbying regarding tax increases. ! Promote joint marketing for local small business owners. ! Do more to show genuine “good faith” in sharing sourcing contracts with local small businesses. o Early identification and communication of upcoming sourcing opportunities well before the RFP is ready to hit the street, e.g., perhaps a January conference to notify all small businesses of the bid categories for the year o In each category specifically identify the capabilities that the selected supplier is required to have o Notify prime or large suppliers that the successful large business supplier will have to “mentor” and prove that they have identified and closed any capability gaps of a local small business so that the large supplier partners in some way with the small supplier o The Historically Underutilized Business (HUB) Coordinators should be more proactive in developing small businesses ! Promote local “flavor.” ! Assist with small business development funding. ! Create an incubator for small business. ! Help small businesses grow outside the City limits. ! Help small businesses become great and sustainable thru innovative marketing to target current and new customers. ! Bridge tough times via streamlined city processes, create loan programs, updated infrastructure, and assist with more access to technology, business expansion and diversity. 5
  • 6. Provide Incentives ! Help small businesses expand by offering them similar incentives to what big corporations get. Consider scalable or percentage incentives. ! Provide incentives or rebates for recycling. Better address commercial recycling issues by paying a portion of the recycling fee for restaurants that are recycling and saving the City money by not using landfills. Help restaurants that are willing to put in full dishwashing facilities with cost breaks to minimize the use of disposable serving utensils. ! Recognize and provide incentives for local business job creation (create parity between “big box” job creation and small business job creation). Local jobs are better than “big box” jobs. Communication ! Provide timely communication and more advance notice on meetings. An example: mandatory pre-bid meeting notices are sent Friday for Monday 9:30 A.M. meeting. ! Let small businesses be part of the process and in the communication loop. ! Bridge the communication gap between Public Works Project Managers and Purchasing. ! Develop better communication via neighborhood newsletters, social networking, etc. ! Ensure high-speed Internet access everywhere. Environmental ! Make parking requirements easier for SBO to meet. The current parking requirements for small businesses are an obstacle. ! Minimize the selling of public parking spaces for private valet parking. ! Extend back-in, angle parking in congested areas such as South Congress and Barton Springs Rd. ! City of Austin should be consistent with the State on handicapped parking space requirements. ! Better traffic management is needed, especially of the East/ West artery. Talk to small business about upcoming traffic changes, e.g., Nueces Bike Park. ! Look at parking in terms of “zones” rather than individuals. Help small businesses look at parking alternatives, e.g., AIBA’s IBIZ plans. ! Help address security issues in the North Loop, i.e., thefts, car break-ins. Public Safety cannot respond quickly because of traffic congestion. 6
  • 7. ! Include Public Safety in City planning. ! Better balance public safety needs and business needs. APD and AFD often trump outright any viable business concerns. Find the compromise vs. just giving those departments carte blanche. ! Not all businesses benefit, and many actually suffer, during events like SXSW. Consider all small businesses when allowing/ granting large scale street/ area closures. ! Promote more mixed-use neighborhoods. ! Demonstrate more flexibility in zoning and codes. ! Provide a budget for the new Sustainability Officer. ! Design the City for health and a healthy future. ! There should be a balance of power and transparency between local small business owners and Neighborhood Associations. Neighborhood Associations are not representative of the demographic they are supposed to represent in many cases. There is no appeals process for the small business owner. ! The VMU (Vertical Mixed-Use) process needs to be more small business friendly. Funding ! Re-evaluate the allocation of funds for City Services to small business. Problems include redundancy of City services for small businesses such as MBE/ WBE and Small Business programs. ! Help SBO access federal and state grants. ! Award some City contracts to for-profit businesses, giving small businesses priority. Other ! Stay out of the way of creative business minds. Welcome ingenuity and advancement. ! Honor the role of small business in Austin’s “uniqueness.” ! Create a local Job Longevity Award, maybe in the form of a rebate. ! Let SBO run their businesses without crazy rules and requirements. ! Reduce the focus on chain-friendly policies. ! Establish more collaborative efforts and outreach between City and small businesses. ! Keep a balance between high tech and health and wellness. ! A change of attitude is needed – we collect sales tax for the City but we are not appreciated and are given the run around. 7
  • 8. What are some specific obstacles you have encountered in interacting with the City, and how do you believe these could be addressed? Obstacles Solutions Sidewalk/ roadside squatters – smaller - Staff should have thorough knowledge of vendors want to set up in front of codes that they are responsible for businesses enforcing - Modify antiquated allowances (permit and enforcement of such businesses) Vagrancy Establish new laws Austin is not pedestrian-friendly Establish more crosswalks near small business sites (cheap, pedestrian-friendly move) and pedestrian bridges Lack of parking Fund a community parking plan Need mass transportation that works Austin is still resistant to growth Encourage “small pocket” growth Focus of City Government is downtown Develop better transportation in these areas. only; other areas get left out Facilitate conversations with UT and the State City-contracted development lacks diversity Show a concentrated effort to diversify City Council overreacts in dealings with New City Council Members must go out and established, regulated small business visit those businesses to learn more about without full awareness of industry history why history has led them to certain operational choices Inconsistency in inspections processes Inspect us all the same way. Have supervisors (health especially); SBO get multiple shadow/ audit a number/ % of inspections answers Lack of urgency on the part of inspectors/ Service training is needed permitting department Unresponsive, non-accountable staff - Establish on-line payments (electrical, permitting, health inspectors); health inspectors are not “food people” - Give rewards for fast permits - Pay for off-hours or fast permits (like the fire department) 8
  • 9. Relationships between the City and small Teach Staff about benefits of local business business owners feel adversarial (reference “Small-Mart Revolution” Michael Shuman) Code enforcement is a complaint-driven Show of an “attitude of gratitude” - system, making it easy for an individual to listening, followed by action wreck havoc Our problems seem to be ignored until the - Create more refined customer-friendly Press gets involved pathways for City processes (Advocates vs. Adversaries) - Take action on studies that have been done rather than conducting redundant studies - The City Legal Department needs to benchmark other cities’ best practices More communication of long-range plans Communication lead time (bid solicitations) - Give more time to respond, more time to plan attendance at pre-bid conference - Provide timetable for City response to inquiries. There should be both accountability and predictability that inquiries will be addressed and when Accessibility to local goods and services Identify creative ways to use local goods and (low bid vs. local) services vs. low bid Limited hours of access to Planning and Expand hours for small business owners to Development Dept. meet with staff Neighborhood Associations dictate what - Ensure communication early in the process businesses must abide by. Associations with businesses and Neighborhood have too much power. Associations own Associations. Consider single district the Planning Board. representation, campaign/ influence reform - Find a compromise on design standards between neighborhoods and businesses as well as local small businesses and large chains when safety requirements can still be met 9
  • 10. Planning and Development needs to Have a COA Advocate to guide small business provide Project Advocates to help with owners thru the process, start to finish business projects. There should be one Advocate for the whole project, not a different Advocate for each department as that would just add a layer Lack of support for small business growth Help small business owners understand the different zoning levels Provide clarity on the SBDP ` City Staff should have thorough knowledge of the codes they are responsible for enforcing Process needs to be more outcome-oriented Investigate what “sustainability” means to the City and for small business. It goes beyond environment. Expand the concept of “Sustainability Officer” Preferential treatment to large out-of-town Demand accountability from these large corporations, like Simon corporations. They aren’t good landlords to small businesses, yet you and we subsidize them If the City gives money to large corporations, a certain % of space (maybe 10%) needs to be allotted and affordable for local businesses Rent control could level the playing field if City money is involved Additional comment: Simon is a bad landlord. They force us to use the use their trash collection and offer no recycling. Simon does not pass on any savings the City gives them. They don’t negotiate in good faith yet they now own the entire Arboretum. 10