• Background
• Benefits
• Additive Manufacturing Processes
• Qualification
• Certification
• Implementation
• Summary
Outline
1
• Traditional Manufacturing
• Materials Manufacturing
• Rolling, Casting, Forging etc.
• To meet mechanical properties by
Heat Treatment etc.
• Machining
• To meet dimension and special
features by CNC machine, Lathe
etc
• Welding
• To join multi-pieces together
Background
2
• Additive Manufacturing
• Integrated process with
materials manufacturing
machining and welding
• Add materials layer by layer
• Controlled by sliced CAD
model, software and hardware
Benefits
3
Manufacturing On-Demand
Prototype new design
Reduce inventory of spare parts
Remanufacture obsolete parts
Reduce lead-time
Repair or Special Feature
Apply functional/new materials
Add specific features
Repair damaged parts
Manufacturing End Use Components
Increase design freedom for complex shapes
Integrate multiple pieces to single part
Add materials for weight saving
Small Batch Production
Cost-effective small volume production
Small batch production under dynamic vs static build
Digital Scanning
Digital Design
Digital Engineering
Digital Manufacturing
Additive Manufacturing Processes
4
• Objectives of ABS are Qualification
of AM Facilities to enable reliable
quality products through a
developed certification scheme
which focuses on:
• Design verification and
validation
• Additive manufacturing
procedure approval
• Initial and periodic factory
audits
Additive Manufacturing Processes
5
Categories of Additive Manufacturing Processes
Materials Extrusion
Material Jetting
Vat Photopolymerization
Sheet Lamination
Binder Jetting
Direct Energy Deposition
Powder Bed Fusion
Powder Bed Fusion Example
6
• Powder Bed Fusion (PBF): An AM process in which thermal energy
selectively fuses regions of a powder bed.
Example of Build Diagram Showing Location, Number, Type, and
Orientation of Test Specimens and Reference Parts
Distance
Between Parts
Nesting
Type and Arrangement of
Part and Support Structures
Powder Roller
Powder Supply
Build Platform /
Baseplate
Powder Matrix
Energy Source &
Beam Controller
Directed Energy Deposition Example
7
• Direct Energy Deposition (DED): An AM process in which focused thermal
energy is used to fuse materials by melting as they are being deposited.
X
Y
Z
Process Coordinate
System
Multi-Axis Arm
Maximum Working
Envelope / Build Volume
Deposition Path
(Contour or Fill Types, Contour Shown)
Build Platform or Existing Part
Part Fixture
(Can be Static or Dynamic)
Binder Jetting Examples
8
• Binder Jetting (BJ): An AM process in
which liquid bonding agent is selectively
deposited to join powder materials
Powder Spreader
and / or Inkjet
Loose Powder
Bound Powder
Build Box
Direct Metal Production
Indirect Metal Production
To Infiltration &
Heat Treatment
Bound Metal Powder Parts
Bound Sand Mold
To Casting Facility
Bound Part Cores
(if applicable)
Additive Manufacturing Processes
9
AWS D20.1
Subcategories of Metal Additive
Manufacturing Processes
Abbreviation
Laser Powder Bed Fusion L-PBF
Electron Beam Powder Bed Fusion EB-PBF
Laser Directed Energy Deposition L-DED
Electron Beam Directed Energy Deposition EB-DED
Plasma Arc Directed Energy Deposition PA-DED
Gas Tungsten Arc Directed Energy Deposition GTA-DED
Gas Metal Arc Directed Energy Deposition GMA-DED
Qualification
10
• Critical/Severity level for application may be determined and agreed. Appropriate AM
process is selected and routing out.
June 2016, International Journal of Fatigue 94,
DOI: 10.1016/j.ijfatigue.2016.07.005 Michael Gorelik, Federal Aviation Administration
• Critical:
• Failure would cause significant danger to
personnel, loss of control, loss of a
system, loss of a major component or an
operating penalty.
• Semi-critical
• Failure would reduce the overall strength
of the equipment or system or preclude
the intended functioning or use of
equipment, but loss of the system or the
endanger of personnel would not occur.
• Non-critical
• Failure would not affect the operation of
the system or endanger personnel.
AWS D20.1
Qualification
11
Feedstock
(Powder/Wire)
Part/Coupon Design
(CAD files, functional and
technical design specs)
Additive Manufacturing Service Provider
• Production Parts
• Reference Parts
• Test Samples
• Test Artifacts
Heat Treatment
(AM processes can build
significant residual
stresses)
Cleaning/Machining
(Not trivial if
complex geometry)
Testing
• Destructive
• Nondestructive
• Functional
Application
Partial Black Box
Machine operations are
observed, but data may
not be well-understood
or shareable.
Qualification
12
Additive Manufacturing Qualification Process
Cradle to Grave File
Part Design Package
Part Inspection and Testing Package
Part Manufacturing Description
Process Configuration and Workflow Diagram
Additive Manufacturing Project Setup
Initial Cradle to Grave File Population
Feasibility Stage
Verification Stage
Pre-Production Validation Stage
Production Stage
Qualification Stages
Qualification
13
• Sample Additive Manufacturing Qualification
Record: Machine Qualification or Procedure
Qualification Record:
• General
• Build Platform
• Feedstock
• Machine
• Environment
• Build Parameters
• Post Processing
• Examination and Testing Results
(additional testing by design
requirements)
Refer to AWS D20.1
Qualification
14
• Challenges
• Process-Microstructure-
Properties
• Mechanical properties
(anisotropy, fracture toughness,
fatigue properties etc.)
• Process-Feature-Function
• Non-destructive testing
• Verification and validation in
manufacturability,
maintainability and reliability http://senvol.com/database/
Qualification
15
• Fit-For-Service
• Severity zone based
• Engineering Critical
Assessment
• BS 7910
• Crackwise developed by the
welding institute, UK
• Risk based
• Statistics data of traditional
manufacturing vs additive
manufacturing
0
10
20
30
40
50
0 20 40 60 80
Initial
Flaw
Height,
mm
Initial Flaw Length, 2C, mm
CTOD
Non-CTOD
Expon. (CTOD)
Expon. (Non-
CTOD)
Certification
16
• Metal Additive Manufacturing
Component
• Product Design Assessment
• Manufacturing Assessment
• Product Quality Assessment
• Unit Certification
• Additive Manufacturing Service
Provider
• Quality Management System
• Additive Manufacturing Capability
Request for
Approval
Instruction
Letter
Submittal
Review
Audit
Maturity
Letter or
Provisional
Approval
Letter
Capability
Demo.
Approval
Letter or
Certificate
Implementation
17
• Additive manufacturing process is continuously improved using a close-loop
product lifecycle management.
Approved
Design
Approved
Raw Material
Supplier
Outsourcing
Suppliers
Approved AM
Machine
Procedure
Operator
Approved
Production
Plan
Accepted
Inspection
and Testing
Report
Traceable
during
Operation
Performance
Evaluation or
Failure
Analysis
• Metal AM for end-use can bring many benefits for shipping industry.
• Manufacturing on-demand
• End-use components
• Repair or add features
• Small batch production
• Three common metal AM processes:
• PBF
• DED
• Binder Jetting
• NTQ for other processes requested
• ABS streamlined qualification scheme, certification and implementation process.
• Additive Manufacturing Service Provider
• Metal Additive Manufacturing Components
Summary
18
• ABS Advisory
https://ww2.eagle.org/content/dam/eagle/advisories-and-
debriefs/ABS_Additive_Manufacturing_Advisory_17294.pdf
• ABS Guidance Notes
https://ww2.eagle.org/content/dam/eagle/rules-and-guides/current/other/299-
gn-on-additive-manufacturing-2018/additive-manufacturing-gn-sept18.pdf
• ABS Steel Vessel Rules
https://ww2.eagle.org/en/rules-and-resources/rules-and-guides.html
• ABS Current Engagement
Joint Development/Industry Project to improve the technology readiness level of
additive manufacturing technology for marine and offshore application.
Summary
19
20

Additive-Manufacturing-Qualification-Certification-and-Implementation (1).pptx

  • 1.
    • Background • Benefits •Additive Manufacturing Processes • Qualification • Certification • Implementation • Summary Outline 1
  • 2.
    • Traditional Manufacturing •Materials Manufacturing • Rolling, Casting, Forging etc. • To meet mechanical properties by Heat Treatment etc. • Machining • To meet dimension and special features by CNC machine, Lathe etc • Welding • To join multi-pieces together Background 2 • Additive Manufacturing • Integrated process with materials manufacturing machining and welding • Add materials layer by layer • Controlled by sliced CAD model, software and hardware
  • 3.
    Benefits 3 Manufacturing On-Demand Prototype newdesign Reduce inventory of spare parts Remanufacture obsolete parts Reduce lead-time Repair or Special Feature Apply functional/new materials Add specific features Repair damaged parts Manufacturing End Use Components Increase design freedom for complex shapes Integrate multiple pieces to single part Add materials for weight saving Small Batch Production Cost-effective small volume production Small batch production under dynamic vs static build Digital Scanning Digital Design Digital Engineering Digital Manufacturing
  • 4.
    Additive Manufacturing Processes 4 •Objectives of ABS are Qualification of AM Facilities to enable reliable quality products through a developed certification scheme which focuses on: • Design verification and validation • Additive manufacturing procedure approval • Initial and periodic factory audits
  • 5.
    Additive Manufacturing Processes 5 Categoriesof Additive Manufacturing Processes Materials Extrusion Material Jetting Vat Photopolymerization Sheet Lamination Binder Jetting Direct Energy Deposition Powder Bed Fusion
  • 6.
    Powder Bed FusionExample 6 • Powder Bed Fusion (PBF): An AM process in which thermal energy selectively fuses regions of a powder bed. Example of Build Diagram Showing Location, Number, Type, and Orientation of Test Specimens and Reference Parts Distance Between Parts Nesting Type and Arrangement of Part and Support Structures Powder Roller Powder Supply Build Platform / Baseplate Powder Matrix Energy Source & Beam Controller
  • 7.
    Directed Energy DepositionExample 7 • Direct Energy Deposition (DED): An AM process in which focused thermal energy is used to fuse materials by melting as they are being deposited. X Y Z Process Coordinate System Multi-Axis Arm Maximum Working Envelope / Build Volume Deposition Path (Contour or Fill Types, Contour Shown) Build Platform or Existing Part Part Fixture (Can be Static or Dynamic)
  • 8.
    Binder Jetting Examples 8 •Binder Jetting (BJ): An AM process in which liquid bonding agent is selectively deposited to join powder materials Powder Spreader and / or Inkjet Loose Powder Bound Powder Build Box Direct Metal Production Indirect Metal Production To Infiltration & Heat Treatment Bound Metal Powder Parts Bound Sand Mold To Casting Facility Bound Part Cores (if applicable)
  • 9.
    Additive Manufacturing Processes 9 AWSD20.1 Subcategories of Metal Additive Manufacturing Processes Abbreviation Laser Powder Bed Fusion L-PBF Electron Beam Powder Bed Fusion EB-PBF Laser Directed Energy Deposition L-DED Electron Beam Directed Energy Deposition EB-DED Plasma Arc Directed Energy Deposition PA-DED Gas Tungsten Arc Directed Energy Deposition GTA-DED Gas Metal Arc Directed Energy Deposition GMA-DED
  • 10.
    Qualification 10 • Critical/Severity levelfor application may be determined and agreed. Appropriate AM process is selected and routing out. June 2016, International Journal of Fatigue 94, DOI: 10.1016/j.ijfatigue.2016.07.005 Michael Gorelik, Federal Aviation Administration • Critical: • Failure would cause significant danger to personnel, loss of control, loss of a system, loss of a major component or an operating penalty. • Semi-critical • Failure would reduce the overall strength of the equipment or system or preclude the intended functioning or use of equipment, but loss of the system or the endanger of personnel would not occur. • Non-critical • Failure would not affect the operation of the system or endanger personnel. AWS D20.1
  • 11.
    Qualification 11 Feedstock (Powder/Wire) Part/Coupon Design (CAD files,functional and technical design specs) Additive Manufacturing Service Provider • Production Parts • Reference Parts • Test Samples • Test Artifacts Heat Treatment (AM processes can build significant residual stresses) Cleaning/Machining (Not trivial if complex geometry) Testing • Destructive • Nondestructive • Functional Application Partial Black Box Machine operations are observed, but data may not be well-understood or shareable.
  • 12.
    Qualification 12 Additive Manufacturing QualificationProcess Cradle to Grave File Part Design Package Part Inspection and Testing Package Part Manufacturing Description Process Configuration and Workflow Diagram Additive Manufacturing Project Setup Initial Cradle to Grave File Population Feasibility Stage Verification Stage Pre-Production Validation Stage Production Stage Qualification Stages
  • 13.
    Qualification 13 • Sample AdditiveManufacturing Qualification Record: Machine Qualification or Procedure Qualification Record: • General • Build Platform • Feedstock • Machine • Environment • Build Parameters • Post Processing • Examination and Testing Results (additional testing by design requirements) Refer to AWS D20.1
  • 14.
    Qualification 14 • Challenges • Process-Microstructure- Properties •Mechanical properties (anisotropy, fracture toughness, fatigue properties etc.) • Process-Feature-Function • Non-destructive testing • Verification and validation in manufacturability, maintainability and reliability http://senvol.com/database/
  • 15.
    Qualification 15 • Fit-For-Service • Severityzone based • Engineering Critical Assessment • BS 7910 • Crackwise developed by the welding institute, UK • Risk based • Statistics data of traditional manufacturing vs additive manufacturing 0 10 20 30 40 50 0 20 40 60 80 Initial Flaw Height, mm Initial Flaw Length, 2C, mm CTOD Non-CTOD Expon. (CTOD) Expon. (Non- CTOD)
  • 16.
    Certification 16 • Metal AdditiveManufacturing Component • Product Design Assessment • Manufacturing Assessment • Product Quality Assessment • Unit Certification • Additive Manufacturing Service Provider • Quality Management System • Additive Manufacturing Capability Request for Approval Instruction Letter Submittal Review Audit Maturity Letter or Provisional Approval Letter Capability Demo. Approval Letter or Certificate
  • 17.
    Implementation 17 • Additive manufacturingprocess is continuously improved using a close-loop product lifecycle management. Approved Design Approved Raw Material Supplier Outsourcing Suppliers Approved AM Machine Procedure Operator Approved Production Plan Accepted Inspection and Testing Report Traceable during Operation Performance Evaluation or Failure Analysis
  • 18.
    • Metal AMfor end-use can bring many benefits for shipping industry. • Manufacturing on-demand • End-use components • Repair or add features • Small batch production • Three common metal AM processes: • PBF • DED • Binder Jetting • NTQ for other processes requested • ABS streamlined qualification scheme, certification and implementation process. • Additive Manufacturing Service Provider • Metal Additive Manufacturing Components Summary 18
  • 19.
    • ABS Advisory https://ww2.eagle.org/content/dam/eagle/advisories-and- debriefs/ABS_Additive_Manufacturing_Advisory_17294.pdf •ABS Guidance Notes https://ww2.eagle.org/content/dam/eagle/rules-and-guides/current/other/299- gn-on-additive-manufacturing-2018/additive-manufacturing-gn-sept18.pdf • ABS Steel Vessel Rules https://ww2.eagle.org/en/rules-and-resources/rules-and-guides.html • ABS Current Engagement Joint Development/Industry Project to improve the technology readiness level of additive manufacturing technology for marine and offshore application. Summary 19
  • 20.